HomeMy WebLinkAbout1987-11-12
Town of Nantucket
Conservation Commission
Town and County Building
Nantucket, Massachusetts 02554
AGENDA FOR NCVEMBER 12, 1987
A. PUBLIC HEARINGS
9 .
10.
~~1.
- ')
1.....
1.
2.
3.
~.
Nantucket Wetlands Regulations Draft
Barth/Taddonio - 79 Eel Point Road
Dooley FaTnily Trust - 13 Polliwog Pond Road
Crow's Nest Associates - SE~8-~36 - 7 Craw's Nest Way, Wauwinet
Crow's Nest Associates - SE~8-~37 - 9 Crow's Nest Way, Wauwinet
John Mark - SE~8-~~3 - 28 & 30 Gosnold Road
Joseph & Joan Cochran ET AL - SE~8-~~2 - 5~ & 56 No. Beach Stree
Robert Earner - SE48-4~5 - 36 Easton Street
l~antu_cke.t ('omrDons Tr11~,t. - Pleasant. Da~Je, Orange (~ Bear S+tree-:.s
Luntz/Emerson - New South Road & Weweeder Ave. (8:30 or later)
IJames Driscoll - One Osprey Road
Wayne ~. Dupont - Codfish Park Road
5.
6.
7.
o
u .
B. PUBLIC MEETING
1. Minutes of September 17, lS87 (Wetlands Regulations Draft)
Minutes of Oc~ober 1. 1987
Minutes ot October 15, 1987
Minutes of October 29, 1987
2. Other Business
a. Nant.ucke.t ComlnoL5 Trust - SE~8-365 - discussion
b. Holland - Maxcy Pond - discussion only
c Secretary's position
d. Robert S. Yates> - SE48-408 - a1TleDd Order or C)nditions'?
e. KeiTh M. Yankow - 22 Starbuck Road - well easement
f. Necessity of weekly field inspections
3. Request.s> f CT Det.errr.inati>::n
a. Dale/F~azie~ - 37 Gar:~ner Road
b. I?-3-Lll 3tc;j eJ.: ._. 8 j H"lJrrJTlOck P':Jl~.d F~~:)a(l
c. Spencer Cowan - ~,O Douglas Way
d. l?hil B,3.T't1 et_t_ - liurnrrloc~: :P,:>nd. }.~:~ad.
e. Wayne H. Dupont - Codfish Park ~cad
Town of Nantucket
Conservation Commission
Town and County Building
Nantucket, Massachusetts 02554
f. Linda Heurlin - Sheep Pond Road
g. Louise R. Jackson - 15 E. Tristram Ave.
h. A.J. Leddy/C.F. Monahan - 48 Madaquecham Valley Road
1. David Lilly/C. Sawyer - 55 Hulbert Ave.
j. Stephen Swift - Squam SW~1P
4. Extension Permit
a. Heinz and Rooney - ::;E~8.-37~ - 29 Hinckley Lane
5. Certificates of Compliance
a. E. G2,rrett BeT.-J'kes - SEL.t 8 - 299 - Squam Road
b. L~ADn DeGenaro - SE48-108 - 19 East Creek Road
6. Orders of Conditicns
*** Open :+i:.>fc
7. Bills to be paid
8. Correspondence
9. Volunteer to notarize
10. Field Inspections
a. Edgar A. Anderson - Monornoy Ave. & Northern Ave. - RFD
b. Elizabeth McIlvain - Millbrook Road - Nor
c. Terry/Margaret Lenzner - :4 North Road - NOr
d. Myles Reis - 80 Miacomet Ave. - NOr
e. Ellen Flan1ffi - 43 Squa!"f1 Road - Nor
f .. Ro})ert. (~ lJ eal1 rla~TJ:ins - 3 "-:) I\,laclaJ:et Road - RFD
g.. St.eT)l~e!l S",-!ift - Squarn Swamp - F~FD
h. Barth/Taddonio - 79 Eel Point Road - NOr
l. lJantucket COITJnons Trust - Pleasant, !)ave, Orange & Bear - NO
J . Lunc:.z /Eme:::-sol1 - NeH South F:oad &: \'Jeweeder F.ve. - Nor
}z.. Jame~=:; I)l"iscol~L - ()Ile (i:::pJ:S")i r~(),3(j - 1'.J()I
1. Silv~t3 L1~t - dirt piles
m.. Lal~gel'/:r~edfel-'rl - 15 rrT'()tts Hill F~c}ad - F~FD
11.. H()11~}l.d. -- 117 I'/Ic13aj:et Ri,)c.id - ~~C)I
Town of Nantucket
Conservation Commission
Town and County Building
Nantucket, Massachusetts 02554
Minutes of November 12, 1987 Page 1
MI~~ES OF NOVEMBER 12, 1987
The public hearings of November 12, 1987 were called to order at 7:30
PM. Members present were: Peter W. Dunwiddie - Chairman, Lee Dunn, Bill
t.Jillet, Donald Visco, Henry Wasierski, Granville Cranston (new member) .
