The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About2019-10-24HDC Minutes for October 24, 2019, adopted Nov. 5 HISTORIC DISTRICT COMMISSION A N -F U C REGULAR MEETING i N C L E E 2 Fairgrounds Road Nantucket, Massachusetts 02554 2919 NOV -7 AH 8: 12, www.nantucket-ma.gov Commissioners: Raymond Pohl (Chair), Diane Coombs (Vice -chair), John McLaughlin, Abigail Camp, Vallorie Oliver, Associate Commissioners: Stephen Welch, Terence Watterson, Jessie Dutra -- MINUTES -- Thursday, October 24, 2019 Planning and Land Use Services, 2 Fairgrounds Road, Conference Room — 1:00 p.m. Called to order at 1:00 p.m. and announcements by Mr. Pohl Staff in attendance: Cathy Flynn, Administrative Specialist; Terry Norton, Town Minutes Taker Attending Members: Pohl, McLaughlin, Camp, Oliver, Welch Absent Members: Coombs, Watterson, Dutra Late Arrivals: Welch, 1:00 p.m. Early Departures: Pohl, 1:47 p.m. Agenda ado ted bv unanimous consent. COMMENT1. PUBLIC None 11. OLD BUSINESS Property owner name Street Address Scope of work Map -Parcel Agent 1. Meadows Two ACK, LLC — 73336 10 & 12 Orchid Place Module A-ener code wind 68-338 KOH Architecture 2. Meadows Two ACK, LLC — 73337 14 & 16 Orchid Place ModuleA.l-ener code wind 68-338 KOH Architecture 3. Meadows Two ACK, LLC — 73338 6 & 8 Clover Place Module B-ener code wind 68-336 KOH Architecture 4. Meadows Two ACK, LLC — 73339 1 & 3 Clover Place ModuleB2-ener code wind 68-339 KOH Architecture 5. Meadows Two ACK, LLC — 73340 5 Clover Place ModuleHl-ener code wind 68-338 KOH Architecture Voting Pohl, McLaughlin, Camp, Oliver Alternates None Recused None Documentation Architectural elevation plans, site plan, and photos. Representing Dinah Klamert, KOH Architecture Public None Concerns (1:01) Oliver — She went to a house where these types of windows were installed and unless you put your face against the window, you can't tell there is no spacer bar. Camp — In view of Ms. Oliver's information, she will go along with an approval. McLaughlin — No concern. Motion Motion to Approve Items 1-5 requested window changes. (Oliver) Vote Carried unanimously Certificate # 73336 to 73340 6. Richmond Great Point Dev. 5 Lilac Court New dwelling 68-361 KOH Architecture Voting Welch (acting chair), McLaughlin, Oliver Alternates None Recused None Documentation Architectural elevation plans, site plan, and photos. Representing Dinah Klamert, KOH Architecture — Reviewed project and changes made per previous concerns. Public NOne Concerns (1:04) Oliver — It looks good. McLaughlin — The louvers should be wood. Welch — The gutters are indicated as aluminum but should be painted to match the trim. North and south elevations, with respect to structural aspect, the ventilation won't be met without a ridge vent because of the window on the front. Motion Motion to Approve with wood louvers. (Oliver) Vote Carried unanimously Certificate # 73341 Page 1 of 4 HDC Minutes for October 24, 2019, adopted Nov. 5 Page 2 of 4 Property owner name Street Address Scope of work Nlap-ParceAgent l.chujeffrey 27 N. Liberty Street Addition/move on lot 41-453 LINK Voting Pohl, McLaughlin, Camp, Oliver, Welch Alternates None Recused None Documentation None Representing None Public None Concerns (1:14) Not opened at this time. Motion Motion to Hold for representation. (McLaughlin) Vote Carried unanimously Certificate # 2. Richmond Great Point Dev. 1 & 3 Clover Place Rev. 71252: bump out 68-339 KOH Architecture Voting Pohl, McLaughlin, Camp, Oliver, Welch Alternates None Recused None Documentation Architectural elevation plans, site plan, and photos. Representing Dinah HIamert, KOH Architecture — Presented project; the fire department has two addresses because this apartment building has two main entrances. Public None Concerns (1:14) McLaughlin — There is a 4 -light window not detailed on the window schedule. No other concerns. Motion Motion to Approve through staff with the 4 -light window to be added to the schedule. (Camp) Vote Carried unanimously Certificate # 73342 3. Richmond Great Point Dev 2 Lilac Court Garage 68-366 KOH Architecture Voting Pohl, McLaughlin, Camp, Oliver, Welch Alternates None Recused None Documentation Architectural elevation plans, site plan, and photos. Representing