Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout2019-9-23 TC Approved Minutes September 23, 2019; Adopted November 4, 2019 i. .....„ ,ti9i. ilk; N' r..... �J. vo ;..„,.. Historic District Commission -0 r_ r Historic Structures Advisory Board w Members:Micky Rowland,Lucy Dillon,Jascin Finger,Angus Macleod,Brook Meerbergen Alternate Member: Michael May Planning and Land Use Services 2 Fairgrounds Road Nantucket,Massachusetts 02554 MINUTES Monday, Sept 23, 2019 I. Procedural Business Call to order at 3:30 Attending members: Michael May,Mickey Rowland,Brook Meerbergen Absent members: Jascin Leonardo-Finger,Angus Macleod,Lucy Dillon Late arrivals: Early Departures: None. Motion to Adopt Agenda made by Mickey Rowland;Seconded by Michael May Vote: carried unanimously Approval of Minutes: N/A II. Public Comment None. Page 1 of 2 Approved Minutes September 23, 2019; Adopted November 4, 2019 III. New Business—See attached Comments Property Owner Street Street Address Scope of Work Map/Parcel Agent 1. Yeager,David 2 Howard Court Rev 72494;windows 42.3.4-36.1 Brook Meerbergen 2. 12 Lincoln Avenue N.T. 12 Lincoln Avenue Demo garage 30-183 Emeritus 3. 12 Lincoln Ave N.T. 12 Lincoln Avenue Garage 30-183 Emeritus 4. 12 Lincoln Ave N.T. 12 Lincoln Avenue Cabana 30-183 Emeritus 5. Schneider,Peggy 5 Martin's Lane Driveway 42.3.2-132 Mark Avery 6. Mueller Nantucket Assoc 34 Prospect Street Addition 55.4.4-77 CWA 7. Mueller Nantucket Assoc 34 Prospect Street Garage 55.4.4-77 CWA 8. Nelson, Scott 12 Hussey Street Remove rear chimney 42.3.4-133 Normand Residential Design 9. Taylor,Kimberly 76 Easton Street Retaining wall 42.4.1-33 Self 10. Virtue,Steve 39 Pleasant Street Move window 55.4.1-154 Joseph Olson 11. Winer,Elizabeth 34 Cliff Road Rev 72157;addition 42.4.4-47 Botticelli&Pohl 12. Kelly,Brian 1 Highland Avenue Addition 30-609 Emeritus 13. Raith,Jon 14 Easy Street Window revisions 42.3.1-13 Emeritus 14. Hulbert ACK,LLC 2 Hulbert Avenue Rev 72094;MH drmr/wind 42.1.4-2.1 Sophie Metz Design 15. Hulbert ACK,LLC 2 Hulbert Avenue Rev 72095;GH drmr/wind 42.1.4-2.1 Sophie Metz Design 16. Yates,Gary 21B Vestal Street New dwelling 41-36.1 Sophie Metz Design 17. Dean,Kevin 51 Pleasant Street Shed 55-32.3 Structures Unlimited 18. Bergantino,Joseph 11 E.Lincoln Avenue Raise house to flood 42.4.1-7 Sanne Payne 19. 103 Main Street,LLC 103 Main Street Demo chimney 42.3.3-153 JB Studio Motion to approve comments from New Business items 1 — 19 Motion made by Mickey Rowland;Seconded by Michael May. Vote: Carried unanimously IV. Other Business V. Adjournment Motion to Adjourn made by Mickey Rowland;Seconded by Michael May at 5:03pm. Vote: Carried unanimously. Submitted by Kadeem McCarthy Page 2of2 1 1 Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB 1 f t Date/Time 69 1 J - �j /70 1 z To: Historic District Commission From: Historic Structures Advisory Board M7? g Present gus MacLeod ( )Lucy Dillon ( )J eonardo Finger ( )Milton Rowland/Brook Meerbergen Alternate: 'chael May ApplicantYP,-5114e--e..__ Address2.- 1 ? P ( at ) -s Historic information/known history 0)Non-Contributing ()Contributing ()Individually significant Comments 0)Incomplete application 0)Historical information needed No Concerns•. ()Recommend View ()Does not meet guidelines ()Not appropriate (As noted elms) 1 North Elevation 8 i East Elevation West Elevation I 1 1 1 South Elevation F 1 1 Other , i I Public Comment f i F z a Signatures(three members required forq .• )/' i 1 - _ - lt:". i 4 Historic Structures Advisory Board MeetingMenzoranduna HDC/HSAB Date/ .2-771()Date/11=0? 