HomeMy WebLinkAbout2019-2-25Approved Minutes February 25, 2019, adopted March 5, 2019
Historic District Commission
Historic Structures Advisory Board
Members: Micky Rowland, Michael May, Jascin Finger, Angus Macleod, Brook Meerbergen
Alternate Member: Lucy Dillon
Planning and Land Use Services
2 Fairgrounds Road
Nantucket, Massachusetts 02554
MINUTES
February 25, 2019
I. Procedural Business
Call to order at 3:30 pm.
Attending members: Angus Macleod, Lucy Dillon, Brook Meerbergen
Absent members: Micky Rowland
Late arrivals: Michael May at 3:35 pm; Jascin Leonardo -Finger at 3:38 pm.
Early Departures: None.
Motion to Adopt Agenda made by Lucy Dillon; Seconded by Angus Macleod.
Vote: carried unanimously
Approval of Minutes: February 11, 2019
Motion made by Angus Macleod; Seconded by Lucy Dillon.
Vote: carried unanimously
II. Public Comment
Page 1 of 2
Approved Minutes February 25, 2019, adopted March 5, 2019
III. New Business — See attached Comments
Property Owner Street Street Address Scope of Work Map/Parcel Agent
1.
Brown, Christina (OB)
69 N. Liberty Street
Alterations/deck/doors
41-142
Val Oliver
2.
Rosenberg, Joan (OB)
8 Chester Street
Color changes
42.4.3-64
Linda Williams
3.
Charron, Paul (OB)
48 Walsh Street
Shed
29-101
Robert Newman
I.
Gastellano, Richard
109 Main Street
Spa/bluestone/patio
42.3.3-150
Atlantic Landscaping
2.
Simone M.D., James
20 Hussey Street
Revisions
42.3.4-130
NAG
3.
Relihan, Robert
4'/2 Gay Street
Fence
42.3.4-17
Jeff Morash
4.
Silver, Marc
1 I Weymouth Street
HVAC Condenser
55.4.1-134
NAG
5.
Gustaveson, Roy
11 Vestal Street
Rev 71654
42.3.3-171
Brook Meerbergen
6.
Miller, Chandra
13 Dover Street
Add of stair case
55.4.1-196
Thornewill Design
7.
Pohl, Raymond
24 Pine Street
Addition
42.3.2-110
Botticelli&Pohl
8.
Hidalgo, Carlos
55 Fair Street
Rev 66985
55.4.1-74
Kelly Ennis
9.
Great State Property
92 Washington St
Demo main house
42.2.3-22
Smith & Hutton Arch
10.
Great State Property
92 Washington St
New dwelling
42.2.3-22
Smith & Hutton Arch
11,
86 Main N. T.
86 Main Street
Arbore, gate
42.3.3-66
Sconset Gardener
12.Sullivan
Krueger Family Tr
6 New Lane
New dwelling
41-294
BPC
13.
Sullivan Krueger Family Tr
2 Ackermuck Way
New dwelling
41-294
BPC
14.
39 Hulbert, LLC
39 Hulbert Avenue
Rev69356; water table
29-19
Botticelli & Pohl
15.
39 Hulbert, LLC
39 Hulbert Avenue
Rev69355; water table
29-19
Botticelli & Pohl
16.
Crane, Melissa Fish
38 Walsh Street
Front door color change
29-102
Main Street Constr
17.
NHA
15 Broad Street
Door change
42.4.2-61
Doug Seholm
18.
NIR Retail, LLC
15 S. Beach Street
Rev70896; covered deck
42.4.2-57.1
Emeritus
19.
O'Donnell, Michael
2 Gardner Street
Window changes
42.3.3-149
Linda Williams
20.
Sayles, Charles
103Washington St.
Deck/steps
55.1.4-37
Barry Dononvan
Motion to approve comments from New Business items #1 -20.
Motion made by Angus Macleod; Seconded by Lucy Dillon.
Vote: carried unanimously
IV. Discussion of Mission Statement for Town Website.
None.
