The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About2018-10-15Approved Minutes October 15, 2018, adopted October 29, 2Q1$; ; : . 'Z `i i' i J o f - ! TOWN CLEF: 2018 OCT 30 AM 11: 2:j Historic District Commission Historic Structures Advisory Board Members: Micky Rowland, Michael May, Jascin Finger, Angus Macleod, Brook Meerbergen Alternate Member: Lucy Dillon Planning and Land Use Services 2 Fairgrounds Road Nantucket, Massachusetts 02554 MINUTES October 15, 2018 I. Procedural Business Call to order at 3:30 pm. Attending members: Angus Macleod, Lucy Dillon, Brook Meerbergen Absent members: Micky Rowland Late arrivals: Michael May at 3:38pm and Jascin Finger at 3:41 pm. Early Departures: None Motion to Adopt Agenda made by Angus Macleod; Seconded by Lucy Dillon. Vote: carried unanimously Approval of Minutes: October 1, 2018 Motion made by Angus Macleod; Seconded by Brook Meerbergen. Vote: carried unanimously II. Public Comment None Page 1 of 2 t - Approved Minutes October 15, 2018, adopted October 29, 2018 III. New Business — See attached Comments Properly Owner Street Street Address Scope of Work Map/Parcel Agent 1. Sanford, Polly 22 Easton St. Demo house 42.1.4-12 Shelter 7 2. Sanford, Polly 22 Easton St. Demo garage 42.1.4-12 Shelter7 3. Hardie, Robert 9 Lincoln Cir. Pool/fence 30-137 Julie Jordan 4. Hardie, Robert 9 Lincoln Cir. Rev. 70585; reloc garage 30-137 Mark Avery 5. Damian, Nathan 13 Williams Ln. Addition 55-134 Self 6. Damian, Nathan 13 Williams Ln. Pool 55-134 Self 7. Dednar, Andrew 38 Orange St. Exterior, A/C unit 42.3.2-221 JN Design 8. Henderson, Barbara 6A Silver St. Gate/hardscaping/stairs 55.4.1-187.1 Ahern, LLC 9. Maxwell, John 32 India St. Rev. 65713; door/wind 42.3.4-152 BPC 10. Kelsey, Holly 16 Grove Ln. New dwelling 41-442 Concept Design 11. Kelsey, Holly 16 Grove Ln. New garage 41-442 Concept Design 12. Kuehn, Alfred 4 Fayette St. Add shed/garage bay 42.2.3-31 Thornewill Design 13. LaFrance, Allan 20A York St. Fence 55.4.1-145.1 Thornewill Design 14. Nantucket Hotel 77 Easton St. Solar hot watr collectors 42.4.1-35 Nant.Solar Solutions 15. Sanford, Alfred T. 36 Lily St. Rev. 67833; demo 42.4.3-93 Botticelli & Pohl 16. KS Blake Rev Trust 4 Summer St. Roof material change 42.3.3-71 Patrick Noddin 17. Mackey, Liam 3 N. Union St. Fenestration 42.3.1-214.2 Emeritus Motion to approve comments from New Business items #1- #17. Motion made by Angus Macleod; Seconded by Lucy Dillon. Vote: Carried unanimously IV. Adjournment Motion to Adjourn made by Michael May; Seconded by Angus Macleod at 5:00 pm. Vote: Carried Unanimously. Submitted by Cathy Flynn Page 2 of 2 Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum Date/TimeooG is To: Historic District Commission From: Historic Structures Advisory Board HDC/HSAB Members Present Angus MacLeod () Michael May () Jascin Leonardo Finger () Milton Rowland Brook Meerbergen AlterrnateLucy Dillon Applicant s -,�^- J 1� �.z Address Historic information/known history () Non -Contributing (Contributing () Individually significant Comments () Incomplete application () Historical information needed () No Concerns () Recommend View () Does not meet guidelines () Not appropriate (As noted below) North Elevation East Elevation West Elevation South Elevation Signatures (three members required for quorum) I istoric Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB Date/Time �c/ iS 12 o 'F '� L(b To: Historic District Commission From: Historic Structures Advisory Board Members Present ({Angus MacLeod (,� ae1�4a3L () Jascin Leonardo Finger ()Milton Rowland/Brook Meerbergen / Alternate: ' ucy Dillon Applicant - Address a� Historic information/lmown history () Non -Contributing () Contributing ( ) Individually significant Comments () Incomplete application () Historical information needed No Concerns () Recommend View () Does not meet guidelines () Not appropriate (As noted below) North Elevation East Elevation West Elevation South Elevation Other I Signatures (three members required for quorum) Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB