HomeMy WebLinkAbout036-03
(
TOWN OF NANTUCKET
BOARD OF APPEALS
NANTUCKET, MASSACHUSETTS 02554
Date: 3""UG-i II
, 20 G2i
To: Parties in Interest and, Others concerned with the
Decision of the BOARD OF APPEALS in the Application of the
fol,lowing:
Applica tion No.: () 3(0 --0.3
bwner/APPlicant:--fe."ter .p,. \<" 00 qh )Tru~7ee.-.
o~ The ('no.V"\;'n &'1.... Tru~-r
Enclosed is the Decision of the BOARD OF APPEALS which has
this day been filed in the office of the Nantucket Town
Clerk.
An Appeal from this Decision may be taken pursuant to
Section 17 of Chapter 40A, Massachusetts General Laws.
Any' action appealing the Decision must be brought by
filing an complaint in court within TWENTY (20) days after
this day's date.- Notice of the action with a copy of the
complaint and certified copy of the Decision must be given
to the Town Clerk so as to be received within such TWENTY
(20) days.
~~t-J \&~
AJ(>J\\~;:f.JQ.tJ f0'U>, Chairman
cc: Town Clerk
Planning Board
Building Commissioner
PLEASE NOTE: MOST SPECIAL PERMITS AND VARIANCES HAVE A TIME
LIMIT AND WILL EXPIRE IF NOT ACTED UPON ACCORDING'TO NANTUCKET
ZONING BY-LAW 9139-301 (SPECIAL PERMITS). 9139-321 (VARIANCES)
,
ANY QUESTIONS, PLEASE CALL THE NANTUCKET ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS.
NANTUCKET ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS
1 East Chestnut Street
Nantucket, Massachusetts 02554
Assessor's Map 73.1.3, Parcel 114
16 Broadway, Siasconset
Siasconset Old Historic
No record plan
Deed, Book 514, Page 216
DECISION:
1. At a public hearing of the Nantucket Zoning Board of
Appeals, on Friday, June 13, 2003, at 1:00 P.M., in the
Conference Room, in the Town Annex Building, 37 Washington
Street, Nantucket, Massachusetts, the Board made the following
Decision on the Application of PETER F. KROGH, Trustee of THE
MARTIN BOX TRUST, c/o Reade, Gullicksen, Hanley & Gifford, LLP,
Post Office Box 2669, Nantucket, Massachusetts 02584, File No.
036-03:
2. The Applicant is seeking relief by SPECIAL PERMIT under
Nantucket Zoning By-law ("By-law") ~139-33.A (alteration or
expansion of a pre-existing nonconforming structure or use). The
Applicant proposes to construct a new basement under the existing
single-family dwelling. In addition, relief by SPECIAL PERMIT is
sought under By-law ~139-33.E(2) (a), to allow the ground cover to
be increased to about 1,085 square feet, for a ground cover ratio
of about 48.6%, in a district in which the maximum ground cover
ratio is 50%, but 30% for undersized lots of record. This work
would entail incorporating an existing outbuilding into the
dwelling upon the subject property (the "Locus"). The Applicant
also plans to expand the structure upward within the required
five-foot side and rear yard setback areas. None of the work
proposed would entail coming any closer to the lot lines than the
existing structure. The Locus is nonconforming as to lot size,
having area of about 2,234 square feet, with minimum lot area in
this district being 5,000 square feet; and frontage, with
frontage of about 43.3 feet on Center Street (from which front
yard setback is calculated by the applicant in order to avoid a
nonconformity in this district where zero front yard setback is
allowed), and minimum frontage in this district is 50 feet. The
structures upon the Locus, said to pre-exist the effective date
of the By-law in 1972, are nonconforming as to northerly side
yard setback, which is at present about 0.5 feet at the closest
point, and southerly side yard setback, which is at present about
2.0 feet at the closest point, with minimum side yard setback in
this district being 5 feet; and ground cover ratio, having
present ground cover of about 996 square feet, for a ratio of
about 44.6%.
The Locus is situated at 16 BROADWAY, SIASCONSET,
Assessor's Map 73.1.3, Parcel 114, with there being no plan of
record, and consists of the property conveyed to the Applicant by
deed recorded with Nantucket Deeds in Book 514, Page 216. The
Locus is situated in the Siasconset Old Historic zoning district.
1
3. Our Decision is based upon the Application and
accompanying materials, and representations and testimony
received at our public hearing. There was no Planning Board
recommendation, on the basis that no issues of planning concern
were presented. Except for the Applicant, his counsel, and his
architectural representative, there was neither support nor
opposition presented at the public hearing. The Applicant
presented twenty-one letters in support from abutters and near
neighbors, including both immediately abutting property owners.
4. As presented by the Applicant, through counsel, he
proposed to place a new basement foundation underneath the
existing dwelling upon the Locus, and in the course of this work
to demolish an existing outbuilding used as a workshop or studio
and a portion of the existing dwelling and construct a new
addition to the remaining portion of the existing dwelling
generally in the area where the outbuilding and the portion of
the existing dwelling which is being demolished are currently
si ted. The proposed work had been approved by the Nantucket
Historic District Commission ("HDC") under its Certificate of
Appropriateness No. 40053. No portion of the new construction
would be closer to the side yard lot line than the closest point
of the remaining portion of the present structure and the overall
height of the structure would remain at about 11.8 feet, so
Special Permit relief under By-law ~139-33.A(5) would be
available for the extension of the present structure. Relief is
also necessary under the general provisions of By-law ~139-33.A
for the alteration of the existing structure by placing the new
basement foundation under the structure within the setback area.
