HomeMy WebLinkAbout04032006 Town Meeting Minutes 1
2006 ANNUAL TOWN MEETING
NIGHT ONE - MONDAY, APRIL 3, 2006
The 2006 Annual Town Meeting convened at the Nantucket High School at 10 Surfside Road on April
3, 2006. The Meeting was called to order at 7:10 P.M. by Moderator Sarah F. Alger. She announced the
Advance and Posting of the Colors by the Nantucket Girl Scouts. Moderator Alger led the assembly in the
Pledge of Allegiance. Jr. Miss Constance McDonough Thayer led the assembly in the singing of the Star
Spangled Banner. The Invocation was given by Cantor Avi Teken from the Congregation. Moderator Alger
then asked for a moment of silence in memory of all the residents of the Town who had died since the last
Town Meeting. In particular, the Moderator asked the assembly to remember Faith Oldham, Don Oliver and
Mary P. Walker, for whom the auditorium was named.
At 7:17 PM, there were 535 Registered Voters in attendance.
The Moderator read the Preamble to the Warrant and the Constable’s Return of Service of the
Warrant. She asked for, and received, unanimous consent to waive the reading of the Warrant.
The Moderator moved that the Town Meeting adopt the rules based on Nantucket Town Meetings,
Procedures and Traditions, written by Mark Arnold. It supplements Town Meeting Time as our procedural
guide. It was so moved, seconded, and adopted by unanimous voice vote.
The rules for advancing the Meeting were laid out. She reminded voters that per an Annual Town
Meeting vote from 1998, she could declare a 2/3 majority on zoning articles without a hand count. If she
was in doubt of the 2/3 majority, she would, of course, do a hand count.
She explained the order of the Meeting. She explained that we would commence with the Call of
the Articles, discussing each in the order of the Warrant. If no articles were called, then we would vote on
them as recommended at the end of the Meeting. Moderator Alger explained the procedures to advance
the meeting: speakers must limit their remarks to the article in question, they must refrain from personal
comment or attack, and, most especially, if one were being paid to speak on a particular article, one must
disclose that fact to the assembly. She asked that all cell phones be turned off and reminded smokers not
to smoke on school property.
The Moderator expressed the thanks of the Town Meeting to outgoing Selectman Bruce Watts, and
thanked him for his service to the Town. She introduced the remainder of the sitting Board of Selectmen, the
Town Administrator Libby Gibson, and Town Counsel Paul DeRensis.
The Moderator introduced Rick Atherton, Chairman of the Finance Committee, and members Gregory
Keltz, Phil Bartlett, Lindsay Perry, Michael Rosen, Tim Soverino, Christy Kickham, and Bruce D. Miller. She
then introduced “Time Keeper” Madeline Mallenfant, Town Clerk Catherine Flanagan Stover, and Mary and Al
Novissimo, computer wizards extraordinaire.
Moderator Alger commented on the appearance and content of the Annual Report, thanking the Board
of Selectmen’s office and, particularly, Nancy Oliver for the wonderful job done. She noted that Mrs. Oliver
used to win First Place when allowed to use color! This year’s issue was dedicated to the memories of the late
Martha Walters and the late Norman Beach.
The Moderator introduced Michael Glowacki for the purposes of making an opening statement.
The Moderator read through the list of technical amendments on Articles 2, 4, 10, and XX and
explained where the original text would be modified.
List of Technical Corrections
2
Article 2 (Unpaid Bills)
Add the following unpaid bills to the Finance Committee motion:
Department Vendor Amount
Health Department Comfort Inn $107.50
School Department Comfort Inn $68.01
Article 4 (Revolving Accounts: Annual Authorization)
Remove the Airport Fuel Sales item from the Finance Committee motion.
Article 9 (Appropriation: Health & Human Services)
Amend the last two items of the Finance Committee motion as follows:
AGENCY AMOUNT
Sherburne Commons, Inc.
