Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout005-98'TOWN OF NANTUCKET BOARD. OF APPEALS NANTUCKET, MASSACHUSETTS 02554 Date: March ~ ~ 19 98 To: Parties in Interest and. Others concerned with the Decision of the BOARD OF APPEALS in the Application of the following: Application No.: 005-98 Owner/Applicant: CURTIS BARNES AND JOAN BARNES Enclosed is the Decision of the BOARD OF APPEALS which has this day been filed in the office of the Nantucket Town Clerk. An Appeal from this Decision may be taken pursuant to Section 17 of Chapter 40A, Massachusetts General Laws. Any action appealing the Decision must be brought by filing an complaint in court within TWENTY (20) days after this day's date. Notice of the action with a copy of the complaint and certified copy of the Decision must be given to the Town Clerk so as to be received within such TWENTY - ~- ( 2 0 ) days . ---- r ~\ le W. Waine cc: Town Clerk - ---- -Planning Board -~ Building Commissioner CLERK:_ PLEASE NOTE: MOST SPECIAL PERMITS AND VARIANCES HAVE A TIME LIMT.T AND WILL EXPIRE IF NOT ACTED UPON ACCORDING~TO NANTUCKET ZONING 'BY-LAW §139-30I (SPECIAL PERMITS); §139-32I (VARIANCES) ANY QUESTfONS, PLEASE CALL THE NANTUCKET ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS. Chairman RECENEC) TOWN CLERK'S OFFICE NANTl1ruF'r nna 02554 MAR ~~ 4 1998 ______ TIME: - --- - NANTUCKET ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS 37 Washington Street Nantucket, Massachusetts 02554 Assessor's Map 41 12 Sunset Hill Lane Parcel 450 Deed Ref. Book 192, Page 210 Residential Old Historic DECISION: 1. At a public hearing of the Nantucket Zoning Board of Appeals, on Friday, January 9, 1998, at 1:00 P.M., in the Conference Room in the Nantucket Town Annex Building at 37 Washington Street, Nantucket, Massachusetts, the Board made the following decision on the application of CURTIS BARNES and JOAN BARNES, of 12 Sunset Hill Lane, P.O. Box 192, Nantucket, Massachusetts, 02554, in BOA File No. 005-98: 2. The Applicant is requesting a SPECIAL PERMIT under Nantucket Zoning By-law §139-33A (alteration /expansion of apre-existing non-conforming use/structure) to allow a vertical expansion to change the roof line of a said to be pre-existing non-conforming 780+ square foot single-family dwelling/garage, that is located partially within the required five-foot westerly side yard setback area. The new addition will not come any closer to that lot line than the existing structure. The Locus is non-conforming as to number of dwelling units on a lot with there being three (3) separate dwelling units when a maximum of the two (2) units are allowed on a lot; and as to side yard setback with the subject structure being sited at zero feet at its closest point from the westerly side yard lot line in a district that requires a minimum side yard setback of five (5) feet. The premises is located at 12 Sunset Hill Lane, Assessor's Map 41, Parcel 450. The property is zoned Residential-Old-Historic. 3. Our decision is based upon the application and accompanying materials, and testimony and evidence presented at the public hearing. There was no opposition or support for the requested relief expressed at the public hearing and the Planning Board found that this application did not raise any issues of planning concern. The Applicants also produced a letter from along-time neighbor stating that the garage/apartment was constructed in 1940's and used as a dwelling. 4. The Applicants represented to the Board that they were seeking relief to renovate and expand the existing single-story garage/apartment structure. As to pre-existence of the subject structure and its dwelling use, the Applicants presented original drawings of designers and architects, dated prior to the 1972 enactment of the Zoning By-law, showing the existence of the three (3) structures on the lot and indicating each structure was used as separate dwelling unit. The Applicants plan to renovate the garage/apartment by constructing a conforming addition to the structure and by reconfiguring the living space therein. The structure will remain asingle-story, but the roof line in that portion of the existing structure lying within the required five (5) foot westerly side yard setback area would be raised from 12+ feet to roughly 16+ feet to match the existing primary dwelling on the property. 