Furthermore, since the proposal will add ground cover to about
44.6%, exceeding the 30% maximum ratio under By-law ~139-
33.E(2) (a) for an undersized lot of record containing less than
5,000 square feet, relief is needed under the Special Permit
provisions of that section to permit ground cover ratio exceeding
30% but not exceeding the 50% maximum ground cover ratio in the
Siasconset Old Historic district. The present conditions upon
the Locus are shown upon a plan done by Charles W. Hart and
Associates, Inc., dated December 2, 2002, a reduced copy of which
is attached hereto as Exhibit A, and the proposed alterations to
be performed upon the Locus are approximately shown upon a plan
done by Charles W. Hart and Associates, Inc., dated December 2,
2002, revised April 3, 2003, a reduced copy of which is attached
hereto as Exhibit B.
5. In response to a question raised by the Board of Appeals
as to the age of the existing structure as proof of its pre-
existing, nonconforming status, the Applicant cited the HDC r s
determination, as set forth upon an historical survey form in the
HDC's file, upon which the HDC based their approval in
Certificate of Appropriateness No. 40053, that the original date
of construction was about 1791, by one Obediah Folger.
6. Based upon this evidence of the age of the existing
dwelling, the fact that no portion of the proposed alterations to
the dwelling upon the Locus would be closer to the lot lines than
the existing dwelling, and the strong neighborhood support for
2
the project, the Board of Appeals, by UNANIMOUS vote, made the
findings that the existing dwelling is a pre-existing,
nonconforming structure, and that the proposed alterations would
not be substantially more detrimental to the neighborhood than
the pre-existing nonconformities of the structure, and
accordingly, by UNANIMOUS vote, GRANTED the requested relief by
SPECIAL PERMIT under Nantucket Zoning By-law ~139-33.A, 139-
33.A(5) and 139-33.E(2) (a), to permit the project as presented to
the Board, subject to the following conditions:
(a) The proposed work shall be performed In
substantial conformance with the plans approved by
the HDC under Certificate of Appropriateness No.
40053, as may be amended;
(b) The project shall be done in substantial
conformance with the plan done by Charles W. Hart
and Associates, Inc., a reduced copy of which is
attached hereto as Exhibit B.
(c) No exterior work related to this project shall be
performed during the period between June 1 and
September 15 in any year.
Dated: JU~'~' 2003
C. Richard
to- J ~
Edward J. Sanford
c:o
~
rr\ y
." 0- ...u
.-1
..- ()
- " z
.,
-l ,- ~
.-
=> .
~ QD
u.: ~. l-
CY.. C"'I
P
F,\WpK\Krogh\ZBA DEe.doc
3
<;;t
1
\..U
z
0-
~9
",0:
iii-
~.~
u.
ur
z
~1l
~:2
z-
~~
~t
uo:
~t:"t:
8~g~~
on
:l.C..
~~~i:
g~~J
::I2>'~O
~~~~~
3:ie:o:~
'~
i,e
~;:
~'!'
~~
V:l
"l
~ ~
~~l'.1..;
~.,-..::
se~ ~
~~<:::s "
-..::~~ ~
~~~ ~
~~~ ~
~ ~
l'.1..; ~
~
~
~
~
~~
~ ,....
<S'"
;:t;~~
~ ~~
~"'ili
"<: ~..
to.; ~::.
~~
~'"
~
~ l
~ tIi lI)
"i ~ l; ".
~ ti~ ~
~ ~~~o~~
~ -.:CI)~tri~< II
'!l1!"'''''~
~ ll.:l~~~ u
<!l Eo. <>: 0; '" :2
~g~~Q;-,,"
~ :i!.~tI)u~ ~
II ..: ~~i2"-e,:,
. .... '"
i i~ ~
u
~
-
-J,
.-fp
#<7p';
o~
<7
<>
z
~~~
~~ti
~ ~
:>
>'
\.
~.p-<?;.
<Y~s>
<Y.:
't.?~4-::
't.?.J
~
~
~
!:l
~ ~
~ ~ >-
~ ~ g
i i i
~ ~ ~
~ ~ ~
Q ~ :::::
t
! 1 ~
~
~r..;!;;
~r.;ts
~~~
[;1.,'"
~~~
~...""
"'!:l:::S
~~~
~~~
~~~
~~~
~ ~
,''''/'''
"
o
2 ~
~~~
~ :
0.:
<:5
~
~
=
~:
iSA
-~
~
t;l
'-'
~
.,
..;
.,
"
"-
~
~
Q
tl
~
'"
...
...
~
<Q
s
~~
~
~ ~t !t..
~ ~~ g~~
.~
j'
Il
i
";
~..
~'" p
t;~"
",60:
o"'~
~~~
'Z'z
~~~
'~
-
!f
= ~
~~u
:::i ~
:i
>'
_O.H.w.----
\,
:::
~ ~
l(
E
g
~
~
~
~ ~
~ ~
~ 111 ~
1;j 8 8
t:J t:J t:J
~ ~ ~
-J.
