HomeMy WebLinkAbout2019-3-25Approved Minutes March 25, 2019, adopted April 08, 2019
Historic District Commission
Historic Structures Advisory Board
Members: Micky Rowland, Michael May, Jascin Finger, Angus Macleod, Brook Meerbergen
Alternate Member: Lucy Dillon
Planning and Land Use Services
2 Fairgrounds Road
Nantucket, Massachusetts 02554
MINUTES
Monday March 25, 2019
I. Procedural Business
Call to order at 3:41 pm.
Attending members: Angus Macleod, Lucy Dillon, dickey Rowland
Absent members: Jascin Leonardo -Finger, Michael May, Brook Meerbergen
Late arrivals: None.
harly Departures: None.
Motion to Adopt Agenda made by Mickev Rowland; Seconded by Angus Macleod.
Vote: carried unanimously
Approval of Minutes: March 11 and March 18, 2019
Motion to Approve made by Angus Macleod; Seconded by Mickey Rowland.
Vote: carried unanimously
II. Public Comment
None.
Page 1 of 2
Approved Minutes March 25, 2019, adopted April 08, 2019
III. New Business — See attached Comments
Property Owner Street Street Address Scope of Work
I.
Pierpont
1 Mackay Way
2.
Fraker, Ford
12 Mt. Vernon
3.
N.I.R. Retail, LLC
38 Main Street
4.
Crowley, Artell
6R New Lane
5.
Gaslight Theatre
3 N. Union Street
6.
Lerner, Louis
15 New Lane
7.
Loeb, Charlie
25 Pleasant Street
8.
Sanford, Alfred
36B Lily Street
9.
Winer, Elizabeth
34 Cliff Road
10.
August Point, LLC
8 Willard Street
11.
Burke, Janice
36 N. Liberty Street
12.
Ruley, Meg
5 Franklin Street
13.
Ruley, Meg
5 Franklin Street
14.
18 Orange Street, LLC
18 Orange Street
15.
8 Highland Avenue, LLC
8 Highland Avenue
16.
Carter, Jeff
10'/2 Cherry Street
17.
Carter, Jeff
10 '/z Cherry Street
Color change
Studio
Color change
Shed
Hardscape; pergola/fence
Purge chimney
Door color change
Rev 71571; windows
New porch
Hardscape; fence
Rev 70021
Main Dwelling porch
Cottage— porch
Color change
Pool/hardscape
New dwelling
Studio
Map/Parcel
42.4.1-62.1
55.4.4-35
42-190
41-539
42.3.1-214.2
41-282
55.4.1-111
42.4.3-94
42.4.4-47
42.4.1-55.1
41-265
41-391
41-391
42.3.2-15
30-287
55-383.2
55-383.2
Motion to approve comments from New Business items 1 — 17.
Motion made by Angus Macleod; Seconded by Lucy Dillon.
Vote: Carried unanimously
IV. Discussion of Mission Statement for Town Website
None.
V. Vote- Expanding HSAB Map for review of application
None.
Ag—ent
Permits Plus
Permits Plus
Jamie Lee Nass
Self
Edgewater
Concept Design
Elisa Allen
Botticelli & Pohl
Botticelli & Pohl
WingHorks
Val Oliver
Val Oliver
Val Oliver
Emeritus
Atlantic Landscaping
Val Oliver
Val Oliver
VI. Adjournment
Motion to Adjourn made by Angus Macleod; Seconded by Lucy Dillon at 4:59 pm.
Vote: Carried unanimously.
Submitted by Cathy Flynn
Page 2 of 2
Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB
Date/Time
To: Historic District Commission
From: Historic Structures Advisory Board
Members Present
(t>4gus MacLeod O Michael May O Jascin onardo Finger (L4_ton Rowland O Brook Meerbergen
Alternat Lucy Dillon
Applicant P/� /V Address
Historic information/known history
( ) Non -Contributing O Contributing O Individually significant
Comments
() Incomplete application () Historical information needed () No Concerns () Recommend View
O Does not meet guidelines O Not appropriate (As noted below)
North Elevation
East Elevation
West Elevation
South Elevation
Other
Public Comment
II;rn-M.
Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB
Date/Tune • J �C3
To: Historic District Commission
From: Historic Structures Advisory Board
Zbers Present /
gus MacLeod () Michael May () Jascipleeonardo Finger (p'Milton Rowland ()Brook Meerbergen
Alternate: ( Lucy Dillon
Applicant � Address /,�,7
Historic information/known history
( ) Non -Contributing O Contributing ( ) Individually significant
Comments
O Incomplete application O Historical information needed O No Concerns O Recommend View
( ) Does not meetguidelines () Not appropriate (As noted below)
,--BTst Eevation �� 2
„jV�st Ele� on l%�/1�-e d% s�/ ;%�v✓[� �J /� // (/t/�/!//
Elevation
Other
Public Comment
Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB
Date/Time
To: Historic District Commission
From: Historic Structures Advisory Board
Mbers Present Kton
(rgus MacLeod O Michael May O Jascmi nardo Finger lV Rowland O Brook Meerbergen
Alternate: ( Kucy Dillon
Applicant All �� Address 1?79 111U,61�
Historic information/known history
( ) Non -Contributing O Contributing O Individually significant
Comments
O Incomplete application O Historical information needed O No Concerns O Recommend View
() Does not meet guidelines () Not appropriate (As noted below)
North Elevation
East Elevation
West Elevation
South Elevation
Other
Public Comment
Sl r erWr4d uorun:)
Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB
Date/Time
To: Historic District Commission
Front: Historic Structures Advisory Board
M bers Present
( Angus MacLeod O Michael May O Jascin L nardo Finger ( Milton Rowland OBrook Meerbergen
Alternate: OPlIcy Dillon
Applicant �7" x Address l�/ x
Historic information/known history
( ) Non -Contributing O Contributing O Individually significant
Comments
( ) Incomplete application O Historical information needed O No Concerns O Recommend View
( ) Does not meet guidelines () Not appropriate (As noted below)
North Elevation
East Elevation
West Elevation
South Elevation
Other
,007a 1�lmlw
4" A0,JXj 41 4!W U14AWW,�Wl
Public Comment
Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB
Date/Time V �l �• 0
To: Historic District Commission
From: Historic Structures Advisory Board
M bers Present
(�gus MacLeod O Michael May O Jasc' eonardo Finger (Olmilton Rowland O Brook Meerbergen
Alternate: ( Lucy Dillon
Applicant ` ess /V
'
61 9
Historic information/known history
( ) Non -Contributing O Contributing O Individually significant
Comments
( ) Incomplete application O Historical information needed O No Concerns O Recommend View
( ) Does not meet guidelines () Not appropriate (As noted below)
North Elevation
East Elevation
West Elevation
South Elevation
Public Comment Ram, r�Lj'►"w�OYI � �S /?�D � R. f YP�° G��
Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB
Date/Time % k
To: Historic District Commission
From: Historic Structures Advisory Board
Me,�ers Present
(PfAngus MacLeod () Michael May () Jasciwmllon rdo Finger ( Ilton Rowland () Brook Meerbergen
Alternate: ()
Applicant G7% "O' Address
Historic information/known history
O Non -Contributing O Contributing O Individually significant
Comments
( ) Incomplete application O Historical information needed O No Concerns O Recommend View
( ) Does not meet guidelines () Not appropriate (As noted below)
North Elevation
East Elevation
West Elevation
South Elevation
Other
Public Comment
S
Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB
Date/Time
To: Historic District Commission
From: Historic Structures Advisory Board
Mculbers Present
gus MacLeod O Michael May O Jascin Leonardo Finger'Milton Rowland O Brook Meerbergen
Alternate: ( L�,Kcy Dillon
Applicant/� Address 16�_
Historic information/known history
( ) Non -Contributing O Contributing O Individually significant
Comments
O Incomplete application O Historical information needed O No Concerns O Recommend View
() Does not meet guidelines () Not appropriate (As noted below)
North Elevation
East Elevation
West Elevation
South Elevation
Public Comment
Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB
Date/Time ; • I
To: Historic District Commission
From: Historic Structures Advisory Board
M bers Present
gus MacLeod () Michael May () Jas Leonardo Finger Milton Rowland () Brook Meerbergen
��Xell
Alternate: ( LucyDillon
Applicant Address U/
Historic information/known history
O Non -Contributing O Contributing O Individually significant
Comments
O Incomplete application O Historical information needed O No Concerns O Recommend View
( ) Does not meet guidelines () Not appropriate (As noted below)
North Elevation
East Elevation
West Elevation
South Elevation
Other
Public Comment
Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB
Date/Time '/ *:
To: Historic District Commission
From: Historic Structures Advisory Board
M hers Present
( Angus MacLeod () Michael May () Jasc' Leonardo Finger (t4iiton Rowland () Brook Meerbergen
Alternate:Lucy Dillon
Applicant • G'(/ Address
Historic information/known history
( ) Non -Contributing O Contributing O Individually significant
Comments
O Incomplete application O Historical information needed O No Concerns O Recommend View
( ) Does not meet guidelines () Not appropriate (As noted below)
North Elevation
East Elevation '
West Elevation
