HomeMy WebLinkAbout018-74
, ,
i:
~",
(
[,
;~t\
~II
I;
~\
I'
;~"I
'i'~ \
.."
"
~ .d
~
~i '
~.
:' .
"
I '
~ I \
~_\..
,
r.t.. ':...
~~:\ ..'~.
/,(""'~i" ,
, ...,.....__~'P......~
.''','.; ;
',,'
"i'"
",.
," I
.....J
\,
" ,
, .
.; I
.. .;1'
"
t
,
I'
~.~/}~:\,'
. \J, ,
f
",
1.0
'1'ne in-
, " "" '. ". ~,'J:"',
IlR thq 'i,""/~,
. . .{~~.
J\.ndprov j do
,
':
';,
, ,'. ~ " \ .. I.
~, t1,':1': (: I ;, c\ {l (om ' H t (\. t 0 ci t h H~, '
"I:': i/l" "" ."
" .
'".. it
l\.ncl
"
., ~
~j~:~L
;i ~'
:.~ \
. 1 , ~ f
th Hultu.hlo
~ } ;:'~ :~~
nr.cw ido u.
" .\~~
L~i;. ;
7, ~ ,v~. i
,f.
'~l. - I
d::'
C',. "
">il~} t.t:',
. r,
lUll 1
, .t ,~,>~~
1111 j 'd i III':
, '
, ,
,:,', ~(;.f':
,I:;,:r~^: ;,
, ;, ,
: ~~,,;. t! .
. ~" i~::~/,:,;t,:i
. <. 'r. :.'~"'; .;~?{
.~ ~~ ),:~ .~;~ i~: t~;":"
,~.:' ~1~' ii~;'
. '~,.'I'~
~ ) " ~1. ,'flt' ,
\
\
I ~'~'"I .
,,:\i1"
'~ ,: .l:t~
j/
I
(
r'
I,
J\
~
II'
11"
II .,'
~ ,,'
I'"
ij,
,\1
'j
I~', "'~,
ij ~
, ,
,
I:,
If
~
~",: "
~ ,:.,
tl .',',
~'\ },
,,I, ,
"
t' ,
:
"
-~_.
.' ,
I';."
,',I
"1' t ,'n,:
.; :""
/
.I
/;
i'
~
,i
" t'.~ !l'''''' ...~' - ~. , .' '...-:)
,..--
"
'"
.1 't
, f
"1',1
:' ~ I
I fl.'.! ~
f ~,
l'~~ .I
" '
~< ..
" ,
f, ~I-
"i
.
':
Htll.t.ing htf..WO,A ttle ownor
, ',1
,:.. ,
PI'iVll,\.oly hoJfl,IJ.nd his plans
.'\It,
, .
. , " .
'j; "
not. :(I,n.U~.;o unY':'J~oonvoniQnc(l or
", '<):" :,:,\' ., \:r,' I ~ .
r'"
': 'I,,' i ~
,- ~~
I
'~I ' "
i ~" ;
'1 il.;11!W I l>r,i fC(~ 11,F;Hf] . " Mr. Dr iacoll ''''.1
Wfl."'" 'cli 1'(1c,',I,!lt! at. tho'~hren.l or erosion
~ "~ : .
.'
1
I "
f :
,I, ;'\
I ';
1-'1.nt.ocl Uw OPU)1 Jl,rcHl. under the \mi1din~
I :' t.. .'
"
~j I
mllt,('\;;III.1 ilnd qoU1ct bq Aub,iect to wll.Lor
~o'h~d no dj~pute
'I,;
, I
~ " l ,
"'1'"
, '
. i
, ..... i :
\-'.' :
"1
. 'I'.'
omphu:..;izqcl th.<?:effect the type
~...:t ';':;(/1'
L/'w d \ I n 0
I
;-
I'
t l \1
'1'"
1,\.1
t ":, ,
I"
. I " l
t.' I
f """1
Board found:'
, <.
,', .::, : . ~!
t YPfl I' llU ncla t1 (>0 w j 11 80rve to
, .