>.
~
~
i~
y'T
~;
:,~1
V:l
"l
;..... ~
~ 9.:
~~~
s::;~ ~ ~
G",<:::s ~
~~S'l ~
-..:: !:l ct: <>:
s::::.~ ~ ~
~!li<:::s ~
~~~
~ ~
~
~
~
V\
~
~
...f P 4/t
(/PQ
~c9"
<<?<p" <P;.
<Y<<? <.5'
<Y<P"..t;
"'V<P"J
,
1~
~
~,!;:i
~o;tJ
,:h~
~~f')
~~~
~,,'"
""t;j;S
~~~
~~~
~~~
~~8
.... ~
~
~
~~
~ ,."
~~
;:t;o.;",
t.S ....~
~ ;:;~
~ ~..
",-
r..;.......
~
~~
~'"
~
/'//
,.
o
~ ~
,"-
~~~
~ ..
...
~
~
.,
"i'"
'"
~'"
~..;
~,...
~~
"'~
~.
"f;J
~~
- ~
~
."
l
~
~
<-i..
~l; ;,;
ti"",~
oe:::.o
~:l:'; 2~
-.:"'~r,;~ ~ ·
l"1:l-':""Vl
" "''''
tl~::.!",u
04..... C\t-
E-o~<>:": :r:
51~~CO'~
:i!. tf)u~o::
0) ~'- 0
-~~~
"'.t ~
I
.:;j:
~
~
~
IS
::
[;j
~
~
.,
..;
~
"-
:>:
1Q
~
\:.1
ti
...
>.
~
TOWN OF NANTUCKET
ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS
1 EAST CHESTNUT STREET
NANTUCKET, MASSACHUSETTS 02554
PHONE 508-228-7215
FAX 508-228-7205
NOTICE
A Public Hearing of the NANTUCKET ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS will
be held at 1:00 P.M., FRIDAY, MAY 9, 2003, IN THE CONFERENCE ROOM,
TOWN ANNEX BUILDING, 37 Washington Street, Nantucket, Massachusetts, on the
Application of the following:
PETER F, KROGH, TRUSTEE OF THE MARTIN BOX TRUST,
BOARD OF APPEALS FILE NO. 036-03
Applicant is seeking relief by SPECIAL PERMIT under Nantucket Zoning By-
law Section 139-33A (alteration/expansion of a pre-existing nonconforming
structure/use), Applicant proposes construct a new basement under the single-family
dwelling. In addition, relief by SPECIAL PERMIT is sought under Nantucket Zoning
By-law Section 139-33E(2)(a), to allow the ground cover to be increased to about 1,085
square feet, for a ratio of about 48.6%, not exceeding the maximum ground cover ratio of
50% permitted in this zoning district, which would also entail incorporating an existing
shed into interior living space. Applicants also plan to expand the structure in an upward
direction within the required five-foot side and rear yard setback areas. None of the work
proposed would entail coming any closer to the lot lines than the existing structure.
The Premises is located at 16 BROADWAY, SIASCONSET, Assessor's Map
73.1.3, Parcel 114, with there being no plan of record, Deed Ref. 514/216. The property
is zoned Siasconset-Old-Historic,
N~~vre~la~M-
THIS NOTICE IS AVAILABLE IN LARGE PRINT OR OTHER
ALTERNATIVE FORMATS. PLEASE CALL 508-228-7215 FOR
FURTHER INFORMATION.
..... -.. 8
0::'- .--V
=e:- ~
2::: c:o
;0
(J ~
r
;-:-1 :.
;:0 ,. IJ
-
.-,. N
A
NANTUCKET ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS
1 EAST CHESTNUT STREET
NANTUCKET, MASSACHUSETTS 02554
CASE NO. 03 0-03
FEE: $300.00
APPLICATION FOR RELIEF
Owner's name(s): Peter F. Krogh, Trustee of The Martin Box Trust
Mailing address: c/o Reade, Gullicksen, Hanley & Gifford, LLP
Applicant's name(s): Same
Mailing address: 6 Young's Way, P. O. Box 2669, Nantucket, Massachusetts 02584
Locus address: 16 Broadway, Siasconset
Assessor's Map/Parcel: 73,1.3-114
Land Court Pia nIP Ian Book & Page/Plan File No.: No plan of record
Date lot acquired: 8/30/96 Deed Ref./Cert. of Title: 514-216
Uses on Lot - Commercial: None ~ Yes (describe)
Residential: Number of dwellings 1- Duplex_ Apartments
Lot No.:
Zoning District: SOH
Rental Rooms
Building Date(s): All pre-date 7/72? Yes or
Building Permit Nos:
Previous Zoning Board Application Nos.:
State below or on a separate addendum specific relief sought (Special Permit, Variance, Appeal), Section of
the Zoning By-law, and supporting details, grounds for grant of relief, listing any existing nonconformities:
C ofO(s)? No
SEE ATTACHED ADDENDUM.
I certify that the information contained herein is substantially complete and true to the best of my
knowledge, under the pains and ~enal~ies of p~ury.