5. Therefore, a majority of the Board finds that the existing garage/apartment is a preexisting non-conforming structure and use. The Board further finds that the raising of the roof line of that portion of the nonconforming garage/apartment lying within the five (5) foot westerly side yard setback area will intensify setback the non-conforming nature of the structure. In addition, the Board finds that the proposed expanded garage/apartment will not be more detrimental to the neighborhood than the existing non- conforming garage/apartment. 6. Accordingly, by unanimous vote, the Board'GRANTS the requested relief under Nantucket Zoning By-law §139-33A to enable the proposed expansion and renovation of the subject garage/apartment structure under the following conditions: All additions and renovations shall be constructed in substantial conformance with Historic District Commission Certificate of Appropriateness. No. 30,495. b. The structure shall remain asingle-story and shall not come any closer to the westerly side yard lot line than existing structure. , Dated: ~!". 1998 V_ /~ ~ ~ N _l ~~C.~ dale W. Waine y Michael O Mara ~~~~ U ~ Linda F. Williams 2 TOWN OF NANTUCKET ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS 37 WASHINGTON STREET NANTUCKET, MASSACHUSETTS 02554 PHONE 508-228-7215 FAX 508-228-7205 NOTICE A Public Hearing of the NANTUCKET ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS will be held at 1:00 P.M., FRIDAY, JANUARY 9, 1998, in the CONFERENCE ROOM, TOWN ANNEX BUILDING, 37 WASHINGTON STREET, Nantucket, Massachusetts, on the Application of the following: CURTIS AND JOAN BARNES BOARD OF APPEALS FILE N0. 005-98 The Applicant is requesting a SPECIAL PERMIT under Nantucket Zoning By-Law 139-33A (alteration/expansion of a pre-existing non-conforming use/structure), to allow a vertical expansion to change the roof line of a said to be pre-exiting non-conforming 780± square-foot single-family dwelling/garage, located partially within the required five-foot westerly side yard setback area. The new addition will not come any closer to that lot line than the existing structure. The Locus is non-conforming as to number of dwelling units on the lot with there being three (3) separate dwelling units when a maximum of two (2) are allowed on a lot; and as to side yard setback with the subject structure being sited at zero feet at its closest point from the westerly side yard lot line in a district that requires a minimum side yard setback of five (5) feet. The premises is located at 12 SUNSET HILL LANE, Assessor's Map 41, Parcel 450. The property is zoned Residential'-Old-Historic. TOWN CLERK'S OFFICE NANTUCKET, MA 02554 DEC161997 TIME: -- - CLERK: `l'am ~/ C/ V~~~/ l ~- Dale W. Waine, Chairman THIS NOTICE IS AVAILABLE IN LARGE PRINT OR C~THCR ALTERNATIVE. FORMATS. FOR ASS-ISTANC;E LALL _ _._ __ (SO~~r..~~$=721 ~. __ -_ ~ - -- --- -- - -- - - -- -- ; . BoA Form 1-89 NANTUCKET ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS Date TOWN AND COIINTY BIIILDINO ^- NAN'-'IICRET, MA 02554 CASE No.~ APPLICATION FOR RELIEF Owner's name(s): Mailing address: Curtis and Joan. Barnes. PO Box 192 Nantucket, MPS 0255.4 Applicant's name: Same Mailing address: same Location of lot: Assessor's map and parcel number ~,- a5n _, ~ _~~~~,.,., 12 Sunset Hill Lane, Registry Land Ct Plan, Plan Bk & Pg or Plan File N/A ~,ot Date lot acquired: ~_/_ Deed Ref-192 , 210.. Zoning district Rox._ MCD? Uses on lot -.commercial :'None _ or - number of: dwellings 3 duplex apartments rental rooms C of O? Building date(s): all pre-8/72? or Building Permit appl'n. Nos. Case Nos. all BoA applicatior-s, lawsuits: State fully all zoning relief sought and respective Code sections and subsections, specifically what you propose compared e° Section and what grounds xou urge for BoA to make each finding p and 139-33A 139-32A if Variance, 139-BOA if a Special Permit if to alter or extend a nor~con~orming use). If appeal per 139-3~A & B _ attach decision or order appealed. OK to attach addendum . The Applicant is requesting a Special Permit under Chapter §139-33A to allow a vertical expansion to change the roof line of preexisting nonconforming dwelling located partially within the required side yard setback. The locus is nonconforming as to number of dwellings on a lot, there being three (3) dwellings where only two (2) dwellings are allowed and as to side yard setback with a dwelling structure located on the westerly lot line. Items enclosed as part of this Application: orderl addendum2__, Locus map x Site plan x showin present +planned~ structure Floor plans present proposed elevat ons ~ (HDC approved?