Members absent were: Carl Borchert.
A. PUBLIC HEARINGS
"1
J.. .
Nantucket Wetlands Regulations Draft. Lee
continue the hearing for a revised drart.
Dunn moved to
So vot.ed.
2. Barth/Taddonio - 79 Eel Point Road. Lee Dunn moved to continue
the heariTlg for a DEOE file number and more infollTlation from t.he
applicant. So voted.
3. Dooley Family Trust - 13 Polliwog Pond Road. Glen Wills of
Nantucket Surveyors was present as agent for the applicant.
Bill Willet moved to continue the hearing ror a DEOE file
number. So voted.
~. Crow's Nest Associates - SE~8-~36 - 7 Crow's Nest Way, Wauwinet.
Tina Coughanour of IEP Has present vli th owner Steve Lindsay and
present.ed ne,., site plans. All portions or the house and ded:
had been moved back and the house will have a solid foundation.
Plans ror revegetation and a pedestrian walkway Here disc'.lssed.
Henry Wasierski moved to close the hearing.
So voted.
5. Crow's Nest Associates - SE~8-~37 - 9 Crow's Nest Way, Wauwinet.
Tina Coughanour or IEP was present with owner Steve Lindsay and
presented new s i t.e plans. All portions of the house and dec>:
had been moved back and the house will have a solid roundation.
Plans ror revegetation and a pedestrian walkway Here discussed.
Lee Dunn moved to close the hearing.
So voted.
6. John Mark - SE~8-4~3 - 28 & 30 Gosnold Road. John Shugrue was
present as agent ror the applicant. Peter DunHiddie read tte
Town of Nantucket
Conservation Commission
Town and County Building
Nantucket, Massachusetts 02554
Minutes of November 12. 1987 Page 2
results of a recent field inspection. There was discussion
with Mr. Shugrue about the wetland':3 status ,::.wd Peter fe=.~ :::
consultation with ~icJ~ey MarCU5~ who originally f13gged the
wetland. was needed.
Mr. Shugrue had revised the septic system. Bill Willet moved to
cOl"1tilll.1e the hea~-'irlg for ITlc:re irlrOl-rnat..ii:J:l. fT'om r-.'li.cl:ey I\1aT'C1l5.
So vCttecJ.
-,
, .
~Tose'p}-l & JCl.:=.tfl Coc.l-.tr'arl ET AL - SE~L~;-4iJ.2 ~ ~;4- & 5.6 tJ(). Beaci-j
.S-r:reet"
Jo~n Shugrue was pre5en~ as agent for ~he arlplic311t and
V.!2S li1 the pJ~"()(;eS5 of v..7T'i tir.;.g Iv1.:Lc~l:.e"l;r Mal""'ClJ3 f()y' TIl0re
. r .
lntorma7.lCrl.
Donald Visco mCived to
ccntin~..l~3
the
. .
.rlP2l-lI-lg
for :T:oye
. - .
lll.tt::JTTll2.tlOr-i.
Sc \lote,j"
C, .
RCibert Hcriler - SE~8-~~5 - 36 Easton Street.
close the hearing. So voted.
Lee Dunn moved to
Cl tJant.1JCtCet CCJrrrrlOf15 tIrlJ.:=,t-. - .Pleas,:irrt. ~L:1-rv:-e. Clr,3rlE':e !":x Be,3.J.~ Stl"'ce1:.3.
Ted Tii10tso~ of Sher})urne, Powers & tJeedham was presen~ as
agent for the app]ican~ and requested a continuance ~~ the
heari~g so clt~er rep~esentatives cc!~ld be present..
Mr. Tillotson ~enticjne~ briefly tha~ t.he plans are f(:.r
.3.frcrdat)le h\)u.sing arld t11at =~EC!E .;:13irrLs (3. l:>CJ~tic'n ~:)f t:-~e :, li
~lnder cc;nsideratic.n is rlO~ a ~~et:~nd. Bill Willet m'~v6:~ t,:-
ccnti}l~e ttl€ hearin~.
.'::,(i vote,].
::0.
L 1.1r-1 ~ z /Erner:=, ~.:>1-1
- l<e\-.:- :3()"'._1t:1
- ..,.,..,. -
:~,c' ~i.;.J.'~:': 'w'~ ~'(-.'e e.Clel~
A-;./e.
