The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About014-05 TOWN OF NANTUCKET BOARD OF APPEALS NANTUCKET, MASSACHUSETTS 02554 Date: F 12-"" NOj;(l3 , 2005 To: Parties in Interest and Others concerned with the Decision of the BOARD OF APPEALS in the Application of the following: Application No.: O{'-f-o~ Owner/Applicant: ~c..~ UJ _ at/\('j ~V'(S'C(~{ (Q F, S~ ~ c;-tf? ('{) Enclosed is the Decision of the BOARD OF APPEALS which has this day been filed in the office of the Nantucket Town Clerk. An Appeal from this Decision may be taken pursuant to Section 17 of Chapter 40A, Massachusetts General Laws. ~ Any action appealing the Decision must be brought by filing an complaint in court within TWENTY (20) days after this day's date. Notice of the action with a copy of the complaint and certified copy of the necision must be given to the Town Clerk so as to be received within such TWENTY (20) days. ~O~~~~~/~ ~ :;J k VlSj Cha irman cc: Town Clerk Planning Board Building Commissioner PLEASE NOTE: MOST SPECIAL PERMITS AND VARIANCES HAVE A TIME LIMIT AND WILL EXPIRE IF NOT ACTED UPON ACCORDING' TO NANTUCKET ZONING BY-LAW ~139-30I (SPECIAL PERMITS); ~139-32I (VARIANCES) ANY QUESTIONS, PLEASE CALL THE NANTUCKET ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS. NANTUCKET ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS 1 East Chestnut Street Nantucket, Massachusetts 02554 Assessor's Map 55, Parcel 337 20 New Street ROH No plan on record Deed Ref.170, Page 37 DECISION: 1. At a public hearing of the Nantucket Zoning Board of Appeals, on Friday, February 11, 2005, at 1:00 P.M., in the Conference Room, in the Town Annex Building, 37 Washington Street, Nantucket, Massachusetts, LEE W. AND PRISCILLA F. SAPERSTEIN, of 801 Laurel Drive, Rolla, MO 65401, File No. 014- 05: 2. The Applicants seek relief by Special Permit under Nantucket Zoning By-law Section 139-33E(2) (a). Applicant proposes to increase ground cover on a lot said to be pre- existing nonconforming by constructing an about 110 square-foot addi tion. The existing Lot contains about 3,231 square feet of lot area per a plan dated January 12, 2005. The current owners' Deed recorded in 1979 recites a lot area of about 3,395 square feet. The existing ground cover is about 1,142 square feet, for a ground cover ratio of about 35%. The proposed ground cover would be about 1,252 square feet or approximately 38%. An increase above the maximum ground cover allowed for subminimum lots in the ROH district may be allowed by a grant of Special Permit relief by this Board for up to 50%. The Applicants also seek relief by SPECIAL PERMIT under Nantucket Zoning By-law Section 139-33A(5) to allow the extension/expansion of both structures, a primary dwelling unit and a separate studio to the rear of the lot, by constructing second story space along pre- existing non-conforming rear and/or side setback lines without coming any closer to the lot lines than the existing structures. There is one nonconforming grandfathered parking space on site, which would be maintained. The Locus is nonconforming as to lot size with the Lot containing about 3,135 square feet of lot area occupation in a district that requires a minimum of 5,000 square feet; as to side and rear yard setback with the primary structure sited as close as zero feet from the westerly side yard lot line, and with the studio structure to the rear being sited as close as about zero feet from the easterly side yard lot line and less than one foot from the southerly rear yard lot line, in a district that requires a minimum of five feet; and as to frontage with the Lot having about 33 feet of frontage along New Street in a district that requires a minimum frontage of 50 feet; as to parking with one nonconforming space provided on site; and as to ground cover ratio with the Lot containing about 1 35% in a district that allows a maximum of 30% for undersized lots. The Premises is located at 20 NEW STREET, Assessor's Map 55, Parcel 337, Plan Book 170, Page 37. The property is zoned Residential-Old-Historic. 