V. Discussion of Expanding HSAB Map for Review of Applications.
John Hedden will ask GIS coordinator to draft a final map that encompasses Jetties Beach
VI. Adjournment
Motion to Adjourn made by Michael May; Seconded by Lucy Dillon at 5:47 pm.
Vote: Carried Unanimously.
Submitted by Cathy Flynn
Page 2 of 2
Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB
Date/Time L C 3 :5S
To: Historic District Commission
From: Historic Structures Advisory Board
Members Present
1 Angus MacLeod(Michael May XJascin Leonardo Finger ( ) Milton Rowland (rook Meerbergen
Alternate: �< Lucy Dillon
ApplicantQ ;� S l yu Address
Historic information/known history
O Non -Contributing O Contributing O Individually significant
Comments
() Incomplete application () Historical information needed () No Concerns () Recommend View
( ) Does not meet guidelines () Not appropriate (As noted beloiv)
North Elevation
East Elevation
West Elevation
South Elevation
Other
Public Comment
Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum
HDC/HSAB
Date/Time �2f'O
To: Historic District Commission
From: Historic Structures Advisory Board
Members Present g Milton Rowland Brook Meerbergen
( gus MacLeod Michael May � Jascin Leonardo Fin er ( )
Alternate: (j Lucy Dillon
l Address`'
Applicant �` '
Historic infonnation/known history
O Non -Contributing Contributing O Individually significant
Comments
O Incomplete application O Historical information needed O No Concerns O Recommend View
( ) Does not meet guidelines () Not appropriate (As noted below)
North Elevation
East Elevation
West Elevation
South Elevation
Public Comment
Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB
Date/Time t �oq) 6
To: Historic District Commission
From: Historic Structures Advisory Board
Members Present
Angus MacLeodichael May Jascin Leonardo Finger O Milton Rowland rook Meerbergen
Alternate: �ucy
Dillon
Applicant6fes- Address 143 WA(n6;.4
Historic information/known history
( ) Non -Contributing O Contributing O Individually significant
Comments
() Incomplete application () Historical information needed () No Concerns () Recommend View
( ) Does not meet guidelines () Not appropriate (As noted below)
North Elevation
East Elevation
West Elevation
South Elevation
Other
x O U r x TuF L17
Public Comment
Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB
Date/Time 2, 22�; I 19 3
To: Historic District Commission
From: Historic Structures Advisory Board
Members Present
Angus MacLeod ichael May KJascin Leonardo Finger () Milton Rowland � Brook Meerbergen
Alternate:'{, Lucy Dillon
Applicant S`T Lr� ? ,�Address � G,�2 "Alt)
Historic information/known history
O Non -Contributing contributing O Individually significant
Comments
() Incomplete application () Historical information needed () No Concerns () Recommend View
( ) Does not meet guidelines ( ) Not appropriate (As noted below)
North Elevation
East Elevation
West Elevation
South Elevation
Other
�� ,�� tai �l li ls► P>i..E ��-�, �;,�►�n�-����(.�' �r� 1.�'� �yT—
Public Comment
Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB
Date/Timet % D
To: Historic District Commission
From: Historic Structures Advisory Board
Members Present
�gus MacLeodi,�i lylichael Maye"Nascin Leonardo Finger O Milton Rowland >CBrook Meerbergen
/ Alt ate ,Lucy Dillon
Applicant ��ir�►���_ Address
Historic information/Imown history
( ) Non -Contributing O Contributing O Individually significant
Comments
O Incomplete application O Historical information needed"'Pdo Concerns O Recommend View
( ) Does not meet guidelines () Not appropriate (As noted bel/ow)
North Elevation
East Elevation
West Elevation
South Elevation
Other
Public Comment
l
i''l �r� c i �. ' i; i '. 'r'✓�k��/
Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB
Date/Time-21,
To: Historic District Commission
From: Historic Structures Advisory Board
Members Present
Angus MacLeo ichael May (Kjascin Leonardo Finger O Milton Rowland ABrook Meerbergen
Alternat�Lucy Dillon f
Applicant �vv-r Address , `-('
Historic information/lmown history
( ) Non -Contributing O Contributing O Individually significant
Comments
() Incomplete application () Historical information needed () No Concerns () Recommend View
() Does not meet guidelines () Not appropriate (As noted below)
North Elevation
East Elevation
West Elevation
South Elevation
Other
Public Comment
� G
Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB
Date/Time
To: Historic District Commission
From: Historic Structures Advisory Board
Members Present
)Angus MacLeodIKM ichael May} Jascin Leonardo Finger O Milton Rowland rook Meerbergen
Alternate• Lucy Dillon
ApplicAddress l (��Fi-C 1�l r_T- -
Historic infonnation/known history
O Non -Contributing O Contributing O Individually significant
Comments
O Incomplete application O Historical information neededANo Concerns O Recommend View
( ) Does not meet guidelines ( ) Not appropriate (As noted below)
North Elevation
East Elevation
e`er
West Elevation /.
