HomeMy WebLinkAbout1987-12-17
Town of Nantucket
Conservation Commission
Town and County Building
Nantucket, Massachusetts 02554
AGENDl-~ rOE DECEHBE.R 1. 7. 1987
A. PUBLIC HEARINGS
1. Nantucket We~lands Regulatio~s
2. Barth/Taddonio - 79 Eel Point Road
3. John Mark - SE~8-~~3 - 28 & 30 Gosnold Road
4. Joseph & Joan Cochran ET AL - SE48-442 - 54 & 56 No. Beach Stree
5. Nantucket Commons Trust - SE413-449 - Pleas, Dave, Or & Bear Stre
6. Luntz/Emerson - SE48-446 - New Sou~h Road & Weweeder Ave.
7. Wayne H. Dupont - Codfjsh Park Road
8. Elizabe~h McIlvain - Millbrook Road
9. Mic:hael Elc,ornberg - 115 Baxter Eaad
10. Hudson & Sandra Holland - 117 Madaket Road
11. Ellen Fl,?..3TD - SE4B-451 - id :3quam Read
12. Eicha~cd e,.d Nicki Gambl e -. POCODW Re,ad
13. Peter Nash/Gifford - One Easton Street
14. J. Pepper Frazier - 3'7 Gardner Road
15. Law.ceLee Pfaff - Alabama Ave.. IVIadc1.ket
16. Craw's Nest Associates - 10 Crow's ~est Way, Wauwinet
B. REGULAR MEETI~G
1. MinlJtes elf December 3, 1987
Minut.es cr Decem...1;er 10, 1987
2. Other Eu~i~e3s
a. Kei~h M. Y~nkow - 22 Starbuck Road - well easement
b. Pon'J. 'dater qual i ty - Bartlett Farm, N2nt.ucket. Cranberries
c. Stephen F'araljis - SE48-~04 - 28 Grove Lane - rev. plans
(}. T'ic}: -'C1..1t'es - l--e<=Itlest fr<)Dl DPv./
~:.. P~eql1es-t~, f,,)J.:" Del_e::r.T:1inati'~'):1
2. Jessi.8 H. Wielage - Wauwil1et R!~2;i
b. StQ~~e Earn II~n Trust - 58 & 60 N'~rth Beach St.reet
C~e~t~_f iCct~e~. cif Cc~rnr.'J iance
a~ !~i~t;SI'~ Waine - SE~8-33 - Beachsids Mctel
b. W2lt~r ~r. C2irnes - SE48-~Ol - 82 E:a):ter Rc,ad
5 . Orde:=~~. c: f ' :<:1 ji t.:.. - :-13
6. E2-11 s t'.:., :10 l)a.id.
7 . Carre:=;-;: '=ndence
8. Fielc1 I!-l:::r-'E;.:~ti;)ll~'
Town of Nantucket
Conservation Commission
Town and County Building
Nantucket, Massachusetts 02554
IJIi,futes of I'ecember 17, ::.987 Page 1
Mnm'TE2 OF DECH1BER .~ '7
1987
The public heari~gs of December 17, 1987, werE: called ~o order at 7:34
Pl'l. Members present Here: Lee L'U:1n - Vice Chairman, Henry \rJa::::iercJti,
Car 1 Borchert. Gra:-lville Cran:=-t-.on. Member:=- ab:::;ent were: Pe~er
DumoJiddie - I::hai:r:-man, Don21d Visco, Rill h'ill et..
A. PUBLIC HEARINGS
1.
~antucket Wetlands Regulatior~s.
Carl Borchert maven to ccnt~nue
'the hear~~ng.
::~o T.yTot.E'-d.
~ Barth/Taddonio - 79 Eel l'oint Road. Aileen Jart~ ~ad coc~a~ted
DEQE ~nd agreed to caJ.l ttem again to see abo~~ the delay ll~
receiving t.ne LEGE f i~~e n'lmber. Hen::::-y Wasierski m,y,..-ed "'::c
'::;or;T_inue t:.he hearing f,:;T' 2. DEGE file n'_Enber. .:::"_ voted.
3 .
John Mark - SE43-~43 - 28 & 30 Gosnold
pre5e~t as 2gent fer ~hE applicant 2nd
of the hearing. Henry Wasierski moved
s:) T./c;t~(3,:=l.
Road.
3cJnn
,-, ~
;:,r-.:'L:grl18 ~"as
cc,r:. t..i. r~ 1..: a.:lc-e
l~eq-Je5~ed a
t.o c~c:nt.in~Je
tr~e riearirlg.
~. iJcseph & Joan C~c~1ran ET Ali - SE48-4~2 -- 54 & 56 No. Bea,:h
::,i~~l'e et.. A 2. et,'t.eT' f:>:;r71 A ~t<~I::""'rle"'l ~ed. '2.": i 11 ot":'SC\rl "i...~;as T~0a(3. aD:,j
re't]iew"'s':1.. .J:~~:;. :~~l:~l,srue \,...;3S prpc-.erl't c..:o..S agerlt r:::r t.l-~e 3l=1l=-1~c;::'.r.:.~:.
,3r.l'':': =t~2.ted. tJl,~t. IVll--. Ma,::-'-:"'JS rna.y" r)e J::'e't../'_~.,Si!lg a lettt?l- ~,1.:t.~ITli ~~-:.ed
wi~~: the c:~iginal a~p~~i~2t~~)n.
Ca~l Borchert mc:ved
+ r,
-',-./
_~c<r: 'C': .:-:t.:e
t:r-~e l-leaT :.rlg fer ITt<..'::.--e i:1fc:~"'r;~.at.i\:)1-1.
:::.0 '"'..lot.ec...
~\. l'Ja.:l-:-~-i_l'~~~k,f.::-c ;~_',CJrTjjTI":;:13 ..:=':....t12t - SS'*:':, - ~,L.r~? - F;l F:asa.'Ilt 1 L:\7....,le ~ i_;~~',:=-,:-~:::e !~~-
!:'ie5:-' ::~T.Yee.t:..:=,.
tiE r.:.r'./1' V..-r2 ~~ i el~ 5]::' \'7:..3 l-H? C:, t.,:) "l:.]~...) .:~ C e
.- - ~
: C;l~ ~~-~ E: :--'2 ~=: (1:~'C.t
s~me (;f hj.s (jjsc(-'~te~lt (.~er jow tti,s a~~)J.i=ati':jn ~a3 pr(~gr2sse\j.
rlt? .\...~ ,::;.::.': 2 t i 1 i ~.1 r:~::: -s t, .;::. -::-. ~. ~.~ e 2, E.: E';11i11 g 1 '~1 cJ-:. () f C'. CI (II:: eI.~ 2: t..~"::-J. ~ ~::'c':--r. tl ': e
21=l!=' l i. :' e,:1 t E~ L r:i.r.or~pt.l'y c .='l....~~e ct i:-.:.g \7 j i:; 1 ,S -:. ~~ (: :~~;::. . r e }-~ 3d. :=. 't.~::, e~-.'tv~r:: d
T...}-1<3::- \.1,~.t.e y' "-'.~l,3:=. 2', t-. ':"11 ~--:_:rl~ '1 .-:..:n E" ~.lr~de r tl-le ~ i I t~.2. ti ('D, f t.~'" :-.....e 3.:--~ c t~-~ ,= l"'!=
.r~ac. L;ec.~rl SCIT:8(>ne ':;'E.::a-:::'::-:.g a fC;J_~J:lit.~ acr::\ss ,5 g.~.lJ l~/. l-iC:~l"':,"
d~d~lt thin): ~he ~u~noff ~~hc)uld be fU:1~,eling d,~~~~ i:1tC ~}:e
\A,'etl::j"},j ar~d tj-iat. t.l:.e r:':r".~.:ble:n e)::istE.:j })eCc.~lse 1Jegeta.t il~:'n }-ia,d l:~eeI1
","'"TUCIr~~
~~ ~~
!~~i
~~)~J
~"~~=-I.~I
(', ~-='..,..,",ro~
0.9,0"-.......,;, 9' ,
ORA1w. ...~
......"
Town of Nantucket
Conservation Commission
Town and County Building
Nantucket, Massachusetts 02554
Minutes of December 1'7. 1987
f'age w
stripped. He tho~gnt they were supposed to have built the
retention basins and drainage systems ~ir5t. He suggested ~hat
the :-r:,reman Tom Harvey r.~ight ni~~,t be that f amil ial- t",ri th ,,;etlands
ar1d l)E:l:rl,:::r=ls t.1-~e C,ornrni~.:::-,.ioll srlould t-;e c8,3.1ing 'vrit.h scn.~~=IJr;.e E-IE.e.
There ,,~a3
, . .
Ol:::CU;3;=;lCrJ
.abc-'-.:t. \.Jl1ere the rt:nrlclff "',"'.35 OcclJ.l"r2...rlg.
It
v.,?EiS ri()teQ tl1at. t.l1e C\c-~rnrn:~sE,iorl 1-.:.c~~,:1 I'lC)t :iE:t. r'ecei\/~d a \.JOl-'.i':~
schedule. a co~binatio}1 of the state and tl)wn Orders of
Cc)r;_d.it~ic~ns c.r a.r~~i h':ld.l--c\lc~g~}' clat2~. Adrrlirlist.l"2.+~OI' Ber~ ~i:-cl{el'~1,~=-:'~7
said tl'"8 applice.rll: had rJct yet c,ppl ied for perJ.'.i t~:: cr revie-w
from other to'~n bc:ards, and added that the regulati_ons sta"te the
(~cr:m1iss-=-C)11 C<3.D set a t.i!7~e li.i:li t_ fc<:.:- t.ne receipt c.:: rlEvl
informati.on fro~ an 3f!plj_cant.
Ilyn.n Z.irnrnerma:1 of tIle l'.Jant~-1~::l:et Lor-l,j CC:l~ilCil 51..:1:):ni t.ted 2 letter
,...7hic~1 CT'i ticized t.l-:e ~'J':eL.c1-1~7. EiY-1Q a-t: tirne.s c()nt.r.3(jictcY'~{, })la:l.s,
and tl~-'gE:d_ t'he Cor:lIr..i3si,'J~ t_c: req11ix'e a }-lE.\"T revi'::::v.J of tr18 site- fo::.~
wildli.fe value and dr2j_nage capacity of tl~E wetla~d. Carl
Borch.e'rt. f".aid t.ht3 se't",rel-- is o'v:o-erl()ad.ed and t.n.3.t -tl-1e af)plicar~t.
does nc:t have 2ny se'~er connectio~s i11 the pla~5.
