The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About2021-3-22 Approved Minutes March 22, 2021, adopted April 5, 2020 IL � lucre ,. ,o WI Historic District Commission 0 mac_: Madaket AdvisoryBoard co 3 rn CO Members: Linda Williams (Chair),Tom Erichsen,Brad Fleming, Robert Kucharavy-,Bruce Mandel Alternate: Mark Palmer MINUTES Monday March 22, 2021 This meeting was held via remote participation(using ZOOM recording feature) Pursuant to Governor Baker's March 12, 2020 Order Regarding fir Open MeetingLaw. I. Procedural Business Call to order. This meeting was conducted via Zoom and called to order by Bruce Mandel at 10:30 am. This meeting was recorded on Zoom video. Attending members: Linda Williams, Robert Kucharavy, Brad Fleming, Tom Erichsen and Bruce Mandel Absent members: Mark Palmer Late arrivals: None Early Departures: None Motion to Adopt Agenda made by Robert Kucharavy; Seconded by Brad Fleming . Roll Call Vote: carried unanimously 5-0//Fleming, Mandel, Kucharavy, Erichsen and Williams - aye Approval of Minutes: January 25, 2021 and March 01, 2021 Motion to Approve minutes of 1/25/21 and hold 3/1/21 for amendments made by Brad Fleming; Seconded by Robert Kucharavy. Roll Call Vote: carried unanimously 5-0//Fleming, Mandel, Erichsen, Williams and Kucharavy - aye Page 1 of 2 1 Approved Minutes March 22, 2021, adopted April 5, 2020 II. Public Comment None III. New Business—See attached Comment(s) Property owner name Street address Scope of work Map/Parcel Agent 1. Paul Piccirillo 6 Baltimore Street New dwelling 60/106 Val Oliver Design 2. Charles Schwarzapfel 9 Maine Ave Pool 60.3.1/425 NAG 3. John Wise 10 Starbuck Road Addition 59.3/62 Emeritus 4. Eric Needleman 6 Macy Road Pool-hardscape 60/144 Atlantic Landscaping IV. Other Business N/A V. Adjournment Motion to Adjourn made by Kucharavy; Seconded by Erichsen at 12:17 pm. Roll Call Vote: carried unanimously 5-0 Fleming, Mandel, Kucharavy. Erichsen and Williams-aye Submitted by Cathy Flynn Page 2 of 2 Madaket Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/MAB Date/Time 3/22/2021 To: Historic District Commission From: Madaket Advisory Board Members Present (X) Linda Williams-Chair(X) Brad Fleming (X )Tom Erichsen (X) Bruce Mandel(X)Robert Kucharavy Alternate: ( )Mark Palmer Applicant: Paul Piccirillo/Val Oliver Address: 6 Baltimore Street-New Dwelling Historic information/known history (X)Non-Contributing ( )Contributing ()Individually significant Comments O Incomplete application ()Historical information needed 0 No Concerns ()Recommend View O Does not meet guidelines ()Not appropriate (As noted below-) Recommendations: • Okay with Design features • Appreciates changes and previous concerns which were addressed • Massive and long for Madaket • Compared previous submissions for context; Suggest showing HDC the previous iterations to show progress. • Most are concerned with length and how fits in with massing and rural Madaket feeling • Fix stairway • Concerned with overall massing, particularly the length. Love to see it reduced a bit • Not in keeping with Madaket the rural RK/TE Public Comment None: Motion on recommendations: Motion to accept comments made by RK; Seconded by TE 5-0 Fleming,Erichsen,Kucharavy,Mandel and Williams-aye Madaket Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/MAB Date/Time 3/22/2021 To: Historic District Commission From: Madaket Advisory Board Members Present (X)Linda Williams-Chair(X) Brad Fleming ( X)Tom Erichsen (R) Bruce Mandel(X)Robert Kucharavy Alternate: ( )Mark Palmer Applicant: Charles Schwarzapfel Address: 9 Maine Ave-Pool Historic information/known history ( X)Non-Contributing ()Contributing ()Individually significant Comments O Incomplete application ()Historical information needed 0 No Concerns ()Recommend View O Does not meet guidelines (X)Not appropriate (As noted below) Recommendations: • Location of the lighting of the pool and the pool equipment • Does not fit the character of Smith's Point, out of context for the neighborhood • The visual impact of what has to be clone to screen the pool • Close proximity to Eel Skin Inn- historical character Public Comment Robert and Bonnie Havery, 6 Maine Ave- Suggested Screen from beach and NH Ave.Would like HDC to consider historic value of Eel Skin Inn. Pat Catchpole, 8 Maine Ave-not in context with area,pool lighting a concerned. Screening life span-Pool equipment location and pool lighting Andrea Baier: represents homeowner at 19 NH Ave. lighting and pool equipment location. Motion on Recommendations: Motion to accept comments made by RK; Seconded by TE 4-1 Fleming,Erichsen,Kucharavy and Williams-aye//Mandel-Recused Madaket Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum NDC/MAB Date/Time 3/22/2021 To: Historic District Commission From: Madaket Advisory Board Members Present (X) Linda Williams-Chair(X) Brad Fleming ( X)Tom Erichsen (R) Bruce Mandel(X)Robert Kucharavy Alternate: ( )Mark Palmer Applicant: John Wise Address: 10 Starbuck Road-_Addition Historic information/known history (X)Non-Contributing ()Contributing ()Individually significant Comments O Incomplete application ()Historical information needed (X)No Concerns ()Recommend View O Does not meet guidelines ()Not appropriate (As noted be/o,r) Recommendations: • Suggested changing all French doors to 6 Lite No concerns • Okay with 2/2 windows Public Comment Alan Schanser-no concerns Motion on Recommendations: Motion to accept comments made by RK; Seconded by TE 5-0 Fleming,Erichsen,Kucharavy,Mandel and Williams-aye Madaket Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/MAB Date/Time 3/22/2021 To: Historic District Commission From: Madaket Advisory Board Members Present (X) Linda Williams-Chair(X) Brad Fleming ( X)Tom Erichsen (X) Bruce Mandel(X)Robert Kucharavy Alternate: ( )Mark Palmer Applicant: Eric Needleman Address: 6 Macy Road-Pool Historic information/known history (X)Non-Contributing ()Contributing ()Individually significant Comments O Incomplete application ()Historical information needed 0 No Concerns ()Recommend View O Does not meet guidelines (X)Not appropriate (As noted be/G)t) Recommendations: • Pool and patio is not at grade-raised • Questioned about brown "fence" on site plan- is it a retaining wall? • Too much bluestone- Patio should be reduced • Pictures depict no visibility-One member says visible from Macy Road despite pics submitted. • Bluestone wall and cap inappropriate creates a formal environment- not"in keeping with Madaket" • Formality inappropriate in a rural setting- if visible, patio should be reduced and wall removed from NW side. Public Comment None Motion on recommendations: Motion to accept comments made by RK; Seconded by TE 5-0 Fleming,Erichsen,Kucharavy,Mandel and Williams-aye