South Elevation
Other
Public Comment
` r i
signatures (three it r
cvi
Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum
Date/Time 2' 2S
),L ', 1-&
To: Historic District Commission
From: Historic Structures Advisory Board
Members Present
�gus MacLeod 1 'chael May Jascin Leonardo Finger ( ) Milton Rowland
Alternate ><
lte ate>< Lucy Dillon
HDC/HSAB
Brook Meerbergen
Applicant �5 Crr.:i, ',v Address
Historic infonnation/known history
() Non -Contributing () Contributing () Individually significant
Comments
OIncomplete application OHistorical information needed
,�Ko Concerns O Recommend View
( ) Does not meet guidelines ( ) Not appropriate (As noted below)
North Elevation
East Elevation
West Elevation
South Elevation
Other
Public Comment
r I
n,p��
Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB
Date/Time 02—
To:
Z•
To: Historic District Commission I
From: Historic Structures Advisory Board F-0—
Members
-0—M mbers Present
gus MacLeod �iMichael May/X<�Jascin Leonardo Finger O Milton Rowland Brook Meerbergen
Alternate:XQLucy Dillon
Applicant i1 �„�,3D%- Address
Historic information/known history
O Non -Contributing O Contributing O Individually significant
Comments
() Incomplete application () Historical information needed () No Concerns () Recommend View
( ) Does not meet guidelines ( ) Not appropriate (As noted below)
North Elevation
East Elevation
West Elevation `
C P n-_ (d lam^
South Elevation
Other
Public Comment
Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB
Date/Time
To: Historic District Commission
From: Historic Structures Advisory Board
Members Present
Angus MacLeod (}Michael May ';Jascin Leonardo Finger O Milton Rowland Brook Meerbergen
Alternate: �ucy
Dillon
ApplicantT�l Address
Historic infonnation/known history
O Non -Contributing ntributing O Individually significant
Comments
O Incomplete application O Historical information needed O No Concerns O Recommend View
( ) Does not meet guidelines ( ) Not appropriate (As noted below)
North Elevation
East Elevation
West Elevation
• y LAJ c_ Fib �Giii1�JG, \Si ✓�ws �
e
South Elevation
Other
Public Comment
Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB
Date/Time
To: Historic District Commission
From: Historic Structures Advisory Board
Members Present
Angus MacLeodMichael May �Jascin Leonardo Finger O Milton Rowland rook Meerbergen
Alte ate: �ILucy Dillon
Applicant %�l ,-�, Lam, / c� j Address T::�o ►2
Historic information/lmown history
O Non -Contributing contributing O Individually significant
Comments
( ) Incomplete application ( ) Historical information needed O No Concerns ( ) Recommend View
() Does not meet guidelinesXotappropriate (As noted below)
North Elevation
East Elevation
West Elevation
CWr bo S
gj 1 �, 2-f ---4--c C--j--&—x> .►'� t�� t� �7Ct�' 4C, f 77
So th Elevation t
Other
Public Comment
Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB
Date/Time
To: Historic District Commission
From: Historic Structures Advisory Board
Members Present
Angus MacLeod Michael May />� Jascin Leonardo Finger O Milton Rowland Brook Meerbergen
Alte(mate:',gucy Dillon
Applicant �� X27——r`� (�� Address
Historic infonnation/known history
Non- Contributing O O Contributing Individually significant
Comments
O Incomplete application O Historical information needed O No Concerns O Recommend View
( ) Does not meet guidelines ( ) Not appropriate (As noted below)
North Elevation
East Elevation
West Elevation
South Elevation
Other
Public Comment
Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB
Date/Tune
To: Historic District Commission
From: Historic Structures Advisory Board
Members Present
Angus MacLeod Michael May ;<Jascin Leonardo Finger O Milton Rowland Brook Meerbergen