Nantucket Human Services Center
$5000
$5000
Human Services Nantucket Cottage Hospital/Social Services $25,000
CHANGES TO ARTICLE 10 IF $924,000 IN FREE CASH IS USED:
ARTICLE 10 (Appropriation: General Fund Capital Expenditures)
FINANCE COMMITTEE MOTION: Moved that the following amounts be appropriated for capital expenditures for
general fund departments for Fiscal Year 2006; all such expenditures to be made by the Town Administrator with
the approval of the Board of Selectmen, and further the Town Administrator with the approval of the Board of
Selectmen is authorized to sell, convey, trade-in or otherwise dispose of equipment being replaced as follows:
DEPARTMENT ITEM AMOUNT
Fire
Purchase of additional equipment for Engine 6 new replacement
engine $50,000
Fire Purchase of wireless alarm consoles $75,000
Information
Systems Purchase of new and replacement servers and associated equipment $50,000
Information
Systems Purchase of wireless network equipment $50,000
Information
Systems Purchase of replacement desktops and printers $50,000
Park & Recreation Improvements to Surfside Beach public restrooms $50,000
Police Repairs to windows at Loran Barracks employee housing $60,000
Public Works Repairs and maintenance for bicycle paths and sidewalks $25,000
Public Works Construction of ADA compliant sidewalk ramps $25,000
Public Works Purchase of replacement pick-up trucks (2) with plows (2) $60,000
TOTAL $495,000
And, to meet the appropriation, that Four Hundred Ninety-five Thousand Dollars ($495,000) be raised and
appropriated from the Fiscal Year 2006 tax levy and other general revenues of the Town, contingent however,
upon passage by ballot of a general permanent operating override referendum question exempting this amount
from the limitations of Proposition 2 ½ so-called pursuant to G.L. Ch. 59, § 21C(g);
and, further, that the following capital expenditures for general fund departments be approved for Fiscal Year
2006, all such expenditures to be made by the Town Administrator with the approval of the Board of Selectmen,
3
and further that the Town Administrator with the approval of the Board of Selectmen is authorized to sell, convey,
trade-in or otherwise dispose of equipment being replaced as follows:
DEPARTMENT ITEM AMOUNT
Public Works Purchase of new street sweeper $174,000
School NES building improvements: Installation of unit ventilators $150,000
School CPS building improvements: Repairs to gym roof $250,000
School Development of new playing fields $250,000
School Purchase of computers and related technology equipment $100,000
TOTAL $924,000
And, to meet the appropriation that Nine Hundred Twenty-four Thousand Dollars ($924,000) be raised and
appropriated from the Fiscal Year 2006 tax levy and other general revenues of the Town;
and, further, that the following capital expenditures for general fund departments be approved for Fiscal Year
2006, all such expenditures to be made by the Town Administrator with the approval of the Board of Selectmen,
and further that the Town Administrator with the approval of the Board of Selectmen is authorized to sell, convey,
trade-in or otherwise dispose of equipment being replaced as follows:
DEPARTMENT ITEM AMOUNT
Fire Replacement of Ambulance $150,000
Fire Replace Engine 7 Engines 6 and 7 with one new engine $350,000
Public Works Purchase of new street sweeper $174,000
School NES building improvements: Installation of unit ventilators $150,000
School CPS building improvements: Repairs to gym roof $250,000
School NHS building improvements: Façade repairs and painting $700,000
School Development of new playing fields $250,000
School Purchase of computers and related technology equipment $100,000
Town
Administration
Supplemental funding for Old South Road and Fairgrounds Road
bicycle paths $375,000
Town
Administration Construction and associated costs for Vesper Lane bicycle path $200,000
Town
Administration
Design costs associated with Public Safety Facility at 2 Fairgrounds
Road; and, general site feasibility, including preliminary site planning
and architectural and structural feasibility, for the use of the
remainder of the site for park, cultural/art/community center, open
space, parking and community housing purposes $1,875,000
TOTAL
$4,574,000
$3,650,000
And, to meet the appropriation for all items other than the Fire Department Replacement Ambulance, that
the Treasurer of the Town, with the approval of the Board of Selectmen, is hereby authorized to borrow Four
Million Four Hundred Twenty-four Thousand Dollars ($4,424,000) Three Million Five Hundred Thousand
Dollars ($3,500,000) pursuant to any applicable statute for all of the above items, contingent upon passage by
ballot of a referendum question exempting the principal so borrowed and interest from the limitations of
Proposition 2 ½ so-called (G.L. Ch. 59, § 21C(k)); and, that One Hundred Fifty Thousand Dollars ($150,000)
be appropriated from the Ambulance Reserve Fund for the Fire Department Replacement Ambulance.
