HomeMy WebLinkAbout1988-03-03
r
,,' .--..'"
j
Town of Nantucket
Conservation Commission
Town and County Building
Nantucket. Massachusetts 02554
AGENDA FOR Y~RCH 3, 1988
A. PUBLIC HEPRINGS
3 .
l.!-.
5 .
6.
7 .
8.
9.
10.
1.
Joseph & Joan Cochran ET AL - SEi18-l.!-'*2 - 5'* & 56 No. Beach St.
J&~e5 Driscoll - SEl.!-8-471 - One Osprey Way
Elizabeth McIlvain - SE48-472 - Millbrook Road
J. Pepper Frazier - SE48-~55 - 37 Gardner Road
!o10D omoy Ha:rbor Realty Trust - SE48 - 465 - 60 Monomoy Road
J. Seward Johnson, Jr. - Almanac Pond Road (cont.- 3/17/88)
K & B Realtv Trust - SE48-469 - Crooked Lane
Sa~ & Rita Stark - SE~8-470 - 39 Millb~ook Road
Tabit.h3 Kraughtoff (2368-1) - SE48-473 'f - off Eoicks Hollow Rd
Tabitha Kraughtoff (2368-2) - SE48-473 ? - off Hoicks Hollow Rd
~)
w.
B. REGULAR Y~ETING
'-
1. Minutes of February 11, lSeS
2. Other Business
a. David Cant.reJ.l - RE: 13 Polliwog Pond Road - SEi!8-447
b. Robert Daylor - Woodbury Lane - SE48-312 - 5. fencing, hse
c. N.3nb.::cket COli'.Inons TrUSL. - RFD &: Nor
~. H & 2 Holland - SE48-452 - 117 Madaket Road - poss. viol.
e. Dirt piles at 19 Madaket Road - poss. viol.
f. Junk cars off Millbrook Road - pass. vic:l.
g. Pelf-is Road bikepath
h. DEC'E site visii.:s lvIarch 10: DU'f'O",.t (11:15:. Mark (1:15), Luntz
~, 2: ~~ C ; . CCHT":.rnissic,rlers enc,::'llr1:ige;) tc) att,er~d.
3. Reqr:ests f;,)]:- Deter!7'~.:Lna,t:J)rl
2. Beachside Realty T=ust - Nor~h Be2ch Street
b. T{::p13~d PrQ?ert~es - Low 3each Road
~. Cert.ificates of Comp:iance
a. John M. Greenleaf - SE~8-12 - 3 Hult:er~ Ave.
D. Joan Bolli~g & John Green:eaf - SE~8-75 - 3 H~lbert Ave.
c. John Greenleaf - SE~8-190 - 3 Hulbert Ave.
d. J.c.hrl M. Greenleaf - ::;E4r8-228. - 3 Htllt::ert P...'Je.
e. Jch~ & Lewis Greenleaf - SE48-395 - 3 Hulbert Ave.
f. Perkins - LaFrance - SE~B-386 - Valley View Drive
1')
j
---.,I
Town of Nantucket
Conservation Commission
Town and County Building
Nantucket, Massachusetts 02554
5. Correspondence
6. Possible Field Inspections - set date and time
a. H & S Holland - SEl.t8-452 - 117 Madaket Road - poss. viol.
b. J~~k cars off Millbrook Road - poss. viol.
c. Nantucket Co~mons for new proposal?
d. Dirt piles at 19 Madaket Road - poss. viol.
.
,~
Town of Nantucket
Conservation Commission
Town and County Building
Nantucket, Massachusetts 02554
Minutes of March 3, 1988 Page 1
IVIll\:1J'l'ES OF IIIJPcRCH 3. 1988
The public hearings of March 3, 1988 were called ~o order at 7:33 PM in
t.he Jury Room of ,-he Nc.ntucket. 'Ioi.,rn aDO. Co:.mty Buildi:lg. Members
present werE:: Willia."n WiLlet - Treasurer - presided over the meeting.
Carl Borchert, Henry Wasierski, Donald Visec-. Granville Cranst.on.
Members absent were: Peter~';. Dunwiddie - Chairman. Lee Dunn.
Ac1ministrator preser~t.: ten !~cEehlaY.
A. PUBLIC HEARINGS
1. Joseph and Joan Cochran ET AL - SE~8-~~2 - 5~ & 56 No. Beac~
St~'eet. .]cr:n Shugrue was p~:-esent as agent for the app:'icant. and
reque~,ted a c':mt.ir~uar.ce ::)f T.he he3.ring unt.il L1I1c:rch 17. 1988.
A rno~ion was made to continue ~he hearing until March 17. 19~A
at the aI)pl.ic.3nt.'~. reque'st... 'I'he ~(oticJn 'rr\?as carri.ed..
2. .Jame:=, D::'i:3co11 - SEL.c8-!",/1 - Cne Osprey l'Jay. Tina Coug:-:an:n.:r ':'=
IEP, Ine. wa::, preseD':: as agent' for the applicc.nt. She c.gai:-;
addressed the definiti~n of coastal bank and described cnanges
irl 1:.J-le he igr.:.t ()f i:.he j~..l.lk.he\3(i..
A motion was made
17, 1988 meeting
to clclse tt!e hearing ana wait until ~~e March
tc issue an Order ot Conditions.
The mO-7_i.:rl
'r.T':: C'
Y"J '--.....
Ca'l....l~le,.: .
.-,
;:, .
Elizabet~ Mcilvai:1 - SE48-4-'72 - Mj_llbrock Road.
1\. rr:.c~"!"_.1.. ~:.:::-; ~': as
:nade ~:.C
- .
~J..;:'2e -+:.r-~e
. .
~-je6.~..:r..g .
:'he
. . -.
mctlon was carrlec.
~.
