The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About035-03 TOWN OF NANTUCKET BOARD OF APPEALS NANTUCKET, MASSACHUSETTS 02554 Date: June /(p ,2002 To: Parties in Interest and, others concerned with the Decision of the BOARD OF APPEALS in the Application of the following: Application No.: & ~oCJJf:n I Enclosed is the Decision of the BOARD OF APPEALS which has this day been filed in the office of the Nantucket Town Clerk. An Appeal from this Decision may be taken pursuant to Section 17 of Chapter 40A, Massachusetts General Laws. Any' action appealing the Decision must be brought by filing an complaint in court within TWENTY (20) days after this day's date. Notice of the action with a copy of the complaint and certified copy of the Decision must be given to the Town Clerk so as to be received within such TWENTY (20) days. \ , \' , d \.t.) -n ;t'I~t ~~- i Co- , 2 'I - Cj 0'\ rr -0 ~~ ..... N ~ N ~ cc: Town Clerk Planning Board Building Commissioner PLEASE NOTE: MOST SPECIAL PERMITS AND VARIANCES HAVE A TIME LIMIT AND WILL EXPIRE IF NOT ACTED UPON ACCORDING' TO NANTUCKET ZONING BY-LAW ~139-30I (SPECIAL PERMITS); ~139-32I (VARIANCES) , ANY QUESTIONS, PLEASE CALL THE NANTUCKET ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS. TOWN OF NANTUCKET ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS 1 EAST CHESTNUT STREET NANTUCKET, MASSACHUSETTS 02554 Assessors Map 55 Parcel 4 R-l 23 West York Street LC Plan 13302-0, Lot 12 LC Plan 13302-H, Lot 13 Cert. of Title 20,234 At a Public Hearing of the Nantucket Zoning Board of Appeals, held at 1:00 P.M., Friday, April 11, 2003, in the Conference Room, Town Annex Building, 37 Washington Street, Nantucket, Massachusetts, on the Application of L YDLE L. AND ROWENA E. RICKARD, of PO Box 757, Nantucket, MA 02554, Board of Appeals File No. 035-03, the Board made the following Decision: 1. Applicants are seeking relief by SPECIAL PERMIT under Nantucket Zoning By- law Section l39-33A (alteration/expansion of a pre-existing nonconforming structure/use). Applicants propose to construct a dormer onto an existing nonconforming garage structure that is sited as close as about 1.97 feet from the southwesterly side yard setback area in a district that requires a minimum side yard setback of ten feet. The dormer would come no closer to the lot line than the existing structure. Applicants also propose to add studi%ffice space in the second floor area. There would be no expansion of the footprint or ground cover ratio. In addition, the Locus is nonconforming as to side yard setback with a separate ancillary structure also being sited as close as about 2.16 feet from the same lot line. See also BOA File No. 001-97. The Premises is located at 12 POLPIS ROAD, Assessor's Map 54, Parcel 183, Land Court Plan 10937-B, Lots 13-16. The property is zoned Limited-Use-Oeneral-l. 2. The Decision is based upon the Application and the material submitted with it and the testimony and evidence presented at the Hearing. The Planning Board made no recommendation finding that the matter did not present any issues of planning concern. There were no letters on file. 3. The Applicants, through their representative, stated that they proposed to renovate an existing garage structure that was sited as close as about 1.97 feet from the southwesterly side yard lot line, by adding a dormer to the front of the structure to provide more second floor space for an office/studio use. There would be no