. nr<'I,L'; . 'ro r<.~qufr~:'1;IH' i OR tall n-
. , :'~ ,'1 ' ,J 11
~.. ' '~ .Ji~ ":I)"~'\ :,",11 ' ,
r () II nclll Li on w il 1 'pl11.CO nn nne rOUf;
, i
I '
i ,:1
, ",~
I
, ,
'I "
,I' , 'i
'.\ ::"
1 T.,' , ~. "
I I I ~
~!f ,\.
',.::it
'::',;'
I' I, "','
i ,,;~ .j:: ;'.~\'
, l~
,gY'nnLud.
from
j n.i\~riO\lfi
. (', ,'"
t.YPO oC
h~, Mrfl.' TlacJ<us;
"I, .,
I ,I; ',,' ,I
.~ I! ': ,~
~ ~<;<."~
j,
" j ", ;',
lI/.
bel l:)uf'ficicnt
:'ii- ,..;lI
\ <,,',
"
~ J'f.
grad~
". .
.
.' ,J'
',',~' ~{",;~>} j
, ,J ! i'
':..~ ...' ,t\~ ~~~
" ~r'
.
..... '
'," ,<'
;. ~
'f": ':'
..~
';,."; ".',",'.'
:. '" ~
"
'{ <
.
)'/'<;;;'i~
>',.": "
.~ ."~, "
--'
MONWEALTH OF MASSACHUSETTS
NANTUCKET
CITY OR TOWN
BOARD OF APPEALS
October 8, _74
..... ........... ................ .... ............... .....u ..19-
,NOTICE OF VARIANCE
Conditional or Limited Variance or Special Permit
(General Law. Chapter 4OA, Seetion 18 a. amended)
Notice is hereby given that a Conditional or Limited Variance or Special Permit has been granted
T Cliffside Beach, Inc.
a.... ................. ... _........ _. ............ .... ..... ........__ ................. ...__.....__ ......... ........ ... ......... .... ...................
Owner or Petitioner
Add Jefferson Avenue
ress....... ............. __.....h........ ..... ..... _... ................ _ _... ._..................... .... _.. ..........__............ .... __......
City or Town....................... ... _.~ ~.I?: ~~. ~ ~.~.~ .~... ~.~. ~~. :...~ :.~ ~ .~............... .......... ....... ..................
... .... ...... ......... .Lo.t s.. .3...&...4.~. .Lan.d...Gau.:r::t...P.lan.. .16.8 7.7 .A.~....Nan:tllck.ej;.. .... ....... ..... ....
R. D . . Identif7 Land Alfected
eglstry lstrlct
........ --.. ....-........... ...............- -...... -........ ---.... .................. -....~............ -........ --.... -.... --- --............. ................ --.............. .......--- ."-" -..---..------- -------.. .........- -..- -..- --- ---..
Cit
by the To~ oL.....................~.~~.~.~~.~~.~..................................Board of Appeals affecting the
rights of the owner with respect to the use of premises on.
Jefferson Avenue Nantucket
.. ......... .....- -..- ---..... -..........--.. ....... ............... .... ..... ......... .......... ....... ..... ........... ..... ......... .-... .......... ....-... ................. ...... ......... ................. ........ ..-..
Street
the record title standing in the name of
Cliffside Beach, Inc.
el&7 Or Tow"
whose address is.. _.. :!.'? ~ .~.'? !:.I?? ~...~Y.~ !.. ..... ... ......~ ~.l!-. ~~.?~ ~.~........ ........ .~~.~. ~.:... 9.?~.~.~......
Street City or Town State
by a deed duly recorded in them...................................nCounty Registry of Deeds in Book
......... ...... Page................, .........-_.........................................Registry District of the Land Court
Certificate No...... ""'" ...... ......m......Book n..n....m ...Page.. ... ..... ....n
The decision of said Board is on file with the papers in Decision or Case NO..~.~.~::-.!.~n.....
in the office of the T~~ Clerk.....___........~.'::~_!~.~~.~.~................................................................