':'i,..-nel-
'~:J ill j_ .~r--,
Lun'~.= was ;)~e5~~t with Tj.~a C'~~lgha::;:i~r of l~;~'.
~~~:.-tl-i"t..:~- F~-=,~:=~
Re2de a~d Alger and Rctlert Dayl~:,r c:f Da~Tlo~ CO~5ulti~; G~':~_=\
y,le~r:. p:ce E e rl t r'e:p2:0e.s err::, .l.ilg trl S .:::.1:~"'...:"7_ ~.=.er. ~J-.:.e I-Ja.. r.l. t. ;J.cJ:e-:.
{:o~serv2t,~cn Fo~~ndati8n.
Mr. L~rlt= gave a descripti~~ -~ t~e prOJe~:t and a hi2t.Jry :j~ ~~-
atten~ts tel negotiate with the Na~~~c}:et Ccnse~vatic,n ?oun~at~o~
for ac('sss to ~is property. lie e~:~j~ained he wis}"led ~0 fc:l.:,w
Town of Nantucket
Conservation Commission
Town and County Building
Nantucket, Massachusetts 02554
Minutes of November
"1 ,":1
...l..... .
1987
Page '-
the sO-(:311ed "beaten path" of en: exist.ing
FOLlrldaticr~ cI>posec ;~eCclJ2}e IvIl--. Luntz r 5 lc)t
ways and wculd potentially have 3 hcuses.
his interest in finding a b~lance between
the property 5nd conservation interests.
would probably only be used seasonally.
roao~.Ja}r, l-1CJv...;E'\le1.... 1:.1'le
had been subdivided 3
Hr. LULtz eXFressed
his right tel Cevel\:p
He ai3ded t.he houses
'r!lSre ~...Jas extensive dis.cu=.2.iol1 .3J~Jc\ut I'v1r.. LUI"'.l.t.z! s al t,eT.-na~i\7e
plarl t.o };:1.3ce 5 l~~ ft. wide f!countJ~}7 lctrleq ttlrc1ugl1 a wet.Iarll,] -t-,-,
access his ~rcjperty. About 6000 sq. ft. of fil.l WClll1d be
needed. Mr. Luntz was considering using a Grasscrete s1~rface to
cross the 2(:0 ft. leI1gth through the wetland. Replication ~i12~5
we~e also di.scu5sed and were deemed to be unfeasible due to ~~~e
r"lal-"r<:>w .:.--igr-.l.t e:f \..\7ai~. 1..1r. ~unt= 32tid. ,:...cc':<r'ding to trle
regulati::)~s, wetl~n.j5 replicati.on lS not even required when the
:I~ly aV2il~ble access to property lS tl1rough a ~;etland. hO~Je~~~er
he had ~n'~l~ded i~ in his plans. ne also conceded this
alternative had its pr'ob:ems and 118 had sought a con~iliatc)ry
soluti~Jn. b~t ~he Cc:nser'Jation FCJundation had denied his rlg~~
to a:-l eElSS:-Jer-lL.
Lee [~~lnil 2::h:e<::! if 3D ele\.-7a.'t.ed rc,a'..1~",Ta'y ~.N3.:::. a possibi2.ity~ rVI2.
CCiugh2~c,~r thOllg}lt the HDC wo~ld ~.robably object. Henry
~\;aSier~3j.:.i ~<-3.S Ct:):-..cE;~':"".i.e~J. s.l:)c'ut tl-:..e c..mC~~:-lt cf fill r-lee(~.E:(j. Lee
relt_ 2,r.:~l }:,J==.[) wO-Jld. ;::,-plit tl-~e \J,:'2~l.::.rli:i arid ha't,/e ,3.(]~)el-5e eff:==c~-":'.:.:,.
Dcnald V.i5::~ thCjugll~ i~ w~s too bad Mr. Lilntz co~J_dn!t re2C~
,3. gl."8 E'!Tli? 1-: -:. or.;.," i t,!-l tlie F curi::~ E:. t.iCIl. "\-.Jhi C.r-i ,A7I~'J.l (:1 :T~i r-lirni:: e ::.l":e lIT.f> 3. ':;"t '~'1 ~
, '
-r=..D:::- '..<te'~-l--=:-..,"7..
l'tl e l.- e \.....~ 3. ~-:;
~: i;;. C"'JS sic =--~ a}::lci '0.-t
> , .
e"-1t::.l J. C
.3(::ce5S
""C.J":
~~'~u~ja~ic~ r'~o~\ert,ies.
11].:[' ~ ':)a~l~::':':- rJ::--62.Elltec. 3.