I>i2..r"le (~oonlt!=, of the Hal"';:~c;~ c.~-ld St.d?llfisi-: PiC~\7isc~r~~l "Boetrd s~)o}:e
abcll~~ the possitlle da~2ge t.O the ~!etla~d f~om all ~}1i5 activit.y.
She said she sees evj_dence ,~f wiltjlife using thj_s ~~e.tJ_and al~"
the ~irrle. She ~eared ~he waterfo,.!l aDij other birds would move
away =ri~m the area wit~ increased di5t11rba~ce fro~ developmer:t.
.Sr-...t? S2'=' d C'111c:e -:.tle G.a"r~13ge is dC'lle t cc::r"l."'ect..l."v-'-e rne2:'::;":Jres ':i:.~e
c1 iff i c~l~.l"t, CT im;:"()~, s i~;.l e .
She felt [~EOE had s'urveved tte are?
. - -
l ri ,=~ ;:;. ~ ..:~ ';_: a -: E: 1 <OC./ .
TI/Is.
I.~: c) .:~ r.J:, s. '\...':' e n t
,r-. "-, -r--
-'.;....;. \.... ....-'
I:::rC'Jec:'"t. t}:dt
contj_::uej devel:)pment i~ this
2.1-'Pa. c"::,1:.l d. C::iTi-cr i.1J-;-.:.t e tel::.rli2 (jE~ C l iJ-j:=' ,~~n ~,:h e s c~211 :::}:; j. 11(:1;:::, .tl"'y'
frc;;n r'll~':Jff i~~0 ~he h2r~'0~'.
~31-.:. ..~ 2. (1 ~j E: (: t. ~b 3 -c t J~; e ::r- e "vI .'=" i~.ll d. :-1 e \'! e 2:'
be a:~y ~3Y to enfcrce the ;>olicy ~h2t ~te 2ffcird~b:e h0~sing
-: ',"'1 . .
WC;~~G De JU5~ ~,)r e7p~Qyees.
Administrator Ben Mc~e:way speculated en the Oct. 30. 1927
filirg date and word~rFd i~ ~he app~}can~ was 2void~:~g t118
Town of Nantucket
Conservation Commission
Town and County Building
Nantucket, Massachusetts 02554
Minutes of December 17, 1987
F\3.ge 3
wildlife a55essme~t under "the l~e~~ state reg~latio~s. He
wondered how the applicant proposes to protect these interes~s
unc.e:r' the l(~,c.:.'.l bylaw, a:l.d felt t.he c.pplice.ticn s.hculd inclu,::J.e ~-
descriptio:1 of mitigation measures and cO~3truction in1pacts.
Carl Borchert stated ~hat isolated wetla~ds ar.e bonafide
wetlands u~der the l~cal ]Jylaw and felt this ~~as a ]{ey iS5ue no~
ae3dre2',2'cc: t\~i' T.he GPI=.'licant.. Lee [)"71D.n sc.j,d t.r-18 C~cn"1niSs~_o:1 h':.iC1
beer1 sitti~g ()~ t11is application fo~ nearl~r 60 (jays. ThEre was
so~e di2Cussi.on c:ver whether to ~eturn thE application and
E:r~cl:)se 2.. let":c.er y'(?qui::--ing a S:~bfili5Sif)!1 to t}-~e Pla.:"l:-12.flg B(>c.l:<l
and a deadline (if J3:1l1a~y 7, 1988 for ~he additio~al information
consistil1g o~ a wildlife assessment, mitigation measures,
informatic~ 0!~ hc,w the :1ew project will c}12nge the original
drainage pla~5 and the hydrology dat2. Ben Mc}:elw~y agree~ "CO
SEnd the letter~ but it was decided to keep the application
2. CT..1.. ......7' e .
Carl Borchert moved to
C(Jl1"L.lrlue
+1-, ,-...
i..-__.L>::::'
, .
l1ear2..:lg
f C'l-- rnc)re
infcl-'rnaticn.
8.Cl T..l(;te:j.
6.
Lu~tz/Eme~s'Jn - SE~8-~46
IJew South Road & Weweeder A~E.
Lett.e:r"~. fr'c:n.i Pet.el'" D:..11i~^,ic1~~ie. (:.3.1:" 1 E~c)rch'2I"t ar.t,.j L,ee 1)'-'j,1"lf1 \.Jel~e
l'"'E- aCl w~11 i ;~"':-l d i:3 C]. (. s e.j irl r"~.ll.') 1 i c. tri e iy' m€"'!T'~tle~:- s }-1 i~~2, ir.~ t.2 e
N'2rlt"t:cl~~l:. Cc!rlser\/a.t~ic:l Conr!i~'.si':1r~ ~ as :r-equire(j b17 see..
,_. .-' ." r,
~.j - D~"1
of the 3-~ate conflic~ of i~terest l2W.
A letter aadressing this
i.SS'L:E; rri=.\m r~I~,. AI'd.i -::.1-1 A.. ~"Ji:=\'T~:;rJ:2 ~~;a2", rE'o.cl \.:hicl-_~ (~()rlf il"'rnE:c1 Tl->~t.
t}~~e 3 CO:l:;;-~':'5~:.i.cl:l.el-:3 \'o,:"'ere ir~deecl n:,)~. j_l-l c':_':r...r_i.lC-:': e,: i~:tel-e~;"t' ~
vc.ting .~~ this aflpli~atic}~.
A lette~ by Ted IilJ.;Jtscn was read wnlCl'l req~estec ~ cc~~~::ua~ce
sf ~he hea~i~g pe~diDg furt~er e~gi~eering Vj::r~: 2~d disc~3sicn
wi -:'l-l tr~l_~ ;.. ~ .3:~rt i r: ~~ ::,~C) l3_I'cl at"":'c:ll ~ t.J-l e s i:: e ,3:-~d '-if:; ~::. l;;~l (: t t~-.:. e I'C: a.~J.'oA~ a~i
t.l-~l'(!ugri :"}-,;.:-3 \/.7et.l ,3fld..
Artl)ur Reade. atto~ney for JppCSll:g par~y t.he Nant;Jcket
(=::nser~~atic'~ F()u:1da~iGn, was disc0ntented wit-h t~e rea~E~:t tey a
COIl til1.'\lal~ce ,
'\t![li(:r-l }-lctlj riot g,.i'v'er~ :-i'Jt.:..ice ~:--;:.,~ c,.t..1-lE~r irY\lol"Je~j
}~J e I>::: ca~ 1 e c:, tl~l e aI=~ 1=' l.i '::arJ t, }-,;.acl E':~~:pe ctEcl t-o l=J~t.:'. ~~ e rl t.
l:'.3.l-.t.iE:s. .."-1'::,
Town of Nantucket
Conservation Commission
Town and County Building
Nantucket, Massachusetts 02554
XiLutes af December 17. 1987
F\3.g e l-}
aaGl~lor.al information at tonight's meeting and suggested that
lVIr. TillcJt.son's :c:-ec.f'.lsst fe'l' a cc,y-,tinuance ,,,rithout. propel' nC'Lice
would ~e viewed ~7ith short shrift by any judge i:: a cour~ (:f
law. He said many parties come from off-island at great ~ime
3.11e1 monetal.~Y e~":pet15e a:1Q can.llot. afford te.l tole~"'ate the la):i -t.,/ ~Lrl
p:rocecllre" Ivlr" Reade re5F'ect-f1..111"yr reque=.ted the CO~UTiis3-=-C:-l
close trle 1"1eay"ing ar.ld .issue a del"lial"
Lee L)~J.rlrl asked lvIl"" Reac1e ",rhett-ler tl-le Fc\uncat.ic>I1 w"c~-Jlc.. cc;::sic:el- '...4
c',)!Til:!rcn~i~,e grcu-l":-ii-:g the e2~le:1;erlt tnCi I\~r" Ilunt.2 if ~~e agreed t.e..
build cnly one house. ~le sai(j the Foundation!s trustees w(;~11j
ccr.Lside:r.-- "t.1: a,t. (.':r-T.ic1l1 , l;.c:vJ(~'.."E:~r !-~e cc;uJ_G n.ot. s};,ea): rC'tl- t.he:!i. Lf:e
pointed out tllat denying ~hi5 application ,~c;uld not spec~rlcall,y
deny the applicaDt 2cce~s to his property.
P,-obert [}aylor of =).3~:ll,-')r C~or:sultirlg (}l>-:) "t.l!=l th'Jugnt the CO~l.-r1i3Sit)11
could avoid 2 denial and still issue an O~der of Conditio~s that
would recuire replicaticJD. He thougl1t the applicant would find
it. riea:r'~'\' irr~f)c<:::::,ible tl) :cest.Cl:...-e .t}-le \"retlands a.nd ~pro~:.ect ,-..i.e
lnterests of the Wetlar,ds Prc~ecticn Act.
Mr. Reade said t118 2p~)licant has two reascnable cptiO!lS: :) t<)
build a t!ridge spann~~s t~e \~etland and 2) reach a co~pr:)~13~ cn
the access across F0undatj_cn pr;:lperty.
required the fili~~g of a new Nctice of
on to s~y he grE3tJy rese:lted the fac~
l;':; t. 1:: l- e s ~~ r-.. ~c. t ':: :12. g }-1 t a 11 ,:} d i ,:1 n C1 -t- r~ \:; t~ ..~_ :: ~T
He thCUg}-l-:' ei tl-ier c:;t.ic:r-i
Intent. Mr. Reade ~ent
that f\'Iy.. l'ilJ..;:JtsC;I". -\,73.':,
at,her invoJ.vE:,j p3~~i~s.
I.:"":,:/.nI: Z ir:-:ne::..'"'r:-lcil-l
..i::
\_.' .i..
l"'~ ar: t."l: c}: E~ t
La::,]. C~ ':)ur~ c i 1 ~~:I' g e \.1 ti":c C.c.n'l!:~,i ~ ::' _i .,~.:-~
~...".)
close ttis heari~g a~d iS3l:e a de2i~1.
T~llc~sc~n~s req1JeS~ 5hc:~_d be gr~nted.
c:~, .":, ,J.l ':: ::-1 c: 7" -= e e -'_ : .t~~: .