Certified this...~.~E..day of.......9~t<?~~.~._....m....m....._..19 7 4
Board of APp~_~.l.~:...........~~.~~~~.~~~'...~....Chairman
Board of Appoal.
......,. -....,.. - -.......-.... .................................... .........'. .xg~~x
Do..rd of Appeal.
...... ........ ............... ......... _.... .....19. ....... at.-......___ ---o'clock and... 'h_'" ...... ......... __.... _minutes __..M.
Received and entered with the Register of Deeds in the County oL............n..........................
Book.............. .... ...... Page...... ....._.. _'" ......
ATTEST
Register of Deeds
Notice to be recorded by Land Owner.
"ORM 1094 HOaSE!. WARREN. INe.. "",V'oElI c"..P'n:,. 212.'"U,
~
::u !
I,
~~,
~:
,I
,':!;
I
. ,
.... I
}
}
}
}
} .
}
}
WAYNE ~. H()tMES'; roBERr''1'AY:WR, HARRIET }
BACKUS,' l:\LLT:lN IUiAL, ANP ElrEEN CJ\lt()(E, }
! AEi .'l11ey~the Board of Appeals of.' }} ,
the "~ Qf~antucket, Towl1.. and County
I~~~'=~J~;~=~, l
land.~~ CURRJ;E, all; of Jefferscn Ave. }
NantuCket, . Massachusetts, }
~DANTS )
,.','" .,'c:'<:-,
"', ..../,"\.
~<~s, M~D., ECWARPHARRIS,
,ERtOO~~<:N , and PE'DllRODOLEIFSCN ,
'a1~P~/;~~~e~~,A~~, Nantu~t,
~sa<t1U$e:t~ ,:;:, >
,(",. ' PIJUNTIFFS
-0
N
N
co
, w.
~T
,W
, r
i 1. . JUrisdiction of this Honorable Court is invoked pursuant
I to01apte~~OA Mass. Gen. Laws Sec. 21. .,
\. "."-,',. ... .,
:! 2. . 'lheplcuntiffs are CMners of certain ~al property situated
Ii on Jefferson Avenue in the town and cx>unty of Nantucketi the
,II' defendants i{ol.nes,. Taylor and. Back~ axe. ~rs of the Nantucket :
Board 9f Appeals, and the defendants~al and'~ axe associate:
Lna;rperSl ofsaid~ardi th~ defendant. ooIpOrat!oo .and the defendants i
'. Currie or ane or sare or. all of them. are the owners of certain :
real estate also situa~ em. Jefferson Avenm in the town SUld i
IC01mty OfNi"'tucket, wh.l.0t1, xeal estate abutts th~i: of the ~~tif'.
1.,3. : 'lhe defendants or one or sene or all of them were ~, I
l~petitioners before the said Board of Appeals in an appeal o(a
I .denial of a building penni tby theTc:Mn. of NaIltuCket Building
I Inspector and a refusal by the said Bui:j..ding;J:nspector to all~
'''the construction of two house units using a'.pile type founcla~Ql."
! 4.. Attached hereto, made a part hereof, and maxked as '
I "Emibit.'A" is a~ CC1i!:I of "Minutes ofa,neeting of the Board
!of Appeals held October ;J" 1974 II upon page twO of which the
I .TcM.n of Nantucket Town Clerk has entered the 4ate of filing
(0Ct0be:r22, 1974) with his offioe of the $laid 1'Minutes" and
. affixed his signature thereto.
,.,
..
I
I
!
II
1 {t';;.,:-: ;-.""
