HomeMy WebLinkAbout2019-4-8Approved Minutes April 8, 2019, adopted April 22, 20.19..
Historic District Commission
Historic Structures Advisory Board
Members: Micky Rowland, Michael May, Jascin Finger, Angus Macleod, Brook Meerbergen
Alternate Member: Lucy Dillon
Planning and Land Use Services
2 Fairgrounds Road
Nantucket, Massachusetts 02554
MINUTES
Monday April 8, 2019
I. Procedural Business
Call to order at 3:31 pm.
Attending members: Lucy Dillon and Brook Meerbergen
Absent members: Mickey Rowland and Michael May
Late arrivals: Angus Macleod and Jascin-Leonardo-Finger at 3:33 pm.
Early Departures: None.
Motion to Adopt Agenda made by Lucy Dillon; Seconded by Brook Meerbergen.
Vote: carried unanimously
Approval of Minutes: Match 25, 2019 and April 3, 2019.
Motion to Approve made by Angus Macleod; Seconded by Lucy Dillon.
Vote: carried unanimously.
II. Public Comment
Nonc.
Page 1 of 2
\ C
Approved Minutes April 8, 2019, adopted April 22, 2019
III. New Business — See attached Comments
Property Owner Street Street Address Scope of Work
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.
13.
14.
15.
16.
17.
18.
19.
Nant. Lightship Museum
Mercaldi, Maria
Moore, Bill
Raul, Allen
Breed, Allen
N.I.R.
Mackey, Liam
Veranda House, LLC
Kilmartin, John
Harold Bros. Realty
N.H.A.
Ericksen, Ana
Jemison, Steve
High Garden Holdings, LLC
High Garden Holdings, LLC
High Garden Holdings, LLC
High Garden Holdings. LLC
16 Orange Street, LLC
Pino, Maria
49 Union Street
80G Washington Street
3 W. Chester Street
109 Main Street
7 West Chester Street
14 Swain Street
3 N. Union Street
3 Steps Lane
11 New Mill Street
23 Walsh Street
15 Broad Street
22 Orange Street
9 West Chester Street
40 Jefferson Avenue
40 Jefferson Avenue
40 Jefferson Avenue
40 Jefferson Avenue
16 Orange Street
44 York Street
HVAC unit
Window replacement
Color change
Relocate fence
Brick driveway
Replace deck
Rev 71908; window chg
Roof change
Addition
Firepit
Add deck/add awning
Restoration/addition
Rev 70107
New dwelling
Cabana
Gym
pool
Window revisions
Fence
Map/Parcel
55.1.4-31
42.2.3-20.6
42.4.3-14
42.3.3-150
42.4.3-13
42.4.1-82
42.3.1-214.2
42.4.2-44
55.4.4-87
42.4.1-105
42.2.2-61
42.3.2-225
42.4.3-12
30-119
30-119
30-119
30-119
42.3.2-14
55.4.1-53.1
Motion to approve comments from New Business items 1 — 19.
Motion made by Lucy Dillon; Seconded by Angus Macleod.
Vote: Carried unanimously
IV. Other Business
• Discussion of Mission Statement for town website.
None.
Agent
Lucy Dillon
Devon Murphy
NAG
Atlantic Landscaping
Mark Lombardi
Self
Emeritus
Chris Carey
Topham Design
Self
Concept Design
Botticelli & Pohl
JB Studio
Emeritus
Emeritus
Emeritus
Emeritus
Emeritus
Self
• Vote- Expanding HSAB map for review of applications.
Motion to adopt made by Jascin-Leonardo-Finger; Seconded by Brook Meerbergen.
Vote: carried unanimously.
V. Adjournment
Motion to Adjourn made by Angus Macleod; Seconded by Lucy Dillon at 5:24 pm.
Vote: Carried unanimously.
Submitted by Cathy Flynn
Page 2 of 2
Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB
Date/Tine 4. F
To: Historic District Commission
From: Historic Structures Advisory Board
Members Present
gus MacLeod ( ) Michael May -Jascin Leonardo Finger O Milton Rowland � Brook Meerbergen
(( Alterhate: O Lucy Damon
``tea
Applicant�-,T%� f= �. .s � ..( tf t. �.<4 .��,_ Address
Historic information/known history
( ) Non -Contributing Contributing O Individually significant
Comments
O Incomplete application O Historical information needed O No Concerns O Recommend View
() Does not meet guidelines () Not appropriate (As noted below)
North Elevation
East Elevation
West Elevation
South Elevation
Other
/��,f-. "`"'�. Com✓ :/ C_'��E'Gs J C°� �G�GL; �L�� ��-�-�V�-�-' '� �' T
1 - - • C.