further encroachment upon the required ten-foot southwesterly side setback area and no change in the footprint of the structure. The garage use would be maintained on the first floor and there would be no human habitation of the structure. Applicants stated that the garage had existed in its present location at the time the Applicants purchased the property before 1978. It had been moved there from another location in the mid-1950's, which was a time prior to the 1972 enactment of the Nantucket Zoning By-law and thus grandfathered. Previous relief by Special Permit was granted in the Decision in BOA File No. 001-97, which allowed demolition and reconstruction of a separate garage structure and the addition of the second floor apartment. 4. Based upon the foregoing, the Board finds that the conversion of second floor space to office/studio use and the addition of the small second floor dormer on the front of the garage structure would be an increase in the massing in the setback area, but said increase would not be substantially more detrimental to the neighborhood than the existing nonconforming structure. The Board further finds that there would be minimal impact on the neighborhood as the side yard setback intrusion would not be increased, the footprint would not be altered and there would be no human habitation of the structure. 5. Accordingly, by a UNANIMOUS VOTE, the Board GRANTS the requested relief by SPECIAL PERMIT under Nantucket Zoning By-law Section 139-33A to allow the conversion of second floor space to office/studio use and the construction of the second floor dormer on the front of the garage structure based upon the following conditions: a. The project shall be done in substantial conformance with the Certificate of Appropriateness No. 41,126, issued by the Nantucket Historic District Commission, as may be amended; and b. There shall be no human habitation of the structure. ~ \ 1q s / / .I / TOWN OF NANTUCKET ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS 1 EAST CHESTNUT STREET NANTUCKET, MASSACHUSETTS 02554 PHONE 508-228-7215 FAX 508-228-7205 NOTICE A Public Hearing of the NANTUCKET ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS will be held at 1:00 P.M., FRIDAY, MAY 9, 2003, IN THE CONFERENCE ROOM, TOWN ANNEX BUILDING, 37 Washington Street, Nantucket, Massachusetts, on the Application of the following: L YDLE L. AND ROWENA E. RICKARD BOARD OF APPEALS FILE NO. 035-03 Applicants are seeking relief by SPECIAL PERMIT under Nantucket Zoning By- law Section 139-33A (alteration/expansion of a pre-existing nonconforming structure/use). Applicants propose to construct a dormer onto an existing nonconforming garage structure that is sited as close as about 1.97 feet from the southwesterly side yard setback area in a district that requires a minimum side yard setback of ten feet. The dormer would come no closer to the lot line than the existing structure. Applicants also propose to add studi%ffice space in the second floor area. There would be no expansion of the footprint or ground cover ratio. In addition, the Locus is nonconforming as to side yard setback with a separate ancillary structure also being sited as close as about 2.16 feet from the same lot line. See also BOA File No. 001-97. The Premises is located at 12 POLPIS ROAD, Assessor's Map 54, Parcel 183, Land Court Plan 10937-B, Lots 13-16. The property is zoned Limited-Use-General-l. THIS NOTICE IS A V AILABLE IN LARGE PRINT OR OTHER ALTERNATIVE FORMATS. PLEASE CALL 508-228-7215 FOR FURTHER INFORMATION. Nanr:?:s~, ~~ 4A/2 --i...". c:;:) ""'- ~> "'" -- :Z:~ C-~; r r.