", ,',' t
'Ihe,last J;?at'~9'rapll.q; said "Minutes" recites as follows:
1111ponrroticn . by Mr. Taylor , se~ded by ~. BackU9,
'itwas manmous1Yvoted to 9r~t thevat'iCU'lCle
'.;ecaues te(i., ' '
'; , i,Acoor&l.ngly ,
the said variance is. GRAN'IED, subject, to. the follCMing
ca1di tion:', .thatt;he' depth of the pi1in9be sufficient
toJ:'each fran the tpp of the dune area'to,.the existing
....j~X'a,~ l~l of the road or way abutting.",
I
'I
Ir
'I'
11 7 .>~" aoa<d 2f Appeals atten\'ts to gr~t, .. vsrisnce in
languages:i:milar< to that used in the granting, of a variance
\',.' Under tt).e . zaring' By-Laws; in clause" three of their decision said
"'nle s~tural integrity of this piling type 0; tQUndaticn is
assured," and went on in the last paragraph of ~it A to
'qualify th~ir decisioo as follows: II swject to' the following
o:>n01tic:n:.' that the depth of the piling be . sufficient .to reach
frdnthE' tJ:jpof the d\]11e ar;ea to the existing grade level of
the,i:9ad., o;'way.', abutting. II ' .
'.~.,.' "......... .... .<': ...t" .......~. <;. . ", '
\ ' 8.,'Sect;ioo six of the Building Code By-LaW a11<:'MS the
'. InSpector, slbject to the approval of the Boarde>! ~als,
. '.' to.;'] 8Pt'rove 'the use of net.hods for oonstruetfd1 and materials
I'not;:,~fied ,in ,this JlY-LlI'I. pIQVided they ate 01; eq11i.valent
I strength and safety." 'lhis.the Board of Appeals has failed
I to~." f' ,.' .'
~RE, the plaintiffs pray this Honorable .COurt:
1) For a decxee that the decision (!)f the Board of
~a1s ,is annulled, and
2) For such othex;' decree and relief as justice and
equi. ty require.
h
\1
~
i
\
II I
II .
II
:\
II
1\
\1 Dated:NQvenber 11, 1974
II
II
II
;\
~ \
II
II
d
,"
Respectfully submitted
by their attomeys
~d~; gf
Reade, . 0' ROurke' & Marino
61 Adans St.
Braintree, Mass. 02184
848-4280
-2-
.'
,
....- .
J
:1
.~~
;i
';!f1
;~~
'1"'j1'
'--':~{
.,;
t1
A
{~~
j
J
/
.~}
t-i
'{!:
" ..~
-,
.
.~
.
if'
f-'
0..'0
OJ
~--.J
0-- V1.
tJ
:1l
n
\....
o
'if? tJ
n (!)
n
"-'
r::- r::-
-J
0-- V1.
0..
>zj
(!)
a'
'" '"
CD a-
>zj
11I
a'
~ ~
<: <:
"-' '"
0-- f-'
r::- w
>zj
11I
a'
'"
a-
'='===~=~-===~~~==-":;-==='===~~'"='-=~'----
f-' 0 '0 CD
f-'
----------------_._-------------~-----'
o tJ''d ::>3:;:>' ~tJtJz::uf-'::U 0 ::u><-o
H.l<1lllJroo<ll ;:l<1l<DO(!)CD(!);:l(!)"g:~~ !
"'"')'1 P.l c+ jl) H)I-+J < cT. c+ C+"'d c+ ~ i
~'" c+ <:+ "1 ~. "1 en c+ c+ . Z t::: CD s:: o' a;
S ,........ 0 .... c ~,f-' 0 '1 llJ n (!) c.
~;:?(!)"'~~H.l(,,)OCDO o <;:l'1;o;-'1
v '1 rn JQ >-'l o'Q ;;' ~ a' H.l ...., f-' 0 g: <1l 'n ~
::l '1 ~ llJ 0 0 f-' '1 <1l 'f) Ul V1. H.l n.... c+-
5~g;~~~:'~ 3. 3. ~;~~~
'ti. n ~' ~ ~ ~ 5 :s: ~ ~ ~ ~.)> g E; (")
<:mo..oot-'c+oli Oc+I-'.~O
~~. ~ ro~~ ~~. g g (t)$~:-5
~t::;"'dO"~f-' g(ll tJ t:l g to""'\i;"
C)~'~5.~23~>-'l)> ~ ~ tJ~grn~'
ll(lJ(!)llJ V1..o0::l c+ .... l1IJQ'1(!)....