~ Listings lot area ~ronta~~e setbacks x GCR_~ parking data Assessor-certifie3 addressee. List 4 sets ma~ling labels 2 sets- ~200 fee payable to To~:;n of Nantucket proof -r'cap' covenant (If an appeal, ask Toom Clerk to sen Bld Comr s record to BoA.~ I certieYandatrueetoethesbestlofomyaknowledgeltundersthebpains1andY complet penalties of pe ju y. SIGNATURE: ~ Applicant ~C Attorney/agent 3flf not owner or owner's attorney, enclose proof of authority) __ \ FOR B A OFFICE USE (~ ~~ . Application copies recd: 4_ _ or for BoA on~~!~ by k one co filed with Town Clerk on~~~~ ~ by ~~ complete? pY One copy each to Planning Bd and Building Dept by $200 fee check given Town Treasurer one ~~~ b waived? Hearing notice posted ~ t mailed( ~~ I & M , Hearing (s) on~~_ cont' ~.~ to_/~_, ~_/_ withdrawn?~~._ Decision due by~~_„ made~~.,_, filed TC~~._, mailed_/,~_ See related cases lawsuits other ZONING CLASSIFICATION: .RQ•~ MIN. AREA: .--?,~OO,.~.F MIN. FRONTAGE: ~C~• ~.~ FRONT YARD S.B.: . . ~yo~~.~ GR U 0 COVER (9.): :? ~/ ~• p,EGK ~ e r ~ .~ ~ ~rY W/F i ac. r No/j~ ~ K Cy°QA a s.F) .g-! - 2 3 TOW/f O f x.~.~T vcx~T ,COT ~ ,G.C. I.S.S/5 D ~- G. !' t~ F. na . L /~.M Fnil yr!i' ^,, xo~s~ ~OTioK G• . ~$~ ~. rtA2 ~g 8 t ,5.~ a s. e .:~.0 G.O ~~ ~SY << S /_" \ . ` ...E ~'c.a ~ , ,~ -SL! - 5U n./ r W. F.' /~.~.i.is. EXISTING: ~.sy,~ . '!... .....! .. .1~ ~•'1 r:~ ~~: / T_J 'S yy~x ~7 r ~ ~J ~^~"~ C`I , A ~ti~cti ,ZA~ 9'J 9 r S. F. ;1 ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ "1 T Y .~ ~ 7 V ~ ~ ~ v Z ~: ~' z c ~ ~ '-i ~-- -~1 ., ~~~" a5 ~„ ~ ~ i ~ ~ i 1 ~ ~,e,/~K/N6 11 ~ /,~z ~ ~ ~ ~ S S ,1 ~~~\lN OF ,yq "~l~ go CHARLES y~ I ~E$ FY, ~ /0-z~;~(~ ,THAT THE IL S/ ~° OCATED ON THE GRO .. ~1 ON. PROFI=SSIONAL LAND SURVEYOR TH1S PLOT PLAN WAS PREPARED FOR THE TOWN OF NANTUCKET BUILDING DEPARTMENT ONLY AND SHOULD NOT BE CONSIDERED A PROPERTY UNE SURVEY. THIS PLAN SHOULD NOT BE USED TO ESTABLISH PROPERTY ES, NCES, EDGES, OR ANY ANCILLARY STRUCTURES ON THE PREMISES. THE PROPERTY L1NES SHOWN RELY ON CURRENT DEEDS AND PLANS OF RECORD. TH1S PLOT PLAN IS NOT A CERTIFlCATION AS TO TITLE OR OWNERSHIP OF THE PROPERTY SHOWN. OWNERS OF ADJOINING PROPERTIES ARE SHOWN ACCORDING TO CURRENT ASSESSOR RECORDS. ASSESSOR MAP: .y~ . PARCEL• .y~? ~. / .rY MJF ~e~sr. ~ ~: , .. R, D• x I ~ L BUILDING LOCATION PLAN OF LAND IN NANTUCKET, MASS . SCALE: ~"= 3O ~ DATE: OCT ~~/99~ Owner: CUr<'TS~•.?~'-. ~ T~A!`~. Bi.4~/V~~ . Deed: ~ ~~z .,~': ~2/O Plan .~C~!1/~. Locus ~~ :S'vNS.E"T ,y,/.~.L , .~_.4it!.~ . CHARLES W. HART & ASSOCIATES, Inc. SANFORD BOAT BUII.,DING 49 SPARKS AVENUE NANTUCKET, MASS. 02554 (508) 228-8910 NOT TO BE RECORDED. H-'~~3 C:\J085~CWF{~BIP a zre' \~ •-'~ azio 2a1 2az ~ a ~ ~° ~« . 71 213 I.S .7 234 0 0 QJ•' ; .I a 1.0 A / y +23•. M43 114 1 ,_n 226 rlcuwias • t 3 ~ a _ ~ 214 1\~' " ?A 233 zso zs1 j - 215 216 217 220 G .,o .+ z rI i.8 A `~ 252 ~ z ~ , 1 tl ~ •. .•s •+~ h~ /1i ~a r W 7~ ^3 10 • _ .~ iia.8 o2`I 232 25 `a98 sr 430 z > 358 359 366 q ~ °q1 \ ] 2S - m 25 - O _ - S'• ~ 367 tip' ^' ~ ~~a.q `5 ~t~'1 so3 yj.1, i'sY u3Sl 357 360 365 /soy 221 .• 500 V \. a0 ~n 502 H\~' ~ 346 ~ Q o ~ t ri13 225 a 231 255 t 9 'y0 (- T \Sr N SS2 358yJ 368 63 3~ \ 224 3 228 229 ~ ~ i r\,r1..1 a ~SZ aEE ~~ 1 `4c,,. 364 SZ - r^ - 345 n " 361 ~\ W t~ 4~ \~ OME51` Sy 1 it .p ~5S I• 473. y3~a • V• 477 '10 ~ A fi y ~ 390 W- w 1 2 I_I s • r 555 EES 375 377 37e 391 ass' "~ a '~' i5e Is3 J63 t+ 3T "S 544 353 $~A 479 69 370 371 '~2 373 374 38 1 3E6 ~ 257 259' s 134 i ~~~• .z0 r•' 250 hSS FOUNDATION, INC. 363 ~ ,• CITE STER 362 578 380 ~ 384 SB7 SCI 26 263 IS6 ~ ~ r 1 354 / yA ~~ 339 340 ljl 417' 478 4a7 F 267 284 M 8 [S\ ,749 R4ryM(zN 266 z65 ~ 157 422 • TOMN Of TOwN OF STREET Jr yB + Vr > 423 NANTUCKET NANTUCKET ~ S~3 378 Ol0 NORTN MEW NORTN L8B 289 486 ' L7 A CEMETERY 4z V CEMETERY IS ~7 r 423 C 48! 