3. Our decision is based upon the application and accompanying materials, and representations and testimony received at our public hearing. There was no Planning Board recommendation, as the matter did not present any issues of planning concern. There was one email from the current owner of the property detailing the history of the rear structure's use and that indicated that it was placed in its current location prior to 1972. Except for the presentation by the applicant through its representative, there was no support or opposition presented at the public hearing. 4. Applicants, through their representative, stated that the single-family dwelling on the locus and the rear studio were undergoing renovation. Applicants proposed to construct a new conforming addition onto the easterly side of the dwelling and raise the rear el ridge height to provide additional second floor living space, without coming any closer to the westerly side yard lot line. Applicant also proposed to construct a conforming addition onto the rear studio structure and raise the overall ridge height from about 11 feet to about 17 feet without coming any closer to the southerly rear and easterly side yard lot lines. As the Lot contained less lot area than the required minimum of 5,000 square feet, the maximum ground cover allowed was 30%. The Lot currently contained about 35% ground cover ratio and the new additions would increase the ratio to about 38%. Both the dwelling and separate studio were clearly visible on the 1938 and 1957 aerials in the Town records substantially in the current locations, with the orientation of the studio with a larger structure attached to it at one point, sited at a different angle in relationship to the rear and side yard lot lines, making the siting and ground cover grandfathered for zoning purposes. Applicant represented that the appropriate approvals had been obtained from the Historic District Commission for the project as described. 5. Accordingly, the Board of Appeals finds that the additions and expansion of ground cover as proposed would increase the nonconforming ground cover ratio and would increase the massing of both the dwelling and studio structure within the westerly side yard setback area and rear and easterly side yard setback areas , respectively, without coming any closer to said lot lines. The Board further finds that no new nonconformity would be created and the proposed alterations and expansions would be consistent with previous relief granted by this Board in the same district, and would be in harmony with the general purpose and intent of the Zoning By-law, and would not be 2 substantially more detrimental to the neighborhood than the pre- existing nonconformities. 6. Therefore, by a UNANIMOUS vote, the Board of Appeals GRANTS the requested relief by SPECIAL PERMIT under Zoning By- law ~139-33A and ~139-33E(2) (a) to allow the alteration and expansion of both of the structures and increase of the ground cover as described above, subject to the following conditions: (a) The maximum ground cover ratio allowed for this lot without further relief from this Board shall be about 38%; (b) The siting of the structures shall be done in substantial conformity with the "Plan", dated January 6, 2004, done by Charles w. Hart & Associates, Inc. , as marked up, a reduced copy of which is attached hereto as Exhibit A; (c) The renovations shall be done in substantial conformance with Certificate of Appropriateness Nos. 45,088 and 45,258, as approved by the Nantucket Historic District Commission, as may be amended; (d) The rear studio structure shall not be used for human habitation without further relief from this Board; (e) The garbage bin that is currently sited over the westerly side yard lot line shall be removed; (f) There shall be no shower or tub in the bathroom of the studio; (g) The maximum height of the studio shall be about 17 feet; (h) There shall be no exterior construction related to this proj ect between June 1 and October 1 of any given year; and (i) The studio shall not be used for a "home occupation" as defined in the Zoning By-law. 3 ( Z BA 0 14 - 0 5 ) Dated: February~, 2005 ~Q~ Nancy J Michael c. Richard Loftin, ~ ire 0 ~ Edwar~-san~brd Edward Murphy 4 ;-., J j-...J Lv -- J , . ;._A....> ..... ZOlillW' CLA.SSIF'lCATION: . ./.f:O,/.