.n....'1"<;""!! rn ""'f-'P-'1
1>1>'" 0 )>~ l>1 ::0 C+I-" ~.
TcO""'o..'1 g-~~ ~ g. (")llJgn",,!!
:l'''''~~:{ (Jl~ llJ ~ ~;;'z:~
:~o~,,-,;;;' f.,~ ~ c+ ~'1~;:lEf'
"1""'5'"1--.Ji-J HJ ~ t'"".) end N
~'~.iS"~ '" ~~ (") E; ~~f-'V1.0
~~o.~~;o;-~ E;;:1. (!)~r::-1ll"
o vto. ;;"xJ ;:1. (!) ~ g.~.
H.lf-' 0 '10 (!) 0 llJ <llo.
~ '1 0 ~ g. ~ !
'?, I to ~ >-3 ;:l Z i
~0--<llH.l '1 0 H 0 !
}--I. -...- ::J 0...... or::::s""" i
o ;:l '1 llJ 0 !
==",====~===_-L' --=,,==----------------===cI
c+ i
0.. I
~ "i
~
en ~
.......
r;)
(V)
0-
(Il Z
.... 0
~ ~
(!) n
0. (b
a'
'<
.,....'
llJ
f-'
f-'
"C
ll>
'1
c+-
.....
(I)
en
.
o
H.l
<
o
f-'
C
~
ll>
'1
'<
o
1-"
'"
p.
(Il
Ul
ll>
f-'
~
N
--1
:::J
-::>
.J
-l
'.~
'Z
3:
..0
'Cf-
~
~.
c+
;:>'
o
c
c+
'0
'1
(!)
c.....
C
0.
....
o
_.,___".AL.____ _ .
'>:l
C
f-'
f-'
.....
....
f-'
11I
'1
(!)
c+
r::
'1
;:l
11I
0.
.....
'1
o
3
CJ>
r::
....
....
o
f-'
;0;-
>-3
o ;:>'
H.l 0
..... 3
llJ
~ Ul
Ul >zj
~ .
trJ
'1
o
"
g
'<
..
N
r::-
)> ..
rfl
en f-'
c+ \,()
--.J
\J'\
(") ..
f-'
(I) ll>
'1 c+
;0;-
~
ll>
;:l
\,()
..
~ if
-..I '1
\J'\ en
co
....
o
'1
;:>'
(!)
$I>
'1
....
;:l
(JQ
'>:l
11I
a'
to
o
en
c+
o
;:l
~
'fi? ;i
.... 0
c+- 3
- llJ
(Il (Il
....
o
'1
;:>'
(I)
ll>
'1
1-"
;:l
lJQ
o "-' ::0
(!) r::- <1l
.... .0
~ ~
tJj
o
'"
c+-
o
::l
~ '>:l
c+
....
o
;:l
>-3
o
:3:
o
c+
....
o
;:l
>-3
o
trJ
'1
o
'g.
(!)
'<
~
llJ
;:l
'"
--.J
..
)>
0.
<:
II>
;:l
o
(I)
>zj
o
'1
::x:
(I)
III
'1
t~
;:l
(JQ
Ul
(!)
c+-
o.
~
)> ..
0.
< :.-
$I> Ul
::l (II
o c+
11I
>zj (")
o f-'
'1 (I)
'1
::x: ;0;-
(!)
llJ 0
'1 CD
.... 0
;:l
(JQ
f-'
'0
--.J
\J'\
II>
c+-
trJ
o
Ul
c+-
o
;:l
'"
rJl a- trJ
(!).. (!)
c+ g
c+-
c+-
f-'
0.'0
o -..I
~ r::-
;:l .
r-
,.
::;
o
o
()
^
'"
.....
z
o
<:
Zf-'
o
<'.o'i1
f-'f-'-ft
r::- f-'
r::-
"-'
f-'
en
Q-5
5. ~'
- o.
