Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout2019-12-9 rc Approved Minutes December 9, 2019; Adopted February 24, 2020 r + ! N U L 21120FEB25 M# 11: i \c�9ie�8A Historic District Commission Historic Structures Advisory Board Members: Micky Rowland,Lucy Dillon,Jascin Finger,Angus Macleod,Brook Meerbergen Alternate Member: None Planning and Land Use Services 2 Fairgrounds Road Nantucket,Massachusetts 02554 MINUTES Monday December 9, 2019 I. Procedural Business Call to order at 3:32 pm Attending members: Angus Macleod,Lucy Dillon, Mickey Rowland,Jascin Leonardo-Finger, Brook Meerbergen Absent members: Late arrivals:Jascin Leonardo-Finger (3:46pm) Early Departures: Angus Macleod (5:00pm) Motion to Adopt Agenda made by Lucy Dillon; Seconded by Mickey Rowland Vote: carried unanimously Approval of Minutes: N/A No vote taken. Page 1 of 2 Approved Minutes December 9, 2019; Adopted February 24, 2020 II. Public Comment None. III. New Business—See attached Comments Property Owner Street Street Address Scope of Work Map/Parcel Agent 1. Nelson,Scott 12 Hussey Street Like-kind window replcmnt 42.3.4-133 Normand Residential 2. Tamsen,Merrill 27 Hulbert Avenue Fence 29-24 Self 3. Town of Nantucket 20 S. Water Street Water station 42.4.2-29 Erica Mooney 4. 17 Lily Street,LLC 17 Lily Street As-built spa 42.4.3-43 Permits Plus 5. Falconer,Tracy 3 Silver Street Clapboard color change 55.4.1-129 Self 6. First Bap Church 1 Summer Street Front door change 42.3.3-70 Russel Simpson 7. Ickes Harold N Tr Etal 33 Milk Street Chg windws to double doors 41-458 JB Studio 8. Nant.Dreamland 17 S. Water Street Hardscape-park 42.31-11.1 Joe Hale 9. Greenspon,Robert 53 Easton Street Open porch addition 42.4.1-85 JMS Architecture 10. Diserio,Mat 16 N.Liberty Street Window/door alteration 42.3.4-40 Val Oliver 11. Kelsey,Holly 16 Grove Lane Rev 71245;A/C cond/steps 41-442 Concept Design 12. Kelsey,Holly 16 Grove Lane Hardscape 41-442 Concept Design 13. 8 Hulbert Ave,LLC 8 Hulbert Avenue Addition/lift house 29.2.3-7.2 Mark Cutone Architecture 14. Remain Nantucket 10 Washington Street Water refill station 42.3.1-142 Self 15. Copley,Group,LLC 59 Orange Street Outdoor shower 42.3.2-37.1 Jo Olson 16. One North Beach St,LLC 1 N Beach Street Trash area 42.4.1-89 Shelter 7 17. 16 Orange St,LLC 16 Orange Street Remove spa 42.3.2-14 Sconset Gardner 18. 18 Orange St,LLC 18 Orange Street New spa 42.3.2-15 Sconset Gardner 19. Burke,Robert 102 Main Street Replace chimney 42.3.2-159 Linda Williams 20. Howard Auburn Cottage 46 Easton Street Demo/move dwelling 42.4.1-22 Linda Williams 21. Ottavino,Mary 13 North Star Lane Relocate pool 30-206 Linda Williams 22. Cohen,Steven L Tr 72 Main Street Exterior lighting 42.3.1-152 Self Motion to approve comments from New Business items 1 —22 Motion made by Lucy Dillon; Seconded by Mickey Rowland Vote: Carried unanimously IV. Other Business V. Adjournment Motion to Adjourn made by Mickey Rowland; Seconded by Lucy Dillon at 5:37pm. Vote: Carried unanimously. Submitted by Kadeem McCarthy Page 2 of 2 Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB Date/Time ?-v( 3i°1/ To: Historic District Commission From: Historic Structures Advisory Board M- bers Present 4 i gus MacLeod 7Gucy Dillon ( )Jascin Leonardo Finger on Rowland (rook Meerbergen Alternate:None Applicant . 4.ua Address ( Historic information/lcnown history (alp( .2.) ���-�,}— Vv -�- i,�,. 44-1 -o --- \9 lo-5 ()Non-Contributing ()Contributing ()Individually significant Comments ()Incomplete application ()Historical information needed ()No Concerns ()Recommend View ()Does not meet guidelines ()Not appropriate (As noted below) North Elevation East Elevation West Elevation South Elevation Other CAA, !SpAo-e.P I. t:LA .raj �J 6 den_ 7u`i k ` f3 �_ Gipt a9 .nom 142-4-0-.ff -v".