Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout100-07 TOWN OF NANTUCKET BOARD OF APPEALS NANTUCKET, MASSACHUSETTSJ).2554@ O' ::n -'JI'. dIIl.". '-- =='" :z . , . , ..- '""- To: Parties in Interest the BOARD OF APPEALS in - Ul f"-- J~ftuary 14 ,2007 ~ o (.j .;::. and. Others concerned with the Decision of the Application of the following: Date: Application No.: 100-07 Owner/Applicant: H. Brooks Smith, Trustee of Cliff Cottage Nominee Trust Enclosed is the Decision of the BOARD OF APPEALS which has this day been filed with the office of the Nantucket Town Clerk. An Appeal from this Decision may be taken pursuant to Section 17 of Chapter 40A, Massachusetts General Laws. Any action appealing the Decision must be brought by filing a complaint in Land Court within TWENTY (20) days after this day's date. Notice of the action with a copy of the complaint and certified copy of the Decision must be given to the Town Clerk so as to be received within such TWENTY (20) days. '--L~p/ t1~~0~~N~) Michael J. O'Mara, Chairman - I cc: Town Clerk Planning Board Building Commissioner/Zoning Enforcement Officer PLEASE NOTE: MOST SPECIAL PERMITS AND VARIANCES HAVE A TIME LIMIT AND WILL EXPIRE IF NOT ACTED UPON ACCORDING TO NANTUCKET ZONING BY-LAW SECTION 139-30 (SPECIAL PERMITS); SECTION 139-32 (VARIANCES). ANY QUESTIONS, PLEASE CALL THE NANTUCKET ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS OFFICE AT 508-228-7215. NANTUCKET ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS 2 Fairgrounds Road Nantucket, Massachusetts 02554 47B Cliff Road Assessor's Map 29, Parcel 43.1 Residential-l Certificate of Title No. 20655 Lot 3 on Land Court Plan 13193-C DECISION: 1. At a public hearing of the Nantucket Zoning Board of Appeals, on Friday, November 16, 2007, at 1:00 P.M., at 2 Fairgrounds Road, Nantucket, Massachusetts, the Board made the following Decision on the Application (100- 07) H. BROOKS SMITH, TRUSTEE OF CLIFF COTTAGE NOMINEE TRUST under Declaration of Trust dated August 8,2002, registered as Document No. 101094 at the Nantucket Registry District for the Land Court, in connection with property known as 47B Cliff Road, Nantucket, Massachusetts: 2. Applicant is seeking relief to validate the location of the existing dwelling through the issuance of a special permit pursuant to Zoning Bylaw section 139-33 for the alteration and expansion of a preexisting, nonconforming structure within the side and rear yard setback areas, but at no point closer than the pre-existing structure's intrusion into the side and rear yard. The site is located at 47B Cliff Road, Nantucket Tax Assessor's Map 29, Parcel 43.1, and shown as Lot 3 on Land Court Plan No. 13193-C (see Certificate of Title No. 20655). The property is zoned Residential-l. 3. Our Decision is based upon the application and accompanying materials, and photographs, representations and testimony received at our public hearing on this case. The Planning Board made no recommendation as the matter did not present any issues of planning concern. There were no neighbors present at the hearing but several letters in support of the application were on file. 4. In 1988 the Zoning Board issued a special permit authorizing the alteration and expansion of the then existing structure (ZBA File No. 110-88), which decision is registered as Document No. 46167 at the Nantucket Registry District. The predecessor in title completed the work described in that special permit, but no record of a building permit for the project can be found. Accordingly, the Zoning Enforcement Officer considers the 1988 relief to have expired and has stated that the special permit must be re-issued before the building department issues can be addressed. In addition, the 1988 decision required the addition to be no closer than 5 feet from the rear property line, but the plan prepared by Emack Surveying dated October 10, 2002, a copy of which is attached as Exhibit A, shows the closest point of the addition to be 4.8 ~ feet from the rear property line. It is evident from the plans submitted with ZBA File No. 110-88 that the structure which existed prior to the adoption of zoning is situated at or over the rear property line and 0.4 + feet from the side property line. Relief by special permit pursuant to Zoning Bylaw Section 139-33A(5) is therefore appropriate to validate the work within both the side yard and the rear yard setbacks. 