J. Pe:;:.'pe":- ?::-:::-..2 iE'.}..... - 3E'~::: - 4. 5 5 - 3 7 C~cJ:.(::r:e~-. F~(:e(j..
".j' ]_;-1.3 (':.-"1.i~;}'~'3::C'-:..l:"-
of' IEP, In:7. '~as pres8Dt as agE~~ fo= the appl~can~ and Kevir.
Dale of V3~gl:~:1. Da~e a~1d Fhil~rick wa~ ;.resent as e~~or~EY t~~
tr~ e 3.;':-'1=' 1 =- C:C :'J--: ~ ~r. e f f 1.-' e:/ B 1 a c~]:-v!e.L 1 c. f !.i 2~~'-:' - Ei J~ a c~j':y.le 1 ~ & .on.:::. S <) c .
-f~i 1 ~~ v2.i ~ 1. et ::-e:r:c "(..7{~d hi;nse 1 f :fl>:~;:1 the :-~ -= 2~I. 2_:-lg
was also ~r~ss~~.
lea\li:-i.g fcrrner ViCE7-'.~~r1airmGr: !:;.a..I~l E~~)~c-l~le~-:. ~o l=~I'e5:.de.
,)
Town of Nantucket
Conservation Commission
Town and County Building
Nantucket, Massachusetts 02554
l'1.inutes of March
.,
v.
1988
Pag.e ~
Ms. Coughanour stated the closest distance between a septic
system 2nd a ditch in the saltmarsh is 105 ft. An es~iiliated 92
- 1:) 7 cubic yaJ:.~ds c;f f ill vl~ll IJe ;J.sed. Iiir. BlacJ.::v.re-ll said. t-J-~E:-
septic tarlJ( cc)'u.ld be sea_led "\-.7i th a l)i t.1..L'Tiir~ous rnateria2. to rr:a}~:-:
it water- tight" rrhere '..,a~ ~ji5cU5S ic;n ;3r-.1!)ut usirlg lift l~~"'nl:'S
ins.loe vs. outside a dHellir:g. The lift pU.mp on the plar. i:.::
01j,t.s.:Lde t.he hOl1se" lVi..r" McI{el'Jlay~ l.-epo:r"ted t}-~at_ E~~aJ..th InsJ=!ec.t.c.~
Richard Ra~T 3ai1j S1:-,3.te law ::-equires ,~t lift };}UITIJ:"; ~CJ be ir:si.:~e: t~le
fCJund.3t.ic)r:! i.~~l=:i(Je a 5e{~ond cr:arnr:e!.- ar.i.(1 ~;,ellted t.r.;.:ro~..lgh tr.:€' :1-::;:'):
of the house.. !Vir" BJ.ac}:well sai,j if ()ne \.[e!.....E~ ~.l~.eij. :.t w~)u.ld r;e
:ocated af7sr the ef~ll:ent~ Donald Visco added ~hat 7itle 5 ~:as
no jurisdic~ion inside founda~icns.
C:c~rl BCI~ch~=rt. asJ~ed vir-;y Gh_15s7.ic;ri #9 Cj~ t~le rJot.ice of I}lter~t ~1at1
1)e€.!1 left ;:tlan}:: (t\letlands R.e3~rict.icn ()rcel-). IJf1.... lr r.~ale saiz..:
t.:r~e:r-e \l,i2.S nc:t,hing e'f! tr,e. ti "c.l~ \'ihicl-l l....e.I er:r~ed to t.ne \.-Jet.l,3r;c5
R.estl"'ii~t.ior: P~ct. L),rrl11 ~~.i:n,-r';;;~:Tr3.n of "'[.he Nan-c.ucket L.3.l1d C\:r....:!-;cil
l)re=~~rli:e.i a cc~py of ::.he \:Je..tl2.11~:is Rest.r_:.cticir"i Act. ::1ap ;)e:t~t.ai::irlg
to the lot and showed tha~ a portion was indeed subject. Ms.
{:;:.ug:hanc:~..:.r sc:~id. "t.hat DCl al t21."atiorl of t118 sal tmarsn iI/as irrt.e~~::ed.
no\-,: ClY l:l t~~e tU.t.U2-'E~.
l~r. L}al~= agree~i t~:> ~esearc.h tr~e ti t.le :::jr
reference TO the O~6er a~d report on it a~ tte meeting cf M~~'c~
17 ~ J. '3 j e . I~~. 9~eade ac1d.eci "t~.~at. ~ i:-~ t:.!"'.:.5...::;. il;~, -:.ar:C~3, lje agr'?e".~
~""'t:. --:.h ~lfr. Da~e :'11 t.na-:. l-~e j~}1'?~.T c:: m;::-~ny C2se.5 \'tr:..e~e t.~is ~}ic 11~~t.
s~ow up on a title~
Ms. (;c'":; g}-; ,3.rJc;u~'" CC-,:-'lt i:-t1..:ea. 1.~'~}' s1.:t::-:-:i t- ~ 2_:"1 g :5. H:lcr'-:J ge.(";:' .:) g i. c
':n,"!/cstige,"t iCJ!1 :F~e;'c)1.-.:':" "ir..i.~h irl.:::l-.Jc:e;:: 3. gl-::;~..:n(l\";clt-.el." c:::-'r:"t.c}~_'~r- ~;.C~.:-',
g~"':=;~,::1C~,:..,r::~::.el." ~::.'a'f.jel .ti:T:.eS2.r'.iJ2 .:),~~"'i;~.!.g l,:<;=:
"- . .
t C~I" ::.r-~e ::.':' -:.e ..
