HomeMy WebLinkAbout057-02
TOWN OF NANTUCKET
BOARD OF APPEALS
NANTUCKET, MASSACHUSETTS 02554
Date:
~ ~Iotr c3 , 200?
To: Parties in Interest and Others concerned with the
Decision of the BOARD OF APPEALS in the Application of the
following:
(
Owner/Applicant:
~lhloQj1
05"7 ~ 2-
(lll'(lr(e~ F ,'n ye <D'Jd?
m. .5:tjk
Application No.:
Enclosed is the Decision of the BOARD OF APPEALS which has
this day been filed in the office of the Nantucket Town
Clerk.
An Appeal from this Decision may be taken pursuant to
Section 17 of Chapter 40A, Massachusetts General LCUlIis....
,-. ..1...
'-' -, C/.I
Any' action appealing the Decision must be brought ~~~ qa
filing an complaint in court within TWENTY (20) day~,after~
this day's date. Notice of the action with a copy ~~~he
complaint and certified copy of the Decision must ~~iven;3
to the Town Clerk so as to be received within such TWE~TY 0
(20) days. 0
~
::::0
m
'.J
~ 1 1
./
.-.........
Tl
::::J
(2{~ Cl7'
AJCPJ('.Q '! ~_.
Cna irman
cc: Town Clerk
Planning Board
Building Commissioner
PLEASE NOTE: MOST SPECIAL PERMITS AND VARIANCES HAVE A TIME
LIMIT AND WILL EXPIRE IF NOT ACTED UPON ACCORDING-TO NANTUCKET
ZONING BY-LAW ~139-30I (SPECIAL PERMITS); ~139-32I (VARIANCES)
ANY QUESTIONS, PLEASE CALL THE NANTUCKET ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS.
NANTUCKE T ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS
1 East Chestnut Street
Nantucket, Massachusetts 02554
Assessor's Map 55.1.4, Parcel 37
103 Washington street
Residential-Commercial
Plan Book 19, Page 28
Lot E
Deed, Book 150, Page 246
DECISION:
,1. At a public hearing of the Nantucket zoning Board of
Appeals, on Friday, August 9, 2002, at 1:00 P.M., in the
Conference Room, in the Town Annex Building, 37 Washington
&tr~et, Nantucket, Massachusetts, the Board made the following
Decision on the Application of CHARLES F. SAYLE and KATHLEEN M.
SAYLE, c/o Reade, Gullicksen, Hanley & Gifford, LLP, Post Office
Box 2669, Nantucket, Massachusetts 02584, File No. 057-02:
2. The Applicants are seeking a MODIFICATION of the Special
Permit issued by the Board of Appeals in File No. 115-93, to
reflect the fact that the retail space, associated with the
business known as "Sayle's Seafood", upon the subj ect property
(the "Locus") is used for take-out food service. The Applicants
further request relief by SPECIAL PERMIT under Nantucket Zoning
By-law ~139-9.B(2) (i) (food processing, manufacturing and
packaging) and (0) (take-out food establishment) to permit these
uses; and relief by SPECIAL PERMIT under ~139-20 to waive the
loading zone requirement. No retail acti vi ties are conducted
upon the Locus other than those related to sales of food to be
consumed off-premises. The building upon the Locus currently
contains an area open to the public in which food and food
products are sold; a commercial kitchen in which both take-out
food and food products sold to trade accounts are prepared; an
office ancillary to the food operations; ancillary storage; and
two dwelling units on the second floor. The total number of
parking spaces required under ~139-18 for these uses is ten (five
for a take-out food station; two for up to seven employees at
peak shift; one for office space of about 160 square feet; zero
for ancillary storage under 450 square feet; and two for the two
dwelling units). In Board of Appeals File No. 115-93, the Board
of Appeals granted relief by Special Permit under ~139-18.B to
waive two of the six parking spaces that were then computed to be
required, with the food sales area having been calculated as
retail space rather than as a take-out food station. Therefore,
the Applicants are now seeking a Modification of that Special
Permit to waive the additional four parking spaces required under
~139-18. The Locus is situated at 103 WASHINGTON STREET,
Assessor's Map 55.1.4. Parcel 37, is shown upon a plan recorded
with Nantucket Deeds in Plan Book 19, Page 28, as Lot E, and is
zoned Residential-Commercial.
1
3. Our Decision is based upon the Application and
accompanying materials, and representations and testimony
received at our public hearing. There was no Planning Board
recommendation, on the basis that the Application presented no
matters of planning concern. Except for the presentation by the
Applicants and their legal representative, there was no support
nor opposition presented at the public hearing.
4. As presented by the Applicants, through counsel, they
have. made this Application in response to a letter from the Board
of Selectmen, requesting that Application be made for a common
victualler license in connection with the sale of prepared foods
b!y the Applicants' business,' known as "Sayle's Seafood", upon the
Locus. Applicants then sought a sign-off from the Health
Department, which was obtained. In addition, as a result of this
Application, the Applicants requested a certification of
compliance from the Building Department as required by the Board
of Selectmen. The Acting Building Commissioner in turn referred
the matter for review by the Zoning Enforcement Officer, who
issued a letter on July 19, 2002, directing the Applicants to
apply to the Board of Appeals for relief, with specific reference
to the need for a Special Permit for the take-out food use. The
Applicants immediately filed the Application which is now before
the Board of Appeals, requesting relief as set forth in Paragraph
2 of this Decision. No appeal from the action of the zoning
Enforcement Officer was filed, and the Applicants conceded that
the present Application was required.