Article 12 (Appropriation: Enterprise Funds Operations)
4
CLARIFICATION: in the Finance Committee motion, in the Funding Sources chart, the “FY 06 Anticipated
Revenues” of $3,907,200 shown with Siasconset Water should actually appear with Solid Waste (line in the wrong
place)
Article 13 (Appropriation: Enterprise Fund Capital Expenditures)
Amend the second Wannacomet Water item of the motion as follows:
DEPARTMENT ITEM AMOUNT
Wannacomet
Water
Rehabilitation/improvement of administrative offices Wyer’s Valley Pump
Station
$750,000
Article 15 (Enterprise Accounts: Fiscal Year 2005 Budget Transfers)
Add the following to the chart in the motion:
FROM TO AMOUNT
Airport Retained Earnings Airport Expenses $1,100,000
Solid Waste Retained Earnings Solid Waste Expenses $400,000
Article 20 (Chapter 90 Roadwork)
Change the amount listed in the motion from $373,354 to $371,357
Article 26 (Appropriation: Collective Bargaining Agreement/Public Works Union)
Delete the existing motion and insert: “Moved to take no Action on the Article.”
Article 59 (Home Rule Petition: Sewer System Capital Improvement Fund)
Typo in first sentence of Finance Committee motion; delete the following:
“FINANCE COMMITTEE MOTION: Moved that the Town’s representatives in the General Court be
requested to introduce legislation to create and implement limitations on motor vehicle as set forth below…”
Article 61 (Home Rule Petition: Community Housing Bank)
REVISED FINANCE COMMITTEE MOTION: Moved that the Town’s representatives in the General Court
be requested to introduce legislation seeking a special act set forth below and to authorize the General
Court with the approval of the Board of Selectmen to make constructive changes in perfecting the
language of this proposed legislation in order to secure passage, such legislation to read substantially
as follows:
AN ACT IMPOSING A SURCHARGE ON NEW RESIDENTIAL CONSTRUCTION FOR THE BENEFIT OF
COMMUNITY HOUSING.
SECTION 1. Purpose
The Town of Nantucket is in need of additional financial resources to create, make available and
maintain housing that is affordable to people who earn less than 150% of the Nantucket County
median household income; to maintain Nantucket's diversity and unique sense of community; to
encourage moderate-income families to continue to reside on Nantucket; and to generate a
supply of housing that will remain affordable.
SECTION 2. Definitions
Deleted: TAX
5
“Addition" shall mean an increase in building area, aggregate floor area, height or number of
stories of a structure.
"Alteration" shall mean a change or modification of a building or a structure or the service
equipment thereof that affects safety or health and is not classified as an ordinary repair.
"Community Housing" shall be defined herein as that housing intended primarily to be occupied by
those earning up to 150% of median family income for Nantucket, as determined by the U.S.
Department of Housing and Urban Development.
"Dwelling Unit" shall be defined herein as a room or enclosed floor space used, or to be used, as a
habitable unit for one (1) family or household; with facilities for sleeping, cooking, and sanitation.
"Employer Dormitory" shall be defined herein as a dwelling on a lot occupied by a legally permitted
or nonconforming commercial or nonprofit recreational use, or on an adjoining lot under the same
ownership, all located outside of the NEHOD and DOD Overlay Districts in which sleeping
accommodations for five (5) or more persons are provided by one or more employers, with
occupancy limited solely to their employees.
"New Construction Surcharge" shall mean the surcharge set forth in Section 3.
"Total Floor Area" shall be the floor area within the perimeter of the outside walls of the building
under consideration, without deductions for hallways, stairs, closets, thickness of walls, columns
or other features. It does not include unoccupied accessory areas such as unfinished basements,
attics or lofts and does not include porches, decks, unenclosed breezeways and windows walks.
