Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout2018-8-27Approved Minutes August 27, 2018, adopted October 01, 2018 Historic District Commission Historic Structures Advisory Board O G 0 Members: Micky Rowland, Michael May, Jascin Finger, Angus Macleod, Brook Meerbergen Planning and Land Use Services 2 Fairgrounds Road Nantucket, Massachusetts 02554 MINUTES August 27, 2018 I. Procedural Business Call to order at 3:30 pm. Attending members: Michael May, Micky Rowland, Angus Macleod and Brook Meerbergen Absent members: Jascin Finger Late arrivals: Michael May at 3:37 pm Early Departures: Michael May at 5:07 pm Motion to Adopt Agenda made by Angus Macleod; Seconded by Micky Rowland Vote: carried unanimously Approval of Minutes: August 13, 2018 Motion made by Micky Rowland; Seconded by Angus Macleod Vote: carried unanimously II. Public Comment None III. Election of Officers None Page 1 of 2 Approved Minutes August 27, 2018, adopted October 01, 2018 IV. New Business — See attached Comments Property Owner Street Street Address Scope of Work Map/Parce Agent 1. Grennan -Maloney 15 Old North Wharf Addition 42.3.1-26 Nathan McMullen 2. August Pointe, LLC 8 Willard Street Add pergola/windw 42.4.1-55.1 Ross Goodwin 3. Winkler, William 13 Warren Street Window/door chg 55.4.1-40 Seth Gottlieb 4. Bennett, Douglas 22 Lily Street Garage door replac 42.4.3-91 SCI 5. Bennett, Douglas 22 Lily Street Door/windows 42.4.3-91 SCI 6. Emert, John 4 Barnabus Lane Add dormer 41-570 SCI 7. D & B Realty Trust 5 Barnabus Lane Shed 41-564 Ethan McMorrow 8. Virtue, Stephen 39 Pleasant Street Demo/move off 55.4.1-154 Ethan McMorrow 9. Virtue, Stephen 39 Pleasant Street New dwelling 55.4.1-154 Ethan McMorrow 10. Bolthole, LLC 17 Academy Lane Historic determ 42.4.2-41 NAG 11. Augustine, Roland 3 Cash's Court Move/demo garage 42.3.2-150 SCI 12. Augustine, Roland 3 Cash's Court Garage addition 42.3.2-150 SCI 13. Hafler, Janet 28 Union Street Roof change 42.3.2-179 Russell Simpson 14. 25 N. Liberty, LLC 58 N. Liberty Street Addition 41-253 SCI 15. Bloom, Chris 11 Lily Street Rev 68143; setp/roof 42.3.4-50 Emeritus 16. Bloom, Chris 11 Lily Street Rev 66389; gar fenes 42.3.4-50 Emeritus 17. Sutro, Marina 21 Vestal Street Door/window chg 41-175 Thornewill Design 18. Friel, Paul 12 N. Beach Street Addition 42.4.1-100 Nathan McMullen 19. Friel, Paul 12 N. Beach Street Addition 42.4.1-100 Nathan McMullen 20. 36 Lily Street, LLC 36 Lily Street Rev 70102; fenestrat 42.4.3-93 Botticelli & Pohl 21. NIR Retail, LLC 15 S. Beach Street New covered deck 42.4.2-57.1 Emeritus 22. Donato, Mark 106 Orange Street MH solar roof mount 55-400.1 ACK Smart 23. Donato, Mark 106 Orange Street Garage solar roof 55-400.1 ACK Smart Motion to approve comments from New Business items #1- #23 Motion made by Angus Macleod; Seconded by Micky Rowland Vote: Carried unanimously V. Adjournment Motion to Adjourn made by Angus Macleod; Seconded by Micky Rowland at 5:13 pm. Vote: Carried Unanimously. Submitted by Cathy Flynn Page 2 of 2 Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB Date/Time To: Historic District Commission From: Historic Structures Advisory Board Members Present Angus MacLeod7Michael May () Jascin Leonardo Finger KMUton Rowland P6rook Meerbergen Applicant — Address ��0 /(%0-��i "� tj Historic information/lmown history O Non -Contributing O Contributing O Individually significant Comments () Incomplete application () Historical information needed ( ) No Concerns () Recommend View ( ) Does not meet guidelines Not appropriate (As noted below) Other Public Comment aW,� y ��1 Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB Date/Time 08 -21-+ ( b z { 0 To: Historic District Commission From: Historic Structures Advisory Board Members Present Angus MacLeod chael May () Jascin Leonardo Finger Milton Rowland Xbrook Meerbergen Applicant 51�e Address ee W,'CL lAR `'T Historic information/known history O Non -Contributing O Contributing O Individually significant Comments O Incomplete application O Historical information needed%<To Concerns O Recommend View ( ) Does not meet guidelines () Not appropriate (As noted beelow) North Elevation East Elevation West Elevation South Elevation Other Public Comment (three members req;mVd for quorum) Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB Date/Time To: Historic District Commission From: Historic Structures Advisory Board Members Present YIngus