5. The Applicants represented to the Board of Appeals that
they had conducted the sale of prepared foods from the retail
space in the building upon the Locus since the Special Permit
relief in Case No. 115-93 became effective in early 1994, under
the assumption that this use was a part of the permitted retail
use as a seafood market. No complaints or enforcement action had
been registered or commenced by any Town official or agency, nor
any other person or entity. Only when the Board of Selectmen
contacted the Applicants in April, 2002, to request that the
Applicants procure a common victualler's license, did the chain
of events occur which resulted in the filing of the subj ect
Application now before the Board of Appeals. The Applicants have
indicated that they plan no changes in their operations, nor any
enlargement of the building upon the Locus, from the conditions
which now exist. Applicants further represented that they
operated the wholesale delivery business, with delivery trucks,
primarily from a remote location in a commercial district.
6. As set forth in Paragraph 2 of this Decision, the actual
uses upon the Premises consist of a retail seafood market, which
also purveys take-out food, such as cooked seafood and similar
2
and related food products; a commercial kitchen which serves the
take-out food operation and also prepared food products (such as
chowder base) for sale to trade accounts; ancillary office space
and ancillary storage; and two second-floor apartments. At
maximum shift, the total number of employees working at the Locus
does not exceed seven. The retail and take-out food operations
are conducted in the same space.
7. Based upon the foregoing, the Board of Appeals made the
finding, by a UNANIMOUS vote, that the total number of parking
spac.es required for these uses is ten, calculated as set forth in
Paragraph 2. Under the circumstances presented in this case, and
with .'particular regard to the fact that the Applicants have
a.lr~ady been conducting the business which is now before the
Board exactly as is now proposed, the Board of Appeals, by
UNANIMOUS vote, also made the finding that it would be physically
impossible for the Applicants to provide all of the ten parking
spaces required under the Zoning By-law and a conforming off-
street loading area; that granting a Modification of the existing
Special Permit as to parking relief, reducing the number of
parking spaces to be actually provided from ten to four, and a
Special permi t waiving the provision of an off-street loading
area, would be in harmony with the general purpose and intent of
the Zoning By-law; and that the issuance of a Special Permit
under Nantucket Zoning By-law ~139-9.B(2) (i), for food
processing, manufacturing and packaging, and a Special Permit
under ~139-9.B(2) (0), for take-out food service, would likewise
be in harmony with the general purpose and intent of the Zoning
By-law.
8. Accordingly, the Board of Appeals, by UNANIMOUS vote,
GRANTS relief by MODIFICATION and SPECIAL PERMIT, as requested by
the Applicants as set forth in Paragraph 2 of this Decision,
subject to the conditions set forth in the Decision in File No.
115-93, which shall remain in full force and effect except as
expressly herein modified, and subject to the following:
a. The parking and Locus layout shall be In
substantial conformance with the site plan, done by John J.
Shugrue, Inc., dated July 30, 2002, a reduced copy of which is
attached hereto and marked as Exhibit A.
9. The Board also approves, by a UNANIMOUS vote, the site
plan, Exhibit A, under Nantucket Zoning By-law ~139-23 (Site Plan
Review) .
3
(057-02)
~/l ~ \/\../ (t
Dated: .v-'\3'~en"w~, 2002
Edward
Edward C. Murphy
4
~ y..t",
f,
~
(' J" /' ...y J"
" + 1J~~
"" :('~ ('/' /Vc/,
"J"/^ o~
"" V-'V
"
"
"
"
"
I
l-
e;:
o
z
;1-
t,)Vl.
<;;:,\
/,
~J'
/,..-
()
)7
'("'\
v,
-----
---
,------,
I \ po.r-I<ing
9'x20'
I \ s;Jc::C'
L_ _ _+ .__ _ _ - _..J
REFERENCE: BOARD OF APPEALS
DESCISION NA~TUCKET REGISTRY OF DEEDS
BD~K CJ38 PAGE 105
t--' le I'Jo 0 )//' () L
~ : f?1 "110~
Q~~ '\ 8( JJ-A~
=~>(z~~~ .
\ ----
\ T' 'r <"''fe" 'r'''I'f'''~
\ r.o:.. .:...' 1.'\..1...., I f...., ~._.)
( r'- l crr,-rD ^S ~ '''1, ,"
\ ,'Ii :,r, _ ~ _:-i ! t, r", ::,-:.,.' ,',
\ ILI//I' /'/
///:.' .. I
_, J ~/:LL,~~__-Sn
-,:",,' J/ ';',:1' '-",(:E w' "
\ ",',,' ," __"u,.,) ,~..>
J:~: _~~,..f!!].?-
\
L I'\'''-S~-""" IVP 5"'" p,nC'I'L '\J ~7
----,-~.::,:=-~?,.:....:__..::~~-'---'" - . ~, , ,~
zOt n;!G: RC
1'l:l:'m~U;'l LOT SIZE: 5,000 S,F,
II,:i':It.',UH FROj,jT ,(I,GE, 40 FT
FRui<T Y ARD SETJ3~\CI<: NONE
I~U\R & SIDE SEi B~\CK: 5 FT
C,;':':jU;'!]) CLiVeR Rl" Tm, 501.
