Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout089-86TOWN OF NANTUCKET BOARD OF APPEALS NANTUCKET, MASSACHUSETTS 02554 October 9, 1986 . Re: RONALD M. DASILV (089 -86) Enclosed, please find notice of a decision of the BOARD OF APPEALS which has this day been filed with the Town Clerk. Any appeal from this action shall be made pursuant to Section 17 of Chapter 40A of the General Laws, and shall be;.-filed within twenty (20) days after this date. � 1 William R. Sherman, Chairman BOARD OF APPEALS el BOARD OF APPEALS TOWN OF NANTUCKET NANTUCKET, MASSACHUSETTS 02554 DECISION: The BOARD OF APPEALS, "at a Public Hearing held on FRIDAY, OCTO- BER 3, 1986 at 1:30 p.m. in the Town and County Building, Nantucket, made the following Decision on the Application of RONALD M. DASILVA,-j-_ToG. (089 -86) address 10 Newtown Road, Nantucket, MA 02554. 1. Applicant seeks relief by SPECIAL PERMIT under Zoning Code SECTIONS 139 -33A and 139- 9B(3)(a) and (b) to alter and extend a non- conforming structure and use, said to pre- existnoning, the commercial use being allowable as an exception by Special Permit. Also sought is relief by VARIANCE from the off - street parking requirements of SECTION 139 -18, specifically, 18A and I. Applicant proposes to add 192 SF of office space for his contractor's shop. The premises are at 9 WINDY WAY Assessor's Parcel 67 -118, Lot 2 of Plan Book 22 at Page 94 (Lot 12 of Plan Book 20 at Page 66) in the zoning district RESIDENTIAL - COMMERCIAL -2. 2. Our findings are based upon the Application papers, corres- pondence, viewings and marked plans (our Exhibit "A "), representations, and testimony received at our hearing of September 5, 1986. Having taken the matter under Advisement until our hearing of October 3, 1986, we there found that the 1980 commercial building and use pre -dated a 1982 up- zoning to R -C -2. ifith that change, front yard setback was raised to 20 -foot minimum. The building had been sited with about 2 - foot setback in 1980 when none was required. The proposed 192 SF office - space addition will extend northerly from a post -1984 (per 3/2/84 ANR plan) addition of 256 SF, the northeast corner of which has presently the least front -yard setback, about 8 feet. The office addition will not be more non - conforming. 3. The lot of 8056 SF is of 7 -sided odd shape fronting on a "hammer- head" or "T" dead -end turn - around. Principal uses on Windy Way are commercial. On- street parking is not available. To satisfy parking (089 -86) -2- needs, Applicant will delineate on the ground two 3 -space parking areas at north and south ends of the lot. For the proposed uses, Applicant asks Variance relief from a Section 18I requirement of 2 more parking spaces. 