HomeMy WebLinkAbout093-07
Print Form
TOWN OF NANTUCKET
BOARD OF APPEALS
NANTUCKET, MASSACHUSETTS 02554
~
:::0
:"";'1
--< - .
6~~
-:;;~: ::"
c::l
CJ
,~007
--
-......-.1
Da te: Deceml:Yer 21
,.-,.
-0
N
To: Parties in Interest and. Others concerned with the Decis~n of
the BOARD OF APPEALS in the Application of the following:
Application No.: 093-07
Owner/Applicant: Iliya Simeonov
Enclosed is the Decision of the BOARD OF APPEALS which has this
day been filed with the office of the Nantucket Town Clerk.
An Appeal from this Decision may be taken pursuant to Section 17
of Chapter 40A, Massachusetts General Laws.
Any action appealing the Decision must be brought by filing a
complaint in Land Court within TWENTY (20) days after this day's
date. Notice of the action with a copy of the complaint and
certified copy of the Decision must be given to the Town Clerk so
as to be received within such TWENTY (20) days.
Michael J. O'Mara, Chairman
cc: Town Clerk
Planning Board
Building Commissioner/Zoning Enforcement Officer
PLEASE NOTE: MOST SPECIAL PERMITS AND VARIANCES HAVE A TIME LIMIT
AND WILL EXPIRE IF NOT ACTED UPON ACCORDING TO NANTUCKET ZONING
BY-LAW SECTION 139-30 (SPECIAL PERMITS); SECTION 139-32
(VARIANCES). ANY QUESTIONS, PLEASE CALL THE NANTUCKET ZONING BOARD
OF APPEALS OFFICE AT 508-228-7215.
c::J
CJ
N
.....
"',' .
f'\..-__"
Print Form
TOWN OF NANTUCKET
BOARD OF APPEALS --i--.
NANTUCKET, MASSACHUSETTS 0255f~~"
~
;.0
;'-'j"',!
'-"j:
-0
, f'io 07
Ui
\0
j:":
Da te : Pecember 21
To: Parties in Interest and. Others concerned with the Decision of
the BOARD OF APPEALS in the Application of the following:
Application No.: 093-07
Owner/Applicant: niya Simeoriov
Enclosed is the Decision of the BOARD OF APPEALS which has this
day been filed with the office of the Nantucket Town Clerk.
An Appeal from this Decision may be taken pursuant to Section 17
of Chapter 40A, Massachusetts General Laws.
Any action appealing the Decision must be brought by filing a
complaint in Land Court within TWENTY (20) days after this day's
date. Notice of the action with a copy of the complaint and
certified copy of the Decision must be given to the Town Clerk so
as to be received within such TWENTY (20) days.
~C.../ .<~ .;)'(/
.I'.' i.'" 1". /',"/ l'.\;.:1~.\
,;. -t..v, (r-l" .J~J
Michael J. O'Mara, Chairman
cc: Town Clerk
Planning Board
BUilding\T~~~sN}^Bir/zoning Enforcement Officer
..- '" _ LJ ~J
PLEASE NOTE: MOST SPECIAL PERMITS AND VARIANCES HAVE A TIME LIMIT
AND WILL EXPIRE IF NOT ACTED UPON ACCORDING TO NANTUCKET ZONING
BY-LAW SECTION 139-30 (SP~CIAL PERMITS); SECTION 139-32
(VARIANCESfZ:~ clOE~~o~; PLEASE CALL THE NANTUCKET ZONING BOARD
OF APPEALS OFFICE AT 508-228-7215.
NANTUCKET ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS
TWO FAIRGROUNDS ROAD
NANTUCKET, MASSSACHUSETTS 02554
Assessors Map 55
Parcel 338
ROH
18 New Street
Book 1067, Page 240
At a Public Hearing of the Nantucket Zoning Board of Appeals held on November 16,
2007, at 2 Fairgrounds Road, Nantucket, Massachusetts, on the Application ofILIY A
SIMEONOV, of 18 New Street, Nantucket, Massachusetts, Board of Appeals File No. 093-07,
the Board made the following Decision:
1. The applicant is seeking to validate the alteration of a pre-existing nonconforming use on
the site so that the applicant may convert the existing duplex to a single family dwelling and then
construct a second dwelling on the site and maintain the pre-existing nonconforming use status.
The applicant is seeking a special permit pursuant to Zoning Bylaw section 139-33 for pre-
existing, nonconforming uses, structures, and lots. The site is located at 18 New Street and is
shown on Nantucket Tax Assessors Map 55 as Parcel 338 and in Nantucket Registry of Deeds
Book 1067, Page 240.