p(,0::(ING pu\"j
PLOT f)\"';',:: UF LAI~D 11,1
I-iANTLiCl<ET, tviA
SC:,\LE: 1':= 15'
D~TE: JULY 3Q 2002
fJ!'li~ J, SHUGRUE, IHC,
57 OLD srUTH ROAD
j':,',: :';'1.JCi<'U, ,1,(\ 02~jS4
r~'.: C' I,';.:~r:s ~X::,ES
ti ::;91GPPI
TOWN OF NANTUCKET
ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS
1 EAST CHESTNUT STREET
NANTUCKET, MASSACHUSETTS 02554
PHONE 508-228-7215
FAX 508-228-7205
NOTICE
A Public Hearing of the NANTUCKET ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS will
be held at 1:00 P.M., FRIDAY, AUGUST 9, 2002, IN THE CONFERENCE ROOM,
TOWN ANNEX BUILDING, 37 Washington Street, Nantucket, Massachusetts, on the
Application ofthe following:
CHARLES F. SAYLE AND KATHLEEN M. SAYLE
BOARD OF APPEALS FILE NO. 057~02
Applicants are seeking a MODIFICATION of the Special Permit in the Decision
in BOA File No. 115-93 to reflect the fact that the retail space, associated with the
business known as "Sayle's Seafood", upon the Locus is used for take-out food service.
Applicants further request relief by SPECIAL PERMIT under Section 139-9B(2)(i) (food
processing, manufacturing and packaging) and (0) (take-out food establishment) to
permit these uses; and relief by SPECIAL PERMIT under Section 139-20 to waive the
loading zone requirement. No retail activities are conducted upon the Locus other than
those related to sales of food to be consumed off-premises. The building currently
contains an area open to the public in which food and food products are sold; a
commercial kitchen area in which both take-out food and food products sold to trade
accounts are prepared; an office ancillary to the food operations; ancillary storage; and
two dwelling units on the second floor. The total number of required parking spaces
required for these uses under Section 139-18D is ten (five for a take-out station; two for
up to seven employees at peak shift; one for office space of about 160 feet; zero for
ancillary storage under 450 square feet; and two for the two dwelling units). In BOA File
No. 115-93, the Board of Appeals granted relief by Special Permit under Section 139-
18B to waive two of the six parking spaces that were then computed to be required, with
the food sales area ~ving been calculated as retail space rather than as a take-out foot
station. Therefore, Applicant is now seeking a Modification to waive the additional four
required parking spaces.
The Premises is located at 103 WASHINGTON STREET, Assessor's Map
55.1.4, Parcel 37, Plan Book 19, Page 28, Lot E. The property is zoned Residential~
Commercial.
(j(
THIS NOTICE IS AVAILABLE IN LARGE PRINT OR OTHER
ALTERNATIVE FORMATS. PLEASE CALL 508-228-7215 FOR
FURTHER INFORMATION.
BOA Form 1-89
NANTUCKET ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS July 22, 2002
37 WASHINGTON STREET Date
NANTUCKET, MASSACHUSETTS 02554 /\c--7
CASE No,~02
APPLICATION FOR RELIEF
Owner's name(s): Charles F. Sayle and Kathleen M. Sayle
Mailing address: c/o Reade, Gullicksen, Hanley, Gifford, LLP
Applicant's name: Same
Mailing address: P. O. Box 2669, Nantucket, Massachusetts 02584
Location of lot: Assessor's map and parcel number 55.1,4-37
Street address: 103 Washinqton Street
Registry plan, plan Book 19, Paqe 28, Lot E
Date lot acquired: 8/14/75 Deed Ref 150-246 Zoning district R-C
Uses on lot - commercial: None or Fish market MCD? No
_ number of: dwellings ~ duplex ~ apartments J rental rooms
Building date(s): all pre-8/72? __ or various C of O? No
Building Permit appl'n Nos. 246-75; 648-77; 2906-83
Case Nos. all BoA applications, lawsuits: 115-93
State fully all zoning relief sought and respective Code sections
and subsections, specifically what you propose compared to present
and what grounds you urge for BoA to make each finding per Section
139-32A __ if Variance, 139-30A ~ if a Special Permit (and 139-33A
if to alter or extend a nonconforming use). If appeal per 139-31A
& B __, attach decision or order' appealed, OK to attach addendum'
SEE ATTACHED ADDENDUM.
Items enclosed as part of this Application: order'~ addendum'
Locus map ~ Site plan ~ showing present ~ + planned __ structures
Floor plans present __ proposed __ elevations __(HDC approved? --)
Listing lot area ~ frontage ~ setbacks ~ GCR ~ parking data ~
Assessor-certified addressee list 4 sets ~ mailing labels 2 sets ~
$200 fee payable to Town of Nantucket ~ proof' 'cap' covenant --
'(If an appeal, ask Town Clerk to send Bldg Comr's record to BOA.)