4. Applicant's contracting business involves light manufacturing of building subassemblies and storage of construction materials on premises, used in building houses and other structures at job sites. Some 7 of his 9 employees work at the job sites, with more or less daily trips to the premises. Two normally work on the premises. At most, 3 off- street parking spaces are required for non - office employees. Industrial space for shop use is about 1800 SF for which 2 spaces are required. Office space will not exceed 400 SF, hence, 2 more spaces. An apartment dwelling unit on the second floor calls for 1 space, thus, a total of 8 parking spaces are required. belief by variance as to 2 spaces is asked. S. As parking is available primarily for employees and only occasionally customers, Applicant's assessment of need isseen as reliable, with any possible shortfall not adversely affecting the public good. 6. Similarly the proposed extension to provide additional office space is seen as reflecting normal growth of the business and not substantially more detrimental to the neighborhood. Substantially all property owners on Windy Way expressed support for Applicant. The objections of an abutter on another street were not clear in their relevance to the zoning question. The Planning Board's reconrnendation was favorable. 7. Applicant is seeking to bring the premises fully into compli- ance with zoning requirements and so asks our finding that proposed uses will not be in violation of Section 139 -20A. We have no basis for (089 -86) -3- anticipating excessive noise, fumes, etc. and so make the requested finding in support of the Special Permit for uses by exception, Section 139- 9B(3)(a) and (b), namely, contractor's light manufacturing and storage of construction materials. 8. For Variance relief, we find the requisite uniqueness in lot shape at a cul -de -sac, hardship in impact of R -C -2 up- zoning con- straining available space for parking with growth of the business, and absense of substantial detriment -to the public good plus unlikelihood of nullifying or substantially derogating from the intent or purpose of the zoning chapter. To ensure harmony with such general purpose and intent, we condition relief upon Applicant: (a) siting the 192 SF addition substantially as shown in Exhibit "A" with at least an 8 -foot front yard setback; and (b) delineating on the ground 6 off - street parking spaces in conformity with the requirements of Section 139 -18. 9. Accordingly, by UNANIMOUS vote, this Board GRANTS to Appli- cant the requested relief by SPECIAL PERMIT under SECTIONS 139 -9B(3) (a) and (b) and 139 -33A and VARIANCE from SECTIONS 139 -18A and I, subject to the above - stated conditions. Dated: October 9, 1986 Nantucket, MA 02554 C 9 William R. Sherman 9 Dorothy D. Vollans C. M rshall eal'e NOTICE A Public Hearing of the BOARD OF APPEALS will be held on FRIDAY, SEPTEMBER 51 1986 at 1:30 p.m. in the TOWN AND COUNTY BUILDING, FEDERAL AND BROAD STREETS, NANTUCKET, on the Applica- tion of RONALD M. DASILVA (089 -86) seeking a VARIANCE and SPECIAL PERMIT pursuant to SECTION 139 -32 for SECTION 139 -18 parking relief, and 139 -30 and 33A and under SECTION 139 -9B(3) of the Zoning By -Law. If granted, the Applicant would be allowed to expand an exceptional use in the RESIDENTIAL - COMMERCIAL dis- trict and for extension of the structure without increase of existing non - conformity of setbacks (front, rear and /or side line). Applicant would add 192 SF of office space for his con- tractor's shop. The premises are at 9 WINDY WAY, ASSESSOR'S PARCEL 67 -118, Plan Book 20, Page, 66, Lot 12. C William R. Sherman, Chairman BOARD OF