HomeMy WebLinkAbout2019-1-28 ( (-
Approved Minutes January 28, 2019, adopted February 11, 2019
;1.6-
•
\9paRAtO
/tom
Historic District Commission
Historic Structures Advisory Board
Members: Micky Rowland,Michael May,Jascin Finger,Angus Macleod,Brook Meerbergen
Alternate Member:Lucy Dillon
Planning and Land Use Services
2 Fairgrounds Road
Nantucket,Massachusetts 02554
MINUTES
January 28, 2019
I. Procedural Business
Call to order at 3:34 pm.
Attending members: Jascin Leonardo-Finger, Michael May,Angus Macleod,Lucy Dillon
Absent members: Micky Rowland and Brook Meerbergen
Late arrivals: None.
Early Departures: Lucy Dillon at 5:20 pm.
Motion to Adopt Agenda made by Jascin Leonardo-Finger; Seconded by Lucy Dillon.
Vote: carried unanimously
Approval of Minutes:January 02, 2019;January 10, 2019
Motion made by Jascin Leonardo-Finger; Seconded by Angus Macleod.
Vote: carried unanimously
II. Public Comment
Linda Williams represented 65 Center Street.
Page 1 of 2
Approved Minutes January 28, 2019, adopted February 11, 2019
III. New Business —See attached Comments
Property Owner Street Street Address Scope of Work Map/Parcel Agent
1. Mackey,Liam 3 N.Union Street Rev. 71722;fenestration 42.3.1-214.2 Emeritus
2. Sayer,John 10 Gardner Street A/C unit 42.3.3-13 Rhoda Weinman
3. Regina,George 25C Pine Street A/C Unit 42.3.2-48.1 Rhoda Weinman
4. Ainslie Lee Trustee 9 Howard Street Relocate HVAC 42.3.3-54 Mike Freedman
5. Maloney,Rosalie 15 Old North Wharf Rev 71058;lift/stairs 42.3.1-26 McMullen&Associates
6. 16 Orange,LLC 16 Orange Street Rev.71602;color change 42.3.2-4 Emeritus
7. 86 Main Street N.T. 86 Main Street Studio rear exterior stairs 42.3.3-66 Thomewill Design
8. Haley,Victor 94 Orange Street Addition 55.1.4-47 Concept Design
9. Kimchee Bedding,LLC 27 W.Chester Street Rev 69765;fenestration 42.4.3-2 Botticelli&Pohl
10. Wepler,John 8 Fair Street Rev 67571;arbor gate 42.3.1-107 Val Oliver
11. Wepler,John 8 Fair Street Rev67572;lattice/pipe/brckts 42.3.1-107 Val Oliver
12. Brown,Christina 69 N.Liberty Street Alterations/deck/doors 41-142 Val Oliver
13. Sullivan Krueger Fam Tr 6 New Lane Move-demo 41-294 BPC
14. K225,LLC 65 Center Street Renovation/addition 42.4.3-16 Linda Williams
15. K225,LLC 65 Center Street Demo grarage/studio 42.4.3-16 Linda Williams
Motion to approve comments from New Business items #1 - #15.
Motion made by Jascin Leonardo-Finger; Seconded by Michael May.
Vote: carried unanimously
IV. Adjournment
Motion to Adjourn made by Michael May;Seconded by Jascin Leonardo-Finger at 5:26 pm.
Vote: Carried Unanimously.
Submitted by Cathy Flynn
Page 2 of 2
Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB
Date/Time Ari 11a(((141 to U't
V
To: Historic District Commission
From: Historic Structures Advisory Board
M tubers Present
Angus MacLeod ( )Michael May Jascin Leonardo Finger ( )Milton Rowland ( )Brook Meerbergen
Alternate:V)Lucy Dillon 3
Applicant G C ELu1 Address iJ• iM/oh
Historic information/known history
()Non-Contributing 0)Contributing ()Individually significant
Comments
0)Incomplete application ()Historical information needed No Concerns 0)Recommend View
()Does not meet guidelines 0)Not appropriate (As noted below
North Elevation
•
East Elevation
West Elevation
South Elevation
Other
Public Comment
71%0_1,
Siaia►,i es(three\`embersr q u
kilt( I�JCI IGS ��ir for quorum)
fel t CIA
Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB
Date/Time tbtiUtCvi"(' 16/9.