Alternate: Wucy Dillon
Applicant��, Address tty�s Tt ,
Historic information/known history
O Non -Contributing O Contributing O Individually significant
Comments
( ) Incomplete application O Historical information needed O No Concerns O Recommend View
( ) Does not meet guidelines () Not appropriate (As noted below)
North Elevation
East Elevation
West Elevation
South Elevation
Other , � t2AA t_, t ► �, �(t t✓ r/l' `� �i I C� 251 `
• i�W1L1t UG35—TZ� �-Pp�r�S -' ilC�� S(
Public Comment
Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB
Date/Time �5
To: Historic District Commission
Front: Historic Structures Advisory Board
Members Present
gus MacLeodichael May+Jascin Leonardo Finger O Milton Rowland ><Brook Meerbergen
l �w Al eY rnate:�`�,ucy Dillon
Applicant(,, ,v K3'" Address
Historic information/known history
O Non -Contributing ;(Contributing�Individually significant
Comments /
O Incomplete application O Historical information needed O No Concerns O Recommend View
() Does not meet guidelines () Not appropriate (As noted below)
North Elevation
East Elevation
West Elevation
South Elevation
Other
Public Comment
q--
Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB
Date/Time 2 S
To: Historic District Commission
From: Historic Structures Advisory Board
Members Present
�gus MacLeod>4',"ichael May �Tascin Leonardo Finger O Milton Rowland/ Brook Meerbergen
Alternate�� ucy Dillon
Applicant,LLA Y Q -0 �:E,9_F, 1 Address
Historic information/known history
( ) Non -Contributing O Contributing O Individually significant
Comments
O Incomplete application O Historical information needed O No Concerns O Recommend View
() Does not meet guidelines () Not appropriate (As noted below)
North Elevation
East Elevation
West Elevation
South Elevation
Other
"Tt-tts�iz w
1-5 7mio_xw cx� o;G
c 1<
Public Comment
Signatures (three e r i e g , r�
5
Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB
Date/Time
To: Historic District Commission
From: Historic Structures Advisory Board
Members Present
-Angus MacLeod (_Michael May Jascin Leonardo Finger O Milton Rowland Brook Meerbergen
/ Alternate: (f Lucy Dillon /
Applicant�l,+-��L� �.F_Q_�_�Address' C -
Historic infonnation/known history
O Non -Contributing O Contributing O Individually significant
Comments
( ) Incomplete application ( ) Historical information needed O No Concerns ( ) Recommend View
( ) Does not meet guidelines ( ) Not appropriate (As noted below)
North Elevation
�T" 1-:� V I S i 1� i_� Kpu7—i�PJ Pt�t tYc'��
East Elevation
9 tJ
West Elevation
South Elevation
Other
u-�c 7 L_ C> i_ c_-rr�EfLy'Q�uQQn? ja cx1.1 An�Pc n3
`31��' •—tom �-��' ��- f3�-SC1�r.�
Public Comment
E_k�>
Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB
Date/Tune
To: Historic District Commission
From: Historic Structures Advisory Board
Members Present
Angus MacLeod ichael May Wascin Leonardo Finger O Milton Rowland Brook Meerbergen
Alte ateucy Dillon
ApplicantAddress�F�
Historic information/known history
O Non -Contributing O Contributing O Individually significant
Comments
( ) Incomplete application O Historical information needed O No Concerns O Recommend View
( ) Does not meet guidelines () Not appropriate (As noted below)
North Elevation
East Elevation
West Elevation
South Elevation
Other
7- � tel` SI-�rl+.X,t L a F
R �, ;J
Public Comment
Signatures thre m r r l }
Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB
Date/Time 2 \9 v ��
To: Historic District Commission
From: Historic Structures Advisory Board
Members Present
C/TAngus MacLeod Michael May�Jascin Leonardo Finger O Milton Rowland Brook Meerbergen
Alt mateucy Dillon
ApplicAddress 1�7
Historic infonnation/known history
( ) Non -Contributing O Contributing O Individually significant