The subject Property is located in the Residential Old Historic (ROH) zoning district and
is improved with a two family structure which pre-dates the 1972 enactment of the Nantucket
Zoning Bylaw. The required minimum lot size in the ROH district pursuant to intensity
regulations under Section 139-16 of the Bylaw is five thousand (5000) square feet. The Property
is oversized, having a lot area of approximately 7,700 square feet. The maximum ground cover
allowable for the Property pursuant to Section 139-16 is fifty (50%) percent of the lot size. The
required side yard setback in the ROH district is five (5) feet. The Property is nonconforming
with respect to use (two family duplex in ROH, as well as to side yard setbacks [0.0 feet from the
Westerly boundary] as shown on an As-built Plot Plan prepared by Bennett Engineering dated
February 16,2006. The applicant has produced an affidavit from Gail L. Po1chinski dated
October 27,2006 which states that Ms. Po1chinski is personally familiar with the structure on the
premises since prior to 1972, and the structure on the premises has always been used as a single
two-family dwelling with two separate kitchens.
The Applicant has obtained a Certificate of Appropriateness from the Nantucket Historic
District Commission to renovate the existing structure on the Property and add a conforming
addition; (See HDC Certificate of Appropriateness #50833 dated August 7, 2007). The existing
structure with conforming additions will have a ground cover of 1,479 square feet. The
Applicant intends to maintain the existing structure as a single family residence. The Applicant
will also need HDC approval to construct a second, single family structure on the premises. The
new structure will have a ground cover of 1,148 square feet as proposed. The applicant plans to
build the second structure on the premises with a customary kitchen and seeks to move the
apartment from the nonconforming duplex to the second structure. The secondary structure will
conform to all intensity regulations set forth in the Bylaw. Accordingly, the Applicant is seeking
to validate the alteration of the pre-existing nonconforming use pursuant to 139-33A to include
Simeonov
1
the kitchen in the secondary structure while maintaining its pre-existing status. The Applicant
then intends to convert the title to the Property to a condominium form of ownership based upon
the pre-existing status of the two family units on the premises.
Granting the proposed Special Permit will not be more detrimental to the neighborhood
than the existing nonconforming duplex. The lot on which the applicant proposes the alteration
in use is oversized containing approximately 7,700 square feet oflot area in a district which
requires 5,000 square feet and all additions will conform to the Bylaw intensity regulations. In
addition, many of the surrounding properties are undersized and some contain secondary
dwellings both in common and separate ownership: (Lot area of 14 New Street measures
approximately 2,200 square feet); (20 New Street measures approximately 3,000 square feet);
(13 New Street is a 10,000 square foot lot containing 3 condominium units and a studio).
Therefore, the relief requested is not substantially more detrimental to the neighborhood than the
existing duplex and by granting the requested Special Permit, the Board will be acting in a
manner consistent with the spirit and intent of the Zoning Bylaw.
2. The Decision by the Nantucket Zoning Board of Appeals (hereinafter referred to as the
"Board") is based upon the Application and accompanying materials submitted by the Applicants
with said Application and the testimony and evidence presented by the Applicants at the hearing
on November 16,2007.
3. Applicants, through counsel, represented that the relief requested was similar to a
previous decision by the Board in 2000 (25 Sankaty Avenue - ZBA File No. 033-00).
Applicants proposed that because of the above-referenced decision, the demolition and
reconstruction of the dwellings is similar enough to the prior decision to warrant the relief
requested.
The Zoning Enforcement Officer countered this by reminding the Board that upon
demolition, the nonconforming status is thereby removed. Upon removal of the nonconforming
structure, the lot and future structures would no longer receive the benefit of the nonconforming
status. Therefore, the requested relief by the applicants is not appropriate and should not be
granted by the Board.
4. Accordingly, at the hearing on November 16,2007, a motion to approve the requested
relief was made based on the finding that the requested relief would not result in a situation that
was more nonconforming nor detrimental to the neighborhood than the existing situation as
outlined above. The Board voted none in favor and 5 opposed (0-5) and therefore the motion to
approve failed resulting in the Board voting AGAINST the requested SPECIAL PERMIT, under
Nantucket Zoning By-Law Section 139-33A.
Simeonov
2
.....1 .,
,2007
DATED:
oj
~--7
~~
Burr Tupp .
Kerim Koseatac
COMMONWEALTH OF MASSACHUSETTS
Nantucket, ss.