-;- d w "! --"'~) :J::> co ::::0 N N .""1 ~ - -0 N A A '~'SoA lon! J.-8~ J I', . ,', ..... .. mw~OCICE~ ZO~n:G S~ ~::"'~G~2AL6 Dl:I.te ~OW Ul), CO~~':l: lJ..X_... muwtl'CD~, HJ\ 0255"' CASB ~0(J3r'" ~ :;~ ,0;""'0. n~(.) I ~re. ~ Cl~ R~~~_{;l'CLa~s-J"' f. 'H&U~q a~eG6H _.-: &OX:; 7_ _ ,__C'-__Jr1* Y' ,':' lp~1cl:I.nt '15 na:me; r .(' r1. N'l\.e.) / . ' ~~ l:I.Clcb:ess; ( r ~ J ' _ " Lo~t1on 0: lot; AsS4iUllifPt"' 'S llll:l.p l:I.nI! Pl:l.t"Ool, nWl1bot" s:.:i _ / 'R3 ,SQI..t a~us; /2- fib 'f/!> . ACJadJ ~1att":f JAncl.ct '~ll:l.n, f'~~ :<i~{::0t" ~lan ,Uo (093 ")-a ~'t~6 . ~ . ", DltG 3..o'tf ao~1t"oCl.; .J.J _ LJ.I () <ld Zon1n~ I c11sb'10't L ocr. ~, , u~u on'lot -' .co.et"o1l:1.l;' ~one i(. ot" HCD?_ . . . .. nUlllbc- ot; dweU1n~s~ dupJ.e~_ ~pat"b.ents_ t"ental roolllS_ S\l11.cl1n;'e1ate(a); l:I.U pn-8/72? ~ or , C o~ O?_ au11.d1n; Perm1t applln. Nos. CUo Noa. all. 201\. ~ppJ.1oat1ons, lawau1ta; c:b _. 'Itate ::uUy aU ;:;on1n~ :;,eU.: .OUt!JAt &n4 ~eapeo* COde .eo't1on8 1M .~.eot10u, .p$O~nO&lly wAat you );l~opoa. E~ 'to p~.f,nt . , QIJ wn't tpQunda YOU U=fJe :o~ BoA to _lee .a. tfJ Re~ S.o.....on . U''':su. _ ~~LVu~anoe, 13'-~OA _ tt a Speo1al>> . t -C&n4 139-331'. 1: to al't.. 0:1: ~.nd l:I. nonoo~o~ ~8). :l:t &);11.'..1 P" 13$1-321'. 'r. ...: , a't't&on t:l.o1.!.on o~ o~cl.i~, appnlecl. ox 'to ~t'taob adc1.n@~. \t., . ~~ ~~ '~{2Q.O by' ~ @C:LtA .{:eClYT em. (39-/3~r;J {~ ~C9cQ , C>cr0rY-d aM~E f1:J?'t~/l1/Ac; 9~~ . 3 ~qJ &1.){~~ IO~t'~'ch't/:J'~Ct.~~ (JAJo.... "yVJ) ~ wcuid2 Mt'\!) N .~ ~ '~hO~dl ' J ~~~(''f'u..A.fL ~ CA)oJfdj fas{ /leJ .Q'8?0JV..0-'O?t. v ';'7 (!ov-e~, ~~CM9-a..QpO(]^~.r~~ acP&. 3~&~~ ~Ok- . ~ ~ ('ClI't~ ~~~. ! ' %:~ ~~o..~ a. pa~t ot tb1. 'App11oat10n: 0~4a~1 a~~.n~U1ll2____ . 6NOua 1A~ stt. plan ahow1hg pt'8&ent +plannec! atruotures , . ti.OUn>>l~);l~.a.nt:--f PS:oPo,,~ .18'Va't1OM ~(~m~OVoCl.?_), A!lo,o,!g;'o~fit:nc1~:~~'mt .:~:~~ 1 foJ.lag3 ~:;t.-- . t- ..It >>":.ru,l. to "own of HqtuClk,t ~O~~ oap' oovenant - , .C:t In ..,p...l, a.~ ':own Oh~~ .to ..nnl!i Com'fT'l ~.oo~4 to loA7I % o.n1ty tAat tAe reqJJested 1nto~t10n sumdtted 15 sub5tl:1.nt1l:1.11y . OQQ~.t. ancl true to the b.at ot m:f knowleclge, un~e~ the pains anc1 'PIM..tL.. of p. :S%GNA~UU: ~ppl~oant _ Attotnay/iqan~ ~ : ~,:: no~ own. n.~'. &tto~.YI enolo.. p~oot ot autbo~1ty) ""- lOR 801'. 0":1:<2 US~ ...... 1 """ \ ~pl1cAt1on cop1as teo1d: 4___ O~___ :~~~ O~~bY~ on~ oop :u.a w1th ~own CJ.et'~ on1:/!~b'l..Lt.2ul... OO'lP-P'J.e.t.f:4JJcP('~ . OA. oopy eaon to PJ.ann1nq 8c1 anc1 8uUcS1n; .~~ ~ 't>y.ii2Jj) " I " taoo t.. oh.o~ g.i.ven _ ;0& 't'.!.eaaut'e~ O~J!Jt!:jbY~ wa1vec11_' .~1n; not1ce po~tec1~llll:l.1h&~:t & H!P~, ~ h~ ;...K'a,:1n;Ca) .On...../-I_ oont',) to-l....l_, ....1-1_ w1th\!~awn7.J.J_' .... , Deo111on due ,'r;Y-I-I_ 'm'4\!e-l-l_ ttlecl 't'O-l..../ _ uU.V -I ~ 8.1 ~.ht,~ .QU" . bWIU~tl' . othet .. - ....- ...... - I ~~~LYO~TrON YOR RBLYBY ..--_... ........ au I .. .. .. ,.. . .......... ............ ......... Apr 03 03 11:24a rex in(;ram 508.825.2132 F. 1 I n 9 r a m 0 e s 9 n VIA FACSIMILE To: Linda Williams Fax: ~ . t ~ . -:r-z,'1q, From: Rex Ingram Date: 4.03.03 RE: Rickard We are sending 1 page(s) including 1f1is cover sheet. If you do not receive all the pages please call (508.325.44821. Unda, .. I've reviewed the project with Lydie Rickard, Including our planned submission to the ZBA. He's Informed me that the garage was existing at the time of purchasing the property (purchased before 1978), His best guess for the placement of the garage or; the property (apparently it was moved from anotrler location) was 1950s. I've asked Lydie to fax to me a note authorizing me to act as his agent. As soon as I receive it from him I will deliver it to you with an application fee of $300. I understand that our hearing date will be on May 9. Thanks for your help. Reg~ Rex 'f-. 64 Old South Road, NCI'ltucket, MA 02554 p. 508.325.4482/ f 508825.2132 e. arcking@attbi.com www.lngramArchitecture.com \ i ~~ 4. ~ , .' 'I ~ \~ ~ \\ >? , . ... I \~; g .5 C") ~ I ,..... . ~ ~I ~I ~I I ~l ~I ~ I ~ 1 liS of title m8Y he issued ~ B' shown r~ to d~aef.l.:l{,t. t ~ Racordcr. I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I \ I I I l~ I~ I~ I~ I~ I .1 I I I Lb. ~ 101) 100 ~, 100 'it." c, ~~~6. . ~ ~~ " Jon, -" , :;:; 7. ~ \ ..... 24. ~ ~ ~ 10f) ~ o "-T\ --. C).) -:;:) -=- 23. [~ ~o lOll -:;::, ,- ~ - -? "" ,.J .;~ en -::=. -' -'C' -:::f' . \ :.J :. . . - 1- _ --- - ~ :"..-/' .-. - .~ -- ---~_--I ..,-- -..--, .-.....--...------ , , , .. . '. ,'~' . .~ ; L e . .. o W ::> 00 00 W <ll .- ~.E o z W .- <{ Q LL i= II: W () ~~ ~ cu c: c: enQ) ~ t5 Q; ::J <{Qi U 0) "- u ~>.O +-.0 _ '0 '0'0 0 LOQ)2 iU 0)"- CU ~ C') 1? .g E (j)t:e ,g -CUO) ~ g-o.u UJ ~cu- UQ) 0 .so (j)~ ~ 00 -g E ~ ';: J: ::J"O ~ ~S ~~.!!l .E~ ~6 ~ ::e'" <<i ~ a. .t: -g 'g)~ .~ '-3 00. >. ~~CD "-a. cu ~ z~> :5:: E 0) "0 (.) CD <{.;:: c: rn "'~... ~o ::J ~""CD'O-'- ~ "- t:,g 0)'c:0> ~ u <llo!! <ll E ~ '0 <<i ':;' ,Q ~9,! ,,-~c;g~> '" v, o:!=:='- a. ' ~ -~- i E 6 W 13 3uou:S aiz c: QUJ '" .xu W O)S C <ll ~ ,2 a."tj 0 - '" Ci. ::JL- o::::-Oeno. -c:~ c:~- O)~ <ll '"'" -.... B u a. "0 <ll_ ~"'=c:<ll0) Z a: Z.,:"Q, <ll C>> > ZQ. -iQ,~.se O 0 '~c".!!l 0 a. .x u- CD ~ a. Ci5a: 0 c:('ii- 0 a. <ll (f) 3: -l "O.!! -"0 0) ~Q.(ijm'3Q,E ~~.s oo::Q."-II:Q <llrn E ...:::.", .a 008 Eo> 0 o '"'" g 0 c >.-5 ~ () LL "- W:I:- .0 3: "- L- -::> . O)CU 0) '-0' rn...JCDUJ"-"-:t:::. ~ om.cE 1?"O:a a: W - 0- CD rn u) >. .- L- c:.c E .- c: <ll (f) ~ 'in:; CD c: J!! E Q '"'" ::J ~.!:: ,Q a. 0) O C:"'~ <<ic: "- u _ '- ca CT u 0 ::J a: LL -g=! '5."0 g o i:: == Eii g-~ ~ .-r- -ca= rn 00 a: 0) - _ c: ,5 0 IW .oCDE<{~z (j) ,g ,g '0) 0)0 ::J-~"2~ cD .s EC.'-"Ou ca...C:O)C: rn.2 0 '-.0 <ll .x__ _.;:: ~ c: Q,CD i5 u .!!l cu 5t-O en :Olll_"O~ '0 =CDUJ~ <{S~ ~~"* _.c 0).:.:; "0 ca-.o,,- .cO +-0 E -CD en 3: 0 "UfDE"O~ CD. 0) en "0 CD "O:g ro c:. C:o. 0) CDca<llo>. E CD - "- E ii: c: a. Q) 0) "- Q) o E_o..c u Q) .... ! ~cl 0 0>1'- - <ll~ :2 lU_lU .alii > ~ ~.!!l .l::c::::a!: 0) <<i g'O u it: cu~:e en > ~ ';;;0 :2~1? .- II: .- c: o :;:: ca .~ c.. Q, ca o .... c: o ~ .2 Ci. a. <{ >- Q C o ... - UJ .!! ~ w .- o z \;-, ffi "0 'n; a.. Q) 0) LL >- ...J Z o w en ::::> w u u:: u.. o a: o u.. "0 0) > 'ij) u 0) "- >- .0 c: c: 0 .Q "0 <<i 0) .2 '0 0.. <ll a. 0) <ll .0 0) .... <ll o -I z o 0 ~ Z D. ...J a: W o ~ fa ~ c > I- a: w D. o a: D. \Z (j) ::J ~ .9 "0 "0 c: 0) 0) 1lI "0 > E c: 0 "- ~ a. 'n; x a. ~ W <{ U rn 0) (5 Z L.: 0) .0 E 0) :::a!: '-= i..: i...: 0) 0) 0) .0 .0 .0 E E E 0) 0) 0) ~ ~ :::a!: '0 c: 1lI ]l :t::: ~ '0 c: <ll ]l :t::: ~ :T ~ :J" - Q) :a ca .2 'ii. c. ca D .w-. - ~ .s.: "- o ~ "0 0) rn o g.~ Q: ~ z i~~ c: == ~a: o LL Z - 1->- ffi~ " ct v- ~ ~ '-l ;Z '0 c: <ll ]l c: ~ z o. . z a.. <( ~ X ~ - o "- 0) ,g E ::J Z Ol:l Q) 0) "- en CD E <ll Z ~ '" (" iJj lIJ ~ "0 "0 <{ 0> ~ 'n; ~ iJj lIJ 0) .... "0 "0 <{ 0> ~ 'n; ~ CD c: o ~ a. 0) Q; .