5. The information submitted shows that the improvements were constructed substantially in accordance with the plans approved by the Board in 1988 and the Board finds that the basis for the relief in ZBA File No. 110-88 is still valid. The design and siting of the addition have no significant effect on the neighborhood and are not substantially more detrimental to the neighborhood than the pre-existing nonconforming structure. Overall, the Board finds that the dwelling as currently constructed is in harmony with the general purpose and intent of the Bylaw. 6. Accordingly, by a UNANIMOUS vote (5-0), the Board decided to GRANT the requested SPECIAL PERMIT under Section 139-33A to validate the structure as currently constructed and shown on the plan attached as Exhibit A. Dated: ~ )4- ,2008 \NQW~ Nancy Sevrens ~"'tv-L '7 I J)~ Lisa Botticelli COMMONWEALTH OF MASSACHUSETTS Nantucket, ss. January J.f:::2008 On this /!!--day of Janu~008tJf~re me, the undersigned Notary Public, person~~~ared ./ ~At( , who is personally known to me, and who is the person whose name is signed on the preceding or attached document, and who acknowledged to me that he/ she signed it voluntarily for its stated purpose. ~~f/4@Zt' Notary Public: ~11t.7~ K. MtflJ7'-( My commission expires: MtU&h ;?-.;J./,;IrII3> Page2of2 !.inda. \\'I1<:ssa will be down in the 1110rrl1nv \'Jith some /JL\ files the October 1 ()th lllecting) t()r your rccords. I Included :1 COP"' of the agenda but l'rn llUt sure if VOl! IV:Ult Ih:H or !lOL I f !lot. just to~~ 11. ! halT assivlled file nurnbers to all of the ne\\' (for the ]\,,\'cmber ] 6 rh nle(' rin g;': ZB,\ (,:lSC~ :b wcJL.f7B ...> , ,-, (:lifF Road is 100-07 and (lId South \\I1:1rf is J 01-07, ,\ re there olher applications that were fikd th:ll \ou need number~ for? IT nor. I'll be sending down :lnorhe! batch because there :1.1(' mne new files Includll1g the [WO referenced above Jhanks! J,e~lw -- -.. ~- ~ ..__'U __ _._ ______ ,,____.._ _..__ 0"_ _..___...~,_ .,.'. __.. _____~ ...______._____ __..~. Leslie Woodson Snell, AICP Senior Planner N,UlWcket Planning Office 2 Fairgroullds Road Nantucket,MA 02554 508..325.5385 telephone 508.228.7298 facsimile !woodson@nantucl<et-llla.g()v 10/16/2007 Melissa D. Philbrick PHILBRICK AND AVERY LLP Post Office Box 148 Zero Main Street, Second Floor Nantucket, Massachusetts 02554 (C(Q)[p1f Tel: (508) 228-5151 Fax: (508) 228-5155 Emily Avery October 3, 2007 kevo J Ot..ovl ~~~'5 () PFI c..e. IO.la-Or f1'. 5~6 BY HAND DELIVERY Nantucket Zoning Board of Appeals 2 Fairgrounds Road Nantucket, MA 02554 Re: 47B Cliff Road, Nantucket Dear Zoning Board Members: Enclosed on behalf of H. Brooks Smith, Trustee are the original and four copies of the Application for a Special Permit to validate the existing dwelling which was renovated and expanded within the side and rear yard setback pursuant to a previously issued Special Permit for the above-referenced property. Also enclosed is the $300 filing fee check, the certified abutters list and two sets of mailing labels. Please notice this Application for the November 16, 2007 hearing, and if you have any questions, do not hesitate to give e a all. enc. cc: Mr. H. Brooks Smith (w / enc.) Mr. Jeremy David (w / enc.) G~A~DI~N; ~,S,AF~ ,eX!Jdrke I'/fflerfca.li PK r F. jSi !"'I I~! .-!~ ; ! - ~ ~~; i, ! 1=/ I~l j~ : f:j I;:>..; 1...1 'lEi C I '1= I ::1 .; >~J~) ~~~"'.fl:l ',,',g-,~r-..:.~>,- '\1 C;-S:_'"~', ....~ '8ll'f")'; ~1z,ri ~l~>I:i nl.._~,"c,~::;.r I ':)"Fi ;_['-.~_.4~( ~- ,I~.' 1iI ~ ~ 0 t 0 r r ):> \~ :0 ..j:::>. Ul '" 0 EP ':' ..j:::>. w ~;r 00 - I\) wo I ~l~ '" ~!i ~~ I ~- i ill NANTUCKET ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS 1 EAST CHESTNUT STREET NANTUCKET, MA 02554 FEE: $300.00 APPLICATION FOR RELIEF CASE NO. I<::c> - o-;:r - Owner's name(s): H. Brooks Smith, Trustee of Cliff Cottage Nominee Trust Mailing address: 147 Forest Avenue, Locust Valley, NY 11560 Applicant's name(s): same Mailing address: same Locus address: 47B Cliff Road Assessor's MaplParcel: 29/43.1 Land Court Plan No.: 13193-C Lot No.: 3 Date lot acquired: 3/6/2003 Deed Ref./Cert. of Title: 20655 Uses on Lot - Commercial: None~ Yes (describe) Residential: Number of dwellings-----1- Duplex_ Apartments_Rental Rooms Building Date(s): All pre-date 7/72? or C of O(s)? Zoning District: R-l Building Permit Nos: 399-98; 4944-87; 6767-90; 14126-97; 404-73 Previous Zoning Board Application Nos.: 110-88 State below or on a separate addendum specific relief sought (Special Permit, Variance, Appeal), Section of the Zoning By-law, and supporting details, grounds for grant of relief, listing any existing nonconformities: See attached addendum rmation contained herein is substantially complete and true to the best of my knowledge, e pains an / p n s-.of perjury. SIGNATUR Applicant AttorneY/Agent-4- (If not owner or owner's attorney, please enclose proof of agency to bring this matter before the Board) FOR ZBA OFFICE USE Application received on:_/_/_ By: Complete: Need copies?: Filed with Town Clerlc_/_/_ Planning Board:_/_/_ Building Dept.:_/_/_ By: Fee deposited with Town Treasurer:_/_/_ By: Waiver requested?:_Granted:_I_/_ Hearing notice posted with Town C1erk:_I_/_ Mailed:_I_/_ I&M:_I_I_ & _1_1_ Hearing(s) held on:_I_I_ Opened on:_/_I_ Continued to:_I_/_ Withdrawn?:_I_/_ DECISION DUE BY:_I_I_ Made:_/_I_ Filed w/Town Clerk:_ _ _ Mailed:__I_ DECISION APPEALED?: 1 SUPERIOR COURT: LAND COURT Form 4/03/03 ADDENDUM The Applicant is seeking a special permit pursuant to Section 139-33A to authorize the alteration and expansion of the pre-existing non-conforming dwelling within the side and rear yard setback; but at no point closer than the pre-existing structure's intrusion into the side and rear yard setback areas. No new work is proposed; but the relief is requested to validate the existing structure shown on the enclosed" As-built Plot Plan" prepared by Emack Surveying dated October 10, 2002. In 1988 the Zoning Board issued a special permit authorizing the alteration and expansion of the then existing structure, a copy which decision (ZBA Pile No. 110-88) is attached. The predecessor in title completed the work described in that special permit, but no record of a building permit for the project can be found. Accordingly, the Zoning Enforcement Officer considers the 1988 relief to have expired and has stated that the special permit must be re-issued before the building department issues can be addressed. In addition, the 1988 decision required the addition to be no closer than 5 feet from the rear property line, and the Emack Surveying plan shows the closest point of the addition to be 4.8 .:!=. feet from the rear property line. The pre-existing structure is situated at or over the rear property line and 0.4 + feet from the side property line, so relief by special permit pursuant to Section 139-33A(5) is appropriate to validate the work within both the side and the rear yard setback. ~.-,';.,'!!l'~_" . \ q6z~r SO/BO 'S'N 0-v60-C;;l~ (80C;;) -vC;;C;;lO ''iVi '13>4~ru.N'iN 3nN~'i N'iVi'iHS'iM l ~N1A3MmS >I~'tri3 7 'A3Mlns 318'fa~03ij v ijQ NOll VNIY'MG 31J.1J. V 38 01 031N3S3ijd3ij 10N SI NY1d SIHl '!IK?3ij3H t-W.OHS SV SlN31'13l:1nSV31'1 0131.:1 A8 031.:11H31\ O~03~ ~ SNYld aNY S0330 .1.N3~ro NO S3fl3~ NV1d 101d SIHl NOll. VNI"~ 3Nn Al.~ ijO,:! DUlll9MP puZ; JOJ JS :+: OL9 :'~'~ ~NIlSIX3 DUIII9MO .(JOWJJd JOJ :+: JS O~S~ :"~'~ ~NIlSIX3 :+: "L'S~ :'e1"~'~ DNIlSIX3 " O~ :'e1':>'D 318'tMOll't 'U C;; :>4:>'t813S e1't3e1 ONV 30lS 'U 0 ~ :>4~V813S OelV,UNOel.:l 'U OS :3DV1NOel.:l rmrilNlri 'U 'bs OOO'S :3ZIS 101 rmrilNlri ~-e1 :DNINOZ 1N3e1e1n~ HllriS S>400el8 'H :e10.:l 03e1V d3e1d l T-v :13~e1Vd 6l :dVri :3:>N3e13.:l3e1 S,e10SS3SSV :)-~6 ~~ l 1d ~1 :3~N3e13.:l3e1 NVld gOO'l L #'lel3:) :)1 :3~N3e13.:l3e1 0330 lOOl 'Ol '1:)0 :31'i0 ,O~"'..l :31V~S Sli3SnH:>'tSS'tri '13>1~ru.N'tN Nl NV1d 101d 11InS-SV f r( lB6l '~l '<Inr palOP (;OUI 'anJfm4S T'r ..<q UOld ( UOIG!^!pqns ":)'1 a9&) . 'STN 11V130 "'..". I \ '--." (onqnd) aVO~ dd17 ::J UOWdI4:) aUIOl3 '0 '" '0 &alJo4:) J\ U 19-0~ / / I Uowdl4:) aUlOl3 'a '" 'a salJo4:) J\ u 6lZ-0r "9, ~. 0.9 'It V. ~ ~/v. 70..y Vv 'Jl '4.ILUS s>joOJ8 'H .:l/N rt -6l J95UlS '8 PJOMp3 .:l/N tt-6Z '~NI1l3YIO ..UIVt1I~d 01 SNOlllOOV ~O.:J L9~9t :)00 :)1 SV 030~03e1 11t1~3d 1VI:)3dS .:JO 11.:l3N38 SVH Al~3dO~d (,Z 'S>I:)V813S O~VA ~V3~ ON'l 30lS 01 103dS3~ HlIM ~NINOZ 1N3~~no 01 t1~O.:lNOO 10N S300 ~NI1l3MO ^~t1I~d (' l S310N / ON.:! 8:)HO ':"f'iF0"""- __ -"~_'-:'-_.-" _~__,':.~_= ~-_--,--,~ '__m_ _ ,,,,. 