SIGNATURE: (~/. (/~ L Applicant Attorney/Agent~
(If not owner or owner's attorney, please enclose proof of agency to bring this matter before the Board)
FOR ZBA OFFICE USE . /'
Application received on:!lC By: (~J Complete: V Need ~: Ale
Filed with Town Clerk:--t1 @Planning Board:-1.J~...? Building Dept.: il _ By: ({ao
Fee deposited with Town Treasurer:!::i-/IlJ,{)3By: fI/2<JJ Waiver requested?:_Granted:_/_/_
Hearing notice posted with Town Clerk:!i..8Id.3Mailed:.!j.JJ1;tJ31&M:!iI!:f/(J.:J& ~Llo~
Hearing(s) held on:~_I_ Opened on:~_I_ Continued to:_/_I_ Withdrawn?:_I_I_
DECISION DUE BY:_I_I_ Made:_I_I_ Filed wITown Clerk:_/~_ Mailed:_I_I_
DECISION APPEALED?: 1 1
SUPERIOR COURT:
LAND COURT
Form 4/03/03
F, \WpK\Krogh\ZBA APP ,doc
ADDENDUM TO APPLICATION
OF
PETER F. KROGH, TRUSTEE OF THE MARTIN BOX TRUST
The applicant requests relief by Special Permit under
Nantucket Zoning By-law ~139-33.A (alteration of pre-
existing nonconforming structure) in order to alter a
structure, pre-existing the adoption of the Zoning By-law,
portions of which are within the side and rear side yard
setback areas and which exceeds the applicable ground cover
ratio, upon a pre-existing, nonconforming lot of record.
The work, which has been approved under HDC Certificate of
Appropriateness No. 40053, includes placement of a new
basement foundation under the existing dwelling. The locus
is nonconforming as to lot size, having area of about 2,234
square feet, with minimum lot area in the Siasconset Old
Historic District being 5,000 square feet; frontage, with
frontage of about 43.3 feet on Center Street (from which
front yard setback is determined), and minimum frontage in
this district being 5 feet; as to northerly, side yard
setback, present setback being about 0.5 feet, and southerly
side yard setback, present setback being about 2.0 feet,
with minimum' side yard setback for this district being 5
feet; and ground cover ratio, having ground cover of about
996 square feet (a ratio of about 44.6%), with maximum
ground cover ratio for an undersized lot in this district
being 30%. The applicant also requests relief by Special
Permit under Zoning By-law ~139-33.E(2) (a), to allow ground
cover to be increased to about 1,085 square feet, for a
ratio of about 48.6%, not exceeding the 50% ground cover
ratio permitted in this zoning district.
1(}N\~ ~fw'c~ Uf2- wcv cV' cM-- ra-C,acY0 ~'\~
!!uAc/\1~a:i\dJ~- w/ ~. 5J- ~acfv. -70 UtI\(~()t7 a.Y:rJ
W:/JL ~ I;'lvd ~ uuhj )0:~~ c:1.L€ Cu~ wr--
(~ eU1'1 VO.r-&- >e J?Aa: (o'f-~ ~
"",.,,"~,,,", Mo',o ~KvJ ~9 ~crltA.Q ·
I I I I I EAST aEVATlON I
I" I I I
I I I II I
1 I II I I I
~============i : : : :
" II II
" II II
" II II
" ""
~=======================~~~~~~~~~~
L_..J L_...J L_..J
MOOEL ''S ARE BY
- - -MAltVIN
:). ~MNIIlCS
!II'!l"fle'INI!IA..,llDI."-'1!
ev.zII!P TO ,"",Ta< P""_
.... Tie' weL. -... ~
_TO ,"",Ta< P_
.~I'III_~.-e
eLAZS> TO ,"",TGM__
,
'r /
tp;
m
I 1 I I I ~lrrl-'11FFnI ~ I rEST aEVATlON I I
I 1 I I I ,If--f-H II-f-HIII I I
1 I I I I ,ILLLJI ILLLJI I I I I I
I I I I I I f~l roll 1 ~============rU-,
: : ::: L~ D';' ~;; ~J: 1 L J
" """
II "" II
" "" II
II """
~~=~~~=~~~~~~~~~~~======~========~
L_...J L_J L_..J L_..J
.
J
!
-~
. ...r..
I
t
1
I I
~ I
f\o'It .....
. ... ~.c'
e..t
. .........,.
-~
. ....... .
Pnt I'br
. fA.".q -
~
e..t
. ...~...,.
.., ...
~!
is Ii
~ tJ -~
9 ~ ~~
8 ~ ~~
~ ~ fz
~ ~ J~
o !.:!
~ J
..,
...-
e
.:&:i
~
'x
LU
~
-o-a
.n
~
-
-o-a
~
o
LU
D* 212m
- ""o('.c'
-...
IIg
~...
-
A2.1
N 97000.
ji2"
o I
8
,.:
"
::;.
n."""
12f
~4.Y
I
I
r---
I
I
I
44'~
~~.\
'1..::-
.
.
..
"
41
o
o
o
...
"
'"
",I
~,~,
~.
-.+=
r i
I INFORMATION SHOWN HEREON WAS
I COMPilED fROM AERIAL PHOTOGRAPHS. DfEDS.
AND PLANS OF RECORD AND IS NOT TO BE
CONSTRuED AS H....VING SUfFICIENT ACCUR-
ACY FOR CONVEYANCE
~;;;;;;r.it~mllll,TK
IOCMUfII,N.Y,
Tlw To\\' 1I It lid COIIII
NANrrUC;
:\ll t ~~It l' llll~ptts
214
80 0 t~ 6'::'
f."it"~~ ~:--.