424 542 438 31 392 274 V ~ '~1 I.5 A 2. I A 2.1 A ~ J -3 i 70 160 c T "~ 1.2 • 10.8 A } SOS 393 c1j ~ 3:.~ ~ ~ A 27 ]Y 271 IEi 33 I_ _ _ > E`Ot•E lAN • 7A ~i 426 ~ Ao ' 1 41e? 39, bs ~ NANTUCKET 1]GI f,1 741.1 ~ 34 '1 ~~ CON 3ERVATION 40 :>6 i,i.y 1441 a7 a FOUNOA:ION, INC., lad 421 427 3 '¢ ti7 1.2 A N „ J -2.4 A ~ ~ \'.S4A \ 435 ~ 3 A /Iii s s30 1 428 GPOV~31i !R8 MA• 434 NAV bW '~ I \ SS'\ 1 •29 4 I ~A ' 4ea ~. 447 ass '~ tS~ ,4*,r7~' h ~ a N'>\ 3y~ n ~ 1+7~~ I.0 A - ~ I h h ~• S}• 1 sl• 431 ~G,1 .1oG t ~E.$ 148 397 K h ~. ' 444 , K'OOO6URY ~ 3.: = Syd S~ ~ y~ 1.2 A 446 394 ~ Si i, ~~Np 1 F Yw7i t ~t 430 r _ 4 .4~ .„^ ~yp1 1 ~ 1 1.8 A ;oL 1 IM 11 603 402 ," 462 39 282 ~ 7 / ~j7 ~a 5a ~'Y 1 432 400 _ "SW 506 164 1 8 4 283 =G7 ! f v 41~ A 14134 349 A CGC 404 401.f Voi.2 ' SL2 (• 3 281 $La h 185 i 1 51.3 r Htl. g ~ 40, a~ 265 Sb9 ~ 5 54q ., 1 a • 570 m 5cs 6 4s4 ~ 408 300 6'~O.1 .~Qq S3 1294 296 i ) SLS 510 S.S A o 1.4 A 1.3 A -__ 287 , i~..a 2C1 n -- 323 4,2 409 ~ d j~ --°1 p 511 ~ 411 1.2 A 1 407 538 295 ~ rif ~ ~ ;70 ITI 172 455 292 4 1V, 4 > 0 301 5.10 ~~'. S 291 i89 '~,`J''~AIN ;Tf?EET 17° 504 303 n ~.,~ a~3 296 = 9S Kr ~~ .S ~:' :1::1 :..•rv~~ i5e 1 O j ~ N S 297 537 S sIZ s ~ ~ 2S 23 o T ° n:z~ n+ szo q MADAKE7 1 n1 O 1j ROAD "ra ~ 322 321 320 319 318 307 308 30 12 • H4 w 524 0 1~ 317 318 ppO 186 ~ ° 522.1 36 37. W 30B ~ 1.3 A TOWN OF NAKTUCKET ~ z1 314 SIS 6 FRIENDS BURYING OROUKO 173 ~~ 4• • 17,•1 IB! 181 174 175 38 ~ 309 y 188 S.O A 1' .1 I ~ 313 ~ 310 , J~~ 187 ve.r• 311 p 1.7 A 312 tl 189 4 176 39 n 190. ~ 18 2 '°y- y0 195 ~ ` 191 ' VBSN 16 ~ ~ ~ ~ 7, ~ r '~ \ 185v' ~ , I.1q.:. / ~ ' 40 of 196 \ 192 z yi p >.] 197 \ 59.1 S7 1 ~ ; i 48 4T 48 46 ~ ` ~~ "Y' ~ 1.0 A ` A9 .h ~• 4 ~ ~• fsw >' 160 ~\ \0 St. 1a.a a EET 4~ J' r ' 001 rYf 62 •O 39 , C tA1, $1F ~ 55 Si i ' 529 'z.•. ~ ; A, ~~w~y 50- N lO2OCO 528 a s• b 56_190 •I •( ~ _ ~ ~ Sri '19 ~ - ~ 56-197 56-2 56.200 - S6-I98 ~ ~ 66-189 ~ Mtn ^ T'Si ~ _~ ~ W TOWN OF NANTUCKET 1 4 i - ry _ _ ~~ s~~Cc,~ ~C:~~f;*~[. ` :ROT1iC6.~, iIOC. ~ .~ z ~HEeT -r: ,r ` ~ ~'.{~ . - ! 1 t ^~ ^S^:.. S o SHEET ;r~DEx 1 ~~•J I ;~ ~,1 - _ : SIGNAL ~ i;I.:EC RS ~ ^er1~STF.n: D IAN: SURYEYORS .-~ v - e _. ~,; ,E'~, - 1 9 FCDERAI + .• F:ANTJCK':T, MA55. ~ J 1 G _'l~~?Y - j ~ e:~ ~ -/~1a ;yt _ 3 w ~ ,O ~ ~ 1~. ti, 1c~ . ~ a / F~ ` ROB~Rt ~F,• l n ~ Y jt ~Z ~t ~~j^ ~~~'-~~ BoA Form _. ~ _.__~---_ - --- ~ 1 NANTUCKET ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS '---- -- ----- -" TOWN.AND COUNTY BUILDING NPNTUCi<ET, MA 02554 ASSESSORS LIST OF PARTIES IN INTEREST PROPERTY OWNER : 1 a ~ i .~ ~1 ~'~ ° ~ ' APPLICANT FOR RELIEF (SAME? ) ADDRESS OF PROPERTY : ~ ~ ~~u~ ~ ° ~" ~ ~ ~ I ASSESSORS MAP & PARCEL: ~--~ ~ ~-I~SC~ LIST OF PARTIES INCLUDING ADDRESSES*(OR SEE ATTAC'r?ED~~ I certify that the foregoing (or the attached-) lists all persons natural or legal, who are owners of abutting property owners of land directly opposite cri-:an-~ Public or private street or way; and abutters of~the arutters~and all other land owners within three hundred feet of the _ property line of Owner's property, as they ( and their - address) appear on the most recent applicable tax list {per M.G.L. c. 40A, Section 11 Zoning Code Chapter 139, Section 139-29D (2)}• °2 P.sses rs Office Date Town of Nantucket *NOTE: Applicant (petitioner) should include with the lot for which zoning relief is sought, any com~-r.only-owned abutting lots which might beco:~e involved ir. the zoning matter. List r.:ap and parcels for each abutter. C 12/01/97 TOWN OF NANTUCKET 08:52:01 OWNER'S MAILING ADDRESS LIST Map Block Lot Owner's/Co-Owner's Name Mailing Address/City State Zip Property Location 0041 0451 GUSTAVSON FRED G 0070 S STATE RD 0031 W CHESTER ST BRIARCLIFF MNR NY 10510 0041 0030 HEIDTKE BRIAN J & DARLENE A 0585 SPARROWBUSH RD 0033 W CHESTER ST WYCKOFF NJ 07481 0041 0149 TOOKER MARCIA G 0035 WEST CHESTER ST 0035 W CHESTER ST NANTUCKET MA 02554 0041 0150 PRATT GORDON WILSON & BARBARA 2835 WINGFOOT CT, SE 0037 W CHESTER ST WINTER HAVEN FL 33884 0041 0151 NANTUCKET ISLANDS LAND BANK 22 BROAD ST 0038 W CHESTER ST NANTUCKET MA 02554 0041 0152 SCHWAS