4GIG7 TOWN OF NANTUCKET BOARD OF APPEALS NANTUCKET, MASSACHUSETTS 02SSLl Date: December 16 . 1988 CERTIFICATE OF GRANTING OF ~~~1~~~~ SPECIAL PERKIT (Massachusetts General Lo~s. Chapter 40A. Section 11) The BOARD OF APPEALS of the Town of Nantucket h~reby certifies that a ~~~};OJ( Special Permit has been granted: To: Horace Hanford Smith, Jr, (110-88l (Owner/Applicant) Address:c/o Reade and Alger, Box 2669, Nantucket. MA 02584 affecting the rights of the O~ner/Applicant with respect to lond or b 'ld' 47B Cliff Road, Assessor's Parcel 29-43.1. Land Court U:I. :l.nSls at Plan l3l93-C, Lot 3 Deed Refercnce___ And the BOARD OF APPEALS further certifies that the Dttached Decisio is a true and correct copy of its Decision granting the ~I{X::tJU"::J{X)l)lJllx':lQX Special Permit and that copies of the Decision And of all plans referred in the Decision have been filed with the Plonning Board and the Town Clcr The BOARD OF APPEALS calls to the attention of the Owner/Applicant that General Laws, Chapter 40A, Section 11 (lest paragraph) provides that no ~K~KXHKHX~~ Special Permit, or any extension, modification or rene~ol thereof, shall take erf~ct until (a) a copy of the Decision is certified by the To~n Clerk that twenty days hove elapsed after the Decision has been filed in the office of the Town Clerk and no appeal ha5 been filed (or, if such appeal has been filed. that it has been dismissed or denied) and (b) the certified copy is recorded in the Registry of Deed for the County of Nnntucket nnd indexe~ in the grontor index under the nome of the Owner of Recor~ or is recorded ond noted on the O~ner'S Certificate of Title, The fee for such recording or rcgistcrTog shall be peid by ,be OV"H//,pli""'- \-.~ J! )\ ,( //~..,' ~/y, "'~ c 0 (0::5 C h [) i r man --' - - C 1 e r k -. ./ I BOARD OF APPEALS TOWN OF NANTUCKET NANTUCKET, MASSACHUSETTS 02554 ;. . DECISION: , The BOARD; OF APPEALS, at a public hearing held on FRIDAY, DECEMBER 9, 19BB, at 1:00 P.M., in the Town and County Building, Federal and Broad Streets, Nantucket, made the following Decision upon the Application of HORACE HANFORD SMITH, JR. (110-BB). 1. Applicant requests a SPECIAL PERMIT under the provisions of Nantucket Zoning By-law Section 139-33.A (Alteration of Pre-existing Nonconforming Structure), to enable the alteration and extension of an existing two-story dwelling partly within the required side yard setback area from the westerly sideline of the property. The Premises are located at 47B CLIFF ROAD (Assessor's parcel 29-43.1), Land Court plan 13l93-C, Lot 3, and are zoned RESIDENTIAL-I. 2. . We find that the Premises contain a single-family " .~ . , ,dwelling, which intrudes upon the required side yard setback of 5 feet at the northwesterly line of the property, and the rear yard setback of 5 feet at the northeasterly property line. The Applicant :.' proposes to construct an addition, continuing in the northwesterly line of the existing bui lding. As shown upon the si te plan attached hereto, this addition will include a small area within '1 i; the required side yard, but in the continuation of an existing building line. In addition, the Applicant intends to enclose an . area of the first story of, the dwelling which is now open but q61G7 which is located directly beneath an existing portion of the building, partly within the required setback, 3. We find that the existing nonconforming dwelling pre-exists the 1972 adoption of the Nantucket, zoning by-law. The Applicant' s r~presentatives presented material to show that the proposed addition is to be located in such manner as to enable expansion of an existing kitchen; expansion to the east of the existing structure would obstruct a driveway. An existing fence at the location of the proposed addition relieves any effect upon abutters, and the Applicant offers to relocate this fence at the westerly property line. 4. We find that the design and siting of the proposed addition are consistent with the existing structure and will have no significant effect upon the neighborhood. No opposition was presented at the public hearing. Accordingly I we find that the proposed addition will not be substantially more detrimental to the neighborhood than the existing nonconforming structure, and that it will be in harmony with the general purpose and intent of the By-law. S.' The relief granted is upon the conditions that the addi tion sha 11 be constructed subs tanti a lly in accordance wi th the site plan and elevations attached hereto as Exhibit A, and that a fence shall be erected by the Applicant at the northwesterly property line between the addition and the abutting parcel, ) ii -2- I ,;~ ~":... :. ~"'''~~I 4 : :;~;-, ~~ ).,.;.