10 ""'r",,S<nl.
/<f\~@~-
Town OfNa~cket
ZONING BOARD 0
RECEIVED
BOARD OF ASSESSORS
MAR 3 1 2003
TOWN OF
NANTUCKET, MA
LIST OF PARTIES IN INTEREST IN THE MATTER OF THE PETITION OF
PROPER TV OWNER.. .Yc..\q:..... ~X 9. tJ '0..................................
MAILING ADDRESS...... ...... ...... ......... ...... ...... ....................0.0. ........ "
PROPERTY LdcATION..l.4>.l$X:9.~Q.~.I.~.~...........~ ·
A.SSESSORS MAPIP ARCEL.. .J.? .t3.~...l. 1.1,. .'i..... .l.7.~.~.?~J ~,~.,)
APPLJCAN~~~~I.. ~~W. ~ ~.L.. ,t@.r.l.~,., .{. {3. .'~ ffi.'(q I. ~LP
SEE ATTACHED PAGES
I certify that the foregoing is a list of persons who are owners of abutting property, owners of
land directly opposite on any public or private street or way; and abutters of the abutters and all
other landJ)wners within 300 feet of the property line of owner's property, all as they appear on
the most recent applicable tax list (M.G.L. c. 40A, Section 11 Zoning Code Chapter 139, '
Section 139-29D (2) ,
..~ ..8. t ~(fy3.....
OAT .
a
o
....
..
.. ... ...
.s t; t; en en
e e e e
~ :i :i a a
.. Ol Ol
.. ... '"
.. ... ...
...
tIl
...
tIl
... ...
~ 1;; 1;; Ii; 1;; tIl '"
1;; ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 33...
~ ~ e M H H H W 0 en
~ ~ ~ i i i i e e ~
., 0: 0:
~ N N ~ ~ M ~ ~
~
o
'"
,
~ . ~ 0 ~ ~ " ~ 0 ~ ~ ... ~ . 0 0 . . .. ~ ~
M " ~ ~ ~ . ~ ~ m ~ 0 ~ ('II ~ ('II ('II ~ ~ ~ M M
~ ... .-4 ~ m ~ . 0 ~ ~ 0 ~ " 0 ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 0
"" \ONNr-4NNNC'\IOONQ)ONlr-t'l""4NNlNN....
N 0000.....000.-4('40\0.-40000000("00
... 1;; ~
; ~ ~
< ~ ~
Ol .. Ol
r- r-
~
H
>0 tIl
~ 0:
!il .,
~ 5
Ol u
li!
~
..
...
01 f-l = f-l
~ i ~
...
'"
1;; ... ~
g en ~
~ ~ u
~ ~ ~
'"
...
li! li!
~ ~
.. ..
tI:I II: E-c f-l
ItQ cn CQ CQ f-l
i i ~ ~ ~
Ol
'" .. r-4 l""l
N N .-t rot
>0 >0 3 t: t: t:
... 0< .. .. .. 0< '"
; ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ = a a a
o ~ a ~ a ~ t 3 3 3
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ goo 0
~ ~ ~ ~ u ~ ~ ~
,., ,.,
,., ,.,
.. ..
III III
'" '"
...
...
'"
...
,
. .. . ... .. r-4 ~ 0 Q) ('II l' .. .. ('II 0
M ~ ('II 0 '" l' '" ('II r-t 0 0 ~ Q) 0 '1""4
.. ~ .... .... ~ r-4 0 .... r-4 ~ Q) ~ ~ ('II ....
rot ('II rot M ('II ('II m rot .... r-4 '" ('II ('II Q) ~
M 0 ~ MOO r-4 0 ..,. 0 0 0 0 ('II rot
....
...
Ii; t: ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ g ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ t: ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
0:
o
..
'"
ti =
li! ~ 1;;
o z 8 .,
t'~~~~
~ @g~~
t!I
Z
~~
00
H
..:IE-<
r:a::l
0011<:
It:u
r:a::lD
~~
lXlZ
~
ti
=
1;; ~
H
Z 0:
~ ~
:il 1;; Z 0
i = : ~ a
: 85~:cn
.. Ol '"
'tS .... II( 0....
~ ;:~~t;!;
!
Z
..
,
..
i
I
o
U
.,
.,
i ~
Z .,
t!I
.
, Z
.. H
. ...
~ e
..
....
a
o
...
.,
~ ~
~ ~
..
0<
H
::: !: ra1
H H
... ...
,., '"
., H
~ e
Ol ~
., Ol
~ ~
H .,
.. ,.,
...
..
~
...
'"
Ii!
...
.,
.,
Z
H
:E:
fil
0<
...
~
e., ti
:i ~ ,., ~
CD ~ ~ 0
..: = u
~ 8 0: ~
~ ill fil ~
Z
o
!;
Z Z
l;l ~
E a 2
...
~
ti
... I I I : ~
a 5 N ~ ~ t; :: a
51 lil ~ ~ = ~ ~ ...
H~..~..So<g'!l
,., ~ lil Ol ., :: - j;l
0< '"
N 0\ 0 ,., 0
....t r-4 Pol r-- '"
0:
...