( U 5 _ ty►.. t5 w� �a '�S Public Co nt Cai-•O 14 t5er�*�.vsSLA Signatures ��� A — Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB Date/Time la 9 2...c)(01 c..41.4,. To: Historic District Commission From: Historic Structures Advisory Board Members Present ngus MacLeoducy Dillon ( )Jascin Leonardo Finger Milton Rowland (Brook Meerbergen Alternate:None / ` Applicant 7LIA,k44, l :4Address Historic information/known history ()Non-Contributing 0)Contributing 0)Individually significant Comments ()Incomplete application ()Historical information needed ()No Concerns ()Recommend View ()Does not meet guidelines ()Not appropriate (As noted below) North Elevation East Elevation West Elevation South Elevation Other IQ0 CL–cr-r\-0-12A--,> Public Comment Sitee members reguir 'Y V0"; II .,,.. .a Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB Date/Time j`.t-n To: Historic District Commission From: Historic Structures Advisory Board Members Present Angus MacLeod ( ,ucy Dillon �f rascin Leonardo Finger) Milton Rowland rook Meerbergen Altdrrn'a"te:None ApplicantT(5-w-1,,_‘,6fl( Jb2± Address 00 -j ltDa." .‘_, Historic information/known history ()Non-Contributing ()Contributing ()Individually significant Comments ()Incomplete application ()Historical information needed Concerns 0)Recommend View ()Does not meet guidelines ()Not appropriate (As noted below) North Elevation East Elevation West Elevation South Elevation Other Public Comment ,,,,, ,:-.-60A1" . tt"..)k----- <-131-h/1 Signa ee me �� /Tuiini) �/�nr --/Itt-7 — i Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB Date/Time 201 7%57 To: Historic District Commission From: Historic Structures Advisory Board Members Present /eCCAngus MacLeoducy Dillon ascin Leonardo Finger RCMilton Rowland Brook Meerbergen Alternate:None Applicant (-7— l,.l .t� �t Address (1--- L1 L-c Historic information/known history 1 ()Non-Contributing ()Contributing ()Individually significant Comments ()Incomplete application ()Historical information needed 0)No Concerns ()Recommend View ()Does not meet guidelines ()Not appropriate (As noted below) North Elevation East Elevation West Elevation South Elevation Other GEsc ke.�7 13t3,-k►-3t W I k) 5tt iAiK1 0 Public Comment Sat SpA_reS(three member, f j •"e r 4! /� 104-- `J ., a Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/H SAB Date/Time . _v. •ld0 To: Historic District Commission From: Historic Structures Advisory Board Members Present rngus MacLeod '�,iLucy Dillon Jascin Leonardo Finger ilton Rowland ,Q rook Meerbergen Alt mate:None Applicant .... - 17,,C !L,L..411 Addressu}-rr_{Z _ Historic information/known history ()Non-Contributing ()Contributing ()Individually significant Comments 0)Incomplete application ()Historical information neededNp Concerns 0)Recommend View ()Does not meet guidelines ()Not appropriate (As noted below) North Elevation East Elevation West Elevation South Elevation Other Public Comment z' , �' ,(three m m ,IZ /W) ( 1/�I7 A' 0, r Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB Date/Time 0 Z O1 q r o To: Historic District Commission From: Historic Structures Advisory Board Members Present •b CAngus MacLeod 4Lucy Dillon lascin Leonardo Finger ton Rowland >e3rook Meerbergen ternate:None Applicant T l�L Y�1 k1 r ve*j- Address _'au Historic information/known history 0)Non-Contributing ()Contributing ()Individually significant Comments 0)Incomplete application ()Historical information needed ()No Concerns ()Recommend View ()Does not meet guidelines ()Not appropriate (As noted below) North Elevation East Elevation West Elevation $ South Elevation Other _rte _ e- 44/ s _ — 4-- �brst2-- l.E . -S 1S .A0 loPa9 tJ-rcir b &C,Z?17 Public Comment `QIN Signatures(three mem ryr�q r Ac7 /I/\ Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB Date/Time e-e___ • O If 't 0.1-' To: Historic District Commission From: Historic Structures Advisory Board Members Present ;(0c--Angus MacLeod `'Lucy Dillon" Jascin Leonardo Finger Ilton Rowland rook Meerbergen Alternate:None Applicant 1.„ f.-2,ak-e e tQ-- - , '1 Address 3 M i L —. Historic information/known history c2-6Ps 0)Non-Contributing ()Contributing ()Individually significant Comments 0)Incomplete application ()Historical information needed ()No Concerns ()Recommend View ()Does not meet guidelines ()Not appropriate (As noted below) North Elevation East Elevation West Elevation South Elevation Other t P.