November ell ,2007
On this d/ day of b'CcJ11b-,. 2007, before me, the undersigned Notary Public,
personally appeared /27UfY J7A.n:z-'-1 ' who is personally known
to me, and who is the person whose name is signed on the preceding or attached document, and
who acknowledged to me that he/she signed it voluntarily for its stated purpose.
/~fUI/~~~
~tary Public:
My commission expires: Ala<<1t ~/, ;J.:v,:?"
Simeonov
3
..... ......
c:>~
:E:.-
Z-::'-
Me
IC)
('T17
~..., :x::;.
A PUBLIC HEARING of the NANTUCKET ZONING BOARD OF qPEALS:;;
scheduled for 1:00 PM in the Conference Room at 2 Fairgrounds Road, Nantucket, ~
02554. The application materials for the below referenced application may be reviewed at the
Zoning Board of Appeals office at 2 Fairgrounds Road, Nantucket, MA 02554 between the
hours of 8:30 A.M. and 4:30 P.M., Monday through Friday. Written comments for the
October 19,2007 meeting must be received by 4:30 PM on Wednesday, October 10, 2007
and may be addressed to the Nantucket Zoning Board of Appeals at the above address,
faxed to (508) 228-7298, or e-mailed to tbroadrick@nantucket-ma.gov .
TOWN OF NANTUCKET
ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS
1 EAST CHESTNUT STREET
NANTUCKET, MASSACHUSETTS 02554
PHONE 508-228-7215
FAX 508-228-7205
~
::0
rli
NOTICE
c::l
CJ
--4
-
0\
r""~
f. . F
-!-
ILYA SIMEONOV, FILE NO. 093-07
The applicant is seeking to validate the alteration of a preexisting nonconforming use on the
site so that the applicant may convert the existing duplex to a single family dwelling and then
construct a second dwelling on the site and maintain the preexisting nonconforming use
status. The applicant is seeking a special permit pursuant to Zoning Bylaw section 139-33 for
preexisting, nonconforming uses, structures, and lots. The site is located at 18 New Street
and is shown on Nantucket Tax Assessors Map 55 as Parcel 338 and Nantucket Registry of
Deeds Book 1067, Page 240.
FEE: $300.00
NANTUCKET Z.UNING .HUARD U.fl' APPEALS
1 EAST CHESTNUT STREET
NANTUCKET, MA 02554
APPLICATION FOR RELIEF
CASE NO. (ff:J ... () 7
0\ .;r's name(s): lIya Simeonov
Mailing address: PMB 230. Greolen Ave. Nan~ucket. MA 02554
Applicant's name(s): lIya SimeOT'lov
Mailing address:c/o Vauohan Dale & Hunter P.C. BOX 659 Whaler's Lane Nantucket. MA 02554
Locus address: 18 New Street Assessor's MaplParcel: 55/338
Land Court PlanIPlan Book & PageIPlan File No.: N/A Lot No.:
Date lot acquired:.l.J201 07 Deed RefJCert. of Title: B. 1067 P. 240 Zoning District: ROH
'I
Uses on Lot- Commercial: NoneL Yes (describe)
Residential: Number of dwellings Duplex x Apartments Rental Rooms
Building Date(s): All pre--date 7n2? or C of O(s)? N/A
Building Permit Nos: N/A
Previous Zoning Board Application Nos.: None
State below or on a separate addendum specific relief sought (Special Permit, Variance, Appeal), Section of
the Zoning By-law ,'and supporting details, grounds for grant of relief, listing any existing nonconformitJ~s:
" -. --
See Addendum Attached.
~ ::0
1::J rn
CJ <'J
~
--" :':1
0\
-
.t.'_"
:y ,-'1
.-..J 0
0
N
t.
I certify that the information contained herein is substantially complete and true to the best of my
knowledge, under ~ penalties of perjury.
SIGNATURE: ~ ij~/ Applicant Attorney/Agent}C
(If not owner or owner's attorney, please enclose proof of agency to bring this matter before the Board)
FOR ZBA OFFICE USE
Application received on:---1_'_By: Complete:- Need copies?:
Filed with Town Clerk: ---1---1_ Planning Board: ---1---1_ Building Dept.:---1---1_ By:
Fee deposited with Town Treasurer:--!_'_By: Waiver requested?: Granted:--!--!_
He~"'ng notice posted with Town ~lerk:---1--!_Mailed:---1---1_I&M:---1-1_ & ---1-!_
He"_Adg(S) held on:---1-1_ Opened on:---1---1_ Continued to:---1--1_Withdrawn?:--1--1_
DECISION DUE BY:--1---1_ Made:---1---1_ Filed wffown Clerk:-1_'_ Mailed:_'--1_
DECISION APPEALED?:---1--1_ SUPERIOR COURT: LAND COURT Form 4'03'03
ADDENDUM
The Applicant, Iliya Simeonov, requests a Special Permit pursuant to Section
139-33A of the Nantucket Zoning By-law for this property located at 18 New Street,
Nantucket ("hereinafter the Property"). The Property is shown on Nantucket Assessors
Map 55, Parcel 338. Attached hereto as Exhibit A.