{', MIN. AREA: . . . . . . .-?;QQ9. S';=; MIN. FRONTAGE: . . . . . . ..;J:Q '. r=r FRONT YARD S.B.: . . . /'y't7.1Y'~ REAR & SIDE 5.8.: . . : . . . ..::r.~ GROUND COVER (7.): . . . ...:T.o. .% "3"'1.13 :#zz ~ 81K ~S-7"S- . ~ .<</r- /:? .eA,~77/VG /;(, F<, Lj {, - ){ $S- .3-43 EXIS1lNG: .f~-:CT~/tVA~ ~ .P.MK . . . .1/ . . . . 1/ . . . . . . . . . . N ;::: YV -5 T: [.35,ct:, -,])/C)'!:D] 33':i: " j~ sry Wi1=' I ;z.c 0 LIS F.: G.C. = 8IGEl (CA:H' o~:)'F. No. 20 I . , I 05ry 1 K ~ ~ " ~,C, "+'01 ~ _/'I~ S,F Pj(OP::J~ . ~LJ/rION.s J ~4.C."70<$~ ! , ,. ;' /./ / ..t ..'3r~. W" I;C- STUDIO ..H.:v:. O/,/.. TAAr /( G.c,. ;G 73 , '*:$,r. {C/W. !3PS,) L , ' , " (3'5 '3'3'cr- . -O~~) n./-P .'R..S.71.(';R-N,I!;;'.;,! PL., U/~- 78 AfOT..€": P~.P R-e-r; .eK/7D .P~,:57 II . CO/Y'.7Ah'r./'/VC:;: ~ 3'9.6~ .$qU~ /-='"$'~ ~ ,SA/P A1~sv~M~ AN'.P CO/'Y/A?r/lr'TS" Aio,..e.s- 0..< ~s_ 1/ x \ , ,. ./ / , , , ' , , h ~ ~ Ii v 1 U.u1-> t:,flq. V\()t-... l.f,0)C) U. 55'-336 /Yfr A.P. Axe'S (NO p~) ON ;C/)..;!i' / r 55-3-1-"" ZOK/I(C, EOA,RO Or AP'p~ PA-.Aj'/ OF LAND IN NANTUCKET, MASS. / SCALE: ,"./5 DATE: JAV'-"o/~{)OL( Owner: ~.~ #-?;f/$~~;:r. $-fI7r5l'..,5!4/.).{ Deed: &'(,/('Q .?~.~7 Plan . ~OA/~ . Locus . ;c;.Q. .<V'.-e-V .-3T~ET. , , , CHARLES W. HART &. ASSOCIATES, Inc. SANFORD BOAT BUILDlliG 49 SF ARKS AVENUE NANTUCKET, MASS. 02'554 ) (508) 228-8910 H -706/ KOI..€.' OC:CUP/A:;C) .A:,.e.€"..{ ";5::5 l-f X 95'-f.:: "5/35'fS,F A.SS.€55'OR.S~ f76-- 337 nJ09S\CWf!\9t? ~.*. ------------------- TOWN OF NANTUCKET ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS 1 EAST CHESTNUT STREET NANTUCKET, MASSACHUSETTS 02554 PHONE 508-228-7215 FAX 508-228-7205 NOTICE A Public Hearing ofthe NANTUCKET ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS will be held at 1:00 P.M., FRIDAY, FEBRUARY 11, 2005, IN THE CONFERENCE ROOM, TOWN ANNEX BUILDING, 37 Washington Street, Nantucket, Massachusetts, on the Application ofthe following: LEE W. AND PRISCILLA F. SAPERSTEIN BOARD OF APPEALS FILE NO. 014-05 The Applicants seek relief by Special Permit under Nantucket Zoning By-law Section 139-33E(2)(a). Applicant proposes to increase ground cover on a lot said to be pre-existing nonconforming by constructing an about 110 square-foot addition. The existing Lot contains about 3,231 square feet of lot area per a plan dated January 12, 2005. The current owners' Deed recorded in 1979 recites a lot area of about 3,395 square feet. The existing ground cover is about 1,142 square feet, for a ground cover ratio of about 35%. The proposed ground cover would be about 1,252 square feet or approximately 38%. An increase above the maximum ground cover allowed for subminimum lots in the ROH district may be allowed by a grant of Special Permit relief by this Board for up to 50%. The Applicants also seek relief by SPECIAL PERMIT under Nantucket Zoning By-law Section 139-33A(5) to allow the extension/expansion of both structures, a primary dwelling unit and a separate studio to the rear of the lot, by constructing second story space along pre-existing non-conforming rear and/or side setback lines without coming any closer to the lot lines than the existing structures. There is one nonconforming grandfathered parking space on site, which would be maintained. The Locus is nonconforming as to lot size with the Lot containing about 3,135 square feet of lot area occupation in a district that requires a minimum of 5,000 square feet; as to side and rear yard setback with the primary structure sited as close as zero feet from the westerly side yard lot line, and with the studio structure to the rear being sited as close as about zero feet from the easterly side yard lot line and less than one foot from the southerly rear yard lot line, in a district that requires a minimum of five feet; and as to frontage with the Lot having about 33 feet of frontage along New Street in a district that requires a minimum frontage of 50 feet; as to parking with one nonconforming space provided on site; and as to ground cover ratio with the Lot containing about 35% in a district that allows a maximum of 30% for undersized lots. The Premises is located at 20 NEW STREET, Assessor's Map 55, Parcel 337, Plan Book 170, Page 37. The property is zoned Residential-Old-Historic. 