CIl~
~. b'
'" c
'" ~
'" ~
'" -
g
~
~
!:l
'"
N
CD
I
o
o
f-'
0-
f.i' ~~f
o ~.~:
~ ir;,;
:JJ ~bl.
c+ c
0;;:
'1 ..,
Z ....-
ll> (Il
::l 0
c+- 0
c: f-'
n f-'
;0;-..
III
c+ '"TJ
'n
.0
"'d
''1
>-3
''"
;:xl
o
C.:l
o
r
,:.j
......
'1j
(Jl
o
z
'r!
::0
H
(")
o
o
Sl
'>1
H
'-1j
'Jl
o
Z
J1!
~!
cr::
>
ig
H
'.n
~
H
~
<j
::0
>-3
::r::
'bo
:.!O
::0
H
':"11
z
!'
~ ~ ~
llJ llJ
..... :.- ;:l
;:l 0. n
c+ Q) .....
'1 3 (Il
III 'fl
III 0..
Ul .
o c+-
"-' 0
f-'
C/.) -u ::0
r::- 0
() ~
'1
;0;-
W <1>
o ..
><
M
"-' rn
f-'.o
"-' .
3:
,::)
~
>
r
i
,_-I
zHI
? :
!
a'
'<
:s:
o
c+-
1-"
o
::;
>-'l
o
'0
llJ
'1
c+
1-"
(!)
Ul
;t-
o.
<:
llJ
::l
r')
(!)
""!!
o
"'l
>-3
'1
1-"
llJ
I-'
'1
ro
S
o
<:
<1l
0.
c+
o
3
llJ
"'l
;0;-
n
III
Ul
ro
H.l
o
'i
>-3
'1
1-"
\l>
f-'
'Tj
(1)
0"
>-<,
'1
o
;3
I-'
,....
'"
c+
~
~
r-
~
>-3 w 0.. >-3
(!) --.J llJ III
I-' 3 f-'
(") III
"-' III Ul
"-';:l "-'
enc+:><:w
I '1 -J
o CD .
-.J 0 V1.
--.J en f-' f-'
f-' r+ 1-" r::-
2: 0
z (!)
~ ;:l
c+
C trl
o '"
" .0
ro
c+-
o ....,
'" 0
V1. "'l
'"
r::- tJ
rt>
....,
c+
o
c:
"'l
'1
1-"
III
;.llo
~-i"
~
:
",'
C'l
o
c
;;:
!!.
Ul
c+-
:<:
(!)
f-'
f-'
III
'"
,....
(!)
~
'"TJ
> 0
'0 '1
"C
III txl
llJ 0
f-' OJ
'" '1
0.
'" (")
o ;:>'
:<: l!l
1-" f-'
f-' ro
f-' (Il
....
II> ~
3
o
o
(JQ
I-'
1-"
llJ
..
~
'1
o
"-'
f-'
en
f-'
o
....,
'"
1
~~
~j
p
"'-
110:....
ff;
~I~
;:;!~
'''is!
g'1)>
~ :t-'
,"
-i
i
dtrl
~1 ~
~lll
H:I
(Illr
I-'~ ('t)
n..lll
ro:
~~
~1;:1.
?1rt>
~,
~
::11
C'l
:I:
;..
::u
;:xl
H
,_'xJ
'-3
:V
~
(")
:><:
c::
,~n
25 ~,iJ.?i,'
rri :~
~ ~!
1--3 . I
> 1
-< ::x: ,
r 0
~ ~i
:15
"
~
;:xl
o
a'
<1l
'1
c+
o
C
'1
'1
1-"
<1l
\%j
H
r
t'xJ
t'xJ
Z
Z
:<>
Z
>-'l
n
:><:
pj
-'1
uJ
o
:<>
::0
u
Q
',"
:<>
"
"
~
~
tJl
""!!
>-'l
>
t-<
(")
;..
w:r::
o Q
\l> 0
3.Z
~IM
c.~
3 ~.
~ c+
C llJ
3 rr
p
1(1)
~
~
iro
r
~i
0":
:1'
2.i
!
---
:~
~
"j