The subject Property is located in the Residential Old Historic - (ROH) zoning
district and is improved with a two family structure which pre-dates the 1972 enactment
of the Nantucket Zoning By-law. The required minimum lot size in the ROH district
pursuant to intensity regulations under Section 139-16 of the By-law is five thousand
(5,000) square feet. The Property is oversized, having a lot area of approximately 7,700
square feet. The maximum ground cover allowable for the Property pursuant to Section
139-16 is fifty (50%) percent of the lot size. The required side yard setback in the ROH
district is five (5) feet. The Property is non-conforming with respect use (two family
duplex in ROH, as well as to side yard setbacks (0.0 feet from the Westerly boundary) as
shown on an As-built Plot Plan prepared by Bennett Engineering of dated February 16,
2006. Attached hereto as Exhibit B. The applicant has procured an affidavit from Gail L.
Po1chinski dated October 27, 2006. Attached hereto as Exhibit C. The Affidavit states
that Ms. Po1chinski is personally familiar with the structure on the Premises and since
prior to 1972, and the structure on the premises has always been used as a single two
family dwelling with two separate kitchens.
The applicant has obtained a Certificate of Appropriateness from the Nantucket
Historic District Commission to renovate the existing structure on the Property and add a
conforming addition; See Certificate of Appropriateness #50833 dated August 7, 2007.
Attached hereto as Exhibit D. The existing structure with conforming additions will have
a ground cover of 1,479 square feet. The applicant intends to maintain the existing
structure as a single family residence. The Applicant is currently in the process of
obtaining HDC approval to construct a second, single family structure on the premises for
which a Certificate of Appropriateness is expected by the time of the public hearing on
this matter. The new structure will have a ground cover of 1,148 as proposed. Floor
Plans Attached hereto as Exhibit E The applicant plans to build the second structure on
the premises with a customary kitchen and seeks to move the apartment from the non-
1
conforming duplex to the second structure. The secondary structure will conform to all
intensity regulations set forth in the By-law. Accordingly the applicant is seeking to
validate the alteration of the pre-existing nonconforming use pursuant to ~ 139-33A to
include the kitchen in the secondary structure while maintaining its pre-existing status.
The applicant then intends to convert the title to the Property to a condominium form of
ownership based upon the pre-existing status of the two family units on the premises.
Granting the proposed Special Permit will not be more detrimental to the
neighborhood than the existing non-conforming duplex. The lot on which the applicant
proposes the alteration in use is oversized containing approximately 7,700 square feet of
lot area in a district which requires 5,000 square feet and all additions will conform to the
by-law intensity regulations. In addition, many of the surrounding properties are
undersized and some contain secondary dwellings both in common and separate
ownership: (Lot area of 14 New Street measures approximately 2,200 square feet); (20
New Street measures approximately 3,000 square feet oflot area); (13 New street is a
10,000 square foot lot containing 3 condominium units and a studio). Therefore, the
relief requested is non substantially more detrimental to neighborhood than the existing
duplex and by granting the requested Special Permit, the board will be acting in a manner
consistent with the spirit and intent of the Zoning By-Law.
For the foregoing reasons, the applicant respectfully requests that the Board grant
the requested Special Permit.
2
...; .~~
~......,"./L.c,...,d..... /
7' ':'1'.';' "_^" ~~ -"t
, l.P Nf;..,J ~
-~
?1btlJW1lf ~.~Ir~
E J( ~"'"
I~" H'1iI ~'1
~. ~............U."1
.-~~.
l~1' Si ~
to.,..
>-
-<
)
..
?
~
P
,
~
~
,
I
J~
-- li(
p. r.opo ~ e." . 1.11 1'l
,~~.. ~l
~ 10)t 30 J ,
t~~~\\
c
~~"""""""r./'
'"
.--.......-.~--
-l ~
~
I ~
I
fi't':J ~
- 1ie v.. < ft~ Jo'J1
"~"
t-
f
-----~.
~
\r t
, \
t 1
t\
~~(..<E!.A- '1.
1-
1
2-7',.'i$ .