3 : VS'To: Historic District Commission From: Historic Structures Advisory Board Members Present 2,5: • i gas MacLeod ()Lucy Dillon ()Jascin Leonardo Finger 'ton Rowland Brook Meerbergen AlternateMichael May / Applicant K3C-Dt461 Address :12 L ttQC0.ld yn 0 /1 Historic information/known history ► Non-Contributing ()Contributing ()Jndividcuallllyy significant 51,vw_6(6A-4—et__ ci Comments 0)Incomplete application ()Historical information needed ()No Concerns 0)Recommend View 4.41%.:44-6.3 641 ()Does not meet guidelines ()Not appropriate (Os noted below) North Elevation East Elevation West Elevation South Elevation Other lAt�v�- S/��1 . • Public Comment Sig 'S(three members required for quorum) Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB Date/Time O 0 [ 2-3 tC? To: Historic District Commission From: Historic Structures Advisory Board Members Present '\(\s)Angus MacLeod ( )Lucy Dillon ( )Jascin Leonardo Finger Milton Rowland )rook Meerbergen Alternate. Michael May Applicant L Address [2- LAay.J (6a;ria,4 Historic information/known history ()Non-Contributing ()Contributing 0)Individually significant Comments ()Incomplete application 0)Historical information needed ()No Concerns ()Recommend View 0)Does not meet guidelines ()Not appropriate (As noted below) North Elevation e p . / c� t7Q�►t,2S �-.- r. 1,e/7n-5 Cr��2. �r �. f..t�K� • • /.. ! _ _ ._ — L • .ire . - East Elevation West Elevation South Elevation Other Public Comment Signatures(three members required for quorum) r t s Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeti'ngMemorandum HDC/HSAB Date/TimeOT 9:2-1 1 q • It To: Historic District Commission From: Historic Structures Advisory Board Members Present ( )Angus MacLeod ( )Lucy Dillon ( )Jascin Leonardo Finger ton Rowland ..,)_Brook Meerbergen Alternate• chaPl May 7 i Applicant t2 1-14•4 N Address t-7.- (--(,--e-42.--(Ceds7) Historic information/Imown history 0)Non-Contributing ()Contributing ()Individmlly significant Comments ()Incomplete application ()Historical information needed ()No Concerns ()Recommend View 0)Does not meet guidelines 0)Not appropriate (As noted below) North Elevation VZatio ct . _ 19-1 `-‘6 5 t rArf s-e_451 Cr West Elevation South Elevation Other • Public Comment Si attires(three members required for um) Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB Date/Time etS1 . 23 I IC/ . To: Historic District Commission From: Historic Structures Advisory Board Members Present ( )Angus MacLeod ( )Lucy Dillon ( )Iascin Leonardo Finger)Milton Rowland�/ Brook Meerbergen Alternate: chael May t F Applicant Address Pit IJ l. r I Historic information/known history 0)Non-Contributing 0)Contributing ()Individually significant Comments ()Incomplete application ()Historical information needed O No Concerns 0)Recommend View ()Does not meet guidelines 0)Not appropriate (As noted below) 1 North Elevation East Elevation • West Elevation South Elevation Other 60.c,( Iq r—o� Top _ ,,a2r -1G4 Public Comment A-Ce.0 Str!iL 1D1 ( NiS Si (three members required for quorum) I V4U / Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB , Date/Time Qq ' Z- ' ) • To: Historic District Commission From: Historic Structures Advisory Board Members Present �/ ( )Angus MacLeod ( )Lucy Dillon ( )Jascin Leonardo Finger�")MiltonRowland ,rook Meerbergen Alternatrilichael May Applicant u` _ _ i ot_- Address 3L` �/ o e ' Historic information/known history ()Non-Contributing Contributing ()Individually significant Comments ()Incomplete application ()Historical information needed ()No Concerns 0)Recommend View ()Does not meet guidelines ()Not appropriate (As noted below) N t1= // • t•1-C C-c-4-1--e-- "-V 14,1c..-1-.-- 1/1/1-6-6 ‘,..