MacLeod/ Michael May () Jascin Leonardo Finge�Milton Rowland .Brook Meerbergen Applicant s" Address Z �rgx� Historic information/known history () Non -Contributing () Contributing () Individually significant Comments () Incomplete application () ,Historical information needed () No Concerns () Recommend View () Does not meet guidelines I�Not appropriate (As noted below) North Elevation East Elevation , e � Lj o n Q West Elevations South Elevation Other Public Comment rx:=_ req fired or quo�un: Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB Date/Time ' ' )=I , I eJ _`: C3C-� To: Historic District Commission From: Historic Structures Advisory Board Members Present jngus MacLeod 'Michael May O Jascin Leonardo FingerKMilton Rowland Brook Meerbergen Applicant?�•a-, Address % 44, Historic information/known history O Non -Contributing O Contributing O Individually significant Comments O Incomplete application O Historical information needed O No Concerns O Recommend View ( ) Does not meet guidelines ( ) Not appropriate (As noted below) North Elevation West Elevation South Elevation Other Public Comment Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB Date/Time 151.12— 7 - (6 4:0(0 To: Historic District Commission From: Historic Structures Advisory Board Members Present ,Angus MacLeod Michael May () Jascin Leonardo Finger Milton Rowland rook Meerbergen Applicantt a 5 Address 2,2 Historic information/known history () Non -Contributing () Contributing () Individually significant Comments () Incomplete application () Historical information needed () No Concerns () Recommend View ( ) Does not meet guidelines ( ) Not appropriate (As noted below) North Elevation East Elevation West Elevation South Elevation Other Public Comment members Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB Date/Time 8 i 21 • 115 7 ••�� To: Historic District Commission From: Historic Structures Advisory Board Members Present �ngus MacLeod/KMichael May () 7ascin Leonardo Finger �04ilton Rowland ..Brook Meerbergen (Applicant a Address�a S Historic information/known history O Non -Contributing O Contributing O Individually significant Comments () Incomplete application () Historical information needed () No Concerns () Recommend View ( ) Does not meet guidelines ( ) Not appropriate (As noted below) ' North Elevation East Elevation South Elevation Other Public Comment members required fqq quorum) Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB Date/Time e' 27 ' 15 4:1b To: Historic District Commission From: Historic Structures Advisory Board 1Members Present (JQ lAngus MacLeod11 1-Michael May O Jascin Leonardo Finger ?"ton Rowland Brook Meerbergen ��Applicant P) /., S • Address s— 13etr, 6,, S Historic information/known history O Non -Contributing O Contributing O Individually significant ' J Comments () Incomplete application () Historical information needed VNO Concerns () Recommend View ( ) Does not meet guidelines () Not appropriate (As noted below) North Elevation East Elevation West Elevation South Elevation Other Public Comment members required for quorum) ' Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB Date/Time E3,42:4-116 4-: 12, To: Historic District Commission From: Historic Structures Advisory Board Members Present ngus MacLeodlichael May O Jascin Leonardo Finger Milton Rowland Brook Meerbergen Applicant V I k&tkr_� Address ! 9 6�b4�nt4 Historic information/known history O Non -Contributing O Contributing O Individually significant Comments () Incomplete application () Historical information needed XNo Concerns () Recommend View ( ) Does not meet guidelines ( ) Not appropriate (As noted below) North Elevation East Elevation West Elevation South Elevation Other Public Comment (three memb; �dfiquorum) Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB Date/Timeyy ' ' It> To: Historic District Commission From: Historic Structures Advisory Board Members Present Angus MacLeod�;A�Iichael May () 7ascin Leonardo Finger Ilton Rowland rook Meerbergen Applicant Uw /�f-, I�-n. Addressf 14 Historic information/known history 7� O Non -Contributing O Contributing O Individually significant Comments () Incomplete application () Historical information needed () No Concerns () Recommend View ( ) Does not meet guidelines ( ) Not appropriate (As noted below) North Elevation East Elevation West Elevation o 1,5' q- ca -Z" B -Z n-&— <.