SECTION 3. New Construction Surcharge. In addition to any local fee that may be
imposed by the Town of Nantucket pursuant to chapter 40, section 22F of the General Laws or any
other applicable statute, the Town of Nantucket is hereby authorized to impose, collect and
disburse as set forth below a fee in the nature of a surcharge on new residential construction
(hereinafter referred to as, the "New Construction Surcharge") as follows:
(a) The New Construction Surcharge shall be imposed on those persons who apply for a
residential building permit from the Town of Nantucket, and is to be paid upon issuance of a
building permit by the Building Commissioner of the Town of Nantucket. The amount of the
surcharge shall be computed at the rate of $8.00 per square foot of Total Floor Area of new
construction space in excess of 3,000 square feet for each dwelling unit.
(b) The New Construction Surcharge will be collected at the same time as, and in addition to,
the Town's local Building permit fees, by the Town's Building Commissioner to be turned over to
the Treasurer of the Town.
(c) Additions/Alterations: No New Construction Surcharge shall be imposed or paid upon the
issuance of Building Permits for Additions or Alterations, unless the Application for Building Permit
for the Addition or Alteration is filed within three (3) years of issuance of a Building Permit or,
where because of age of the structure, no building permit record can be found, then within three
Deleted: Tax
Deleted: tax
Deleted: Tax
Deleted: tax
Deleted: Tax
Deleted: Tax
Deleted: tax
Deleted: 2,500
Deleted: Tax
Deleted: There is no fee for
Deleted: receipt of a Certificate of
Occupancy
6
years of the dates established by other equivalent evidence of the date of construction for the
Dwelling Unit upon which the Addition or Alteration is proposed. In this instance, square footage
will be calculated by combining the Total Floor Area of the original Dwelling Unit and the Total Floor
Area to be created by the new Addition or Alteration.
SECTION 4. Exemptions
Employer Dormitories are not subject to the New Construction Surcharge.
SECTION 5. The Town of Nantucket, acting by and through its Town Meeting, shall appropriate
the receipts of this New Construction Surcharge only for the purposes of purchasing, acquiring,
constructing, operating, maintaining, making ordinary repairs or otherwise making extraordinary
repairs to Community Housing within the Town of Nantucket, including engineering, architectural,
planning, designing and permitting costs associated. therewith, as presented by the Board of
Selectman.
SECTION 6. The imposition and collection of the New Construction Surcharge
described above shall expire on December 31, 2015 .
SECTION 7. This act shall take effect if the Town of Nantucket votes to accept its terms at the
next regularly scheduled municipal election for any fiscal year commencing on or after July 1, 2004.
The question appearing on the official ballot shall be in the following form:
Shall the act allowing the Town of Nantucket to impose a community housing surcharge to mitigate
the effects of large-scale residential real estate development be accepted?”
If a majority of the votes cast in answer to said question is in the affirmative, this act shall take
effect, but not otherwise.
Article 66 (Real Estate Acquisition and Disposition: Round-about at Sparks Avenue/Hooper Farm
Road/Pleasant Street)
In item (2) of the motion, change the first line as follows: “To dispose of the following three two parcels of
land…;
Then, in the blank map date reference shown in the last sentence of the motion, insert the word “April”
Article 71 (Real Estate Disposition: Long-term Lease Authorization)
Amend the Motion as follows:
“…7 Miacomet Avenue as described on the Assessor’s Map 67 for parcels 345 679, 680, 681; Lots A4/A5/A6 as
shown on a plan filed at the Registry of Deeds numbered 02-04.”
CHANGES TO ARTICLE 74 IF MORE FREE CASH IS APPROPRIATED:
Article 74 (Appropriation: Stabilization Fund)
FINANCE COMMITTEE MOTION: Moved that Six Hundred Thousand Dollars ($600,000) One Million Two Hundred
Thousand Dollars ($1,200,000) be raised and appropriated from the Fiscal Year 2006 tax levy and other general
revenues of the Town for the purposes of the Stabilization Fund in accordance with Chapter 40, section 5B of the
General Laws.
