HomeMy WebLinkAbout2020-10-20 V CLEF :-,
Town and County of Nantucket 2020 NOV 20 Ati 10: 17
ROADS AND RIGHT OF WAY COMMITTEE
Posted Meeting of 20 October 2020
Held by Zoom Videoconferencing
FINAL AND APPROVED MINUTES
1. Call to Order, Approval of the Agenda, Approval of Minutes,and Public Comments.
A. Chair Allen Reinhard called the meeting to order at 4:00 pm. In attendance were Rick
Atherton, Leslie Forbes, Ed Gillum, Bill Grieder, Allen Reinhard, and Lee Saperstein; there was
a quorum at all votes. All responded to an attendance roll call. The meeting was recorded and
can be viewed on You Tube.
Absent: Nelson(Snookie)Eldridge,Nat Lowell.
Guests: Ken Beaugrand Real Estate Specialist, Phil Smith
B. Approval of the Agenda. The agenda was approved unanimously by acclamation.
C. Public Comments; Officers' Comments.
There was no public comment.
D. Minutes. Approval of the minutes from September 15, 2020, was moved by Rick Atherton
and seconded by Bill Grieder. Unanimous approval was given by roll-call vote.
2. Priority Projects Update.
Allen Reinhard reviewed the progress that was made at the last meeting to identify ways that
need sidewalks and to draft a report to the Select Board,to whom we are advisors. There are six
ways listed in the draft report(attached) and four of them have plans that make them eligible for
the next steps in planning and funding.
Lee Saperstein reminded the committee that the report was created with the assistance of Andrew
Vorce, Planning Director, and Art Gasbarro, Chair, Traffic Safety Advisory Work Group. The
report will be shared with them and the Capital Program Committee for their information and
solicitation of support.
In discussion, Bill Grieder expressed concern about delays from the Town in developing
previously approved projects. Allen Reinhard said that this letter was dedicated to sidewalks and
multi-use paths. Leslie Forbes noted that the proposed work around Pleasant Street included
Williams Lane not the similarly named Williams Street. She asked about sidewalks that might
1
intrude onto private property and Lee Saperstein and Ken Beaugrand replied that the Planning
Department is negotiating with abutting landowners for easements. Rick Atherton noted that the
Lovers Lane project passed Annual Town Meeting but failed by a small margin on the ballot.
This comment caused a discussion on funding, what is available now and what will require Town
Meeting approval, and its impact on priorities. Allen Reinhard noted that the Downtown
Sidewalk Project has been funded and, with input from the Nantucket Historical Commission,
the DPW is working to rebuild sidewalks in the Downtown.
Lee Saperstein moved the adoption of the report, Bill Grieder seconded, and the motion passed
unanimously by roll-call vote. The edited report is attached to these minutes and, after review by
committee members will be submitted to the Town Manager. [Action. Submit report after the
November meeting.]
3. Washington Avenue Encroachments; Independent Way(formerly Coon Street) and
Pine Grove Road (aka Lane)for Possible Taking.
Allen Reinhard noted that Independent Way, the recently adopted name for the former Coon
Street, was a private way that had been treated by the Town as if it were public. The Town,
according to Ken Beaurgrand, would like for it to be public. It was noted that this one-block way
was in the Residential Old Historic District, ROH,where most ways are public Thence, Bill
Grieder moved that we recommend its taking, Rick Atherton seconded, and the motion passed
unanimously by roll-call vote. Lee Saperstein said that he would bring the takings spreadsheet
up to date(attached).
Next, Allen Reinhard brought up Pine Grove Road(aka Lane)because there had been a request
of the Town by abutting residents for its taking. Ken Beaugrand asked for the Committee's
advice and suggested that members visit the way. Ed Gillum noted that this was a private
development that had once opposed taking of the road by the Town. Ken Beaugrand said that he
would survey abutters to find out how many wanted a taking. Lee Saperstein offered to include
the way on the spread sheet for information before review at the next meeting. A map of the way
is attached.
Washington Avenue, noted Allen Reinhard, has been discussed in earlier meetings,particularly
over encroachments into the right of way and excess parking. He asked Ken Beaugrand to tell
the committee of progress made on these items. Ken Beaugrand reported that he had asked the
Traffic Safety Advisory Work Group to recommend no parking along the avenue up to its
intersection with 'E' Street and the work group concurred. The Select Board will hold a public
hearing on October 28th on the no-parking restriction. With respect to the encroachments,he had
found three major ones and believed that the owners would remedy them. Leslie Forbes asked
what constituted "major" and he replied that they were all landscaping; no structures encroached
on the right of way.