--6.r -F--e-f--........Y,4-k, v u`►/TiCI, isl4-0-Nevt,�Yi N Dm-JS t') Ptertr-5_Ac'P r-k�- l - . ":-..•_?_ 11-- V_► _ ..._.PItit. it.V.1.-- _,► - %..out 41 _ " M.-. s 111.1111i.af _.!_ 1d- r. Public Comment ` �� l ? , c (' , r Signatures(three of ,126 'u• 'f , .0.„,,,,,,,,,,,„,„,..41--21,- Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB Date/Timed / , • -01 To: Historic District Commission From: Historic Structures Advisory Board Members Present 1>CJAngus MacLeod Lucy Dillon Jascin Leonardo Finger/Milton Rowland Kc7Brook Meerbergen Al ernate:None / Applicant J AtkL,<p Address `J, Historic information/known history ()Non-Contributing ()Contributing ()Individually significant Comments ()Incomplete application ()Historical information needed ()No Concerns 0)Recommend View ()Does not meet guidelines ()Not appropriate (As noted below) North Elevation East Elevation West Elevation South Elevation (0E 15 3A+01%'652.4.3E (7,w(ai-c"'. 0.0.? Other s t-MnY; A 60(W4,T 7.16(Aree—, eV E 2- o GI lZr—UC..' cxp • off..Dc i ' Th est 01 14,1 1 Public Comm n p . 6(utt. /10#f //, i1 matures(three me i•-�`./,•J r-, i'l Avi/� nn/2 _ Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB Date/Time l To: Historic District Commission From: Historic Structures Advisory Board Members Present MacLeod d Lucy Dillon Jascin Leonardo Finger J0 Milton Rowland rook Meerbergen 7cAnus Alternate:None Applicant,...:0,_ __.A,. _ L. Ji Address t5 _, .77)),) Historic information/known history 0)Non-Contributing 0)Contributing ()Individually significant Comments 0)Incomplete application 0)Historical information needed 'No Concerns 0)Recommend View ()Does not meet guidelines ()Not appropriate (As noted below) North Elevation East Elevation West Elevation South Elevation Other a id�...w. -1/f_11 . 4.4 's . 11 GNP _ - _ ..0 A ri _ '...E Public Comment . r i r ie // //e �vr� ..,_ _._ .? go iet gf6I---- C_Stu -4077-40774- :;rs`e " res(three � •r 14 / Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB 5= otp Date/Time /_j/, _2,,19 To: Historic District Commission From: Historic Structures Advisory Board Members Present /f ( )Angus MacLeod ucy Dillon ( cm Leonardo Finger ( Ilton Rowland rook Meerbergen Alternate:None • Applicant 1 � rJ f,y Address I (p 12.e)(1 ]G Historic information/known history ()Non-Contributing ()Contributing ()Individually significant Comments ()Incomplete application ()Historical information needed ()No Concerns ()Recommend View ()Does not meet guidelines ()Not appropriate (As noted below) North Elevation East Elevation West Elevation South Elevation Other. N -17 ratA'1zoN G GT1o+N`� if-S4 ttoc4 V4 u 1'9101i-411f VP-3)( ,r7L( 7a lett() t ` t 447Fe 4-1-1 U'C_ vteme-- '/€ 5 P- e-r/t-/(?W/of/. Public Comment r Signatures(three mem..'r , • •r/ • ) .1111101 y Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB Date/Time OP- v ; 051) To: Historic District Commission From: Historic Structures Advisory Board Members Present > /Anus MacLeod ,Lucy Dillon gJascin Leonardo Finger Milton Rowland ,Brook Meerbergen Alternate:None Applicantof Wrr' Address ( ), Historic information/known history ()Non-Contributing ()Contributing ()Individually significant Comments ()Incomplete application 0)Historical information needed ()No Concerns ()Recommend View ()Does not meet guidelines ()Not appropriate (As noted below) North Elevation East Elevation West Elevation South Elevation Other 17e4-, V 1 Public Comment I i 111# /647 jitu1/4„ \i„), vAtpt,Sriegres(three v ,ers r -4zred or quorum) 117)Z t. II v.: Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB Date/Time Y&�y 76� S=a1 To: Historic District Commission From: Historic Structures Advisory Board Members Present (Angus MacLeod Lucy Dillonk5Jascin Leonardo Finger Milton Rowland rook Meerbergen Alt rnate:None Applicant k<F i( m( Address ' Historic information/known history ()Non-Contributing ()Contributing ()Individually significant Comments ()Incomplete application ()Historical information needed ()No Concerns ()Recommend View ()Does not meet guidelines ()Not appropriate (As noted below) North Elevation East Elevation West Elevation South Elevation Other • � R �-tA��N 12' i ‘ C412.. -ii Public Comment /1Qfr, /, ,„ S atllIeS(three membe ,re y, ) . ��' l/ �'Ch r/(/1 1111Ye Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB Date/Time ve f`�i 2t(c, 5 l 4- • To: Historic District Commission From: Historic Structures Advisory Board embers Present gus MacLeod ,kNO Lucy Dillon ' 4 Jascin Leonardo Finger Milton Rowland (rook Meerbergen Alternate:None Applicant j jir,e2r_l_L_ _ Address j3 Hut 43E424-- Historic information/lmown history ()Non-Contributing ()Contributing ()Individually significant Comments ()Incomplete application ()Historical information needed ()No Concerns ()Recommend View ()Does not meet guidelines ()Not appropriate (As noted below) North Elevation • ceu --S4-z5vuL7 µekVs_nom- �-r- E.1.4-r 40'3 East Elevation nt tit. West Elevation --O CF, Q SoIluuuth Elevation / ' `l y a Other ^7 >4 .• '-.. tat......'_ A'4 i..- Public Comment -...._ ' 1/4,—.11. 140 attires(three m m"i f. to (fit.0---1- Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB f Date/Time -e ,, zo(U) ' 0 To: Historic District Commission From: Historic Structures Advisory Board Members Present ( )Angus MacLeod ( )Lucy Dillon ( )Jascin Leonardo Finger ( )Milton Rowland ( )Brook Meerbergen Alternate:None Applicant � ,� Address i0 kit/14-1151c Historic information/known history ()Non-Contributing ()Contributing ()Individually significant Comments ()Incomplete application ()Historical information needed t)No Concerns ()Recommend View ()Does not meet guidelines ()Not appropriate (As noted below) North Elevation East Elevation West Elevation South Elevation Other 9 �� .%° _:0if_ _.__AL Ids, if Public Comment \---1). Ow jari1/4Cr..._ /, , , , , (.4 i es(three y m Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB Date/Time V.A, /, 20 (42 To: Historic District Commission From: Historic Structures Advisory Board Members Present gMacLeod Lucy Dillon Jascin Leonardo Finger Milton Rowland Brook Meerbergen p&\nus Alternate:None Applicant (c00..,,,.{ 47 LLC_., Address C7Q,,,,Gr_ Historic information/lmown history ()Non-Contributing ()Contributing ()Individually significant Comments ()Incomplete application ()Historical information needed ()No Concerns ()Recommend View ()Does not meet guidelines ()Not appropriate (As noted below) North Elevation East Elevation West Elevation South Elevation Other A) , — _/ —_-ft _ 1- �` " .:fir — Mt-1/4k f �i t-1�_�■ • Public Comment Si a three mem:• ', z ,i /// \s, racitA___P Astcyl 1(11......._..\.„1-'. Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB Date/Time To: Historic District Commission From: Historic Structures Advisory Board Members Present Angus MacLeod 41 ucy Dillon Jascin Leonardo Finger Milton Rowland 'Brook Meerbergen Al ernate:None Applicant \� - La.., Address f 30i-i- Historic information/known history ()Non-Contributing ()Contributing ()Individually significant Comments ()Incomplete application ()Historical information needed o Concerns ()Recommend View ()Does not meet guidelines ()Not appropriate (As noted kw) North Elevation East Elevation West Elevation46tr-L ss WWC_C2,1kY6' South Elevation tvallt-E4 Other r 11-5 D I i-t N.!\ Public Comment Si atures(three ,e. ,ut/ f, a Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB Date/Time ?fL. i , 2o(I To: Historic District Commission From: Historic Structures Advisory Board i e, bers Present /.4'Angus MacLeod 1Lucy Dillon Jascin Leonardo Finger Milton Rowland )Q Brook Meerbergen Alt mate:None / Applicantj(rj e_ S-i—Z(.