David Mcre~~~. s~'eak~~; a5 a ~'rivat~ citizen. ;'0~:~ted G~j-. -112t
tl-.. (':'l'"'S e :~:.i 5 t.s 2, :~-. t. 3.:-.:.':: 2..~"'(1 t>I.~' i~e\:l.Jl-'~ f ~:-:;-::' cq:1 1;' 1. i c 3.:-~ L.3 t.:; 110 t. i:: ~/ z~; ~.l
p3r-r.ie 3 i!:\7C 1 \leC ir1 2..f=.'pl i c a.tic n s be i c;re tile ''/3):' j_.~=f:] S
, .
.r:'.'(~ 3.:r.(~:= .
.--',.=:
erlC()l.ly::::.g e d ~~r.: e. ~~.c\ITlI':1i 2;~: j_ c':-~ t,.) c: oriS l;] 8r.-- 2.. dc- ~p t. i 11 g -r:.t,.:.~; 1:1!:~O c:e '.J."dY e CJ.2J
?ar~ of tte r:ew reg~11at~o~3.
Town of Nantucket
Conservation Commission
Town and County Building
Nantucket, Massachusetts 02554
Minutes of December 17, 1987
1?ag1= 5
Carl Borchert moved to sene a reply to Mr". Tillotson's le~ter
denyi~g his request for a corlti~uance and as}cing t!18 applicant
t.o S1JJ:;ITLit. aric1tr1er apJ:,lic-c.:t:.iiJn fC~I' 211~1 ::ev.; 1=)12115. r~fter' 2.(jrnE
disc~\._~S3ic::-i, Cal.~l mO"',le(J. tc c.lcise tr.le he\:il."'ing. t(.) ser,c: a repLy t,.o
r~.Cr~ ,}'ilJ.ot-2~orl' s lett.e:r o.erl"}:'"irlg his rE:~q:"tlest =c;r a cc.r:t.ir..'l..lar~Ce,
and to deny the applica~ion. So voted.
7 .
Wa\7:1E H. D~pont - Codfish I;ay.k ~(Jad.
Joh~ Shugrue '~as prese11t
as agen~ for the af)plica~t and tho~ght the '~ait now was just ror
a DEOE file nU~lDer. Jienry Wasiersl:i moved tc cClntin1J8 the
11e,3.I"irlg for a l)Ei":;E file n~1ber. ::.~Cl \7cf:.ec1..
r:.l
Eli::.Ei])e~..h Tv1cl1\lai.rl - Millbrc\o}: Roaj..
i1;:i-;lini s t.r a tell". Bf3D I''ic:}<e 1-\.k7a~~l
sai6 Mark Avery of Des~gn Associates,
- . -- . ,
agen~ tor the app~lcan~.
had C21~pd rec~uestirlg ar~proval of the del:k 2nd }:eeping t}~e
problen1~ ~Jith the drive'~ay se?arate from this application.
John Shugrue discussed the design and con3~ruc~ic'n of t11e
dT'ivew<3.-',;/ a.ll,j :he :ji.~i 1~()"t- t.}-..irl}':
been i_55ued cn the property.
~h2 tearing~ So vc~-~ed.
~fl.. ~E' ~\..E ~~N\~.
a C.e:r-'t.if icate
l:'; f C~ (i[.-lI) 1 i ct}-l c e
r, ::=,.-,
J....-'"'--..
C2rl B:J~chert moved to continue
~
9 "
TvIi.2}-lael 31()cn...t:8x'g - 11:=) Ba,xtex' F~cad.
Henry WasieTski ~oved ~c
C:OIli:l:l-J8 tJ-le hecI' i:~lg f (-'l- 2. [:E()E -:= .~l. e rr:J.!nt;eJ~'.
::~CJ \loted.
10. H~dso~ 5 2and~a ~c):lan~ - 117 Mad~cet Read. Jc.hn S~ugr~_ie 3:.d
~-~t:l~:~e~' Kevin Dale ~;ere present ~s ageJ:ts for the a~i~~lic2!:~.
New dJ:i~~eway p12~~ were ~re~ented.
LeE
=:'~::lrJ. s"tT'es SE-',j -:.:-~e r~e.e(1 ;:'0
~ ~-J '~:,: :~' e
...,:.t'::':
s ..:.. .:~;' e s '-':.' r~ c) IT: !:'l' E:
ero .:..:"C:-1 c,y t'rsa}:1:.hl~'-:"~-= ~i-~5 ~~., i.ll c,c: C~_1r .
~cvever. the CC~~~3si(i~
2tiJl ~eeded 1) fi_nishe.d plans of the pern1anent drive~!2Y 3h~'Ji~g
s~atjilizatic~ of the 2~iveway. f)Ossibly l~si~g chin~~s~o~;3 2~_0~g
t~ne ed.ge! 3:-~d. 2) 2. Cl"'C)~~. - ~ ectic'D th1>,:>ugr~ ~}--~e t\,7Cl C0.l.~:2,:>?r.:t.,l y"
ero~i=:g driveways shcw~~g s~abilizaticl~ ~'_e25~rAS.
~ . ." .~A.~~LE~~'@
Ca:~l ~orshert moved tei CO~~lnue ~~e neaI'lngA ~o v~)ted.
Town of Nantucket
Conservation Commission
Town and County Building
Nantucket, Massachusetts 02554
I~inut-es of Decernr-::er 17, 1987
:Page 6
11. Eller~ F12rnm - SELj,8-!~51 - 4.3 :::quam Road. .:f:::JhL Shugrue \-I3.S
preserlt a~l agerlt fc-:: t:ne apr)l iCC'..nt. rTfj,el--e \,Jas d.isc;lssicJfl at>~:!l..:t
Cl~~1.-.is Fl"cJ.:e:r" s corrtrnel1t.s at the las"t rnel~ti11g arid IvIr. 2,l-iugl"'ue E"air.}
he had Gi:it heard ~'e~sonally fro~ him. There was also d~_SCUS5ioI1
abcll"t Hhs}~e the scft edge of c:he vletl and ;>leeS. ;'\R .~~ ~~~
A~~~~~~ ~~\~. ,. ~~~=-:'\_i:::.Y~~~.
Herlrj7 \:J.:3.5 ier2,ki ITlo'\led t.() -:;o:-ltinUE;? tile }-leal....l~.;.gA ~)() ~Jcte,:j. CN\.Tt;)
[{ic.lla::...-':,] arid l\TicJ,i '3an1t,le
- E\)como Kc)acl.
Arcl1itect Travis
~ .
r<I"'}.C':;'
a.Dei 2PI=ll :i.~.3.r.it R:"clj3.l"c (?a.rnbl e pJ.....eser:ted ey~'ter~s i'tJ8 ;:>lar13 al>3
':.12-2..;1-',:3.:1"t3 fc)~'" -::.he i:,r'oject. ~'Il-'. ~PJ.:'ice, E.:.:p12irJ8c;. trlf; FI~)C 1-13J ;~'E-.erJ
quite enco'~JragiDg about the ~ou5e de~ign as it resembJ.ed the
rO:L"Ti:alj_E,t. ~i.:TlagE-'r'y'" c"f s'':;:7le of tl-18 gl'"'c..rl,j t'Jlcl l1c!n1e~..; ar;c1 ~nct.e.l:::;.
Thev had even aaaec some height to the cent~al portion of ~he
hOlMse tC) balance it c!~t. The main jouse w:~ullj now be 25 ft.
high and ~a~ge from
':,. "-l _
...J 'J
l:' I~'i .;:. +-
u v .L l.-.
dis~ance ba2}~ from the bl~~f~
edge.
He menticlrlec. l>J,3.nt.u,cket .Elect.ric Cc).. hf~d }:,1a.:-L3 to t2.J:'2: (J:_:t
'::r-ie l_ltil.i ty :pole~s alc.r:g that read, r-:.lll.:lirlg Ever~lt.h_'::_:-lg
-urld.E:I"src::'::-ld.
Le~3 L':.:r.r... ~"a.r-it.ec1 -r:CJ }:no"~'" tcr a f::ict t.11a.~ -:.he b'l~J.ff
. .
race "'r\",7a3 :-l':'-:.
el"C!{:il:-~E;" I~,r. :Pri,:;'2 ~E:ic1 ~h.e 'bad. cCjr:.t.2ct.!?,j :r"j"'Ces Tiff:"le:l., di:~'ec:t.c.=c
t:)f tt.lS 1..-r::v1a32> l\~a:1t~lc}::et Fielj St..3.t.iclr:.. ~l~~l-.:.() sa.~(j t"~~e rn,3._~rl eff~3ct.S
are t2~~ t. rrClf:1 ~,,?.i.:~d ~=rC)Si011 t.he:r."e.
G~-'ar.i.'\T ill e (:ra:-l~' tcr: mer~ tic ::';'_7,j
that :~n the l1igtes~ tides~ t112 wa~er i_s nor eVE.n 11? ~o the
base c;f tr-:'2 l,arlJ:r IVI}:,. IJ'I".:_ce feI.t the 25 - ::0 ft.. :_~l~=;:=,e3~:
di3t2:~ce ~2S 32fe.
(:;''cT.l
BC'.l~..:h~~rt said
..;-.1-,-.
L..i..J.C"
CCjnu"T,i~> 2 iO:-j
~13ually re.~~~Ye3 a
':' (\ ..:..:: ~
~) I_I .I.. :_, .
set~2C}: ~rom blut~s, incl,u'i~~g all decl:s. a11i} W2S ~:;)rr'~s~ ~~:'0~~
~.rot.eC~ll~g the t.2
a~c ~he ;rc~!eyty ~C!1g~e~~.
: ~=) r-~ ::;. L.:" -1..: C: 1":' i ~~
act.i~.7it,iES c01..1J.d. Y~3"'le 2. ~~';":~5-:-",3.r:ti,3.l irl:~<:3.C-+':'..
'rheJ">~ ",\'2..5 \.jisCU::'=,5-=-C':'~ al)Cl_:':::' :nc}"\lir:g tt-i8 1~!_-.;u2,e Da.,:J: ~:,:-lC. t,~uj.
trl e f'Y'r3::1e tc) 2<::: C c.::Tcn.:. ;~.c.1:.e t'.l"le "',,7 i e ~1I1 :: 1~C",;n1 t.l-~e ~;l"'C:UllC. f 1 Ci c:cr' .