I'J:::\7. 2-'::(,7. \-~71'.J.icl-~ l-~e
t~~~ ~;e~-J_a~.js P~ctecti~n
C'J~" .:__ t i :_:;~.l e
- ~
'.~ - .....
t,hs
pre> ;::::) 5; e c
r-.i 2:-iS ~
Cia"':.",..::
~el~ di~ n'~t pr::tect t~e irlteI.est-s of
"'\ .-,...;-
.--:"'- ....... .
l.n :::- 11:1'; ,
the criti.'Jue l:ighligh~~j
i l.i ::,':. n E i =, -::.~ :-_ c il'~~ 5 be~"v,leE:r.i. t.rJ e r"J ::It.i c: e c f I r1 t.e r~ ~ a.T~ '.j t}-le s \.:1=':;:cr-:..i ~-~;:
IEP rer,;:,rt and Mr. Dayley ~~u~,j thrclug~ ~is (.wn c~lculatic:15
"t:-~ ,?;:., t .....7!-~, =. -: i s F)~c' 1:''':) sed. t. c \~}f:'; I }.-~ ~., irr;}:" 1 ';/ (1 i d, n () t. . 'I't-l e y'e 1=' l:.l--t. l i.~ ~.- e 'l
~ crit~c2~ ;;~:'ints .jescribing ~egativ~ im~acts ~,~ ~he are2 2~~i
rs,:;-,...=e3t.::c -.:.he C:O:T1Elissic,:1 der-.l.~:i -:}-"le l-~:Jad\"T2__}7.
Town of Nantucket
Conservation Commission
Town and County Building
Nantucket, Massachusetts 02554
Minutes of November
1 "
1987
Fage /.1
Mr. Reade expressed the Foundation's opposi~ion to the project
by saying signiricant wetland values may be impaired by access
or the sort the applicant prc~)oses. He gave a history of access
cn the property dating back ~c 1912 and said it may be nc
coincidence that this area is undeveloped due to impaired ~--~
impractical access. he wen~ 011 ~c say the applicant }1ad ~:~
legal righ~ to subdivide the land into 3 lots and that the
Fc:undation would vigorously resist a~y Froposed development lD
the area.
Ivlr.. Reade cc~nt.inued. tlV ;3:JggeS::=-lrL; -:he api=-'l iC5:-1t. r.~(a~;/ nClt 112t\.re
legal ~ight to construct ditches. He said it ~ay not be
feasible to replicate and this may well be a case source fi::r 2
de""lial from the Ccnservatic,n CO!TL'ilJ.ss.l.cn. He 31so refere::). t.c
significant wildli~e habitat value for Short-eared Owls and
Regal Fritillary Bu~terflies on the lot. He will present a
legal j.tin~rary at the next hearing_
+- :.-, -.,
I..-.,j,C
F'eter I)-Lln.\..;riddie
irlrc1rrnat.iorl cn
Luntz to j:,rove
acce:::,s route.
a~J':ed IvIT'. F~eade -l::o sUPl~ly the (~c)f:1.In.i5Eiclr-l \.\Tl."t~!l
which tc base a ~~os5ible denial. =ie asked ~r.
he was legally allowed ~o not replicate t.he
Mr. Daylor did nc>t thj_n1: tl1ere was room eno~gh
f':r ~rer)licE~ticrl ::-;:1 eitrli=,.l- si.6.e c;f -tr15 l-C'2d. rvIr.
added his ljesire ~~ fi11:i a sol_uti\Jrl s2,tisfactcry
L-C:-ltz aga.i:-l
t.(l
_ 1 1
dJ..l.
1.=.2..1"'(:-.l ~ 2.
involved.
Sill vCillst
S.:; "!v"'o1:-e.j..
1
mc'\"ec..
" '
C C:-1"t. ~n "_i~:?
'--.l. .i ~::;
s:e 2J.:' i:-:g
,-
1: CI~'"
Il"; ':i J..... e.
i ~-i f;:; T"r:i a t i :' :-~ .
-'- -L.
"JalT1es ~)l--:.sccll - C:-~e ()~::-.;:::''''e~~' F...C;3(t.
Tina CCiug~a]1C;~~ ;)f I~= ~~,-i
.J e f f}:'ej.7 31 a;::J:\Jlc 1 ~ .'~' f H2..~:-t -:E 1 2..'::J.:'.'.j"re 1-1- ;...3 S 0 cia.. tE'; S re!='l-e s en"t.e,:: .~~ a~:-.:? .::
Drisco~.l fGr the ~Ja~WaveI'ns. Ms. :~ciugha~cur' g~./e a t1rief
d.escT..iptic'Tl c)f tr~E: prGject~. Trlere '",las ~,()Tle dj.SC"l_1Ss~i:jri ar~.\i:,u~_
\..r};etr-i.e~ B1~'T~110Cj.-: I\-:-:-.:.,:3_ <;--I...':.3.1.:_f iecl 35 a sal t PC.:'}i:: ,-,iY' .3. fTESI-l P(_~:-~ij.