- "E o u 0) .... - o .... 0) c: 3: o 0) c: o ~ a. 0) Q; .- \ r u ~ II o c: 'S: <ll 0' a.. (f) t~..J (!) <ll;;:z ~ DC) o .. ~ +- ~ ~i5 .3 ~ "0 0) ~ 00 o lIJ a. 0) en o o 15 Z 0) t:: o 0) o () lIJ ::J o 'S: 0) .... a. o .... c: o :;:::; <ll > o c: 0) II: (ij u .;:: o ~ o I W 0 :i:. c: O:c: 0 f2g E o:~ 0 wC: (ij E 0. ~ '~ 0) W::J 0) 0 mg E 0 0"0 E t-"O 0 ~ ~ () 0:'5 0 00' 3:~ "- ILO 0'; Z~ Q~ t-O) 0."- a::B 000 U) W o 0> c: :Q '5 m C 0) ~ ~ t ~ [0 ~ 0> ~ <ll (!) o c: o 0) +:; 0 :a c: ~ 8!. ~O i...: i..: o 0 o 0 ~ ;:;::: (j) -g "E C\I C") 0) 0) 0) € g>ooo (5 ~ ~ z 000 LL-2.E~ ~ o ~ rn ~ "0 0) rn ~ o t a. 0 e Z a. "0 0) c: "0 <ll as "- 0) 0> "0 ~ ~ rn o 'c 0:;::: .5 (ij (j) c: 'x it: 0) 0) c: > 0) 0 0) .0 3: as - 0) CD 0> .0 "0 CD ';:: u - c: 0 ~ 1: CD 0 :t::: 'CD OI "- .... o 0 g g "0 "0 c: c: C\I C\I 00 "- .... o 0 g g Ui (;j ..... 00 ~ 0 o 'in 'S: 0) II: o D .~ CD 0) N N en en iJj .x u CD o c: o :;:::; ~:a '0 "0 CD <{ a. "- rn 0 0> CD CD ~ c:C>rn::J c: <ll +- Q; as 0) u .3:5:9.2 '0 .... "- Ci5 ~ ~ S <5 z .0. 0 ~ OOOen II (j) 0) ~ (j) CD ~ (j) <ll W \ ~ ~ (j) as W I I :; ! i ~ . t t LI .. ~ - ::J o (f) . c. .. ~ c. ~ ~ C 0' 0' (f) (f) I~I . I r ., h!i Yft "1.3)QfUHVN en b "' ~ I I QVOV SId10d 1:1 C I 0 ~I~h 3 --- 0 ~ 5 N i h I ~ -' ~ [L !:i E:~!! I a:~ ... -..'CC...... 8 i <( _ ____ ..... .-s KI .. a:Juap!Sa~ ~ E .., Hit-! u .. If . ~ . 0 ..;t! ~i I a ..,. l u6!~.aQ W 0 J Ii U I pJO>1:J!~ :r: fii{; i~ 5 i = ~ i l'.~j " j ! 1 .h;!H 5 l 11Hz. l@ J , - D~DDD ~DDD D~DDD D~DDD IEmBI z o ~ -< ... 0 >- -< 0 :x 0 i-- ;u :x u> ~ ,. ~ (") :il :c '" ,. m ~ 0 0 ,. c! c: '" r m m ~ - e .. Z i; '" 0 " 0 't !=> E X II! u> .., N (") .. m :c ~ m 0 c: - r m i! '" m ~ :x > 0 '" ;.: 1< '" S; ~ .. - \l ... ~~ II 1>':1: II II II ~ i II l~ II @ II II II Q~ II "'" II Qr II ~ II ........... g II ~ .. i II - II C ;!! ~ II ~ II II I )> II I Z U 00 II I II I II I II I "@) I n = - - II 2 L_______ ---------- II II = ~ II II II II II II II ~ II II 00 II II II ~---------------:~~r---------------i .----- . IIII I I IIII I -----, d' I I 1111 I ; I I I I1II I I . f 1111 I I I I 1111 I I I I 1111 I I I I 1111 I I , I IIII I , I : :::: 1 I I I I I II -.:= I I I I ~ ~ - J f @rZ~Fr . -: .. ~ i s l.s .1 [ i I r . H . 1 fsrli'l I . ll.l-l~' I . , I Rickard I In 9 r Q m De's I 9 n rnl.~i. I ~ ~". 0 r..';.iH 0 !> '- () Residence r i 11 ~'II )> ~ ~ a .. EN ,.. .... ......... 1M rp;~_ ... 3 ,,~... l~ ~ . -U A -- -;JII~~ --\. --- ~ ~ 0 12 PO.PI!: IlOlD f r t.l n I 0 I :J ~,1 T a q 1.0 lIAII1UCI<ET.llA II ~ I I I I... If:; lte I I ___2.!4' I I I ...1 ~I ":1 I I I GARAGE 2 763 SF. 1:=01 --2:i6< ~ CI\ · N 8 8 o b o 0 <. ' CHATHAM ROAD ~1JOIE 200.00' I NI !Ill ~I ~Hf 80 SF. U CI s.. U Ld d a.. 22.31' HOOSE J.842 SF. ~ 22.1)4' " t3. 0\' N .! o 0 p te CJ 0 o C> , r1 1 LDTS 13-15 4Q,OOO SF. 2DO.OO' ~ PDLPIS Ro.AD f\'I~t ~po\\u ,- w' . \"" +' {~t nO vYIjl'lf '.'. - rflIed re rer'" . I vYl you. . r 'olA. a .:rffer jTOflC,. L. ut prtO maY uJJJ . wtt,.,o - iof\.. -ficattOflS corrtrrnss , 3 4 5 8 .f:r~C:Oval of the ~G 1. ~ 199$ ZONINGs LUG-1 MINIMUM LOT SIZEr 40}OOO S.F. .,i MINIMUM FRONTAGEs 100 FT ~ hRDNT YARD SETBACKI 35 FT .R!;AR 8. SIDE SETBACKr 10 FT ."qROUND COVER RATIOI TI. I -----Pl:.hT PLAN OF LAND IN AUG 1 {) 1999 " ,,, ~ 11- I I ~I ~I I , I , " t I " ~"'~.' :.."" ')' 1 P-f;!I<'''''l " ~ ".> "- CHI, ~'v" " 'l' 'i' '\- ~ r,/ 'vJ "- "- : m't i\ 'r. t'o ~ 1</,' 1'?1'6 U/'I,e, . .11.