0.~\t..~ r~ Nancy J. Sevrens~ cihairman THIS NOTICE IS AVAILABLE IN LARGE PRINT OR OTHER ALTERNATIVE FORMATS. PLEASE CALL 508-228-7215 FOR FURTHER INFORMATION. NANTUCKET ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS 1 EAST CHESTNUT STREET NANTUCKET, MA 02554 CASE NO.a y -o~ FEE: $300.00 APPLICATION FOR RELIEF Owner's name(s): Lee W. and Priscilla F. Saperstein Mailing address: 801 Laurel Drive, Rolla, MO 65401 Applicant's name(s): Same Mailing address: Same Locus address: 20 New Street, Nantucket, MA 02554 Assessor's Map/Parcel: 0055/337 Land Court Plan/Plan Book & Page/Plan File No.: Date lot acquired: 4/13/1979 Deed Ref./Cert. of Title: Book 170 Page 37 Uses on Lot- Commercial: None X Yes (describe) Lot No.: Zoning District: ROH Residential: Number of dwellings 2 Duplex_ Apartments_ Rental Rooms_ C of O(s)? Building Date(s): All pre-date 7/72? X or Building Permit Nos: No file available at the Nantucket Building Department Previous Zoning Board Application Nos.: None State below or on a separate addendum specific relief sought (Special Permit, Variance, Appeal), Section of the Zoning By-law, and supporting details, grounds for grant of relief, listing any existing nonconformities: See addendum attached hereto. I certify that the information contained herein is substantially complete and true to the best of my knowledge, under the pains and penalties of perjury. c.. SIGNATURE: ~/"~v Applicant Attorney/Agent 2L- (If not owne,f,-6r wner's attorney nclose proof of agency to bring this matter before the Board) i r- FOR/~M OFFI<;E USE Applicati received on:L/f..L/Ql By: W/M _ / Complete: ~eed copies?: ' Filed with Town Clerk:L/Z)/QJ...1ifanning-B9Md:---!'_I_ Building Dept.:_I~.J_ ByOtt{) Fee deposited with Town Treasurer:LO ,OJ' By: Ul{)Waiver requested?:_Granted:_/_/_ Hearing notice posted with Town Clerk:~/Z7/()] Mailed:LI--J70fI&M:L/Z)/ Of& Z-/l/~ Hearing(s) held on:~_/_ Opened on:_/~_ Continued to:_/_/_ Withdrawn?:_/_/_ DECISION DUE BY:_/~_ Made:-"-"_ Filed w/Town Clerk:_/_/_ Mailed:_/_/_ DECISION APPEALED?: / / SUPERIOR COURT: LAND COURT Form 4/03/03 --- ADDENDUM The Applicants seek relief by Special Permit pursuant to Section 139-33 E (2)(a) to increase ground cover on a pre-existing nonconforming lot by 110 square feet. The existing Lot contains 3,231 square feet per the Plan by Charles W. Hart, dated January 12, 2005. The current owners' Deed recorded in 1979 recites a lot area of 3,395 square feet. The existing ground cover is 1,142 +/- square feet or approximately 35%. The proposed ground cover is 1,252 +/- square feet or approximately 38%. This increase is well with in the limits of the permitted 50% ground cover ratio in the ROH zoning district. The Board may find that such increase in permitted ground cover shall not be substantially more detrimental to the neighborhood than the existing nonconformity. The Applicants also seek relief by Special Permit pursuant to Section 139-33 A (5) to allow the extension/expansion to a second story of the two existing structures along pre-existing non-conforming rear and/or side setback lines. The main house on the front of the lot does not meet the side yard set back along the westerly boundary. The studio does not meet the side yard set back along the easterly boundary and the rear southerly boundary. The Board may find that the extension along a non-conforming set back for second story additions on both structures will not be substantially more detrimental to the neighborhood. There is one nonconforming grandfathered parking space currently on the lot. The property is numbered 20 New Street (Map 0055, Parcel 337). It is located in the Residential Old Historic District. ~, 'I I I I -'I;.,'iid~ , "' . ,~:~',1 '1 ! ~ '. ':'.':" tfi: :- ':~,.~, hJ!J' ' ~ . " ',. ,....... ~ , .:,J(( ',I, ' I... I ~; 1 {' 'I,: :1, , t' : ' \ :/Jt' . ) '1 ,ti ow '1 . , ,r', f ';" , 'I' I.., 'I '.!I I 7!iJ"", , , I ' ...:~) ;.' ;. i " \ I : I I' olq t. ., ,;'i'.I;L-,~" I '. .' ,I '1f-J . il,' j , . i J .:1 ~ } . I I , '. I ; , " l' r '. :. I, f" ; t i-:. '; !" r '" ;j 'J ' '.1 '. ; J ], ! I, ,,' I , , ,,, I I 'G/':~-("' 'l.