The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About2021-4-26 Approved Minutes April 26, 2021, adopted May 17, 2021 0 + a4 C L E P _ 2021 JU -2 PM 3: 1 pu-ii c o�0 'tom'' 0 Historic District Commission Madaket Advisory Board Members: Linda Williams (Chair),Tom Erichsen,Brad Fleming, Robert Kuchara\-v, Bruce Mandel Alternate: Mark Palmer MINUTES Monday April 26, 2021 This meeting was held via remote part icipation (using ZOOM recording feature) Pursuant to Governor Baker's March 12, 2020 Order Regarding ti Open Meeting Law. I. Procedural Business Call to order. This meeting was conducted via Zoom and called to order by Bruce Mandel at 10:15 am. This meeting was recorded on Zoom video. Attending members: Robert Kucharavy, Tom Erichsen and Bruce Mandel Absent members: Brad Fleming, Linda Williams and Mark Palmer Late arrivals: None Early Departures: None Motion to Adopt Agenda made by Robert Kucharavy; Seconded by Bruce Mandel. Roll Call Vote: carried unanimously 3-0//Erichsen,Mandel and Kucharavy - aye Approval of Minutes: April 05, 2021 Motion to Approve made by Robert Kucharavy; Seconded by Bruce Mandel Roll Call Vote: carried unanimously 3-0//Mandel, Erichsen and Kucharavy - aye II. Public Comment None Page 1 of 2 Approved Minutes April 26, 2021, adopted May 17, 2021 III. New Business—See attached Comment(s) Property owner name Street address Scope of work Map/Parcel Agent 1. Carol Anne Surface 47 Warrens Landing New dwelling 38/54 BPC 2. Carol Anne Surface 47 Warrens Landing Studio 38/54 BPC 3. Carol Anne Surface 47 Warrens Landing Pool 38/54 BPC 4. Matthew Dwyer 11 Mississippi Ave Shed 59.4/233 LINK 5. Mark Finnegan 36 Warren's Landing Garage 38/44 BPC 6. Mark Finnegan 36 Warren's Landing Gazebo/cabana 38/44 BPC 7. Mark Finnegan 36 Warren's Landing Pool 38/44 BPC IV. Other Business N/A V. Adjournment Motion to Adjourn made by Kucharavy; Seconded by Erichsen at 10:56 am. Roll Call Vote: carried unanimously 3-0//Mandel, Kucharavy and Erichsen - aye Submitted by Cathy Flynn Page 2 of 2 Madaket Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/MAB Date: 4/26/21 Members Present: MANDEL, KUCHARAVY AND ERICHSEN Applicant: Carol Anne Surface BPC (Agent not present) Address: 47 WARRENS LANDING Scope of Work: NEW DWELLING Historic information/known history: (X)Non-Contributing ()Contributing () Individually significant Comments: ()Incomplete application ()Historical information needed 0 No Concerns ()Recommend View O Does not meet guidelines (X)Not appropriate (As noted below) Comments/Recommendations: • Very tall/long- over powering • Madaket Area Plan limits height to 25' Main/22' secondary dwelling • Height of cupola not indicated on plans. inquired about SDL's. Too large for rural Madaket. Visible From Warrens Landing Road • 2/2 should be 6/6 Motion to accept comments/recommendations made by BM; Seconded by RK 3-0// Kucharavy, Mandel and Erichsen- aye Madaket Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/MAB Date: 4/26/21 Members Present:MANDEL,KUCHARAVY AND ERICHSEN Applicant: Carol Anne Surface BPC (Agent not present) Address: 47 WARRENS LANDING Scope of Work: STUDIO Historic information/known history: (X)Non-Contributing () Contributing ()Individually significant Comments: ()Incomplete application ()Historical information needed 0 No Concerns () Recommend View O Does not meet guidelines ()Not appropriate (As noted below) Comments/Recommendations: • questioned equip room for pool- not indicated on elevations-only floor plan Is it open or screened. • West, East and South horizontal/vertical boards-would like better description Motion on comments/recommendation made by TE; Seconded by BM 3-0 //Erichsen, Kucharavy and Mandel - aye Madaket Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/MAB Date: 4/26/21 Members Present: MANDEL, KUCHARAVY AND ERICHSEN Applicant: Carol Anne Surface BPC (Agent not present) Address: 47 WARRENS LANDING Scope of Work: POOL Historic information/known