HomeMy WebLinkAbout2018-6-7Minutes for June 7, 2018, adopted June 26
HISTORIC DISTRICT COMMISSIOij�+. F
REGULAR MEETING
2 Fairgrounds Road 2016 JUN 27
Nantucket, Massachusetts 02554 Q� �� 5
www.nantucket-ma.gov
Commissioners: Raymond Pohl (Chair), Diane Coombs (Vice -chair), John McLaughlin, Abigail Camp, Vallorie Oliver,
Associate Commissioners: Stephen Welch Terence Watterson Jessie Dutra
-- MINUTES ~—
Thursday, June 7, 2018
PLUS Facility, 2 Fairgrounds Road, Conference Room —1:00 P.M.
Called to order at 1:03 p.m. and announcements by Mr. Pohl
Staff in attendance: John Hedden, HDC Compliance Coordinator; Terry Norton, Town Minutes Taker
Attending Members: Pohl, Coombs, McLaughlin, Oliver, Welch
Absent Members: Camp, Watterson, Dutra
Late Arrivals: None
Early Departures: None
A ends ado ted b unanimous consent.
COMMENT1. PUBLIC
None
DISCUSSION11. REVIEW AND OF • •
Voting Pohl, Coombs, McLaughlin, Oliver, Welch
Documentation Roofing shingle color samples, Shingle voting sheet, vote tallying sheet
Public Tony Shepley, Owner/President Shepley Wood Products
Bob Yourell, Marine Home Center outside sales
Mark Stanley, Home Center outside sales
Opening Welch — Brief on procedure to review and record votes presenting the preselected colors first; there are approximately
Comments thirty-nine (39) 3 -tab and architectural colors for review; 20 additional shingles were brought over this morning.
Pohl — Wants to come up with a short list of acceptable and eliminate the absolute nos.
Review of Shingles
no -4
OHD = Town of Nantucket Old Historic District
SOHD = `Sconset Old Historic District
Certainteed Land Mark Architectural
Cobblestone Grey
OHD and SOHD:
Driftwood
OHD and SOHD:
Georgetown Grey
OHD and SOHD:
Granite Grey
OHD and SOHD:
Morie Black
OHD and SOHD:
Weathered wood
OHD and SOHD:
IKO Cambridge Architectural
Charcoal Grey
OHD and SOHD:
Driftwood
OHD and SOHD:
Dual Black
OHD and SOHD:
Harvard Slate
OHD and SOHD:
Weatherwood
OHD and SOHD:
Dual Grey
OHD and SOHD:
BP Yukon 3 -Tab
All Other Areas:
Autumn Brown
OHD and SOHD:
Brownstone
OHD and SOHD:
Cobalt Black
OHD and SOHD:
Driftwood
OHD and SOHD:
Fossil Wood
OHD and SOHD:
Jade Green
OHD and SOHD:
Silver Grey
OHD and SOHD:
Sunset Cedar
OHD and SOHD:
Twilight Grey
OHD and SOHD:
yes -1
no -4
NO
All Other Areas:
yes -3
no -2
YES
yes -0
no -5
NO
All Other Areas:
yes -5
no -0
YES
yes -1
no -4
NO
All Other Areas:
yes -5
no -0
YES
yes -1
no -4
NO
All Other Areas:
yes -4
no -1
YES
yes -4
no -1
YES
All Other Areas:
yes -4
no -1
YES
yes -3
no -2
YES
All Other Areas:
yes -4
no -1
YES
yes -3
no -2
YES
All Other Areas:
yes -4
no -1
YES
yes -1
no -4
NO
All Other Areas:
yes -5
no -0
YES
yes -4
no -1
YES
All Other Areas:
yes -5
n0-0
YES
yes -1
no -4
NO
All Other Areas:
yes -4
no -1
YES
yes -1
no -4
NO
All Other Areas:
yes -3
no -2
YES
yes -1
no -4
NO
All Other Areas:
yes -1
no -4
NO
yes -0
no -5
NO
All Other Areas:
yes -0
no -5
NO
yes -1
no -4
NO
All Other Areas:
yes -3
no -2
YES
yes -3
no -2
YES
All Other Areas:
yes -4
no -1
YES
yes -1
no -4
NO
All Other Areas:
yes -3
no -2
YES
yes -0
no -5
NO
All Other Areas:
yes -3
no -2
YES
yes -0
no -5
NO
All Other Areas:
yes -1
no -4
NO
yes -2
no -3
NO
All Other Areas:
yes -4
no -1
YES
yes -0
no -5
NO
All Other Areas:
yes -1
no -4
NO
yes -0
no -5
NO
All Other Areas:
yes -2
no -3
NO
Page 1 of 2
Minutes for June 7, 2018, adopted June 26
Weathered Rock OHD and SOHD: yes -0 no -5 NO All Other Areas: yes -1 no -4 NO
Certainteed T 25 3 -Tab
IKO
Motion
Vote
Black Pepper OHD and SOHD:
ey rost OHD and SOHD:
Morie Black OHD and SOHD:
ey
OHD and SOHD:
ite
OHD and SOHD:
Blend
OHD and SOHD:
:ed Wood
OHD and SOHD:
indmark (other Architectural)
od
OHD and SOHD:
1 Black
OHD and SOHD:
I Slate
OHD and SOHD:
Blend
OHD and SOHD:
rood
OHD and SOHD:
Shake
OHD and SOHD:
rch
OHD and SOHD:
3 -Tab
All Other Areas:
yes -5
no -0
YES
All Other Areas:
yes -5
no -0
YES
yes -2
no -3
NO
All Other Areas:
yes -5
no -0
YES
yes -4
no -1
YES
All Other Areas:
yes -5
no -0
YES
yes -1
no -4
NO
All Other Areas:
yes -2
no -3
NO
yes -0
no -5
NO
All Other Areas:
yes -0
no -5
NO
yes -0
no -5
NO
All Other Areas:
yes -1
no -4
NO
yes -2
no -3
NO
All Other Areas:
yes -4
no -1
YES
yes -0
no -5
NO
All Other Areas:
yes -0
no -5
NO
yes -3
no -2
YES
All Other Areas:
yes -4
no -1
YES
yes -3
no -2
YES
All Other Areas:
yes -3
no -2
YES
yes -0
no -5
NO
All Other Areas:
yes -1
no -4
NO
yes -2
no -3
NO
All Other Areas:
yes -3
no -2
YES
yes -0
no -5
NO
All Other Areas:
yes -0
no -5
NO
yes -1
no -4
NO
All Other Areas:
yes -1
no -4
NO
OHD and SOHD: yes -1 no -4 NO All Other Areas: yes -5 no -0 YES
c OHD and SOHD: yes -4 no -1 YES All Other Areas: yes -5 no -0 YES
ussion about the colors approved being able to go on consent unless HDC Compliance Coordinator identifies a
r incompatibility with trim or other colors of the respective structure; the idea is that only exceptions would be ruled
i by the Commission. The list should be sent to all the companies that sell shingles.
ion to Accept the vote as tallied for approved and disapproved colors for the noted areas. (Coombs)
ied 5-0 Certificate # N/A
approve ivunu es I I 1V one
Review Minute None
Other Busines • Update from HDC Organizational Focus Committee.
• Discussion of Madaket HDC area map. No action at this time.
Commission C nurents None
List of addition do uments used at the meeting:
1. None
Motion to Adj : :32 p.m.
Submitted by:
Terry L. Norto
Page 2 of 2