To: Historic District Commission
From: Historic Structures Advisory Board
Memb5rs Present
( Bogus MacLeod4)42j:it&
ael ( Jascinnardo Finger ( )Milton Rowland ' ( )Brook Meerbergen
Alternate: ( ucy Dillon
Applicant S CA eV Address /0 ( 6vcittLK
Historic information/known history
()Non-Contributing ()Contributing ()Individually significant
Comments
()Incomplete application ()Historical information needed ()No Concerns 0)Recommend View
()Does not meet guidelines ()Not appropriate (As noted below)
North Elevation
(k)/5 1S 61,0 as—bi,-off, Shaid he dzidrCrca c/iyiy,
v
cSh a1,,W cy ` -e , J cov ,-r/2
64ok 1
East Elevation I, WI v7a � n s+-Ca1
West Elevation
South Elevation
Other
Public Comment
irtSignAtures(thbensreguir for�gttot�m)
+�C� ;tk e0/44(10 Gam.,
Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB
Date/Time I 25I1017.
To: Historic District Commission
From: Historic Structures Advisory Board
Mem ets Present
(4. 1grus MacLeod ( chael May (" rasc' `eonardo Finger ( )Milton Rowland ' ( )Brook Meerbergen
Alternate: ( ucy Dillon
Applicant if((',k) Address 2 5 C //M
Historic information/known history
()Non-Contributing ()Contributing ()Individually significant
Comments
()Incomplete application ()Historical information needed ()No Concerns 0)Recommend View
()Does not meet guidelines ()Not appropriate (As noted below)
North Elevation
Ihi5 is aVF a5-ho 1-1 ---ke fir/ 'e. assfc,S CI
�t u ci l niircte -to lovIC
U' /tie a /eadeK.
East Elevation 14. sh at d n Qi- /, 7�UIQ lr haiz
who is d I,P If`-this ? /nIzTi/(eks Pt-ESn< tto
,� } t{-`ll E (f/Le� q haw So / al
West Elevation ht �(/G/�/ � /�t
.1-5. CSC ,ecliv -e S:, .4 mom �r/r .
South Elevation 2
C 1 io.I (S f ,I/tc CA 't l , , 5�i .
Other
Public Comment
� / �/y
V w '�
i nature (t ee members requ'ed for quorum)1I'?V1
I Uitatc O f it( ` / /----/ 7
Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB
Date/Time 120 201 9 1
To: Historic District Commission
From: Historic Structures Advisory Board
Members Present �'
( gus MacLeod ( ) chael May ( ascm L ardo Finger ( )Milton Rowland ( )Brook Meerbergen
Alternate: ( ucy Dillon
Applicant Ai V64 Address ?tiatiaed
Historic information/known history
()Non-Contributing ()Contributing O Individ»ally significant
Comments
0)Incomplete application ()Historical information needed ()No Concerns 0)Recommend View
()Does not meet guidelines ()Not appropriate (As noted below)
North Elevation SQ_, OW-
'Mid 1 V 110/a i -6 CLMi
•
bods * lob', 1l teaote s 4 ho*.
East Elevationl Glk 1 C /10
/ /P
West Elevation
South Elevation
Other
Public Comment
Si eS(t ee mbersnrequi d for quorum) / /
ni�t1�1 titVl(id 671 hGr-
��
Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB
Date/Time LT j S
To: Historic District Commission
From: Historic Structures Advisory Board
Members Present
( )Angus MacLeod ( )Michael May ( )Jascin Leonardo Finger ( )Milton Rowland ( )Brook Meerbergen
Alternate: ( )Lucy Dillon At. ^
Applicant HCLiOY1L/ Address / , ofd (,u\1-a vf
Historic information/known history
()Non-Contributing ()Contributing ()Individually significant
Comments
QQ Incomplete application ()Historical information needed ()No Concerns 0)Recommend View
()Does not meet guidelines ()Not appropriate (As noted below)
North Elevation
Th t S 14.6a4S at CfOCoaOi w7 a L 4-KeSeaic L
avid a rir. aft e 1h(,s ( ?k ke c(thmatecf.
East Elevation
A tiliravAdS bed-
,
West Elevation
/JO OMCA4 Of Milid ka 0/0 .
`-fh(scS ci i �- covuirormse,S any
South Elevation hisimc 'i h rill QS'
Other
Public Comment
/
y i atnr (t ee members red for quorumgcl.......... ......c........L„ /
If /� nnM iii 'n hII/M l
Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB
Date/Time 117 6 I o
To: Historic District Commission
From: Historic Structures Advisory Board
Me ers Present
(gus MacLeod ( ael May ( ascin eonardo Finger ()Milton Rowland ()Brook Meerbergen
Alternate: ( cy Dillon
Applicant / ( OVGZI'&)C' Sf. 1CC Address /(b Oran
Historic information/known history
()Non-Contributing '1 Contributing ()Individually significant
Comments
()Incomplete application ()Historical information needed ()No Concerns ()Recommend View
()Does not meet guidelines ()Not appropriate (As noted below)
North Elevation
7/1Cd- IS -fcro math,/ Col Vit
mod of 4-hrs ho)4w
East Elevation
O.( .d , l) cbiaV\1 car9 color. It catmo-- be cfait ct am "4--
miwaf . .: ' .