Other
Public Comment
r
Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB
Date/Time
To: Historic District Commission
Front: Historic Structures Advisory Board
Embers Present
Angus MacLeod O Michael May O Ja Leonardo Finger ( Milton Rowland O Brook Meerbergen
Alternate: ucy Dillon
ApplicAddress
Historic information/known history
( ) Non -Contributing O Contributing O Individually significant
Comments
( ) Incomplete application O Historical information needed O No Concerns O Recommend View
( ) Does not meet guidelines () Not appropriate (As noted below)
North Elevation
East Elevation
West Elevation
South Evatiop F.F 7
Other
Public Comment
Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB
Date/Tune ✓ / / f /
To: Historic District Commission
From: Historic Structures Advisory Board
M tubers Present
Angus MacLeod O Michael May O Jas ' eonardo Finger ( on Rowland O Brook Meerbergen
Alternate: ( Lucy MiltDillon
ApplicanAddress G1 ��
Historic information/known history
( ) Non -Contributing O Contributing O Individually significant
Comments
( ) Incomplete application O Historical information needed O No Concerns O Recommend View
( ) Does not meet guidelines ( ) Not appropriate (As noted below)
North Elevation
East Elevation
West Elevation
South Elevation
Other
Public Comment
Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum
Date/Time
To: Historic District Commission
Frons: Historic Structures Advisory Board
(tubers Present
Angus MacLeod () Michael May () Jascin'Peonardo Finger ( 01wton Rowland
Alternate: () Xucy Dillon
HDC/HSAB
( ) Brook Meerbergen
Applicant Address �57
Historic information/known history
( ) Non -Contributing ( ) Contributing ( ) Individually significant
Comments
( ) Incomplete application O Historical information needed o Concerns O Recommend View
( ) Does not meet guidelines () Not appropriate (As noted below)
North Elevation
East Elevation
West Elevation
South Elevation
Other
Public Comment
Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB
Date/Time ,13
To: Historic District Commission
From: Historic Structures Advisory Board
Mqihbers Present
(� Angus MacLeod () Michael May () Jascm onardo Finger ( Ilton Rowland () Brook Meerbergen
Alternate: ( nucy Dillon
Applicant AAddressjr1
Historic informatio own history
?-
() Non -Contributing () Contributing () Individually significant
Comments
() Incomplete application () Historical information neededNo Concerns () Recommend View
() Does not meet guidelines () Not appropriate (As noted below)
North Elevation
East Elevation
West Elevation
South Elevation
Other
Public C waraen
Si b r quorum)
J
Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB
Date/Time 7U
To: Historic District Commission
From: Historic Structures Advisory Board
bers Present
(I Angus MacLeod O Michael May O Jascin eonardo Finger ( Ilton Rowland O Brook Meerbergen
Alternate: ( YLucy Dillon
Applicant'TAddress ZZ a
Historic information/known history
O Non -Contributing O Contributing O Individually significant
Comments
O Incomplete application O Historical information needed W_<o Concerns O Recommend View
() Does not meet guidelines () Not appropriate (As noted below)
North Elevation
East Elevation
West Elevation
South Elevation
Other
Public Comment
r e quorum) h&
Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB
Date/Time /��/ /
17
To: Historic District Commission
From: Historic Structures Advisory Board
Me hers Present
(ngus MacLeod ( ) Michael May () Jasc' eonardo Finger ( Milton Rowland ( ) Brook Meerbergen
Alternate: (cy Dillon
Applicant Address U
Historic information/known history
( ) Non -Contributing () Contributing () Individually significant
Comments
O Incomplete application O Historical information needed O No Concerns O Recommend View
( ) Does not meet guidelines ( ) Not appropriate (As noted below)
North Elevation
East Elevation
West Elevation
So4WElevation
Q /(/
Public Comment
Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB
Date/Time
To: Historic District Commission
From: Historic Structures Advisory Board
Mqrnbers Present
144 gus MacLeod ( ) Michael May O Jasci5Xeonardo, Finger ( Milton Rowland ( ) Brook Meerbergen
Alternate: ( JyLucy Dillon
Applicant Address 44
Historic information/known history
( ) Non -Contributing ( ) Contributing ( ) Individually significant
Comments
( ) Incomplete application O Historical information needed O No Concerns O Recommend View
( ) Does not meet guidelines () Not appropriate (As noted below)
East Elevation
West Elevation
South,Elevation A.
Public Comment
4doo,K4�1�o, uorum)
Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB
Date/Time '/ G�'� / / •�f
To: Historic District Commission
From: Historic Structures Advisory Board
Me bers Present
(�gus MacLeod () Michael May () Jascin 1poifa5rdo Finger Rowland () Brook Meerbergen
Alternate: ( ucy Dillon
Applicant r Address
V 711
Historic information/known history
( ) Non -Contributing O Contributing O Individually significant
Comments
( ) Incomplete application ( ) Historical information needed O No Concerns O Recommend View
( ) Does not meet guidelines () Not appropriate (As noted below)
North Elevation
East Elevation
West Elevation
South Elevation
Other
Public Comment
Sl mb r equorun: — �/� e