I certify that the requested information submitted is substantially
complete and true to the best of my knowledge, under the pains and
penalties of perj/:1..I'./ ~
SIGNATURE: p~ !, Applicant __ Attorney/agent ~
I
'(If not owner or owner's attorney, enclose proof of authority)
FOR ~OFFICE USE
Applicacion copiea 'ec'd. ,Vor ~ !-cUBaA on ~y~ '
One copy filed with Town Clerk on ~/~e/l-by complete? ~ (tot-
One copy each to Planning Ed and Building ~~~ ~ by ~
$200 fee check given Tow:;J.l::::asurer on *~ by waived? -
Hearing notice posted -:::z./~~mailed 21UftAr-I & M"").....~CDt-- 'i?1 Jj(JLJ
Hearing(s) on __1__1__ cont'd to __1__1__, __1__/__ withdrawn? --/--/--
Decision due by __1__1__ made __1__1__ filed TC 1__1__ mailed --/--/--
See related cases lawsuits other
F,\'o'I!-'S\Say1e\Charles\ZBA APP 12002) ,doc
@@{J2>~
2 :::0
~ m
(")
N f11
~
,.-"
_c_
-0 l~n
W
- :::;
-.J
ADDENDUM TO APPLICATION OF
CHARLES F. SAYLE AND KATHLEEN M. SAYLE
As requested by the Zoning Enforcement Officer in his letter of
July 19, 2002, the applicants hereby request that the Board of
Appeals amend the Special Permit relief from parking requirements
granted by the Decision in File No. 115-93 to reflect the fact that
the retail space upon the locus is used for take-out food service.
The applicants further request a Special Permit under Nantucket
Zoning By-law ~139-9.B(2), items (i) [food processing,
manufacturing and packaging] and (0) [take-out food establishment]
to permit these useSi and a Special Permit under ~139-20.C to waive
the requirement for an off-street loading space,
No retail activities are conducted upon the locus other than those
related to sales of food to be consumed off-premises,
The building upon the locus contains an area open to the public in
which food and food products are soldi a commercial kitchen area in
which both take-out food and food products sold to trade accounts
are preparedi an office ancillary to the food operationsi ancillary
storagei and two dwelling units on the second floor,
The total number of required parking spaces for these uses under
~139-18.D is 10 (5 for a take-out food establishment with one
stationi 2 for up to seven employeesi I for office space of about
160 square feeti 0 for storage, which is ancillary and does not
exceed 45~ square feeti and 2 for the two dwelling units) .
In File No. 115-93, the Board of Appeals granted Special Permit
relief under 5139-18.B, to waive two of the six parking spaces that
were then computed to be required, with the food sales area having
been calculated as retail space rather than as a take-out food
station.
F: \wpS\Sayle\Charles\ZBA ADD (2002) .doc
~0'Z:B!l.".~.~
~"";;;1""';'""'f'
.~"."~"""':"".,.."':~
I
I-
~
o
z
-~
ot0~
~o !l..
~f:J
~
V'/' "9~
" ('+ ~A"\ Y..>-
" /' \(' <~
"" ('-1-- /' G'/,
" ,~<A 0-1--
, " \/-1--
"
"
"
"
'"
't
t))o
~-
~J'_
~
--
-
,-----1
I 9'x20' I po.rking
I I spo.ce
L_____-'
REFERENCE: BOARD OF APPEALS
DESCISION NANTUCKET REGISTRY OF DEEDS
BOOK 0438 PAGE 105
THE STRUCTURES
ARE lOCATED AS SHOVN
ZONING: RC
MINIMUM lOT SIZE: 5,000 SF.
MINIMUM FRONTAGE: 40 FT
FRONT YARD SETBACK: NONE
REAR 8. SIDE SETBACK: 5 FT
GROUND COVER RA TID: 50%
PARKING PLAN
PLOT PLAN OF lAND IN
NANTUCKET, MA
SCALE: 1'::: 15'
DA TE: JULY 12, 2002
JOHN J, SHUGRUE, INC.
57 OLD SOUTH ROAD
NANTUCKE~ MA 02554
FOR: CHARLES SAYLES
ASSESSORS MAP 55.1.4
PARCEL NO. 37
#3816PP
Town and County of Nantucket
Board of Selectmen. County Commissioners
Frank T. Spriggs, Chairman
Timothy M. Soverino
Stephen L. Bender
Matthew G. Fee
Finn Murphy
16 Broad Street
Nantucket, Massachusetts 02554
Telephone (508) 228-7255
Faarin1ile (508) 228-7272
www.town.nantucket.ma.us
C. Elizabeth Gibson
Town & County Administrator
July 16, 2002
Arthur Reade, Jr. Esquire
Six Young's Way
Nantucket, MA 02554
RE: Sayle's Seafood Common Victualler License
Dear Mr. Reade:
This office is in receipt of your letter dated July 15, 2002, requesting a further extension of
time in order for your client to obtain the necessary sign-offs for his common victualler
license.
As a result of your client's cooperation in this matter thus far, this office will grant your
client's request for an extension till July 31, 2002. Please contact this office if you have any
questions. Thank you.
Sincerely,
fl~OfU:-
Licensing Agent
pc: Board of Selectmen
Building Department
Zoning Enforcement Officer
?~
,l~~.-s.~\
It~'?
:0/ \(,.1
-"I' -- ~l"'-
:.;. , ' 1 ~ i
\1", ~~J.-\'f
C'o'<:::::;~."~ ~
~PoRAlf.<!l;'~
Town of Nantucket
Office of Zoning Enforcement
37 Washington St., Nantucket, MA 02554
Marcus Silverstein
Zoning Officer
Ph. 508-325,7578
Fax: 508-325-7579
July 19, 2002
Charles Sayle, Jr.
