HomeMy WebLinkAbout022-02
TOWN OF NANTUCKET
BOARD OF APPEALS
NANTUCKET, MASSACHUSEITS 02554
Date:
A-trl ( f
, 200~
To: Parties in Interest and. others concerned with the
Decision of the BOARD OF APPEALS in the Application of the
following:
Application No.:
Owner/Applicant:
R u35el \
cl2.;z - 0;)-
g:au I -r. (] VI c.{ f J (J rile..- J3.
Enclosed is the Decision of the BOARD OF APPEALS which has
this day been filed in the office of the Nantucket Town
Clerk.
An Appeal from this Decision may be taken pursuant to
Section 17 of Chapter 40A, Massachusetts General Laws.
Any action appealing the Decision must be brought by
filing an complaint in court within TWENTY (20) days after
this day's date. Notice of the action with a copy of the
complaint and certified copy of the Decision must be given
to the Town Clerk so as to be received within such TWENTY
(20) days.
\a(t~)~ ~ c;~, Mlq LO
Nancy qe~ . / Chairman -
cc: Town Clerk
Planning Board
Building Commissioner
PLEASE NOTE: MOST SPECIAL PERMITS AND V~IANCES HAVE A TIME
LIMIT AND WILL EXPIRE IF NOT ACTED UPON ACCORDING'TO NANTUCKET
ZONING BY-LAW g139-301 (SPECIAL PERMITS); 6139-321 (VARIANCES)
ANY QUESTIONS, PLEASE CALL THE NANTUCKET ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS.
NANTUCKET WNING BOARD OF APPEALS
1 East Chestnut Street
Nantucket, Massachusetts 02554
Assessor's Map 76.1.4/Parcels 7 - 15
Assessor's Map 76.4.1/Parcels 447 - 458
LUG-3
2 Fairfield St., Tom Nevers
L.C. Plan 5004-Y/5004-G,
Lots 2 -9, 84 - 92, 487 - 489
COT 2101/9198
At a Public Hearing of the Nantucket Zoning Board of Appeals held at 1 :00 P.M.,
Friday, March 8, 2002, in the Conference Room, Town Annex Building, 37 Washington
Street, Nantucket, Massachusetts, on the Application of PAUL T. AND ELAINE B.
RUSSELL, of2 Fairfield Street, Nantucket, MA 02554, Board of Appeals File No. 022-
02, the Board made the following Decision:
1. Applicants are seeking relief by V ARIANCE under Nantucket Zoning By-Law
Section 139-16A (Intensity Regulations - ground cover). Applicants are asking the Board
to validate a ground cover of about 3.6%, when a maximum ground cover of 1,500 square
feet or 3% is allowed for a subminimum lot of record. Applicants are also seeking further
V ARIANCE relief under the same section to construct an about 49 square-foot enclosed
entryway that would increase the ground cover to about 3.7%. There would be no further
alteration of the footprint and all parking would continue to be provided on the site,
which contains a garage apartment and a separate single-family dwelling. All setback
requirements would continue to be met.
The Premises is located at 2 FAIRFIELD STREET, TOM NEVERS, Assessor's
Map 76.1.4, Parcels 7 - 15, and Map 76.4.1, Parcels 447 - 458, Land Court Plan 5004-Y
and 5004-G, Lots 2 - 9, 84 - 92 and 487 - 489. The property is zoned Limited- Use-
General-3.
2. The Decision is based upon the Application and materials submitted with it and
the testimony and evidence presented at the hearings. The Planning Board made no
recommendation as the matter was not of planning concern. An interested member of the
public was present in the audience and expressed support for the Application.
3. Applicants represented that they had bought the vacant lot of record in 1985. They
built the secondary garage apartment first in 1986 then built the primary dwelling in
1988. They obtained a Certificate of Occupancy for the garage apartment during a time
when the Building Department did not require an as-built survey. They had set the batter
boards themselves and thought that the garage had a ground cover of about 676 square
feet. Based upon the figure, Applicants obtained a new Building Permit to construct the
primary home which indicated a ground cover of about 822 square feet, again setting the
batter boards themselves, which was the custom during those years to save money. When
an as-built survey was done in 1996, Applicants found out that they had a problem with
ground cover. They surmised that the difference was due to the fact that they had
--
measured the ground cover to the foundation and not the finished wall as required by the
By-Law. They are allowed a ground cover of either 3% or 1500 square feet, whichever is
greater. The existing ground cover is about 1532 square feet or about 3.6%. Applicants
are asking the Board to validate the existing ground cover ratio of about 3.6%.
Applicants are also seeking further Variance relief under the same section to
construct an about 49 square-foot enclosed entryway onto the primary dwelling that
would increase the ground cover to about 3.7%. Applicants wish to add an enclosed
entryway to the primary dwelling to allow reconfiguration of the interior entry foyer that
is problematic. It would allow the moving out of the main exterior door to allow the other
interior doors to work more properly and allow for safe exit from the dwelling in case of
an emergency. All setback and parking requirements would continue to be met.
4. Therefore, based upon the foregoing, the Board finds that the grant of relief to
validate the existing ground cover ratio would be in harmony with the general purpose
and intent of the Zoning By-Law. The Board further finds that a grant of relief by
Variance is appropriate in this case and that owing to circumstances relating to the
topography of the structures, constructed in good faith at a time when as-built site plans
were not required and many measured the ground cover to the foundation wall rather than
the finished walls, and especially affecting such land or structures but not affecting
generally the zoning district in which it is located, a literal enforcement of the provision
of this Zoning By-Law would involve substantial hardship, financial or otherwise, to the
Applicants, and a grant of relief would not cause substantial detriment to the public good,
and have little impact upon the neighborhood, and the desirable relief may be granted
without nullifying or substantially derogating from the intent or purpose of the By-Law.
The Board further finds that the existing improvements would have no impact upon the
neighborhood as they have existed in their present configuration for about 15 years and
are arguably protected from any enforcement action under the curative provisions in
MGL Chapter 40~ Section 7.
However, the Board further finds that are insufficient grounds upon which to base
a grant of Variance reliefto allow the increase in the ground cover ratio to about 3.7% to
allow construction of an about 49 square-foot exterior entryway. Upon a request made by
the Applicants to withdraw without prejudice that portion of the requested relief: the
Board voted unanimously to allow said withdrawal.
5. Accordingly, by a 1)Jl~nimous vote, the Board GRANTS the requested relief by
VARIANCE under Nantucket Zoning By-Law Section 139-16A to validate the existing
ground cover of the two dwelling units upon the Locus, with a maximum ground cover of
about 1532 square feet, or about 3.6%. Relief is conditioned upon the following:
a. The structures are constructed in substantial conformance with the
"Building Location Plan", done by Charles W. Hart & Associates, Inc., dated April 8,
1996, a reduced copy of which is attached hereto as Exhibit A.
(022-02)
Dated: April <{' , 2002
....