.:... ...:. -'"~ ~c
the ~we:lj_~g b18n1ied in ;~ith t}lP 3b~:~ti~g l:cuses 310Gg tte ~~'~ff
W2.S C".{::lsidered.. ~ee Dunn cited t.rle diff iCi.ll "'":.ies T.~1'=- CCJTI"l!nis2.i.:.rl
erlC0unters with applica~icns like ~hj_5 and opened discussi0~
Town of Nantucket
Conservation Commission
Town and County Building
Nantucket, Massachusetts 02554
Minutes of December 17. 1987
Page 7
about- wetla:-:d 5cenlC Vlews.
J.ooming effect of tte large
Henry Wasierski mentioned tne
h~use a~ the Haulover as see~ from
as far away as the ferr'v or when serving as a sight for"
fisl:erme:l. AdrrinistT2tor Ben McKslway s11ggested this house ~ay
shcY\A! 'Llp '':';:..li.--:-e '~ell '\,-;heI1 \7iev..7ed fI"\~m (Jut irl trl8 -r"JcirlJc'l'"' rr::=,:-r.
pleasure boats, fer i.nstance. Henry thought the house ~c:c'J:ed
pret~y good co~sideri.ng i-ts size.
The ~~:cTn;'T(i~~sio:1 \~7a.rlt-ed to see tt18
pool moved bacJ: to abo~t ~Q ft.
and stairs by :nea~5 elf a
as \'Jell as l=':la.r::~; for t.he \';G~lJ:"\-Ja~l
CI'oss-seC~lO~. The root base of
t.e mai~tained and the applicant
r:-tec"i:.::;'ll::'-'C:'::~ i:-l v..G......:.tirlg.
the bluff's plant species
-'-,~'" ,--
.:;:_...::.' L_
snculd SUDml~ mitig2ting
The sep~ic s~!~~e~ ~ouJd be split
across trle
, .
cr l ~\fe\",,"'ay
-.+
Oc-
1 ::?'3.st
150 ft." t)ac~": f}:-cJlTt trlC: bl tIf:E " C~a.r l I~cl-'clle~t. thou;;l~_t -the Gee):
should be lo(:ated 30 ft. back trom the bluff and asked t~e
applicant ~o s110w a hypothetic31 view of how this }1ouse blends
in ~~ith the others along the bluff. Lee Dunn as~ed ~he
applicant to provide a plot pla~ showing the drop-cff ba(~~~ fl"C)ffi
tt18 ~[>10ff atlc: Sl-1,)\~irlg a 3:~J:\,""e)ioI'!:=. sec..t.icn t11rCiJg:-l trle hcu:::e.
{~arl added ~~_... s110uld a130 defi~e the 1~mit5 of ~Tc)~k C;]~ t~1~
3ll:e.
Carl I~oYc!:ert ffievea ~CI
, .
C CD T-.lT:'_le
the
. .
nea~=-":'l1g
felT' rn-,:}].'e
i:1f ~)='l1i,3t.icln
ariC ::=. DEC>E file: 11tlr::l::er.
So ":I,,:()t.eo.
23.
Pete~ !~ash/Gif~ord - CIne Eas~o~ Street.
Att(.r~ey Ke~7in =ia:~ t~as
p~e5en~ 25 agent fer the ap]~~~::ant ar;d res~'ectf~~lly re'~~estsd ~
con~i~1]0~-lc:e cf ~he heari~g.
C~~l EGrche~.t sugges~ed th3t ~a_~l~ng [~EQE someti~1e3 see~s
tCJ ~3c~li~a~.E get.ting a DEOE :~:c ~D~ber.
,~~1 ,3.:-- 2.. r'{1C)\,7e c~ ,-'-.-
~~~~~~~e ~~e teari~g.
::.~(=) "'''?ot.e(l.
-~ I
...'ot.
_. ~-'
~.)~-:...'.'l;.'="'-. ",,'yo ':..:l'" ~ c.,.....
....1. ~_ -.- ,-. -- ___ __ .......... ............ ..... _........
:. '7 (~aI.~J.ilel~ F~02.d.
Attcr~ey Kevin U3...e W2S
He made a public apclcgy
I='I'~.ser~"t. ,~..E, 2ger-Jt fC~l-' t.ne a.:ppi.ic'.arlt.
fc]~ the 3;plj_C3~t ~c;t being preseLt and agreed to ~1()tify 2~1
ir~'\rc2-~../e,:i }:'2::,ties c:f ttle rlext. l-Jea~.i.ng. !"Ir. :Cale ~r-E:sr,~c-:.:>~li~1
req~lesTed a continuance of th8 heari~g until JaI1uary 7, ~?88.
Town of Nantucket
Conservation Commission
Town and County Building
Nantucket, Massachusetts 02554
Jv1inl:te s
(-..;::
_' .L
[Je ce:11.bel'"
17
~L 9 8 7
1?age 8
Lee Dunn pointed out that whi_e the limits of work were
described in the Notice of Intent, they were not shown on the
pla~s. Mr4 0ale 5~ated the applicant's intent is to limi~
activity on tl1e wetland side of the site. Carl Borchert sai.d
\..,roulej 1)8 ~1ice t_Cl h<3"=,J8 "t.~e hClL:Se locati()11 s.ta]:ed fClr a11otteT'"
field inspection. Lee wanted to see the lc:t again.
.; 4-
.i....
~en Kelley. speaking as a priva~e citizen, who has worked J_~ the
I:J2rlt1J.cj<~et IvTarirJe ~er~)a)~tTnent for the l=-'23t 8 yeal-S! cescrit)e:j ~~Ttlat
ne saw as a gradual deterioration of t.he llpper ha]~bor as an
lmpcrta11t 5pawn~~g area for the Island's she:lfish populat~o~s~
. ."
lD pa~tlcular~ Day
nitrates and othEr
S C 3ll c: 1=: 5 .
~,ul)3t.2.n.ces
He sai~ t.he increasing levels
- ~
(.) .L
leaching into the ~~ater from ~~ards
a~d lawns may 0~ ~espG~sitle, as scme ~c'wns O~ Cape Cod are
C.lSC:I)\lerlng.
\,rJiti: rega.rd~. to t~his 3,:;'!.=llica,t.i:.~)u! 1\11.:'. I<elle~:l fel~ allcvlirlg
mere hOllses right next to this rria~sh could only make !11atters
y~rorse . he. 3.3.id T.ne C:C1ITll-:1is::: ion f13S tile ()PI)Ortuni -:'~T tel s 1 i~\'; '.:J.c\wrl
the deterioration process and ~hat the Tow~ has been too lax on
regulati~g septic syste~3 and monitoring
. . .
(:;orl-:','3.Ir;.l.:12. 1:.J. en.
He
mentioned a town OTI M~rtha!s Vi~eyard had set up a Gel-day
r:lor2 tel):' i_ UIT; ;:):1 a.ll 2, lic;T'e 1 i;-~e tl;.::~-:..l cli:-.: g ,3 ~'l(i "VIEt =, C C;Yl:':, icie:r.... iY)Is 2 :=.o-:.a 1
;:,211. Lee. rn~r~rl 3.~}~'ed 1'~11:--~ :r~e11E~Y t.o 5,-:,,:;:'1::ly t}1i.:; (:'::!mrni2.~._i(.:1 ~vrit.h
1~is data on increa5ed nitl:a~e levels a~:d re5ults of colifcY:~
~ests in Nantucke~ Har~or.
Ad~inistI'atcir E~en McKelway ag~'eej:~ ir-.
lC1cl: ir~,to .i.t..
...---... . ~. -. .
...) l2.:1e c~ 0.: rrJ:'~, T''3!~'l'''''~ s c:~ ~ lr-i g
-~.r~E ~c<I'- l:;C-l"' S}-~e Il f j_ s r-l P..,j~..:, i2. C }:'''.9
.- .
i:'::.: ,~::""(::
cited the iITpc'r~ance c;f '~hi3 ~'2~'~ic~lar ~ars~ SY3t~.~ to ~~E
f1Jt."lly-e (.if ta~i sC2.~lc'I:'~' .i~-.:. 't:.hc\.t. i~. is C;~'le ,:f t~l~ 1:~est 2'.(.;_::.-css c!
5eed sC2:lcps i~ ~he H2rbor.
(~":';':' teslli :l'~ t_.::. :':-l l-=-~ f t.]-li5 ,3::'-(::.~ c'(' t: ~ ::,
l'la-Je d.isas~r::;lJ.2". 2:' ~=p.:.: ~_:,. =-..rlC1 s~-~e t_}-J..:)~1g.i-:t.
......,~ 2;3 ~~7 ~~ '2 f.-' t. ('; ,-";. -'
pI-eventlve mea311res ~:c:w.
Al--T.:J-1Ul- Read.e re:p:=-:=:S~~Y-lL.ed_ ,~\~)1J.--:.t.~?l"'S t~al--~., 'T'uCJ::~::::r'! I,e=;e":..rel~ c,l'J.f: tile
Sr.:.irnrno ~n..s so cicrt.i c::-~ t:~../ s !:=18a}: ir1g ill C:PJ.:'CI s i t.i::'rl t~c' -:-.l-;E; 3;'1=<:' ice. t. i C,Tl .
The Tucke~s had als!) engage~ Rc.ter~ Day~lo~1 ot =lay10r Con5ult~ng
~~~TUCJr~~
~~ ).
.... .1-
t_\~i
o 'UI
I- .,. - J. i
. ~ .., .
~~~~-- _- ...u:
~~ ~~ '-"- II
('b~ "'*'~...........t>"
()-9p........c9. ,
ORA1~ ",.~
.....'"
Town of Nantucket
Conservation Commission
Town and County Building
Nantucket, Massachusetts 02554
Minutes of Dece~ber 17. 1987
Page 9
Grou~~ whc described the wetland as ha~Jing a frssh thicket alc:ng
the e6ge. Mr. Daylcr said t.he wetland boundary on t.he pla:1s may
be ~isrepresented a~d should be re-evaluated. The line on the
pla:-l 'i..Jhic}-i is 011 't:.1-..e e~.J.g~3 of tr1e sal trnal~sh rnay nc,t ~be tt18 t.T'ue.
wetla~d bc;undary. He telt the site sho~llj be appropriately
f12gged in all places.
Davicl ivIcrec:.ti represented David Crosby ,:::end had nc ,::c;-nrnent at.
this t.ime_ bllt wanted Kevin Dale to incl~de him ir1 the
l""lCiti.f j~c~a--:.icI1..