Comments
O Incomplete application O Historical information needed O No Concerns O Recommend View
( ) Does not meet guidelines () Not appropriate (As noted below)
North Elevation
East Elevation
West Elevation
South Elevation
Other 'jam c i,C� f.Li = 60 6,S�T
� �f� L� ?s��►�- �-r=te. �„ �
Public Comment
Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB
Date/Time Z° 2- S, 1 J Z J
To: Historic District Commission
From: Historic Structures Advisory Board
Members Present
gus MacLeod XMichael May �Jascin Leonardo Finger O Milton Rowland 'rook Meerbergen
Alte ate: �} .Lucy Dillon
Applicant_6_A rte, ( -t_-( ���''' Address
Historic information/known history
O Non -Contributing O Contributing O Individually significant
Comments
( ) Incomplete application O Historical information neede�o Concerns O Recommend View
( ) Does not meet guidelines () Not appropriate (As noted below)
North Elevation
East Elevation
West Elevation
South Elevation
Other
Public Comment
Signatures
Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB
r
Date/Time O z-
To: Historic District Commission
From: Historic Structures Advisory Board
Members Present
&( _ngus MacLeodMichael May O Jascin Leonardo Finger O Milton Rowland rook Meerbergen
(X Alternate: ucy Dillon /// ---/
f
Applicant Address (31V, j
Historic information/known history
O Non -Contributing O Contributing .Individually significant
Comments
O Incomplete application O Historical information needed O No Concerns O Recommend View
( ) Does not meet guidelines ( ) Not appropriate (As noted below)
North Elevation
East Elevation
West Elevation
South Elevation
Other
Public Comment
1
Ar 17 fi'
Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB
Date/Time 021
To: Historic District Commission
Front: Historic Structures Advisory Board
Members Present
`( &ngus MacLeod Michael May Jascin Leonardo Finger O Milton Rowland rook Meerbergen
// Alternate Wucy Dillon
ApplicantL Address' --
Historic information/known history
O Non -Contributing O Contributing O Individually significant
Comments
( ) Incomplete application () Historical information needed No Concerns () Recommend View
( ) Does not meet guidelines ( ) Not appropriate (As note below)
North Elevation
East Elevation
West Elevation
South Elevation
Other
Public Comment
Signatures (three awoir o
t
Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB
Date/Time 2—' a5
To: Historic District Commission
From: Historic Structures Advisory Board
Members Present
j�I Angus MacLeod ¢ Zichael May &7ascin Leonardo Finger O Milton Rowland � Brook Meerbergen
/ / Alternate.�Lucy Dillon
Applicant 0 V>Ot-3 ��-�— ,�J� Address Pratte fL
Historic information/known history
( ) Non -Contributing O Contributing O Individually significant
Comments
O Incomplete application O Historical information needed O No Concerns O Recommend View
() Does not meet guidelines () Not appropriate (As noted below)
North Elevation
East Elevation
it t`�
West Elevation
South Elevation
QEE�W r�(Z W1 _i_ +moo;— '3 E- \lS�'� =-
Other
Public Comment
Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB
Date/Time'-2--
To:
ate/Time`Z
To: Historic District Commission
Front: Historic Structures Advisory Board
Members Present
Angus MacLeod ichael May )(<a Jascin Leonardo Finger ( ) Milton Rowland rook Meerbergen
Alternate: ,Lucy Dillon
ApplicantAddresses
Historic information/known history
O Non -Contributing O Contributing O Individually significant
Comments
O Incomplete application O Historical information needed O No Concerns O Recommend View
() Does not meet guidelines () Not appropriate (As noted below)
North Elevation
East Elevation
G p/VS I� 12 e
a� ism 1-AV�—rr�r
Westl�levation
South Elevation
Other
Public Comment