\0,= " I P/lOK'''',,"I 1-.0 TS J,fI<E/I = J .00 po J- P / :s r I , " "- ., ,~I \ ;.i. 31 ;;. STD~Y' D ~EJ...i-/~\: /, g 'f ).. t s.,; " ~ '1 , ""' "- :::: -::'- J" n"i /3 -IS l. ,,0) Of ("viA \0' t), APPRUVED <"au QfIe r~ '_"_J Dm......... thar """'. differ from YOur ~ - lfJecifkDt;o". 'tJ._-- WI '",," Prias ~l ct tJu. Com~ 't"",Oc?O S,;:: Ro-1t> 0< SEll - 5 z~~~. I'- U G- 1. _ MINIMUM LOT~','.1'/ooo ""r MINIMUM FRONTAGE:/p~' FRONT YARD SETBACK: .35' REAR & SIDE SETBJ..CK: /0 ' GROUND COVER RATIO: / % PLOT PLAN OF LAN;) IN NANTUCKET, MASS, SCALE 1 "= 30 / DATE: Au 6-. I'll r ?96 JOHN J, SHUGRUE INC, 57 OLD SOUTH ROAD NANTUCKET, MA,02554 FOR: I-Yulr:. P, ,'e/l, 11 Ii. Ci lISSESSORS MAP 5" _ PARCEL NO. Id.; q ;08 - 1 TOWN OF NANTUCKET BOARD OF APPEALS NANTUCKET, MASSACHUSETTS 02554 Date: March /9 , 19 97 To: Parties in Interest and. Others concerned with the Decision of the BOARD OF APPEALS in the Application of the following: Application No.: 001-97 Owner/Applicant: ROWENA C. RICKARD Enclosed is the Decision of the BOARD OF APPEALS which has this day been filed in the office of the Nantucket Town Clerk. An Appeal from this Decision may be taken pursuant to Section 17 Qf Chapter 40A, Massachusetts General Laws. Any action appealing the Decision must be brought by filing an complaint in court within TWENTY (20) days after this day's date. Notice of the action with a copy of the complaint and certified copy of the pecision must be given to the Town Clerk so as to be received within such TWENTY (20) days. DlJ Michael . O'Mara' Chairman cc: Town Clerk Planning Board Building Commissioner PLEASE NOTE: MOST SPECIAL PERMITS AND VARIANCES HAVE A TIME LIMIT AND WILL EXPIRE IF NOT ACTED UPON ACCORDING' TO NANTUCKET ZONING BY-LAW 9139-301 (SPECIAL PERMITS); 9139-321 (VARIANCES) ANY QUESTIONS, PLEASE CALL THE NANTUCKET ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS. NANTUCKET ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS 37 WASHINGTON STREET NANTUCKET, MASSACHUSETTS 02554 Assessor's Map 54, Parcels 122, 123, 182, 183 Land Court Certificate of Title NO. 5940 12 Polpis Road LUG-l DECISION: 1. At a public hearing for the Nantucket zoning Board of Appeals, on Friday, January 10, 1997, at 1:00 P.M., in the Selectmen's Meeting Room, in the Town and county Building, Broad street, Nantucket, Massachusetts, the Board made the following decision on the Application ot RO~NA c. RICKARD and LYOLE RICKARD of 12 Polpis Road, Nantucket, Massachusetts 02554, File No. 001-97: , 2. The Applicants are seeking a special Pe~ under Nantucket Zoning By-LaW i139-33.A (alteration/extension of~re-existing nonconforming use/structure). The Applicants propose to change the use of a pre-existing nonconforming 763+ square foot garage structure to a garage/apartment. The subject garage structure is nonconforming as to side yard, being sited 2.16~ feet from the westerly side lot line in a district that requires a minimum side yard of 10 feet. The property also contains second garage structure that is nonconforming as to side yard, being sited 1.97~ feet from the westerly side lot line and a two-story single family dwelling. The existing structures on the property are nonconforming as to maximum allowable ground cover, covering an aggregate 3,216~ square feet or 8.04' of the property in a district that allows a maximum of " ground cover. The property is located at 12 POLPIS ROAD, Assessor's Map 54, Parcels 122, 123, 182 and 183, Land Court Plan 10,937-B, Lots 13-16. The property is zoned Limited Use General-I. ~ 3. Our decision is based upon the application and accdmpanYing materials, and representations and testimony received at our pUblic hearing. Although the Nantucket Planning Board granted secondary dwelling approval for the garage structure on October 15, 1996, the Planning Board also recommended unfavorable action on this Application. There was no public opposition to the Application. 