.A~D~;l.t.tel'" Ed,{ar':: l{ern S};>cly::e lr-l OPJ)C3 i tiOl1 to the aF~21 ication arld
:pl-e;:.:.erlt.ed. Pl-l(:)tC.1S s'h:Ji.",ir:g the svTeer=>irlg panclr,3Inic \rie\,~I5, elf tl-~s
aI-ea. He "Cl:()1J.gl~t the r:~r(\p.osed d.v7elling \<'c)uld stic1.-: C;1..1t- liJ::c: a
SC)l--E: t.l-~u.r:.-d~) ill ;::r~e c:f "tr1(3 lo\7eliest :pa}:-t.E, c'r the Is2..arid arlQ -;:.}-13.-:.
it woulij disrupt ~he fee~lng of tranquility. Lee D11nn wanted to
see ~ne proposed elevations for the dwelling.
Abutter GeTIevie\~e 1'ucl:er submitted a pho~o of a full :noon tide
on '~hat ~arsh ana sr'oke in oppositio~ to the applicatio!1.
Carl 30rcnert made
an opell request to Ke:1 Kelley a:1d
. ..., ...
2: lritl J. a.::-'~. j-
qualified individuaJ.s to address issues of this ~ype
fl"'(?c.r;J8ntJ.j:r He :2i<':1 t-h:~ Cornrnissic<~l \.Jf,)1.~l~j .3l='l=lI'ecia--:e
rr{~i''"C
~ . . ......'..1- '._
2.rl~/ in.l:,ut
or o;jposi~g views and could benefit from mc're publlC
lnvolvemen~. He ~uggested scheduling a~other fie~d i~spec~ion
fC1r I'1Grl-3.2~"', J0.r:l.1a:r-~/ L.,!.! lS~E~3.
A3~ir~is~_~atcr Be~ ~cKelway though~ Ken Ke~lev an~ ~iane
,-~ '-, ,_.:,",1_, c:-
.....'... '_)"1......._'
rr~ig~t be intereste6 in ~he 0;'c:J~i~g TI1eeting with Health A~e~~
Ric11aJ~f3 ~2~Y a~d a2Ye~d ~~~ ~ot-if7 tl~e~ l:f ~.he exaC7 ~a~e a~d
+- :. !'+:;..--':'
Hep~-'j7
:"JEiS i ~.:-:::--::=:}: i
;T :.'Je c~
-c: r:l
cC1ntinue
~- n{::)
r:e S.::r.-l:-lg
.4:- ""'\_
.L,_' ~
~n'=.l-.e
. - , .
"' ,. of- ,-',"-'-"1:'::'+ - ,-\"r"".
........:.~.... '- ...:. ,; ,,-... '--- -...;,.;,. .
:":1 C 'oJ .:~ t. f-:;- I:' .
-1 c:
.l....J.
L::-..'vr:~ence Ffa.:':f- Ala.b2rr.a Ave., IvTac1aket.
I~l"'. :P f '=:. f -: 'fv7a~~, f.r"? :.', (:-:J. t
Wl~!~ a~e~~ Ail_ee~ 3arth of Aileen Barth ~ Associates.
IVl:3. E',artJ-i
C1re'l'-"r _-~_:-i t.tlE; 1 ille t)f d~_jn.e g:r'a=-,s an1j a ;::'llOW fence C'Il t:~e ;:)_a.;-1~3.
Town of Nantucket
Conservation Commission
Town and County Building
Nantucket, Massachusetts 02554
Minutes of December 17,
1987
Page
1 "
..LV
Lee Dunn said this application characterized the typical problem
of dune migration. henry h'asierski rei t there ,."ould ahlays be 2-
problem with tenants cressing t~03e dunes to get to the beach in
addition to the public foot traffic there. He asked if it was
possible to move the deck and wiGdows around to another side of
the h;)use. Ms. Bart.h agreed to lc)cJ-: at other a1 ternat.i\re:=:,
Carl Bor!~hert moved to con~ir~ue ~he heari_ng for alternate plans
arid c [iEt)E f il e r:urnbE~I'. 8-0 vc.?te(t.
16. Craw's Nest Associ2tes - 10 Crow!s Nest Way! Wauwinet. Aileen
Barth of Aileen BE~rth & Associates W23 prese~t as agent fc-r ~he
a};:};> 1 ~L C.3rlt .
Lee Junn stated tha~ Ms. Barth had convinced the field
irl~~l=:'ectic:rl -te.3..:Tl tl-~at t.l.,iey d.id r:ct. need tc~ .visi t the site 2fld lie
a5~ed her for a set of pla~3. I~s. Barth agreed to note O~
another set of plans the line c_lf tall brush and added that the
2.pplicant ,lid not propose to cut down any vegeta~ion.
Carl BGrc~ert ~o\.ed to conti~~e the hea~ing for more il1foI'~ati(Jri
arId a DEOE f ile :~:.~.'n;:-el'..
So ..../~)t.ed..
E. REGULAR MEETING
lviin.-tl-,:::.e;5 c f De ce~-J:::::~" .3,
1 L.l C ,...,
....L j L
(~a~'l L,o-;,,-'crlert mO~v'.ed to a:ppr;::"':]2 t,l-ls
DU!1,~iddie ~ad made a cQrrecti(~n i~
m~~~te3 ~5 writ~e~.
:Fet.er
thE: Ei.j.n::.t.es tler<-.:re l:e left crJ "\.:"a:-.2.::2-CJ1--:~:
r:'c..g'? -I
- ;1 3.l~2;,.g 1-' ,::;'1=<1
#.2:
.3ft.cr. =.ieRe=-~~i~..
~- h Ci~": ~ (1
,
2::'eE~.Cl ,
"'\...Tl:~:;
CC; D t: :i...r~ :,l~:-~~' 'c.) :r'e~J i.?., 2 r..:.r.: e :'"'f-: gt:.J...3, tii:,r13 " ~t
:3 c) "/ ':: -:.~. d. .
Minu~es cf Dece~b5r
the n~}:~ meet~ng.
1 '-I
..........' ,
193'7,
rI'r~ e rr.:.n ~J. .....:.e S '\..7 ill
l~;e
accep"tEC
aT
Town of Nantucket
Conservation Commission
Town and County Building
Nantucket, Massachusetts 02554
Minutes of December 17, 1987 Pag~ 11
2. Other Business
a. Keith M. Yankow -
Yankow explained that
305. 3 i3 '7, and 696 - 697
2? St,aJ~t:l1Ck RCE"-iJl - well easerr!en-::. >IJ:.
b1..lil~:iirjg I=leT"nli L.S 1-1o.d })t3ell issued ():1 l()"ts
,. ,
ccrr:D.:..rlerj.
Car~_ Borchert said that althol1gh there Wl~_~ llkely t)8 otters 'co
corne ,3~-~::)ng WEiflting 1:-0 re\:"aITLI? -:'~~eil~ sept.ic ~'~2.r3terr:s, ~ n t}le
interes~ of fairness he felt the C'Jnrnission sholJld grant t}:e
ease~ent on what is To~~n-owned 12nd. He didn't thin}c it loo}:ed
li](e tllis WG~lld set a
, ,
prece.:::en\: .
Lyn:l Zirnl"~el-:--rrLan v.c the 1'1antucke.~t. Lc~r.d l-:ol.1Dc.il E~jbrni tted <1a-::a I"I."'orn
fl.'Iac:a.J-':e.t. ~~\7ell ScunpleE. taJ::en f:....()ITl P.[J:r"il 23 t 19E5 -- Oct. 13 t 1~~e7
wl-lic2l. 51-.i.c:,\>,.red incT"easi~-lg l8'v""813 ()f scdillITt (l't./er t.i:11e.
(:al"l 3c:r-c~lel...t
m'j"v"'e d ~.o
apprc\~e the eaSErnent.
Sc.
......-..-+-,-,.--l
\/ '_J \,...C '-:" ..
D. ?C:DC '."'!~a"t-er
(:r11al i t}T - Bartle.t.t. li'2..rrrt"
of Nantucket Cranberries
Nant~ck9t Cranber~ies.
was present repJ:esenting
R"L1SSe 11 La~Y',Tt.on
Phil Bartlet~ and hi~self.
H~ was upse~ at hew the issue had
bee~1 }'.:a.r:clled by the pre 2". 5, a.l"Jd t~l tl~E~ C~crnrnissi(>rl. hf3 said tl1E~
WCI:!....fj ~'pc::ll~~t.io;-lr! is essen.tj.alll:,J a 1-"(-:(1 flag t.o the ;-,'ublic. =-:8
;::"L.2te:.,j tt.;at r~c, par-ids c1n the :::.: la.rlct or E,'\,-er1 CttlaJ)b.ill F;~eseI"\:rc i:'"
meet iJ.ril-l}:irlg \-\Tate:..~ cdua~i "Cl' ~ t.ha.T. drir.:.J,,:irl~s \..l2~tel-' is c.=ir:2',t~arlt.:;/
mc~ni t.c~}~ec. fell'" corlta.rniIla.r:~5 2nd. ur:.d.e::g()e;:, e):terlsi\18
t_r',~a-trller~t. .
- . ~ .
t :..l 7.e:.... '::'.rlg
.3. r.:. c
IV1:[-. L.:C~-:I'!-:-:-=::-: C i t.ed. an:=> t.r... i3::- E 2..~'ll1. 2.l'" .:.n Ci:.1c:/:i t. ,=.l::c;ut a ~::/ef::c: c{g~:' \,.,~l~t= r.:.
H2l--}~i'~'::~' 31-..-:1 :3~ne 11 f i s:-~ J.1.d.,\l:' s :::::'--~.l E'G aT'd. (.3E]~E;':- "'-~3.:: ':':.1- l.e d. J;>C':::-;::, i ~:=<i e
".:;o:lta;-:-;~~:1.~-:-.ic':1 ir.. ~ic,l :.:~i5 2a:r-.bc.:..- fr;:J;n tl-:.e :l:--'...l.Dcff
,... . ",
r~':)In -::.ne
CT' a:nt.""JS::'T',":,7 ;~\() g S .
"P-.. f t~E-.r ~ .-::~~e c or~-~'"T,t:.r~ i.. c' -3.t..:i. ():-l 2n.i c 1. Ei:'~' i fie c '~'. i. (':;-l r ~.-'Clni
Mr. Lawt.:~:1~ SHAB made a ~.ublic 2polc.g)7 2bou-c tl1e matter.
':'.C C "~: 1:':= ~-:-~E; t ':~ L.c,\,,;t e,f'.:. .