CHANGES TO ARTICLE 75 IF MORE FREE CASH IS APPROPRIATED:
Deleted: of Net Floor Area
Deleted: actual
Deleted: amount
Deleted: Tax
Deleted: Tax
Deleted: Tax
Deleted: 2010
7
ARTICLE 75 (Appropriation: Free Cash)
FINANCE COMMITTEE MOTION: To see if the Town will vote to transfer One Million Six Hundred Twenty-five
Thousand Dollars ($1,625,000) Three Million One Hundred Forty-nine Thousand Dollars ($3,149,000) from Free
Cash in the treasury of the town for the purposes of meeting the appropriations for the ensuing fiscal year by
authorizing the Assessors to use in fixing the tax rate.
8
[TOWN CLERK=S NOTE: Town Meeting Officers and workers included: Check-in workers
Carol Barrett, Ellen Nora Toombs, Natalie Fletcher, Jeanette Topham, Lilma Cook, Carol Crowell,
Suzanne Daub, Beverly McLaughlin, Jean Trifero, Janet Wagner, Martha Butler, Jean Duarte
Margaret-Ann Fleming, Jane Joynt, Penny McIntyre, Debbie Merritt, Terri Molis, and Jo Zschau.
Those who worked as Tellers: Barbara Jenkins, David Goodman, Carole Corkish, Ellen Nora
Toombs, Dave Fronzuto, Jean Duarte, Carol Crowell and Frank Psaradelis. Town Meeting Wardens,
Constables, and ushers were Frank Psaradelis, Dave Fronzuto, Gene Toombs, Jim Perelman,
Manny Dias, and Tony Molis . Officer of the Nantucket Police Department assisted in keeping
good order.]
The calling of the Articles commenced:
# CALLED BY
ARTICLE 4 Mr. Barnes
8 Mr. Bennett
10 Mr. McGrady
13 Finn Murphy
14 Bruce King
27 Alice McWade
28 Patrick Sullivan
29 Curtis Barnes
30 Linda Williams
31 Richard Loftin
32 Aaron Marcavitch
41 Arthur Reade
42 Cormac Collier
45 Cormac Collier (Will be Moderated by Timothy Madden)
46 Mr. Ray
47 Mr. Loftin
48 Kent Murphy (Call Withdrawn)
49 Wendy Hudson
50 John Stanton
51 Arthur Reade
53 Cormac Collier
54 Phil Austin
59 Mike Glowacki
9
60 Matt Fee (Call Withdrawn)
63 Alice McWade
66 Alan Brown
67 Alice McWade
73 Ms. Huber
Articles not called were: 1, 2, 3, 5, 6, 7, 9, 11, 12, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21, 22, 23, 24, 25, 26,
32, 33, 34, 35, 36, 37, 38, 39, 40, 43, 44, 48, 52, 55, 56, 57, 58, 60, 61, 62, 64, 65, 68, 69, 70, 71, 72, 74,
and 75.
The Moderator explained that once the articles were called, she not allow any subsequent call at
any time in the future of the Meeting.
Moderator Alger explained that she had a conflict of interest on Article 45, and that she had appointed
Legislative Liaison to act as Moderator Pro Tem.
10
Mr. Bartlett moved to recess the meeting until 7:00 PM on Tuesday, April 12th. It was seconded. A Voice vote was
taken and at 10:45 PM, the Moderator declared it a Unanimous Voice Vote in favor of recessing the meeting
until Tuesday evening.
NIGHT TWO – 2006 ANNUAL TOWN MEETING
Tuesday, April 4, 2006
The Moderator called the Meeting to order at 7:06 PM.
Uncalled Articles: 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 11, 12, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21,
22, 23, 25, 27, 28, 29, 30, 31, 32, 33, 36, 38, 40, 42, 43, 45, 47, 48, 49, 50,
51, 52, 53, 54, 55, 57, 63, 64, 65, 66, 67, 68, 69, 70, 72, 73, 74, 75, 77, 78,
79, 80, 81, 82, and 83.
Were voted as recommended, and/or amended by the Finance Committee, or as
recommended, and/or amended by the Planning Board, as printed in the Warrant, with
technical corrections brought forward during the course of the Meeting, by Unanimous
Voice Vote.
Board of Selectmen Chairman Michael Glowacki moved that the 2006 Annual Town
Meeting be dissolved. It was seconded. A voice vote was taken. The 2006 Annual Town
Meeting was dissolved at PM.