APPEALS FEE., S1010.00 Case APF1ACA`_'10N TO '1111', 130ARD OF hPP•ALS Na10_uc11-,0t1, Massachusetts To the of the Board of AJ11(1,11tl: 'Flit, undersigned hereby cipplios for 1-elief from the t(•1111s of t`je (_10N11,V'G Di-1,AW)(BUILDING %�OL)E) on property described be1c)"ej: A)c , L i 0 ri (:) f Pt ope r ty 9 WillflY Way 12 Book 20, Page 66 ''istrict is zolleo f(jr RC Type of structure(F-misting or Ptoposc-,,d) or proposed Ilse: stGrage N Ronal Q M. D,u S., 1 a Address 10 Nle-,,!town Roacl, NLin+-_uti__k'c:,t. , NIA 012554 �Nlieri did acquire this property? .9 i_7 at Vu'.'_Icli- j Yes my at-poal bpe,­ macle' y (. s or _'ocle from -�-:hich rel_iet is rc!(iu(. 1-39-9, Special ion of kly ,_,aw fsc-_, res--cl ntial e r in a- -L V _r),,n,,.ierc1ai znne,- _139-16 Intensity .,)I. tor 3 3 -CA space f-or the cclitra,_cors r _sho p it the existing adding 92 Squz re f ect. Tipplicant requcS­.S _pccial- pre-existii-_g v,_ird' andlc)c rear Side -line sc-'- backs (,f- ---------- -1 by (,oction 139-3' _md special permi- ,.he ex t n St: stru(_-.'ur(_ 1-m I is peittz � r c i is tht_- a-d-Aition -c4- -tire offi-­c_e­a�� permi-tteu by Section 139__9 Of cij Further applicant r(_cduests variancr-, i:eiieE rom Sc , e i39-18 i, a :',tio c)­ of two "") park_',­ g ;'A':H: A list o f t) ic, n.,,i zlm-.�.--, and I d dAl I c';s es, C) f each .1i It tl-ifl(l (_)wn,_r -a n (I c w i % er abuttincl th... (2) A check in the ar;Iiotmt_ of of Nantucket. (3) Fuur cQpics of the a )plica icn a],­, a !il,m) (-)1 I.11 1-in sh;owi the locatioii of t property be (4) If app licarit is ot ],,cr t I,an L I I e o "i i i r e i i i r' , a your author"i--, to thl:.; BOARD , S D E C I S I u 1 .1 q,plic.itlun _­.u1LW_Ltte(_1 to Board-­­­ v c r 4 isin g da He'l nq �!a Le (s) Sion of i S, - L("!" filed with the Towil C1c�1A-.___ IA� ,k. ,4��',..� �/ Tom, �,1� 0 All 68 �' �' zr 0 • p, r' •' ` p � �i CA iO b 4 ry( 0 Q M -s- J C �Y 8s• ,�z '- v � h - o o.. i • 0 TOWN OF NANTUCKET BOARD OF APFEAL,; ,,f pars : +:�s in interc.' t. in U lip. matter Of the petition o LASIUA Add r e s s ' 0 Pr )�,''r�_y A:Idress z W/ --'-X� 2U. / D � j 6 02- /,',/ - I certify the f.-re<, q is a list of persons who are owners of la Utting'the propert.-, -ners of land abutting the abutters, ownej of land directly opposit, e property on any street or way, an - owners of land within 300 ?_ of the property, all as they appe . on the most recent applicable list. Le Town , la. 1.;cket ^ �-� a o ��| i' / ooar-zznz coopsn Jn«V*� o zwu . 000r wz*n/ wo, � °cxowocc r wzwo, wo/ ' mK-w`inn po-,`w ,c/ /ot, '1 0006 yzNo, WAY wwwrucxsr_ MA 02554 LAr o PL yn uo PS 65 MA 02SS4 0067-1182 MAURY JOHN & THERESA px-00181 0005 WINDY WAY pn-336 o*/ ,a, ' W)_�����L_�pI��`���.�n nl�� .| ,/--0067=M ao,urowJOmx o & xILonso n NANTUCKET , ,MA P2554 YOT6 PL, UK 20 P0 6n, °c*owssn 122 ponr AVE mK-vo/rp ps-zm 12/ /80 ------------noorpne�----�—rx����run '1 pc pc �c-* ------ --_--- 0067 13.74 aoYwrow Joov F) - novo nn,nrnx 'n NAN T UCKET MA 0=01 I-OT 10 PL UK 20 PO 66 � a .� un " Pl� ,L �u-s ' ~ . -----------_-----------------------_-----___---_-_---_ r, �cnsn �onr *znr-_-_-_-_ oo�^ a^nr�srr xn .'