~-
L...0----
Edward Toole
~ ::0
-42:
o::t:~ :Ja ~'r;
=e~. -0 --
z:"'-, ::c ..
n c=: I
CD
,c.
/"T1 :: \J
:;lJ1 - i , j
~.- ,
A "-
VI
. . -....
. .1"'- /
s;l'.-?O~ $.F'
~l;'..~Qff
:j; .' . . 3.S":n::
.;';.. tt:?-:*< I"T
\... ''2 .,;;0
'C.l.t11!~ . ~,. .-.-t ./17
EXISTlNG:
. Z"~/ef1.~/
.~:;e:' ~
. . . ."~. . . .
N
. . . .~; . . . .
. . . . . . . . .
h.
~
~
,
.,
....
~
'. ,
.~ .~
C'(
~
~
.~
~
.~
........ .....
\ - .....
\ -
\
\
\
_ .!11 ~r _,
--
,- -. . .e:xIS77<<C,
\ _ __ ~~VV.-<y
, ....^~KC;
\
\
(;.<:.. ' 8'Yo.S.~ .
I
I
~I
~I'
I
r.v'.o<(J
,l.or.5 ,e - <1 /.....e.
8.1t'- <1.:5 HoC.
'1"$7- t'Sq /~.
~
~
V)
~
Icl
~ ~
~
....
-~---
, -
<;;.c.' (,;9::e. S.I?"
I
111
~
I
I
I
I
--
;;eao.oo
7~.f:/-/T/O
K/..-- .
O..::r. )<.t~,.c r.e.
PROFESSIONAL lAND SURVE'l'OR
THIS PlOT PlAN WAS PREPARED FOR THE TOWN
OF ~ BUILDING DEPARTUENT ONLY AND
SHOI,ly?;' NOT BE CO~OERm A PROPERTY UNE
SURVf.'(~; ,JHIS PLNi SHOUlD ~E U. SED TO
ESTAB'WVPROPERTY UHES, HEDGES, OR
ANY ANPlLLARY STRUCTURES ON niE PREMISES.
THE PROPERTY LINES SHOWN RELY ON CURRENT
DEEDsi AND PLANS OF RECORD.
THIS PAm. PLAN IS NOT A CERTIFICATION IS TO
TJ1Jl _ OWNERSHIP' OF TtfE PROPERlY SHOWN.
OWNE@' OF ADJOWING PROPfR1lfS ARE SHOWN
AccoRolNG TO CURRENT ASSESSOR RECORDS.
ASSESSOR MAP: . "7,'"..;(, 1": PARCEl.: . 7. . .
BUILDING LOCATION PLAN
OF lAND IN
NANTUCKET, MASS.
SCALE: 1- - ~o' DATE:..v"oC. Sol /996
Owner:RAQ.l. T....~-Y4" 13, ;ep,5.s~.
. /.;:' 10/ ,.(...C. ~~~JI#
Deed: ~~.' .'V. . . . Plan.l.G'~Je'-
Locus .~. t:A(~Q"A-<P. .sr~KT..
CHARLES W. HART & ASSOCIATES, Inc.
~~~1'A=G
.,dcur, KASS. 02554
(508) 228-8910 H -r~~
NOT TO BE RfCORl)S); - ~
TOWN OF NANTUCKET
ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS
37 WASHINGTON STREET
NANTUCKET, MASSACHUSETIS 02554
PHONE 508-228-7215
FAX 508-228-7205
NOTICE
A Public Hearing of the NANTUCKET WNlNG BOARD OF APPEALS will be held at 1:00
P.M., FRIDAY, MARCH 8, 2002, IN THE CONFERENCE ROOM, TOWN ANNEX BUILDING,
37 Washington Street, Nantucket, Massachusetts, on the Application of the following:
PAUL T. AND ELAINE B. RUSSELL
BOARD OF APPEALS FILE NO. 022-02
Applicants are seeking relief by VARIANCE under Nantucket Zoning By-Law Section 139-16A
(Intensity Regulations - ground cover). Applicants are asking the Board to validate a ground cover of
about 3.6%, when a maximum ground cover of 1,500 square feet or 3% is allowed for a subminimum lot
of record. Applicants are also seeking further VARIANCE relief under the same Section to construct an
about 49 square-foot enclosed entryway that would increase the ground cover to about 3.7%. There
would be no further alteration of the footprint and all parking would continue to be provided on the site,
which contains a garage apartment and a separate single-family dwelling. All setback requirements
would continue to be met.
The Premises is located at 2 FAIRFIELD STREET, TOM NEVERS, Assessor's Map 76.1.4,
Parcels 7 - 15, and Map 76.4.1, Parcels 447 - 458, Land Court Plan 5004- Y and 5004-G, Lots 2 - 9, 84 -
92 and 487 - 489. The property is zoned Limited- Use-General-3.
(!~ffWAV ~
TIllS NOTICE IS AVAILABLE IN LARGE PRINT OR OTHER ALTERNATIVE
FORMATS. PLEASE CALL 508-228-7215 FOR FURTHER INFORMATION.
~~ 10= :1.-8$1
fi., I
" '
.0'1
..
"
WW':UOCU:U ZO~;WG S~ e~ U>PnLS o~te
~O\nl ~, COlm~~ S"O%~:tllG
~UOQ~, ~ OU$. CASE No .cfi!::V..::!dl-
J\PPLtOJl.'.L':teN peR RBL:tBP
:~ ,O~I, n~~(a) I
f. '~~ ~~eaal
,11'~~t'a n~.1
"
WlU1n; &clc!~eaa I
'.
tlooat1on 0: lotI As..a~o~l~ ~ap ~nc1 p,,~o.l nU'lJJbe~7(~:f..-
. ,
.SbMt ~U.I :l 9
aa;ta~ 'ct '~lan, l;.n ~.' >>~ o~ >>lan "1'J.e~Stb't:l...."tJot ';;~~;&t1-
.... Date ~~ 1.0qu~; -'~D"c1 a.:;:2LQ~ zon1ng~t{.1'i;t Lv';;-, ~ .
. v~.. on '~ot .' ,dQ;ljm.~otaJ.;' Non. .:.. O~ 101C01_' .
. . ..
· nw=U' 0:; c1weU1nga~ c1uplex_ ~paRm.nt._ ~ental roolllS_ ~-C.O
a~41n;'4I.te(a) I aU p~."a/72? _ o~ . /9fG'+ 19X^lt C o~ O?~UftA(-m(!().
~41n~ >>e~t applln. Nos.
CU. HOSt I.J.J., Sol\. ~plicat1ona, lawsu1tal
'Itate :ullY all ~on1n; ~e11.: aO~At &n4 ~.apeot=. COde aeot10ns
aM .=..o~10n8, apaolt1oaUy wha't you propoae ,!tsd to pref,nt .
, Qd WAa't 'P'9W\C!8 YOU =;. tor SoA ~9 ~~ eaoh: _~ per S.o....on .
