The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About2018-9-18(— Approved Minutes September 18, 2018, adopted October 30, 2018 `c F; `V� . C\i. Historic District Commission Sign Advisory Council 2016 LOV -1 Ali 10:21 Commissioners: Kevin Kuester, Chris Young, Paul Wolf, Mark Cutone, Ben Normand Planning and Land Use Services 2 Fairgrounds Road Nantucket, Massachusetts 02554 MINUTES Tuesday September 18, 2018 I. Procedural Business Call to order at 9:00 am. Attending members: Chris Young, Kevin Kuester and Paul Wolf Staff in attendance: John Hedden, HDC Compliance Coordinator Absent members: None. Late arrivals: Mark Cutone at 9:20 am. Early Departures: Kevin Kuester at 9:37 am and Mark Cutone at 10:36 am. Motion to Adopt Agenda made by Paul Wolf; Seconded by Kevin Kuester. Vote: carried unanimously Motion to Approve Minutes: August 28, 2018 made by Paul Wolf; Seconded by Kevin Kuester. Vote: carried unanimously II. Public Comment None Page 1 of 3 Approved Minutes September 18, 2018, adopted October 30, 2018 III. New Business — See attached Comments Property owner name Street Address Scope of work Map/Parcel Agent 1. Nantucket Comm Sailing 12 West Creek Road Wall Sign 55-175 Self 2. St. Mary's Church 3 Federal Street Post Sign 42.3.1-174 Self Motion to approve comments from New Business items #1 - #2. Made by Kevin Kuester; seconded by Paul Wolf. Vote: Carried unanimously. 3. Nantucket Cottage Hosp. 57 Prospect Street Master Sign Plan 55/3 John Twohig Documentation: Representing: Public: None. Concerns: Kuester - concerned of height of freestanding signs being 6 feet tall. Thinks if would be more appropriate if they were 4 feet tall. Normand- asks if directory sign could be less tall and perhaps angled for easier viewing purposes. Discussion of lighting signs. John Twohig- Some of the signs must conform to certain codes in regard to lettering size and sign size. David Kelly- The signs will have reflective lettering. Master Sign Plan David Kelly, Cannon Design; Miranda Hall, Cannon Design; John Twohig, Esquire The SAC discussed alternatives to reflective lettering and other lighting options. The consensus is that reflective lettering is not appropriate. Young- Summarizing Council's concerns. Overall everything looks to be off to an appropriate start. Agrees with Council that freestanding signs should be reduced in height. Feels the freestanding signs should match the existing signs. Something should be done for the campus direction signs such as lowering them and angling them as pointed out by Normand. Other options should be explored for lighting instead of having the reflective lettering Motion to hold for revisions: Made by Ben Normand; seconded by Paul Wolf. Vote: Carried unanimously (4-0). 4. Nantucket Cottage Hosp. 57 Prospect Street Wall sign 55/3 John Twohig 5. Nantucket Cottage Hosp. 57 Prospect Street Wall sign -Ex 1 Hosp ID 55/3 John Twohig 6. Nantucket Cottage Hosp. 57 Prospect Street Free standing sign-VH1 55/3 John Twohig 7. Nantucket Cottage Hosp. 57 Prospect Street Free standing sign-VH2 55/3 John Twohig 8. Nantucket Cottage Hosp. 57 Prospect Street Wall sign- Ex 3 55/3 John Twohig 9. Nantucket Cottage Hosp. 57 Prospect Street Wall sign- Ex 4 55/3 John Twohig 10. Nantucket Cottage Hosp. 57 Prospect Street Free standing sign- Ex5 55/3 John Twohig 11. Nantucket Cottage Hosp. 57 Prospect Street Wall sign- Ex 6 55/3 John Twohig 12. Nantucket Cottage Hosp. 57 Prospect Street Wall sign- Ex 7 55/3 John Twohig Motion to hold New Business items #4 - #12 to track with Master Sign Plan. Made by Paul Wolf; seconded by Ben Normand. Vote: Carried unanimously (4-0). Page 2 of 3 Approved Minutes September 18, 2018, adopted October 30, 2018 1. Enforcement. Discussed enforcement with Nantucket Island Resorts. Representing: Mike Duffy, Nantucket Island Resorts; Greg Farrington, Nantucket Island Resorts. Mike Duffy- We are here to go over violations we received over the summer. We're trying to work with all our tenants to make sure they know they need to apply for signs. Greg Farrington- Perhaps a walk -through town with the SAC would be a good thing and informative for us. We want to work the best we can with SAC. Young- Feels a walk -through town with NIR would be beneficial. Hopefully we can set that up in the future. IV. Adjournment Motion to Adjourn made by Chris Young; Seconded by Paul Wolf at 10:52 am. Vote: Carried Unanimously. Submitted by Cathy Flynn Page 3 of 3 STC/S AC Sign Advisory Council Meeting Memorandum Date: % Time: To: Historic District Commission From: Sign Advisory Council lKembers 'resent: (Please Check) iris Young P'aul Wolf -I&vin Koester Mark Cutone B -6h- Normand Applicant: , Sign Frame: Address of proposed sign: 12- W..o C wax Ty of proposed sign (all Mount ( )Projecting ( )Freestanding ( )Rock ( )Other Location (on property) of proposed sign: ( )Entrance to building ( )Rear of building ( )Side elevation ( )Other Comments: ( )Incomplete application / Hold for representation ( )Recommend view ( )Associated with a master sign plan ( )Master sign plan required ( )Does not meet guidelines(as noted below) o Concerns Recommendations: /Approve ( )Approve as noted ( )Hold for revisions ( )Present to -full board 3 nn/no/,ini-1 HDC/SAC Sign _Advisory Council Meeting Memorandum Date: Time: To: Ilistoric District Commission From: Sign Advisory Council Members 'resent: (Please Check) .,Kris Young --r'aui wolf vin Knester Marg Cutone Ren _Normand Applicant: Sign Name: Address of proposed sign: Type of proposed sign ( )VAll Mount ( )Projecting ( Free standing ( )Rock 40 Location (on property) of proposed sign: ( )Entrance to building ( )Rear of building ( )Side elevation ( )Other Comments: ( )Incomplete application / Hold for representation ( )Recommend view ( )Associated with a master sign plan ( )Master sign plan required ( ) Does not meet guidelines(as noted below) ()No Concerns Recommendations: ( )Approve ( )Approve as noted ( old fo/ re isions ( )Present to full board Revised 03/00/2016 hyDC/S Date: % Sign Advisory Council Meeting Memorandum Time: To: Historic District Commission From: Sign Advisory Council Members Present: (Please Check) �ris Yourae Baal Wolf Kevin Kuester Mark Cutone �n Normand Applicant: Al C H Sign Name: Address of proposed sign: Type of proposed sign ( )Vda11 Mount ()Projecting ()Free standing ()Rock Xther j�1r Location (on property) of proposed sign: ( )Entrance to building ( )Rear of building ( )Side elevation ( )Other Comments: ( )Incomplete application / Hold for representation ( )Recommend view ( )Associated with a master sign plan ( )Master sign plan required ( ) Does not meet guidelines(as noted below) ( )No Concerns Recommendations: ( )Approve ( )Approve as noted CV1KId or revisions ( )Present to full board Signatures Revised 03/00/2016