P.O. Box 1062
Nantucket, MA 02554
Dear Mr. Sayle:
Your request for a building permit for kitchen improvements, and for Certificates of
Occupancy for Building Permit nos. 246-75, 648-77, 2906-83, 13645-96, and 874-98, for
other work, at 103 Washington St. (Map# 55.1.4, Parcel# 37), has been denied for the
following reason(s):
. The site plan, dated July 12, 2002, submitted as part of your request shows two
front yard "coolers" for which no Historic District Commission approval or use
permit has been issued.
. A rear deck encroachment onto property owned by the Nauticon Realty Trust, 97
Washington St. (Map# 55.1.4, Parcel# 6), which during the hearing for Zoning
Board Special Permit no. 115-93 was represented as having been removed,
remains; said encroachment must be corrected.
. The expansion of "Sayle's Seafood" to include take-out service will require an
amendment of your Z.B.A. special permit (#115-93). Please contact Linda
Williams, Acting Administrator to the Zoning Board, at 508-228-7215 for
information on how to proceed.
Your application materials will be held in the Building Department, in the file for 103
Washington St., and will be kept until you can retrieve them, or these issues are resolved.
If you have any questions regarding this notice please call, fax or visit.
~Ks:ectfull
~~~ i stein
Zoning Enforcement Officer
Town of Nantucket
Cc: on file
Please be advised that an appeal of this denial may be filed with the Zoning Board of Appeals pursuant to ~139-31A(2) of the Town of
Nantucket Zoning Code.
c
c
~
..-!
, . '~
,
,
N 102.000
.
., .
<i0
f~
v00
Q'
+~+
~
I
~f
~~
~~
TO...~
~#fO,,~
0,. Ir.c....,. ~
Jt<3< i.lc I
".......1'10" k <,.
~
~
"
<.>
"
~
'"
...
'"
-i-
I
J
'U''''V(:O{<<T
...
<.>
'"
~
<.>
~
';
:} '.:
';"~ -x .,':
<.>
~
~~~.~-->~
; -; -:~'
...
. .~..::~,
Iud ('OI1I1f\' of
UCI{ET
dill S( \ t. t,s
;;;
~'.~-:>:
c::J(__)
SCHOFIELO BROTHERS, INC. DO
""OH:'SS40"A... CHCHrc(I:"$ . "<~4'S'(.,,(O ""-.0 S\tfIlvt T'OtlS
t.. "(.Of;flAt. 5'.. ........TVCfl,(T. ....~~S:
.., 101 O"X)
Skf{ r tHO( k
a
;.~-
t-}f
v~j~~(
~- ....~,-- ,,:
r ~t;y,
1t~1
~.. '''~:':'~'''.
\
i
. \,
\' ,)
Wd-.-
, J ~
~ ~ g Z
.z~ V~2
'\~~:';:O
~ T ~~:
~'
"\i'
iI;.'
~:Q~
~ .....~ ~~':J
~ ~:if~~~~:~
VJ~.i" )4 )JlE.L?~!.-~~~~
J~. ~'.~7~+:~L% ,;;~~';:;;;zt
.. '\'''' 6'... 61... ~. 1'1)." TlllJ~
~~~~~~
55.1.4
TOWN OF NANTUCKET
BOARD OF APPEALS
NANTUCKET, MASSACHUSETTS 02554
Date:
January 14
, 19 94
To: Parties in Interest and Others concerned with the
Decision of the BOARD OF APPEALS in the Application of the
f ol ].cwi ng:
Application No.:
115-93
Owner/Applicant:
CHARLES F. SAYLE AND KATHLEEN M. SAYLE
Enclosed is the Decision of the BOARD OF APPEALS which has
this day been filed in the office of the Nantucket Town
Clerk.
An Appeal from this Decision may be taken pursuant to
Section 17 of Chapter 40A, Massachusetts General Laws.
Any action appealing the Decision must be brought by
filing an complaint in court within TWENTY (20) days after
this day's date. Notice of the action with a copy of the
complaint and certified copy of the Decision must be given
to the Town Clerk so as to be received within such TWENTY
(20) days.
UdbCL/ /!)cuu;
Chairman
Dale W. Waine
cc: Town Clerk
Planning Board
Building Commissioner
NANTUCKET BOARD OF APPEALS
10 South Beach street
Nantucket, Massachusetts 02554
Map 55.1.4
Parcel 37
Zoning District: R-C
103 Washington Street Extension
Deed Reference: Book 150, Page 246
Plan Book 19 Page 28, Lot E
Decision:
At a public hearing of the Board of Appeals held at 12: 00
P.M. on Friday, December 10, 1993, at the Town and County
Building, Broad Street, Nantucket, Massachusetts, on the
application of CHARLES F. SAYLE and KATHLEEN M. SAYLE, Post
Office Box 1062, Nantucket, Massachusetts 02554, Board of Appeals
File No. 115-93, the Board made the following decision:
1. Applicants seek relief by Variance pursuant to Nantucket
Zoning By-Law ~139-32 from the requirements of Nantucket zoning
By-Law ~139-16A, or in the alternative, by Special Permit under
Nantucket Zoning By-Law ~139-33A, to validate the siting of an
outside two story stairway and of decks constructed on a said to
be preexisting, nor.-.;;onforming structure known as Sayle's
Seafoods. The unenc10.3ed stairway and decks were sited wi thin
zero feet of the rear yard lot line at their closest point, and
within 3.8+ feet of the northwesterly side yard lot line at their
closest point. The zoning district requires a 5 foot rear and
side yard setback. Applicants also seek relief by Special Permit
under Nantucket Zoning By-Law ~139-18B and by Variance pursuant
to Nantucket Zoning By-Law ~139-32 from the off street parking
requirements of Nantucket Zoning By-Law ~139-18A. six spaces are
required, 3 spaces that meet zoning are provided, relief is
sought to waive 3 spaces. The subject premises (the "Locus") is
located at 103 WASHINGTON STREET EXTENSION, Assessor's Map
55.1.4, Parcel 37, as shown on Plan Book 19, Page 28, Lot E. The
property is zoned RESIDENTIAL-COMMERCIAL.