...
'"
o
0:
...
:E:
fil
...
'"
ti
~
i5 '"
'" ~
e H
~ ~
.. >0
oJ ~
~ 0
'" ,
H U
:E:
u ~ s
Z H
H ., Z
~ ~ ~
Z 8
ti ~ .,
'" t!I
Z '" 0:
~ ~ ~
:3 ~~~~~~~~~
...
u
o
...
Ol
e
:i
~
.,
t:
H
..
...
'"
...
o
'"
N
,
N ...
o 0
N N
., N
N N
N ...
'" ... ...
o
'"
r-
...
N ... ... ..,. .... 0'\ 0
o \D II) \D \D \Q M
0\ r.n it'l 11'1 II) .... r--
\D N N N N M rot
o 0 0 0 0 M 0
<1!
'"
'"
'"
... ...
'" tIl
ti ti ti ti ., t e t
~ ~ ~ ~ 8 Z ~ ~ :i ~
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ i ~ i ~ ~ i ~ ~
'" 0< 0< '" '" '" ~ III ~ Z 8 .. '" 0
~
H
0:
'"
ei .:
~ ~ ... ~
e a li! ~ ~ ~ =..
~ ~ ~ .. ~ ~ t ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
: : ~ ~ l;l ; ~ g ~ : ~ ~
lil lil Ol r-' i '" r lil 8 '"
o ~ 0 0 ~ N ~ ~
o 0 0 ~ ~ N " N 0 ~ ~
~ ~ ~ N ~ ~ ~ " " ~ " ~
~
0:
t t ., ~ ., zit ti ti t 0<
= Ol ~ ~ ~ e ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 1;; ~
l ; ~ ~ i a i ; = ~ a ~ a a I ~
51
S
... t ;
i ~ 0
i =;: ~
o O! 0 ~ ~ ...
~ 8 ~ * a ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ .
'" X N ... ..: ~ H ... !il'" = ~
~ ; ~ a ~ : ~ ~ E ~
o " " ~ 0 ~ 0 0 " ~
~ N " N ~ " ~ ~ " M
~
~ ~
o ~
'" I I
~ i:i i:i
Ol
"r-4 \0 \D
0\ rot It'I 0 ... ..
f"o In .... Po. r-t ....
i
III
0:
.,
..
..
H
Z
o
,
U
t
~
I ~ ~
., >0 ~
BE'"
:E: Ol z
o 0
~ ~ ~
Ol '" U
!il !il
~ ~
...
0:
0:
...
:E:
0: fil
.,
~ t
i !
H
., ..:
is t;
0< t!I
Ol H
'" .,
'"
0:
...
., t
., .,
~ ~
:E: ..
e ~ ~
: ! I
~ j l;1
.1 '" ..
~ \ ., l'l ~ ~
H!!'i E t = :E:
~ "~; B,., ~ ~ ~ ~
"E't::>~..t lIl..lil~
0< .. ~ E : ~ ~ ~ ~ 8 ~ : 8
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ i i : : i o~'" s
w ~ H H ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ u ~
.. .. ~ oJ ~ H H ~ ~ ~
~ ~ >0 Ol z z t t Ol z
~ ~ ~ w g g ~ w U w
i ~ ~H : ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~o ~ e
~ ~ t!I g S 0 0 ~ ~ .. ~ ~
N N
'" '"
C""'l .... If) r-- r-- CD
M ,.., M M M M
~ ~ ~
~ 5 E
~ ~ 0
'"
N
N
...
1;; ~ I ~
g ~ ; ~ ::;
'" >0 :'.l ~ '"
S ~ H :;l .. ..
Ol ... Z 1;; lil lil
'" '" '"
r-- 1"'4 0 MOO
It'! M 1""4 M Ct CL.
:l!
8
t
0:
.,
,.,
o
,
u
...
'"
o
0:
...
~ ~
0: ~
~ ~
: i
'" 0
H ~
..
'" 0
0'
U U
...
Ol
..
.. 0
Ol
'"
o 0
'" ..
~
~
o
., ...
t: ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
~
~
~
H
:E:
o
,
U
~
...
~
..
.. Ol i:l !i1
~ a g ~ I E
~ z ~ ., :;l ~
:! 14 ,., t!I ..
10 ~ ::: '" i5 a
t = ~ 8 =
At a: 5Q P:; t.:)
I ~ !
.. u ~
'" ~ ..
~ .. '"
~ .. s
~ ~ f
lil ~ ~ ~
8 ~ ~ 0
~ fil ~ ~
.,
.,
...
'"
~ \II .. H
... H
.. .. H
.. 0<
'" ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ :> .,
o H 0 ,., ~ ,., ~ u
0: ~ ::1 ~::1 lil
~ ~ ~ Z ~ Z : ~
.. 0: :! i5 z i5 ,., p
~ ., 8 ~ t; ~ ~ ;;l
~ ~ lil ~ ~ ~ ~ :
~
H
0:
'"
..
j
,., !il
~ ~
...
Ol
Ii!
...
.,
.,
Z
H
:E:
fil
,.,
..:
Ol
a
.. ~
~ ~
0:
~ s
I :
~ ~
., z
~ 8
'" 0<
,., ~
~ ..