'TherE: was also d~scussi,:,~ abl:.ut ~he elevatio~ (lf the r'i~~,j
'_:'iilcl se:par.3.tiCJI1 tc' gr'\_)ull:3"f...7a~eI'. F'et__er' [J-Jr-~\\i-ic!3ie c.sJ:ed T\ls.
CrJughano~r ~o cO:1sider moving the dwelling an,j septj.c back =IOOffi
Town of Nantucket
Conservation Commission
Town and County Building
Nantucket, Massachusetts 02554
Minutes or November
i ?
-~ .
1987
:p ,3. :; f:" S,
the pond more. She said she would consider it, but the
vege~ative buffer would m~:e it difficult.
Peter Dunwiddie said this site was one of the 2 worst places on
H'llITL.110cl: P('I1d. '\~lhere erc::=,i:)[l CCCUl"'S <3rlcl he felt ,tlie prCl)CSe1j
bulkhead ~~ould only ITlake Ecouring action '~orse on ei~her si3e.
Henry Wasierski said this may be a classic case of an applicant
\I.;a:-i-ti::'lg a. l>ulkheEid. ~JO\;J alla :pert-laps .3 largeT' hc"c~se later C'D.
Henry favored moving the house haC}:.
Ms. COlJgha~our agreed tc 5f,eaK 1~ith the applican~ about
al~erna~ives and soJ.utiODS. Donald Visco sugge.sted
re-nour'ishing the beach E5 an alternative. BilJ_ Wi.l]_e~ movElj 1:0
cc.ntinue the hearing for more infc:rmation.
SCi "fy~()t.ecl.
12. h.7a:y"ne E. I)upcrlt - C~o(lfish f'ar}:: F~C~3d. JCihn. S:b1.1gl*'ue W2.S ;:;l-eSeJlt
2:=, ~::.g;=r~-:_ tc;r' tile al)r:'lic.an~ ari(j ge.'\,'"c a ~brief descrir:-ti()ll cf t.l-15
prOJec~, located entirely within 6 resource area 5urrou~dej b~T
TCWD F,rc;:8l-t;.".
The ssptic system.
discussed b~iefl~7.
~ier-type foundatic'D and deck design were
Henrv Wasierski moved to continue
"'t.. l-''=
'-_.I..l.'\,.J
heari!~g for disCl1ssion eif the deck design.
20 vcted.
B ~ F~EGULAF~ T.1~E;I' I l-J(;
~
lJIiriutes of Se;:'terntiEl-"">
17
19:37.
Penry WasiersJ,:i moved
-'--
l,_ i__:
=:: ....,-.~~r,~
'-" '_' '_ '._ 0- '-
t~ne IT,ir~-:--=-:.e~ as "v:ri -:1:.er,;..
;:'c. ""'JClte\::..
TVi'; ....... l ~ ~ -, c:
..-...........t...LO. ,_c.....
CJct<:;I::Gr :"
:9S~
H~r'~r.y Wasi,ers}ei ~clvec
...j... -.
r:: c-c ~:= :~::-.
rr~l:-.L"G.te5 2:S \,;ITi t-:.en.
::.~::-) \7(;t,e~j.
I<ri:-.; u tf:-:::
,-. ~ c:' ': -:.::l~:;E l.... 15,
A r. c. '7
1. ':1 c; I .
ne:-l:"-j- hf,:iS ie2..- E.J:j. :TIC--:,/E;j
.... -
i,_ ._i
.=: C ,-:." t:' l= t
t rl e r7'l:' :._1...: t.:. c.:;: S .:=. S 'v'~T i t 't: ~':-1 .
.:; '....' \;" c.; t. e- ,-:3. .
M~~~te5 of Cctc,ber 23, :937
Hen~v ~a3ier~ki rnc:vec
\1.:'" 2..~ "to
u~tiJ_ the ~E):t n,eeting tel a;:prove the rr;inutes.
~ .-
:~c) -;-..7C1-cec..
Town of Nantucket
Conservation Commission
Town and County Building
Nantucket, Massachusetts 02554
Minutes of November 12. 1987 Page 6
')
"- .
Otl:el' Business
a. Nantuc}~et C:om...rnon~, Trust - SE~ 8 - 3 65 - disc.ussicn. Ted
Tillotson represented the applicant and stated he was
working on merging the two Orders of Conditions issued from ~he
Ccm.;nission and DEQE. He offered to highlight. any gray areas ane
discuss them with the COffi~ission.
b. Holland - Maxcy Pond - discussion only. Chris Maury was
present as agent for the applicant and offered his apologies for
not. h:rving filed a Not.ice or Tnt.ent. He gave a brief
description of the project to build a l-story dwelling, the
majority of which would be below 20 ft. high. Both the house
and the septic are outside the buffer zone, but the driveway and
a portion of the yard are within it.