Ivls. Zirfl:11e-r'ma:": Stlg[:,E'.~t.et:~ ::,:-..;E. C-~;.-.:.E:E:r.\o,.,3.'~..~-ic'!"l (~c'.rrJnis~.:..'::~~l-l h..3(1 +-W~C
aut~ori~y to as}: for a c2~2e~7ation re~:t~i=ti8n i~ ce~ta~~ C2ses
'.~,c'rnr:li.~~s:"C.';-l ::c--:.:ld U:3"':? L.=-~is -r_':-,.::'-:~'st'.yict :::.lr:-.l>~r je.J71.':'I=~!ne~:~:. (':-: 2
,~~ :.=aeI' ~':. pr0tect wetla~lS5~
S:bE" S-3~':,::: ~ rc~.::' e):a!:""lr~__E.'. "t.~.le
~'a:r.~icul.=..l'" 1 ot. a;-..(~ r.:'I^'(.!ceede~ ~~ (j ~u~.lt..e f~~:.;n t}-~e t~e~'.:"arids
IJr".:'t..ect.iSJr: Ac.L.. S:~e repcjrtec: that t.nE:" ~(2~n:t,uc'J:e~ Lan.::' Cc'u::cii
cC;:j~.i!jere6~ this req11E'st 2.J:"!=;2:'"c:}:,ri3:t.8 arld \I,!i)ul.:: be '~iilli!;g "T:.;-: v.lorK
'\...ri th the Col1t."r.i S 5 i '.)rl c,n it.
')
Town of Nantucket
Conservation Commission
Town and County Building
Nantucket. Massachusetts 02554
Minutes of March 3. 1988 Pcge 3
s.~ Stark asked what happen~ \~hen the leaching s~bstrata becomes
saturated. IlI.Is. Coughanour discussed travel times of ni t:.rcxes .
how they are a~sorbed by =clt~arshes and aeded the longe~ the
travel tL~e the better.
Mr. Eeade aSK-eo the Com.'11ission for -::.ne cpr'cl~-::uni-::-.v to reVie\o1 t.be
ney, informa-::ion and presen-c final cor-:-:men.ts at .the meet':':1g or
March 17, 1988. He also requested that the name or Amos
Hostetter be added to the list of par-::ies oppose~ to this
ap?lication.
A motion was made -::0 con1:inue 1:ne hearing UD1:il March 17, i988
f()l'" mo~"'e j~r.itc)l-maticn a:~clt:.~ t.fJe \rJe-c~and5 F.es~ric7~icrl ():~:del-' et -:'r-4e
rec;uest or the applicant. 3.ud for ccmrnents in c:;yposition fr::'m
abutters th:-ough Mr. Reade. I-IT. Dale asked. jlirr. F_eade t.e' senQ
him 11is co~ments at least 5 da:ls Fri(.~r t.() "C.t~e :lext meet.ing s'') a~
to alJoic c,o::tirluir1g "t'.hE~ heariDg o;'-.le r!l<)re L:lme. I"lr. F:eade ag::.-eec
to do so. The motion wa5 carrlec.
i:
~l .
MODOffiOY Harber Rea~tv Tr~s~
Coughanour of IEP, Inc. was
Kevin Dale of Vaughan. Dale
at~0rney tor tbe a~plicant.
- SELr3-469
prese:-lt as
- 60 ~~o~omoy R02d.
~ i I~ ~
agerlt. fc:r tn.e .~pp:i~~~.~r::."t..
and Philbrick was prese~t as
Ms. Coughanour set o~t to 5hcw why rep:ica~icn was bei~g
prCIr:-d)Se~:i arid W01.1~_d net. r;e dc":.rimental t"~G "i~"et2. all'J.S :::'D tl-it S.:.. tl? .
Ca~"'l B{~rcJ-lert ag:reed t}-~e C::J!T'missic;r~ .A"c;uld. list.en ~.Cl he.T'
p~ e:3 E~ rl"'t.:~L_i,i):-i l1n~jer t:'_'~ne C:':f}::J i t"_ic..':-; t.r~a.1: ~;]-;e rf1E- eot ()i: ~:..tle ::.1. t7 ,..c)
,jisc;..:.=:s ~l:.e Pl-'Clj:'()~.a: ""..:2- 't.b ~')8"t.eY [J"ilrl'Yliclc1-=-e "\a!l-.:.') r:..3.(: r;r:,"!..: ~.r~~__ f;~::'er;
the ::,:.;:e.
Sh8 2greed to do Sl~.
1\11:::, .
C;()~l&, t; 2..1-~Ci...:~
s~~t:e::1
"':.he .s.1=~j,:;licar~t
1'J.(le~
r~ot rE'_lS~1 ~he
.:..-:.~a
--'--
{_,: .L
f~lling wetlQ~d3 i:~ gener21. however he wan~5 tc' constr~_.:~ 2
t.'...;()-car g3.r2ge :-~:r.. "":..1-jl:: 2.,:-:.
She said ~~e re~!lica~i!~n c0~:d r'~
\rie"A7ed as a dc.ubling c;f t:le T...<)--::.al v.?8tlarlds .::~~"'e,3. T'h.e a~';:.:..:.!.-:ar~t-
~.c.7as v~ril~_ir~g 1:.() ;!rc/\!ic1e "r~l-~e (:~)rnITtiss.if')l~ '!.N~ t!1 I"egula:!" ~-ep0l~-:.S ":i::
the replicat.ion I s progres;::. SS1e Eidded that t.r):L~' pa::.--t.::icnla::, 2,rea
has historically been 6isturbed by man and she felt replica~i~n
Ylo1.ud likely be succE>;ssr"l and beneficial to wildlife.