history: (X)Non-Contributing ()Contributing ()Individually significant Comments: ()Incomplete application ()Historical information needed 0 No Concerns ()Recormnend View O Does not meet guidelines (X)Not appropriate (As noted below) Recommendations: • visible from WLR • questioned light pole on site plan because it is visible from street concerned with architectural nature of light pole is it "down-lit"? • more detail due to topography of lot and visibility from WLR- Buffering should be indigenous and mature, is pool raised off ground, walls, etc.? • More detail on pool, more design information; elevation and materials. Screening of pool to the street. Planting detail Motion on comments/recommendations: Motion to accept comments/recommendations made by TE; Seconded by RK 3-0// Kucharavy, Mandel and Erichsen- aye Madaket Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/MAB Date: 4/26/21 Members Present: BRUCE MANDEL, TOM ERICHSEN AND ROBERT KUCHARAVY Applicant: MATTHEW DWYER—not present Address: 11 MISSISSIPPI AV Scope of Work: SHED Historic information/known history: (X)Non-Contributing ()Contributing ()Individually significant Comments: ()Incomplete application ()Historical information needed (X)No Concerns ()Recommend View O Does not meet guidelines ()Not appropriate (As noted belom) Recommendations: • No Concerns • Needs window and door schedule Motion on comments/recommendations: Motion to accept comments/recommendation to add window and door schedule as a condition of approval made by RK; Seconded by TE 3-0// Erichsen, Kucharavy and Mandel-aye Madaket Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/MAB Date: 4/26/21 Members Present: MANDEL, ERICHSEN, KUCHARAVY Applicant: MARK FINNEGAN BPC- not present Address: 36 WARREN'S LANDING RD Scope of Work: GARAGE Historic information/known history: (X)Non-Contributing ()Contributing ()Individually significant Comments: ()Incomplete application ()Historical information needed (X)No Concerns ()Recommend View O Does not meet guidelines ()Not appropriate (As noted below) Recommendations: • No Concerns Motion on comments/recommendations: Motion to accept comments/recomendation made by RK; Seconded by TE 3-0// Kucharavy, Mandel and Erichsen- aye Madaket Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/MAB Date: 4/26/21 Members Present: BRUCE MANDEL, TOM ERICHSEN AND ROBERT KUCHARAVY Applicant: MARK FINNEGAN BPC- not present Address: 36 WARREN'S LANDING RD Scope of Work: GAZEBO/CABANA Historic information/known history: (X)Non-Contributing ()Contributing ()Individually significant Comments: ()Incomplete application ()Historical information needed Q No Concerns ()Recommend View () Does not meet guidelines (X)Not appropriate (As noted below) Comments/Recommendations: • Visible from three traveled ways-questioned screening. • Suggests mature/indigenous screening • Pictures are not labeled • more info on pool equip room and how its buffered • fence shown- more information needed Motion on comments/recommendations: Motion to accept comments/recommendations made by TE; Seconded by RK 3-0//Erichsen,Kucharavy and Mandel- aye Madaket Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/MAB Date: 4/26/21 Members Present: MANDEL, ERICHSEN AND KUCHARAVY Applicant: MARK FINNEGAN not present Address: 36 WARREN'S LANDING RD Scope of Work: POOL Historic information/known history: (X)Non-Contributing ()Contributing ()Individually significant Comments: ()Incomplete application ()Historical information needed 0 No Concerns ()Recommend View () Does not meet guidelines (X)Not appropriate (As noted below) Comments/Recommendations: • Looking for tall buffer area- pool is close in proximity to street. More info • Suggests relocate on lot • more mature, taller indigenous buffer • more info on elevations of fieldstone wall-only picture shows a pallet of stone Motion on recommendations: Motion to accept comments made by RK; Seconded by TE 3-0//Erichsen,Kucharavy and Mandel-aye