c^
i
Public Comment
S atureS (three members required for quorum)
>'I've
Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB
Date/Time (� —f },
�•'�1c�
To: Historic District Commission
From: Historic Structures Advisory Board
Members Present
YAngus MacLeod ( ) Michael May Jascin Leonardo Finger O Milton Rowland Brook Meerbergen
Alte ate:( Lucy Dillon
Applicant ��/1 Z1�{CC �r'r`"r."r:�.rc Address (:1i
J
Historic information/known history
O Non -Contributing O Contributing O Individually significant
Comments
O Incomplete application O Historical information needed O No Concerns O Recommend View
( ) Does not meet guidelines () Not appropriate (As noted below)
North Elevation
East Elevation
West Elevation
South Elevation
Other --- -
J'
Public Comment
W �l
Signatures (three melfj8e�s�fiG fg�fi� '
Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB
Date/Time lam' I ' ( � f
To: Historic District Commission
From: Historic Structures Advisory Board
Members Present
(`Angus MacLeod ( ) Michael Mayascin Leonardo Finger OMilton Rowland Brook Meerbergen
Alternate: (J ucy Dillon —
Applicant I ��r�7y� �� t f Address
Historic infonnation/known history
O Non -Contributing O Contributing O Individually significant
Comments
O Incomplete application O Historical information needed O No Concerns O Recommend View
( ) Does not meet guidelines O Not appropriate (As noted below)
North Elevation
East Elevation
West Elevation
South Elevation
Other
—LSI)., I y .✓
F �
Public Comment
Sl atureS (three mem er ��fio 7
Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB
Date/Time: `� L, �j. '';`
: rS
r r
To: Historic District Commission
From: Historic Structures Advisory Board
Members Present
�( �,Angus MacLeod O Michael May 04Jascin Leonardo Finger O Milton Rowland ��cJ Brook Meerbergen
Alternate: Lucy Dillon
Applicant ' G' ,,__ ��- `_r t Address (' ) K�� is
Historic information/known history
( ) Non -Contributing O Contributing O Individually significant
Comments
O Incomplete application OHistorical information needed, No Concerns O Recommend View
O Does not meet guidelines O Not appropriate (As noted below)
North Elevation
East Elevation
West Elevation
South Elevation
Other
Public Comment
atureS
;` e}�s rre u�
(three'
G 7 � _
l /
Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB
Date/Time %(' ( ,
To: Historic District Commission
Front: Historic Structures Advisory Board
Members Present
(').-Angus MacLeod O Michael May � 4Jascin Leonardo Finger O Milton Rowland XTBrook Meerbergen
Alternate: (Lucy Dillon
Applicant fAQee(-)-L' �F Address
Historic infonnation/known history
( ) Non -Contributing O Contributing O Individually significant
Comments
( ) Incomplete application O Historical information needed O No Concerns O Recommend View
( ) Does not meet guidelines () Not appropriate (As noted below)
North Elevation
East Elevation {1
t4iL GtC' 'vC l C,c
West Elevation C�. � ra) rh
Lv/
South Elevation
Other
Public Comment
Si tures (three 4e� 16�z. o
Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB
Date/TimeCi q L"C", f
To: Historic District Commission
From: Historic Structures Advisory Board
Members Present
Angus MacLeod O Michael May O Jascin Leonardo Finger OMilton Rowland j�) Brook Meerbergen
Alteil ate: (-I Lucy Dillon /
7
Applicant% Address `- `A;
Historic information/known history
( ) Non -Contributing O Contributing O Individually significant
Comments
Incomplete application O Historical information needed O No Concerns O Recommend View
()Does not meet guidelines ()Not appropriate (As noted below)
North Elevation
East Elevation
West Elevation
South Elevation
Other
e
Public Comment
SiQn3tur eS (three f r o
Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB
C'S �
Date/Timet`_! C/ C ;y -` 1°)
To: Historic District Commission
From: Historic Structures Advisory Board
Members Present
��ngus MacLeod O Michael May lJascin Leonardo Finger O Milton Rowland Brook Meerbergen
Alternate: (14lucy Dillon
t
Applicant �}'>c�r AL -'—
-1 r �Address
� � � , �
Historic information/known history
( ) Non -Contributing O Contributing O Individually significant
Comments
( ) Incomplete application O Historical information needed O No Concerns O Recommend View
( ) Does not meet guidelines () Not appropriate (As noted below)
