Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout073-94,- y TOWN OF NANTUCKET BOARD OF APPEALS NANTUCKET, MASSACHUSETTS 02554 Date: December /& , 19 94 To: Parties in Interest and.Others concerned with the Decision of the BOARD OF APPEALS in the Application of the following: Application No.: 073 -94 Owner /Applicant: JULIE W. PARKER Enclosed is the Decision of the BOARD OF APPEALS which has this day been filed in the office of the Nantucket Town Clerk. An Appeal from this Decision may be taken pursuant to Section 17 of Chapter 40A, Massachusetts General Laws. Any action appealing the Decision must be brought by filing an complaint in court within TWENTY (20) days after this day's date. Notice of the action with a copy of the complaint and certified copy of the Decision must be given to the Town Clerk so as to be received within such TWENTY (20) days. n Dale W. Waine , Chairman cc: Town Clerk Planning Board Building Commissioner Assessor's Map Parcels 142 and R -1 TOWN OF NANTUCKET BOARD OF APPEALS NANTUCKET, MASSACHUSETTS 02554 42.3.2 32 and 32A Union Stree: 085 Plan Book22, Page 55 Lots 1 and 2 At a Public Hearing of the Nantucket Zoning Board of Appeals held 1:00 P.M., Friday, November 4, 1994, in the Selectmen's Meeting Room, Town and County Building, Broad Street, Nantucket, MA, on the Application of JULIE W. PARKER of 253 Meadowbrook Road, Weston, MA 02193, Board of Appeals File No. 073 -94, the Board made the following Decision: 1. Applicant is seeking relief by SPECIAL PERMIT under Nantucket Zoning By -Law §139 -33A or in the alternative, a VARIANCE under Nantucket Zoning By -Law §139 -16A to reconfigure the interior lot line separating two (2) said to be pre- existing non - conforming lots held in common ownership, so as to create two (2) new separately marketable lots. Each Lot contains a said to be pre- existing non - conforming single family dwelling. Lot 1, 32 Union Street, is said to be nonconforming with respect to the required 10 foot front yard setback, having a structure that is sited 6.5+ feet at is closest point from the front yard lot line. Lot 2, 32A Union Street, is said to be non - conforming with respect to the required 5 -foot side yard set back having a structure that is sited 2.0+ feet at its closest point to the easterly side yard lot line and 1.6+ feet at its closest point to the westerly side yard lot line, and is nonconforming as to frontage requirements as the Lot contains 28.34 feet in a zone that requires 50 feet. The premises is located at 32 and 32A UNION STREET, Assessor's Map 42.3.2, Parcels 142 and 085, as shown in Registry Plan Book 22, Page 55, Lots 1 and 2. The property is zoned Residential -1. 2. The Decision is based upon the Application and materials submitted with it and testimony and evidence presented at the Hearing. There were no letters on file. The Planning Board made an unfavorable recommendation on the grant of relief under Zoning By -Law §139 -33A as it did not have any provision for changing the configuration of lots. They further point out that the lots were created in 1983 and thus were not pre- existing non - conforming. The; further found that there were no grounds for grant of a Variance. 3. Applicant represents that each Lot conforms to the minimum 5,000 -foot lot area requirements of the Residential -1 Zoning Distr:..