Date/Time Q C�- 1 I2� To: Historic District Commission From: Historic Structures Advisory Board Members Present Angus MacLeod�chael May �Jascin Leonardo Finger () Milton Rowland rook Mmrbergen Alte atLucy Dillon Applicant�-� A� - — Address Historic information/lmown history () Non -Contributing () Contributing () Individually significant Comments () Incomplete application () Historical information needed () No Concerns () Recommend View () Does not meet guidelines () Not appropriate (As noted below) North Elevation East Elevation West Elevation South Elevation S, es (three members rquir4rW- Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB Date/Time C* 1 S1 2 or, -fp�, To: Historic District Commission From: Historic Structures Advisory Board Members Present ragas MacLeod Michael May /P Jascin Leonardo Finger () Milton Rowland,'$rook Meerbergen / Alternate: �ucy Dillon , Applicant It V-0 Address Historic information/known history () Non -Contributing () Contributing () Individually significant Comments incomplete application () Historical information needed () No Concerns () Recommend View () Does not meet guidelines () Not appropriate (As noted below) North Elevation East Elevation West Elevation Public Comment rf r S , e5 (three members Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB Date/Time; , S I -01p, ti, 575 To: Historic District Commission From: Historic Structures Advisory Board Members Present IKAngus MacLeodMichael May ascin Leonardo Finger () Milton Rowland rook Meerbergen Alternate:' 4I ucy Dillon Applicant Address f �� lM Gc.►�.-� Historic information/known history O Non -Contributing O Contributing O Individually significant () Incomplete application () Historical information needed Wo Concerns () Recommend View () Does not meet guidelines () Not appropriate (As noted below) North Elevation East Elevation West Elevation South Elevation Other Public Comment Signatures (three membe s r ) cl/1 1 i L Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB D ate/Time .n&7r— To: Historic District Commission From: Historic Structures Advisory Board Members Present ingas MacLeod ,Michael May�Jascin Leonardo Finger () Milton Rowland rook Meerbergen l / Alternate:(u-Lucy Dillon Applicantto_ i-�`c�, �r�(,.�. Address�22LC�.� S Qvo Historic information/known history () Non -Contributing () Contributing () Individually significant Comments () Incomplete application . () Historical information needed () No Concerns () Recommend View () Does not meet guidelines () Not appropriate (As noted below) North Elevation East Elevation West Elevation South Elevation Other Public Comment tuurreS�(three membe Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB Date/Time(f),!:51— 1 To: Historic District Commission From: Historic Structures Advisory Board Members Present Angus MacLeod vli.chael May XJascin Leonardo Finger () Milton Rowland 'Brook Meerbergen Alternate: ,ucy Dillon Applicant �v¢ t�,�,c� Address �-'o Historic information/losown history () Non-Contributing�<Contributing'( ) Individually significant Comments () Incomplete application () Historical information needed () No Concerns () Recommend View () Does not meet guidelines () Not appropriate (As noted below) North Elevation East Elevation West Elevation South Elevation Othe Public Comment lyl— Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memor andum HDC/HSAB Date/Time � v) �• �t To: Historic District Commission From: Historic Structures Advisory Board Members Present ,,Angus Ma.cLeod,,k<Michael May Kfascin Leonardo Finger () Milton Rowland rook Meerbergen Alternate: XLucy Dillon Applicant Address, Historic information/Imown history ( ) Non -Contributing O Contributing O Individually significant Comments () Incomplete application () Historical information needed () No Concerns () Recommend View () Does not meet guidelines () Not appropriate (As noted below) North Elevation East Elevation West Elevation South Elevation Other Public Comment rat �I �� Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB Date/Time Oct/ �/ -) r' To: Historic District Commission From: Historic Structures Advisory Board Members Present ngus MacLeod "Michael MayJascin Leonardo Finger O Milton Rowland ';��Brook Meerbergen / Alte ate Lucy Dillon / Applicant Address 92— • I Historic information/Imown history () Non -Contributing () Contributing () Individually significant Comments () Incomplete application () Historical information needed () No Concerns () Recommend View ( ) Does not meet guidelines () Not appropriate (As noted below) North Elevation , _ East Elevation West Elevation South Elevation Other Public Comment 'l Sl es (three member Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB Date/Time (J�_ 2 Ol F5 To: Historic District Commission From: Historic Structures Advisory Board Members Present (Angus MacLeod ,,aMichael May f Tascin Leonardo Finger () Milton Rowland Brook Meerbergen �' / Alternate Lucy Dillon Applicant Address (�, 6D.QQ-e— L4D-ra _ &h) Historic information/known history () Non -Contributing () Contributing ()In dividually significant Comments () Incomplete application () Historical information needed () No Concerns () Recommend View () Does not meet guidelines ( )Not appropriate (As noted below) East Elevationj w e n r t d WF -.Cf F.1P.VAfin-n South Elevation VVb, C -e. -n Other _ Comment Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB Date/Time L C/7— To: Historic District Commission From: Historic Structures Advisory Board Members Present kFAngus MacLeodf Michael May x Jascin Leonardo Finger () Milton Rowland Brook Meerbergen / / " Alternate Lucy Dillon Applicant Address (�y,2n.� _ l G,�.J Historic information/known history () Non -Contributing () Contributing () Individually significant Comments () Incomplete application () Historical information needed () No Concerns () Recommend View () Does not meet guidelines () Not appropriate (As noted below) North Elevation East Elevation West Elevation South Elevation r ARM - - -- - quo Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB Date/Time-Ob-71— /S--, 2-018 L/ -36 - To:- To: Historic District Commission From: Historic Structures Advisory Board Members Present Angus MacLeodV' lichael MayJascm Leonardo Finger () Milton Rowland ,(i�Brook Meerbergen Alternate" ,Lucy Dillon / Applicant Address %r Historic information/known history () Non -Contributing () Contributing () Individually significant Comments () Incomplete application () Historical information needed x No Concerns () Recommend View ()Does not meet guidelines O Not appropriate (As noted bel !!flow)))) North Elevation East Elevation West Elevation South Elevation (lthar - c Public Comment Signatures (three memo---��A 4 s Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB lJGc, '�� ` Date/Time To: Historic District Commission From: Historic Structures Advisory Board Members Present Angus MacLeod Michael May A Jascin Leonardo Finger () Milton Rowland ' Brook Meerbergen Alternate�Lucy Dillon Applicant 2c�1�c Y� Address zC.4 Historic information/known history ( ) Non -Contributing () Contributing () Individually significant Comments () Incomplete application () Historical information needed,),�o Concerns () Recommend View () Does not meet guidelines () Not appropriate (As noted below) North Elevation East Elevation West Elevation South Elevation Other 1 ( /� / (/�`y �V✓�r '�"'�'f... fir. 6V�+ Public Comment V Si se members requi Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDCIHSAB Date/Time-UC-7--/Y,2-0//f ,Y" ,�Iz, To: Historic District Commission From: Historic Structures Advisory Board Members Present {Angus MacLeod Michael May AJascin Leonardo Finger () Milton Rowland / �Erook Meerbergen {/ Alt mate: (Lucy Dillon Applicant / Address_-�(— Historic informationAmown history ( ) Non -Contributing () Contributing () Individually significant Comments () Incomplete application () Historical information needed VNo Concerns () Recommend View () Does not meet guidelines () Not appropriate (As noted below) North Elevation East Elevation West