4. Chapter 91 License Monitoring System.
2
Allen Reinhard asked Rick Atherton if he had had a response from the Department of Natural
Resources on our questions about Chapter 91 Licenses. "Unfortunately, no."was the response.
Rick Atherton then suggested that our next invitation to the Department be in writing and Allen
Reinhard agreed. [Action. Allen Reinhard to write to DNR asking then to attend a committee
meeting to review the status of the chapter 91 program on Nantucket.]
5. Member Comments, Old, New and Other Business: Outstanding Projects List; Historic
Coloured Cemetery Access.
There were no member comments,however, Allen Reinhard gave news of the construction of a
ramp into the Historic Coloured Cemetery from the Hospital parking area. After reconstruction
of the helipad,the hospital has arranged with Victor, the local paving company, to complete the
ramp. When that happens, this item will come off the agenda.
It was mentioned during a call for new business that new fencing along Surfside Road at
Hatikvah Way(opposite the Indian Burial Ground)may be an encroachment. Ken Beaugrand
promised to look at it to see if there was problem.
6. Adjourn,
Adjourn: The meeting was adjourned at 5:10 pm by motion from Leslie Forbes, a second from
Lee Saperstein, and a unanimous roll-call vote. Our next meeting will be held on November 17,
2020.
Lee W. Saperstein, Secretary Date
Roads and Right of Way Outstanding Projects List:
Public Way Monument Project: (Lee&Allen & Snookie)
• Install remaining monuments at Sconset Footpath, Hulbert Ave.
• Update file of existing monuments
• Move monuments at Westchester St. Ext. &Crooked Lane
Sidewalk Projects: (Allen)
• Prospect St. (bike path to Upper Vestal St.) and on to Madaket bike path
• Cliff Rd. Coffin Park to bike path at Sherburne Tpk.
• Pleasant St. Gardner Perry Lane to Williams St.
• Follow implementation of downtown sidewalk improvements
• Bike/Pedestrian connection from Surfside to Hummock Pond to Madaket paths
Harbor Walk Project: (Rick)
3
• Identify route and identify sections needing constructed walkway
• Concept drawings of construction required
• List permits and approvals needed and process to obtain
• Funding
Chapter 91 Monitor Project: (Leslie& Lee)
• Define goals for project
• Make local license information available on line
• Chapter 91 licenses along route for the Harbor Walk
• Locate other locations on Nantucket and Madaket Harbors requiring licenses
Nantucket Greenway and Trail System Project: (Allen and Lee)
• Nantucket Central Rail Road trail
• Map existing island trail and footpath systems and identify missing links
• How should maps and information be shared?
4
MEMORANDUM:
FROM: Nantucket Committee on Roads and Right of Way, Allen Reinhard,
Chair
TO: Libby Gibson, Town Manager, for the Select Board
Copy: Art Gasbarro, Chair, Traffic Safety Work Group, Stephen Welch,
Chair, Capital Program Committee, Andrew Vorce, Planning Director, and
Rob McNeil, Director, DPW
The Roads and Right of Way Committee has undertaken a project to identify critical missing
sidewalks and to make recommendations for sidewalks on Town properties where no sidewalk
currently exists. This creates situations where pedestrians are forced to walk in the trafficked
roadway. We have identified six specific areas in or leading to the downtown area:
• Prospect Street from the end of the multi-use path past the hospital to Joy Street, (then
repairing the sidewalk from Joy Street to Upper Vestal Street).
• The bicycle path/sidewalk connector to the Miacomet bike path beginning at the North
Mill Street entrance to Mill Hill Park, thence to Old Farm Rd.
• Pleasant Street from Gardner Perry Lane to Williams Lane.
• Cliff Road from the end of the multi-use path to connect with the sidewalk opposite
Coffin Park.
• North Liberty Street from Derrymore Road to Cliff Road.
• Lovers Lane bike path.
A discussion among Art Gasbarro, Andrew Vorce, Allen Reinhard and Lee Saperstein, with
suggestions from Rob McNeil, considered which of these areas had a plan and survey showing a
solution to create sidewalks or bike paths. We found that there are plans on file for three of these
areas: 1. Prospect Street to Joy Street; 2. The Mill Hill bike path; and 3. The Lovers Lane bike
path and road reconstruction, which was narrowly defeated at ATM. We also are aware of a plan
to connect the historic downtown area with mid-town via Pleasant Street and Sparks Avenue.