~. , , ".~': I~. ; , ' , '" ~ ." . ~ I ,I ' I , ; If,J\ ":'('" j', , , , Pt-rt,- ~"~I l, , ,'. ,,', ~. 1'1 ~ . J .. . I t.' 11 '?: I 1 " t.' . I - .... '. ,;1 '.' , I" :). " 6~ . ~. J' I j:' I I -;. ., ! . i -L,~ I. . '.1 i -1" t I I I, ~ lit t- , I I " '0' -:. U-.- ~ ~ t&O)g " -"'" I / J ! .' f ,,' .- 20 New St. Nego 2192 ~, '~ j "r c./ t..r~ J ,~ . ./ . .~.) \~~.j.f :. . 'r v~. f-_-s'l- AJ ;{ fJ. . Cet I ~ f? 0..... , ~~ 0 eCe-~ ~ " """ I ~ & CJ - Ig>~ l. ~ ~ Vi46 CERTIFICATE NO: A 57? B DATE ISSUED: Appicatlon It) the HISTORIC DISTRICT COMMISSION. Nanlllcket, MlI58EICI1U6eIlS, for a CERnACATEOFAPPROPR~TENESS for II!tuClIdl WlIlk, A1lll1ankB mU8\ be ll1lec1ln umg BLUE OR BlACK INK (no pencil) or marluld N/A. NOTE: It la lltI'ongly _mmend.d thai the appllaant be famllllr with the HDC IUldIlIII'IlllI, BuIItIInQ WifIlIIIIIrIuDbt In ....d, prlor to lIUbml1tal of IIJIllIIC8tlon. Plea.. _ othtlr "de lor BUbmlltal requll'lllll8lll8. 1_1ilpIele appllalltlane win not lIB RIVI8w8d !IV 1M HOC. TI1i8 i8 a oonllacUlf agl8emlllll end mUll be filed out in ink, An appIicalIcn Is hereby IlllIde for Issuance cia Certlficate of Approprlllleness under Chapter 3Il5 of the AclB and FIesoIve5 DI Mass" 1970. for proposed work as described herein and,on plBns, dlllWhgs and phalOgrsphs ICCOlllfl8/IYklthl8 8ppI1CIIion and made a part hereat by relerllllC8, The certiticate Is IIlIIld for three years from dale at Issuance, No structure may dlHer from .... appRMd appllca1lon, VlOlatlon may Impede ie8uance of CtI1ftlc8Ie of Occ\lpllllCy, \\ PROPERTY DESCRIPnON if TAX MAP NO; .515 PARCEL~. 3.. ~ "1 Slreet & Number of Propoeed Worle 2. 0 N eJ,.:1 ~ Ownerofr.oord: I u .v fk!">c..: IlJL. ~~u.t""') MaIlIng Addl"8l8: 80 I ~ IM1 c-Vt t:>c-;..-L. J::..&lIA 1 M 0 C9540\ Telephone:513 1lv\)~1&t{on Island) (offllllancl) AGENT INF0RMA110N (if applicable) Name: M '.l~", Eojj~ tb...so,-fJt-,. M~lng.Add~:~~~~~ ~ Telephone: Z:z.t>- z.ot4-Con Island) (off Island) Dal8 application -wed: Must be aclIld on by: Extended to: Approved: Chelrman: Member. Membsr: Member: Uembsr: FOR 0FFlCI! USE OHLY I r 1'5 /6t Fee Paid: 5 --5L2- I , I'''7/of? I / ~lICI: NotBI.~pwi.{r~ () OJM.)- o Gnge OOele DESCRIP110N OF WORK TO B! PERfORMiD See _lor nlqUlr8d cIoc:uIllInIaII, o QngefApertment 0 Commerdel 0 Hletorlcel Renow1lon 0 Deck o PavIng 0 Mow BuUdlng 0 DemoIiUOn 0 RevIsIons to previoue CerI. No. o New Dwelling ~ Addlllon o Color Chenge 0 Fence o Other (pIeue specify) SIze 01 S1nIe1ure or Additicttj'" Length; Sq. Foolag9 1 et 1Ioor: <..., Width: 1- ' Sq. fDo1ags 2nd ftoar: 2.0' Sq. footage 3rd IIoor: Olflerenoe between lIllIe1InlJ grade and propDlleCl ftnlsh gl8lle: Norttl 0" H~hl 01 rldge above IhaI finlah grade: North South -- RernBl1<s o llIeps 0 Shed 1st IIoor 0 2nd tIoor o 181l1oor 0 2nd IIoor west Q'" Ea&1 0" East Will RFVISlONR. l,EestEleva1lon...., ~ F~r- /vJ..-:~ov--.~ ~) 2.SouthBevatlol'f't.l\. ,~~~ ~a ~l.l_O" 3.WestElevallon \J....u....,> o.JJJ.~~ .. tl.v~wl.~ 4, NorIt E1svalion N-l d..o~ ~ r~ nt<f .<<Ioud on cbwilllJB lII1d auIxniI phOlOgraphe of lIllie*Jg e1lM11ione. 1_" DETAIL OF.WORK TO BE PERFORMED FoWld8llon: Helghl Exposed \11 0 Srock CI Block Parged D Brick (type) '0 Poured Concrete 0 l'let'* Masonry Chimney. C Block Palged 'lal BrIck (type) l \~~~(\AJch 0 Other Roof PiId1: UaIn M_ ___/12_ SeooqcIary MlIae ----112_ Donner ----112_ 0\Ilef AoDftng materI8I: >>Aephalt Manulacilrer K 0 . 3T ~ . o F1b8rg111ll8 M8nufac1ur8r o Wood (Type: Red Ceder, While Cedar. SItekea, etc.) SkYUghla (flat only): Manlhcturer Uodel No. ManufllClUrer Uodel No. ButI8rs: 0 Wood (type) 0 Aluminum Le8dera (material and size): Sldewd: !AWhile C8CIlw I/"inglea o OUter Trlm: Lumber type 0 Pine Tl'98lmeni ...,gpalm Dtmenelone: South HiIsIotlD Name: - Original DBI8: OItgInaI 8ljlcl!lr. Is Ih8ru an HOC s~ IQrm tor lhl8 building? 0 Yas BfNo 1;- LDC8IIon Looallon o Coppll' SIze SlZI o Clepboard ("""""ure: incMa) Front only o Redwood ~ Cedar 0 Other o StlIin-solld 0 Natural to wealhBl' 0 CIe&r ollnsh Fascia I ~ 'B RekB I X S SoIfiI {O'ie~ C" Frieze WIndow Casing ~ Door Frame d-)(.(.. 'WIndowa;;8tOoubleHung DCaaement ~IWood 'S0Ih8r JI...v...