--PtA,Ael if_ X East Elevation Co.a. n...0-(-- TJk_ekete LS - % tet...-- et..�i d' �j 7 • tt 15 tom(.,.;(�.,. --(1.. 4441%-.c. e--c- (s• a V g6 0'5 `j West Elevation South ylevation i • _ `c23--)-11'1--'-'0-,' IS.-11"1-.'- T1G4 -1--"-.P---—t( nuc-t^---_ r ....,, 0.4_,.... . e1/431,...4---,e1/431,...4---,. V2.4.4-pry er _ -- - - � (t tQ 106 77 Other / i , “ter I-.&X tga•-J ,F.', IS. Gc.]-"--te,--- ,tQ -A)10 '26. CCi 1 1M s ci4 vow • blic Comment _ � , -' Liu-AJI 4L4 //J - d1.' i aet. / i ,-i44 07111 17 • ' ' / ptnX W24� B 4:CA :Lc g ,i �7' /'1bvea.44— S es(three members required for quorum) Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Meinorandwn HDC/HSAB Date/Time v' / 17 t/'!l "J To: Historic District Commission F).-or: Historic Structures Advisory Board _ Members Present ( )Angus MacLeod ()Lucy Dillon ()Jascin Leonardo Finger .}Milton Rowland XBrook Meerbergen RRAlternate:Qichael May Applicant lAA t .Q Address y Historic information/known history • ()Non-Contributing ()Contributing ()Individually significant • Comments ()Incomplete application ()Historical information needed ()No Concerns 0)Recommend View ()Does not meet guidelines ()Not appropriate (.Is rested below) North Elevation M 110—frk.f b 6A.5ti4 > 62444 ata tip 1 .//It• i Li East Elevation /(70-270•-_ /4/1";-16 West Elevation • South Elevation • • er -+tia� 1 ,,•1�� .�,�a-r..4C. 61451-12-1, /}r cuG�u,4- -th Q doG�i G� CR -� ►�. � FL - -ta AC-c06A-e-s . /77N7j � Gsdf 615 l5 vvo C4 7b Peo,Wig Si- 14/4/ matir Cls-A14/A/ #011 ; es(three members required for guar :) 1 � �� �/ Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB Date/Time ©°) • 2-"5 I To: Historic District Cominission �� — From: Historic Structures Advisory Board Members Present ( )Angus MacLeod ()Lucy Dillon ()Jascin Leo do Finge5 Tilton Rowland rook Meerbergen Alternate: 'ch el May // f Applicant4,ffee,,7 9,4 • Address /Zs L� Historic information/lmown history ()Non-Contributing yContributing 0)Individually significant • Comments 0)Incomplete application ()Historical information needed ()No Concerns 0)Recommend View ()Does not meet guidelines ()Not appropriate (As noted below) North Elevation East Elevation West Elevation South Elevation Other (F(5 4' 15 ‘16(41-*-( Public Comment • Siy r-e members required for quorun tir Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB Date/Tnne&r.23 ` V„/ �� 4 F To: Historic District Commission From: Historic Structures Advisory Board Members Present ( )Angus MacLeod ( )Lucy Dillon ( )Jascin Leonardo Finger) ilton Rowland rook Meerbergen Alternate: 'Michael May Applican ,ocf e Address (e0 (ex* 4.3A-3 Historic information/known history ()Non-Contributing 0)Contributing ()Individually significant Comments ()Incomplete application ()Historical information needed ()No Concerns ()Recommend View ()Does not meet guidelines ()Not appropriate (As noted below) North Elevation East Elevation West Elevation South Elevation Other r ,e� { C�pr_c� e NN-of Veve-124,4 Public Comment Sims attires(three members required or quorum de111A - U 411.^- Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB _ Date/Time ' If, ('i -1c) 2..,t To: Historic District Commission From: Historic Structures Advisory Board Members Present ( )Angus MacLeod ( )Lucy Dillon ( )Jascin Leonardo Fingeii Ilton Rowlandirook Meerbergen Alternate:Michael May Applicant VI I2.--T1-)E V Address Ser2� Historic infoimation/lmown history ()Non-Contributing ()Contributing ()Individually significant Cr Comments 0)Incomplete application 0)Historical information needed j No Concerns 0 Recommend View ()Does not meet guidelines ()Not appropriate (As noted below) � North Elevation. East Elevation West Elevation South Elevation Other Public Comment • tures(three members r-. *'red . quorum) A� ` .