1
West Elevation0519-13
iiva/1,16 bact )F
South Elevation
Other
Public Comment
Sl tures(ta tubers r quired quorum)
Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB
Date/Time Z V zo/, T
To: Historic District Commission
From: Historic Structures Advisory Board
Me ers Present
( Angus MacLeod ( chael May ( ascin onardo Finger I '•tot �. , -.: ( )Brook Meerbergen
Alternate: ( ucy Dillon
Applicant t2) l/ 5(0 /1C?If1 (9. j rAddress 8( . / i a 114:
Historic information/known history
()Non-Contributing ()Contributing ()Individually significant
Comments
0)Incomplete application ()Historical information needed ()No Concerns Recommend View
()Does not meet guidelines 0)Not appropriate (As noted below)
North Elevation
kk hejthit if I S V)01 0&R e. '-/i & a pprwalle
hvt Shca. c/ b vteaxd •71 . i-'
East Elevation pivtS Y -� ( eci �' G� /C� v sic1 st c_Q)
1
and (Aam 7 ? , lan (v,ea or 144 kes �e.
J
West Elevation
•
South Elevation
Other
Public Comment '
Si.fill
atur S(t'ee members re ed for quorum) 7 � �/ 71‘-) ,
Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB
Date/Time 11 2,6 Zo 19 6.-:'6
To: Historic District Commission
From: Historic Structures Advisory Board
Members Present
Angus MacLeod (Michael May ( Jascin Leonardo Finger ( )Milton Rowland • ( )Brook Meerbergen
Alternate.X)Lucy Dillon
Applicant 4t1 tjAddress G
Historic information/known history
•
()Non-Contributing ((Contributing ()Individually significant
Comments ��11
()Incomplete application ()Historical information needed ()No Concerns 0)Recommend View
()Does not meet guidelines ()Not appropriate (As noted below)
North Elevation
Why; l S arc otvea v ill Q chowigiy 01497f0
kik(u;o ei ? (,'Gil vI Kteds vitgaio.
East Elevation ;IQ/IQs f 2;IQ/ i/e-6K fitc4, 0),
i.s iS hof GZ Gl dill w oSU
Lean. reduce—W o ias0/7 f -1 -to best)/0
West Elevation
0-6(
/1 b Gni
South Elevation 14`sh76 76 i n t b cL
Other
Public Comment
.r—
tures(�e members reg d for quorum) ` /
1 "fit- marl r 4 i�,�, 4I,, •
Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB
Date/Time I Z )iii
To: Historic District Commission
From: Historic Structures Advisory Board
Mem ers Present
((.), g-Lis MacLeod ( chael May ( ascin Leo do Finger ( )Milton Rowland ( )Brook Meerbergen
Alternate: (- cy Dillon
Applicant k,truiiu / - Address 277 W r Chskv .
Historic information/known history
0)Non-Contributing ()Contributing ()Individually significant
Comments
()Incomplete application ()Historical information needed ()No Concerns 0)Recommend View
()Does not meet guidelines ()Not appropriate (As noted below)
ra4it sSbuil(c,1 Ih wow/.
J
�asr E vanon- ci
(, )14cJ- is 0 c o.-f c,u'lrrio ) O✓) 2— , �ot c�
a 1447 5-lk on ecosi
West Elevation 1kL / ncv/ crkiiq3
ercepfw vr V dO,hev
-lite. 4 a ' &P eat CtJfav comitici3O
gatitiimvateff
Other
Public Comment
•
1
j
1`14 ::64'; '
Sl es(t ee embers require r quorum) 7 ilii i . Ani1a:,i%t1hi4r2,`- I
Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB
Date/Time I 7019 5?06
To: Historic District Commissions /
From: Historic Structures Advisory Board /OW
Men a ers Present
( i gus MacLeod hael May O4.T n ardo Finger O Milton Rowland '()Brook Meerbergen
Alternate: ( ucy Dillon
Applicant t&ple t Address 8. 1T
Historic infonnationn/lmown history
()Non-Contributing ()Contributing ()Individually significant
Comments
()Incomplete application ()Historical information needed ()No Concerns 0)Recommend View
()Does not meet guidelines 0)Not appropriate (As noted below)
North Elevation
(his a cis ham; — as ess-4i .