Donald Visco tho1.:;ght the simpler Req~..lest for Determination could
have been filed instead of a Notice of Intent. Mr. Maury SalG
haybales are now in place and a Notice is being prepared. The
COr.ITnission decided ED Erlforcement Order was needed.
c. Secretary's position. The office staff requested
authorization to use aD unused portion of the personal serVlces
budget (payr.:;ll) a'lailable due to the fact that the new
administrate:r was hired SQme 3 1/2 months int.o fiscal year 1 ~'E 8.
Both t.he aCL~i:-dstratcr and secretary draH out of one payroll
account. It was recognized that the secretary had been wor~~ng
C;"veT' th{~ :b-LlCtgeted. 2. 0 :h):'2,. per weey:. s irlce rnid - SUITUT~er, U1=' tc bt:C:;_~t.
30 h:r:.s. per wee]:. in c,rder t.o 2CCOffi'Tlodat.e an increased wo:d:
lca,j. A C5SI= ,,^!as :T1ade fOl-- ~~sing tl-le ex;,:ra mC1r-18},T ..L.i..L t.ne pa'l-:'"l":..:ll
budget ~o allc'~7 tte secreta~y ~0 wc;rk more hours as neceSS2I'Y
t~ro~gh June, 1988.
HenJ.~Y Wasiersl:i ffiQ'":,..red. tc ,3ut.horize tl1e 5ecret,ar-:/ tCl U5e Tr.or"e
than the buege.ted 20 .hr. per ,,,eek amount of the per.=.,.:mal
services budget, up to 30 hrs. per week, in light of the fac~
tha~ the funds are there already. So voted. Donald Visco felt
she should be afforded the full benefits granted to any
Town of Nantucket
Conservation Commission
Town and County Building
Nantucket, Massachusetts 02554
Minutes of November 12, 1987 Page 7
full-time Town employee. The option of expanding the position
to full-time for fiscal 1989 was left open and may be considered
when next year's budget is dra'.;n up in December.
d. Robert S. Yates - SE48-408 - a~end Order of Conditions?
Arthur Reade reviewed items listed in the Special Conditions
which in h.:Ls opinion ,.;ere inaccura.te or misleading concerning
the public water supply. Said items were discussed.
Bill Willet moved to ~~end the Order of ConditioDs as follows:
1. page 1 - paragraph #3: 1n
"pollution" and de2.ete ::-est of
word of line #9.
1 .
.L1ne
1 .
J..lne
#7, place period after
#7, all of line #8 and first
2.
page 3 - paragraph #2:
delete sentences #3, 4 and 5.
So voted.
e. Keith M. Yankow - 22 Starbuck Road - well easement. Mr.
Yankow was present to request permission for an underground well
easement for a lot landlocked by the "greenbelt" land ovmed by
the Co~mission on Goose Cove. Extensive discussion surrou~ded
setting a precedent for allowing wells to go in on conservation
land.
Peter Dunwiddie wanted to discuss the issue with Town Counsel.
Lyr::.n Zirnmer:7\an of t.he Nar::.tuc}~et Land Council expressed co:,cern
for the sodiUIT'L pr,:,blem in Madaket well::=. and offered to supply
data on such. Peter asked Mr. Yankow to bring the Certificate
or Title to the next meeting.
f. Necessity of weekly field inspections. Administrator Ben
McKelway wanted to initiate a policy of co~ducti~g weekly field
irlsI:'~ecticr~s, as r.:.eecled, te> 21.:::'':CJITJ"llOtjat_e trle irlcl:easing nunlte:r' ;'':'If
applicati()ns befcTe the Commission. Donald Visco hj.ghlighted
some of the things which cften slow down the inspel:tions suc~ as
lack of we~lands flagging, poor or non-existen~ maps and lack of
an agent. Ben was asked to look into an applicant hand-out used
by the Town of B~ewster which helps expedite field inspections.
Town of Nantucket
Conservation Commission
Town and County Building
Nantucket, Massachusetts 02554
Minutes of November
1)
-'-~,
1987
Page 8
3. Requests for Determination
a. Dale/Fra3ier - 37 Gardner Road. Henry Wasierski moved to
issue a pcsitive Determination stating the area described (nets
to refer to the entire lot) in the Request is an Area Subj eet t,c,
Protection Under the Act. Therefore, any removing, filli~g.
dredging or altering of that area requlres the filing of a
Nctice or Intent. So voted.
b. Paul StC)j ak - 83 Hurflrnock Pond Road. Henr'{ Wa2.ierski moved to
lssue a posi t.:Lve Determination ;o:,tating the area described E1 ::ne
Request is an Area Subject to Protection Under the Act.