�-t in which they are located with 32 Union Street having a lot area o, 9,981 square feet and 32A Union Street having a lot area of 5,496 square feet. 32A Union Street does not conform to the fifty -foot frontage requirements having 28.3± feet of frontage on a way. (073 -94) -2- Each Lot has a pre- existing non - conforming single - family dwelling or it and each Lot complies with the ground cover requirements for thiE R -1 Zoning District. The structure on Lot 1 (32 Union Street) does not conform to the ten -foot front yard setback requirement, a portion of the structure being sited 6.5+ feet from the front yard lot line. The structure on Lot 2 (32A Union Street) does not conform to the five -foot side yard setback requirement, a portion of the structure being sited 2.0+ feet from the easterly side yard lot linE. and 1.6+ feet from the westerly side yard lot line. The reconfiguration of the Lots in 1983 did not change the non - conformities. 4. Applicant further represents that on September 1, 1983 the lot lines of Lots 1 and 2 were altered by a predecessor in title and a plan was filed in the Nantucket Registry of Deeds in Plan Book 22, Page 55 showing the current configuration. This alteration of lot lines caused the pre- existing frontage, front yard and side yard setback non - conformities to lose their "grandfathered" status with respect to zoning but did not cause a technical merger of Lots 1 and 2 because Lots 1 and 2 each arguably satisfy the definition of "Lot" contained in Zoning By -Law §139 -2 which states: two or more adjacent parcels in common ownership... each of which has been lawfully improved with one or more dwellings conforming to all applicable zoning requirements, if any, at the time of construction thereof, and each of which parcels was in compliance with area and frontage requirements applicable thereto at the time of such construction, shall be considered to be separate lots for all purposes under this By -Law, notwithstanding any subsequently- effective amendment to this By -Law. However, the frontage, front yard and side yard setback non - conformities became enforceable zoning violations after September 1, 1983 but are no longer enforceable because no enforcement action was initiated by the Town of Nantucket within ten (10) years of the creation of the violation as provided in the curative statute, M.G.L., Chapter 40A, §7 and By -Law §139- 25(C)(3). 5. Therefore, the Board finds that the shape of Lots 1 and 2 an3 the location of the dwellings located thereon are unique to the Lots and do not affect generally the zoning district in which they are located and a literal enforcement of the provisions of this Zoning By -Law would involve substantial hardship, financial or otherwise, to the Applicant and the desirable relief may be granted without substantial detriment to the public good and without nullifying or substantially derogating from the intent or purpose of such By -Law. 6. Accordingly, the Board GRANTS the requested VARIANCE relief under Zoning By -Law §139 -16A with four (4) in favor (Waine, Williams, Leichter and Hourihan) and one (1) opposed (Angelastro), to allow the reconfiguration of the interior lot line separating Lots 1 and 2 so as to create two (2) separately marketable lots with all of the non - conformities as set forth above, subject to the following conditions: (073 -94) -3- a. There shall be no further building on the Lots without further relief from this Board; b. There shall be only one (1) dwelling unit on each Lot; and C. The reconfiguration of Lots 1 and 2 shall be in conformance with Exhibit "A" attached hereto, a surveyed plot plan dated October 4, 1994 done by licensed surveyor Nantucket Surveyors, Inc. and labeled "Proposed Lot 1" and Proposed Lot 2 ". Dated: December /6 , 1994 Michael Angelastro TOWN CLERK'S OFFICE NAN- ruCKFT, MA 02_.55a DEC 161994 MAL. uLERK. /(^4 A FND. CB/DH EASEMENT CB/DH Dd.Bk.175,Pg.280 CB/DH FND. 1p CD 0 G5 Proposed LOT 3 2 1 /2 STORY WOOD FRAME/ 56 Go 00 6 Go DEED REF.: Dd.Bk.265,Pg.87 ASSESSORS MAP 42.3.2 PARCELS 85 & 142 NOTE: LOTS 3 AND 4 SHOWN HEREON HAVE THE BENEFIT OF AN EASEMENT TO WASHINGTON STREET RECORDED AT Dd.8k.l8lPg.271. A Public Hearing at 1:00 P.M., Friday, Room, in the Town and Massachusetts, on the JULIE W. PARKER Zoning Board of Appeals South Beach Street Nantucket, Mass. 02554 NOTICE of the ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS will be held November 4, 1994, the Selectmen's Meeting County Building, Broad Street, Nantucket, Application of: Board of Appeals File No. 073 -94 Applicant is seeking relief by SPECIAL PERMIT under Nantucket Zoning By -Law §139 -33A or in the alternative, a VARIANCE under Nantucket Zoning By -Law §139 -16A to reconfigure the interior lot line separating two (2) said to be pre- existing nonconforming lots, held in common ownership so as to create two (2) new separately marketable lots. Each lot contains a said to be pre- existing nonconforming single family dwelling. Lot 1, 32 Union Street, is said to be nonconforming with respect to the required 10 foot front yard setback, having a structure that is sited 6.5± feet at its closest point from the front lot line. Lot 2, 32A Union Street, is said to be nonconforming with respect to the required 5 foot side yard set back having a structure that is sited 2.0± feet at its closest point to the easterly side yard lot line and 1.6± feet at its closest point to the westerly side yard line, and is non - conforming as to frontage requirements as the lot contains 28.3± feet in a zone that requires 50 feet. The premises is located at 32 and 32A Union Street, Assessor's Map 42.3.2, Parcels 142 and 085, as shown in Registry Plan Book 22, Page 55, Lots 1 and 2. The property is zoned Residential -1. Dale W. Waine, Chairman THIS NOTICE IS AVAILABLE IN LARGE PRINT OR OTHER ALTERNATIVE FORMATS. FOR ASSISTANCE CALL (508) 228 -7215. BoA Form 1 -89 NANTUCKET ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS TOWN AND COUNTY BUILDING NANTUCKET, MA 02554 APPLICATION FOR RELIEF Owner's names) JULIE W. PARKER Mailing address: 253 Meadowbrook Road, Weston, MA 02193 Applicant's name: Same Mailing address: Same Date/l/l/,,��//,{'.�//� CASE No Q- 1 Location of lot: Assessor's map and parcel number 4232_ Street address: 32 and 32A Union Street 0142 and 085 Registry baTr&-Ct- -Flan, Plan Bk & Pg or 22/55 Lot s 1 & 2 Date lot acquired: 1/_L2/ 86 Deed Ref 264 87 Zoning district R -1 Uses on lot - commercial: None x or MCD? No - number of: dwellings 2 duplex_ apartments_ rental rooms_ Building date (s) all pre -8/72? Yes or Building Permit appl'n. Nos. Case Nos. all BoA applications, lawsuits: _ C of 0 ?