~'.~IA __ ~"V~~anoe, 139.~OA ~: a Sp.eo1al >>~'t I~ 139"33^
'ra$,~t~ :t~:roh oa.:~~~ ~rn~~~~~~=il~~~) oifo a~~::OhP:ad;~~~~2~
, . "" " .
~
-''1S~
~ a.~(JO~oO odd2J2lAofwrtt
~
):1
~
~~!U tn~o..c1 a. paR 0: thb 'APpUol.'t10na orcl.rl ~ ac1clenclu1ll2_
, _OUl ~ S1te p3.an .now1hq p~e.ent +plannliJQ .tt'Uoturea
. , '~09.': P1au:pr8.8nt~ PioPo.~ 81tWatIOiis ~(HDa ~pprovecl?_).
~~;.~O~~.. - ~~onta~.. .atba~ G ~I.r~n; 4ata___
1I10"!OMct~t~an~..... 'nit 4 .at. -. 1 1&])a1. a aeta_
, !' 0 .... NU3.. to ':own of: Hantuaket -mfocrt cap' Qovanant .
,en q app,.~, ..~ "own 01e~~ ,to ..nn1!i codTI ~.oo~ to loA':"j
~ O'f'ti~:f tAat tAe ~'~est.4 ~nto~at~on 8Ubm1ttec1 ~. 8Ubatanti~11y
. GOIPt' , and . to ~, ~,.t ot tA'/ Jcnow3.e"qe, unc1.~ the pa$,n. anc1
,PIAI.t .. 0: u~
:S%GiA':UUa Applicant ~ Attotney/aqent _
. . , .
,:.~C:: not own.~ or own.r'. attorney, .nolo.. proot ot author1ty)
, '.
. . FOR B~ orrXCB USB ....
App~1cAt1on cop1es tec1d, 4.~ o~___ tor BoA O~~b~ ~J
on~ oop :~J,ec1 w~th Town CJ.o~~ O~~'iIf(JJ{p\ OOlJlpJ.e.tI7-'..d
· Onl ooPY ...oh to Pl~nni~9 Bel anel 8ui~cU,ng Dopt LiY...1t2_,:>~ ~ /){ LJ ' .
\, ,aoo:.. gA'~ q~V.n ':own ':rea.ute~ o~b'l.L~flIJJwa~vec1"_'
. ,Ktu$.n; not~o. po~t.~~ ~aU.c1.&~~ & WZ;~, ~
;..,K"7tn;(.) 'on-l-/_ oontl,) to-'-,_, -/-'_ withc1~awn7-'-'_'
" Om.ton cluo '0'1-1-'_ =14e-, -1_ :Uec1 .,0-1...)_ lRU.c1-.1-''':''
a.. r.bt,~ ,Q~JOJ. . no bw'U~t' ___.. ' othet
,
'If '
-----.. ."."
...
........... .............. .-..... '.
. .. .. .. ..... "f'
d
N :::0
-r! ' m
IT1 (")
CD
~ i1
-
~
-0 71
w
U1 ;~
U1
ADDENDUM
Applicants are seeking relief by VARIANCE under Nantucket Zoning By-Law Section
139-16A (Intensity Regulations - ground cover). Applicants are asking the Board to
validate a ground cover of about 3.6%, when a maximum ground cover of 1,500 square
feet or 3% is allowed for a subminimum lot of record. Applicants are also seeking further
VARIANCE relief under the same Section to construct an about 49 square-foot enclosed
entryway that would increase the ground cover to about 3.7%. There would be no further
alteration of the footprint and all parking would continue to be provided on the site,
which contains a garage apartment and a separate single-family dwelling. All setback
requirements would continue to be met.
Applicants bought the vacant lot of record in 1985. They built the secondary garage
apartment first in 1986 then built the primary dwelling in 1988. They obtained a
Certificate of Occupancy for the garage apartment during a time when the Building
Department did not require an as-built survey. They had set the batter boards themselves
and thought that the garage had a ground cover of about 676 square feet. Based upon the
figure, Applicants obtained a new Building Permit to construct the primary home which
indicated a ground cover of about 822 square feet, again setting the batter boards
themselves, which was the custom during those years to save money. When an as-buih
survey was done in 1996, Applicants found out that they had a problem with ground
cover. They surmised that the difference was due to the fact that they had measured the
ground cover to the foundation and not the finished wall as required by the By-Law. They
are allowed a ground cover of either 3% or 1500 square feet, whichever is greater. The
existing ground cover is about 1532 square feet. Applicants are asking the Board to
validate the de minimus excess in ground cover.
In addition, Applicants are seeking an increase in ground cover with the construction of
an additional about 49 square feet, to add an enclosed entryway to the primary dwelling
to allow reconfiguration of the interior entry foyer that is problematic. It would allow the
moving out of the main door to allow the other interior doors to work properly.
.r",",/
..?~pc>a5'
.~.. . .eQQ ff
<'." . L.:._-.s.s:~
. '. <<< ...c:q. r."
)l'....~~4
EXISllNG:
. j"~NJfl.-'5;E
. ~:;e: ~
. . . /(. . . .
. . . . /! . . . .
~,
I '~
f: I -
"'-
~
~
,
"
....
}C)....... ......
~ \........
\
\
\
\
_ .!If/X _,
.......
.. ,
'~~
i(
~
~
--
..Ii!:X1!!J 77KC,
- __ ~..E"k/';'(Y
--... ...
""~Kc;
"
~.c:.. .. 8.yo~S.1"f
I
I
..\
,
~I'
I
\
,
~~
.t..or.s "e - <f .INC..
8~- 9.:5 HoC.
'1"e7- ~ /K<.
}-..
~
~
V)
~
q
~ ~
~
_~':"'-r_
~.e." ~9;t "S.E
I
'III
~
I
I
I
I
-'
;;wo.oo
7<:' .4':/ - /T/o
K/~
D..::r. ;<G~'< r~.
PROFESSIONAL lAND SURVEYOR
THIS PLOT PLAN oms PREPARED FOR THE TOWN
OF ~ BUILDING DEPNmfENT ONLY AND
sHOI,I~: HOT BE COHSlDERfD A PROPERlY UNE
SU~~ , ...'JHlS. PLAN: SHOUlD ~E. USED TO
ESTAB~-'PROPER1Y ~ES, HEDGES, OR
Nt( AlilPllURY STRUCTURES ON THE PRafISES.
THE P~OPERTY UHfS SHOWN RELY ON CURRENT
oaoS: AND PLANS OF RECORD.
THIS P.L:OT PC.AH IS HOT A CERl1FICATIOH AS TO
mu: Oft. OWNERSHIP' OF 1lfE: PROPERlY SHOWN.
~. OF ADoJOWJHG PROPfRT1ES ARE SHOWN
ACCORPlHG TO CURRENT ASSESSOR RECORDS.
ASSESsOR MAP: , '7."~l6 ~ PARCa.: , 7: , .
BUILDING LOCATION PLAN
OF lAND IN
NANTUCKET, MASS.