~..J~ &<<.k >>rrue DIvIded Ughls(muntlns) 0 SOL'. (Slmullled Divided L.I!t1l8) . Doon (Iypundmalerial): Front Rear kU '5t,~ F~ GIIIlIglI Ooor(.); Type Malerial l.and8Qlljle m8lllrtals: Drivew8yl1 Walkwsy8 . Note: Complete door and winci3w scltedulee llnl required, Comer boards fJj 1r- ]I: tJ, Posts: Round _ Square_ SIde Welle COLORS Clapboard Of applicable) Sash WL..~ Foundaton SldewaN~ Trim p\ ~~ DeckN~ . A1Iach menufaclurer's GOIor SlIIIlJIIes. I hereby au1horlZ811t81lQ8nt named abcMllD act on Ill)' behalf to make changes in tIw appIaaIJon InID compUlUllIIl with lite HOC guld8lln88. I hereby 19_ to 8bId8 by comply au aRf flIYIaIonI to IIIIa ~ wlllnihle a IlIW 8ilclV-dIIY reWlw S :: ~~ME. Fence ShuUm E LJ ..., .::7 ;5 i~ ; ti 2 ! w ,.. I V tiC .~,... 1:1: " ;~~ .---.......... .-- --... -- ......- ... .... '. ~ f · r oSS - "'5 a./-P :ie, W:)Jr. & /vt.G-. ;eA.:>' .ss- .3~3 ...... ) Ill' ~ 1 ~! r I hr , : ~I ,~ ' ~ tJ 't ;:t { ~, 1, ';~./i j ..-l ,jS /''C, '.DKKD~ 33':t: ! -~ PIC, , , .' .. .. " ... -' / ... ...',"' ,. . J~ S~-y .....,../1=' J.(OUS,J;: G.C. ~ BG!:J ~ s.F'- No. 20 '/' '. , , '-' , I / STy .. -- / .,., -:: / . L .sr::,;, ./ 'VV/~ STVZ>IO G.c.= ;2, 73 '* $.F: / .~ ." . n-/+:' ;Fe.S. TleR.NE':::I . " / . , I I lry\ / \ \.2>:-\\- '. . i ~+"" ~~ ..L> v' t \L~'l ! · ~ .5$- :3S6 ~ 1'1.-/.p lq C\ J. &.. A. .P. .,. .A /\.ot .E..s f ~ I i lJ 'H .,.. ! t' 'i.. : ~ lc)lq ~~O)C) t L{ ! '2,.'7 r ")' .....-x-- -.) , 1- .''; , .1 Q I ~ ," .; j ""I'i - 5"5-3-4-+ M:ORTG~,qE PLOT PLAN -OF lAND IN NANTUCKET, MASS. I" ,..-,1, - 'J SCAlE: 1..15' DATE: B -23 -..93 TO:. .~~~:~~J:'.~?: .~~~~...... .".....-.,- ~._-:'\ .:;. _:: f CfRJIFY. TO 1HE BEST OF lIY I<NOWLEDGf. 1HAT THE PREUISES SfI)WN ARE LOCAlED IN flDOD HAzARD ZONe .': C; :'. ..oa..KAlED ~ FJ.RJI. J COIIUIIY PANEl. HUIIlER: 2502JO-OO.' ( . .u. BY lIfE FEDERAl. BIERGEHCV IIANAGEUENT 1OOK:i. EFFECTM: om: OF' MAPS: .JUJIE 3, 1888, AND AS I9IODICAU.Y RNSED. NO'! ,-,0 -.......^- -.eJiC W'; ~'p Ii:. /.s C I/.../... A. F'. wn..... . . . . . . . .',' . . . . . . . . . . . . SA P E:R.. S r,.e:- / J'o& .,..-Deed: -:--'./~"=C:::--~7.. Plan: ../Y'?/"f ~. . . THIS PLOT PlAN WAS PREPARED fOR iIORTGAGE PURPOSES ONLY Nfl) IS HOT 10 BE COHStDERED A roLL JNSlRUUOO SURVEY. THIS PlAN SHOULD NOT BE l1SED TO ES'TABUSH PRQ.PfRJY LNS. fENCES. HEDGfS OR ANY ANCJl.LARY I ~1rM;njiU:.:J UN .tit: P~~Q. .tiE rRUiitRTi ~ ,')HoWti /WI.V nil rJlRflnn' ~c: "Nn PfAWC: n~ ~n Tax Uap: ~5:-.~~7'. CHARLES W. 11ART & ASSu\;1A"rJ!;S. inC. Locus: ;;. Q t<.E: 11"{;> ~ r~- tT1 > Ql ~ m r- Tn ~ ::I ~ c::.- " ~ 1 C> .:> c:5 ~ -t> IJ'1 r',,) rr ".:'1 -!) ,.. = \11 ( EEl ,",--- c. (a3 z C ~ rn .- rn ~ '-\ 5 z 83 ,AA A IN HtJU s ~ CD CD CD CD I 11 OJ IT] DO rn OJ DO DO -. ~~!~.J.I'; , NORTH ELEVATION (F..tn) ;::-! \ I . ' ' ' . ~ l, ~J:~ :~ I ,.".,. Ie Ii MrM Fk"dI.,. . (McAa_,,) CD CD CD CD 1\ I rn rn DO rn rn DO DO T ( F"""'""'i ~ l L-'=j ffij . . . . 'r "MAIN HIJII~G 1--\ N .. Z ,. W C) W -l U ~ <( W <( u \SJ D \JJ [ml tffi EtEtm ~ U Z ~ Q ........ ~ C/lJ UJ ~ ~ Z ........ ~ UJ C ~ r r rr. L.. ~ '!1 r ~ ~ ffi r r.rJ .J ~ a:: ~ ~ ~ 00 ~ C/lJ ~ ~ r.rJ w r ~ z : c 0 r ~ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . GXI6-nn) M/P:551337 SOUTH ELEVATION ~ ~ -l , I:L I ~ ~' 9 (;j = u..~' D ~ ~ ~~~ \SJD~ EtEEtE tmtm Q;J U Z uJ ...-. C) ...-. ~ C/lJ uJ E2 ...-. Z .......... ...-. uJ C r CffJ Ei. ...-. uJ ...-. a... ~ CffJ uJ ...-. :c c r tm MIP:55I32 P"'IN_cl SOUTH ELEVATION ~ A IN )hJllrc , . m ~ , , , , , , , , , , , , , , . . . . . . . . . ". . . . . . . . ff1EfrE) :;::::) e~/Nrn.1 ~r+G"; -11M , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , m mJIm . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . P"."8'''' WEST HEV AT/ON ~'.',"'.,'" 1=- rmm - . . . . . . . . . . . . ''''-~''-''''-'''''~''~''~~l J . .~1'tl . ~,~.........,-.." . . . . . . . . . ~ --- i t . . . . . . . . . . -'h'''':''\ " ,. '-'-''''^''~ @ e I ) / / _/ I I 8 ~ c fa e @ ,':~ I , , '---" UJ z < ..... .... III 8 .-I u.. Co :z Q u l1J tn \ , , \ \ 'j- \ :'1".' \ ,:-..1 \ 1 U J UJ ! c::" , ", .....-) - z :5 I.\... ~ (j) " CERTIFICATE NO: 4'5(\ l1:ll, DATE ISSUED: --U.