WILLIAM C & SHEILA D P.O. BOX 43070 0045 N LIBERTY ST C/0 BANCBOSTON MORTG. CORP. JACKSONVILLE FL 32203 0041 0153 BLOWERS WARREN L & GAIL E 0408 LATHROP AVE 0043 N LIBERTY ST BOONTON NJ 07005 0041 0154 SHERAW THOMAS D TRUSTEE 152 ROSEMONT STREET 0041 N LIBERTY ST ALBANY NY 12208 0041 .0,155 GOLDBERG MARVIN L & MERNA E PO BOX 4157 0039 N LIBERTY ST C/0 PRUDENTIAL HOME MORTGAGE FREDERIC MD 21705-4157 0041 0485 RAY MELVIN L & GWENDOLYN 0036 W CHESTER ST 0036 W CHESTER ST NANTUCKET MA 02554 0041 0031 WOODLE JESSICA 1001 PARK AVE 0034 W CHESTER ST NEW YORK NY 10028 0041 0259 GILBERT THEODORE W & PEGGY A 0046 N LIBERTY ST 0046 N LIBERTY ST NANTUCKET MA 02554 0041 0258 ERASER FLORENCE 0080 SIWANEY BLVD 0040 W CHESTER ST EASTCHESTER NY 10707 0041 0257 BLOOM HOWARD S & SUSAN E ETAL 0003 MACDONALD PL 0042 W CHESTER ST SCARSDALE NY 10583 0041 0236 HAMMOND BRADFORD C & PHYLLIS R 2140 NORTHLAND AVE 0074 N LIBERTY ST LIFE ESTATE LAKEWOOD OH 44107 0041 02561 DREW MARY V 0029 MOHEGAN RD 0048 N LIBERTY ST C/0 LAND JANE LARCHMONT NY 10538 0041 0255 TOOLE BARBARA 0050 NORTH LIBERTY ST 0050 N LIBERTY ST NANTUCKET MA 02554 0041 0254 GILLUM JAMES E JR & SARAH HORN PO BOX 1857 0056 N LIBERTY ST NANTUCKET MA 02554 0041 0253 KNAPP NANCY HAY 0326 SPRAGUE RD 0058 N LIBERTY ST NARBETH PA 19072 0041 0252 LEMAITRE CHARLES E & ALINE A PO BOX 66 0062 N LIBERTY ST HARDWICK MA 01037 0041 0232 SCHIFF ROBERT J & SUSAN R 61 FRANKLIN AVE 0060 N LIBERTY ST RYE NY 10580 0041 0233 SILVA ALBERT L & GLADYS M PO BOX 809 0064 N LIBERTY ST NANTUCKET MA 02554 0041 0226 SILVA ALBERT L & GLADYS M PO BOX 809 0068 N LIBERTY ST NANTUCKET MA 02554 0041 0235 TAYLOR ROBERT L & DEBORAH A PO BOX 1013 0070 N LIBERTY ST NANTUCKET MA 02554 0041 0490 BOYNTON RICHARD L ETAL 0067 N LIBERTY ST 0067 N LIBERTY ST NANTUCKET MA 02443 0041 04901 BERRY TURNEY P TRUSTEE 1200 ONE RIVERFRONT PLAZA 067A N LIBERTY ST C/0 OGDEN NEWELL & WELCH LOUISVILLE KY 40202 PAGE 1 MUAS750 8.4 12/01/97 TOWN OF NANTUCKET PAGE 2 08:52:01 OWNER'S MAILING ADDRESS LIST MUAS750 8.4 Map Block Lot Owner's/Co-Owner's Name Mailing Address/City State Zip Property Location 0041 01421 LEE PHILIP ODONNELL & 6501 LONGVIEW LN 0004 GIFFORD ST BROWN CHRISTINA LEE LOUISVILLE KY 40222 0041 0029 *NANTUCKET TOWN OF 0002 BATHING BEACH RD 0048 CLIFF RD C/0 PARK & REC NANTUCKET MA 02554 0041 0144 SYKES RICHARD M PO BOX 308 0063 N LIBERTY ST E NORWICH NY 11732 0041 0143 SYKES RICHARD M PO BOX 308 0065 N LIBERTY ST E NORWICH NY 11732 0041 0248 HILLIS EDWARD C JR 456 DIAMOND RD 0061 N LIBERTY ST JACKSON NJ 08527 0041 0492 *MILNER ANN L 9A MONUMENT SQUARE 0057 N LIBERTY ST CHARLESTOWN MA 02129 0041 0495 DAMBRA GARY F & PAULA M 0010 OYSTER SHELL LN 0055 N LIBERTY ST BARRINGTON RI 02806 0041 0497 DAMBRA GARY F & PAULA M 0010 OYSTER SHELL LN 055R N LIBERTY ST BARRINGTON RI 02806 0041 ~ 0495" FEINSTEIN LEONARD & EDITH 0012 W 96 ST 0053 N LIBERTY ST - ~-- ----- NEW YORK NY 10025 0041 0499 MULLIN GERALDINE A & 6 SUN5ET HILL LANE 0006 SUNSET HILL LN BARNOTH THOMAS J NANTUCKET MA 02554 0041 0500 HRONES JOHN A JR & CYNTHIA 0053 COULTON PK 0051 N LIBERTY ST NEEDHAM MA 02192 0041 0501 CONLON HUGH W & SUSAN SANDLER APT 9C 0002 SUNSET HILL LN 780 WEST END AVE NEW YORK NY 10025 0041 0502 BAIRD KENNETH S & ELIZABETH AT 0004 SUNSET HILL LN 0004 SUNSET HILL LN NANTUCKET MA 02554 0041 0503 MOHR BROOKE S 396A SOUND BEACH AVE 0008 SUNSET HILL LN OLD GREENWICH CT 06870-2222 0041 0145 HILLIS EDWARD C & DORIS C 456 DIAMOND RD 0061 N LIBERTY ST JACKSON NJ 08527 4244 00334 PORTER STEPHEN TR C/0 PORTER D 1155 21 ST NW 0010 FOLGER LN WILLKIE, FARR, GALLAGHER WASHINGTON DC 20036 4244 0032 *NANTUCKET HISTORICAL ASSN PO BOX 1016 0022 SUNSET HILL LN NANTUCKET MA 02554 4243 0004 STOUT KATHERINE & WOLFE ELIZA PO BOX 2233 0024 SUNSET HILL LN & STOUT FREDERICK L III NANTUCKET MA 02584 - 4243 0003 HURLEY DAVID F & JOHNSTON RICH 0290 N BEACON ST 0019 SUNSET HILL LN DBA HURLEY & JOHNSTON BOSTON MA 02135 4243 0002 PLACKE JAMES A & MARY S 2176 NORTH 21ST COURT 0027 W CHESTER ST ARLINGTON VA 22201 4243 0001 SPRING SUSAN K 0029 V1 CHESTER ST 0029 W CHESTER ST NANTUCKET MA 02554 4243 0052 HADDAD RONALD J & PATRICIA S PO BOX 3736 0030 W CHESTER ST PLYMOUTH MA 02361 4243 0051 ROREM NED 18 WEST 70TH ST 0032 W CHESTER ST NEW YORK NY 10023 NUMBER OF RECORDS = 49 12/01/97 09:02:42 Map Block Lot Owner's/Co-Owner's Name 4244 0049 SAWB CORPORATION C/0 BROWN R M TOWN OF NANTUCKET OWNER'S MAILING ADDRESS LIST Mailing Address/City State Zip 0011 a 19 ST NEW YORK NY 10011 Property Location 0024 CLIFF RD PAGE 1 MUAS750 8.4 NUMBER OF RECORDS = 1 ~ t?I L?I 41 11 U I I I I I U 11-tl 41 51 0~ LJ I~,,~~.,.