2. This Decision is based upon the application and
materials presented with it, and the evidence presented at the
hearing. No opposition was expressed by neighbors. The Planning
Board staff made unfavorable recommendations as to the variance
relief and the special permit relief relating to the rear yard
setback intrusions; they made a favorable recommendation on the
special permit parking relief, provided that the reduced spaces
were made available for public use. Concern was expressed that
the structure actually encroached upon land of an abutter; the
applicants represented at our hearing that this encroachment had
been removed.
3. Parking requirements under the By-law for the existing
uses upon the Locus are as follows:
-1-
Use
2 Apartments
First floor retail
space - 120 sq. ft.
Employees
storage
Office - 160 sq. ft.
Total
4. We find that while the siting of the outside two-story
stairway and decks within the required side and rear yard
setbacks intensify the nonconforming nature of the structure upon
the Locus, the stairway and decks are not substantially more
detrimental than the preexisting nonconformity. Accordingly, by
a unanimous vote, we GRANT the Special Permit relief requested
under ~139-33A to validate the siting of the outside two story
stairway and decks within zero feet of the rear yard lot line and
within 3.8+ feet of the northwesterly side yard lot line at their
closest point, as shown upon the plot plan attached hereto as
Exhibit A, upon the condition that no further building shall be
allowed upon the Locus without further relief from this Board.
5. We further find that it would be physically impossible
for the applicants to provide the six parking spaces required
under the By-law for the uses on the Locus, and that granting a
Special Permit to waive a certain number of the required spaces
would be in harmony with the general purposes and intent of the
By-law. Accordingly, by a vote of 4 to 1 (Balas opposed) we
GRANT a Special Permit pursuant to the provisions of
~139-18B. (2) (a) and (b) of the By-law, and waive the required
number of parking spaces from six spaces to four spaces. Said
four parking spaces may be provided anywhere on the Locus, and
need not be in conformity with the parking plan presented with
the application, but must conform to all dimensional requirements
of the By-law, must be available to the public at all times
without obstruction, and must be provided . t~' n the lO,t lines
and not in the Way shown upon Exhibit A. _-
Dated: January~, 1994 I
Robert ~~hter
'Mara
kah/41/SAYLEl
-2-
. EiIsriNG:
S-.9 6 -1- >I: .s.;::
~~;c: !:"+~~
N
. . . , t . . . .
..
. , t ';.. . . .
. . . t , . . . .
""~~'<"T>'
\S'
~
'.
\
"
/'
/' 1.5'
/' ~
/" ~
./ ( -(0,",,0
./ \ J.5 1".
""'" ..-~
--....-
~
/ / ";\
./ /
y! ..- 9~
"
"l,\
-l-
(1\<:)
. ~
..- ~
-....
...- '\ \)l
11\
,.- \ \l
...- \
,.-
,.-
~
~ .....-"-
;-'
,.- ";.:1; /. -f. - 71
,.-
~
,.- CI....II.."/if;Z> 8">/ ANTOIV.I!:'
./ J. 1-1.';1..1-.0 Ct- .ll.~
;-'
...-
S'S./.-<J. - .3""
, 1'1./~
~V.sT~ J.
:JJ~1C4.c>,. TR..
...-
.....-
,.,
I CERTIFY, AS OF : .~-. ~<f.- f7.3. . . , 1HA.T
THE BUILOING(S) IS/ARE LOCATED ON THE
GROUND AS SHOWN HEREON.
eIC.oA.li1-{)) .~~
PROFESSIONAL WID SURVEYOR
BUILDING LOCATION PLAN
OF lAND IN
NANTUCKET, MASS.
Ji!e.v.: IO-I.s--~':3
SCAI.E: ,..20' DATE: s-z~.~~
Owner: q,,!~~J.;Af~ ~ ~ -rr:. ~ .Kr*-,Tfif.~~-:-t."":<.
-5AY..<....e::, ;::'or $
Deed: . . . . . . . . . . . Plan ../..3.- (G.8. . . .
'THIS PLOT PLAN W.4S PREPARED FOR lHE TOWN
OF NANTUCKeT BUILDING DEPARlllENT ONLY AND
,SHOULD NOT BE CONSIDERED A PROPERTY UNE
SURVEY. lHlS PlAN SfiOULO NOT SE USED TO
ESTABUSH PROPERTY UNES, fENCES, HEDGES, OR
ANY ANCILLARY STRUCTURES ON lHE PRDlISES.
THE PROPERTY UNES SHOWN RaY ON CURRENT
DEEDS AND PlANS OF RECORD.
THJS PLOT PLAN IS NOT A CDmFlCATION .4S TO
mu: OR OWNERSHIP OF THE: PROPERTY SHOWN.