~ ~ ; ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ; ~ : ~ : ~ : : ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ; ~
.-<
'"
III 0:
~ ..
'" 0<
tl lil
,., H
~ ~
g ~ ~
.. t ..
'" ~
~
t
..
Ol
~
.,
z .,
o ...
Ol '"
z Ii!
E ,., ~ ... ...
::l 0< z 0< ..:
~ H Z H ~
lil ~ ~ ~ ~
~ z ~ z Ol
~ ~ ~ ~ 8
'" !i1 ~ ~ S
<Xl
N
o
o
N
.......
C""'l M M M M M M M C""'l M M M M M M M M M M M M M M M M M M M M M M M M M M M M M M M M M M M M M 00
~ r-4 r-t rot r-t rot r-4 rot .... rot r-t r-t .... .... rot .... .... .... rot .... 1""4 r-4 1""4 r-t rot 1""4 r-t 1""4 r-t .... 1""4 rot r-t 1""4 1""4 1""4 1""4 1""4 r-t .... 1""4 r-4 r-t r-t .... r-t p~
~ ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~::!~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~:;-
~
o
...
~ t
oS ::!
OJ
'il S
u 0
.. ..
.
..
E-t E-t E-t E-t E-4
tf.I tf.l D] (f.I tf.I
f< f< f<
tI) tI) tI)
::! ::! ::! ::! ::1
H H H H H
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ t ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ tf.I tf.I tf.l tf.I ~ ~ ~ ~
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ i i i i i ~ ~ ~ ~
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ u u u u u ~ ~ m m
~ ~ ~
~ ~ ~
~ ~ ~
"' "' "'
~ ~
~ ~
~ ~
"' "'
f<
tI)
f< f< f<
H H H en tf.l l:Il H
H H H H
~ = = ~ ~ i =
g) tf.I 02 H H H tt.:l
'" '" '"
~~~~M~~~M"M~ON~_O.~M"~~~~OON 0
N N N N N N M M ..-4 " " " .-4 " " " N N N N N ..-4 .-4 " ..-4 N N N ~ N N ~ ~ " ~ .-4
f<
tI) ::!
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ E-t E-t
~ ~ m ~ ~ ~ tf.I tf.I
~ ~ = i ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
aumm..m:i
'" 0 '"
.. '" ..
~ ~ : : ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ : ~ ~ :
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 00 ~ 0 ~ ~ ~ m m ~ ~ N .-4 ~
.... \DONNONO\DMOOOr-tN..NN
N 0r-400N0.-40M....tNNOO..OO
'"
o
'"
on
.. 0
o ..
on '"
'" ..
'" '"
~ m M \D \D .. NO"
: ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ : ~
M \D 0 M N N \D \D N
M 0 \D N 0 0 0 0 0
.
o
'"
'"
on '" '"
r- .. ..
'" 0 '"
'" 0 0
0....'"
~ t ~ ~ ~ ~ t t ~ ~ ~ ~
5
O'i
"'
f<
0< OJ
~ ~ tJ
li Q ~
~ ::l =
t; t~~~~~~t~~~~~~i!l~~~~
OJ tl tl
Q tI) tI)
H ~ = = u
::l = 8 8 ~
E ~ ~ 33 ~
u a: ~ tf.I CI) Po.
Cl
Z
~~
tIl
H
HE-<
ril
tIllo<:
!l::U
rilP
~~
l%lZ
~
...
f< ...
tI) H
..
: ~ ~
. OJ 0
~ ~ =
~
.
~
=
.
I
..
i
I
o
U
I i ~
z i I
. ~
! ~ ~
.,
...
g
'"
~
~
o
0:
'"
~
"
OJ
... f<
.. '" tI)
U"I Il'l p,. \0
~ ~ E ~ ~
H H >< II
g ~ g g
GO '"
000 0 t"I
p,. Pol r-4 l200 N
tl ::l
tJ 0
~ ~
= E
tI)
...
0< ...
~ :il t.1 '"
~ 8 :il ~
",0<0
8 ~ ~ ~
:c p,. m ~
f<
OJ OJ
... tI)
... ~ =
~ S 8 iH;
tJ "' ::! ~ f<
~ ~ :ndl
tl OJ =
tJ ~ ~
I ~ ~
~ ~
OJ tI)
~ ~
~ ~
'" f<
i I
i ~
~ ~ ~ tl ::l ~
i ~ 8 ~ ~ gJ
e ! 3 a ! E
~ i tf.l p,. i m
OJ
~
= t
t.1 =
::! t; ~
.. .
~ i g
'" '" 0
'" '" ..
..
:il '"
f<
t1 ::!
~
a t; t
..
.. r; !O
! : 1 !
.... .... '"
'" '" ....
rl .. .. m \D ~ ~ .. .. .. 0 .. ..
; ~ ~ ~ 8 : : ~ ~ ~ : ~ ~
" N N m 0 .-4 ....t N N N ~ N N
MOO r-t N 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
~ ~ ~ ~ g ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
t t
.. tI) tI) OJ
0< = = ..