4. . The Applicants inform us that there are three (3) pre- existing structures on the Property: a two-story dwelling with 1,842 square feet of ground co~er, a garage at the front of the property with 611+ square feet of ground cover, and a garage which is the subject of this Application at the rear of the property with a ground cover of 763+ square feet. The Applicants have demolished the 763~ square foot garage under Building Permit No. 13553-96 in accordance with Section 139-330(1) of the By-Law rr.rT JLCT_T7_a~~ f.0"d ltllOl whioh permits the reconstruction of a pre-existing, non- conforming building which is accessory to a residential use. The conversion of the garage to a secondary dwelling (garage/apartment) will not cause any increase in the existing 2.6'~ non-conforming sideline setback and groundcover non- conformities. 5. Based on the foregoing the board FINDS that the conversion of the garage to a garage/apartment will not be substantially more detrimental than the existing non-conforming garage to the neighborhood.. 6. Accordingly, the Board grants the relief as requested by SPECIAL PERMIT under section l39-33A of the Nantucket zoning By- law to allow the conversion of garage to garage/apart~ent by a UNANIMOUS VOTE subject to the condition that the ground cover of the garage/apartment not exceed the existing garage ground cover of 763~ square feet. Dated: February /9 , 1997 TOWN OF NANTUCKET BOARD OF APPEALS NANTUCKET, MASSACHUSETIS 02554 ICf Date: March , 19 97 CERTIFICATE OF GRANTING OF ~~~~ SPECIAL PERMIT (Massachusetts General Laws, Chapter 40A, Section 11) The BOARD OF APPEALS of the TOWN OF NANTUCKET, hereby cer~ifies that .a- ~~ SPECIAL PERMIT has been GRANTED: , To: (Owner/Applicant) Rowena C. Rickard (001-97) Address: Box 757, Nantucket, MA 02554 affecting the rights of the Owner/Applicant with respect to land Qr building at: 12 POlpis Road, Assessor's Map 54, Parcels 122, 123, 182 and 183, Land Court Plan 10,937-B, Lots 13 - 16, Cert. of Title XlIDC<X<XXOCOCK<<)()UnC~ : 5940 And the BOARD OF I\PPEALS further certifies thet the attac:,ed Decision is a true and correct copy of its Decision GRANTING the JV~~~MC SPECIAL ?ER:.1IT and that copies of the Decision 2:-:::: c: all pl<3.ns referred to in the Decision h~\re beetf ftle-crw'tth .-the -P"'l3;1-ff"iT-; Board and the Town Clerk, The BOARD OF APPEALS calls to the attention of the Owner/ Applicant that General La~s, Chapter 4DA, Section 11 (last paragreph) provides that no 'X~~k~IX~ SPECIAL PERl-lIT, or any EXTENSIOi" MODIFICATION or RENEWAL thereof, shall take effect until (a) a copy of the Decision is certified by the Town Clerk that TWENTY (20) days have elapsed after the Decision has been filed in the office of the To~n Clerk and no appeal has been filed (or, if such appeal has been filed, that it has been dismissed or denied) and (b) the certified copy is recorded in the Registry of Deeds for the County of Nantucket and indexed in the grantor index under the name of the Owner of Recore or is recorded and noted on the Owner's Certificate of Title, The fee for such recording or registering shall 'be paid by the Owner/Applicant ~/ / / ( \ , () {~,tl (~/ C:~~C~~\ Ir'-Q- # 3 JOO Town of Nantucket RECEIVED BOARD OF ASSESSORS MAR 2 1 20U3 TOWN OF NANTUCKET, MA ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS LIST OF PARTIES IN INTEREST IN THE MATTER OF THE PETITION OF PROPERTY O~ER.,... Lr.