OWNERS OF ADJOINING PROPERTIes ARe SHOWN
ACCORDING TO CURRENT ASSESSOR RECORDS.
.4SSESSOR MAP:-4"~.,1~~, PARCa: .~~ . .
'\J08S\t'fIf\'"
Locua '-;-~3. ~A..s.~/:"".G.':O/,<: ~T1 ...Ei>p;.. .
CHARLES Y. HART & ASSOCIATES, Inc.
SWORD BOAT BUILDING
, 49 SPARKS AVENUE
NANTUCKET, YASS, 02554
(608) 228-8910 H-3~88
NOT TO Sf RECORD
TOWN OF NANTUCKET
BOARD OF APPEALS
NANTUCKET, MASSACHUSETTS 02554
Date:
January 14
, 19 94
CERTIFICATE OF GRANTING OF ~X~XXN~XXXN>>~~NXSPECIAL PERMIT
(Massachusetts General Laws, Chapter 40A, section 11)
The BOARD OF APPEALS of the TOWN OF NANTUCKET, hereby certifies
that a ~X~!X~~~~~XSPECIAL PERMIT has been GRANTED:
To: (Owner/Applicant)
CHARLES F. SAYLE, JR. AND KATHLEEN M.
SAYLE (115-93)
Address:
103 Washinqton Street Extension, P.O. Box 1062, Nantucket,
MA 02554
affecting the rights of the Owner/Applicant with respect to land or
building at:
103 Washington Street Extension, Assessor's Map 55.1.4,
Parcel 37, as shown on Plan Book 19, Page 28, Lot E
Deed Reference:
150/246
And the BOARD OF APPEALS further certifies that the attached
Decision is a true and correct copy of its Decision GRANTING the
~~>>>>~X~XXSPECIAL PERMIT and that copies of the Decision and of
all plans referred to -in the Decision have been filed with the Planning
Board and the Town Clerk.
The BOARD OF APPEAL~ calls to the attention of the Owner/
Applicant that General-Laws, Chapter 40A, Section 11 (last paragraph)
provides that no ~~~~~XSPECIAL PERMIT, or any EXTENSION,
MODIFICATION or RENEWAL thereof, shall take effect until. (a) a copy of
the Decision is certified by the Town Clerk that TWENTY (20) days have
elapsed after the Decision has been filed in the office of the Town
Clerk and no appeal has been filed (or, if such appeal has been filed,
that it has been dismissed or denied) and (b) the certified copy is
recorded in the Registry of Deeds for the County of Nantucket and
indexed in the grantor index under the name of the Owner of Record or
is recorded and noted on the Owner's Certificate of Title. The fee for
such recording or registering shall be paid by t e Owner/Applicant.
~(J) {fhu~~
airman
Clerk
07/24/2002 13:57 FAX 5082285630
RE...DE GrLLICKSE
l4J 001
BoA Form
2-89
,~d:J (p ,t; d
NANTUCKET ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS
TOWN AND COUNTY BUILDING
NANTUCKET, MA 02554
ASSESSOR'S LIST OF PARTIES rN INTEREST
PROPERTY OWNER' ~1..Mlt.~ r 1.:: ~tu~ I-A. 5"-7 ftJ . ,
APP:LlcA1~T FOR RELIEF (SAME? V'): C-,fD ~) Gvlln,{~1 ~J(I~Uf
ADDRESS OF PROPERTY: fD'~ V\)~,~ ~J":j-t ' *
ASSESSOR'S MAP - PARCEL: ~~ - ;,~ *
LIST OF PARTIES INCLUDING ADDRESSES*(OR SEE ATTACHED ) :
RECEIVED
BOARD OF 'AS.SESSORS
JUL 2 2 Z002
TOWN OF
NANTUCKET, MA
I certify that the foregoing (~r the attached ) lists
all persons, natural or legal, who are owners ~abutting
property, owners of land directly opposite on any public
or private street or waf, and abutters of the abutters and
all other land owners w~thin th~ee hundred feet of the
property 1 ine of- O\tmer I s property, as they (and their
address) appear on the ~ost recent applicable tax list
[per M.G.L. C.40A, Section 11 and zoning code Chapter l39,
Section 139-29D(2)J.
Jtt ~3. Od-
te '
~ '. a~
~~ . ~~
A sessor, Town Nant:uc et
*NOTE: Applicant (petitioner) should include with the lot .
for which zoning relief' is sought, any commonly-owned,
abutting lots which might become involved in the zoning .
matter. List map and parcels for each abutter. '
...~ - ~..-.... .
"" ........- ,-,
,'.
,.'
..................--
,
,J
.......
tV
'..J
......
~
o
,~
lnlJllnln.."t.nlltll'l""U\tJ\UlI,J'IU'lU1,,"lI1iJ1l11""""',,""'Ul~\lt""'''U1 :I
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~.
~~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 'U
. . . . . . ~ ~ . ~ ~ ~ ~ . ~ . . . . ~ . . . .. ~ . . W
u...\
~
~
I
"'
.......
tV
'"'
t-'\II~....~~~a"toO"la"tG\C7\lI1~~WL..1Wt---6foJ"'''''-*'CP'IO\''''''''. t""
O...w~""Ot.bm.~"....JwtmtO\lI1~"""N ...,... 0
'" III ..
co
'ti
~
t~
~ I
~ ~
~
'-
--t::
~ ~ ~ ~ I
tl : "= r;i In
a ~ i4 = ~
~ ~ = ~ ~
to III '" I tII
'II Z
.. 0
~ Ir' 'IJ n
(') il' il'
~ l'!
