The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About2021-5-4 Approved Minutes May 04, 2021, adopted May 10, 2021 N'i i� • I� Historic District Commission Sign Advisory Council Commissioners: Kevin Kuester, Chris Young,Paul Wolf,Mark Cutone,Ben Normand MINUTES Tuesday May 04, 2021 This meeting was held via remote participation (using ZOOM recording feature) Pursuant to Governor Baker's March 12, 2020 Order Regarding die Open Meeting Law. I. Procedural Business Call to order: This meeting was conducted via Zoom and called to order by Chris Young, Chairman, at 9:01 am. This meeting was recorded on Zoom video. Attending members: Chris Young (Chair),Paul Wolf,Mark Cutone and Kevin Kuester Staff in attendance: Cathy Flynn. HDC Compliance Coordinator Absent members: Ben Normand Late arrivals: None Early Departures: None Motion to Adopt Agenda made by Kevin Kuester; Seconded by Paul Wolf. Roll Call Vote: carried unanimously 4-0//Cutone,Kuester,Wolf and Young- aye Approval of Minutes- 4/27/21 Motion to Approve made by Kevin Kuester; Seconded by Mark Cutone Roll Call Vote: carried unanimously 4-0//Cutone,Kuester,Wolf and Young- aye II. Public Comment-None Page 1 of 2 Approved Minutes May 04, 2021, adopted May 10, 2021 III. New Business Property owner name Street Address Type of Sign Map/Parcel Agent 1. 9 Petticoat Row, LLC 9 Centre Street Projecting sign 42.3.1-203.1 Dalton Frazier 2. Chris Keogan 1 Freedom Square Wall sign 55/702.1 LINK 3. James Siminoff 15 Washington Street Wall sign 42.3.1/99 Sign Here Nantucket 4. David Cox 58 Main Street Relocating proj sign 42.3.1/219.1 Self 5. David Cox 58 Main Street Relocating wall sign 42.3.1/219.1 Self 6. NIR 18A Federal Street Rev-Projecting sign 42.3.1/72 Giovanna DiRusso 7. 29 Center St LLC 4 Chestnut Street Rev-Gate House-wall sign 42.3.1/68.1 Plymouth Sign Co 8. 29 Center St LLC 11 India Street Rev-Roberts Hse wall sign 42.3.1/122.1 Plymouth Sign Co 9. 29 Center St LLC 11 India Street Roberts House wall sign 42.3.1/122.1 Plymouth Sign Co 10. 29 Center St LLC 31 Center Street Rev-Manor House wall sign 42.3.1/68 Plymouth Sign Co 11. 29 Center St LLC 29 Center Street Rev-Meeting Hse-wall sign 42.3.1/122.2 Plymouth Sign Co 12. 29 Center St LLC 29 Center Street Rev-Faraway wall sign 42.3.1/122.2 Plymouth Sign Co 13. 29 Center St LLC 29 Center Street Rev-Faraway canvas flag 42.3.1/122.2 Plymouth Sign Co 14. 29 Center St LLC 29 Center Street Rev-Sister Ship-fence sign 42.3.1/122.2 Plymouth Sign Co 15. 29 Center St LLC 29 Center Street Rev-Coffee—wall sign 42.3.1/122.2 Plymouth Sign Co IV. Other Business/ Preliminary Review (if applicable) • Enforcement-sent letter to homeowner re free-standing sign.Caretaker will remove. ACK Nov,. has been informed of 30 day political signage • Sign Guidelines update discussion-None • Discussion and possible vote of Construction sign letter to Nantucket Builders Association-None • Next Sign Advisory Council meeting: Tuesday May 11,2021 at 9:00am V. Adjournment Motion to Adjourn at 9:42 am made by Cutone; seconded by Kuester. Carried 4-0//Kuester,Wolf,Cutone and Young-aye I I Submitted by Cathy Flynn I 1 Page 2 of 2 Sign Advisory Council Comment Sheet Date: 5/4/21 Members present: Chris Young, Mark Cutone,Paul Wolf and Kevin Kuester Applicant: 9 PETTICOAT ROW LLC Representing: DALTON FRAZIER Address of proposed sign: 9 CENTER ST Sian Name: The Dress Code Type of proposed sign ( )Wall Mount ( X)Projecting ( )Free standing( )Rock ( )Other Location (on property) of proposed sign: ( X )Entrance to building ( )Rear of building ( )Side elevation ( )Other Comments/Recommendations: Frasier- never submitted a Master Sign Plan. Sign is similar armature is 37 inches. Young- consistency needed for signs in terms of size. Inquired about size of armature. Ask if color swatches submitted. Pink color is bright. Asked if lights on application. Would need to be approved. Cutone- noted size correction.No concerns. Looks like Pantone color not Benjamin Moore. Building has had a variety of signage. Red should be muted. Suggests linen background. Has no concerns graphically. Wolf- concerned with colors-not appropriate for OHD. trademark needs to be removed. Kuester-font not appropriate. Has trademark on sign. Curious if wall sign will be submitted. Would like more traditional sign. Other signs on buildings are subdued. Suggests black gold scheme. Suggested looking at Ladybird Lingerie sign. Overall concerns- font and color scheme; reduce size of logo, if they want to keep font as is should be 15% of the sign or change font