The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About2021-5-11 Approved Minutes May 11, 2021, adopted 5/18/21 0 2021 j:j N -2 °M 3. -1\7oRA _ Historic District Commission Sign Advisory Council Commissioners: Kevin Kuester, Chris Young,Paul Wolf,Mark Cutone,Ben Normand MINUTES Tuesday May 11, 2021 This meeting was held via remote participation(using ZOOM recording feature) Pursuant to Governor Baker's March 12, 2020 Order Regarding the OpenMeetirgLaw. I. Procedural Business Call to order: This meeting was conducted via Zoom and called to order by Chris Young, Chairman, at 9:02 am. This meeting was recorded on Zoom video. Attending members: Chris Young (Chair),Paul\Yolf and Kevin Kuester Staff in attendance: Cathy Flynn. HDC Compliance Coordinator Absent members: Mark Cutone Late arrivals: None Early Departures: None Motion to Adopt Agenda made by Paul Wolf; Seconded by Kevin Kuester. Roll Call Vote: carried unanimously 4-0//Normand,Kuester, Wolf and Young- aye Approval of Minutes- 5/04/21 Motion to Approve made by Kevin Kuester; Seconded by Paul Wolf. Roll Call Vote: carried unanimously 4-0//Normand,Kuester,Wolf and Young- aye II. Public Comment-None it Page 1 of 2 Approved Minutes May 11, 2021, adopted 5/18/21 III. New Business Property owner name Street Address Type of Sian Map/Parcel Agent I. 9 Petticoat Row, LLC 9 Centre Street Projecting sign 42.3.1-203.1 Dalton Frazier 2. Chris Keogan I Freedom Square Wall sign 55/702.1 LINK 3. David Cox 58B Main Street Wall sign 42.3.1/219.2 Antonio Aransaenz 4. David Cox 58 Main Street Relocating proj sign 42.3.1/219.1 Self 5. Town of Nantucket 15 Harbor View Way Educational panel 42.4.2/9 Janet Schulte IV. Other Business/ Preliminary Review (if applicable) • 31 Center Street sign option-Cara Marquis-proposed lettering on stairwell leading in to business. No precedent to paint onto wall.Not appropriate.Not in the guidelines. Suggested chalkboard sign • Enforcement-discussion of springtime enforcement • Sign Guidelines update discussion-None • Discussion and possible vote of Construction sign letter to Nantucket Builders Association-None • Next Sign Advisory Council meeting: Tuesday May 11,2021 at 9:00am V. Adjournment Motion to Adjourn at 9:428 am made by Kuester; seconded by Normand. Carried 4-0//Kuester,Wolf,Normand and Young-aye Submitted by Cathy Flynn Page 2 of 2 Sign Advisory Council Meeting Date: 5/11/21 Council Members: Young, Kuester, Wolf Property Owner/Applicant Representing: 9 PETTICOAT ROW, LLC/// DALTON FRAZIER Address of Proposed Sign: 9 CENTER ST Name on sign: THE DRESS CODE Type of sign (wall, projecting, free standing, other): Other Location of sign (entrance, rear, side, other): entrance General Comments: ***HELD FOR REVISIONS** REPRESENTING- DALTON FRAZIER- ADDRESSED PREVIOUS CONCERNS WOLF- NO CONCERNS KUESTER- QUESTIONNED IF RED WAS TOO BRIGHT, OTHERWISE A GREAT JOB YOUNG- NO COLOR SWATCH IN APP, PREFERS GOLD LEAF VS GOLD PAINT- WILL BE MORE 'EYE- CATCHING' AND LAST LONGER NOTION TO APPROVE WITH GOLD LEAF PAINT MADE BY WOLF; SECONDED BY KUESTER 3-0//WOLF, KEUESTER, YOUNG-AYE NORMAND- RECUSED Sign Advisory Council Meeting Date: 5/11/21 Council Members: Young, Kuester, Wolf, Normand Property Owner/Applicant Representing: Chris Keogan/ Tori Ewing, LINK Address of Proposed Sign: 1 Freedom Square Name on sign: Island Insurance Agency Type of sign (wall, projecting, free standing, other4: WI4 PROJECTING Location of sign (entrance, rear, side, other): entrance General Comments/Recommendations: , ***HELD FOR REVISIONS from 5/4/21** REPRESENTING- Tori Ewing, addressed previous concerns. Changed to projecting sign; measured existing armature- 34" off building- showed new location, with updated colors- red to be tristams' red. Sign to have hole in middle Young- proposing projecting sign now. Asked about additional sign on existing