I
Town of Nantucket
Conservation Commission
Town and County Building
Nantucket, Massachusetts 02554
Minutes or March 3, 1988 Page 4
IvIr. Dale point.sd 'Jut. that the plan sllbmi tted \>ias the one
preferred by the applicant. but alternative plans were i~ the
works and would be ready :by the Mc.rch 17, 198'3 meeting. :ie said
~he applicants are fairly elderly and wish to make a permaneLt.
ful.l-time move to the Island. They felt the proposal ,;.;a5
:')eneficial Dot.h -to themselves and the. Island as a whole beca..:se
the wetland area would actually be increased and c0uld theref.ore
be beneficial to wildlife. He also wanted Peter Dunwid~ie to
view the site with Ms. COl:ghanour 50 as to convincE:: him of t.l:e
merits of the plan.
Hen!."y Wasiers}':i asked tyh~..r a 03-~e- f.:-ar .garage \~louldn t t wor.r~.
suggeet~ng the applicant consider leaving his other car on ~h~
mainland. He was disturbed by a plan involving filling or a
wetlarlo in c~-d_er to accommodat.e crle mc:.~-e 'vei1icle c:n tr.le I ;:.la:1;j.
Hr. Dale sa'\>1 Henryl:;; point. s.3id .the applicants were an elde::-l"1
couple, yet agreed to feel them out on the idea. The
practicality of the ;:'ropcf,ed bus sY:3terr~ l~elat:ive to eli~'Li!1atir:g
~he need for the additional car was discussed.
A notion was ~ade to con~~nue the heari~g ~ntil March 17. 19S8
for alter~ative plans end a c~a~ce for Peter Dunwiddi6 to Vlew
t:l8 s i tt3 ,,,it.!: Ms. Csugharl()l.:!.--. Tr.:2 rcc~ti_ en 'Vl2.S car::- ied .
6 .
J. Seward J ()11DSC1!:! Jr.
- Almanac Pend Road.
( t~ ~ r~:t i l-::U e ~:1
~--
....... '-
the last ~ee~ing until March 17, 198B.)
"7.
1<. & E~. f::E:al1:j7 !Ii::-1.1st. - ::Els8--4i.6~ - C~::'-t:}cj}:8d
of Laylor Co~sul~ing Gro~lp was pre5e~~ as
':-?P;:'.Llcan-:.. Mel i3.3a PbilbricJ: 0: Vai.:gr-:-3.L.
I.,5.!1E ..
F~c)r)ert 1)2.:" 1 :.!::'
age:-~t f~.::r T-~e
Dale and Ph~~t'l.icj: ~?az
- - - ~
~lrEse~~ as a~~.crney =o~ ~~e ap~_LlCQnt.
IV:r'. D3:1:':' C.:l' .= c J...tJ. 7~~--~e }:i~ .~rlS ere ~C:'t." ir~ ~; ': ier:ti f i (: B,gl--e er:1er~1:. \.l~ -:_':-;'
V}..~:2i::. .t'~.e"Cer I-}~.:r-~v..":..!.:;.d.~e d.e-:.el~i:1e'{.:i tel l:)e t:be \~~tl~~r..cl boun(:1a::---ie-;:=;.
=-.~-;e re\7.:.~,ed I)lar..s st;c;yJed a ;..!€::l-=.fl<:S 2..ir18 ag1.-eed ijj:JC,!"l W':'-::l I'e:-.E":!-
.i r~ "Co.l':. e f i:~ ~.j .
He 1:1rie::ly disc1.:s~ed ar~d re\'i.e~:,(~:.3 'the p~ar:3 3:;:-
\>yell as t.he seils n12K8;Jp.
,.""
\
Town of Nantucket
Conservation Commission
Town and County Building
Nantucket, Massachusetts 02554
Minutes of March 3. 1988 Page 5
Mr. Daylor also submit.ted a plant species list fa:::, the let,
wri.tt.en with Peter :!}t::.nwiddie! s consultation and app=oval. He
des cribed the lot as an old f iela com:nuni ty containi:1g 30r:1e
wetland species. The distance to groundwater a~d sept.i.c systsm
were discussed. The applicant prc!posed to fill 1300 sq. ft.
There was discussion about the possible need to hook up to the
Tov;n sewer on Grove La~e. Ca~l Borchert coulcntt see app~ovi~g
the F:roj ect... Mr. I)ay 1;:1r ag1.-eed t.~ lr:)o}c i;:tr:~ access t.o rc:wn
sewer and requested a contin0ance of the hearing.
Melissa Philbrick wanted to know if there were any problems w~~n
the p~opose6 location of the ~wellings. Bi.ll Willet wanted an
explanaticln for tIle ciis cl~epancies in gro\.:rldTHatE~= dep.'th. l.>c.lia~.:.
lJiscc suggested this 'VIas a matter for the Nantucket Beard of
Heal"Lh and ~hat Richard Ray cl)uld be asked to observe firs~-~and
the t.es~s for depth of g~oundwate~.
A :nc;tio3'1 was n1ade to ccntin1.le t.he l-~earing for r:~ore irltorrna--:.i.or..
about the :::.ep"!.:ic sys-:.enl at the c.r)plic~.=.nt ~ s request. ~r1-Je mo-r.,:,ofl
was carr-lee.
8 .
S?JTI c.:1d Ri :-~a S~c~rJ~
Stark was prese=t.
field in5~ection.
- SEld-i.,70 - :39 liIJ:illbroc,1: R:>ad. rv':.r.
Bill Willet read the resuits of a rece~t
Iv:r. ::;~ark s.3i~j r!.f':? J:'~al1S 1:"() 1:.ie intc; T.:he existing se'p-::ic S-:7s"teI:":.
It \>103.3 unclf3a~ fr2:T\ -:.11e ;;n:-!=}1 icaticrl exectl-l \~.There tne ~~~st.erfi 't'l.:S
1 o ca-::.e(j . ~enry' ~\aSier3j:i ;'.72..3 c':':1cE~r:-~ed T.hat- ",The:! a. C'e-rti:= i::;ste
elf Co~plia~c~e is reques~ed the sep7ic might be in E diffeI'e~:t
~..Lace.