North Elevation
East Elevation
West Elevation
South Elevation 5
VV Vv,M1
Other
7 � '". i
.1
Public Comment
i
Signatures (threer/i' Ie 'l 're f r u
Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB
!�
Date/Time C,; �'"� � t= 5%
To: Historic District Commission
From: Historic Structures Advisory Board
Members Present
Angus MacLeod O Michael May �4.Jascin Leonardo Finger O Milton Rowland .rook Meerbergen
Alternate: (4Lucy Dillon
Applicant Address
Historic infonnation/known history
( ) Non -Contributing O Contributing O Individually significant
Comments
O Incomplete application O Historical information needo�*o Concerns O Recommend View
( ) Does not meet guidelines () Not appropriate (As noted below)
North Elevation
East Elevation
West Elevation
South Elevation
Other
Public Comment
Signatures (three me r r o
Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB
Date/Time L_' `'�
To: Historic District Commission
From: Historic Structures Advisory Board
Members Present
(Angus MacLeod O Michael May )'41ascin Leonardo Finger O Milton Rowland ( Brook Meerbergen
Altdnate: (Xtucy Dillon
Applicant iii ti -I k_ ►. , rl Address
Historic information/known history
O Non -Contributing Contributing O Individually significant
Comments
O Incomplete application O Historical information needed O No Concerns O Recommend View
( ) Does not meet guidelines Not appropriate (As noted below)
North Elevation
East Elevation
West Elevation
South Elevation
Other
AkT ir>ii7�r� ts�i Ott`. F-1� i►.(w=� i� t"s : z 1�c'r�l� �ktllt t i GGL I." ►moi r.r T
"k -f (.4 K. = -
Public Comment
Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB
Date/Tune
To: Historic District Commission
Front: Historic Structures Advisory Board
Members Present
f, A IAngus MacLeod O Michael May (s� Jascin Leonardo Finger O Milton Rowland Brook Meerbergen
Alternate: '(,)`Lucy Dillon
Applicant l r Address
Historic information/known history
( ) Non -Contributing O Contributing O Individually significant
Comments
O Incomplete application O Historical information needed O No Concerns O Recommend View
( ) Does not meet guidelines Not appropriate (As noted below)
North Elevation
East Elevation
West Elevation
South Elevation
Other
t:7- i t -=.E,.' i_� � 6- � 5 r -7i 9. r �. � air `Y� r�2.�� 3±=:ul S7 �-�- �- r-• t�.c--'s-rYl�c•i7
Public Comment
Signatures (three
Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB
Date/Time c`_ c ( Cf -
To:
' C
To: Historic District Commission
From: Historic Structures Advisory Board
Members Present
Angus MacLeod O Michael May 04 Jascin Leonardo Finger O Milton Rowland /'C- Brook Meerbergen
Alternate: �4 Lucy Dillon
Applicant_A,_ { {-,,- Address
Historic information/known history
O Non -Contributing O Contributing O Individually significant
Comments
( ) Incomplete application O Historical information needed �KNo Concerns O Recommend View
( ) Does not meet guidelines () Not appropriate (As noted below)
North Elevation
East Elevation
West Elevation
South Elevation
Other
Public Comment
S1Q11atureS (three mem q p )
Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB
Date/Tine C'_—, `( c,: �)
To: Historic District Commission
From: Historic Structures Advisory Board
Members Present
(Angus MacLeod ( ) Michael May Jascin Leonardo Finger O Milton Rowland Brook Meerbergen
Alte ate: �(,j Lucy Dillon
Applicants 'Z Wiz. �, .� Address
Historic information/known history
( ) Non -Contributing ( ) Contributing ( ) Individually significant
Comments
__Sfif V v M� �I
J
O Incomplete application O Historical information needed O No Concerns ) Recommend View
( ) Does not meet guidelines O Not appropriate (As noted below)
c
North Elevation ,
East Elevation
South Elevation
�� /L./!a2�L'ZL'� �`,'"J"L /1(L��%L e"�ll7rr77`L. '`�._t;�s'i2tG'/� ' �/'L�'�p '^�1:✓ ! il� �%1��
J.
Other
4-,
Public Comment
a
Sign tures (three members
Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB
-/'I-
Date/Time L 1-_( ` �' I)
To: Historic District Commission
From: Historic Structures Advisory Board
Members Present
(,Angus MacLeod O Michael May Vr Jascin Leonardo Finger O Milton Rowland 0�rook Meerbergen
Alternate: �j Lucy Dillon
Address ''i
Historic information/known history
O Non -Contributing Contributing O Individually significant
X` �:�,'`�•.