.
--:- ~
... .,
" <>
\.9 "
~;
..........._~. ,
(2.0 Po sea
EXHIBIT A
Additional Info
Town of Nantucket Web GIS
Home
Find
f\'~ a p
.
Zoom In
~ ~..
III1IIIIII Out
[if ~ ~ ~.
':II'" ..."
"... "'':11
SOUTH .....
~ ~':.
DAerial Photo
Label Parcels with Parcel ID
Property ID 55 338
Location 18 NEVI
Last Sale Date
Last Sale Price
Book/Page
Lot Size
~
Land Use 1 Code
Land Use 1 Desc
Land Use 1 010
Land Use 2 Code
Land Use 2 Desc
Land Use 2 010
!
~
Out Building
Value
Ex. Feature Value
Improvement
Value
Total Exempt
Total Value
Utility
Land Class
Zone
Use of this facility is dependent upon acceptance and understanding of Use Conditions and Data Caveats contained on
httn./Ih()~t l'lnnup,() ~()m/nl'lntll('.1<p,tml'llMl'ln l'l~nY
QIl?noo?
EXHIBIT B
~#
/.. ",,,,'"
BUIlDING .. ",'"
SETBAO< ' '"
UNE (TYP. '.. '" r <0
","'~C~..o 1-
"'- '\;l> 'R" ~
"'- cj,. '.
",-"d'~ .. ~ ~
",-"~O~ .. # "
",-"'-~ ~
"'-~C
MAP 55 LOT 338
7,700 SF:!:
Current Zoning Information
Zoning Classification: ROO, PWRD
Zoning Definition: Residential Old Historic
Well head recharge District
BuUding Setba~ Requirements
Observed Required Notes
Front Yard Setback 0 Feet 0 Feet N/A
Side Yard S~back 0 Feet 5 Feet
Rear Yard Setback 42 Feet 5 Feet
Bulk Re uirements
Observed R ulred
Lot Area Lot Area
80.6 Feet 50"
17.7% 50%
1.490 s.f. 2.550 s.t* *Maximum
/-'
PLOT PLAN
18 NEW ST.
NANTUCKET, MASS.
/
/,'
Lot Area
Lot Franta e.
Max. Ground Cover
ervlous Area
/
SCALE: 1 "";'20' , DATE: 5/1/2007
~
BENNETT ENGINEERING
PLAN REF: LCP 22795A, 00-22
DEED REF: B: 995 P: 107
JOB NO: 1051
1
LAND SURVEYING. ENGINEERING. 8: DEVELOPMENT SERVICES
----=------l1lI
PO BOX 297 TEL (508) 88&4868
SAGAMORE BEACH. MA 02562 FAX.. (508) 888-4867
o 20 40 60
~-...;-
3'-1 q aU? pL-l("l-loVTH 1Z-o/ilb
EXHIBIT C
~1/05/%007
~,.~~ , -_"0#.
.~
... ".I
I
I
i
P~I 1'1]0 PAX 1'082283070 v.u~h.n . 0.1& ~~~ K1ll.n R..1 B.~.~e
~0021003
STATE OF MAINE
COUNTY OF KNOX
IN RE: 18 NEW STREET,
NANTUCKET, MASSACHUSETTS
02554
AFFIDAVIT OF
GAIL L. POLCHlNSKI
I, GAlL L. POLCHINSKl, being duly sworn, depose and say:
1. I reside at 40 Oyster River Road, Thomaston., Maine 04361. 1 make this
Affidavit on my personal knowledge.
2. Prior to July 1, 1972, I resid~ in Nantucket, Massachusetts 02554 and wn
personally familiar with the UnpToved real estate lowted at 18 New Street, Nantucket,
MaS$~chusetts 02554, shown a$ pa:rce1338 on Nantucket Asses$Or's Map 55 C'N$w Street
Propentl
3. Prior to July 1, 1972, the New Street Property included a single, two (2) family
dwelling with two (2) separate ldtchens. The New Street Property is shown on the Town of
Nanmckct Web GIS page Sllnexed hereto as Exhibit UA". The N~ Street building on the New
Street Property has exi$ted in its current location and configuration, with no material alterations,
and has been used and occupied as a two (2) family dwelling since a time prior t.o July 1. 1972.
Signed 'Ullder the penalties ofpeljUTY this e:J.f'J day ofOclober 2006.
~lli~
GAIL L. POLCHINSKI
KnOx, 55.