= W V . Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB Date/Time O • Z3 To: Historic District Commission From: Historic Structures Advisory Board Members Present ( )Angus MacLeod ( )Lucy Dillon ( )Jascin Leonardo FingerMilton Rowland Brook Meerbergen Alternates:( ichael May p 61-t t=om Applicantl/V(��- � � Address �� Historic information/known history 0)Non-Contributing 0)Contributing 0)Individually significant Comments ()Incomplete application 0)Historical information needed ()No Concerns ()Recommend View ()Does not meet guidelines ()Not appropriate (A:rested below) North Elevation East vation Ele 6:=e, iL West Elevation • South Elevation Otlyr/ • c- e c (.4..--,...due-of Lt-ts L.-et Public Comment ua,atures(three members required for quorum) Historic Structures Advisory Board MeetingMenaorandurn HDC/HSAB Date/Time 69' 2-2j t�' / k2 J To: Historic District Commission From: Historic Structures Advisory Board Members Present ( )Angus MacLeod ( )Lucy Dillon ( )Jascin Leonardo Finger)(Milton Rowland Brook Meerbergen AIternatechael May q { Applicant 113,e-lc�.,_ - Address Historic information/known history ()Non-Contributing ()Contributing ()Individually significant Comments ()Incomplete application 0)Historical information needed No Concerns 0)Recommend View ()Does not meet guidelines O Not appropriate (As 1 ed below) North Elevation East Elevation West Elevation • South Elevation • Other Public Comment Si?'attires(three members required for quorum) t 1 i 1 Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB 1 Date/Time D1 ' 7-'2? ' Ic) (7/,' ; 1 1 E To: Historic District Commission From: Historic Structures Advisory Board - 1 i f Members Present i ( )Angus MacLeod ( )Lucy Dillon ( )Jascin Leonardo Finger / 'NTilton Rowland o•.01• �ook Meerbergen Alternate:( 'claw'May Applicant q... —„, Address 1 LI ''"—T Historic information/known history i 1 I f 0)Non-Contributing ()Contributing ()Individually significant • 1 Comments i ()Incomplete application ()Historical information needed ()No Concerns ()Recommend View ()Does not meet guidelines ()Not appropriate (As noted below) 1 North Elevation East Elevation r ,ref v1� tt , • a-= � 1- en-e-ab--6 B u-e-c T 4_1 h0... w IC? 1 Gam, , West Elevation South Elevation Other • Public Comment Signa es(three members required for quorum) �_ 1111)(2-- -'---72,r I 3 I Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB I } Date/Time 09 • 2.5 ` \7 (11 kf .2., s I To: Historic District Commission From: Historic Structures Advisory Board Members Present ( )Angus MacLeod ( )Lucy Dillon ( )JascinLeonardo Finger 'ton Rowland /rook Meerbergen Alternate. Michael May ! Applicant . "1' 4 V--- U.L.--0 4 Address 2 kG.e- --CwA- 1-4-) I Historic information/known history ONon-Contributing OContributing OIndividually significant • Comments 0)Incomplete application 0)Historical information neededo Concerns 0 Recommend View 0 Does not meet guidelines ()Not appropriate (As noted below) North Elevation East Elevation West Elevation South Elevation Other Public Comment S' -es(three members required for quo . i Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB Date/Time d, , 2-3 (i.' yI To: Historic District Commission From: Historic Structures Advisory Board Members Present ( )Angus MacLeod ( )Lucy Dillon ( )rascin Leonardo Finger )4Milton Rowland rook Meerbergen Alternate:Michael May Applicant -v-e-Lk AGY_-- 1. ( C Address t' - 4f / Historic information/known history / ()Non-Contributing 0)Contributing 0)Individually sign cant Comments ()Incomplete application 0)Historical information needed o Concerns 0 Recommend View '• O Does not meet guidelines ()Not appropriate (As note Blow) North Elevation East Elevation West Elevation • South Elevation Other Public Comment • Si (three members required for quorums) Lbs° ,.