Dinah HIamert, KOH Architecture — Presented project. Public None Concerns (1:21) No concerns. Motion Motion to Approve as submitted. (Oliver) Vote Carried unanimously Certificate # 73343 4. Richmond Great Point Dev 4 Lilac Court Garage 68-365 KOH Architecture Voting Pohl, McLaughlin, Camp, Oliver, Welch Alternates None Recused None Documentation Architectural elevation plans, site plan, and photos. Representing Dinah HIamert, KOH Architecture — Presented project. Public None Concerns (1:23) No concerns. Motion Motion to Approve as submitted. (Oliver) Vote Carried unanimously Certificate # 73344 5. Richmond Great Point Dev 5 Lilac Court Garage 68-361 KOH Architecture Voting Pohl, McLaughlin, Camp, Oliver, Welch Alternates None Recused None Documentation Architectural elevation plans, site plan, and photos. Representing Dinah HIamert, KOH Architecture — Presented project. Public None Concerns (1:25) No concerns. Motion Motion to Approve as submitted. (Welch) Vote Carried unanimously Certificate # 73345 Page 2 of 4 HDC Minutes for October 24, 2019, adopted Nov. 5 6. Richmond Great Point Dev 3 Aster Court Garage 68-373 KOH Architecture Voting Pohl, McLaughlin, Camp, Oliver, Welch Alternates None Recused None Documentation Architectural elevation plans, site plan, and photos. Representing Dinah Mamert, KOH Architecture — Presented project. Public None Concerns (1:26) Welch — Suggested that the landscaping of each lot should be different since the garages are all so similar. No concerns. Motion Motion to Approve as submitted. (Oliver) Vote Carried unanimously Certificate # 73346 7. Richmond Great Point Dev 6 Sandplain Garage 68-354 KOH Architecture Voting Pohl, McLaughlin, Camp, Oliver, Welch Alternates None Recused None Documentation Architectural elevation plans, site plan, and photos. Representing Dinah Klamert, KOH Architecture — Presented project. Public None Concerns (1:28) McLaughlin —The door should be a 9 -light side door. No other concerns. Motion Motion to Approve through staff with the side door to be a 9 -light. (Oliver) Vote Carried unanimously Certificate # 73347 13 Union Street Replace windows 42.3.2-16 Self Voting Pohl, McLaughlin, Camp, Oliver, Welch Alternates None Recused None Documentation Architectural elevation plans, site plan, photos, and historic documentation. Representing Jon Schoudel, owner — There was discussion about the age of the windows; they are 20th century replacements, circa 1960. Public None Concerns (1:31) Camp — She didn't have a chance to go look at this structure; she wants to hear what the other members say. Oliver — No concerns; the replacements will be Boston Sash, true -divided light windows. McLaughlin — Clarified which windows are being replaced and that the others are previously approved. Discussion about storm windows/panels that don't have aluminum frames. Consensus would like to see an example of Leksan storm panels before they are installed on the exterior. Motion Motion to Approve as submitted. (Oliver) Vote Carried unanimously Certificate # 73348 9. Cuniff, William 38 Appleton Road Dormers/deck/stairs 66-42 Nantucket Design Voting Pohl, McLaughlin, Camp, Oliver, Welch Alternates None Recused None Documentation Architectural elevation plans, site plan, and photos. Representing Kent Murphy, Nantucket Design Public None Concerns (1:43) Pohl — Reviewed changes made per previous concerns. No concerns. Motion Motion to Approve per the revised drawings submitted at the table. (Welch) Vote Carried unanimously Certificate # 73349 Page 3 of 4 HDC Minutes for Octoher 24. 20] 9. adonted Nnv_ 5 OTHER Approve Minutes done Review Minutes October 8, 10 & 15, 2019 Other Business • Mission Statement for Town Website vote: Held • Updated Like Kind Application: Held • Discussion of National Grid Distribution Reliability Project (I.8) in regard to new utility poles and overhead wires: Held • Discussion of Net Zero Stretch Code and impacts to HDC: Held • Discussion and update of Sidewalk Work Group: Held Commission Comments I Welch — Asked staff to look into SDL front door sidelights at 5 Beaver Street. List of additional documents used at the meeting 1. None Adjourned at 1:49 p.m. by unanimous consent Submitted by: Terry L. Norton Page 4 of 4