STATE OF MAINE
Ocl..ober 1)1 , 2006
On this j)? day of October 2006, before
personally appeared Gail L. Polc:hinski and proved t
identification, which ~ .
the preceding or attached docum~nt, and acknowl,
stated purpose.
EXHIBIT D
tl':ll .l.:i/ Ltltl f .l 'I: '1.l
::Jtl/j.:iL::Jf::JfL
MIA..
rHqc. V.l.
----
-----
DATE ISSUED: 0;(0 j lor .
ceRTIFICATE NO~ \-~ b2> Appl~Uon to ltle HISlORIC PISTf\lCT COAMpMpISSROIOpN'RNalAnrENESSaCl1U$Ellta, lot' a
CERTlFICATE OF
10' !llluctural wo;!<, . rl<ed N/A
All blllnl<5 mLl91 bo::I nlled in using~~~Rg~~~~~~::;'CI~ ~nttlcbl in M~~~ aubmlttal of ~.
NOTE: " Is lItfOngly rec~:.nd.1I th~~~arl!=~~~~~.nta,lncompleteIlPPIlGatlon&;::: ~t=~-:a.t:~ unde; c~ar 396 cA \tI8 Ads end
n:. 8M . k An .wIical,ion ;5 hereby mad. for i$SUBne& of .. ." this Bpplicallon llI\ll niade . part tlereol by reletenC8.
ll11a i:; a cooltactual 8Qmlmenl """ ~.:; ~~~~ '"herein and an pI<<n8. drlJwlngs and pl\OIOO<apIl$ ~rnll~tion may impede I8sU8/lC8 of Cef1jJicate (It 0ccuIWlCY.
R~ (II MaGli., 1970, fOf prOpO$ No atrueture may dilt6, ftQ!l\ tho: apjllO\led appl.......iOIl,
ll1e CIlrtltlcllW ia wJil;l lor lIl,ee yeara trom dala of \8au&nC8.
FOI'\ OfFICE use ONLy
Oate applICation rec.ived: c'".... (?.~ pt
MLl81 be acted on by~ 0', { \' P P'
Extended 10:
.Awoved:
f' ;"'10.1 ;:......t ::t_-,.
Fe, Paid; S ~"'. m
PROPERn' DESCFIlPitON
TAX MAP NO: S ~ PARCEL NO. ~~ ~
SIr"I&Numberol~rop08edWork: ,~ ~ ,~. t-J~ ~~-
0_ of reoor4: ....1!:X.I A<r..r H E..ot.,/cV -i 2-$ 0 ~
Ma\tingAdd~:..-1:-. r;,~ fnlE.. ~-~
-----
cnairman:
Member:
M.,.,ber.
Mamller:
Member:
Telephol'le: Sob ~e '..M:LfIpt ialaOd) _ (011 ist3nd)
AGENT INFORMATION (If .ppl~ble)
Name: ~ '\)1iid.1<. t:J, . LL c.. ~._-
Ma~\<1gAddres': _~~~~.
--'t::lftN 'IV ~ Mf'r
Telephone:7dJ.-Il> -"~loo i61..nd) _ Ion (eland)
r:: N9w DWelIlC1!l ~:: Addilion
:.; COlor Cha~ OJ F~
C other (please .~Iy)
Size 01 Slfl,H;!:ure Of Addition:
OGara~
CG.le
DESCFl\PTlON OF WOR~ TO BE PE,.FoRMED 1r-PfI/ n , .1
s.e _ lor reQU'rod doc:\Jm8{lIatlon. "'t' '7
.:.: GaragelApwtmenI : ': Corltmen::lal X Hi$tOriCaI Renovation ::: Deck
L! PaVIng :.~ ~oYe BullOlfl9 -:: Oer/'Ollllon - Revi8lon& \0 prevlous-Cel1. No.
--- 9tep$
= Shed
Sq. FOOIQ~ 1st 1100'; I '" 1~
Sq. foofage 2nd Iloo(: 11 '1"1
Sq.lOOIlI.9" 3'12 Mo<: ~- W.at .....--
Difference betYleen e)[i$ijntlllrade end prl>PQll8d finleh grad,,: NoM---=:::::::::._ South _~- Eae,t, -- ..,. ~ '_' - II
· . '2-. '-1.1 Wallt -.,. -
H.ighlol m;g. above ~I finish gracle: NotIIt ~.. 'IlL SOult> '2- '2- 40.10 'LL East .