~: ... ; ,;Jf:/I.: ; H~)!I' ; ;,':,W,,~ i'.. :X\ 401G7 Acco~dingly, this Board by UNANIMOUS vote, hereby grants the requested relief by SPECIAL PERMIT, upon the conditions set forth herein. \i Dated: h O~~tJp 1988 L-:;l'~.:... K~/f'~'__ William R. Sherman .-- (b, .J/"~__d~ .{;/P/,? ~HAVE ELAPSED AFrnliliE DECISION W/>S FILED IN 1HE OFFICE OF nie 10WN CLERK. AND 1HA T NOAPPEALtlAS FILED,PERSUANTTOGEN S <40 A. SECTION 1 -3- "'\l). fI. l' \ - .:;, -~ ~: ~\ ~ )J I' \) \'l..l-:~ ~\ .\ ~ ~ C ~\ \\ - \ 11 I" I\.\ -,t-.'\" ~ -=:d~l~ '" \~ I ~ ~' i- _",.:" ~\.)J \ ,\ Wl . . [') ~ "" f'..... ' ' I -................,. " 1 "- I , I I I I 1/ ", /:". o ..../.. --'. . r) 1- II ", \1 J. I J e j. ;I / 13 /7 !l- \\ '.'1" '" ., 'l> L . I,~'ll:, ./.,' / '" .1,1 '1~ ,'-., '""- ,/ \" . . ' .....~..... . ". ',,/ ..............:~. .": ~~'''-''''':'''':,,- . . ....,.... . ',. . ........ . 7. -< k ~. ... -.\ ;,-1 " (\i:- }} 1'\ .J '/ i: -7 ,- -.17 ): L. \. "" 1/' j.~ , , ~\ - rl'\' \:\ N ~l''-' , , , \' ,.) ','- \:I I ~-. 4' ' -\" i -I, ,.~~\ . U - -\ ~~ \1 I . =1 , , '," '"', , , , ~I ',.,",,- v!> ,~ " I;, - IT' 'p ,'\" f."l" " (,;'. _I \"'\1 '~'" VI .1 ~ '{ ~I -~ ........ f,\.. [', ~ ",- f' ~,J \' .' II hIt" ' ,- \~ -"\ . -" III , 'J\ 't) -1\ \'j ~ ,I. II' ". Y ,-\ IJ c; :~: ',\\ I.. " " "" ", -:/.: -~\ Y '-\ -\ \~ l" ~.L , f. \\' 1\\ -,\ ! -'''J''-'-''''-- - L. , I :'( I' ~ \,. )- t"-; ,t;. .' ) \. I', '" \. IllJi \'. Y. " )h~;:} -::-:{S t _~; '. I. \\1 , .:.1.. \)t !::.-~. "J I" , '. ,<,~ .. " '"'" . .' ,'" ..... : ",.""'-. '.. . . , '-.. , 4GIG7 t ;'~ j, ,,\ .' \,1\ L L, ,II 'I' '. , '. '~ '. '" .........,. " " -. ./ ............ ''"'''" / 'or'>....... /" . " I" '.~ ~\ J~ .1: .' '\'-~ \i " I \ q G 1(; 7 i~ 1: ~ \\-t :r. .- ). t.. \\ \\l ). VI :r; ~----~~.-~. I' I f ' c~L Ii . _'I=-~I\ ! ~ ~ -LJ i-2 1,: \\' ~ ! I ! ~, IL ..,.- I " I 1\" I \ '1 ! ! .... 1'1 .. .~.' .... .~, - I .', f ,I ~. .' I . ,,;':, I II I ~~' I I I I I I L I I I I : --- ,. J ...-- - ,- -:-.J.t - ';: - / !.' ~' -,f -=.' ,: J, ~, =:4: ...:..k (;>, ti-,": \;)' p ~4 s; " ' I '~~t f \ I." T- -r \.\ .-\ :.1:.., fIT ~ / ,.. \j\ :XI N ={. '" -\,>:,\\ \"- \'l -..; \ .-:J V \ ~o~..\ s;:.' ~ :t r Y" I "'. .:;:::. ~', v' , \.( L.: r \l' ::L '~ -=J \~ (\ ): , I;:) \.' ,- 1 !.i. ~)- ~ i '--~ s:: ~ T-' -- ,~ - ,', ~ ,.I " ''0 ;:',' 1.\' L_ \ ,,' -j F f\-"'" 4'- \'~' -r.. ,...\ = '- ~ '~\~! ~J ,/\ -.1 \\ ,V) 'I t-: I ~\ I,~U \ \\ ' i' i-\ l- i . \'1:- \ ':' I'f; \>t> r;J 'U' ' ('\ I" ~ I i I I 1 qGIG7 ~r ~ -3 7_ \,'\ '''' ____ ,_ ,..~A--~ =:::=-~:___,__--;!\, _ _______, . Ii: , \\ '\\ i \'\ .. \ " '\ \ \ ' -..,', :--"--,--::' - ..----..- -_'::~~~- .( \ \ \. , _-..------..'..\ \ \ t ; \ ~,' '\\ ! \\ ~ , " ,. '\ "\' '. '\ \<~::'" \~\. ~J .:, /1 >> : Ii / 1 /) : l ~t -,; -"=-=;---/ ;j'l I II', \: /t,.' I ,,//' I i / /1 I ,: ;' Jl , I \ .' I.,:' I ,/ /,' 'I '; ,... /,..", ; \'_ _ _ _ _ ,,_.,,1.1 \ \ i ~ ,. '. \ ~ : ' Iii ; \ __ i l;' \ i i ] ~ , I;' . _t==,~~, ,.: -.:::.~-j :'-___-'->---.-J --.- ..---- ..., ".. \ . \ ~ l \ ! -I ! -----;----- .". ~ ~ ~l \ \" I (;\ L -- .~. .-J ': -\1 -~J ~l \~ ~ 1 ,I I f _ ,. I _u ._.... -.-. -- .. ....~. \ \ \ \ \ " \ \, " \ \ \ \ \ \ I ;1 /, I' Ii I ! / , / I .__ I ,_" _ - L==t:_~---- I 1 \T' ~ <.1' ~r "';1 .," I' t' j ~ I r .,t' , J; , , '''' 'lulu7 . , , - ',. , "... .,.'.j (I' , .. "~~:l " f >':; ~, . " / t z ~ ~" .' ~41 V>' i %~!n,8w ' ! g] f3 E; ('\ ~, a . ~ IX: 011 - ~.~ a: I . 2:0" 0 "':! \c:r{l;.g % J 0 ~ ~ ~ w 0 (.l 0 > I v:: li'l .... j;] _: ;: 2 'P U -j CL" Q ..:-/ w. UJ.... (..-v,..,. u <( 10'" Z o o uJ .... C r- c..o ~ W "::If o z r- z I,a,i ~ ;:J ~ ~ r- ,.., z ~ if 0 I ~~",ri . ,/;" ~ _ E, 0] ..--Cl I Z . ~ ~ ~;ii r-~, C IX: i z.~ 0'" ~ ~ ~ II.. g == ~ J 0 ~ ::J ~ ~c, '::: ~ j;j- ....' ~ u- c 1'-' ~ -~ '--' \- r .-:. ('.1. ,u (L .-J d: ~ 1.1) ~ r: 'J " , WO-V/ 1/0,00 / It ~ Town of Nantucket ZONING BOARD OFAPPEALS LIST OF PARTIES fN fNTEREST IN THE MAITER OF THE PETITION OF PROPERTY OWNER.!l..