~_" CHL '41-1 l_~ LL's L-J L-~J ~ ~ AI Ire„ „„ cnuD No ._ o f-~ Pl~l~llll.i 1<^^-/11/97 UU1< SUNSET HILL LN nnD snLE ~ -- CIIAN(:E DELETE PROPERTY FACTORS ___ TOPOGRAPHY UTILITIES .`~i HL i.i On FlOnO LOCATION LEVEL nu ruour, Pnvrr--- minnN na~ivE SniFFr ~unuc wnlFR z sl.~o no-D sunuuonN BELOW srREET ~PUeuc sewtR a uu~nvrb RunnL ROI.ONG CAS PU~IPC~iFD BUS UI[i [IFFP _ weL-i. - - ~-:;~rr,Fn ~ Iuausl~InL Low -- - - E nr - - - - - - - ADDT -_ F A -' -'__ ~ ~__ I - - - - I',, RECOaDOPOwNERSHIP R T °` ` `'r `" AFNES-CL7RTI5-L~F.~R~IIAT7-TF25T 044.~_IS~-4 ~7 •~i - --D-99 HISTORY CODE APPRAISED VALUE ASSE„ED ':'~i UE ~ \i N RES LAND 1090 247700 X47700 RESIDNTL 1Ct9t> ?i740U _~74U0 TorAL 5751i7Ct I 575100 EAR Q RE3 LAND iCt90 24770~t ~477pO RF_SIDNTL 1090 3~74U0 '<<^7400 ToTnL 5751Li1i 5751Ctit~ ARNES CURTIS L JR $: JOAN S ?Ctl9^<~10 G it ^c ~ O --- ----n- - EXEMPTIONS _.- - _ iI __-------_.--- ~9~n'"r-~'ES-EXEMF"f7DN~itnE~445g51 I I I L I TOTAL AREA I ~ ~ "~~~ I - _ ~ LAND VALUE CONSTRUCTION DETAIL NOTES/VALUATION AUTHORITY HEARING CHANGES SKETCH ' ELEMENT _ [v!E .N( CRIPT ION : D ES - --_-_.. STYLE MooEL< i~ ll T'1A~T~~ T f~ DI~L,AL-0 'ESIDENTIAL it-i~Tii.~i~ DQL ~.VIVL -- -RnDE 1.`. sroRlES OCCUPANCY EzT WALL , z ) J1 14 . U OOD SHINGLE <4 +--------------- IFGR I --------+ I I RoDFSrRUCTURE RaxcovER . 13 SF'H/F GLASS/CO I I I I wT wnu 1 z I 14I I 14I INT. FLOOR i ~ I I I I HEAnrJC FDEL - . HEAnNGrrrE nIR COND. TYPE r ?~ _)1 OT WATER ONE COST MARKET APPROACH I I I z4 24 I I 5 I IIEDROOMS DnrNROOms roTAL RooMS ~~ nnTN srvl.e I nlrcNEN STYLE L "tC > ~ l • EIII~IOQ~-- 1 . U "tit ODERN ODERN UNAUJ BnSE RATE. slzE nor. FACroR DRADE woex EFF. ensE RATE FIID. MZTJCST VnLUE S. _ _ 1.4849 0.9 117. •'_+£3 SG4~7 +'---i'--------------- I BAS I I I ----+---++ I STF' I I I I I , I I fOMMERCIAI.ONI. Y YEAR GUILT 1951 I I I ' -ifEATa nm coruD DIANE IYI'E ' nniRSPLUMBING CF.ILhNALL FIN. RooMSPARnnorJS ^~~ (:OMAION WALL WAl l Hf,NI Err. vEAR BLT. NORM. DEPFl. FUNC. OBS ECON. OBS. srec. corJD coDE SPEC. COND "•" CONDITION 197' ~4 . Ltl1 6 • ~ 1(1 17I I I I I I I 8 I 15I i8I I I I I I I I I 5 I +----+ CONDOMINI UMS ICO OPS DEPR. 9LDG. VAL 5p5t:tCt +-------+ 1G I EI-OOR LEVEL I1NIT LOCATION ' No. of LEVELS ' TOTAL UNDS "'"OWNERSHIP +----------- ----+ ~' 17 ' ~I T T .. NAME AND ADDRESS ' OWNER NAME iARNES CUF:TIS L JF' & JOAN TF.•ST ~ CO-OWNER NAME HE BAF:NES NOMINEE TF;UST MAILING STREET ADDRESS ~Til~ SUNSET HILL LN ^ IINO CITY SIATE. ZIP NANTUCKET MA O<554 OWNER NAME a CO.OWNER NAME 1 MA LINO STREET ADDRESS - Mnlurve cNV, srnre. zIP N I W-+-E I S - -- Isr LAND Ton r In+o ~ NorES nND DTRFR nDJL T jTOrnL nD.JUSrF^ L ION NG 5 IlY -- - - FRONTAGE DEPTH IINII RI('C UJ I ANU ~nLUE CODE DESCRIPTION ~ I LAND UNIT. ACII i A,10 1 [ SPECIAL LAND CALC LUUSi UN T PRICE c t L SE I ~ . U ~9 : Ct t L.1 C ~ of i 5 r_t ~SZS~9 .. _ ~ AFNES CUhTIS L JR .. JOAN TF~T ' cDUwNFR NnME HE BARNES NOMINEE TRUST MAILING STREET ADDRESS 71?12 SUNSET HILL LN MAiI NG GITV, STATE, ZIP ANTUCKET MA u2554 1 OWNER NAME CO-OWNER NAME MnawG srRBEr nooness MAILING Cn V. STATE, ZIP nDD ..nLE _ 1 cgnrJCE ocLErE PROF ER fV FACTORS r(I o~.nnl } u L IFS ~ ,n noel L~enTION LC :EL ~l I'l1B F UFBAU nBplE STnFEr Pwnlc wnlm > s~- _ - suR:mann z BELOW S1f1EEi T ru911n sewF_R .~ L' RunnL a I:pt LING a ~ CnS PRL`I Ff ~ D BUS OIFI LEI M1EY f it H - 1 f ^ RL:f IIANTL nrnc nn:ogo onTE p v wDlcn rrn vnuo RECORD OF OWNERSHIP Rrn PnI:F M : vn is i sAI.FS 1`nir-E r,OOE on, AFiiVES-CCfFi'TIS L ~f. F: 7~JD _ n44'.1~2 4 ARNES CURTIS L JR $s JOAN S ?0192 10 6 0 2 O _ OUILUING PERMIT RCCORU I.D Un IE YP DESff11FTION AI'FIl n UNT ry FTFn +-pMMF.NiS P~SST-95 .SI~D~ ~ 57DENTTAL --ZOOOn~~sprs1~0 DDTTION-7-Tb~-S I I i I i I I I I I I I I I I - '. OTHER ASSESSMENTS_ - -CD -6escr umber Amours Comm Int. ~` ' I~ ~~r ~}~ T \1/_. I~~_~I COMPARABLE _ _ iarinl MAP Rl OCK LOT MO VR ADJUSTED _ VISIT HISTORY 1w55~NATURE ONLY ACKrxxNLEDGESAVIGIr DV ADn1A COLLECIpR VALUE DALE R 1 C I.D _(1(1 ZZi)96 TE 61694 JDii) 1 494 JDO1 _ _ LAND SECTION _i _ CODE ~ DESCRIPPTION ]ONING 5 FRONTAGE DEPTH I TOTAL j v~lFl UNIT PRICE `Af,I/.