Based on this information, especially as plans currently exist for each of these areas, we felt the
priority order of these projects should be as follows:
1. Pleasant Street and Sparks Avenue sidewalks including the missing section from Gardner
Perry Lane to Williams Lane.
2. Prospect Street/Mill Hill multi-use path through Mill Hill to Joy Street (the approved
Bracken Plan).
5
3. Prospect Street sidewalk from the end of bike path to Joy Street and possible reconstruction
of sidewalks to Upper Vestal Street.
4. The multi-use path on Lovers Lane connecting Old South Road and Boulevarde.
Each of these areas has an existing survey plan available. Each of these connections would
greatly improve the safety of pedestrians and bicycles and traffic flow in these key areas.
We urge the Select Board to consider these plans positively and to develop funding resources to
implement these plans.
6
POTENTIAL ROAD TAKINGS LIST,As of September 2018
Traversable Access to
Road Status, Public Use Road links Public by Public Traffic
Public(pub)or of this Two Public Safety Emergency Abutters' Property Circulation Other Benefits to the General
Order Road Private(pvt) Road Roads Concerns Vehicles Requests Including Patterns Public;Comments
Amelia was private but has been
taken;Ticcoma(to Fairgrounds)is
public. Expanding commercial
developments and narrow
roadways limit two-way traffic and
suggest that improvements to
these roads is appropriate.The
committee may wish to advise on
Amelia Drive and parking,trafice flow,and even
1 Ticcoma Way pvt/pub Yes Yes Moderate Moderate Yes No Heavy road widening.
Taking private portion and
rebuilding will provide public
access around Quaker Cemetery to
beach bike paths,which is a high
priority. Private portion of Winn
St.is narrow and this may affect
2 Winn Street pvt/pub Yes Yes Moderate Difficult Yes No Moderate ability to rebuild it.
Drainage and maintenance
problems;input from abutters;
Somerset DPW concerns that drainage fixes
Road/Friendship should be comprehensive to be
3 Lane complex pvt Yes Yes Moderate Difficult Yes,%age No Light effective.
Warren's Landing Light to Access to Warren's Landing and Eel
4 Road pvt Yes Yes Slight Moderate Yes,FLA Yes moderate Point;Fisher's Landing Assn Letter
Stone Alley is an historic
pedestrian way captured in many
historic paintings. It is uesd by
residents on the alley and by
visitors to the island.Town
maintenance would improve the
look of the alley and increase its
5 Stone Alley pvt Yes Yes Yes No Yes No heavy safe use.
A taking will provide public ccess
to New North Cemetery including
control of parking alongside entry
6 Franklin Street pvt Yes Yes No Yes Yes,CemeYes Light point.
Independent Way,formerly Coon
Street,is an historic street that,
somehow,was left off the 1799
listing of streets.Although a
private way,the Town has
maintained it and now suggests
strongly that it should be taken as
7 Independent Way pvt Yes Yes limited Yes Yes no light a public way
yes,
percenta
ge not Abuters,noting poor condition of
establish abutters to road,have asked for the Town
8 Pine Grove Road pvt limited no yes limited ed no only to take it an maintain it.
7
Town and County of Nantucket,MA Oc ber 23,2020
Pine Grove Road
7R'• .r.: 4,yr
kSL rf" i Hl iA]
o 44,
i rt • 47 7`-� 3tlf - � t
4-P 4AI
Y f« 444' ,r1.401.11, 40...„
YS+ 0
� tCl.xxa.psr_ i * ., b. Ii ..741?'
•
c.a '7 4,� t 1 i -4,,,, - asp
S iia . ] ;lg.�,1._^^ d. r� Si, 'A�1
f *4c it
.1:- r--•%- "i ,-1.1z,-Y St 0 rii ,i ' ..„ ,
7 , ire tib. *04
lio
2441
D'
'''t
s to
it "2
-i,'--L, a ..
2L21 ¢7 ♦ t:
yto y. f
•
1•013' 41
d r01
't
'rY" i p -q a
t.a t
,^tilik Q �_�
Y n t:ir ?� c.La
S
^- t V '. ''I'i
' i r=242k
,,:;3:114k.A
r#
+q AA FoR REFERENCE ONLY
NOT A L.EGA1..DOCUMENT
%ern wGblellr MMOZrR AA MOM 06 6000*are ae
+afwedaAegraraMatopMOmttwgr .
8