IvIr'. L .::..\.-;t.C:j ,=:5:.' ]:e c1 t.n e ':~ c\rlTri.-L s;3.i (.:n. t.G u. '.= ,~ ~-, ~
32.m'3 l:1 t.-~..._i;,:, ca:=-, e t:e CE:~J.S.== l-~ e ~'~h':'ilj6ht t!-iP 1::<::-;.;: ;:~e :=', S l-.:.:.:r':, ::-~ 2_ ~
ccrn}"'cJ.~'..~/ ("22:, '~Jel~ as tlle C-,'.cr:-~"lj_s~~.iC;!'1 i trself.
Town of Nantucket
Conservation Commission
Town and County Building
Nantucket, Massachusetts 02554
Minclt.es ot Decer.:ber 17.
10C'7
~ _' \_, I
Page 12
Lee [Jl...lrlD s2~id tl1e C>.:::r:-CT1l.S s ic:rl -has 11() cCJ1'1t.rc)l O"\ier Wl1at appeaT'5\ l11
the t="reS5 al""ld does riot IT'.al-:e pl-ess re.l'.3a~.es. T'ne, Cc!r;rrnis:=\ioll i.s
charged with protecting ~later qllality, }~e cited the ove~a]_l
E:\ii,jence f,-yr declil~irlg \~r,=:.ter (:p)r?1lit~~.~, and felt t~h8 CC;r11r;-il.s:=.;icirl
did ~ot owe any apology. He felt that Mr. Lawton and Mr.
Bart.l ett wel~e in ::,eJ:-fect P05:" tions to 21.:ppl y t_he CO:-;'Jni~:= icn Hi t.h
data l)n the quality of their water and that ~he i:1tent ,~f tte
rec~~'r1t le1:T-el'" ret=Iuest.irlg S'UC}1 data frc.--;m t.he C;ornrr,5_52,iorl \~2~S
i:J.:1Cl c e rl t .
TJIr. La\~r-CJ'):.l e..d.ffi.it-"L.ed tJ:at rrl<3]-:~l l:l ag~ic,"',.lj.ture a~E: a. l)it f-;U[.;.-;.::,ll-:l
1 ate.l j1 tIe caus e I:) ft.er1 i~. SU~3 S aDr::'JU-: y,~a~el.~ ~~ual i t.:z,~ ana. cc~rlta..:-nirl,3.r: ~.s
,3J.:'E t::lo\",tn 01.lt. ()f l=Jr:.:)rol""ti;::,~~ c,r }).32.e.d C;D mi=,i:lfc.rrrl.:::.t.ion.. C a..:..'" 1
Bo~cteyt once again justified his interest i~ the water tes~s.
Hell}~~l \!~;aSier3j-:i E':eri.t.iCi:1ed as :3.:1 asi:..-je trJe r>l.'ob2..enls "r,.:ri t-n ~,~2t!-3l-'
c-c)r.:."t.arninat.ic\:l. 1)'.:/ .tvJa-terfov,l c~rl s(;me elf the p.onds aY1C E~2,ked I'T':l-' ~
LEt~1J"~c'n if te had a:1)7 ir.:.fiJrrnat,~icir1. OIl colifor:n C01J.:ltS at. ',3~L;.~~b I :::.
Por:,:; .
He 3aid that A & L Labs has tested it on ooc2~ion and ~as
never had any problems.
::-ecer~t lett".El'"5 t-c rJl~'. L2\}rtor~ .s.rid Iv~::. 3a.:-::-~let.t r:~'="'lT tl2\:'8 l.lce:-l ~_:s~d
E.en IVlcI::e 1 '\-,T 2Y
2c1rni t:ted. t}-~e
\,.~:,,()!."d. ff~pc;11\lted.;~
, .
n ~~~
A':ir.~irl:_ 5 t-::. a t (:Jr'
loosely, but feJ.~ the best thing Mr.
~he aiI' wo~~d ~e to l'El.ease his test
Lawt_crl .2ould
(30 t_o c 1 e?~l'"
rSE,~l'~-s . ~e
a~l21 0 1)::': i!lT.(?;j
OU~ that the tests S~A3 has dc,ne O~ water eTItering Polpi3
Harbo~ fyom the bogs ~e2te~ only for old, o~tdated pe3t~cide3~
I~ot for many ci the ne~~er chemicals c~Yren~~y i~ use.
~~l'" .
~E-..~I-!t.C:l 2'. ,~ij (,? il:-.b ! ~'. Pon.d
r.:c.t. dl"'in}~.iri.g "Vla."tET' (J'L~2~l.t-"J ':l.:.E:' \ 1
.:.'t.~:; -'~ :.:f ~" S. ;>:'S2~~t;.ly'- at_"'~=-~_b\.J_t_,~.t~l,e 1:c.l 2cic: l....a~rl a:-ld i'::-:=;
:.: 2- .::: ~.~: :-. fie a -+:. -=- c. :i" ;3. S ~, '.,1 ,::'=-~"T:;:' -r',~ 2: t" f: r d "ll e
the h~g,t :evels (;f c~g2:~ic5
;:r E ::- E: :'1-:. .
add:?d there had been no
-. " '. ..,
:-12,~""l !~J..-,-.l~'
, ~-.
...L ~ ..
..,- .-.:::.;. ..
'\ .- =~ 7:-, ~'."" '7.'
" -.....,......-'
i-1E' .:-j,:.:..,~: ;:.~;e"f?:-.:. ~!~:-i tj-~ ::.:-_s c =):;1T=';'3.::~~.
c. S.tep~en Fays3is - ~E43-~O~ 28 (j~ove L2~e - I'ev.
(;len Wii~E of Na~7uc]':et S~r\Teyors was ~re2e~t 25 2ge~t
;. ~_ a r::. .
- -,....
..... '- --"- -.....-
" . ,
c~r:'::"l.:..:al'lT~. cllC
,:],1.::: ~::' c:r' it;e' d f..~ ~ a:~ s
-jifrel-'ell~
';:'.,.~."-l""""
-. ,- - .- .-
'~"_ 1 (_' .;:) ','::
,::-.. ;:." ;:, l' C, --/ ;3 '::. ~.::- '_
~ncllJde a bay 1.1l]~aCW~ ~ l2~ding aDd a st~~]).
e~~:elope wo~:d ~8 ~ai!~_t3ir~ed.
'l'tle 52..rne t,~_:~:,Si:lg
Town of Nantucket
Conservation Commission
Town and County Building
Nantucket, Massachusetts 02554
Minutes of December 17. 1987
Fag,? 13
Carl Borchert moved ~o send a ~.e~ter stating the revised slte
plan #N-18~O, dated March 13, 1987, revised Dec. 16. 1987.
::.;igr1ed 2nd st.ar;-;I;led }:-;}7 Ric.he:rd. 1<:. Eax'le r'e};'l-'eserJts a srnall c-flarlge.
in the proposed building locatian a~d d~i.~jeway cC1nfiguraticn.
2~d therefore the filing of a ne'~ ~otice of Intent is not
required. The TIlotion included lssulng the requested ame11ded
Order of Conditic;DS citing the revised plan. So vote:5.
c.. 1'ick tu}::.es - l~e<:;uest fr.c.r,-L DPW.. ]'\l3TIlil1istT'aT.(:1.... Bell IVJc:t{el\",~2.~i
had recei\7ed a call fro~ DPW Su?erintel1dent Phil Shea requesting
the C1oTm.issic1r1 to l:;e tl-ie Y:'lltJlic dist.l""ibut-io:-l ce:1tE:l~' f(--l.... tl-:.e ~ic}~
tubes they wish to give out }1ext seaSOl~.
The COIT~li55ic)ners rel"t. t.I-lis \..;c:uld il1CC}:1'"v"'eriie:lce t.he ottlce t.:.:o
rnuch~ wO~11d invol'Je a lot of time, and that ~here was 110 stc:rage
sr!aCr= ::-cr tr-.;.em III -:-ne cff.i.ce~ E::8Jl IilJc:S~el~0'"ay c~gl--eecl t:') \^,rit~e or
t:;all I\lr". S.l-lea. "y-lit.h a flega.t.i""v-e l-'er:\l~l..
j. Requests ror Deter~ination
2. Jsssie H~ Wielage - Wauwinet Roa(j. John Sh~Jgrue '~as prese~t
as agent fer ~he a~)?licant and e~:p12i~ed the applica:1t ~i3hei to
:.:ei:;,c:I"...S,t.:r-'l...1ct \-'l}-....~t' s there t.Cj t'l""i:-~g it ~.lt:' tC.l c.c)de.. I\1c:l-'e }:lili:-:g:.=,
w~ll be added by hend uSlng a w~eel~arrow and shovEl and ~I(~~lri~g
cor"'1crete, Il,'lr.
.......' . .,
:::,:-l.U.:;:....:_le SalQ.
C2~l Bc,rche~t mOVEG ~o
':'SS1.:e
... r: e g 27. l 'J e
~.' " ,"
L:eT ey.rr~lr12L-l. Gll
--=: -:-- _~-r- - ,:"~:.,
..... -'-'" '- _...~ -
P::-.O t. e c t.:~ .::;:-: TJ r~ de:-' ;: ~~ e i'\ c~.. 1:<:~;..l-:. ~~7 i 11 II c.' t. ~...er:lc:\~E' ~ f ~ l:.. dl"'e d;' ~, '_'.L
the wClr~ ~e3cri.bed in ~he Re;~uest is ~~i~l:in a~ A~ea S
J '? C -::. ~-'~:
131-t:eT' ~.i~;:::.-:- ayea...
I:-l e- -:!~ f:' f c:-:r' e ~
:::2ld wcrk o::e::::
YlC; "t
~'e ,.:;..~~ lre
.......1.. __
. -
=2..~l:-lg C',::-
:3. I<Jc-::icE:-
()I
I :l""C.er: ,":, .
SI::'.
~ ~ --. - .-. ,-,
\.' '-.' :..- -:=: \~ \ ..
1~: .
St_C~:-le
L'r:~.,_ .;
J..,;.....l
::3 E~ 6e
~c:r~h 3eac}: 3~reet..
r)2~Jji::~ :'.-lc-.~~~~~'::.~_
\.7as
pre5e::-;:. E,~
cge:r.-;::
-:= ;-, 1-
"7- 1-,::::.
3. j:' 1:-1.1. J. C c. :-1 -::=.
,3f.:..'.=i
2. gJ:c' ,?:j
-i-_
\,.. ,-'
~. ~J }:J r.> 1 ~/
::.;--, (~
specific l::t. numt:e=s.