~I:f I fA,OND Nf' ADJ NOS [GI' LANG UNITS I I I TOTAL AREA I - - ~ -f CONSTRUCTION DETAIL NOTES/VALUATION AUTHORITY HEARING CHANGES SKETCH ELEMENT rroE HG DESCRIPTION STYLE MooEld J1 'ESIDENTIAL STORIES )i ~ OCCUPANCY JS _ EzT wqu I 14 OOD SHINGLE z _ _ ROOF STRUCTURE t UDGF CGVeR i~ SF'H/F GLASS/CO INi WALL 1 Z INT FLOOR 1 _ 2 HEATING FUEL I+ennNG rYPE J.. OT WATER' ~-~ nln COND. TYPE V 1 ONE COST MARKET APPROACH BEDROOMS FIIONT UNADJ. BASE HATE S . C)I ~ BATHROOMS i . ~.) SIZE ADJ. FAfiDR 1..1219 TOTAL ROOMS )I JU GRADE INDE% S . US onTH srvLE O ' ODERN EFE BnsE RnTe 1 00.1 KUCHEN Srn.e i, ODERN BLO. MKresT VnwE 126264 COMMERCIAL ONL Y YEAR BUILT 1940 HEAT A AIR GONG EFF VEAR BLT .1.968 FRAME TYPE NORM. DEF'R 29 . VCI BATH511'IUMBING FUNC. OAS. CEIInVAIL FIN ECON. DBS. ROOMSIPARTITIpNS SPEC. COND CODE ^o COMh10N WALL SPCC. COND WAIL IIGHi °~^ CONDITION 71 . ~ 11J CONUOMIN IUMS ICOO PS DEPR BLDG VAL 89600 FLOOR LEVEL UNIT LOCATION NO. OF LEVELS TOTAL UNITS "n OWNERSHIP onv cove nPPanlseo vnwE nssessen vnu!F n~~N RES LAND ii)90 247700 2477001 RESIDNTL 1090 '27400 '274i1i1 TornL 57511ii) 575100 enR RES LAND 109if 2477VU 2477i)il RESIDNTL 1~i9~) '27400 ?27400 roTAL 575101 I 57510iI I EX EMPTIONS -- -_ ____ _ YEAn iVFE CODE nMOUNT 'ES-EXEPf FTTON .. ~SHg~ ~ TOTA L 4~S_ + TOTAL APPRAISED BLDG VALUE • •• tOTAI. APPRAISED %F VALUE ~ (II I TOTAL nFPRA1SE0 OB VALUE TOTAL ASSESSEp VALUE NET TA%ABIE VALUE TOTAL GIASSIFIEO USE VALUE. CARD TOTAL CLASSIFIED USE VALUE PARCEL TOTAL VALUE-.CARD , ToTnL vawE=. PARCEL 575 , npJUSTED I LAND VALUE UNU PRICE rK:2L LAND VALUE 24 ISTF' I I I 9I 9I I I 29 ~9I 24 I .F ------- ---------+-----+- -- ---+ -- ---+ IBAS I I IEAF I I IUBM I I I I I I I lbI I I I 24I 24I I I I I F I I 10 I I I I BI I I I 29 I N I W-+-E I S SUB AREA SUMMARY OBIxF c.L. OUTBUILDINGS/E%TRA FEATURES nTE ANNUL PcT. OD:xF oem+. AREA GROSS EFFECTIVE uNIT ur+oegnecwTED , f,ODE DESCRIPTION CODE UNITS UNN PRICE pN UB ~^PR COND VALUE TYPE DESCRIPTION ggEA AREA T;OST COSVgLARXET FF •~- ~'L717:O- "' +AS FI~ROST FLOOR B56 856 i)0.1~ 85711 .AF ATTIC EXPANSION, 696 244 '5.10 ^44~2'r~-,';;' BM BASEMENT, UNFINI 696 1~9 Zi).00 1918 TOTAL OBIXF VALUE -15VT IDTnLS t,4 ~b-364 - ~ , -- ~BRS=to«s'4"I6AYe?9s>=rrTlvi~iuii$ ~ - ,, G9W17EAF=W"29S24E29N24$UBM=W29524E29N24SE17N92. ~.. Lili41- 45 V I gl i II 41 11 U I I I I I U I c it 41 51 I>i LJ ",~ ~ - UJ L~ U ~_„1 IL~J' !" I y! No. CARU NO. c 6 T NnME ANO ADOness r~` ~~""TF .12/11/97 Oi)12 SUNSET HILL LN OWNER NAME ' - x. ~~- - ~ 17 ' ARNES CURTIS L JF .. JOAN TRST ~ CO OWNER NAME HE BARNES NOMINEE TRUST ' MAILING STREET ADDRESS j012 SUNSET HILL LN ° lAAILING CITY BTgTE. ZIP ANTUCKET MA 02554 OWNER NAME GOOWNER NgME J MAILING STREET ADDRESS MAILING CITY, STATE, 21P ADD SALE GRANGE OF.LETE PROPERTY PACTORS_.-_ TOPOGRAPHY UTILITIES SIRE FT OH ROAD I OGATION LEVEL ALL PUPLIC I CAVFII URBAN ABOVE STREET J PLIBUC WATER Z nvED 2 SUBURBAN Z BELDW STREET 3 PUHLIC SEWER ~ IInIPn JEU 3 RURAL 3 ROLLING Gn5 d PR(;POSF.D BUS BIST STEEP \'/Ell ilnB `GUTTER C 5 INDUBIHIAL fi LOW 6 SFP11G SIDEWALK fi REGRFA 110NAL 6 SWAMPY nIIEV ) WATERFRONL ] LEDGE o N')nr e FLOOD PLnN n INDICATED SALES PRICE UUILDING PERMIT RECORD __ _ I.D. DATE VP DESCRIPTION APPR. AMOUIJT GATE COMMENTS COMPLETED _ _ ~ . <nnrrn _ Lrijnl?n - IIII"iTrOft- ~3~'~ S ~~ ~ I I I I I I ' ~ I I ~ ~ ~ ~ I I ~ C'I 'h 41 1 LJ I I I I I U I CII 41 51 CIS U ~~IIO,~YI..~'" Cn~ -)41 11451 CL! J L-~ L~ ~ _ - LARD NO NAME nND ADDRESS P 'I.IF 12 /11/9"1 0012 SUNSET HILL LN OWNER NAME RJ OTHER ASSESSMENTS t=scr lam er ~-Smoun~ Comm Inf~ _ VISIT HISTORY TH1551GNAruRE ONLY ACiwoW'LEDGESn vtliRVn Dain LxuLECTnR DATE R I C I.D. 22096 TE 61694 JD10 1 494 JDtji LAND SECTION ___ 1RLE _ nP ~ HLOCK LOT MD YR ADJUSTED vnwF HISTORY CODE APPRAISED VALUE ASSESSED VALUE RES LAND 1090 247700 2477UC1 RESIDNTL 1090 '274cjtj ~274tjtj TOTAL 575101) 57510C1 YEAR RE5 LAND 1C190 2477CIi) 247700 RESIDNTL 1490 '27400 X27400 TOTAL 57510C 1 575100 YEAR TYPE LODE AMOUIJT i \ -- TOTAL TOTAL APPRAISED LAN[) V TOTAL LANG VALUE AGRICULTURAL TOTAL APPRAISED VAt UE TOTAL ASSESSED VALUE NET TAxARLE VALUE TOTAL CLASSIFIED USE VALUE LARD TOTAL CLASSIFIED USE VALUE PARCEL TOTAL VALUE. LARD TOTAL VALUE'. PARCEL ITHEH ADJUST TOTAL ADJUSTED AND CALC. DJihi UNIT PRICE 5() 100(>00 ar :e LAND vnLUE i A _: . 