, A ....'... /$1'\So.IO fl<.bO<<-t!>$...ti~t
Atldnl"O,,1 R91J111rkl:. REVISIONS: t, SutElIIVa~on DD --. W" ~t1 "" ~& o.\of ..tI\"
(d"serlbel ~O.. ,.......- '-&"', ""~,:' -,.;.,. ,II'L."'.U,~ ...:.:J toW I
HI5t~N_: ~t>'f) 2.Soutl1eleYetlOn~.It..+-""\'-'o..~J_ ~~"o ........,.0 ~(..
OItgln<<IODt.o: .s;e,.oJ~.....~ 1&1b W'~Olf)r 3. We81 Bevlltion "'QO 1'......0-1\. ~'E ",....IWS ~o.....u.l ~
OrtginilIBulld9<: II>JfI\;\j:.- -4.NQI'Ih-ElIIVaUon t-Jo G~"(. ~~1'\oJ\n"llM U"'-"- 'f
~"'lV~
Is Ihti.. 811 HOC survey lann lor tnl8l11111ding7 r" Yes IK1 No "t'O ""~-CIoLld on lh 01 exl8ll eleve.1ion8.
~ of ... DETAIL OF WPRK TO BE pERFORMED
FOl1nd-'on: Helght ~ed r,...,a ~ Block . _ BIocI<. Parg~ _ BrIck (typel
"'..onryChlm""y: =-:-:BlockParged 3{Br1<:k(type) )A~c.t\ t:-lC.IJ'l'lo.j~ ::::: 0ln8f
Roof Pllcn: Main Ma~$ ~12~ $e<;Qndllt)' Mesa ~12~ Dormer ----112_ Other
Roofing mmrlel: RA9Pha/t Ml\nl,/h..,turer 11:-0 ~~ ~, r.lM-OL
:-: WOOd (Type; R~ Ced81. White Cedar. Shakes. .Ie,)
:.:... otoor MBnufactur.r
Skylight. (flat ol\ly): Manufacturer ~ ~. ROLlQh Openlng
Manufacturer ----- _ Rough Opoolng
O\me,..: )(wm(lype)_~~!s',"N1 WOOh '::Aluminum
Leed.,.(me.lef\trlend.iz.e): "" S.Jr.I~"oJ7 ALUM'/>)l>L1 CHrttJ<jf"TO llJ.,' ~(>k&o L<<>(>D
$ldllw.lI: ~Whlte cedar shingles ...:: ClapbOard (exp08u'e: il'ldl6a) Front ,-
~ Other ,_~__
Trim: A. Wood .. Pine :.J RedwOOd ~edar :... Other
c..~ B, 'rrealmenl Thlnt:J Slain-$Q1ld :::.: NaiLl/alto waa.ther ~ Clear Olllllllsh
~","\: S<' C, DImensions: Faecle 1)L" ~'f1" R...k4 I JI. ~ eJ['lT Soffit (Ov.....lIOg) ______ Comer ~,df, .!!.LtlJ. fL Frieze
~' /' WIndoWCa91ng ~'f"'i ~fitloort=....._ ~~~ P~tv COlun-.ne/Posl8: Round_Sql.Jll!rll ~ ~e..e pti>-rc. I
Window.': ~ Double Hung :::: CII8emen1 ::: All Wm :; OI;h.r .___--
Ffrue DIVkItld Ugh18(munMa) = SOL'll (SimulDI"1 Divfd~ Lightro)
000.... (Iype and material): Fronl ~.:~ LJyt-r ( E-)(u:n) R';l.r C4 ~~ It(
G"",lI<' Door(s): Type ---- Material
u!KbOllPlllltlterlll!l.: Driv,weY5~ WellrNays
, Nole: Cflnl>Iele doot and wlndoW ech9dules Il!re r..quire<!.
()ed(e: ~ix.: (, 1/. , l4'
Slze:
lZ 191 ftoo< ': 2C1d floOr
= 1:st 1I0OI =. 2nd fIoo<
LengV1: 5'1
WIdth: +\
:: Pouted Concrete
::- 1'18<6
S" " 1.- 1.
:srru- Ml'rSl....<.
Fence: Height:
Type;
Lengtn;
Sill/
SIze
LOClItion _
Locallon
-, eopp.,
SIde C
~ o"'~ L.l((Wf' 1> M-....."'.l>~
f!UlJU{ (AJ E.t.J Side '1 l.l~ltr ~ ~,'~ (t.lJj
.~Walle
COLORS
Sidllwtlll = ~ >. Clapboard (~"pplioablc) --
Trim ~~ (; (MIt'TlJfIf ~~Sll5h~~__(;..ff.i{H,ft'fG\\-)
Deck ..,"", HA:~AN't Foundation ~XI-.tO.!:)~ r....Jt
. Atleeh manuractur.r's color samples ~ color Is '1Ot lrom HOC app<O'I8Ili..t.
