HomeMy WebLinkAbout1985-12-19
....~
~~~TUCJr;'~
t:O~ ~~
f \~\
0_ 1(1)1
I-~.. ,'. ,
. ,. I
;..... - . .....,
~.. - .~'" "
.,^, ~ - ..~~
..., .. .... ... ....
()~::"'''''';.l\)' ~
rORA1~ it......
.........".
Town of Nantucket
Conservation Commission
Town and County Building
Nantucket, Massachusetts 02554
Agenda December 19t 1985
A. Public Hearings
1. Leonard Sherman - SE48-335 - Squam Road
2. Harborside Realty Trust - Christman Cottages
3. Carter Cafritz - Hulbert Ave.
4. Robert McGrath - Miacomet Pond
B. Regular Meeting
1. Minutes of December 5t 1985
2. Requests for Determination
a. Robert Garrabrant - Madaket Harbor
3. Orders of Conditions
4. Field Inspections
a. Dennis Shapiro - SE48-239 - Tristrams Avenue
b. Harborview Shopkeepers - South Water Stt Oak St't South Beach St.
5. Correspondence
a. Declaration of Easements and Restrictions running with land on
Woodbury Lane.
b. James Cabral - DEQE Appeal
c. Ponds Appeal
d. Mass Historical Commission Newsletter
e. MSMCP Brown Bag Lunch Series
f. Current Budget Sheet
6. Other Business
a. Nantucket By-Laws - Report from M. Arnold and L. Dunn
b. Warrens Landing
-"
Town of Nantucket
Conservation Commission
Town and County Building
Nantucket, Massachusetts 02554
Minutes of December 19t1985
The public hearings of December 19t1985 were called to order at 7:30 p.m.
Members present were: L. Dunnt M. Arnoldt L. Lesket M.J. Williams.
Members absent were: D. Viscot P. Waine and P. Dunwiddie.
A. Public Hearings:
1. Harborside Realty Trust - Christman Cottages. L. Leske moved to
continue the hearing until DEQE issues a file number. So voted.
2. Carter Cafritz - SE48-343 - Hulbert Ave. Bob Emack was present as
the agent. P. Dunwiddie and L. Leske have not viewed the site or
reviewed Stuart Steele file. Emack would like the commission to
move on this hearing tonight.
Stuart Steele - 4' wide stairway
- final foundation plan
- no coastal structures
- no impeding dune movement
Orders require final plan to be submitted to the commission
before construction begins. House has begun but the commission
has not received plans!
Mark: The impact of the new house will not change existing conditions.
Piling foundation will actually improve sand movement relative
to existing full block foundation. The boardwalk on sand is
to be replaced which is better than no walk at all as blowout
problems from foot traffic. There will be a minimum disturbance
to the dune with hay bales and fencing being used.
Lee Dunn moved to close the hearing. So voted.
3. Leonard Sherman - SE48-335 - Squam Road. The public hearing was
continued for a field inspection with John Shugrue.
4. Robert McGrath - West Miacomet Road. John Shugrue was present as
the agent. Three areas of concearn were discussed.
1. If the Planning Board allows 16ft. wide then 200 sq. ft. of
bordering wetlands are to be filled. If they allow 12 ft. then
no wetlands to be filled.
2. If 16 ft. widet then 100 sq. ft. of wetlands to be filledt
also 800 sq. ft. below bank to be partially filled. If 12 ft.
wide then 30 sq. ft. of wetlands and 360 sq. ft. of bordering
Town of Nantucket
Conservation Commission
Town and County Building
Nantucket, Massachusetts 02554
wetland to be filled.
3. If 16 ft. wide then no wetland to be filled and 360 sq. ft.
of bordering wetland to be filled. If 12 ft. then about 100
sq. i't.
Even at 16 ft. widet still less than 500 sq. ft. to be filled and
if the Planning Board allows 12ft. even less will be filled.
Lee Dunn moved to continue the hearing so the applicant could talk
to the planning Board about the critical places and allowing a
12 ft. width. Peter and Lucy are to check the delineation with
Mr. Shugrue and Mark will speak to the Planning Board.
The replacement area is not available to the applicant.
B. Regular Meeting:
1. The minutes of December 5t 1985 were approved.
2. Requests for Determinations:
a. Robert Garrabrant - Madaket Harbor. The field inspection report
notes that the building is back from the buffer zone. A letter
is to be sent stating that anything within 100 ft on the plan
requires a filing of a Notice of Intent. The commission issued
a positive determination stating the the area is an area subject
to protection under the act. Thereforet any removingt fillingt
dredging or altering of that area requires the filing of a Notice
of Intent.
b. Harborview Shopkeepers - South Water St't Oak St. South Beach St.
Construction for new shop located away from water. L. Leske
moved that the project is not significant. A negative determination
will be signed at the next meeting as there was no form in file.
3. Extention Permits
a. Dennis Shapirot SE48-239. Tristrams Ave. L. Leske moved to issue
an extention for three years on this project which has not been
started.
4. Orders of Conditions
a. Carter Cafritz - Hulbert Ave.SE48-343. L. Leske moved to issue
Orders of Conditions modeled after Stuart Steeles Orders from
file number SE48-273. So voted.
Town of Nantucket
Conservation Commission
Town and County Building
Nantucket, Massachusetts 02554
5. Correspondence- All correspondence on December 19t 1985 Agenda
was read.
6. Other Business
a. Nantucket By-Laws - L. Dunn and M. Arnold postponed discussion
until after Christmas.
b. Warrens Landing - L. Dunn dropped a note to Bruce Wattst no
response as yet.
The meeting was adjourned at 8:40 p.m.