-j3l'> 10<; , Appicalion to the HISTORIC DISTRICT COMMISSION, Nantuck81. Ma88!lChu8e1ts, lor a ' CERTlFlCATE OF APPROPRIATENESS lor stlUotural Wlllk. All blanks mUBl be 1111l1d In using BLUE OR SLACK INK (no pencil) or rnal1<ed NlA. NOTE: It Ie ""0II111V recomm....ded lhlll Che Illllllcant be tIm"lIr with Che HDC guId...... Sullilflll/ wfrh NIIIIIIMJbt In Aftnd, ptIcIr &0 .ubmlUIII at appllcallon, P1a_ _ altIer elM for aubmfttal requlremen18. Incorilplelt eppnC8llone will not be reviewed by 1h. HDC. This is a conIracIuaI agrsBlTIent and mu.. be filed out in ink. An application is hereby made lor i_ 01 a CerIIIIc8te 01 Appro(Jf1ateneee under Chapter 395 ollila Acts and FIe&olves 01 Mass,. 1970. for proposed work as descrtbed helllln arid,on plans, drawlngs IWld phcIographs aoc:ompanying this appIcation and mada a part hereof by reler1lrlOe. The C8f1iflcale Is 1IiIlId lor Ihree years from dale 01 Issuance. No alruclUre may differ Iwm the approwd aJJlllicalion. VoolelIon may i~e i88uancB Q/ ClwtiIk:a18 01 Ocwpancy, ._, ~ / FOR OFFICE USE ON~Y PROPERTYDESCmpnON Dale appllcallon lIlDelwd: 11/;: j" .If Fee Paid: $ 'tif-o TAX MAP N': 5 IS PARCEL N", ~7.;37 Must be acted on by, '/1'/1;10.,,; SIreet & Number 01 Propoeed WOlle 20 tJE' oW .o:;r~ Elclended to: /" I I OWnerolrecord: \'--DQ. '\ -R-~~U.... :;"'f"~t-<<J'\- =~-=- Mailing Add_; P,O' Lh.J NO.D DC'";~ r.:.o \L... H 0 (oE>+C \ TeIephone:D1-1 &0.& 3:z!on Illland) (off iBland) Member. Y1'\.. C c.L. 11 AGENT INFORMATION (If X:IICable)' MII'/lber: Name; ll~ eou~ fi; ~.-.c. MemblIr. '-~Ing~: ~~~r-~ IO~ ~'Cmn~nW-F~ fCoJ~ Telephone: /..2:h - z..o "'t '\ (an Illland) (oIIl81l11d) o New Dwelling ~ o Color O'tange 0 Fe So1nar (p18llll8 lpeclIy) Size of BlrUcture or Addlllon: DESCRIPTION OF WORK TO BE PERFORMED see _lor rwqulred dooumenlldlOn, o GaragafAplrlment 0 Commen:lal 0 Haloric:8J RenCMlllon 0 Deck o Paving 0 Move Bulking 0 DemoBIIon 0 RevIsions 10 previOUS Curt No, 't: Sq. Footage 1 al floor: Sq, fooIage 2nd ftoor. Sq. loolage 3rd floor: Dlllerence be'-R exis1lng grade and Jll'oposed ~~ glllde~ North (,Y' South Halghl Q/ ridge abOve h1l1n11h grade: NorIl 1:.1 - 0 South I, I - O^ AddItIonoolRl!!nw1oI o S1eps 0 Shed SbIe: Size; o 11lt1loor D2ndtoor o 1 at Iocr 0 2nd Iocr Original Dal8: Orlginal S..lder. II fllll8 an HOC survey form lor IhIs bulldng? 0 Y lIS East (',Vo. West O~ East \1'-()4' West \,T-& FEVlSIONS" 1, East EIava1lon N.A '0' adJ.....'t, "'- ~ ~ > (de.ecribe) .1 2-SOillhBavatIon~ ~ --tL-. c-lLJ..l1l\~ 3. WestElevelion LJ~ ~ :'b.-.:v--O 4, NorIh E1elfllllcn tf Hlsto:1c ~ ,<<lOUd on drawWlge and 8Ubmlt phofogIaphs oI"ng eIevaIor&. O ..,...A, DETAIL OF 'IIORK TO BE PERFORMED Block . ~ock Parged 0 Brick (type) 0 Potnd Concre1e 0 PI_ Masoruy ChImney: 0 BJock lWged 0 BlIck (type) 0 Other RooIP"IIch: MaitrMaee---'12_S8cOnclaryMlI88----11L- Dormer ---112..-- Olher RoalingmDrial;~ MsIu1aclurllr I K.~ <,;, ~ IFeI-= Height o Fiberglass Manulaclurw Lengf1: o Wood [Type: Red Cedar, While Cedar, Shakes, elC.) Type: SkyIlghtll (fII>t only); ManutIlQIurer ModlII No. Size LocaIion Manulaclllrer Modal No. Size locaIlon Gutters: 0 Wood (type) 0 A/umimm 0 Copper ,L.eadera (mal8r181 and size); .JIdeW8U: ~ cedar ehrQlBl o Olher Trtm: Lumber \ype 0 Plnll Treatrnem IifPaint DimlIr1eione: DNa Foundallon: Height Expased to... o Clapboerd (8XpCl8UnI: Inahes) Fronlonly o Redwood t&cedar 0 0lh8r o StalI'I-8OIld 0 NllIurellO W88Iher 0 Cl98l' 0I1Imlh Fasc:ia I ,-11) Rake (~'l 801ft! (Overhan~) 0 Frilll'B Window CasIng ~ Door FrMl8 ~ T 7'- ..... . Windows: ~Ie Hung 0 Casement )iliA/I Wood 0 OIher \lJlrrua DMd8d L1ghlB(munlns) 0 SOL's (SlmlAaI8d DMdad l.lghIs) . Ooor$ (type and material): Front Rear Garage Ooor(s): Type Material Land8cape mal8rials: Dri_ys WakWays . NoM: Complete door and wincrow ached_ In required, Comer boards PoetB; Rouncl_ Square_ Side \!') L.1l=:t7 t. ~ WBlIs ~::-~~~ Deck . Attach manufadurer's color samjlIM. COLORS ClapbOa/:!I (II appRcable) SaIh ~ FOIIldaIlon ~ =~~~1~ Fanc8 Sllutlera . j NO\! ~ IS - _....~- 'L___-~------ "--~ .... . :. ) NOV - 5>\ _~_.._- _. .._.___,,-_..-_<_.' ........~._....:...c:..i.__.'--....~.J--'.~ ~. PLAN CtfJ~~.1e tfB EEE . . . . . . . . . . . Erlsl-In~ WEST ELEVATION m ffij . . . . . Ern EEE . . . . . . . . . . . J>"~SIJ WEST ELEVATION- ~ C.~i-1' Ern e~/S"'ri9 NORTH ELEVATION $..~,;C"'~'~-.