— ", South Elevation O r,,,,sP crLi ' 1 - ,-1491V /71-z-ay4,e tom/IL� 74D Other Public Comment members required for quorum) Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB Date/Time 9 ' 2 -�- ' If) � : Zd To: Historic District Commission From: Historic Structures Advisory Board Members Present ;IdAngus MacLeod �dMichael May O Jascin Leonardo Finger Xmilton Rowland _ rook Meerbergen /�L Applicant c 7'f -f o L,� L Address t -G,4 ; 64asi�- Historic information/known history O Non -Contributing O Contributing O Individually significant Comments () Incomplete application () Historical information needed(No Concerns () Recommend View ( ) Does not meet guidelines ( ) Not appropriate (As noted below)` North Elevation East Elevation West Elevation South Elevation Other Public Comment Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB Date/Time 8 " i �& `t' To: Historic District Commission From: Historic Structures Advisory Board Members Present /6ngus MacLeod Michael May () Jascin Leonardo Finger ton Rowland Brook Meerbergen Applicant Auq±ct> i, t e. R (a,,eW Address 6-L� 'S _cru t24— Historic information/laiown history () Non -Contributing () Contributing () Individually significant Comments () Incomplete application () Historical information needed () No Concerns () Recommend View ( ) Does not meet guidelines ( ) Not appropriate (As noted below) North Elevation East Elevation L-sem. West Elevation South Elevation Other Public Comment Sij�oree members required for quorum) Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB Date/Time 0 "�?. L 5 T!,5() To: Historic District Commission From: Historic Structures Advisory Board Members Present �Angus MacLeod (Michael May O Jascin Leonardo Finger Milton Rowland rook Meerbergen "11 Applicant�t(. / // Address 3 � 5`t, ,s �^ �Qy �9�—tn.e ��-Cc�cG'� � C1 Historic information/ mown history O Non -Contributing O Contributing O Individually significant Comments () Incomplete application () Historical information needed () No Concerns ( ) Recommend View ( ) Does not meet guidelines ( ) Not appropriate (As noted below) North Elevation East Elevation A Com' ' S C-� `"'�' 15 ra C' S © /5 Crz ° O C West Elevation South Elevation Other Public Comment Sl eS three member re fired for quorum) Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB Date/Time 6 12-�' ( 1/ To: Historic District Commission From: Historic Structures Advisory Board Members Present XAAngus MacLeod ichael May () Jascin Leonardo Finger on Rowland 1,11rook Meerbergen Applicant . — Address 2b OM Q -Pi Historic information/known history O Non -Contributing O Contributing O Individually significant Comments () Incomplete application () Historical information needed &o Concerns () Recommend View ( ) Does not meet guidelines ( ) Not appropriate (As noted below) North Elevation East Elevation West Elevation South Elevation Other Public Comment members re ui for Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB Date/Time 2. t F2 �4 To: Historic District Commission From: Historic Structures Advisory Board Members Present Angus MacLeod/Michael May () Jascin Leonardo Finger Ilton Rowland Wr Meerbergen Applicants IU . Li l 1, Addr/ess� /Ll Historic information/known history () Non -Contributing () Contributing () Individually significant Comments () Incomplete application () Historical information needed () No Concerns () Recommend View ( ) Does not meet guidelines ( ) Not appropriate (As noted below) TT... -fl. T71--+4— Other :ln.—+4— Other Public Comment (three members required for quorum) Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB Date/Time 8 ��� � C5 V,V7 To: Historic District Commission From: Historic Structures Advisory Board Members Present gus MacLeod f lichael May () Jascin Leonardo Finger 00"ton Rowland Brook Meerbergen Applicant 1 Address �„t (j j/ Historic information/known history O Non -Contributing O Contributing O Individually significant Comments () Incomplete application () Historical information needed () No Concerns () Recommend View ( ) Does not meet guidelines ( ) Not appropriate (As noted below) North Elevation East Elevation West Elevation Q South Elevation jkj Other Public Comment Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB Date/Time 8 r 27. 