An as-buil~ plan w~s needed.
Donald ViSC0 ~olnted :::-2~
tl-..3.::' '2-..rer.;. i:-i tL.E'; e"\7ent c,:f a. <::':'n=lict ~,jit.h -~he nev~'" '!.:Jel~le..;-.;=s
l.--et-~-<~",l.::'=ttj_o=;~ (;r ':-12\,y Bc'a.r;~ (if :1::::211 t.ll r€.~g""J.i.at..1.c'r!s. if Tv'"...r". S::..3.~",~,:: ;:?.:.
2. l.o-:,#!rull:,t e;.:i~,~t.ir;g ~3tl~..1ct.ure, ~heri rie is DC.:'-:' ~,Ul):E'.ct ~.c.: -:':-:..e:~i
~e~roacti~ely. C2~lBcrc~er~ thc~gh~ i~ there ~a5 a cha~ce ~te
SEp~lC sys~e~ ~ight be expa~6ed, ~he~ ~he new leachi~g fiel~
sho~ld be reprezented in this appl~catic~.
, ----.
. "
Town of Nantucket
Conservation Commission
Town and County Building
Nantucket, Massachusetts 02554
Minutes of March 3. 1988 Page 6
A motion was made to contin~e the hearing for more accurate
plans showi~g 1) exact locations of the existing house,
proposed house a~d septic system relative to the pond a~d
2) plans to expand the septic system in the future. The. notion
Has carrleo.
9. Tabitta Kraughtoff - (23Se-}) - SE48-473? - orf Heick's Hollow
Road. John Shugrue was pre5en~ as agent for the applicant. One
IlE("']E file nurnl::1er ha~j !:;een re(~eiTv.ed vIi th r10 indicati:.)!! as t.o
v7hich of these .t,.!O files i-:. applied. It \<las. felt. the ether
would be issued within the 21-day period during w~i~h the Order
of Conditions ~ust be issued, so it was 5afe to clc~e the
hearing. A mction was made to close t~e hearing. The mcticn
\'.fes carrie,.rj..
10. Tabitha Kra'Jghtof::: - (2368-2) - .:~EI*f:-~73? - off Heick's Baliew
Read. John Shugrue was p~esent as agent for the applicant. One
DEGE file nTh~ber ~ad been received with no ihdica~ion as ~0
ylh~c!l of tt1ese 1:.'\v() f il es it aj;lpl ie{j.. It ~Jas tel t t.he c~ttleT
w::::.:;.J.d be issued wi thin the 21-day period dt..ring which tl-~e Order
::'1= (:c1ndi -r.icns nlust~ t;e i=-.s;,:ea. so it was safe tCi close "t.he
~learing. A rn~)t.ic~n '"~"a5 made to cl,jse the J:-~earir~,g. Ttle rn..:;::if):1.
v.!-3S Cc..rl--:..e..:..
B. RESeLAR I~ETING
i\linu-s'3S
of
~ ,
:- e.t~ruar'v
11.
1988.
A nlc~.ion was made
- :-,
a. c: C e ~:J -:. :.:.t~ e
,:Ti':' T: 1]1:. e 5 c.:3 .....,r:;..... l. -t_l. e:"1 "
The m''Jtic'Jr:: '.7as ca~I'.ied..
(it.her' 3"'.::..s 2..ne 5:7:,
David Can~~ell -- RE:
1: Pc.~J..iwc:g: P(iD(:: F~.:)ad - ;:;E~8~.il,~7"
l/l::' .
Cantrell. pastor cf the Nant~cke~ United Meth~dis~ churct. was
~resent to ~ave clarified the sonditions imposed C~ t~e
cbove-me~~i~ned fi~e.
. ~ -... ~ . .
SlDce ne haG ~ct Dee~ presen~ G~~l~g ~~~
hearings. He fea~ed tha~ l~ater flow wc-u~d be res~ri_c~ed w~e~
-;:he ariV8vIBY was put. in across Wh.3t he c:or.:z.idered an a::::'ea '..:e-::.
~or most of the yearc This water could potential:y ilood the
par](ing lot on his property. He also voiced co~cer~ about
impac~ O~ wildlife i~ t~e area.
)
')
Town of Nantucket
Conservation Commission
Town and County Building
Nantucket, Massachusetts 02554
Minutes of March 3, 1988 Page 7
[J011alc Visco P':Ji:1ted c~ut t.rlat I'1r. (;an1:rell mu::.t r-~a"~e realized
the 1 ots behind him woul j be b1.lil t on eventually. I"rr. CantreLL
l~eplie-:l t.hat the real tor who sold him his lot claimed that area
was safe from development. Donald said the houses would all be
on Town sewer and this driveway in particular wo~ld involve so~e
filL.ng. Another of t.!18 lots E,howed a culvert cn the pla.~l~.
con~isting of three 12-i~ch plpes.
A motlon was made to send a letter to applica~t Joh~ P. Doo~ey
stat~irlg it had C.(1:r:e to the l~ornmiss.i.c~r: f s attent.ion that tr16
driveway about to be constructed on the lot could act as a d~n
and may cause f loodi:lg cn a~l adj acent. lot or in a basemen"'..: ovrnea
by the Nantucket U~ited Methodist Church. The Com~issio~ \voulc
l:"eq-Ce2:t. he instc.ll an e - i~cll ciia'T1et.er cuI \re~'t l.lnde~ the dri '\.rew'Pc\.:'
to c..~/oi(.i any flocH:ting prc,blems irl the ru.ture. The rnoti::>rl \"as
car~-iE~C~ .
b. Rober~ Daylor - Wooebury Lane - SE4B-312 - snowfencing.
l:O"Llse.. rvI~~. Da:llc:r ,,1as preS~3nt t.:) ~"'eq1..1es-t the fCJllc~~7ing:
lj permission t.:.o remove :=.iltation reDcing beT-ween the exist:.:-;g
'JTet.i.2:_"l~i l~n ~ot 23 and the compensat(.j1..-.Y' wetland befc~re the :-.:e\,I-/
veget.ation growE in: 2) as referred to in t~e Order of
(~c~diti~ns, co~structicn of a Greek ~evj.val house was 7.0 begi:t
i:: kpril 1988.