SCALE: 1.. ~O' DATE:~.c. sJ'Nl.
Owner:;f'~ 7-"'....~,y~ p, ((U...s.s~.
...--.. /P 10/ ,(..c. 5CJOi"- y
Deed: ...-.;p;:",' .'V. . . . Plan.l.G,~~
. ~/;e
locus. ;;e. t=:'A(~~A~. .sr~KT. .
CHARLES 1'. HART & ASSOCIATES. InC.
SAl(fORD BOAT BUILDJNG
.. SPARKS AVINUI
IUNTaClET. KASs, 02554
NOT TO BE ~ (508) 228-8910 H-;:sess-
.... ',":~~:~~j_~~~:R'
i';f;" .), ..~~;i
.... q .;:;.q ~,;;,.,
Mi": '. .,. ':?':f(~;;:,.
EXISTING:
,1;(S NJfJ. ~.~'
:~<"'~
",I
. . . . . . . . .
//
. . . . . , . . .
;-
. . . . , . , . .
; t - ~
">--0
~
~
/1,/<--1-:
~"""'~ ~....c
.o-s> . \0'
k
~
o
'-
/-;23-02,
? R-O P 0'\5 I!r:/)
( 7'X 7' R:N-
...... CJ....O.s;e;.:J) /CH'TR.Y
':- -\--.. G.C. -::.~9:f:S..F~
. --
'\...... trJ . $XIS77..vG;
\ _ -.. ~..g;V\/..-(y
,,/ --.....,.
\' PA~/KG
'-..
"
.~
~
~
~
~ '-.... \
\
\
\
\
__ .!it' /:1 _\
,
''9
'<I
<'(
c:c. " e90~5.R '
I
I
~I I
\
\
"
~I
I
'---
rK~
~or.s .e - '1 ,INC..
8-'1"- 9.:.5 /he.
~6'7' ~g<? /K~.
~
~
~
V)
~
Icl
~
~
~
_~':"'t'_
" .-
<:;;. c,. ~ G9::G S./."
I
'III
~I
I
I
I
I
;<.00.00 Ii
7<:;; .4-:/ - 7"/0
K/r i
o..::r. ;<E"~'< r,e.
o'
PROFESSIONAL lAND SURVEYOR
THIS PLOT PlAN WAS PREPARED FOR THE TOWN
OF NANTUCKIT aUILDING DEPARTMENT ONLY AND
SHOULD NOT SE CONSIDERED A PROPERlY LINE
SURVEY. .THIS PUN SHOULD NOT BE' USED TO
ESTABUSHPROPERlY LINES, FENCES. HEDGES,OR.
ANY ANCILlARY STRUCTURES ON THE PREMISES.
THE PROPERlY LINES SHOWN RELY ON CURRENT
DEEDS: AND PlANS OF RECORD. ,
THIS PloOT PlAN IS NOT A CERTIF1CATJON AS TO
TITLE OR OWNERSHIP' OF' THE PROPERlY SHOWN.
OWNERS OF' ADJOINING PROPERTIES ARE SHOWN
ACCORDiNG TO CURRENT ASSESSOR RECORDS.
ASSESSOR MAP: . '7.~.1-7": PARCEL: . 7: . .
c:'JOeS\cw~'\I
, J;3UlLD!NG LOCATION PLAN
OF lAND IN
NANTUCKET, MASS.
SCALE: 1.... -'t'o' DATE:A.....-C. 8,,/'1'16
Owner: ,f7A'IJ...<<'.<f, ~/..y~ 13, !e.U..s,sIZ.-4..
, , ,,<..c. svo~. V
Qee& ~~7:7:'f~ !C?t: . Plan~.c. ,~~ .S;f.L
~o~~~. ;,e>~A(-1:*"A~. .sT~KT. .
I ~ I ' ,
CHAiRLES!W.',;:<ij~RT & ASSOCIATES, Inc.
: . : 's~oRf> :BOAT BUll..DING
: "'4i.9~,: 'SPARKS, AVENUE
NANTUCKET, MASS. 02554
(508) 228-8910
NOT TO, BE RECORDED: H - -;5,Zas-
i ,::~i
\.,\ i ,'1!
"" '"".. :.
,...'- .
· i 0-
i _
.~",) I ~
a-'I i
...,..! f ,) :
:,,- : L-
J -~-! r-
III . .-.i
.... -,. :
. <=1 :IE
-" :r II:
. ":
~
11.I
a..
~~
~, ~l ~
.. "
~t~
\
'-\.. - ~,
~~ '",
-.:.~
.'3
~t'
E
va
g
i
~
~I
i
8
I-
Z
1.&1
I-:IE
~I-
ull:
=c
I-a.
=1.&1
ZQ
"-
Qm
Zz
:1:_
eca
I-~
~,
::)
III
J.4
Q
"S
C)
~
fIJ
~
bD
~
"=
e=
~
C)
':S
.....
Q
C)
(.)
e~ .
==
o
~I
i
.. I
, i
~
M
.,.1
~i
i
!
-. *A
· = Z v,
i::;~~ ::l I:~ ~
i A.'" en -' _~ _
i A.oC) -' ~III ~
i ..c z z ..c ~ ~ 11II:::
~ ~~c ~ ~~ ~
: I-en-' III _ .. A
: III ~ ... .. ~ ....
! .......:;) .... ~ ~
..,.a 1 0 ~ ... ~ 0 ... ~
;.. .1 en ~ .... ~O ~- ~ ~ ...
"1 ~!=O z"" Z
: III"'. 0 U ::c z
(\i "'11I ~ ~ ... f ~ 2 0
....; :x:'" I- - '" - ti .....
If.'! 1-... f4 ~ ~ ......~ c.:I.
..~ 0 0 A. III III :;) A.
ill I- ~ ~:;; !( !!l ~ D.
.,.'~ ~ 0 - - - .... U
;.:..; ~;;; 0 i!:::: 0 0 en
· j ! 2>z "'~"'I- =>>
~~<'i. €J ~~: oz~ ~~ g
V"i ~ ~~~ ~;:...S ~
\1"1 l 1 ~ I- ~ ~ i!: i!: g en
~! ; ~~~ ~>-,;~ Z
i'~L:1:::. Z!: 0 ~ ~ ~ ~!z 8
--, 0 ,;Z~ .........0 _
o ~..c ~ :;) ... en U .....
c:I~: 5 ~!z~ fa! ~~ !:
J U -III =>>z 00 -..
:c~- en ~w ...
Z . 9 I- j:: t !!.! ~ .c;... .....
-1 '~~ 0 -oU >
.~.: : C)..c ~ III o.~
-'~i ZA.... mill o~
O. : - III en ... Z _ A.
i. to- 0 z ..." -'... A.
~..I mi.;:. ....t-i iii 8 ~ s; in ~ 0 en
... - cJ...s ~ ... Z Z Z 2i
~"""-III >-:1 en
! , .... 9 :x: u...... _ .....