_ State fully all zoning relief sought and respective-Code sections and subsections, specifically what you propose compared to present and what grounds you urge for BoA to make each finding per Section 139 -32A x if Variance, 139 -30A if a Special Permit _(,ay.Ld. 139 -33A x if t6—alter or--extend 'a nonconforming use).'1f appeal per 139 -3JA & B _ , attach decision or order appealed. OK to attach addendum . Applicant seeks a Special Permit under Section 139 -33a, or, in the alternative, R ECEi14 ED a Variance under Section 139 -32a, to reconfigure the interior lot line separating (2) pre-existing, non - conforming lots in common-ownership so "as to'create two TOWN CLERK'S O F FI 7 separate lots. Each lot includes a pre- existing non - conforming dwelling. �} NANTUCKET;: MA 025 4 OCT 19;1994 TIME: Items enclosed as part of this Application: orderl addendum2 x CLERK: Locus map x Site plan x showing present x +plann -f x "structures oor plans present proposed_ elevat of ns (HD— C.approved ?_) Listings lot area x frontage x setbacks GUT parking data Assessor- certifie3 addressee T st 4 sets x mailing label 2 setsx 1200 fee payable...to_. .Town of Nantucket • x proof • - -' cap' d6Vbnant (If an appeal, ask Town Clerk to sen3 Bldg Comrrs record to BoA-.7- I certify that the requested information submitted is substantially complete and true, to t )ie best of my knowledge, under the, pains and penalties of perjury. j Julie W. Parker, By her rn SIGNATURE: �ti /• z' nt Attorney /agt _ 3(If not owner or owner's attorney, enclose proof of authority) FOR Bo OFFICE USE Application copies recd: 4_ or_ for BoA on /V/� by One copy filed with Town Clerk on//�* by complete? One copy each to Planning Bd and Building. Dept $200 fee check given Town Treasurer on / 7�b //�����,�,,r1Lwaii)v�e�,d? Hearing notice posted�� mailed�� I & M�2h' , &JL;7/2 y Hearing (s) on_/__J_ cont' d to,_/_/_, �_/_ withdrawn ?___/__/ Decision due bye_/_ made_/_ filed TC�_/_ mailed__/__/_ See related cases lawsuits other rab7.7�1�n1i151 Applicant owns two (2) contiguous, non - conforming lots. Each lot includes a pre -1972 dwelling. Applicant seeks a Special Permit or, in the alternative, a Variance to allow her to reconfigure the interior lot line separating these two (2) properties so as to create two (2) separate, marketable lots. The properties are located at 32 and 32A Union Street and zoned Residential 1. Each Lot was created by virtue of an ANR Plan dated August 22, 1983 and recorded in Plan Book 22, Page 55 at the Nantucket Registry. Lot 1 (32 Union Street) has an area of 9,981± square feet and a non - conforming, pre -1972 dwelling which has a front yard set back from Union Street of approximately eight (8' ±) feet. A front yard set back of ten (101) feet is required in this R -1 Zoning District. Lot 2 (32A Union Street) includes approximately 5496± square feet and the pre -1972 dwelling and shed on Lot 2 are non- conforming as to side yard set back requirements. In addition, Lot 2 has non - conforming frontage of 28.28± feet on a Way; fifty (501) feet of frontage is required in this R -1 Zoning District. Applicant seeks relief to reconfigure the interior lot line between Lots 1 and 2 so as to create a Lot on Union Street (Lot 3) with an area of 5,549 ± square feet and a Lot on the Way (Lot 4) with an area of 9,930± square feet. Each lot will include an existing pre -1972 dwelling and there would be no increase in zoning non - conformities. p r i ` I� r ,� � �� � r y�i k •�i�� tin ., I.' MR .i� r ._ f ;. �.0 � �- I � it •,I �' b 1S: My4 •y4 p .. yy, c 1i R �06 m pz h i4 r Yttt a� IL -CIR } r 't.pi�l•YYfW�U. # t`ilac 'iiir ..:':rr�+,#�^".:' � .'v.......r ' ;; ��_ —.d .