~...~.,..~ ?~ k---. MAILrNGA DDRESS.... .00...;;;X............... Y:.<. ';.;""'.'.)"............... PROPER TY LOCATION..... .Y.......... ..~. ..~............ ASSES SORS MAP;P ARCEL("i .P.:.1!1:~........................................ APPLICANT,~" ,~..".. _..,....,..., ......,..."...., ,.......".. SEE AITACHED PAGES [cenify that the foregoing is a list of persons who are owners of abutting property. owners of land directly opposite on any public or private street or way; and abutters of the abutters and all other land owners within 300 feet of the property line of owner's property. all as they appear on (he most recent applicable tax list (M,G,L. c, 40A, Section 11 Zoning Code Chapter 139, Section I 39-29D (2) ~ ,~ y.!/'l7.!. . . <<~L? i; (! () / /; , //0,,\ TE /", . I ! I 1 U' j I ~ / " ' ' / It. 7 '" / j /f f'dA-"I),e.) I ",'j'j/' /"'1 ). ' fJ (, -/ A_ < /' I .,~.,Il. "',.,;".",.".",,,., .., 1/ - ASSESSOR'S OFFICE Town of Nantucket " " .... +' A A III Il: P P Il: g 1:1.. ~ ~ lZ.o 3 H tr., t%o ro.. ro.. H ro.. Ii< H f-l ...... ...:! H H ..:i 0 III () ~ H t.l ':9 U t) t) U ~ ~ M Lfl ~ p., 'It' '<tI .qt o:f4 .. '" N 0 .e ~ g '" 0 N '" '" U tIl U A ~ ~ :J; II; U 0 r:J gJ III ., .. Z .. ., e; " '" .. ~ II; o It: tIl () '" .. ., ., .. III .. ., Z " ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ III 553 ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ : ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ z z ~ ~ ~ 00 00 00 00 00 ~ 00 00 00 ~ 00 00 H 0( ~ U Q ~ '<tI N 0 ~ 0( u ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ M M ~ ~ 8 8 f-l 8 8 tIl 00 tI) en 00 o tQ '-0 N N \0 Lll U1 \.0 \0 It: It: ~ ~ III III Z Z '<tI 0 0 N N 0 tQ tQ 00 '<tI '<tI ~ ~ M \0 ~ ~ '<tI tQ 00 Lll M 0 ~ ~ M ~ \0 ~ N ~ ~ 0 0 0 Lll U1 rl 0 U1 00 00 00 U1 ~ 0 '<tI ~ 00 00 \0 rl ~ U1 00 0 N 00 0 0 0 U1 U1 rl M U1 rl rl 0 U1 ~ N '<tI 0 M U1 0 rl N rl \.0 0 0 \0 0 0 0 N N rl 0 0 N N ~ N M U1 N N m N \.0 N o rl 0 ~ maN N N 0 0 N M rl 0 0 rl 0 0 rl 0 0 rl 0 0 0 ~ ~ t; ~ .( E-t tJ U U U U Q Q Q tIl ., ~ >< tIl ., .. H H ~ ~ E ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ tr., H ~ 00 j;lJ.o ~ ro.. U H H H >-~=~p H :J;:::QlI: .&J H tIl ::a U ~ U ;J: CfJ Cf.I tI) -C ~~z3g~,Hi!~~~ III III ~ k 'tl 'tl .. '" " .... .-< '... " :0: t!J Z ~~ Ul H ...:IE-< li1 Ul:><: Il::tJ rilt:J ~~ ll:l < tIl '" '" A ., : ~ o U tIl .. Z tIl ~ ~ ~ ~ k .. '" 'tl '" '" 'tl '" '" .. N N ~ ~ Z III , j o U ~ ~ ~ 0 Z It: >< III '" ~ ~ ~ ~ '" '" ~ ~ ~ " '... " ::> ~ ~ ., ~ '" ~ ~ '" ~ tIl Z a> ~ 0 ~ I ~ ~ ~ III .-< o Z ~ ~ ~ p.. U l"1 Ll'l .--l '" tIl 0. ::> H '" H '" >< ., '" ~ ~ ~ .. )l '" o .. Z ., '" ., rg ~ ~ ;: '" '" 0 III '" Z ~ 8 s2 0. .. .. o ~ ~ ..... H :<! U U U :0: .... U '" H ., H III o 0. '" ., "' .. " ~ ~ '" tIl "' '" o .. ... '" .-< .. "' "' "' '" ., tIl '" b tIl '" b '" '" U '" tIl '" H o o '" '" '" 0"''' III ::> 0: '" ., tIl H 0: '" '" H '" H H H :0: ., H tIl III "' ; I ~ .-< .. ... A H "' H .. '" ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ Z o }i ~ }i H ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ tIl Z o U .-< N ~ ~ ~ '" '" "' ., '" '" ~ ~ tIl H H H ., :0: ~ ~ i ~ ~ < CI) ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ z Z o 0 '" '" H H H H :0: )l tIl '" " ., ~ g ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ t; ~ ~ ~ A " ~ '" "' '" .-< '" ~ ~ ~ ~ '" A '" '" ~ ~ :< ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ t; ~ ~ U 8 ~ E-l Q U Q CJ ., ~ 0 ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ CIl U ~ 04 U t!l 0 Cl 0( 00 H 0 Z ll< Z ~ H Ii< >t >t H ::.= H g ~ e; ~ ~ ffi ~ ~ 8 ~ ~ rg 0 ~ g ~ '" tIl W tJ1 '" '" tIl tIl tIl '" '" '" '" '" '" ., ., ., tIl tIl tIl ~ ~ ~ U U U .. .. .. tIl tIl tIl ~ ~ ~ ., '" " H "' >< .. ~ A o o ;J: \0 \D \D '" '" '" N M M M co N N N '" tIl b '" '" )l o z '" tIl 0: U .. ., '" 0: '" '" o Z .. ... )l ~ H "' ~ U '" '" ~ ~ ~ '" "' tIl H ::> > ., '" H '" '" 0: ~ '" j ~ H :< A H ~ ~ "' '" H 0 )l '" ~ o )l )l :0: '" J:il E-f E-f E-f J;:I P:; P:; P:; ., ., ., ril III p:j In ~ 000 ~ ~ p:: p:: A '" '" '" ~ ~ ~ ~ '" '" .-< .-< >< >< o 0 III III o 0 0. 0. " " >< ., H ~ ~ ~ H " 0. tIl Z ., ., '" '" ~ ~ ~ ., ., '" " .., '" '" H tIl tIl H 0: s ~ ~ '" '" H H H H 0 )l :0: " ~ ~ a> l"'1 M 0 r-- .-I .