bracket. Suggested both armatures the same, match armature and height with existing armature and height for location. Wolf- asked for measurements and bracket location Normand- updated from wall to projecting-should go above head of window casing. A few boards up. Kuester-top of sign should be 1 clapboard up from top of window casing. Great solution Motion to approve with armature to be placed in identical elevation as existing and to match existing made by Normand; seconded by Wolf. 4-0//Wolf, Keuster, Normand and Young- aye Sign Advisory Council Meeting Date: 5/11/21 Council Members: Young, Normand, Kuester, Wolf Property Owner/Applicant Representing: David Cox/ Antoni Aransaenz Address of Proposed Sign: 58B Main Street Name on sign: Clorinda Antori Type of sign (wall, projecting, free standing, other): Wall Location of sign (entrance, rear, side, other): Side General Comments/Recommendations: Antoni Aransaenz, Jean Petty- proposed new sign replacement. Essex Green not Gardner Green to match existing sign. Provided 2 options Normand: prefers Essex Green. Wolf- agrees with Normand Kuester- likes sign, color should match existing. Young- iconic building. Motion to approve with Essex green made by Kuester; seconded by Wolf. Sign Advisory Council Meeting Date: 5/11/21 Council Members: Young, Kuester, Wolf Property Owner/Applicant Representing: David Cox Address of Proposed Sign: 58 Main Street Name on sign: David Chase Type of sign (wall, projecting, free standing, other): Projecting Location of sign (entrance, rear, side, other): Side General Comments/Recommendations: David Cox- reviewed meeting and minutes. Keep same height and plane over to corner of building. Exist bracket above door will be removed. Position similar to Mitchell's Book Store. Sign needs to be replaced. Project 34 inches from building. Kuester(acting Chair)- armature and placement was the concern. Should be mounted on inside of downspout. Young-same perpendicular orientation. Wolf- agrees with what's been said Motion to Approve thru Staff with armature design with 34" sign located at same height as existing, inside the downspout made by Young; seconded by Wolf. 3-0//Young, Wolf, Kuester:_et c_ Normand - recused Sign Advisory Council Meeting Date: 5/11/21 Council Members: Young, Kuester, Wolf and Normand Property Owner/Applicant Representing: Town of Nantucket/ Erika Mooney, Janel Schulte Address of Proposed Sign: 15 Harbor View Way Name on sign: Expedition Blue Type of sign (wall, projecting, free standing, other): other Location of sign (entrance, rear, side, other): other General Comments/Recommendations: Erika Mooney, Operations Administrator; Janet Schulte, Director of Culture and Tourism; Educational panel around the Cape and Islands shows impact of Ocean on local economy. Sign has 25-year lifespan. Design of structure reflects fishing shacks along National Seashore. Approved by HDC. Color matches others- explained the three signs and location on structure. Normand - likes location by the playground- sign modern. Feels that HDC approved forcing the SAC to approve. Not historic. Ask if timeline- prefers if it could be more historically sensitive Wolf-shocked HDC approved structure to hang signs. Nothing is approvable from SAC viewpoint. Concerned about setting a precedent. Young- agrees with Wolf. Does not meet public information sign requirements. Concerned about precedent. Kuester(acting Chair)-agrees with what's been said. Suggests looking at Sankaty Light- mounted at ground level. Perhaps adapt graphics, does not fit the guidelines. Suggest revisions or withdraw. Corporations fit their fonts/logos to fit the SAC guidelines. Staff offered extension or withdraw. Mooney-would prefer withdrawing. Motion to withdraw without prejudice made by Young; seconded by Normand. 4-0//Young, Wolf, Kuester, Normand ter, a t_