��..•.__y_„ ... .. .... ___ , s n e Z ;nTis ON Z xpOSi A2 x�r - a a tl Q k ; n n a, r-i r : C7 ♦ N < � � Imo, pz> -0 om�mn nn dr O� Sb y l `y T N Z ;nTis ON Z xpOSi A2 x�r - Q k ; n n a, r-i oc zsa m 000, 1 Vlyln pz> -0 om�mn nn dr O� Sb y l `y 0"SOO'0 � sJ F Y l.J Y X r N - gym° n -- _ i £m O N A I a II h H �• W 9�T. L� � pp O�tCKZ n ; mn° ulvnom v r0 � �SS 'i r ins °�N i O � pNl 0 1 , ;ryp� O IP C- N 0 Se�r=nNZ x O > D 02 y n ° �p0 x r C r7 2 v >yoz >�z('r, oi�.� zzc��in °mom` RI'Rt �• 1 � ��Fm� O 9 \ C °a0 mmN�A ti y 0 \Q rn 0>> 0 < m Z m m T N Z ;nTis ON Z xpOSi A2 x�r - Q k ; n n < omoos nN r-i zsa m 000, 1 Vlyln pz> -0 om�mn nn Dzo AmxnN 60 TD Z pmII000 A 2 y z 'o.R °'•i0 > X r N - _ £m O N D a r A T N x�r - G .- c^Z °m n °a ,i c at '� a S 16 s P j . I I h O �y c� Oti' 0 0 3r1 0 0 x _ T 2 -89 3oA' Form: NAITIICXET Z KING 10A OF 'TORN'71M COUNTY BUILDING = NANTUCKET, MA 02554 -= ASSESSOR = -8 LIST OP PARTIES IN INTEREST PROPERTX-;.OWNER:: APPLICANT~ FOR RELIEF (SAME' ) - ADDRESS-. OF - PROPERTY: ASSESSOR'S MAP - PARCEL: LIST .OF PARTIES "INCLUDING ADDRESSES *(OR SEE ATTACHED ): . - • - '�', `, � 199 � `° I Ce --that. the �orec oing (or the attached ) lists all -persons:; ,natural or legal, who are owners of abutting opposite on any public propezty'r.:= owners - oF:' land' cUsectly pp or private'street or way; and abutters of the abutters and all Other`�:and owners within three as.thed hand there property-line'.-Of Owners property, ey (a tax list address) appear ;on'•the most recent applicable Section 11 and Zoning Code Chapter 139, P Section- 139-29D.(,2) ] • Date Asses or�S Town of ntucket C>�R C-i- *NOTE:.Appli.cant *(petitioner) should include with the lot for.which zoning relief is sought; any commonly-owned abutting lots.which might.become involved in the zoning matter. List map and parcels for each abutter. b 08/30/94 TOWN OF NANTUCKET 07:41:59 OWNER'S MAILING ADDRESS LIST Map Block Lot Owner's /Co- Owner's Name Mailing Address /City State Zip Property Location 4232 0138 CLIFFORD CLARK M & MARGERY K 9421 ROCKVILLE PIKE 0022 UNION ST BETHESDA MD 20814 4232 0077 HALBERSTAM DAVID & JEAN 0027 W 67TH ST 0012 COFFIN ST NEW YORK NY 10023 4232 0080 NOYES ROBERT K & GRACE T 0010 COFFIN ST 025R WASHINGTON ST NANTUCKET MA 02554 4232 0081 NOYES GRACE TUTTLE & ROBERT K 0010 COFFIN ST 0027 WASHINGTON ST NANTUCKET MA 02554 4232 00822 CARUSO REGINA L 0016 PROSPECT ST 0029 WASHINGTON ST PO BOX 254 WOODSTOCK VT 05091 4232 00821 RAVANIKE REALTY GROUP 0030 BERKSHIRE RD 0033 WASHINGTON ST C/O ZISSI BARBARA WINCHESTER MA 01890 4232 00823 BARRETT PETER J & CLARA H 0010 MARTINS LN 0031 WASHINGTON ST HINGHAM MA 02043 4232 0177 LONGENECKER PAUL & DAVID JAMES 0024 UNION ST 0024 UNION ST PO BOX 1421 NANTUCKET MA 02554 4232 02021 CARROLL TOD TR 2620 S MARYLAND PARKWAY #403 024- UNION ST AAA LITERATURE CORP PROFIT LAS VEGAS NV 89109 4232 0202 OLSON ROGER G & JENNIE RAY 31300 EMERY RD 0026 UNION ST MORELAND HILLS OH 44022 4232 0178 FEIN SHERMAN E & MYRA N 224 LONGMEADOW ST 033C WASHINGTON ST LONGMEADOW MA 01106 4232 0179 VAN DE WATER VIVIAN 0028 UNION ST 0028 UNION ST NANTUCKET MA 02554 4232 0201 LEVINS HELEN 0023 UNION ST 0023 UNION ST NANTUCKET MA 02554 4232 0218 DIDRIKSEN PHILIP H JR & HELEN 0140 INDIAN HEAD RD 0025 UNION ST RIVERSIDE CT 06878 4232 0203 BRIGGS CHRISTIAN 0027 UNION ST 0027 UNION ST NANTUCKET MA 02554 x"4232 0204 * SUTRO PETER C & PORTER