-I 'l:fl N '" .. '" U '" ~ ~ o H '" H H ~ : .., ., ., H ~ ~ tIl .. '" 0: '" rg ~ H III H tIl '" '" 0 '" 0 H '" 0. III '" ., H '" '" H tIl ., H ~ M ~ ::x: ~ 0 g >< ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 2 .. .. ~ ~ '" .. .. o H H ., ~ tJ tJ U"l (!) t!) U .-< A Z Z '" .., .., .. '" '" .. o 0 H ~ ~ tJ U U >< '" " A '" '" " ., '" H H Z ~ ~ A '" '" H .. '" 8 !i; ~ '" .-< '" ~ l"'1 5 ~ o ~ ~ ~ &; ~ P::: P:: 0 ~ ~ ; ~ i ! ~ .. 0 0 :E rg ... r-- N U1 0 .-I LI'l r-- .-lor-- N .-I .-I ll) r-I 'l:fl .... tIl ::> '" '" >< '" .., .. ., '" " U .. " o ~ tIl ~ H ., U o " '" '" tIl P '" '" :>: o Z ~ ., > .. '" ., '" U ::> ~ :0: rg H " ~ '" '" ~ ~ '" )l > H Z U ., H U ., H H "~ ~ E ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ : ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 0 ~ p:; Ul Z ~ ~ ~ ~ i ~ .. .. .. .. .. H H H H U U M O"l eo 1.0 If'l to U"l ll) '" o ~ N N ~ 0 0 O"l M O"l ~ N U1 1.0 0 O"l 0 MOO N r-I ~ ~ M ~ ~ N N r-I ~ O"l O"l ~ O"l 1.0 ~ o 0 to 00 0 M ll) to 0 m 0 ~ 00 00 ~ 0 00 o 0 1.0 1.0 1.0 .-I 0 ~ 0 0 0 1.0 O"l 1.0 N ~ 1.0 .-I N 0 0 0 .-I .-I 0 .-I N N 0 .-I 0 0 00 0 .. .. H ., H '" ~ " '" " III tf) ~ H H c:l ~ P:: Ul P:J P:: H Pi! H ~ !;; ~ is u 0.. P. H H p:; ~ H H ~ ~ ~ ~ III ~ ~ " ~ g ~ tJ ~ !; t; ~ Z U 0 '" ~ tIl rg ~ 5 ~ '" '" ~ ~ rg ~ ~ o ~ ~ ~ !; '" '" ... 0 N .-< ~ N '" .-< H H '" '" ~ ~ ~ 0. ~ ~ g j I( < ~ @ ,., H .. .. U Z o H '" ~ ., tIl Z o U '" '" ., ., '" '" I I Z Z .. .. '" ,., '" ;;; ~ !;j o H 0. '" H 0 '" ~ ~ ~ ::; !i; !3 0 0 '" :< H ~ " "H gj ~ ~ ~ s ~ U Pl (!) C) 0 0 ~ 3gg~6~ ~ Q CI f-l: Q P:; ~ " ., ., .-< N : ~ ~ " '" ., tIl ., '" ~ '" '" ., ., U III P H " H 0. tIl ., > H '" " '" 0: ~ tIl .-<!;:;; ~B ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 6 ~ III III '" 0'-<0 0. ... 0. ~ g t; t; t; ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ><!iJ U f;; ~ ~ ~ ~ j '" o N .-< '" H .. A '" ., '" " H '" ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ; ~ .-I N ...:I 0 ...:I :x: >< p.. ~ ~ X ~ ~ III III ~ r-- 0 0 rl OOO.-l 0 p.. p.. N ~ p.. N tIl ., .... ::: U o tIl tIl .. :0: H ., .. '" " '" tIl P " '" >< " H .. ., " .. ~ H U ., Z o '" Ul ~ ~ H 0 o " ~ 0. ., 0 " .., ... ~ N '" ... '" '" H ~ U H )l '" tIl '" ~ ~ '" '" tIl .. Z H H U III H III " H '" III .. 0. Z o '" tIl ., H III H H .. ., gj ~ ~ ~ ~~ U U !i; ~ .-< '" ~ ~ H >< 6 ~ ~ ~ ... ~ 0 .-< ... ~ '" ~ ~ ~ A H H H " H 0: !;; ~ ., tIl ... ~ ~ ~ U III N ~ ... 0 N '" 0. '" '" ., ., U ~ ~ H tIl " H b '" '" '" '" ~ ., '" H ., '" !2. U ., tIl H ::> o H >< ~ '" '" ~ " o ~ '" '" N .-< :0: H rg H '" ~ '" ~ >< H ., U ~ ~ ~ '" .: 0: o tIl '" " ::> Ul .. ~ ~ ~ " .. .. .. III U ~ "' o o M oW MCDrl.-lr-lrl.-lI.OIX)O"lO..-lNN.-I M'<:t'Lf'lNf'1'<:t'U1 o O.-iNf'1U1r--Q)O"l\O\.OI.DOOO'\O~LOOOOOOOOOri..-lr-l.-lOI'O\OrlNl"1'<t'<1'q<~U1U1lf'lU1'<:t''<:t'LO 0 ...:I ~'<t'q<'<t''<t''<t''<t''<t'OOOOCOCDOOO'\.-I.-IO'\O'\O'\O'\O''lO'\O'\O'\O'\O'\O'lO'\O'\Lf'lLOI.O\Dl.Dl.Ol.Orlr-l.-lNNNNNNN C 0J ...... o 0J '" ., ~ '" H .., ., U >< >< ~ ~ '" o '" '" ., : i ., :< " U .. .. '" H H H Z H 0" >< ~ ~ g: g: P:; H U Pi! -< Ul r.:I ~ -< f-t I-l u} ~ ~ ~ : ~ 8 g ~ g; ~ ~ to) M ~ ~ H H M tx.. tIl ~ ~ ~ g 5 ~ ~ '" >< ~ '" ~ H o ~ U .. Z ., ., '" H '" 0: '" ~ ;:! Z ~ U ~ .. H H H H ,., 0: H '" U ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ '" ~ ~ ::; ~ 8 ~ )l 0 '" '" '" > H U .-< N " ... ... QJ ,8 '" '" tJ1 '" " >< >< ~ 0. ~ Q Q 12 Q ... ... Q Q " " " " " " " " 0 ., ., .. .., .. .. .. .. '" '" .. .. .. .. .. .. .. H H .. H .. M H H H H H H H .., H QJ H H H H H U H " U U U U Z Z u u >< -: .. ... N 0 co "' '" '" M .... 0. "' "' "' ... co co ... ... '" 0 '" ::; ... M N 0 "' "' co '" "' 0 0 ... 0 '" ,~ "' co "' "' 0 N '" '" 0 0 M N N 0 N .... 0 0 " .... 0 0 0 .... 0 0 '" '" ... ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ .., tIl H '" ~ ~ ... 0. ... Q 0 ., ., '" H ~ ... '" '" " ., ~ ., u u 0 ~ H Cl ~ ~ >< .. ), 0: ... ~ " ., 0 ~ '" Cl ," >< ., f;] 0 ~ H U 0: Cl '" H :< 00 00 QJ >< '" '" -: '" " ," M ," .. :<: -: (!) "' Z ... H ~ 0. ~ -: E-t ~ ~ Q ., tIJ H " > H 0: ... ... H Q ...:I E-< ., Q :< tIl tIl " 0: > U Q IXl '" >< -: :< ., ., tIJ :-:: g; Q ., ... " ... tIl H ... " '" 0 '" tIl ~ -: P: U '" '" M H " ~ 111 P ., 0: .. ~ " ... 0: ., .. ... ~ ., ~ 2 E-t ~ 00 " ~ H H '" :< E-t 00 0 H :< ., 0. QJ .. U ~ ~ 0 p >< u 0 ... '" M III '" 0 '" N 0 N '" co '" 0 "' 0 ... ,.; ... III -: N M "' N .... N M N ~ ., Cl ~ .., -: ... ~ '" to ~ '" Cl ... QJ so 0 :<: ~ ., u " 0 :< ., H Z Z ... '" ~ ... Ii! 00 ~ .. ., , .. >< " ... QJ ., ~ 0. .. ~ ., ., H .. 