Therefore, any removing. filling, dredging or altering of t:-iat.
area requires the filing of a Notice of Intent. A note added:
The le.nd appears to be Bordering Vegetated 1tJetle.nd Subject i:o
Fll~oding. So voted.
c. Spencer Cowan - 30 Douglas Way. Henry Wasierski moved to
lssue a negative Determination. stating the "work described in the
Reque:=-,t is wi-chin t.he Buffer Zone, but will not alter an. Area
Subject to Protection Under the Act. Therefore, said worl: dees
not require the filing of a Notice of Intent, (note added: )
provided no work is to occur less than 65 ft. from the edge of
the wetland. So voted.
d. l?hil Ea::-t.le-:.t - Hl_1.rnrneck PO:-ld Read.
Henry Wasierski ml)ved to
the work described ~11 ~}:e
lS sue a. }-~e g.3. ti ve [)e"terrr:.:..na tiC)r-i S t.J3 t ir.;.g
Reque~~t is withi~ the Buffer Zone, })ut
S~bject ~s Protection Under the Act.
will not alter an ~rea
~1-1eT"efors. sc..id \-.70:::):
c~ c:
'-....,
not require the fili:1g of a Notice of ILtent.
condi~ions shall apply:
T}1e fc)ll(I~;J].i:-~g
1.
Till. st~ructl:res
are to be loca~ed more ~han 50
1=+
J.. '- .
rrC)i'"L -c.r.;.t----
b .3.:-iJ:: .
.,
~ .
The:c..-e ,'lill be a
':It:.
,-' v
ft. undisturbed buffer.
Town of Nantucket
Conservation Commission
Town and County Building
Nantucket, Massachusetts 02554
Minutes of November 12, 1987 Page 9
3. A siltation fence shall be installed 35 ft. from the bank
consiE.ting of a continuous rew of staked haybales.
~. The applicant or his engineer will present detailed plans to
this Commis sion prior t.o the st~art c,f excavat.ion.
So voted.
e. Wayne H. Dupont - Codfish Pal~~ Road. A motion was made tc
issue a positive Determination stat~ing the area described lD the
Request is an Area Subj ect to ProtE'ction Under the Act.
Thererore, any removing, filling, dredging or altering or that
area requires the filing of a Notice of Intent. So voted.
f. Linda Heurlin - Sheep Pond Road. Robert Daylor of Dayler
Consulting Group was present with Linda Heurlin. Mr. Daylor
explained ~he proposed ~oadway would replace an existing
traveled way and was laid out at one time, yet was never b~ilt.
Ronald Eamber gave a history of the roads in the area and said
the existing traveled way crosses Federal Aviation and
Conservation Foundation lands. Mr. Daylor said the Nantucket
County CCiTl7nissioners are \villiEg t<:' be t.he applicant for an
easement and would file a Notice of Intent.
Lee Dunn ~oveQ to issue a positive Determination stating the
area described in the Request is an Area Subject to Protection
Under the Act. Therefore, any removing, filling, dredging or
altering cf that area reCUlres the filing of a Notice eif Irlte~t.
~ "
::JC' 11D-c.8C..
g. Lo~ise R. Jackson - 15 E. Tristram Ave. Henry Wasierski
rno?ed ~:c) ':'2<:;ue .3 negaticJ8 Determinat.ion stat.ir.g the 'dork
des::ri:::1ed in the RequeE.t is \"ithin an Area Subjec-:. to Pretec7.ic.n
Under the Act, but will not remove, fill, dredge, or alter ~~at
area. Therefore, said work does not require the filing of a
Notice of Intent. So voted.
Town of Nantucket
Conservation Commission
Town and County Building
Nantucket, Massachusetts 02554
Minutes of November 12, 1987 Page 10
h. A. J. Leddy /e. F. IYIonahan - Ii 8 I'1adaquecham Valley Road.
Henry Wasierski moved to issue a negative Determination stating
the area described in the Request is not an Area Subject to
Protection Under the Act. So voted.
l. David Lilly/C. SaHyer - 55 Hulbert Ave. Lee Dunn moved to
lSS"'Je a negative Determinaticn .::.tating the work described in the
Request is within the Buffer Zone, but will not alter an Area
Subject to Protection Under the Act. Therefore, said work does
not recr":lre the filing of a Notice or Intent. So voted.
J . Stephen Swift - SquaTI'. S,,,arnp. Rebert Emaclc of Nantucket
Surveycrs was present \..;ith Mr. S",if-t and felt another field
inspection was needed.