Carl Borchert rnGv~d ~c lS5ue a Dositive Deter~~!latio:l stat,~~g
the '~ork ~6scr~be6 in t.he Request, w~ich refers to const~uct.iOI1
Town of Nantucket
Conservation Commission
Town and County Building
Nantucket, Massachusetts 02554
Minutes of December l7, 1987 Page 1~
on Lo~ 6 only. as shown on Land Court Plan No. 16416-D filed
with the Nantucket Registry District for the Land Court. ie. the
lot at the southeast corner of the plan (Nantucket Planning
Board file No. 2897), is within an Area Subject to Protection
Under the Act and will remove, fill, dredge or alter that area.
Therefore, said work requlres the filing of a Notice of Intent.
So \7ot.ed.
~. Certi.ficates of Compliance
a. Gilbert Waine - SE~8-33 - Beachside Motel. Richard Glidden
of Glidden and Glidden was present as agent for the a~lplicant.
A motio~ was made to issue a Certificate of Compliance
certifying that the work regulated by the above-refe~enced Order
of Condi~ions has been satisfactorily completed. So voted.
t. Walter J. Cairnes - SE~8-401 - 82 Baxter Road. Henry
Wa5~er2ki agreed to do a field inspection. The Certifica~e wil~
be issued at t~e next !neeti~g.
5. Orders of Conditil)nS
a. Luntz/Emerson - SE~8-~~6 - New South Road & Weweedsr Ave.
Carl Borchert moved to iss11e a denial. of the application a:~i~
s~ggest the applica~t file another Notice of Inte~t for a muc~
s() 't,t(,tE~d..
more n:odest mea~5 cf access..
Carl 2J1d Lee D~nn
Een Mi:Kel~~ay. The
follC'~JJ~, :
ag~eed tel draft ~he de~ial
and 5ubmi~ it tl:)
-:.~ansc~ipt elf
+~C"..
'-............
~:.,l...Cl J e C"'C.
d.e:-~ia 1 T'8 C.\~ S ,=-- 2,
Town of Nantucket
Conservation Commission
Town and County Building
Nantucket, Massachusetts 02554
IvIinut.e::::. of Decembe:r.'
1 7
~. ,
1987
Page 15
OR::.nm OF CO!\DITIONS (PROJECT DENIAL)
IVlF~HAEL ':J. r=. EI'1ER::,ON
v-JILLIA.1\1 LUNTZ (PRCFERTY OhINER)
DECE FILE ~~1BER ~E48-~46
UNDER T~E i:ETLANDS PRO'I'ECTICN J-iCT (I.LG.L. CHll.P'IER 131, SECTION I~C); J~l\JD
THE vJETL;ANDS B~{L;l-~vJ ()F THE TC}~\i1\J OF :~;'~NTU(~}(ET t, (~EAPTEF~ ::. 2 6 ;
}? I I'J[; I l\~GS
Public hea~ings on the above Notice of Intent lasted from November 12 tr.
Decer-j)eJ:' 17 e,f 1987. :E2.se,:: ()l1 test.irr;Orly-r prese11ted at tllose 11e;3:r-ing5,
both ".;er},::.all:l 2r~d. in \,.rritillg, frc.'lrn trle J;:;'r()pel"'~L-Y Ov.TI1er ar~d l~li:=,
J:."el:,re3'2::lt.3ti~./es as ,.:rell as t.0stirncJrljl frc,nl 1....erlre~,erlt.ati\tes C'lf t_r~e
N2ntucket COIlservation Founaation, Inc., the Nantucket Conservatio11
Cc)rnrniSS2.,:;rl rna}:es the ::e,llc:wir:g f.:r_r:lirlg3:
1) T~e 1.!E~ meadow ~hroLgh wl1ich ~l:e p~oposed road would pa35 lS s11t,ject
to f!I'0tecti;~n under the Wetlan~s Protection Act because it is a
B()l"'cex'ir.:.g 'Vegetatecl hJ8t~lailcJ. (31C crvi.F~ 10. O/:i- and 10.55 j arid Lar~d S~l-)jec~t
too (~c,as,-c_2..1 ::~t:~J:-rr; F'l,.::>w2ge (J1C! (:I\'IT-~ 10. O'-l.). ;~s SUCrl, i_t is 2,igrlific"2.:-1t tCi
t~e following in~erests o~ the Ac~: Grotlndwater Sllpply, Flood Co~trol,
::}tc>:--:rl r)E;,-r:~.c;:; e ~P:::'e'\/e:n tic; rJ! E~rl\:l I~l'"'~"\/~~:-~ ti c~ 11 c) f ~)c' 11 "J-t. 2. c' r~ .. T}-~E: r:~le ~d,='-,\;: s er\}f?:=,
as a }::'C> -=- :-1 t c. f g:r."'c:urlc"1ht.3. t.-= 2,.... d, i. s.-:-l-i'3.:r-~. e '\...rt~ er~ t.l~le \,}' a tel'" t3.}) 1 e i.2', 1-; i. g~-.:. . I 7~ 2'
-,le g~:' t_c-~ t. i ::! L 3.21 d. i"t.:= 1 O~7. f 1 ~-:-.. ~ t.e p ~=. g::.- :=~J.:.l!-';' ~,~ slow C-~':)vl:-l 221i:, :1.'" e C:i ~_: c ~', tl-~ €:. ;. a;.::, S Ctg e
() f f 1 c' .~'; '} \_~ 6. -:.e:r 3 d"'Jl-' i:lg ~;.el~ ic).d s c f pe aJ: f 1 C:\1\,1~, 1:1~l l=.T' C~\l i d.i:12 t.er:~.;>c'~' =-X"~.l.
flcod wa~eI' storage~ a~~ by facilit2~i~g watey I'e~0val ttl~I:;u~l~
e\lc:;';:1~.)~"',3ti,,:.:'.~ 211G ~ra,r:sl)i:::':3.-t.i.clr~ [3:1] CI\<lF~ 1C:. 5~5 (~.) J .. Its ;:,lct:lt.~. c-..r~c. ~.Cl....2">
can functi'J~ in the r'en~c\T21 c'r ie~e~ticJ~ c;f sedi~ent5, ~ut~ients. 2D,j
toxi~ 5~t3~ances such
2 =, l~ .=:: a ..vt.~ ,.~
""V".=,--':::;'C
. I, '__. ._....~~, ...' .
~ "
}-;. :::' ;.:~ C.L \~:
o 0
-:_:~::' Cj ',] g n
-..... .-
L..l~
~Le s<:ic\~:
, "
<:".-t.-, ~., . '-i
\.~. \.... I..... ~ \......1.
i~h~~it ~tese ]1at~~al f~nc~io~s.
( (~haf.ts::-
3'-: S() 2,ubJect
1 ~,~ (:. j, p,3.5 selj
to pro~ec.tic~ under ~11e
a~ Town Meeting in M2~ch
2) Tte ,~~tl,~~d descri.berj
Nant,1.::c}:et 'VJetlands T:'yla'."
. .
anc'.Je l.:-
-;:' f 1. 9 8 3 ~
Town of Nantucket
Conservation Commission
Town and County Building
Nantucket, Massachusetts 02554
Minutes of Dece~ber 17, 1987
Page 16
3) The project as proposed l5 not wo:r-thy of "l.:.mited project" statuE
under 310 CI-1P. 10.53 because tile a;,plicant has not prOVeI.l t.hat. rea~.')nable
alternati.ve means of access is unavailable. In fact, the property a~
which the proposed road would terminate is already crossed DV at least
o~e existing road.
4) As pointed out in a memo dated December 3, 1987, from Arthur ~.
Reade, wr., attorney for the Nantucket (~oLserv2tion FoundaticlD. it lS
doubtful tl1at the right of passage through the 50-foot right of 'J~Y held
~y Mr. Luntz and his partners e:,:tends to "tJ1E right to carry out
re~;lica.tion war}: ~n that. c()rridoy". Wetland replication in an area e~~ual
to the area vrhicb would be destrcyed [(310 '.:~/IR lO.55(li)(bl] ,.Jould rlot be
fe5sible because the Nantucket Conservation FOU]1d2-~ion will allow 110
-Cl:.'e:.:::spa2;=, orl its la.nd fc,r- tt.Lis 1='Ul-~'c.lse, as ~poir~t.ec1 ',)11t. irl a lett~el- (12t.erj
Ncvember :2. 1987, from Robert F. ['3)rlor, an e~gineer rep~esenti~g the
NantucJ:e~ Conservation Foundation. Even if this were not an issue. the
best ~.epJ_icatiol1 possible would be narrow rt)adsi!ie di-tches~ ~11d it 15
~1Ct even clear that there ~~ e~ol~g11 space for suel1 i3itches wi"thin
t~-1~2 :>O-fc~c;t r'igllt of \<'.3')7.
5) The application, filed Octobe~ 30. 1987. may ~)e i}1compl~te bec~use
7t~e ap;,licant has no~ 3?plied f()r appreval to t~e N~ntuc]~et Fla~n~}1g
E:\,::'ard (3.1-0 ClvLh( 10.G5(1~)(E) 2.J1Q beca'use the I\JoT.ic:e of Irlterlt f.'3.ils ::.()
r.;..:3.tne- the
T'E5C)Uy"r:;e a~"'ea~. undl~r- Pal--::' IV
,S.[l<:
f;3.ils
;::c
:::es CY" ll.:,e
. . . ,
n-:l.-::-....:..ga L_~:"'::: :-j
r.l~=-a~::~,_1.T..e2. felT' c~)a~:,td.l stcl-m fl,)'\.o-"',3ge.
T}-le prCI);:,sed p~oject w~uld ~2~-e 2 sig~ifica~t ~~ffect llf:O~ Wl~,J_l:e.
a~ i!~tere2~ pyotected t'~1 th~ N2n~~cket Wet-13n,js Bylaw. A I'Odd ~tl'8.1g11
t1:e msadc:w \~cluld b~sec~ t}le wetl~~~, thus affecting the mcvemer:t c,f
~'Ji:dlife ~p and ~jc,~n 't~:e \~a:ley. 3c;r~jering Ve~et2:e~ Wetla~ds are ~.er~.
ir~p2~~an': for wildlife habitat ~ie':3~se they ;,rcJvide ~l~C),j t,:, m2~Y species
and s~elte~~ many o~je:~2.
= :-1 --:..~-;, i:=: C .:::'5 e! t.l1 e n~~e ,3d C\"T .i s a l-~ ~i:'~ -: ir:'6 .3.T.'-? Ei :- C' .::'
;:'l-- ,~~ (!. :?~
IJ :;...l- C~ c~ 2, .,:" C 1.~ 2- 5:-
7he f~10~.t-eared c,~l!