0. '" .., 0 u 0 .2. 0 "- "- .... u u u U M so ., '" ~ '" ... ... ~ .., :< ., 0. -: ... '" -< j >< ~ Q '" ~ ~ H '" u :i! 0 -: H .. '" U 0. '" .. " ~ .. .. .. " ... ., 0 :<: u '" -: .. ., '" Q U ~ >< 0 ... ~ ... ~ '" H ... QJ '" ::i z 0 H :x: ., Cl ~ H ... ., ... !3 H Cl ~ ~ " .., .., ., z " ... -: -: ~ '" ~ ., '" ., 0. Cl . '" ~ ~ , '" " :< u Cl " " >< " ., ... to H 0 Z ., ., QJ 0 " fi] ~ j ~ H .., Cl ~ 0 0 .., :< ., '" ... 0 H 0 0 0 -: '" '" tIl :< u '" .. >< " ~ ," " '" to 0 0 M '" " co '" .... 0 '" .... ~ M '" N 0 H N N N N .... .... ... 0 N ...... ... ... ... 0 " ... ... ... '" Easy Peel Labels Use Avery@ TEMPLATE 5160@ ~ Thomas Keegan 2644 Bronson Rd Fairfield, Ct 06824 Brooks H. Smith Trustee Cfiff Cottage Nominee Trust C/O Humes & Wagner 14 7 Forest Avenue Locust Valley, NY 11560 Eleanor C & Mark H Gottwald 14915 Whitfield Avenue Pacific Palasades,Ca 90272 Melanie R & Robert G Sabelhaus 227 Greenspring Valley Rd Owings Mills, MD 21117 John E Duggan 135 Milton Street Milton, MA 02189 Rich Christopher 3 Spruce Tree Lane Wayland, MA 01778 Carol A W & Hugo Pagliccia c/o Mary Louise P.O,Box 471 Hingham, MA 02043 Doris Yaffe c/o Alison Bibbins Ward Trust 280 Catherine Dr Rockey Hill, CT 06067 Kathleen W Toombs Tr ACJ Realty Trust 25 Canoe Hill Rd New Canaan, CT 06840 Phyllis Hoadley 217 Forest Rd Douglaston, NY 11363 Etiquettes fadles a peler I . II l/eed Paper _ See Instruction Sheet: - for Easy Peel Feature 1 Mary & Robert M Haft 2346 Massachusetts Avenue NW Wasahington, DC 20008 Stuart L Bell Trustee Campana Nominee Trust 350 Willow ST Southport, CT 06890 Deborah Van Dyke Trustee 74 North Beach Street Nom Trust 82 W oodway Ridge Lane New Canaan, Ct 06840 Cindy P & William C Fowler 3106 Andrews Dr NW Atlanta, GA 30305 Mary Elizabeth & Gregory T Tadduni 408 Round Hill Rd St Davids, P A 19087 Judy R & Barry Alpert 6827 Reynolds St Pittsburgh, Pa 15208 Sterhen & Jennifer Dolente 714 Yarmouth Drive Westchester, P A 19380 Joseph & Carolyn L Massik 165 Tremont St Unit 1203 Boston, MA 02111 Kathleen F & Eric E Grant 372 Brushy Ridge Rd New Canaan, CT 06840 Peter & Gabriela Leventi 15 Old Roaring Brook Rd MT Kisco, NY 10549 . ~ " , \. 'fi} AVERV@S260™ l ~ AI Little Bo Peep LLC c/o Philbrick & Avery LLP P,O, Box 148 Nantucket, MA 02554 Katharine M & William C Miller IV 515 Madison Avenue 3151 Floor N ew York, NY 10022 Nantucket Conservation Found I P.O,Box 13 Nantucket, MA 02554 Janet T & James K Kloppenburg 15 Rutland Road Scarsdale, NY 10553 Mary C & William J Donovan c/o 27 Liberty Street Nantucket, MA 02554 Hyslop Realty LLC 37 Hyslop Road Brookline, MA 02445 James A Chu c/o Patricia H Schreiber Trust P,O, Box 3087 Nantucket, MA 02584 One Grant LLC 4707 Woodway Lane NW Washington, DC 20016 Richard B Urban & Jocelyn Sandor P.O,Box 750 Lakeville, CT 06039 Louis L Ceruzzi Jr 1720 Post Road Fairfield, CT 06824 Consultez la feuille www.avery.com Easy Peel labels Use Avery@TEMPLATE 5160@ ~ Kathleen M Rotondaro Trust c/o 8 Nantucket Avenue Nom Trust 10 Newlands Street Chevy Chase, MD 20815 Whispering Pines LLC P.Q, Box 2306 Wilmington, DE 19899 Sarah E Barnes P,Q,Box 490 Park City, VT 84060 Alida L & Richard E Storer 16 Canterbury Drive Georgetown, MA 01833 Kelly M Williams & Andrew Forsyth 252 West 30th St Apt 5A New York, NY 10001 Cinda P & William C Fowler 3106 Andrews Drive NW Atlanta, GA 30305 EtilJlJettes faciles a peler i: . II ~~ feed Paper _ See Instruction Sheet: ~ - for Easy Peel feature J\ Five Nantucket LLC 4707 Woodway Lane NW Washington, DC 20016 Stone Radford Trustee Stonec1iff Realty Trust 207 Mill Road New Canaan, Ct 06840 Nancy R Cavanaugh 2015 Ponus Ridge Rd New Canaan, CT 06840 Something Inc c/o Matthew G Fee 50 Cliff Road Nantucket, MA 02554 Commonwealth of Massachusetts c/o Dept Enviromenta1 Manage 100 Cambridge St Boston, MA 02202 Gregg Yaeger Trust c/o 37 CliffRd Nom Trust 2423 Egandale Rd Highland Park, IL 6003 5 A ~AVERV@5260TM 1 John Everets Jr DBA ELM Associates Southport, CT 06490 Janet K & Robert L Fronk 110 Ash St Weston, MA 02493 Andrew A & Pamela W Brooks 280 F orrest Avenue Rye, NY 10580 Town of Nantucket c/o Park and Rec 2 Bathing Beach Road Nantucket, MA 02554 Paulette K Boling 24 Tophet St Lynnfield, MA 01940 Consultez la feuille www.avery.com