' ......1. Z - I- · Z... ,; ~ a:I
!( -hliil~5 ~~ ~~ ....
~ Jd'lfll!:!'I!)!:! U :x: ...... !!!
o.-z_ Uen U _ __
'" III 1-._ I- 0 Z :: Z ~ ::E
!!! :J:ZI-Z...o ~"'...
~ ....-j~ 0- :x:,;~ Q
... '......Z...t "'';~ ~
~ I!(~~... 1-... 1-01- C
U ] ~""130 ~e; ~u. ~ U
I- "'ZUZ ~Z 0i!1-~
- 'ooz~ ~- "'0... en
~ ''''z~o!-fa ...Z>- ;:
III J. e 0 Z I- III ~ !!.! "'''' ....
... '~j:c... us :x:~~
!! ~~~o~ ~Of ...
X o.U
I-
:::)
III
.
o
Z
~
%
o
in
en
-
~
~
III
A.
en
..c
x
GC
o
to-
~
A.
va
~
C)
z
C
::!.
::>>
a:a
au
!C
u
iE
=
au
U
~' .'
._;-"!t'?.;.,~;~~:~~~il/-:,~;;""'-"
. t ,(; - ,- ,,- - ';'~,' -. .:
. -~ -\"
o
'~~\..
P'
,:fto
I!\. n ~. ,~.
~~. .~~~'
~,'~ "', <: ~," .
.~'\"--) l . ~ "~"
.~ &l
\. ., .),
-~ ~
"l:':-~ ". _ r.ji.~-~
)(. .,-c--
". -... .-1,
(:~ .'f ~
~ f
r
;J
\
v..
c~ '- {
.~ ~)
~<
.~
~:IJ
~o
- c
" :IJ Ci)
Z ~ :r:
)> r
.r )>
()
m
.:~,
"-;'~.-.
. ",
,
. Ie::: .
"I---"-~"-:--'<:' "
. , ~--- --1:;-'
z
G>
m
c
r
9
:r:
.0
()
G>
(j;.
s:
m
Z
'Q
..
-' ~
~
(i)
I"
...,
, ....
,
,....
c:
"
.
~
. .
'>
\
'y
..
t,
" "
0 Z :IJ -t 'j
0 " 0 :b
-t )> C m 0
r Z ~ :!!
z )> G> :IJ -0 Z C
G> r :r: 0 0 )> CD
en c ;D r ::I:
)>
:IJ
.-<
, .
to.
. .
"
c'
, \
( ~.t.. .
,1'\,:.... "~ . .
. ....:' ....:~ ; 0. ".
.~ '.' ,,-.
," . "-
~ -, "
'"'~,
~.
I I ~.
., I~- ~'"
-i ~
::I: -t ~
:;iI
..f
'';;
"'.
.
"tJ
rt'I
JJ
~
~ '"
.. I
"
Z
.>
.-
'..'
,
;.i'
. t
:~i,
.m";
.a.
*',
':... "
..4t
,,;;'
~:, ;;.
.J~
i
""'i
m
~- ~\
I . .
~- ...
~
~
~
(j)
<(
,:
c
IJj
I--
<s.:
(,,~
,r...'
'-'
,
-~
.
-.. I. '0
~I,~.'i
'-I: .~
.t......;
,W.' ..... ....... . '. . . , ' .' "."~"" :. :. " : ' '.. "...1
I""~.."I.
~""';
C. '. ,
t- i
I !
, I
. ... ,', ...1 !
~a!
II!
"":lr
:; "~..'
W~.,'
t-
<!
:r~
F~
~- "'-,",--
Z--': "...._
W -::
o ~~.
~)~;i: .
-,.:;106 ~....'"
.~
:;;.-,. ,'~-f
"F....
~~....
Lr:
c.. .
(;~'
(,...-~
:;] ~~ ~~
'-:".:.", t""...".
. "', Z j-.-
'2o:ww
i:-r^~U)
\ ....... ...... ,"" ::>
'r' .,.;;..
1- W -- :x:
iU-T<t .
iZ->'-=:U
' ~ oe::: <t
1.0 ~..^
IUOzw
. I-o(/)
::i.' OL~
.' "'r-: ..:@
L. cc
l;J b
~~ f?
;,).-
> 0,
".r~. (;)
2.~ :z
r::) ~~
til
t:.:" ~~
.-....i-;,.
I ..(/)
0:<(
UJ
o..z
~O
L"C r=
Ow
~o:
W2
:Co
~ ~:.,,)
.
CJ)
W
CJ)
-
:E
w
a:
c.. ,.~
UJ
J:
i-
/,.~
~1':1
, ~#
a: ~.
o ..
I- ;...,;
()
UJ
0..
en
Z
" .
IV
.~/,- "
~~oc,'"
.: ~: "~
': .'~
u...o
:"y-- CC <_
...., n WI--
M. ~.~ ::> >-
J.t c...
if) rr: (fj -'
- c. (I) (j";
't: 0... ~ ~
~~ ~g
'.) :t: I- z_
~""".
.z. <(I-
0::>" oz
~QJ 0
t;8 ~u
a:::l- I-C)
.<( :E~
50 00
0...0 a:w
Z u..w
=>< (/)()
C '0
UJ 0, :I: a;
a~ _.' ~ 0..
Q)~I '''0 I-
~(1) , :E 0
,.....'.,1..3.:.;.....2:
z
o
w
.0
<
--I
a..
en
::>
o
::>
o
-
a..
en.
z
o
U
<C
~
C
W
/~ /V r
0-D-?l~~ I
APPLICATION WILL NOT BE !I
DEEMED COMPLETE UNTIL
!B_EVi~Vi~D BY BU:LOING INSPECTO~
[=-~=~__fMPOR~ANT-~P/jCant to complete all i/"ms in Sec'io~~_!.2,3.~~':.d ~ -------1
1. ~WNERS NMlE:~~t ____ ___..P~.__ r; mdfhfi . fa flatu 8. !
LOCA TlON I ~ . st FlrSI Mldd Inll al :J
OF ~ Fm.ofid d . S-/-.. .__.__ . 10m IJeflers
BUILDING No. 1".I,Ll(1~ S~~S,;).-<1I~-<\~ I Village
Assessor's Map No.~, I (.,<n-'1~Hessor's Parcel No. 't<i1. ~~ I Fire. Oi~trict
2. TYPE AND COST OF BUILDING - AI! applicants cLlmp/ete ParIs A - 0
"'. TYPE OF IMPROVEMENT
OONew Building
o Addition (If residential, enler numher.
0; new housing wlils added. if any,
In Perl D. 13)
Q...'tera\ion (See:! <1'-'0...1')
o Repair, ,.eplacement
o Demolition (1f mullifamily n>Bldentia/.
etlle,' "umber of unils In buih/lny in
Purl D, 13)
o Moving (relocation)
o Foundalion only
B. OWNERSHIP
~ Private [individual, corporation.
nonprofit insOtut ion, etc.)