':.: C C ,) l" r:: .:...~-~ g
-!~.}-i E:
2bcve.-ci~ej le-tter frc:m Rohe~t ? DayJ.r:r.
7) The prc~posed projec~ would have 2 signfic3nt effect -l~'on wetlan!j
scenlC views, another .:.nte~est protected by the Nantucket We~lands
Bylaw. A new road in ~his area would impair 5~ch v~eW5 fron1 the r\)ad
and p~iva~e homes to the Dorth, from the coastal dunes to the south, and
fl-:~'.l!;-l t.Ile llrl5pc;iled u;>~~c~:-.:d. c::ees t':.' the east. .3. rl cl \'7e~;L..
Town of Nantucket
Conservation Commission
Town and County Building
Nantucket, Massachusetts 02554
Minutes of December' 17, 1987
P::.1.t;e 17
t~ () l'~- C~ =.: L; ~:. T C) ~,T
A close e~x~1inatio:1 of the 20-foot-wide roaa firoposed by tne aPP_lC~t~t
irl.:1i cat.t? s l.~12 t. al='r:i~c,::{irnate l'y 6. 6 Ci 0 5 <;ruare f E:~et ~ 2. t leas 1:., 0: f ~ ll'y
veget-2te:j bordering freshwater ~~etland would be destro~1ed \~ith little or
nCi mitigat.ic'D or ref,lication fJossitle, due to the width constrai]~t-s --
the 50.-foot easem2nt. Substantiai public harm is probable if t.lle
f)I'C j e c..-:t i,>.7eJ:e all o,^"ed! cHid t.1-1e Cc>rnrnis sioli :E irlds rlO f ea.::; ible COI1(ii.t':C:-l2,
tj-lat ~AlcLl<j p~e\Te!-it. s"tlch r-ld.rm. Tl"le ap1=,lic':=in-r. }-la.2 l-j'J~ civerco;ne -::J-18
l)re~;UJTlr->t_.ic'r~ [~':ilO ClIoIF~ 10.. .:.5 (3) J tllat the \'lc.r}.: };lr'ol:;cse,j is si.griific'a.:-lt t,,-.-;
tl1"~ j~!-li=f.;j.:'(::, s -c_~~ c i t".ed a.!)o.....Te. Be (.'.21..1 s e -rJ-lis };Ire 5 UJTI:pt i I:) !-l h,::.~s ::1C.lt. .beell
oveI'co~~e! the proposed work may ne.t destroy or otherwise impair 6ny
!)(:lr--ClC:-l ,-~,f T~rle rread,:;t>I [1.0. 5:: ( 4: 't J . J::\~rerl if the pre SU'Tll:\t iorl hac1 :-ee:-l
cveY'c(,n~e, ~eplic~tic~ i.s nc~t feasible: ditches are not ade'~~ate mea~3 r~
, . .
re1="i...:..-~a1:l0rL ..
Tne:cE: i2. l'1t) l~_gatiorl 'uporl tr1.e (~orru~i5";sio:1 to g}~2:1t }~)el~mlS52.()ll ~ -,- 7-~~~
Ije::~:1'::'J~.t:r'.::~i<::l1 cf t.l-:.is Eltlch '.Jetlar~d in f='l....,jel... tel c.ll')\'7 acc~e5S t.o '-".
pre-'ex~2ti~g l.~t .Jtherwise inaccessible.
Even if there were sucl1 211
cblig2tio~. ~}~e c12im of inaccessibility has nat b~en proven tc the
(:,orr~:T"'t':, S:3 j c' r~ '3 E, a. -:,.:i~, r3 C~ ic: 11 .
There is already at least one road cr'~5~~~1g
a corner c;f ~he lo~ in questi'Jn: this road is open te, the publicy
inC~~~~11g ~he ow~ers of the let.
The size of the ;Jro;J0se~ road and t}~~
l~ck (If ~it-ig2~io:1 nleasures that W0l11d meet the performa~ce st2~d.3I'd2
tt-:e l\1.:=t___ ~:-1:J3 ?~"".,~.-<=>?ct.i(:<rl A,:ot. 2..nd tl-..e ~"Jal-lL.1j(~]..:e-r. lll}e-=-12:1d.s B'J"la\.J rr;aj-':~ t-~"} :~,
~r0D.:~5~_~ ~_,~~2ccec.,~~~r!le~.
?:J.::..... -:-.::,:.? ~F2,E:-:):r~5 ~~~-;t =C~.t}l l=..t<::~ve. t.1-1E: ~~-J<:,t.ice cf I:-::t.e:.lt t'':ll:' a l-C3,j
5Cr(:~s 1\:~fc~12e V2~ley (D~O~ ?iJ.e Nc:. S~~8-~~lS) is denied ull;jeI'
"~!l;= ~~:~,::lt2 V,,~tl~'-:rld.=. ~'rc;tec"':.ir:'rl T:.c~ (, paJ:::.tic"'.2=-;:..~--~.#';/ ~-=-'?;.~F~ 31D 10: 5:~ 2:-~=- =..._..:.
'-'.. ~_"' ~.: ~.,~ C:.:: l... "t.!-:: is ~=::-::. _. ~\~ e rl t~ 1..1 ::.':J.: e t vJ e t.l .:=.r-l /j s B~,.;" 1. .3.v! (Ct~? 1=:-I:-e::,.-- 1 ~~ 6 ). J--I i_'\, T~ \: c.::-- ~
~:>-:e c ,~,~"'!-'-,i~:: s~,:->r~ .:-:'23 :-!(\:=. cc:n 2'. id.el-'e d r.:;.rlcl l}()8 S r:()"L 2C: c:r-e;? 5 2'"': "cr: i=, -:~-in-~:?
':::~rli=-::"-. ,:=:i.~'-+:.~i."'/it-ie.3 c;..r~d. 1~)J:'o:pcs21s c,f tr-18 ap~:licant. ir~ I'Es:pect t.e) 1=.:-1-3
Sl_:.:::.: ::-- '..=' -:. }~:c"l-' '~-:E~ 1_ '..Jr.:.i c ~-l i :-~\7C' 1 \,""e d.i f f 2YJ2:nt l:te 2: ig!lS, 3 t.~"i.l::'-:: "'.1l--e:3, ..:... C":: 2~ -:-~ 2- ,=':..~ .:', I
or tV=I~S. a:~d which 2~e not in~lu,jed i~ the Notice of I~tent ~t iss~e.
rrhi~ ':1e:-li,3.l sv.pe-.r.sE<:e3 all c,f t.he '\f.:C>T"'tji:1g i!1 F()r!~ 5 (at.-:'cicbed.; vJl-iic!-~
i~ll)l~es ~hat some '~(jrl: will be permitted under ~h~s Order. This 2erl~~1
~, :-1 c~ 1-:,
- ...-,..- ...
,-- " .,
'.". .r-;...- -- .-l
t..:'::l
.3. r-~ ,]
successor in iI1t.erest or successor'
l:-l
c:~>r.i.l.~cl.
Town of Nantucket
Conservation Commission
Town and County Building
Nantucket, Massachusetts 02554
Minutes of
December
~ "
~.' !
1987
Pa-ge
18
If the applicant fails to record thlS Order in the Nantucket Registry eft
Deeds or the Massachusetts Land Court and fails to file with the
COFJ1,j_ss ic.r;. the c:cnpleted slip provided '-Ji th Form 5 i-Ji thin 10 bu::,ir~es s
days f:f ths date of issllance of this Order, the Ccn~issi')n is effif,owerei
tc: 2.~ecol--,:l thi.s dClc1.lrner-lt.. If t.he (~orr.missio!l does rect.)l....d this di=,cl-;.rnent,
du~ to ~he failure of the applicant to do 20, the applica~t will be
c112r~2d ~he reco~ding fee plus a fine of not more than $300 per Gay.
*:>, *
LYi1D ZilM1erma11 of t.he Nantucket Land Council reported on two conflicti~g
lette~5 in I"efereI:{:e to Sherburne Associates - SE48-435 - Boat
Basin/Easton Street. Slle said Steven Davis, Assistant Secretary ~~ the
~n~'irc'}:mental Impact Review at the E}:ec. Office of Environmental
A~f3irs, told the Land C0uncil that the project does require an
E;l'lirC'n;nei~t.al Notificatic:-J Form, yet r"~. Davis he..d told IrJeTren Lc.1ITry,
2f;erlt. r':')l'" t1-~e ap:;"li.ca~r}t" "that r.:.o EI'JF \Nas nE~edf3d. Ms. Zin"1'rf:errnarl ;=:,a.i<: ~~1-1E-
pllr31~lGg the matter'.
:+: ::'1~ :1:
J1.-=1r:1i~-list.J.:'at.I=:;l~ Eier_ IvTc;I(elvJc"j" dis.cc;\lel"'E;d tl:.e origi11a.l Erlfc~I'ceT7'lellt (;rde:.'" i~:::
l.le.e,::ed \"itlEr! G_t""C.2C1-1ir-lg c,:-;.e tel a ;:eerj. T1lliS. t.=.11e CCITInissio:-l ,jecided t.el
iS5ue 2~!10theI' ()rder to B~u(~e KiJ.len - SE~8-359 - 67 Cliff Read i!~ (,~,~S~
, -, . , .- .- ,
~o ma,~~e l~ er=~c~:ve.
Ca~l Borch~~t sai.d it is ells-tornary f,~r 2
-: ~~: 1-"':' ~ -'I -:-- . .
~ - ~,' ~... '- ....- ~ '--~ --
,::::-:-igir.:.e..2.:3 t,:;
.. - _.-
~Ie -~~awn up ar:d slgned.
an~ then o::e goes
_.... ~tlS
a~~;lic2~t ~Jld ~he c~heI. ge~s attached to t~e ~eed.
.--, .... .
~ec 2g~seij ~I: :ra\~
i:.}- ~ f-~ P-i
, ,,"!-,
U,,-]_'
':.::-~ j 1.; C.C:':-C;~~=- =, s ie-De:: s a.greed.
t.e
co~~s
1:.'Y~ tIle e,ffice t.c> :.::.g:-l -::-}>?::~,.
't *~:
'l'ner0 Dell:g ~C' :;~~e~ D~j2lne5s! ~he mee~lng 2djcju~ned at 11:29 PM.