The applic'a~t requested an on-si~e cClnfere~ce ~.'~
assure ~he adequac~' of 2ite-p~epa~2tion 2D~ erosicn.contr;~~
meEL3'.::r'::,s during c-::nS1::r-..lcti'::;n:
3 ;
a 'req'U.{3~.t fl:;I- a j.....a.I.~.::.i3.=-
Cer~if~sate of Cc~plia~ce
... - .-.
':~'r:. LI:;1,:. ,j.
C:a:::,"l ~Jc:rc~.r.:er.t t:..:"1(':1..:gl-~t "':.~~e "':'-eq.;Jes't.s vlerp ~-ea3c-r.iaDIE" a_rl~=~ 5':":~~:..-:::5"'C..e,j
MI'. D.~ylor d=aft -~he F~r~~~: Certificate of (:omplian=e a~Q
3~Jl:~:::it. it "':.() t.r:.e C:::;!r..r~j.5s,i-~:;; ;':lerore T.ne :-~e:,.:t rnE-e':::,l'"lg. A =-:.e_:_:.~l
ir.l5T.'t7 c't:. ':'TI ~"la:=. 2' c:-~ed:.ll -=,.:1 r ::::. Sl.::-ld=~...,., Ii.1;=.I.c:h 6 .5. ~ '3 ill":.
c. l\l.~ri"t.uc}~et CClrr~~c.~rls 7:r-"'C.2.t - F~FD &:. !\-J(;I. Ac1n1i.l1is't.r2~:-'::1.'" Ee~
McI(€,1~~".5Y described t,,JO l"'e::ent 1~ i1 irlgs ar:d ::~e cCJmpl ica"t.i.c:r~5
surroun6ing the fact the::. they had been submi ~ted a:: the ",eel:': ng
of February 25, 1988 (at w~ich the Nantucket We~lands
Reg~lati0ns were adopted late in that meeting) anc af,-er the
~
~\
Town of Nantucket
Conservation Commission
. Town and County Building
Nantucket, Massachusetts 02554
Minutes of March 3, 1988 Page 8
me~t~ir~g 11ad comrnenced. ,:it that. The ap;:,lic,;'itioflS, after beirlg
reviewed ~he next aaYr February 26, 1988, \{ere discovered ~o be
lacking "the necessary checks and were t1:erefore incomplete. The
applicant's agent was called and the checks, dated Feb. 26,
1988. were delivered later in the day.
The question 'IJas ..{hetter ~he applicat.ions ~"ere indeed e}:Em;:::.t.
fr:)~~ tl1e rle\.~" l...eg1.l1at'.ions and ~~e:r'"E~ af:-forde(~ a Feb ~ ~:5 date c:r--
should net be properly considered complete until the Feb. 26
date. "Tt.:.e C:omrniz5i~:;r: deci~ie:j to cc;n~3it:3er F'el~. Lb. 1988 t-r:e
effective filing date since sec. 10.05 (~J (a) states the
filil-~g fee is one of the filing reqtli:r:'en:el1ts.
d. h. & S. Holland - SE~8-~52 - 117 Madaket Road - poss~ble
viola\:ion. Ben McKelway mentioned a problem with siltation
occurring on ~he site now and agreed to send a letter ~equesting
that 20 ft. of sil tat.ior: fencing and jute netti!:g be ins-t.alled
on the hill betvlee:-l t.he dri~,TeHay and the pcr:d. Another si 1:.e
where :mud is ready tc. go over the tops of: t.ne haybales also
neeied a~~e~:tion.
e.
Dir~ piles at 19 Madake~ Road - possible violation.
Be;-:
l.VTCr.:'21wCl"1 ,:1;~sc;l"'i1:';ed cOl~iji tions at the-. 5': te 2.:-.d submi -:"t.ed ~t"'ecent
t.\h'~:it.CiS. T1-...e C~(.)mmissic\n acide,j tt:e prc\peyt:.~' (,:!w:1ea ]:;y. Heic::..
Todd and Ric11ard F. Koza~) to ~te lis7 elf field inspec~ions.
f.
~)'.1n:': C3.:::-~ o=f Milit::....c,c,}: RC1ct::t - F'C'~~s.:i"t:;le '\.,"i::";1,3"t..:."~'r:..
....:z=., "-.
':-'-,- ....,
Mc:r~el~,;a:? 2,}:':.\1-:e c~f an 13n~J-:-;~.7]111::':J_S 1:"ep;:.Jr-c recei~.t€~C_ ~~~':'l:t 3CJ
\/'el~lCJ..es seern.irlg1~l <i~~s(;ay,:ie'::! i~ a '1\7€:tiar:d. '?r:'3 '~('nce::-:! "v!2~'
aver t!:8 ;'(2si.ble co~ta~~na~io~ by ga5(\:i~e~ ~~15 0Y- 0~neY
~OXlS Sub~'~3nces to the we~ianci vEg6~~t_~C~. wildlif~ ~~d
,~ats:.-'
-_:='~'i! C
-...-_..-"- -. -
3e~ !1~d visited ~he site a~i taken pj.ctur~5.
i.ch':?re wa:3 e.;{-:.e115i"\l-e i::lSC.tlSSl;~:rl abc.'ut 'r\..rl-l.3t ~hQ ~(.lle c!t T.:.le
Adrr~i.6list:-'Gt-::r S11()t:l(~t t_~e ir1 ree:;:.orlse "t,c~ ~:.'Cc25ic;r~2.1 reJ)'.=-)~"'~:::
follow-u?s on repor~~; s~ch as this_ Donald Visco had ml:ch
say abc~t the aF'propria~eness of trespas~ing onto pr~va~e
pro?erty in order ~o investigate a possible violation. ne
thoug~t tr.:.e C:cHnrr:ission =.rlc7ulrj :t"ia\Te been corltac:t.ed =il...~,t a:-l!:} tJ-len
-:. ~.')