Elevation South Elevation Other 1 7 i L v CA Public Comment Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB Date/Time oc-,`j- 1!3--.7,0 1n�I To: Historic District Commission From: Historic Structures Advisory Board Members Present Wngus MacLeod Michael MayX Jascin Leonardo Finger () Milton Rowland ' $rook Meerbergen AgAlt`` mate:p Lucy Dillon Applicant�� . �Yl�( Address 3( • LLy Historic information/known history Non -Contributing () Contributing () Individually significant Comments () Incomplete application () Historical information needed () No Concerns () Recommend View () Does not meet guidelines () Not appropriate (4s noted below) North Elevation East Elevation b6& West Elevation South Elevation Public Comment Signatures (three membermo n-... - Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum Date/Time To: Historic District Commission From: Historic Structures Advisory Board HDC/HSAB Members Present Angus MacLeod PdMichael May �<Jascin Leonardo Finger () Milton Rowland ",(Brook Meerbergen Alternate: KLucy Dillon Applicant ��- r l �Address L( OLeA Historic informationAmown history ( ) Non -Contributing ( ) Contributing () Individually significant Comments () Incomplete application () Historical information needed ro Concerns () Recommend View () Does not meet guidelines () Not appropriate (As noted below) North Elevation East Elevation West Elevation South Elevation Other Public Comment Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB Date/Time f To: Historic District Commission From: Historic Structures Advisory Board Members Present r Angus MacLeod Michael May IK Jascin Leonardo Finger ( ) Milton Rowland - yBrook Meerbergen ` Alternate: � Lucy Dillon Applicant V rG Address Historic information/known history () Non -Contributing () Contributing () Individually significant () Incomplete application () Historical information needed)010 Concerns () Recommend View () Does not meet guidelines () Not appropriate (2s noted below)— v � r North Elevation East Elevation Wes Elekation �r South Elevation Other Public Comment 174 - Qi= /✓ Si es (three -- 4– Approved Minutes for October 15, 2018, adopted October 29, 2018 Historic District Commission Sconset Advisory Board Members: Rob Benchley (Chair), Angus MacLeod (Vice -Chair), Michael May, Caroline Ellis and Mary Lathrop -Will Alternate Member: Alix St. Clair Planning and Land Use Services 2 Fairgrounds Road Nantucket, Massachusetts 02554 MINUTES Monday, October 15, 2018 I. Procedural Business Call to order at 1:06 pm. Audio Recording Announcement Attending members: Rob Benchley, Mary Lathrop -Will, Angus Macleod, Michael May, Absent members: Alix St. Clair and Caroline Ellis Late arrivals: None. Early Departures: Angus Macleod at 2:02 pm. Motion to Adopt Agenda made by Rob Benchley; Seconded by Michael May Vote: carried unanimously. Approval of Minutes: October 1, 2018 Motion to approve made by Mary Lathrop -Will; Seconded by Rob Benchley. Vote: carried unanimously. Page 1 of 2 Approved Minutes for October 15, 2018, adopted October 29, 2018 II. Public Comment None III. New Business — See attached Comments PropeM owner name Street Address Scope of work Ma Parcel AAnt 1. WIlse, David 1 Sunset Ridge Lane Color Change 73.4.2-83 Topham Design 2. Saynor, Catherine 30 Codfish Park Window Well 73.1.3-56 Val Oliver 3. 16 Stone Post, LLC 8 Stone Post Way Main House revisions 74-78 Rowland &Assoc 4. 16 Stone Post, LLC 8 Stone Post Way Cabana revisions 74-78 Rowland &Assoc 5. Hedge Fun, LLC 31 Sankaty Road Move/demo 49.2.3-42 Gryphon Arch. 6. Hedge Fun, LLC 31 Sankaty Road Garage/studio 49.2.3-42 Gryphon Arch. 7. Belichick, William 38 Shell Street Addition 73.1.4-52 Botticelli&Pohl 8. Greenberg, Frank 3 Packet Drive Addition 7420 CWA Motion to approve New Business comments for items #1-#8. Made by Rob Benchley; Seconded by Mary Lathrop -Will. Vote: Carried unanimously. IV. Adjournment Motion to Adjourn made by Mary Lathrop -Will; Seconded by Rob Benchley at 2:11 pm. Vote: Carried Unanimously. Submitted by Cathy Flynn Page 2 of 2