575. 1011 LAND vALUE 480tiC1 24 USE LAND TOTAL. INIIU ~; CON LODE DESCRIPTION NI ). FRONTAGE DE!'iH IANU UNITS UNIT PRICE AfHnn I Afil L) f 7 ~-ROEJ]o • l)C)CI .t.)f 1 iY 111 ~I )I 109 ULTI HSES 'OHi O_48 C 40000.00 tjCl 0' r_Ig ~ g0 TOTAL AREA ' CONSTRUCTION DETAIL NOTESNALUATION AUTHORITY HEARING CHANGES SKETCH ELEMENT HG DESCRIPTION STYLE ) '=F~IIIIFW Mooel.° )1 'ESIDENTIAL GRADE' 1 STORIES 1 OCCUPANCY ) i ExT wqu I 14 OOD SHINGLE z ROOF STRUCTURE ) _~ { lu)or wvER j~ SF'H/F GLASS/CO INT. WALL I Y z INT. FLOOR t Z HEATING FVEL Ij S HEAnnIC TYPE l5 OT WATER _ nIR ('OND TYPE .11 ONE _ COST MARNET APPROACH ReDRDOI,+s PL~i OF;--P1 uNnDJ. ansE RnIE ~0 RA TIJRUOMS . t 7 L SIZE ADJ FACTOR l l .8527 TOTAL ROOMS It 1 11 I GRADE IfIDE% 1 i ~ 1 RniH srvLE ~t.: ODEFiN EFF. BnsE RATE 76.91 KRCHEN STYLE j2 ODERN BLD MKUCST VnLUE 1 9927 4 roMMERCInL ONI V vEnR BUILT 198£3 III.AI h AIR LAND FFF. VEJUP BLT 1988 FRAME TYPE NORM UL PR 9 . UU RATHSII'LUMBING FUND OHS. f FIIhNnIL TIN ECON UBS n~gMyPnn11TIONS SPEC COUD CODE ,r r~MMDD wnLL srec DOND wmLHGLrr ~.coNDnloN 91.CIt7 Cn NOOMIN IUM.S K.O OPR D~Pn RI nG VnL _--~- 181't.1 () -- FI OOH LEVEL uwr LocnTION NO. OF LEVELS TOTAL UNITS '"~ OWNERSHIP 9 +---+ + I I I 12I I I 20I + I +----++ I I I it I +--+ 1.T• I +----+ + 18 SISTF'-----+ ISTF' I i°' 6I +--------H---+ I +-------+ ISTF' IUBM I I I I 19I I 14I 14I I 18I 1 I "I I I 18 28I I •Q I +--------+ +---+ 18 I + I I +--------+ I I I ++ I I IBAS I 25 I ' 12I +-----------++ I I I 44 I +----------------+ 8 +-+ N +---+ I W-+-E ' I S _ __ SUB A REA SUMMARY oelxF G.L. OUTBUILDINGSIEXTRA FEATURES )nTE LIB AriAUnL DEPR Pcr ORlxf DEPR nREn DESCRIPTION GROSS EFFECnvE UNIT w+DEPRErIATED COSTIMARKET CODE FF'L OEBCRIPTION LODE UNI1R --~5?. UNIT PRICE <'LCTO;z?0 nN 8 . .~ CONU 1YY Vnl LIE 4.. TYPE - gREA c, nREA ><, COST ~L~~~~ FLUI FLUE-CONCRE i.VO 500,04 B .OCI lOt 500 TF' STOOP 980 98 7.69 757 ; ' BM BASEMENT, UNFINI 1,581 '16 15..T_•7 24 t14~:;;!.j TOTAL OBIMF VALUE 4gq TO TA lS L } ~ ' ~. Z Q111,~DINS'.JRgV~ij~S ~ . - ' - ° ~ R s ;... SHW rtS~5P~S7~ Fg1J - _ .~._, ..iSt .W1.~T'E 15~ ,2E1'NSWI~SSWSSS$STF'=W18S14E18N14~S14W18S3W1S5 .' 6 t ,W1512E.3253E8N3E4N6E1N3~Ei1S5E15STF'=W15NSW11S1 ' " ' , TR=W~6UBM=S16E2S8W1'S2W5 9EBS4E18N18$N6EiN20~F B BS28E25N~3E11SSE15N6E1N2tjW._b~E~6~STF'=108$. 17 _ _ 1 3[ ~ ~3UILDING AND CODE ENFORCEMENT DEPT. TOWN BUILDING ANNEX 37 WASHINGTON STREET NANTUCKET, MASSACHUSETTS 02554 John H. Dunn Telephone 508-228-7222 Building Commissioner Tele Fax 508-228-7249 November 19, 1997 Curtis and Joan Barnes P.O. Box 192 Nantucket MA 02554 Dear Mr. Barnes; Your application for a permit to build an addition to a dwelling located at 12 Sunset Hill Lane. (41-450) has been reviewed pursuant to §139 of the Code of Nantucket and for the following reasons denied. The lot is non-conforming as to the number of dwellings (three) on it and the structure as to side yard set back (less then five feet). Because of the non- conformities an expansion of ground cover or a vertical expansion within the setback is only permitted after action by the Zoning Board of Appeals. A building permit can not be issued with out a finding granted by the Zoning Board of Appeals, see §139-33A(4) of the Code of Nantucket below: Pre-existing, nonconforming structures or uses may be extended or altered, ... provided that: _ "No such extension or alteration shall be permitted unless there is a finding by the permit granting authority or uy the special permit granting authority designated by this zoning bylaw that such change, extension or alteration shall not be substantially more detrimental than the existing nonconforming use to the neighborhood." Pleased be advised that you may appeal this decision of the Building Commissioner to the Zoning Board of Appeals pursuant to §139-31 of the Code of Nantucket. If you require any additional information please contact my office. Sincerely, John H Dunn Building Commissioner Word\build--\41-450