Dpublic (Federal. State. or
local government)
C.COST
Cost of. a. Structure-.;.............
b. Electrical...............
BUILDING INSPECTOR'S ESTIMATE
~/07-?'?
,/-0-- (5 ~
___.YUILC'.!:~..C .APP~~~2~?_N NUMElER
APPLICATION FOR
PLAN EXAMINATION AND
BUILDING PERMIT
Residential
o. PROPOSED LISE - (For "De/roo/ilia"". mosl rt'c.:nl use J
-1
I
I
/ <lb9, i
_11'1 .1._
For new buildings and additions. completl! Ports E-II
for Demolition. cor./plete only PorI I.. fat" 01/ others sk.ip to 4.
-I
I
lEOne F~mily
OTwo or mare (amily -!;o'er
numhe,. of unils - - - - -
o Tr"nsien! Hot..l, Notel or
dormitory; or IHTP.RVAL
OWNERSHIP - enter number of IIn; ts
o Garage
o Carport
UOther Spec'fY ____________
(OmU cents J
E. DIMENSIONS
c. Plumbing ........ . . . . . . .
d. Heatinq ................ _-1l,S"O<:>
I
e. Other................... t--~-
TOT AL COST OF IMPROVEMENT 1 00
$'0
-*00
f,<iOO_
Dimensions (N,'w) ot
Dwelling or Addition:
No of Slories:
First Floor Area: !l...19.pu
Second Floor Area: flll_'
Third Floor Area: .fJt9S"
Total Fl'lOr Area:
Full Cellar Area:
3. SElECTED CHARACTERISTICS Of BUILDING
H. TYPE OF SEWAGE DISPOSAL
~}rl
F. PRINCIPAL TYPE OF FRAME
I'., OMasonry (wall bearing)
Qg Wood frame
o Structural steel
l 0 Reinforced concrete
o Other - Specify
--
-----
G. PRINC'I'AL TYPE OF HEATING FUEL
DGas
[&]Oil
OElectricity
CCoal
C~ Olher - Specify____
L__.
o Public or' private company
~Private (septic tank. etc.)
I. TYPE OF W"TER SUPPLY
o Publk or private company
eyPrlvate (well. cistern)
1. SPEC IAL CHARACTERISTICS
o Air CondItioning
[J Heat Pump
o Central Vacuum
DOther __________
Nonresidential
o "'".usemenl. re<:reational
o Church. other reliqlous
o IlIdustrial
o Parkinq qaraqe
o Service statbn. repair garage
o Htospital. ;nstitutional
o Offi.:t' , bank. professional
o Public u:ility
o School. Iit.nry. other eduQlliondl
o Stores. mercantile
o Tanks. lowers
o Other - Specify
JY'l...
Dimensions of
Additiol';" Structures:
E.><I3f" ()4 .. 1.,J
Caraqe~tq-" hlh
^cc~ssory Bid!,!.:
Swimmir.g Pool:
Other:
1(. ACCESSORV HEAT SOURCE
I
I
No. of Fi.-efJlaces
No of Wood Stoves
No. of Coal Stoves
Solar Collector
Other:
L. SMOKE DETECTORS
No. of Dectectors
Type (11all("1")' or AC}
S
A.L
....
See Plan for l~caliDn
M. RESIDENTIAL BUILDINGS ONLY
Number ot Bedrooms .~_
NUinber of Bathrooms ~.
full _.::I. _ Partial-L_
/
____31 2;) -~- d
~~~~~~A2T?_~=~UM~ER--
-RECEIVED \ ,... '2-1" -'{ fp 9" ~ d AJ,..
APPLICATION wiLL NOT BE~
DEEMED COMPLETE UNTIL
~EVIE'NED BY BUILDING INSPECTO
r.
f~
(&A- ~
APPlICA liON FOR
PLAN EXAMINATION,
BUILDING PERMIT
IIrtPORTANT- Applicant to complete all it~ms in Sections: 1,2.3.4. and 5
r-::RS NAME: Ii L1 \~ ~ J' f)f14'---~/IL~-0~ -- --------
I. V':"t:m NQ. Wf st b~~ee.. E~:r~ I f't\IIo;g;~':i~I-------
NO.. 71,,1', 'I ("/ +^r ,;J') re~,. if. J "-
Assessor s Map No. Assessor's Parcel No.
1.
LOCATION
OF
BUILDING
2. TYPE AND COST OF BUILDING - All applicanls comp/ele ParIs A - 0
Village
Fire District
---.-.------------ -----.-
Residential
D. PROPOSED lJSE - (For "Oetr(llit;c"," . mC1.~1 rc.c.'nl usel
A. TYPE OF IMPROVEMENT
~w Building
o A.ddltion (If residenlial. enler number
II; new housing unilt added. if alt)'.
In PorI D. 13)
o Alteration (See:! ubo..''''
o Repair, replacement
o Demolition (If mullifamily ,"uidenliul.
enlcr number of "nlls in building in
ParI D. 13)
O",\oving (relocation)
o Foundation or,ly
DOne Family
o Two or more family -Enler
numher of units - - - - -.-
OTransient hotel. motel.
or dormitory - Enl"r number.
of unltll - - - - - - - - -;..
o Garage
o Carport I
~her - Speccf)'_(~fJ t~ €-_ ~_
0/11 rt#1~'"\iJ Ov~___
B.OWNE HIP
rivate (individual, corporation,
nonprofit institution, etc.)
o Public (Federal, State, or
local go.vernment)
C. CUS T
Cost of; a. Structur~............... $
(Omit cenls)
E.DIMENSIONS
Dimensions (N.,w) 01
Dwelling or A<.IdiU.,n:
b. Electrical...............
Nonresidentia!
o A.H\USem~n', rt:Cre3lional
o Churc:.h. other reliqious
o Induslnal
o Parkin~( qar.a~~\!
o Servk-~ ~t.ili')n, rf:pair 9.Jra~e
o H(;spitill. ;nstilutional
DOff;';,.. LallK. prordsion-"I
o Pub'ic;.u'i1ity
o S,ho><ll. IiLrary. other education..
o Slo..cs. mt'.rcantile
o Tanks, tOlifrfl;r.$
o O-th~,. - Speci/)'
Dh~enslons of.
;'dditioncsl ~).I.i..IClures:
Cd ,. .IC." : IL.2.k _
c. Plumbing...............
d. Heatinq ................
No 01 Stories: , :1-.
First Floor Area: ~
Second Floor ^ rea: i,., (d ·
Third Floor Area:
Total Floor Area:
e. Other...................
^..;:~s:.ory Bld!=!.:
;-;..immir.q 1'001:
\")
"\
~
/"\
~
'\)
()~"o,)O
BUILDtNG INSPECTOR'S ESTIMATE 8~Opt>
, .