I her.by authorize the 1I~ named aboVe 10 act on my be/1Qlf 10 malc.e ch;ongea in th" ~ication8 Of 1118 plane conlaloOO to this appllcQtton In ~... to bring ""
appllcallon into complie.nc9 wi\h th" HOC guidellMe, I hereby ag'8<l to abide by and com ith th<; .,,""" and l>Ol'IdItlona or II1IS appMcation, I hereby agree thaI ....
$Ubml681on 01 revisl 9 to II1l8 application w~1 initill!I" ... new 81JC1y-day reVl&w peflOO, ;...----
Oal l- '/ ~ 61 ~ . " lJl'6 of of rllCOtd
'Dutr-<.- ~ C If14-n;A.I
:::s ~()~':f' ~(~:rX\J~
F9!lC\l - Shl,/ltens =--
EXHIBIT E
!
!
-}-
1.,0...
~ '-...-
/-\
o
G...., ,ry"1
:....,_ 0
'A"~
......
I ...,I
i 1& ,"'..g
n
U;
!
. I
I I
~
, :~:~
__.': ~ .,' ___:_ '-'n:. -'_:[,~j;~,
J
~...,,".ij.. ... .c.
_;"'..,~~c'""~.... ..
_." ')~~~
rm-
\
I
I
I
\ J
I ~
I III
I ~
I ~
I "i
H-
DW
,!>t" ~.
~ 11't.-t4e,J i
14 (/0
..,
'0
'N.C.
6Jt~
~~l'
~)D<~
lll;O l ~e
o
---..-+-.---.---
, _ '1
~() -~
w. ""
$
~€A1"
SEoD N., t>~~c.. ~ c NC}
i
. ~
j;l) -0
4.>>"~do Dc:>(.M~
t
I/~,
'~ L-
L-OW
\..;wt:.J
,.....~~ t;~,,-
-... 0",,\
14"l<.1~
--,
I
o
..
ria I'>"
;D,
~~'d ....,.~
..~.... ...........i<;~ ./.....1:~"(.,>..,.,.<__-. [!'...."'_ '. ...e,.. ...........,~e.~.~.--.
.,' _:.. -c. ,',' ,:,:_:_.'_,',"<:'-__'_"".. ........ ....__.._....._..... _,' . " .. ,..,~",;:" _~."~.,.J__.___~_,,.,...._,. _ _ .." ,-, -
l~..:..*..;,.,"
.S E.Co~~ 'O\.t.)eL"-I~
~
...ll't.
,-
()
-.............~~
~
~
r.:- -~
, I ir -=r= ....-=;1"1
Ilt{'\ -r __ -:fIt
I ~~J. ;".--...111
.L..o- ___ - ::J
, -"I".".......;;;'"'''''-~.~,:,....:,''
9~,.,
f.
I
;"'-':;",-.k'~,",' .-..
c.....:." u.....
~.
r rr T-=41
III- -I- -11
ltQ LdJ
....",.....
"
<r'...~
pl
.
)>
~
II
I I
I I -
l~~
. ~~.
i'"
. ,ilL..
1 '
i~
~
;~!
~
!4-
"-
li\,r,
. .....,
f..lo.-..._~
I ".
~-1
I
I
I
I
I
I
I'
r-
I!'IO'
t.j
I ,-'
r'
I t~J ~_-
t.J ~.c-
~j ~;
i.Yt"
iliT ' ~
1(.. h
II [ ='- J,.,.
r; I~_==- ~
L r""-
L
r~
I .
I
I
I
~
X
, ~
()~
r-+
I L
1..1
I
I
I
I
I
I
Vb </
OQ-
6 I
I '
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
rJ
I
L.r- - -
r~ ?1f1
I ~i\4-1~1
-pt- -..4l1
'1'-, . ."J r'
'. It:.'.i - 1'... -... -ft .........j
j..{ ~~J
,At
J I
,I
I
I'
if!,
.~
- -..----..,....-.-~-.-... .- ._.,~.-,~......"',..._..".,......,...,.......-.--,.- .-----, ..-.' ,....._"'.........,..--.-.....~.~-,.."'..,.,..-="~.,...~~_..........~ .~'.. v.-.~~~.M.,.,.. ,...~""""'~~~.,.,.,'=""~-""""~_'?"'........._,.,.,.....~._.._.
, ',' ~.' .
~..,L..._:,;~'.':;:'_. .,'....."~"i,..~-._,., U.'"