4. Extension Permit
a. Heinz and Rooney - SE48-374 - 29 Hinckley Lane. Melissa
Philbrick of Vaughan and Dale was present as agent fer the
applicant. The discrepancy between the lecal and state
regul,3t.ioI}s \",ras discu~.sed rega.rd.ing the !luITtber cJf 'year.~s Orc.eJ:--:::;
of Conditions are valid.
Lee .Junn moved to have AdJninistrator Ben IVIcKehJay send a letter
certifying the above-referenced Order of Conditions has been
extended for a period of 2 years from the date of the Order
under the Tc:wn Wetlands Eylaw sectiO!1 136-4 (8). The expira:.ic:n
d5te of ~11e Order under the To~n 3ylaw would then be cc;ncurre~~
with the Expiration date stated in the Order pursuant tc: ~11e
S~3te tr2etl ::rl,js ?rotect.ic,fj Act - L\iovember 1:3. 1989. So vote(~.
5. CErtificates of Compliance
a. E.:iarrett BeHkes - SE"'8-299 - ::::quam Road. Jl, r:-iotion W33
made to issue 3. Certif~eate of Compliance certifying that the
work regulated by the a~ove-referenced Order of Conditions has
been sati~factorily completed. So voted.
Town of Nantucket
Conservation Commission
Town and County Building
Nantucket, Massachusetts 02554
Minutes of November 12, 1987 Page 11
b. LuAnn DeGenaro - SE~8-108 - 19 East Creek Road.
Administrator Ben McKelway read the results of a recent field
inspection. Lee Dunn and Peter Dunwiddie felt ano~her field
inspection was needed. Ben was asked to determine if the lot
had Town water and to find the Certificate of Occupancy fer the
dwelling.
b. Orders of Conditions
a. Crow's
l^,au';!,1inet.
Conditions
Nest Associates - SE48-~36 - 7 Crow's Nest Way,
Lee Dunn moved to issue a standard Order of
to include the following Special Conditions:
1. The elevated walkway shall not
cross the highest part of the dune.
2. The foundation shall be at least 25 feet back from the
rear edge of the dune.
3. All decks shall be at least 20 feet back from the rear
edge of the dune.
4. All fill must be of reaterial compatible to eXlstlng
soil at the site.
5. Snow fencing shall be maintained throughout
construction as indicated on the pla~s.
6. All distcrbed areas shall be revegetated with
. ...,. .... .
lndlgenous plant specles.
7. The project shall be completed In accordance wi~h the
Notice of I~tent, the above conditions, and the site
plan revised 11/10/87, signed by Robert E. Epple.
So voted.
Town of Nantucket
Conservation Commission
Town and County Building
Nantucket, Massachusetts 02554
Minutes of November 12, 1987 Page 12
b. Crow's Nest Associates - SE~8-~37 - 9 Crow's Nest Way.
Wam"inet. Lee Dunn moved to issue a standard Order of Condition
to include the following Special Conditions:
1. The walkway shall not contain the triangular deck
indicated on the plan cited below.
2. The foundation sh31l be at least 25 feet back from the
rear edge of the dune.
3. All decks shall be at least 20 feet back rrom the rear
edge of the dune~
~. All fill must be of material compatible with existing
soil at the site.
5. Snow fencing shall be maintained throughout
construction as indicated on the plans.
6. All disturbed areas shall be revegetated with
i~dj_genous plant species.
7. The project shall be completed In accordance with 7he
~otice of Intent, the above conditions, and the ~ite
plan revised 11/10/87 signed by Robert E. Epple.
So voted.
c. Robert Horner - SE48-~~5 - 36 Easton Street. A motii:j~~ was
made tc issue a standard Order cf COT1diticns to include
the follc1wing Special Condition:
1. PC>. srlo-:...;fence is l~C) be installed. <:lgainst. the r)ul]:rlE-2:J l~n
the harbar side to prevent siltation into the harbor.
So voted.
Town of Nantucket
Conservation Commission
Town and County Building
Nantucket, Massachusetts 02554
Minutes of November 12. 1987 Page 13
7. Bills to be Paid
Chairman Peter Dunwiddie wished to initiate a policy of presenti
current Conservation Commission bills to all Corrmissioners for
review so they can be aware of regular expenses.
8. Correspo~deDce
All correspondence was read and accepted.
9. Volunteer to notarize
The secretary wished to include this as a regular agenda item to
ensure that one signer of documents will be responsible for havi
them notarized within 6 days following each meeting. This
responsibility can rotate among the members. Administrator Ben
McKelway is in the process of acquiring his Notary license to
facilitate the notarization of Cormnission docurnents in the fut.ur
There being no other business, the meeting adjourned at 11:25 PM.