3. SelECTED CHARACTERISTICS OF BUILDING
lrt 5' i .., 'if;; 1_. ')__i1_~_r : _
Full Cellar Area: !./
For new bul/dings and additiom, complete ParIS F.. II
for Demolition. complete only PorI I" (or 011 111 her. s kip to <t.
TOT A.L COST OF IMPROVEMENT
~
H. TYPE OF SEWAGE DISPOSAL
o Public or private company
~vate (septic tank, etc.)
F. PRINCIPAL TYPE OF FRAME
OMasonry (wall burlng)
~d frame
o Structural steel
o Reinforced concrete
o Othe.r - Specify _
I. TYPE OF WA. TER SUPPLY
o Public or private company
~vate (well, cistern)
G. PRIN IPAL TYPE OF HEATlNC FUEL
J. SPECIAL CHARACTERISTICS
o Air Conditioning
o Heat Pump
o Central Vacuum
Gas
0011
O.E lectrici t y
OCoal
DOther - Speclfy_
[]Other ____
I
\
L__.._
K. A.CCESSORY HEA. T SOURCE
No. of Fir~IKes
No of Wood Stoves
No. of Coal Stoves
Solar Collector
Other:
L. SMOKE DETECTORS
No. of Oectectors ,j
_ . Type (lhll1('ry Ol~
~ Ser. Plan frw l.ocalion
M. RE!>IDENTlA.L BUILDIHCS ONL"
'j.
Number 01 Bedrooms. I {;
Number of Bathrooms ~
J'ull._ J-_.- Part.al-
~-_._._-_._--
,I'IING COMPLIANCE
To be C<,~loleted hy all applicants
l
."plicant Is required to subrfllt " registered plot plan with application. showing lucation of all structurl's.
Zoning District: i (J C? 3
Frontage on Street: c2 ~ Lf . ~ I
Plan Book No. and Page:
O..te Lot Purchased: cd. t q 8 (;
Total Land Area: Lf3,IC?O ~1' ~f.
lot No. ~ '1$"1 ,t4-q 3 I Lf 8~ 14e"1
land Court Plan No. SQo'f G. 0001.( Y
SUBDIVISION INFORMATION
N..me of Owner:
Certificate No.
Name of Previous Owner: :r. Ht1.Ljo
Oate of Plan Appro"al:
Is a Relea.e required: YES
Has Plan ~ filed with the Registry of n~ds !
~IO
TIMESHARING IH~URHATION
Is there a Declaration
of Covenants and Re-
strictions of Interval
Ownership noted on
your Title or Deed?
Yes_ No_
Type of Approval:
ANR
AR
Planning Board File No.
Is the Subdivision subject to a Covenant: YES
NO
YES
NO
If YES: Plan Book and Pilge Noo____
Date
DIMENSIONS
Distance frOlll Property lines: FRONT-----1.Et'O ~ Hf"'R_tt~ LEFT
Di.tance between Principal and Secondary. Dwellin9: _~~.__ . (12 fto minimum. j
/::zo I
RiGHT 3S"(
~-
Helj1ht of struc:ture above finish grade:
N
:j8'(a"
E
z~ I to "
S
2tt" I fp /,
W Zf' b I{
NUlllber of off-street parkinq spaces:
Enclosed
On-site
CROUND COVER
Principal 0_lIIn9:
Secondary Dwelling:
Ad ,_ tJ'i
h1h
Addition:
Total:
/~97,~'f
SF.
..
Cara~e :
Accessory Building:
Swimming Pool:
Other:
Allowable:
/5 C?O
SF.
MISCELLANEOUS
WaS. request to "Determine Applicability of the Wetland T>rotection Act" filed with the Nantucket ConMrvation Committee! YES
If answered YES. Include "Order of Conditions. w;ith application.
What date was the "Order of Conditions" filed with the R"'9lstry of Deeds?
NOA_.
Is the property located within a Flood Hazard District?
YES
NO
W.. a Variance or Special Permit grlnted by the Board of Appeals?
YES NO
--
If answered YES what ~te was the decision filed with theTown Clerk?
FOR BUILDINC DEPARTMENT USE ONLY
Frontage on Street:
Front Yard:
IZ(),deJl)
20fJ
~-~
Ground Cover Ratio: -3<J~
Side and Rear Setback: .,~
MInimum Lot Size: .
Additional (:o_nt. :
DATE:
APPROVlD BY:
-I
7.onill!l \J {(ic.,r
/
.. - -------.-----.------ ._---
02/11/2002 20:01 15082574613
RUSSELL IItJBILE SERVI
PAGE 04
~.J.(' }:>Y~I.t)\Vj ~ "1
-,J fl';,sS:"'2L '1,,)$ I, ~
I . 0 u,~\._.__.'''.'---_.''''''-'-:'"'--'~---~-.__l
_ (i\ f>.__ ~-~._--_. \ \ u.
\
I
/ /' '\ ~)
/ >--.
....u~ ",y::r~
.1)P'ts C
.L\
~J
t
{
...
\1)00 l"f"i'Cd
~
\
, l..
'- ,
-
01
I
~f" I.
-
,
"-
,
.~
~.".
dJt
/
'----
. - -.\ /
, ./
I /
\pI;) t-:> _ '
\oM Qc).A~
"
~., <
-...,/ .
,. "-
-".~ \
11M
C. ._. .
\
".
/'
I
\4~
~U...
h"tU3
~ fuOJj ~u, 1""\3
02/11/2002 20:01 15082574613
is P'~\jJ' .I".:t (,
H dS'S""~
r=~.. -...-.--....-.------.-::::1
I ~flV'~ -----.------~-n---U--
1 '
\
/ '" .\ 1""1"
I L-'
-.-...-'-"" r
.
a
,
~
t
~
,
'-'-
li~(
,
"
LP-WH
RUSSELL KUHLE SERVI
)\,\1)S ,. hI,
.1 :~ P' IS: \
PAGE 03
I
'-'JoO~
. .
. - - -t J
, I
, '"
I ,.,.
t-) -'"
uJoo.)~ca.
.....
"
'\
~
1--:-.
.\
,
,
vJ,. QQ..J.~
'"
r
I
I
-I"
-_ J,
Y
/ '\
,,, \
-' 'h.tt"l
b"'ttc\~t:
~
D\ ~~
I
<",~u.~
L )(L
I ,
" ',. ~..\.,.
\ ~N
i ,
r-;-----J p,QOdQJd,.
CI-w....IU~..:... -1
i
~.
'-
eo
cD
. .
02/11/2002 20:01 15082574613
-....--... y
a
c:
...
~
v.)~O~
, .
I
u..\OC>.J.f'\
.-"
./
I'
{
,
,
/
",
Ii ~~
.........
- ._~_.-.:J.. ("l'\ 0 \>>"'t('f\ F~
Lp~
'\
\
RUSSELL I\tJBILE SERVI
PAGE 02
6''';) s: hI,
'I (I
.).~P' 19 \
woo~~~ .
- .
"
'\
)
-i-
~~
- - .~\ I
'l' J
, ./
I /
r-';) .. '
, l I .