~ .q~..... f. \ f:~t\f:- P.".,...... .~(>,V'!,~ JII-h MAILING ~DDRESS.. f.p. :..~.l?~.. ..J.'?.l....... ..t:l.~~<;:J:~1....M 02,~'-I PROPERTY LOCATION."" .t~.. r.~Jf.l,~,.. ,f.?..,.". :t'lwty(/.~rc:T,.~ .. ~4 -, 1.3 t.. ( \1. I) 10 Z. ASS ESSO RS MAP /PARCEL.,. . . .,.Q. !:\:.,., .,)l~,.,..,." ff.., , ..\':7 :::. \:5., .. l ~ 0 ; ) I APPLICANT.., ..~~~..l,N.~r?.kM,.,.. ,., ..,.5.0.~..,. .Q.'?~,:,!t.':f. ~,2,.",." SEE ATTACHED PAGES I certify that the foregoing is a list of persons who are owners of abutting property, owners of land directl~ opposite on any public or private street or way; and abutters of the abutters and all other land owners within 300 feet of the property line of owner's property, all as they appear on the most recent applicable tax list (M.G.L. c, 40A, Section 11 Zoning Code Chapter 139. Section 139-29D (2) . /}lJ(I/?,d-:. i?/l,.. ;?:q~ ~ /!M..~.,.(2~ DATE' ASSESSOR'S OFFICE Town of Nantucket R o ... ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ H .. .... .. '" .. '" 0 " 0 .. " .. CO 0 .. .... ~ ~ ~ ~ tI1 ~ ~ ~ H III Po. ~ ~ c1 S ~ o Pot p., 0 .. 3 3 ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ t ~ ; ~ ~ e e ~ ~ ~ a ~ i i e e ~ i ~ ~ <Xl '" .... r-l ..-t r-l ... '" 0 .... .... '" ... ... ... rot ... ~ ... .... ~ ... .... . ... ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ M ~ ~ 0 ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ l1Iltlltl.ItlNll'lIt)COItlIl'lItlItl\O....r-t ..-l NNNN....NNNNNNN.NNN IS! OOOOMOOOOOOOO\oo ~ ~~~~~~~l;!~~~~~~~ ~ ~ :J t t ~ tit t ~ t t t t ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ € ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ .. .. .. " '" '" -: '" R ... .... ... co :E t!l Z ~~ tIl H ..:IE-< Il:1 till><: Il:: tJ Il:1 P ~~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 01 rJ :::: '" H H .... Ikl all \0 PI:k 8 co r-t H tI1 >< GI r-- 0 III 0 k At H ca '" >< .... ~ ~ 2 ~ i ~ .. , " .. ~ \ o tJ CJ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 0 ~ .. .. 01 01 o tJ ~ ! i ~ ~ ! ~ g .,.,\n 0<>0.. .......... ... .... -" .u r-l.ll'I r-l\Dt"-\Df"" (tlO'lOM 1l1\D o NNN(J)CX)CX)OONNNNl""'Il'"'lCOCO H r-l.-tr-lr-lr-lr-t....NNNNNNNN .... '" '" , ... .... -: ~ H ; ~ ~ H i ~ I rJ '" '" "' "' N 0 0 ll'I N N rot r-l r-l N rot rot ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ e e e ~ ; e e e .. Dl ... .... '" .... .... "' 01 .... H .. >< '" o 0 III .. o .. ... 01 .. .. .. ~ .. 01 ~ .. ~ .. .. -: :j :j .. .. .. .. .. ~ ~ 0) ~ Q Q ~ I:i1 tI1 tf.I ~ ~ 11 11 ~ = i i ~ ~ III III "" .. .. Cli 0 01 C. ~ 0 0 0 "" " E-4 U U U ~ Dl D 01 ~ o '" '" .. ~ .. >< ~ o ., ~ i H ~ .. ":E E ~ ~ -: ~ .. III ::; = ~ H" E-t .. \II ~ ~ .. ~ 0 M E-t o ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ :E ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ t ~ ~ ~ ~ .. 8 g ~ a ~ ~ 0 < ~ .. ~ ~ a ~ g ~ ::; ~ : ~ : ~ ~ E = ~ ~ 8 ~ ~ ~ l;! ~ ; ~ ~ ~~ \').... 1 ..:> 'l'" ~'''' ~ ~ .. .. .. .. .. ~ ~ ., .. .. = = ~ Pot Pot .. g g III 01 01 ~ ~ ~ H rJ rJ ~ 01 ~ ~ ~ 0 0 g 01 01 ~ al ~ ---------------