>-i I>l
~ ~
... I<C
~ t"
5 ~
:;: ::J
~ 0
::Ii
~ ~
II t"'
! i
;
~
t"
:it
,
.....
~
,
to-' P'd ~ .... ..... ..oJ t1
.,.0..00.,..0
~ 2 ~ ! ~ liJ ~
~ :;: i ~ i; ~ :0:
(1l" ~ CIl ~
"'~~titi~
I-'
~ a ~ i ~
I<C ~ f4 ~ ~
CI ca III ell III
~~!~~
:a 1; ~ ~
!1 It> H
: i :
~ i:
=
:s
i
fA
~
:i:l
~
H
..... rI D'l a..
II) (D .. ...
)I
fa ~ ~ i
H 00'"
~ 1II lIS 0
fa 11\ z:
fA >-I I-l &I>
'" ti
~
~
~
I<C
;1
/:l
CIl
t'l
...
~ ...
...
i ~ ~ i I ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ i ~ I
I<C ~ ~ ~ . ~ Q Q tl ~ ~
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
~ I-l ; ~ ~ I ~ H 2 n ~ ~ m =
I<C 0 ~ 0 ~ · III ~ 9 i ~ .. ~ ~
il' j ~ ~ = ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ tl ~ .
~ ~ ~ m .. .. ~ .. < n = n I
~ 8 ~ I e ~ ~ ~ ~ 5 ~
H lA I<C ~ ~ o~
C ~ ~ "f;
~ .. III ......
~ i :;
o CIl
8~ ~ ~~
.. ~
t )<4
o
...
...
I/l.
~
VI
III
H
!Pl
t;l
a
II:
III
I-l
Q 'D
~ ::
n
tll
t'
H
i:
III
Ii>
~
'"
tlI
~
g
2 :s
"'J 2
i I
~ ;;
~ n
III
~
;
\II
~ ~ i
~ ~ ~
III ~ ~
2 = .
! ~ I
1lI I
~ ~
lA
..
I'l
~ u; ~ ~ ~
..a
s U' III III '" l!: e
e III 2 IOl lot ~
.. ~~"o
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
~!8::'lE-:;
lt1 Ii:
~
~~~~~=~~~~e== ~
. ~
III SlllDlII~llI'CllIlt1
~=~~~~w~~~o g
~ 1ft I-' t!; ~ ... l!j ... ... i ~ II
~ ~ ~ CIl ~ ~ ~ ~ ; _.., ~
~ z ~ ~ ti ~ ~ - ~ - ~
~ ~ ~ ~
o ..; III
!Ill CIl.
'" ti
Ul
i-l
~ i i ~ I I I I i I ~ i : ~ i I I ~ i ~ i I
... ... ~ . . ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ . z . ~ ~ tll ~ ... ~ ~ ~
'" '" ~ rl ti .., ~ ~ ~ ~ '" ~ n ti ~ ~ I-l ~ '" '" ti ~
H
Ul
n
o
ID
c::I
H
b
~
l2
Q
~
o
0-1
~
EO
I-l
~
~
....
t-i
UUUP
s !j ~ ~ ~
~~~Ji~~~~~~i5~&;~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ ~
OOQOOQoccooocmc;:.OOOOOQQOCOOOOOO t3
to.JWlroJloJ~Nt.J~to.Je..3tl.JlJ""~N...,tl.le.J"'tlJNNNNNfl.JNtvU )-
I/l. ~ U' U' U' ~ lt1 lt1 lt1 ~ ~ U' .... III ~ lt1 lt1 ~ ~ ~ ~ lt1 lt1 lt1 ~ lt1 ~ ... U' ~
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 0 . ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 0 ~
. . . ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ . ~ ~ . . . ~ . . . . . ~ . . . ~ .
.
'"
'"
'"
...
"'::
0>
,.0
ro
...
o
'D
~ ~ 8 ~
t6 0 0 0
=r: Zl Z Z
....
~ ~ ~ ~
~
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ . ~ ~ ~ m ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
~ ~ m ~ ~ 0 . . ~ . m _ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ m 0 ~
... > ~ ~... ~ ~. ~ 0
~ ~ ~ i ~ ~ ~ 8 ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ = = ~ ~ i
m i i 0 ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ Z H
~ m m Z Ul m ~ ~ !! ~ ~ v. ~ ~ ! ~ Zg" ~
~ 0-1 0-1 m I-l '" t'l ti "' ~ ~ = ~ ~ ~ "' ~ 0
~ '" ~ ~ ~ Oz 0 g ~ ~
z :~s~ =llIlllllZl~
~ ..,~>< ~~~ti~
,...
Ul
"l
3:S)[.) I 11l1~ 3(JV]~
zoo [g
~~~~~ ':
:Il en 'l
~~!t~ ~
~ :I: :I: ;I: ~
~i~~~ ~
~~l2~~ ~.
r6t1tn P
tII 0-1 ~ '"
'"'
al
c:l
19
j
1II
11
I
III
.
5
~
!;
~CT
~
~.,
~ID
tQ~
I-! ....
CD
~ ~.
~
l"
'"
OC9SfiZZSOS XVd .!oS: {;l ZOOZII'Z; lO