(___ Address t( O F Historic information/known history ()Non-Contributing ()Contributing ()Individually significant Comments ()Incomplete application ()Historical information neededo Concerns ()Recommend View ()Does not meet guidelines ()Not appropriate (As noted below) North Elevation East Elevation West Elevation South Elevation Other Public Comment S•'a:. es(three meAill i-.p �i 2 �—.1 /� / / Jry// 1li)itm,{1..wdo i Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB Date/Time-VW 1, 2.6(0? iP I To: Historic District Commission From: Historic Structures Advisory Board Members Present *ngus MacLeod `Lucy Dillon gIascin Leonardo Finger Milton Rowland ;(Brook Meerbergen / _ Alternate:None • Applicant 1E13 Address t Historic information/known history ()Non-Contributing ()Contributing ()Individually significant Comments ()Incomplete application ()Historical information needed ()No Concerns ()Recommend View ()Does not meet guidelines ()Not appropriate (As noted below) North Elevation East Elevation West Elevation South Elevation Other ,„■ ill r QL.`” mfr' l GI _ a 6.11 - ✓ I t•t-T �rW Pt/`SG l 1 • tempt NU wtt_lr ga- -8" e Public Comment (factAilfte'111°40'k-fkr3N- Signatures Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB Date/Time („cgC.—G, 2.d 1, To: Historic District Commission From: Historic Structures Advisory Board embers Present gus MacLeod (<Q,ucy Dillonascin Leonardo Finger Milton Rowland J•$rook Meerbergen Alt mate:None / ((��\ Applicantr',CAt-C- �. Address /0-2 11/44,04 Historic information/known history ()Non-Contributing ()Contributing ()Individually significant Comments ()Incomplete application ()Historical information needed ()No Concerns ()Recommend View ()Does not meet guidelines ()Not appropriate (As noted below) North Elevation East Elevation West Elevation South Elevation Other LiA4,e,70Alt MADIzTA Public Comment QIP 1312 1b tk-k-4) � ( N�d�1t���t�tU�Fx� QCr�S A Cry 1. et r• �t C— "ACik 1 tJ H �)V rr t ( KsA42e_s, '/ ' 41 Kik/ (71 rsigahlres(three membe i• •, mn P Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB Date/Time Pe....e__ / `2ef)t 9 To: Historic District Commission From: Historic Structures Advisory Board Members Present Angus MacLeod Lucy DillonfAcJascin Leonardo Finger Milton Rowland rook Meerbergen Alternate:None Applicant .0.,_ .;. JET !t „`i Address 105 e-4‘-jr-em) &'\ Historic information/known history ()Non-Contributing ()Contributing ()Individually significant . °(144-) 0 /1;1/ 11-0 Comments ()Incomplete application 0)Historical information needed ()No Concerns ()Recommend View \. ()Does not meet guidelines ()Not appropriate (As noted below) North Elevation East Elevation West Elevation South Elevation 116* c. Other is P /qa `- �`-re, (/� GL -6 v r h , ”/ # aJeJ if 6C LAT , /• Nirpli ,40 os*L DK '7v fG0447€ oN S 17-6 Public Comment 1 i/ �` /I/ ` Gr 0Vli� ,� // ( `x 4( ee me be s equir•d for quorum) t) j Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB Date/Time 9 , 2-0 2 2 To: Historic District Commission From: Historic Structures Advisory Board Members Present Angus MacLeod ucy DillonXJascin Leonardo Finger ;Milton Rowland rook Meerbergen Alt rnate:None Applicanta-Vl X11."1,,1 (k-Akigi Address Historic information/lcnown history ()Non-Contributing ()Contributing ()Individually significant Comments ()Incomplete application ()Historical information needed No Concerns ()Recommend View ()Does not meet guidelines ()Not appropriate (As noted below) North Elevation East Elevation West Elevation South Elevation Other Public Comment a (61/41(A\-1 Rf,Frr�/ / J/(three me // 04,-------- ^ Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB Date/Timer-D.0'e 9 2-O c` '27G. To: Historic District Commission From: Historic Structures Advisory Board Members Present ( )Angus MacLeod ucy Dillonascin Leonardo Finger ,( Milton Rowland cM,Brook Meerbergen Alternate:None Applicant r fi i�1�5 Address r-' l Historic information/known history ()Non-Contributing ()Contributing ()Individually significant Comments ()Incomplete application ()Historical information needed ()No Concerns ()Recommend View ()Does not meet guidelines ()Not appropriate (As noted below) North Elevation East Elevation West Elevation South Elevation Other 1...0, +._la 'J •__moi -1L . .1 _.1'._40?._40? F. _moi ti __, •I L` t Public Comment 1 P------------ Signatures(three me /.- : ' ' '/• s,-� 1 le- t