:€J ,
,_:
Lt of\' t,
,
"
",~a.
.~.:.-
....
~l\ 0 \J.4~
-'__ "",;,,~ , .AOQ~
lUOJj !;.~It' '''.!l
h -'t u'] ~N
fcil\~lclwoJ
I
t.
:I
-.
c
q]t
, .
Town of Nantucket
So A€C~,\~.....
'ARD ..... c, If :::: ':')
O""A-~' "
\) " -.
~':::SSOR"'"
JAN 1 7 2002 .::>
NAN~~~N OF
KEr, MA
ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS
LIST OF PARTIES IN INTEREST IN THE MATTER OF THE PETITION OF
PIlClPEilllr\! Cl~EiIl""""""""""",~",....~!~.i\..~....~ "-"--
MAILING ADDRESS...... ... ... ... ... ...... ... ..................... .................. .....
. ':) to..hl .h ~,~ $\-
PROPERTY LOCATION............... .0\....................... ~...................... ~
ASSESSORS MAP/PARCEL......... .1..b.l.~:-:...1.......(J.:J.5J.. ~....;~\ ]4Y. 1- y 5~
~~ ~
APPLICANT......... ...... ...... ...... ..................................................... .~..
L~ $c)O't~4 I Lc>Y--G-~ ~~ 6~S
\ ~ ,....q 2-8'9
CC)T~~~~ SEiEiATIAC~g?PA~S
I certify that th~g is a list of persons who are owners of abutting property, owners of
land directly opposite on any public or private street or way; and abutters of the abutters and all
other land owners within 300 feet of the property line of owner's property, all as they appear on
the most recent applicable tax list (M.G.L. c. 40A, Section 11 Zoning Code Chapter 139.
Section 139-290 (2)
........... .1..\. ~.d.:) Pl........
.....g~dts...o~
DATE
ASSESSOR'S OFFICE
Town of Nantucket
t:n
~;i
10 ..
....E-t
..::1M
~
~U
G)~
~~
~
g t;t;t;t;t;
""
U
II
U
oS
PI PI
Il/l Il/l
Eo< Eo<
tI) tI)
Il/l Il/l
II II
~t)t)
~ S S
.. Cl Cl
II
114
PI PI PI
Il/l Il/l Il/l
Eo< Eo< Eo<
tI) tI) tI)
Il/l Il/l Il/l
II II II
t) t) t)
S S S
Cl Cl Cl
Eo< Eo< Eo<
tI) tI) tI) Eo<
tI) Eo< Eo<
tI) tI)
Eo< Eo<
tI) tI)
PI PI
Il/l Il/l
Eo< Eo<
Il/l Il/l
>< ><
Il/l Il/l
Eo< Eo<
tI) tI) :z;
o
~ ~ ~
o 0 H
~ ~ ~
CI CI
PI PI
Il/l Il/l PI
Eo< Eo< Il/l
tI) tI) Eo<
Il/l Il/l tI)
II II Il/l
t) t) II
S S t)
Cl Cl S
Cl
~ ~
Il/l Il/l
H H
~ ~
H H
.c: .c:
IZo IZo
Eo< Eo<
tI) tI)
PI PI
Il/l Il/l
Eo< Eo<
Il/l Il/l
>< ><
Il/l Il/l
Q)CDO 11\0\
M M III ~ N ~ N M N " " n Q) III ~ M M
'" '" '" N '" '" '"
co \D III M 10 CD Q)
0. III III III 0 III III III
'""'" NNNMNNN
N 0000000
'"
~
'"
N
I
. III . . . ~ M 0 \D
Q) \D III III Q) 0\ Q) ~ ~
III 0\ III III III CD . Q) ~
("II M ("II ("II ("II \D ("II \D M
o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
t; ~~~$~~~
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ t ~ t ~
Eo<
Eo< Il/l
Il/l tI)
...: :z;
€ I !
III
.... N
.... '"
N ....
:><><
GI 0 0
.. III III
'tl
~ 2 2
a
:z;
WI
I
..
GI
~I
o
II
Cl
:z;
H
tI)
tI)
Eo< Eo< Eo< Eo< Eo<:il
Il/l Il/l Il/l Il/l Il/l II
tl S tl tl tl !: tl ~
m ~ m m m ~ m ~
~
Cl
:z;
H
tI)
Eo< tI)
= :il
PI II
Eo<
tI) U) Eo< .... '"
:z: ~ to ::: ~
o U) '" N
H H
~ ~
~
~
:il ~
III III
'"
~ 10 0
III ~ Po
Il/l
Il/l
Eo<
tI)
~
Eo<
IZo
~
tI)
PI
Il/l
Cl
:c1
o
"-
II
.c:
t'i
Il/l
~ ~
~ ~
H ~ :!:..
a i!~~~~
:z; CI ggtii::
~ Il/ltiPlatltl)
.. IZoHIl/l ~Cl
GI M9tl Cl
e tlit!ofil ~
o 0 III 114 114 lli IZo
t)
H
Eo< Eo< Eo<
Il/l Il/l Il/l
...: ...: ...:
III
:z:
II
H
>0 I
Il/l Il/l
H Il/l >Os
:z; <Il PI
o Il/l Cl
Eo< H III
~ ~ ~ 15
~ ~ 0 U)
10
....
~
~
Cl
:z;
~ ~ ~
114 0 H
U) PI 0
PI >0 114
~ \!II >0
H ~ tl
H .c: 0
U) > PI
~
114
~
:il lil
~
S
H
Il/l
IZo
Cl
:z;
o
H
~ I '" ~ ~
~ :z; ~ t'i ~
:z; ~ H
>< ~ >< >< Cl ~
oo~g...g=g
III :< Cl
o 0 0 0"'10"'10
114 114.... 114 N 114 '" '" N ....
~
~
H
PI
tl
S
8
II
lFil
~ i
f;l ~
o IZo
II
~ ~
U) ~ oil ~
oil II lFil II
o
i U) .c: oil Eo<
~ ~ ~ ~ ~
~ ... g Il/l
~ ~ = g
IZo ' H E:; U)
~ = ~ ~ a
.,
...:
:z;
H
~
~
H
PI
Il/l
~
.c:
::i
III
Il/l
CI ~
oil Eo<
U)Btl~.c:PI~
as~~i~
~~8~i:
i~~~~~
oil
oil
Cl
U ....~Ill....~ "''''ONIDO",OID
oS ::l~~~~~~:;:~~::l~~:;;:;;:;:~
III
N N N N N '" '" '" '" ~ ~ ~ " " " " "
~ '" '" '" '" '" " " " " '" '" '" '" '" '" '" '"
II """""101010101010101010101010
lFil .... .... .... .... .... .... .... .... .... .... .... .... .... .... .... .... ....
~
rl
Q)
0\
<1l
p.,
~
o
N
N
M
r-i
r-i
o
o
N
"-
N
N
"-
r-i