~-
,
Town of Nantucket
Conservation Commission
Town and County Building
Nantucket, Massachusetts 02554
Minutes of March 3, 1988 Page 9
a field inspection tea~ COUld visit the site if deemed
neceS'3a:ry. Ben McKehiay felt. he was empowered to do so by -r.:-;e
state Wetlands Protection Act and Carl Borchert agreed. car~
reI t T.:.hat i-laS C;De ot the many reasons -the Commissic.n had hire::'
an Admi~:istratol~.
Donald sa,.... t.his as a zoning problem. Abandoned and unreg.istel.-ed
vehicle::: =.re cov'ered under a Town byla;..l and he sugges.ted
referring ~he report tv the Nantucket Board or Selectmen and the
BuiJ.oit.g Cc'rnrnissionel~. Donald also rel t all complaints shoL:ld
be ~ade in Hri ting to the Commission and signed by tJ1e ?el'sc'r:
subm:."c::ing the complaint.. Carl Borchert disagreed and t.ho1..:gtt
p'ec?le should reel free to report si ;::uationz. of c,:'nc:ern to -:.bem.
\..rhen i-:e Has Building Commissi')nel~. he i'.iould rout.inel y accel='T..
arl(~rr}rrrlC::_:2'. re;)Ol....t.s 9 [)onald \..;as concerrled a])out 1 iaJ:..ili t":i"
Henry ':!asierski and Carl both recalled that t2:e Com;ni::-,sic:'-l ;-:ad
vo~ed at a meeting in Nov. 1987 to designate Ben McKelway a~
the CorruT.ission I s agent, which at the -eime refeJ::red mostly "C.;)
representation at other boards~ meetings~ but in a gene~al een~e
""'Tas 17~€~c.r:t to t.aJ:e 5CJrr~e or the- load off the CCirrLrnissic;n i tS6J. f .
Carl mc....;ed. tel gi't...7'e E.en carte-blanche authorl:~)1 to j_l-r\,:-estiga:::e
pos.sib2-e 'J.7:lcllatioflS al1d t.resspass if necessary. Trle rrICjt~C":'n ~~7,:iS
11 c; l:. sec~:"!1-:led a:1d t.","'as t1-lerefo~~e withdraw~. Ca:....l st'1gge~',-::ec E:e:-l
lee;}: :':-1-:0 ,,.;hat \~tller (:c)rlse:r.~J'aticrl CCjrr~'"nissicJn Af.:imi~1i5t::'at.oJ...-'5 ,5cl
in t~e~e instances and t~ report back.
The discussion wc:~J.j te
. ~. - -
C0!1~~~~Sd 2~ a ~ater date.
,.,
:=.-
Pol?is Read Bikepath.
Nant~cket Land Use P~a~ne= 3~~a~
hiie::,8 };,clj .3.sJ.:ea. E',en !~c};~el'\}.72.:l h':1\;] the C.(.r;miss.ic!1 ,..~~o~J.ld ~.:..j.:.::- ~C.
see iile~i ~.lans for the bike~'.3th.
:S~ef.~:r~-iIlg tc~ ::c:'-'.' the iv:.~:.::.~:e7..
3ike~'2~n had been ha~dled~ Carl Borcje~t suggested fili~~ ~
Rei~:..:e~::-:. =c~ I)et:ermi.:-~a;:ic~rl S::-.: t.he C~crrLTnis~io~ cC:~.1ld :5.0 c. f".:els
inS?8ction and view prelimi~ary plane. 3en agreed ~~ sen~ ~
mem:, ::,,::,-ck to Mr. ~-Jiese to -:.nat effect.
h. DE0E si~e visi~s ... 1~5ted on agenda. Robert Dayl~r or
DayleT i.::c,nsulting Group ':::or:1mented on the Dupo:1t site visit
say:.ng ::-;.e wasn't quite sure vi!'.:.:: DEQE had intervened and t:-:c,-ught
.'--.....
"
Town of Nantucket
Conservation Commission
Town and County Building
Nantucket. Massachusetts 02554
Minutes of March 2. 1988
Page
1t"1
.LV
any questions would be answered when they actually saw the site
and plans in the field. Mr. Daylor sugges~ed, in the interest
of moving things along, that it reay be possible fer the
Commission to arr,end its Order :)f Conditions -'.:.0 suit the DEOE's
concerns rather than wait for DEOE to issue a S~perseding Order.
The Co~mission agreed to consider that as a possibility if and
~411en the case is remanded ..t.o trle C:ornrnission.
.,
~, .
Request.s for ;:::etermina"t.ior:
a. Be,3.chs ide Re.3.1 ty 'Iru5t. - !\[c,rth Be.3-cn S"t.reet. Att.c:r:rle~i
Richard Glidden cf Glidden ani Glidden was present as age:1-::-. :cor
the applicant. There was discussion about w~ere the fill frc~
"t.118 exca~...ratiC~!1 for the s'hTirrJT'~ir.:g pool "i'oul~j go ar1d Ml...... (~lid~jen
agreed to send a letter abo~t it.