~ 8 8 fil
~ 3 3 !
en to V) i
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ t
=;;8=8=tJ~
t.1 ~ ~ ::! ::! ~ ~
~ ~ ~ :;: :;: = g
Q)
'"
'"
'"
f<
'" ~
5 ~
:i ~
"' 0:
"'
f<
f< tI)
'"
tI)
::! ;'i
H tI)
tI)
E E
o
....
o '"
.... ....
t
~
~ ~ f< ~ ~
~ 0 : t; t; ~
~ i ~ e e ;
~ .... Z r- r- 8
~ .... U'l 0 0 :z;
co 0 .... ... H
r-- N t"'\ ..-4 .-4 ..:A
f<
tI)
lil
f<
..,
..
..
'"
tI)
o
..,
"' ~
'" 0:
U
~ g
~ ~
0: ...
f< 0
= ~ Q a
;"' ~ lzeei5
~ ~ z ~ .. 8,.~.g 8 : E
~ ~ ~ ~ i ~ ; : : ~ i ~
g g ~ ~ ; ~ ~ ~ e e ~ ~
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ E : : s i
E E a ~ ~ ~ ~ i 8 8 ~ ~
OJ
~
...
~
:il
r;
0: f<
'" ~ tI)
: a I
lil ~
o
..
~
~
0:
'" ~ a ~ ~ s ~
\D H O~ ~
~ ~ 3 8 ~ · i ~ ~
: : ~ ~ g ~ ~ ~ ~ :
g g ~ 0 ~ ~ ~ U'l ~
o 0\ CD ..-4 N co ..:A
o 0 co N .-I 0 ~ \D m
~ ~ .... ..-4 .-4 M M .-I "
f<
tI)
lil
f<
~
~
..
0:
OJ
~
~
0:
f<
H
=
..
... ~
OJ OJ OJ
II! f< '"
..:;] ~ t;
z t liJ
.. X >t IQ " f-4
""'i a a i = · ; ~ ~
~ !:i 0: "' ~... 0:
H 0 OJ ~11: tl ~ 2
= : ~ ~ t; 8 ~ tI) :
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ = ~ "' "'
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ t; e e
~ ~
'" 0:
~ :J ~ OJ ..
0: ~ ~ ~ ~
~ co ~ ~ g g N
· ~ t ~ e e :
~ ~ ~ s s ~
CEll lEa N .-I U l' III
.... '"
o 0 M f"'l r-- r-- 0
~ "'- \0 .... .-t ..-4 ~
0:
f<
tl
..
o
l::
~
0:
=
o
H
~
f<
tI)
f< f<
tI) tI)
lil lil
f< f<
OJ ..
tI) tI)
I:J I:J
fil fil
0: 0:
! !
~ ~
o 0
t ti
tI) tI)
= =
8 8
::! ::!
H H
tI) tI)
~~
0: 0
Q 0:
f< ~
.-4 8 = ~ ~
i ~ I r- '"
o
..
'" .
'" '"
>< ><
o 0
"' "'
o 0
.. ..
..
....
'" GO
r- '"
f<
tI)
lil
f<
o
u
..
t; ~
lil tl
f< ~
~ ~
...
!O ..
~ ~
.. u
0:
OJ
H
...
~
OJ =
~ 0 a
::! ~
~ ~ I ~
ci ... ~ z ~
~a~~~
t
tJ
I
t
tI)
=
8
::!
H
tI)
r;
H
Z
tI)
~
8
=
H
0:
..
..
5
o
--
u
f<
0:
OJ =
5 S
H
i'1 g
H .,
Z tI)
'" .. -<
~ = ~
8 H H
: ~ B
t
~ ~ ~
~ :; ~
.. .. H
0: tI) tI)
~ :
....
Q
i .. ~
,.. 0: ~ ~
~ E ~ tI) ~ .. 5 t ~ ...
~ ~ ~ ~ s s ~ ~ ~.. a
~.., g ~ '" g OJ r; ~ f< OJ ~ ..
.. H .. .. Q ~ Q Z ~ ~
~ ; ~ e a = ft 2 ~ g ~
0: t ~ ... ~ g ~ ~ 9 ~ 2
8.. 0: ~ o::! w ~ "
~ ~ ~ i ~ ~ ~ ~ I ~ ~
"
..
~
~
H
...
.. ...
H
tl a lS ..
-< .. ..
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ tI) .. ~
~ I:J 0< * 0< 0< .. ~ ~
: ~ i i I ~ ~ ; ~
P! i! ~.. ~ l:: ~
5 '" ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ e
~ ~ g ! ~ ~ ~ : :
~
...
:il
tI)
S N,.,..,.U'l\Dr--COO\O.-tNM....U'lr--ClOO\g~~~~~:g6~~~:::~~~~~~ OCOIl)\D:E
co co co co co co co co 0\ 0\ 0\ 0\ 0\ 0\ 0\ 0\ 0\ .... .-t .-4 .... .-t .-t .-4 .-t .... .-4 .... .-t .-4 .-l .-t .-t .-t .... .-4 N M .... ~ r-- co .-t M .-4 .-4 ~
r<
U)
...
u
.'l
"'
<D
N
o
o
N
'-
~ ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~::
~ r-- r-- r-- r-- r-- r-- r-- r-- r-- r-- r-- r-- r-- r-- r-- r-- r-- r-- ~ r-- r-- r-- r-- r-- r-- r-- r-- r-- r-- r-- r-- r-- r-- r-- r-- r-- r-- r-- r-- r-- r-- r-- r-- r-- r-- r-- ~