H TRSTS 2 GORHAMS CT 0002 GORHAMS CT SUTRO FAMILY REALTY TRUST NANTUCKET MA 02554 4232 0220 * SUTRO PETER C & PORTER H TRSTS 2 GORHAMS CT 0004 GORHAMS CT NANTUCKET MA 02554 4232 0180 *BEAULIEU VIRGINIA L 0551 LONGMEADOW ST 0029 UNION ST LONGMEADOW MA 01106 4232 0205 OCALLAGHAN HAROLD A JR & WENDY 0032 MT HOLLY RD 0001 GORHAMS CT KATONAH NY 10536 4232 0206 BROOKS MARIE L 0389 LAKE DR 0040 ORANGE ST PALM BEACH FL 33480 4232 0145 *HUMPHREY MARY C TRUSTEE 520 ASH ST 0031 UNION ST HUMPHREY NANTUCKET TRUST WINNETKA IL 60093 4232 0152 REINER PETER C & WOODS JULIE R 0207 WENDOVER RD 0044 ORANGE ST TRS 44 ORANGE ST NOMINEE TRUST BALTIMORE MD 21218 4232 0151 REINER PETER C TR 0207 WENDOVER RD 0046 ORANGE ST C/O WOODS JULIE REINER BALTIMORE MD 21218 4232 0150 MILLS SHIRLEY B CHERRY LN BOX 300 0003 CASHS CT C/O STOCKMAN SHIRLEY B MENDHAM NJ 07945 4232 0146 *CONGER MICHAEL W & CAROL R LEES HILL RD 0033 UNION ST BX 555 NEW VERNON NJ 07976 4232 0147 VAN ORDEN PAUL WILLIAMS 0005 THOMAS RD 0035 UNION ST WESTPORT CT 06880 PAGE 1 MUAS750 8.1 08/30/94 TOWN OF NANTUCKET PAGE 2 07.41.59 OWNER'S MAILING ADDRESS LIST MUAS750 8.1 Map Block Lot Owner's /Co-Owner's Name Mailing Address /City State Zip Property Location . 4232 0148 SANFORD EDWARD J TR 0003 MILL STREET 0037 UNION ST 37 UNION ST REALTY TRUST NANTUCKET MA 02554 4232 0092 ARON JON & LESLIE LINSLEY 0039 UNION ST 0039 UNION ST NANTUCKET MA 02554 4232 0093 HENSLER ARTHUR C JR & JULIE A 0020 HOLLY AVENUE 0003 FLORA ST TRS SIMPLICITY REALTY TRUST CAMBRIDGE MA 02138 4232 0094 * HANSLER ARTHUR C JR & JULIE A 0003 FLORA ST !4232 0095 HENSLER ARTHUR C JR & JULIE A 0020 HOLLY AVE 0003 FLORA ST TRS SIMPLICITY REALTY TRUST CAMBRIDGE MA 02138 4232 0096 MILLS SHIRLEY B POST HOUSE ROAD 0006 CASHS CT C/O STOCKMAN JOHN C MD MORRISTOWN NJ 07960 4232 0097 LETHBRIDGE FRANCIS D & MARY C 48 ORANGE ST 0048 ORANGE ST NANTUCKET MA 02554 4232 00891 BYRNES EDWARD J TR C/0 96 COUNTRY CLUB WAY 040A UNION ST WPOA NOMINEE TRUST IPSWICH MA 01938 4232 00892 *BIERLY L E JR & 0300 BOYLSTON ST 040C UNION ST DRAKE CHRISTOPHER P BOSTON MA 02116 4232 00893 *FRONK JANET K 110 ASH ST 040D UNION ST WESTON MA 02193 —'4232 00894 BYRNES EDWARD J TR C/0 96 COUNTRY CLUB WAY 040B UNION ST WPOA NOMINEE TRUST IPSWICH MA 01938 4232 0088 LEECH RICHARD E JR & LAURIE H 0005 HIGHLAND AV 0038 UNION ST BINGHAMTON NY 13905 4232 0087 BERTOLAMI MARGARET P 0069 SUMMER ST 036- UNION ST COHASSET MA 02025 ""4232 0088 LEECH RICHARD E JR & LAURIE H 0005 HIGHLAND AV 0038 UNION ST BINGHAMTON NY 13905 - -°4232 0087 BERTOLAMI MARGARET P 0069 SUMMER ST 036- UNION ST COHASSET MA 02025 4232 0144 MCCLURE FREDERICK P & MARGARET 1500 FLEET CNTR 0036 UNION ST PROVIDENCE RI 02903 4232 0086 COYNE SUSAN W 0091 STEPHEN MATHER RD 0034 UNION ST DARIEN CT 06820 4232 0026 *TOWN OF NANTUCKET 033B WASHINGTON ST 4232 0141 *PARKER JULIA W 253 MEADOWBROOK 030R UNION ST WESTON MA 02193 4232 0024 LORING LINDA PO BOX 1359 0035 WASHINGTON ST NANTUCKET MA 02554 4232 0025 LORING LINDA PO BOX 1359 035R WASHINGTON ST NANTUCKET MA 02554 4232 0084 *TOWN OF NANTUCKET 0037 WASHINGTON ST 4232 0028 LEWIS RICHARD E PO BOX 301 0042 UNION ST NANTUCKET MA 02554 4232 0221 NANTUCKET FOUR CHIMNEYS INC 0038 ORANGE ST 0038 ORANGE ST NANTUCKET MA 02554 4232 0219 REINER ANNE H FKA STEEL LOWER FROYLE ALTON 0036 ORANGE ST ROCK HOUSE FARM HAMPSHIRE ENGLD LD 4232 0217 SZIKLAS JOHN J & EDWARD A 0007 DRUMLIN RD 0034 ORANGE ST W SIMSBURY CT 06092