A motion was made to issue a negative Determination stating ,-he
work deecribed in the Re~uest is within the Buffer Zone! as
defined in the regulaticns, but will not alter an Area SLbject
to Protection Under the Ac~. Therefore. said work does Dot
rec;uire the filing of a I\jc~t.ice c:f Ir:tent. Tl:e r:(yte ft AI: fill
will be taken t.() an upla:1'~ sitet1 \IJil.l be c.ridec. fIne moti(':n wc..s
c3.rl'ied.
o. Topla!1d Properties - Lc'w Beach
j:'l"e~en~ as a.ge-nt. f~:--r t.tle o~~}:<i.ic-~nt.
withdr~~~ ~.he Req~e~~. with ?ia~s ~~
:Road.
;]Ci:ln t:i1u.gr-Ue "l,~GS
- -
anc. ~""eque s -::e..). ~:!e::--rr~.l;::::: l!:':-':
:tl~.E: a. l~c~~ice :---r lZ'l-:S::"':.
--\-}
PeT~is5ion was g~'a~ted.
'-1. CeI.t-l. f 2. c.s.i:e.5 of f:C;:1j;'.L i2..:-.;.;::e
B.
Joh~ ~. Grep:~~e~f - S~43-13 - 3 Hulbert AVA.
fJ.. m':~"'C ~-::: ~.l..-.~ 5
rnac~e t.) :.ssue. a ~:~E,::-tifi(;,~:te C;!. ::c:f:"~~.li-:;:-.;.ce cel.--~..:i.fyi:Jg tr~.~t. -:i-_~~
'lJor}~~ regulc.t_ed tlY t~ie a1:jc:\/e'-~:-e::ere:1c8d C.:l""'der ,.):: :~c;~1d=-t:_::;:-.:3 l-~.5;:::
been sa~isfacto~ily cOffiple~ed. :he mQ~lCn wa~ ca~~~ed.
b. Joan Bolling & ,..Tohn Gl'eer:leaf - SE/le-7S - 3 ~"..~lber.t k.:e. F.
motion was made to issue a Certif icat.8 (,f Compl iance certifyi:1g
that the work reg"Jlated by the above-referenced Order of
Conditions has been satis:-actc.rily completed. The r::c-::ion was
carried.
/}
f:
,.~
)
Town
Conservation
of Nantucket
Commission
Town and County Building
Nantucket, Massachusetts 02554
Minutes of March 3, 1988 Page 11
c. ~rohn Gree:11eaf - SElJ,8-190 - 3 Hulbert Ave. A motion was
made to issue a Certificate of Compliance certifying that the
work reg~lated by the above-referenced Order of Conditions has
been satisfactorily completed. The motion was carried.
d. JCh:1 IvI. Greenleaf - SE/~8-228 - 3 Hulbert Ave. A motion ,o/as
made t-o issue a Certificate of Compliance certifying that the
work l-egulat-ed by the above-referenced Order of Conditions has
been sRtisfactorily cOffipleted. The motion was carried.
e. John & Lewis Greenleaf - SE48-395 - 3 Hulbert Ave. A ffiO~lon
~~as made to postpone issuance of a Certificate until the d~ne
2rea behind the bulkhead has been revegetated. The motion ~ras
car~j_ed .
f. Perkins - LaFrance - SE~8-386 - Valley View Drive. Rc~ert
Emack of Nantucket Surveyors was present as agent for the
applicant. There were questions about whether the sewer was
hooked up. !VIr. Ernack stated the status of the sewer hookup
doesn't affect the wetlands in question at all. the buildi~g lS
being used as a workshop and there is a Certificate of Occupancy
fer the build~ng.
The Co;r.::<ission 'i.,ranted to see proof of where se'..rage is goircg.
includi~g the Certificate of ()ccupancy. Stones to tee placed --
the 1:J(,Y-:~0:11 ~::f a rocr c:rai:1 were det~e-:::rr~i:1ed :"lot t...) r~e a F~rc;Dlern.
A motion was ~ade to post~o~e issuance of a Certificate c:f
(~om'Pl.i ;=~rlce i.J.:1t~il inr or::iaticl!1 (Jrl "v\'here sewage. \.Jill ~o is
I-ec.ei'\~ed. I"1~. E:nacj{ agl--eed t.o ap~)ear ~3t tr~e I~arc1-J. 17. :"S8b
r:1.eet.ir;g ..
4. Orders :~t Conditions
a. ?abitha Kraughtoff - (2368-1) - SEl.t8-~73 ? - off Hoi8ks
Hollc:,;.J r:oad. A motion was made to issue a standard Order of
Conditi8Ds to include the following special condition:
1..'.01
-"
Town of Nantucket
Conservation Commission
')
Town and County Building
Nantucket, Massachusetts 02554
Minutes of March 3, 1988 Page la
1. Eighty-five (85) feet of snowfencing shall be installed
between the house and the bluff, centered on the house, and
shall be maintained in good condition throughout the duration of
the project.
The motion was carried. Since only one DEQE file number
had been received, issuance of the Order was pending receipt of
the other referenced to the accompanying application, below
( i!b ) .
b. Tabitha Kraughtoff - (2368-2) - SE~8-~73? - off Hoicks
Hollow Road. A motion was made to issue a standard Order of
Conditions to include the following special condition:
1. One-hundred (100) feet of snowfencing shall be installed
between the house and the bluff, centered on the house, and
shall be maintained in good condition throughout the duration of
the project.
The motion was carried. Since only one DEQE file number had
been received, issuance of the Order was pending receipt of the
other referenced to the accompanying application, above (i!a).
c. Elizabeth McIlvain - SE~8-~72 - Millbrook Road. A motion
was made to issue a standard Order of Conditions citing the
pertinent plans. The motion was carried.
There being no other business, the meeting adjourned at 10:05 PM.
I
1