Comments
O Incomplete application O Historical information needed O No Concerns O Recommend View
( ) Does not meet guidelines O Not appropriate (As noted below)
North Elevation
t L , z' Y 0L r !c_
`rF \c,e'�--t L q—rte Z� l t L' c l L fi'i i ` �[� v L r
'h -� I " �: L L""t--S l ? k Z. C
East Elevation
West Elevation
South Elevation
L V �. ', i { lip �-� d •l l _ --- /;
.c- a R (_A-
gA
Other r- z c ;
Public Comment
vizt-�
u6
S atUTeS (three men¢bers-rPrfy�f g ,
t,
Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum
Date/Time C.� L ( . C%
To: Historic District Commission
From: Historic Structures Advisory Board
H��/HSQB
Members Present
(Angus MacLeod O Michael May Y—)'Jascin Leonardo Finger O Milton Rowland Xbrook Meerbergen
Altemate: (aj Lucy Dillon
l�=i(i� L ci.G
Applicant���rt���;�, L—L,/-Addressl�
Historic information/known history
O Non -Contributing O Contributing O Individually significant r
Comments
O Incomplete application O Historical information neededr,No Concerns O Recommend View
( ) Does not meet guidelines O Not appropriate (As noted below)
North Elevation 1—
East Elevation
r
West Elevation
South Elevation
Other
(;
Public Comment
FAN— j1 i fVL(t`�
Signatures (three bers requi f quorum
e;
U
Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum H[FC/HSAP.
Date/Tune Li �e _ H <, _ 12 J
To: Historic District Commission
From: Historic Structures Advisory Board \ ;_
\ i
Members Present
O_Angus MacLeod OMichael May r( rascin Leonardo Finger OMilton Rowland -Brook Meerbergen
Alternate: Wucy Dillon
Applicant kAk ("16— L 4,-. Address L l
Historic information/known history
O Non -Contributing O Contributing O Individually significant
Comments
( ) Incomplete application O Historical information needed O No Concerns O Recommend View
( ) Does not meet guidelines ( ) Not appropriate (As noted below)
North Elevation
East Elevation
West Elevation
South Elevation
Other
d
Public Comment
Signatures (three
V �t l� 1^'
Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum
Date/Time `__-' ` r' C \ 10
To: Historic District Commission
Front: Historic Structures Advisory Board
NQ�/HSa4B -
91 'j' Ni 2_ .J C �, 12- VI3
Members Present
-Angus MacLeod O Michael May k Jascin Leonardo Finger O Milton Rowland Brook Meerbergen
Alternate: (&Lucy Dillon
Applicant Address
Historic information/known history
( ) Non -Contributing ( ) Contributing O Individually significant
Comments
( ) Incomplete application O Historical information needed O No Concerns O Recommend View
( ) Does not meet guidelines O Not appropriate (As noted below)
North Elevation
East Elevation
West Elevation
South Elevation
Other
Z_/ t- !'� r' ' "qt=r' ►=�=1'
! )LOA, � '�' i i it G C(
Public Comment
Signatures (three memt�gjfi�f
Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum 1. NVC/H3AB
Date/Time i �� (� G ,i i ! SF`! 12: 3
To: Historic District Commission
From: Historic Structures Advisory Board
Members Present
Angus MacLeod O Michael May X). Jascin Leonardo Finger O Milton Rowland Brook Meerbergen
Alternate: Lucy Dillon
Applicant!Address
Historic information/known history
( ) Non -Contributing O Contributing O Individually significant
Comments
O Incomplete application O Historical information needed XNo Concerns O Recommend View
( ) Does not meet guidelines () Not appropriate (As noted below)
North Elevation
East Elevation
West Elevation
South Elevation
Other
Public Comment
atUreS (three /�fi�Yitte. r /
Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum
Date/Time
To: Historic District Commission
From: Historic Structures Advisory Board
e , «
k4C, �aAl
Members Present
)(<f� Angus MacLeod O Michael May �41asciu Leonardo Finger O Milton Rowland KBrook Meerbergen
Alterate: Lucy Dillon
Applicant/ f - c._ �� < 1 41. � . _ _ -Address
Historic information/known history
( ) Non -Contributing O Contributing O Individually significant
Comments
( ) Incomplete application O Historical information needed O No Concerns O Recommend View
( ) Does not meet guidelines () Not appropriate (As noted below)
North Elevation
East Elevation
1. �r
�i
West Elevation
South Elevation
Other
Public Comment
Signatures (three members re 2
Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum r �'
2015 A F r ? F;'12:3J_
r
Date/Time
To: Historic District Commission
Front: Historic Structures Advisory Board
Members Present
'(�).Angus MacLeod O Michael May '(.)Jascin Leonardo Finger OMilton Rowland `(,$rook Meerbergen
Alternate: �- ,ucy Dillon
Applicant 7( V�,,� Address– z� iL37 i'-:-
Historic information/lmown history
( ) Non -Contributing O Contributing O Individually significant
Comments
O Incomplete application O Historical information needed O No Concerns O Recommend View
( ) Does not meet guidelines () Not appropriate (As noted below)
North Elevation
East Elevation
West Elevation
,U
South Elevation L,
ntli er
Ajca, , r
!—T2
�3
Public Comment
U_
Sl tures (three nz�ib z !
i`