1r;11uaV,e £h GuYZ (, S i G - eg-e l 7b 9 -A-
U _U
East Elevation
I-I- kVitS /11WYthieho4 i S v%sbe. —
West Elevation ._L+ s h�iu/C/ 19 X31 `'' i�'' " a S i v��C%►'
South Elevation
Other
Public Comment
41110 /74.7--\
Signatures(three me ers required for orum) 4411111r1�7t 914 niers
Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB
Date/Time I i(J 1 7019
To: Historic District Commission
From: Historic Structures Advisory Board
e bers Present
y
gus MacLeod (ylichael May y)Jascjn Leonardo Finger ( )Milton Rowland • ( )Brook Meerbergen
Alternate:Lucy Dillon
Applicant Wii UV/ Address e v
Historic information/lmown history
()Non-Contributing ()Contributing ()Individually significant
d5ses5 Comments J�/ kes.
()Incomplete application 0)Historical information needed ()No Concerns 0)Recommend View
()Does not meet guidelines ()Not appropriate (As noted below)
North Elevation &ATbmc wrl i be Kemov 7 (. `/2a /�,f�� . - �? gyp'
East Elevation
l td cirli2, CleCk -0o1--o rimpt . 1414cve .
West Elevation /!`' e ie C L C COO—
SOY)- 0-F he ' mce-e K i,1/hrdc i,U box .7/Ornate%
South Elevation ai CI ok1 3cte Q-Phod e �./ ��0 ���`
tOhtt 15 ILeve a ccs ' `'`r-i dvath bc1C•04v
Other
Ccm&v Cocee-- cJ D co c/'7 � /7SP
�r-- 00f-�= iv� rc� as f'.�
Public Comment
proae of bay( Fail,- hum the za.1--9d-we:Kb?
i
Sl es(three members required for Drum) /- / ' /
-41,1" .t.�1n.. /T -A.. .._ W
SCI --
Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB
Date/Time IZ��f/O C' .--",'?—O
To: Historic District Commission
From: Historic Structures Advisory Board
Mems Present
( �. ngus MacLeod ( chael May ( j Jascin Leonardo Finger ( )Milton Rowland ( )Brook Meerbergen
Alternate: ( )Lucy Dillon
Applicant i5rZ m... Address (-t 7.Al. Il/o
I
Historic infonnation/known history
0)Non-ContributingContributing ()Individually significant
Comments
(complete applicationHistorical information needed ()No Concerns 0)Recommend View
WDoes not meet guidelines $Not appropriate (As noted below)
North Elevation
CAMcc Gas V, i6Veal i 414 Se GAG'S beeyt___
Ii? eci vyi K.ece -i -has n 6 5�,
East Elevation
i\leLd
l (S i'is1C ?t
cos
Li'UVc do-(9 efte (4- , Jdw 1thL I(
West Elevation
NA/ Was ( yno or eAdvii a wed 2
South Elevation
if titsig-6 kiraid5 bad-
Other `* Ct. co 1 otreriie ---A
��UrV) IqO
I-I- r cls.* be a LS* as d-hacl.
Public Comment /tad mays
y (' 't c p1eas — r�(JTn
kciivx bk,11 .
p 1thJ--/dices Va;ds UK( PA _1"k
S'.u.i' es(threemembersrequir-djorquorum) _
Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB
Date/Time I I Lt 1 10 19 V:
To: Historic District Commission
From: Historic Structures Advisory Board
Me7bers Present �
( Angus MacLeod ( y16,Chael May ascin Leonardo Finger ( )Milton Rowland ( )Brook Meerbergen
Alternate: ( )Lucy Dillon
faro,
Applicant (SJ�IIVakVr r7—,�, Address (Q il€JL4nQ,
Historic information/known history
()Non-Contributing , Contributing ()Individually significant
Comments
()Incomplete application ()Historical information needed ()No Concerns 0)Recommend View
0)Does not meet guidelines Not appropriate (As noted below)
North Elevation
71 rs i s cc/Lia//y
abo 1736/9'o(r cf (95 as
erryikai
0001/10+- am/6a_ u)/o /Pick)/f • 4(.1/(td—
East
c1/Gd—
East Elevation
NMCI clo in rk iiaae _
West Elevation . -i- a ( to IUz e alSe3 n iVe aK
tosiho Atm _,e51,0e:rie
4S cfrI1 L . 9( S Rl)'
South Elevation I,,
LS/f Olt,Id nod & moved 6v clinoAdRol,
Other
Public Comment
i atures thr member req fired for quorum) _