| °c*Awssn 1.4 a*mrLsrr nn IM 00170 po-cor 05/ /ry w^wruoxsT_ _ MA02,01 //!r c PL mK 16 pn no �-� a o ��| ASSESSOR'S DATA FILE vUPDwsD-muz3/e mWN OF NhMTmKFr . -------------------------_-------------_----_-_----------__-----_--' nnsoa ppoppR,, nssc e,n ee, ` ' ooar-zzor wzcK**ooss AaooczArznw 0006 yzNo, WAY -r/� n�r �mnss --- MA 02SS4 , *c*owosn pn pox zazn px-00181 pn-336 o*/ ,a, ' W)_�����L_�pI��`���.�n nl�� .| ,/--0067=M ao,urowJOmx o & xILonso n an,wnm /w °c*owssn 122 ponr AVE mK-vo/rp ps-zm 12/ /80 ------------noorpne�----�—rx����run '1 pc pc �c-* ------ --_--- 0067 13.74 aoYwrow Joov F) - novo nn,nrnx 'n munro1 Dsnn ----------�- --- -- -- -�- � � .� wAwrumKEr w* vc�ol un " Pl� ,L �u-s ' ~ . -----------_-----------------------_-----___---_-_---_ r, �cnsn �onr *znr-_-_-_-_ oo�^ a^nr�srr xn .'| °c*Awssn 1.4 a*mrLsrr nn IM 00170 po-cor 05/ /ry w^wruoxsT_ _ MA02,01 //!r c PL mK 16 pn no �-� a o ��| MA 02SS4 LOI 9 PL PL no- �-� a o ��| ASSESSONIS DAVA FiLk wrmm- .:'!! NrJ!T!tC!'J7.1 FA 1: 1.__' L. ...................................................................... NAME ; BILLINO AIIt,r 4I rn FT.T"Ty -PIES"C "IN D It, 0067 -2105 JOHNSEN ALBERT C JR,t SnRM P NAME & BILLINO ADDRESS 0003 MIACOMFT A11F xCl 1ANGFI) BOX 21.08 PRPPERTT DEPC nNU Cnir T 07/ /90 pi_ N1V1TUC"1J_­T, 6A 02,'581 L ITT 2 2 SK 21 1'>i11 mi . . . . . . ------------- 0067 - -3£30 -------------- ARN01.11 RODI".-Rf 2 ------------------------- 11 & NANCY C, ---------- ono6' mr: lf.'!�'s PROVI D(IN(E Ry 0"N'07 4"." FoRMC1 117F TIR '!K­001.85 ....... 0 ....................................... IARRY FRAMMS _1 ETAL PS-071 OR/ /91. . ...... . ...... ...... _..­__......_.... SLAITUNBURY CT 06033 Lor 10 PL FL 9-P T� 0067-381. . .. .............. SCHREIBER-ERIC 5 --------------------------- O&A MADMS •CHANGEU 40 C'f-..NTF,*.-:R ST PK.00221 1.:.(. 3,1 PC- Ass 11/go"01 1100,00 0067-116 WINDSOR LOCKS CU 0609A LOT It PL FL 9-P ------------------------------------------------------------------------ ---------- - - - 0067-37M MORSE STEPHEN A & MARY NW5 MWEH ff"MMS 1AN('-,'1-:J1 241 TAYLOR ST %�0022- P& 111 11109/Pi mv.o( (33RANBY MA 010133 1.01 8 PL FT 9--P ­ - - - - - - - - - - - - - -- -- - - -- 0067-­,77 NEWS OM JOHN �.*l & P [-----wcHhWGEd--- z4 WATFRSIDE­LN PS-21S 101 - /81 (.':L.IN'T0N Cl 06,11.3 LOT 7 F.•. FL 9.-H 0067'-113 PERRY f.'1111H 0022 BnRILETT Rr! cl BART LT. T'T RD EIRT-0009915 j /1." NIAN TUCK1.*-_'T MA 02'5511 !"1 SH 1.3 LC Pl.. ^.0108 -..n ASSESSOR ,S DATA FILE *UPDATED..- 06/13/9,1.. ?YIN . T. t NAME & BILLINO ADDRESS PRPPERTT DEPC nNU Cnir T 006 7­11.32 PERRY MANUEL j SR 0020 BARTLETT RD "?1.1 MELMSE ST PROVI D(IN(E Ry 0"N'07 09/ /80 L01 I PI.. "I PG z -------------- 0067-114 ....... 0 ....................................... IARRY FRAMMS _1 ETAL - --- --- 0016 BAR TkYrT Rp *C4lANG1-:D 16 BARTLETT RD NANTUCKF I' MA 0211-;31 PS -159 01/26/94 F11. P!, 1.:.(. 