//'.0°"" l f I Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB i Date/Time ' 2727 I ) 47 I i To: Historic District Commission From: Historic Structures Advisory Board • t Members Present ( )Angus MacLeod ( )Lucy Dillon ( )Jascin Leonardo Pini 'ton Rowlanc ')Brook Meerbergen Alternate: 'chael May Applicant m / Address v[ Veds14.—L i!Historic in ion/known history E i I ()Non-Contributing ()Contributing ()Individually significant • Comments ()Incomplete application ()Historical information needed 0)No Concerns ()Recomm end View i ()Does not meet guidelines 0)Not appropriate (As noted below) North Elevation East Elevation West Elevation `' - /� LICe/tAx .e7 Ul .X.Q9-1., IS a' /114 L'1/4, South Elevation • Other _// `ac;_ f 60P:Gt _ c t,,.q--4--, VL aic.e-Gti a r5 •�-.�p(,c 6,-u-Ka.6ec..) S & 4 n,:e_a.tGam— U Public Comment V • attires(three members required for quorum) R' LA _4 Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB Date/Time tq'- 2-5 - f 7 To: Historic District Commission From: Historic Structures Advisory Board Members Present ( )Angus MacLeod ( )Lucy Dillon ( )Jascin Leonardo Finger Milton Rowland ><Brook Meerbergen Alternate:WMicitaP1 May _ Applicant 1VAddress S( 12 -�op,....7i-- --4--"--#4) ' Historic information/known history ()Non-Contributing ()Contributing ()Individually significant • Comments t ()Incomplete application ()Historical information needed o Concerns 0)Recommend View ()Does not meet guidelines ()Not appropriate (As noted below) North Elevation East Elevation West Elevation South Elevation Other Public Comment Signatures(three members requfredfor quorum) Arai. 1iti A I I/ !..,. Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Mernorandurn HDC(HSAB • Date/Time dq• 25 • 1 Cp VI 5 J J [� To: Historic District Commission • From: Historic Structures Advisory Board Members Present ( )Angus MacLeod ( )Lucy Dillon ( )Jascin Leonardo Finger Silton Rowland rook Meerbergen Alternate: ichael May € Applican( rvo� -e Address 1, ( T"_ - .4' 4Leteti fro, Historic informati7/lnown history 0 r ()Non-Contributing 0)Contributing 0)Individually significant Comments ()Incomplete application. ()Historical information needed ()No Concerns 0)Recommend View ()Does not meet guidelines ()Not appropriate (As noted below) North Elevation • East Elevation West Elevation -��--12-- 51-. . - outh Elevation , Uo„_,J,44,...,....44,,,A, _ _,___ _,,,,,,J,,,,L,.),(_„_.•_e_c_e__,4-......,__ --1-2.„ •444-eitr-t--- • . . 1 ,, 14, i Other r (.�e.� , pp.s.�"dL �s 64-.� Le✓. -,, o tq j 1,3"4- Q-- 11• — z. • `�K1�r�^-,tA �i.e r C 11.04.- R.A7 1.cv-ea 7� cr ? t � GZ G ey , Public Comment [ U 1 Sir attires(three members requuired�for quorwn) j l Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB Date/Time 0 !�2 J - `g 5 ' D To: Historic District Commission From: Historic Structures Advisory Board Members Present ( )Angus MacLeod ( )Lucy Dillon ( )Jascin Leonardo Finger)civIilton Rowland Brook Meerbergen Alternate ichaei May • Applicant 3-27 '--- (�(rC . Address lb ? Vii. • Historic information/known history • • ()Non-Contributin Contributing ()Individually significant • Comments ()Incomplete application ()Historical information needed ()No Concerns ()Recommend View ()Does not meet guidelines ()Not appropriate (As noted below) • North Elevation East Elevation West Elevation South Elevation Other ��1ri v�r.�s rt —zdt--, Public Comment Si es(three members required for quorum)