to more traditional style, muted color scheme, color swatch of what is proposed. Trade mark needs to be removed. Motion to Hold for Revisions made by Kuester; seconded by Wolf. 4-0 Cutone, Kuester, Wolf and Young- aye Sign Advisory Council Comment Sheet Date: 5/4/21 Members present: Chris Young, Mark Cutone, Paul Wolf and Kevin Kuester Applicant: Chris Keogan Representing: Tori Ewing, LINK Address of proposed sign: 1 Freedom Square Sign Name: ISLAND INSURANCE AGENCY 1'vpe of proposed sign (X)Wall Mount ( )Projecting ( )Free standing( )Rock ( )Other Location (on property) of proposed sign: 2 OPTIONS (X }Entrance to building ( )Rear of building (X)Side elevation ( )Other Comments/Recommendations: Ewing: included other signs in the area. Has two choices. Would prefer sign to face Pleasant Street. Wolf- Recused Kuester- Wall sign is not appropriate on side of building. Suggests projecting sign or smaller sign either on corner of close to the door for visibility. Interested in edge or frame Young- agrees with Kuester. Nantucket Pure sign is too large. If owner wanted to change size and move, might be more appropriate. Noticed existing armature. Asked for color chip. Wants detail on sign Cutone-Agrees with what has been said. Motion to Hold for Revisions made by Kuester; seconded by Cutone. 3-0 Cutone,Kuester and Young- aye//Wolf- recused Sign Advisory Council Comment Sheet Date: 5/4/21 Members present: Chris Young, Mark Cutone, Paul Wolf and Kevin Kuester Applicant: DAVID COX Representing: NONE Address of proposed sign: 58 MAIN ST- RELOCATING EXISTING WALL SIGN Sian Name: DAVID CHASE Type of proposed sign ( X )Wall Mount ( )Projecting ()Free standing( )Rock ( )Other Location(on property) of proposed sign: ( )Entrance to building ( )Rear of building ( )Side elevation (X )Other Comments/Recommendations: Cutone- no concerns Wolf-no concerns Kuester-no concerns Young- no concerns Motion to Approve made by Wolf; seconded by Kuester. 4-0 Cutone, Kuester, Wolf and Young- aye • Sign Advisory Council Comment Sheet Date: 3/4/21 Members present: Chris Young, Mark Cutone, Paul Wolf and Kevin Kuester Applicant: DAVID COX Representing: NONE Address of proposed sign: 58 MAIN ST- RELOCATING PROJECTING SIGN Sign Name: Type ofproposed sign ()Wall Mount (X )Projecting ()Free standing( )Rock ( )Other Location (on property) of proposed sign: ( )Entrance to building ( )Rear of building (X )Side elevation ( X )Other Comments/Recommendations: Kuester-vague in how it's going to mount. Missing information. Questioned the lighting. Does not think it needs to be lit. Cutone- agrees with Kuester. Would like to see more information and site proposed. Suggested providing a photo. Young-Not showing the direction of the armature. Wolf- no comment. Motion to hold for more information made by Kuester; seconded by Wolf. 4-0 Cutone, Kuester, Wolf and Young- aye Sign Advisory Council Comment Sheet Date: 5/4/21 Members present: Chris Young, Mark Cutone, Paul Wolf and Kevin Kuester Applicant: NIR,RETAIL- Representing: CAITLIN_COOKE; SIGN HERE NANTUCKET Address of proposed sign: 18A FEDERAL STREET Sign Name: POLLACKS Type of proposed sign ()Wall Mount ( X )Projecting ()Free standing( )Rock ( )Other Location (on property) of proposed sign: ( X )Entrance to building ( )Rear of building ( )Side elevation ( X )Other Comments/Recommendations: `'`Submitted revisions- Cooke- changed size and color of projecting sign, provided mock-up per previous concerns Koester-thinks the color might be light to read. Likes the sign Cutone- no concern Wolf- no comment Young- thinks it's appropriate as proposed Motion to Approve made by Wolf; seconded by Cutone. 4-0 Cutone, Kuester, Wolf and Young- aye Sign Advisory Council Comment Sheet Date: 5/4/21 Members present: Chris Young, Mark Cutone,Paul Wolf and Kevin Kuester Applicant: JAMES SIMINOFF Representing: CAITLIN_COOKE, SIGN HERE NANTUCKET Address of proposed sign: 15 WASHINGTON ST Sign Name: HANDLE BAR CAFE Type of proposed sign ( X)Wall Mount ( )Projecting ( )Free standing( )Rock ( )Other Location(on property) of proposed sign: ( X )Entrance to building ( )Rear of building ( )Side elevation ( )Other Comments/Recommendations: Cooke- presented application. New owners,new design and color, same name Young- asked if there were additional signage Wolf- no comment Kuester- concerned with miscellaneous freestanding signs in the past. Applicant needs to be aware of potential violations. Cutone- no comment Motion to Approve made by Wolf; seconded by Cutone. 4-0 Cutone, Kuester. Wolf and Young- aye