3,1 0067-116 PERRY DAUX0 r 01-OL-L ----- 0032 BARILET! RD ICHAN(31­71) 12 RI) NANTUCKET r.!K -Vol in ps-519 MA 02554 LOT I PL BK 16 ps 3() ---------------------------------------- LAMB EVERETT V KrUk 0010 BARTLETT NP NCHANGEX) Pl_ PK 20 P(, -I o 4 LAW OFFICES HOLMES, HAYS & FITZGERALD 35 CENTER STREET NANTUCKET, MASS. 02554 WAYNE F. HOLMES WILLIAM H. HAYS M JULIE A. FITZGERALD June 27, 1986 Mr. William Sherman, Chairman Board of Appeals Town and County Building Nantucket, MA 02554 Re: Special Permit /Variance Ronald M. DaSilva Dear Mr. Sherman: Enclosed for filing please find the following: 1. Application plus three (3) copies; 2. Certified Abutter's List plus three (3) copies; 3. Plan (4) copies; 4. Check in the amount of $100.00 to cover the filing fee for same. Please notice this matter and schedule it for hearing at the earliest available date. Very truly yours, Wayn F. Holmes WFH /jrc Enclosures cc: Mr. Ronald M. DaSilva .-i 79 AREA CODE 617 228-0052 till -1 FE F, $100.00 Case No. APPLICATION TO THE BOARD OF APPL•'ALS Nantucket, Massachusetts 1'o the Membej.s of the Hoard of Appeals: The urndersigned hereby applies for relief from the terms of thu- ('ZONING BY- LAW)(BUILDING CODE) on property described below: iocation of Property 9 Windy Way - - — -_ l,ot No. 12 Plan No. Book -20 Page 66 Dis-t rict is zoned for RC 'type of structure(Existing or Proposed) or proposed use:_ storage 'w►cci-'s Naive Ronald M. DaSilva Owrier's Address 10 Newtown Rd., Nantucket, N'A 02554 - lhen did you acquire this property? 1977 '!as applicatior been filed at Building Department ? Yes iias any previous appeal been made? Yes -- - - ^ - -- :'ect ion of Icy -Law Or Code from which relief is side line setback 139 -16 i,,o i!ic)n fov jslc.ing relief: To maintain existing building lines of structure, it is necessary to- Ioa�cte additizs�wzthin- allowed- side line setback limits. Si (: rat e o %) licant Ron ) Iva Attorney - :,'1 "1'A1 -I1 : (1) A list of the names and addresses of each abutting owner and owner abutting the abutters. (2) A check in the amount of $100.00 rnade payable to the Town of Nantucket. (3) Four copies of the application and a map or plan, showing the location of the property to be considered. (4) If the applicant is other than the owner, please i.nc?ic-ate your authority to make this application. BOARD'S DECISION .I?plication submitted to Board Advertising dates _!_ -� - - -- 1 1 e a r i n g date (s) -- -- - -- - -- -- - -- - -- - - -- -- - - -- Decision of Board Decision filed with the Towra C1Lrk Is �M All 68•� OR /8.gCgF -9 0 •��UP ��' .r _ ,; � �,, � _ � x,¢11 pp Ao � � t ry O q ci ` 0 .nor 41. :4.,W,4 - %z, ,a 6 ,3 6 O. o �, �o 8� .f h .nor 41. :4.,W,4 - %z, ,a 6 ,3 6 O. o �, �o 8� .f ASSESSOR'S DATA F'31 ...F.. !'OuN (,!­ !vN71!(T3 PAR'Cl-A I A INC 0007 ul•m my PROPORly Pg" " SOW: -XCHANGE'll 7 WINDY WAY BK-OOISS PS-013 OR/ /81. C/O DAY JAMES NANI UC'KET MA 021 54 LMT 5 PL-BK 20 PS 65 PO DOX 1.82',5 BT -00181 PO-336 04/ /81. F'(3-- ;'.'S'8 MA 1-120.--t31 1-_.71 11 F,L 0067-1182 MOURY JOHN t4 THERESA 0005 "IN"Y WAY ID020 POYN I 0H ! N *Cl IANGF-.1-1 19 UNION ST 1'.K-00179 Op/ /21. 9 NANTUCKET _MA 1..!K '20 F (, BOYNTON A z---------------------------------------------------- youl wXygy WAY SURFS I DF.­ RD CHANGED (:1D -(!�l RT 0-11 09" LOT' A Pl. FL 12--F ... .. I ... .... . ........ .... MAN I UFI((�')(KIE r MA 025.5-1 LM 10 PL UK 20 PS 66 ASSESSOR'S DATA F'31 ...F.. !'OuN (,!­ !vN71!(T3 PAR'Cl-A I NAME.. ;BILITHO CMUSP ------------------------------------------------------- PROPORly Pg" " SOW: I 0067-11G7 NICKANOOSE ASSOCIATION 0006 WINDY WAY C/O DAY JAMES 71 0061-379 CONLON PETER A 0001 PO DOX 1.82',5 BT -00181 PO-336 04/ /81. F'(3-- ;'.'S'8 MA 1-120.