1 U ' / To: Historic District Commission From: Historic Structures Advisory Board Members Present ,('Angus MacLeod Michael May () Jascin Leonardo Finger Milton Rowland rook Meerbergen ( Applicanf .0 (, LF-t�12tS Address u Lt r_Y l Historic information/lmown history ( ) Non -Contributing O Contributing O Individually significant Comments () Incomplete application () Historical information needed () No Concerns ( ) Recommend View ( ) Does not meet guidelines ( ) Not appropriate (As noted below) North Elevation �, c� East Elevation West Elevation South Elevation Other Public Comment Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB Date/Time 6 ' 2.:� ' Jb L� �2 To: Historic District Commission From: Historic Structures Advisory Board Members Present �ngus MacLeod ichael May () Jascin Leonardo Finger ��lton Rowland $rook Meerbergen / (" Applicant—' i ti Address Historic information/known history O Non -Contributing O Contributing O Individually significant Comments () Incomplete application () Historical information needed �, No Concerns () Recommend View ( ) Does not meet guidelines () Not appropriate (As noted beloow) North Elevation East Elevation West Elevation South Elevation Other Public Comment Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB Date/Time 9 � 9—T' I -t) T :S To: Historic District Commission From: Historic Structures Advisory Board Members Present ?' Angus MacLeod,/�ichael May O Jascin Leonardo Finger ' ton Rowland$rook Meerbergen ApplicAddress t'Z— � Historic information/known history () Non -Contributing () Contributing () Individually significant Comments () Incomplete application () Historical information needed XNo Concerns () Recommend View ( ) Does not meet guidelines ( ) Not appropriate (As noted below) North Elevation MI00 Public Comment Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB Date/Time b t 2:1-' T" / To: Historic District Commission From: Historic Structures Advisory Board Members Present �(SAngus MacLeod?"Michael May O Jascin Leonardo Finger ?"Milton Rowland (/ } rook Meerbergen Applicant t ✓L4 6A,0 FAVL_ Address 1-7— Historic information/lmown history () Non -Contributing () Contributing () Individually significant Comments () Incomplete application () Historical information needed () No Concerns () Recommend View () Does not meet guidelinesXNot appropriate (As noted below) North Elevation S�tu�2fi/ East Elevation West Elevation South Elevation Other Public Comment (three members required for Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB Date/Time 8 ' `Z -T ' I b 6.`O To: Historic District Commission From: Historic Structures Advisory Board Members Present �gus MacLeod�4michael May () Jascin Leonardo Finger �3 lilton Rowland rook Meerbergen Applicant � LrL_� -.7r L -Le, Address --36 L.% i-`[ 5y—' Historic information/known history () Non -Contributing () Contributing () Individually significant Comments () Incomplete application () Historical information needed () No Concerns () Recommend View ( ) Does not meet guidelines ( ) Not appropriate (As noted below) North Elevation — -5,_XZ_V 5W PA -A j o w 1 t> �l�o CO QTT-=M Aon" East Elevation West Elevation South Elevation Other Public Comment (three members re u for quorum) Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB Date/Time 09 ' 2-4'' ( rD �•'" To: Historic District Commission From: Historic Structures Advisory Board Members Present lw�ngus MacLeod 4() Jascin Leonardo FingerkC�Milton Rowland rook Meerbergen SHistApplicant Q � (—L -C— Addr((((ess (5— Historic oric information/known history ( ) Non -Contributing O Contributing O Individually significant Comments () Incomplete application () Historical information needed () No Concerns () Recommend View ( ) Does not meet guidelines ( ) Not appropriate (As noted below) North Elevation East Elevation — L0 West Elevation South Elevation t Other Public Comment members required for quorum) Historic Structures Advisory Board Meeting Memorandum HDC/HSAB Date/Time (9u,IJ-�' To: Historic District Commission From: Historic Structures Advisory Board Members Present C-, d Angus MacLeod a�e�e}Fa3 () Jascin Leonardo Finger (Milton Rowland Brook Meerbergen Applicant � a�a , {�}`�� t Address /06 (it ot, Historic information/known history O Non -Contributing O Contributing O Individually significant Comments () Incomplete application () Historical information needed () No Concerns ( ) Recommend View () Does not meet guidelines X N�ot appropriate , (As noted below) North Elevation l4141L. L ( 5 L,�'Ce East Elevation West Elevation South Elevation Other Public Comment members