--t31 1-_.71 11 F,L k ? "!;, 20- PC--- 66 -----0067-9.3.7 --------------------------------------------------------------------- BOYNTON JOHN A & MILBN2:,O ID020 POYN I 0H ! N -wC1-lAN(A-':D 3.22 PORT AVE: 1'.K-00179 PO-711 12/ /80 19 '1EM!'2 LOT ION. R. !&I-- 0061 11.'74 BOYNTON A OGOH ROYNTEN LH SURFS I DF.­ RD NANI UCll,'ET MA 02!-"-'-"j,! LOT' A Pl. FL 12--F ... .. I ... .... . ........ .... -1 1-aRry AcRE.s-c ....... .... -ETT RP 0014 -BARTL- *CHANUED 1.4 BARTLE-TT RD P6-237 05/ /79 NAN'T UCKEA' MA 02t,"31 1. OT 2 PL SK 16 N3 30 :,I-- 10177218 REIS MYLES M & PRISC,ILLA,L 0057 SURFSIDF RP 57 SURF'SIDE: RD P11-00112 PF-411 /50 N - N'T U(','Kl,.: T 71 0061-379 CONLON PETER A 0001 GREFN MFATKIWS -CHANOED PO BOX 105*7 F'(3-- ;'.'S'8 It/ -- /92 NANTUCKET . - - MA 62554-TO1 9 PL FL 5-0 osoLsmUR'o mo/A pzUs :uroArsn- 06/131e: ---------------' m�'sv yr^.cen r:yn o" WRn/cA*/ ^ ..� ^ m'zwnON Cl* 06a3 �or r F«. r�. v-o _ ^ |. . 00672105 JO°macw nLosRr n jn & sem x CHANGED c� ^ °c*^wsso xo, 21.00 nr/ /sv ' 0016 PARTIEFT RD _w_Awr_cxsr _w* - 1 z581 L-r ce M. - an co - _ - n |'/-------'--'����� , '-- ] ,| - __-______---------------------__--... vnar-nvo , ^n mm x vwmLen - ^ wm�, - n --- --- .... ............ ---------------_---_-_ - - - !.' °�x*wsso Ao ronnc�zrp on 0012 RARILETT RD ,I ---- -- -------------------'--------________________________...... - m-Aorowoon, cr 06033 Lor 10 PL FL p-o |'1 .' _ WHANGED .... _______ Po 104 0067- 3711 MORSE: STEPHEN A & MARY L 0005 GREEN WnNIMP, m--HAN(,.;FJl 241 TAYLOR ST BK-00220 00-311 11/09/Si tqw,w vv^'-^'' wLwsom Jxxov n ^ rl szc , vo:, ---------------' m�'sv yr^.cen . ---�c���meu----z+ wAr,xm11-11-1 1 w ..� ^ m'zwnON Cl* 06a3 �or r F«. r�. v-o _ ---------------------------------------------- .� 0067 -113 nEnnr pnzr* oorc n^n,Lsrr pT! °cx^wmU'll omRrI-crr nn msr+mvpr^n ' /W, *f-)wrucm�r °m ocoo^ pr n* za �.c Fl.. 10100 ASSESSOR'S DATA FILE 'UPDAIEn- 06113/P6 rom tw p%mT"cKF*j, PERRY MANUEL J SR 0020 BARTLETT RD CHANGED 21. 1. MELROSE ST PROVIDENCE 0?/ /90 0016 PARTIEFT RD *CHANGED :1.6 BARTLETT RD NANTUCKET MA 02=4 PWITS 01/26/84 PL nK 15 ps 31 - PERRY DAVID E 0012 RARILETT RD WHANGED Po 104 TOWN OF NANTvCKET BOARD OF : "PPLAL Add r e s s ' l � ► V � ! V w� � � � , Y .wr� ,���� 00� �S` -- -- A l d r e s S 7 ccrti fy the f..re<• q is a i' tztting the propert.-, •ners of land directly opposit, e owners of land within 300 �.. on the most recent aonlicable /960 to list of persons who are owners of la of land abutting the abutters, owner property on any street or way, an - of the property, all as they appe. list. Town , Ia. ,.•cket in inf_ert.: t. in tl�.- matter Of tl�e pet ition o Name_k ! l� (,C� � ba- I V%� -- Add r e s s ' l � ► V � ! V w� � � � , Y .wr� ,���� 00� �S` -- -- A l d r e s S 7 ccrti fy the f..re<• q is a i' tztting the propert.-, •ners of land directly opposit, e owners of land within 300 �.. on the most recent aonlicable /960 to list of persons who are owners of la of land abutting the abutters, owner property on any street or way, an - of the property, all as they appe. list. Town , Ia. ,.•cket