~ tm tm Em Ern Em J>>-/lH.J NORTH ELEVATION- C'dt-tlAjL . Ft/r'/'''J SOUTH ELEVATION ~ ~ ]>M'IJSlJ se,ld'h CW.l>n tIE -- -- -- -- .. .. .. -- -- .. -- .. 1 1 I I ". c /)#117" tIE tIE . .. .. .. . .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. &1i~ EAST ELEVATION ~~~s~ :- . ' . . . . . . . .. .. .. .. ~~s,J .I: A "....#tI.-..,,_n...WIlI . . / . 'I I I i I I II ! I I I i !: : I I I :1 11'\ il II i I Ii II11II II I'" I i!1 ,il! I I ilj 11 Ii il! I! II ,I, , II ! i' 1 111,1111 ~ l! I j I t:::tj (\J i! i II ill'llll I. I! I II !lllli EE3 'J ii! III Iii 1,11111 (\J '1, . I! I'!II!I ii ~ .1 , I I i I,I! II I ,II I I,! II I I ~ I I! I I ! I! II i'! i ~ j I I I ~ I i EE tc) I I 11 ~ ! ~ l i ! i I I I I I I ! A NOV 3'0 '04 4. 5 0 8 8 !~o ~~ ~ ~HIOlh'-' '-HANG~ I UT H.D.C ~PROVA ~ l() EE tc) \, 5 ) ~ APPAOVE() NOV j 0 '04 4 5 0 e 8 .~O E1ia. > c.IriIU",' ,AHOt:.,;. 11THOU' "'.D.(; "PPROVJ,\ 7 ! ! i j I' Ii , I II i; ,I II II II ii, II i ,I i 'I ! I ! I II i I Ii ! I i 1 ,i ,! ,':', ! : i ! Ii !! i i i : I , I, i 1 i I: : i , Ii! I I III II I I I! , II I ! I i I I i I I: : I I , : I I j 1 iTI"I\' :'" 11,!I!III! III1 !! 111',1111,' 1111 'I II!'I! I ,. ""11' 'I Ii IHI Ii ! Ii 1 ;:,11 i 11111 !~, ,i, II1I 'II 'i I' 'I II 1',ll,Ui1dl III'!I i : I i ~ Ii; III 'iI:: i i'lflll!! i 1111 I " 1'1 Ii ;: I I 11: iLII!' i illl!,!1 'Iii In l:illll1 ! H 1\111'11[11 II; In d i Iii Iii iH, ! I I' oil Iii i111:!1 "I '''I'''' : I 11;11 ill! I 'I' ;' III illllli I 1"1,,, I to ~ z o F ~ 1U -.J 1U :c I- :;:) o U) NOV - 5-' . , ' ,................---...,..._....-=- ---._''''...._-.,.-~--............'-''~-~ _.- " \ ) ~ov - 5 _-.-.~_._----- ..~~...-......-.,.-; .'-. . . 't~OV !; oJ L._ -.'-'-'-........-.. ..J.__'~' -"".. .' ......._"_V .'-"- ~ ~ l BOli Fan.., 2-89 11 00 j:)J ' . / , NANTUCLE:T ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS , ' 'TOWN AND COONTY BUILDING ". NANTUCKETt MA 02554 ASSESSOR'S LIST OF PARTIES IN INTEREST ./ PROPERTY" O~ER: Lee, w. (JJ'\cL VA"~jC~ F S:Lf-U.b~ 'APPLICANT F<;)}~ RELIEF (SAME? V'): AD,DRESS. OF ',PROPERTY: d.(j K]eA.0 ~. A~S~SSOR I S. MAP - PARCEL: ()lYli - 3~1- LIST -OF PARTIES INCLUDING ADDRESSES*(OR SEE ATTACHED ---) : I. * .' - * RECEIVED BOARD OF ASSESSORS NOV 0 3 2004 TOWN OF NANTUCKET,MA .' ~ ., . .0 . ;: "' I' certifY':.th,~t :~the 'for~going (or the attached _) lis~s all .-persons.;':, natural or legal, who are owners of abutt~ng 'property,,~'..:o,wners, of' land directly opposite OJ} any public . or private-:.street or way; ,and abutters of the abutters and all other land owners within three hundred feet of the property' line' of Owner's propertYt as they (and their address) appear on the most recent applicable tax list (per.M.G~L. c.4DA, section 11 and zoning Code Chapter 139, section 13~-2~D{2)]. /f}~ 5" ;l()tJi Date / . '- *NOTE: Applicant (petitioner) should include with the lot for which zoning relief is sought, any commonly-owned abutting lots which might become involved in the zon~ng matter. List map and parcels for each abutter. - --------- -- -------=-=-~- -=~---- ---- :'l :'l :'l:'l ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ w ff ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 00 ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ M ~ ~ ~ 0 ~ ~ N m ~ N 0 ~ ~ M ~ ~ N ~ ~ ~ ~ N N ~ ~ rot ..... '" o .., '" I m ~ ~ ~ ~ . ~ m ~ ~ ~ ~ . . ~ ~ ~ . . ~ ~ 0 0 ~ 0 . . . ... """ ~ ~ ~ ... "" m "" "" "" ~ 0 o 0 ~ ~ N m N 0 ~ 0 N N ~ ~ N ~ .. ~ ~ ~ 0 ... ... 0 ... ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 0 ~ ~ ~ N ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 0 ~ ~ ~ N ~ N 0 ~ N ~ ~ ~ ~ ..... ~ n ~ ~ "" " ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ..... N m ~ ~ 0 ~ ~ ~ ~ m .~ 0 ~ N N m N m 0 N m N N N N N N N N N N M N N ~ N N N N N N ~ N N N N "" N N N ~ ~ N N 0 0 0 0 0 0 NON " ..... 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 " 0 0 0 ~ 0 0 0 N 0 <= ~ ~ ~ ~ a] ~ ~ ~~~~ ~ ~~~~ ~ AI AI Il:C .( III r-- ~ en 0 III "".. ... .... ~ ~ ~ ~ tI) U1 en U1 E-4 00 ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ II') rt r-t I .... .... ..... 0'1 ~ g~~~;J~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ .., U :z; Q ~ 00 OJ tl' '" 00 ~ U1 E-4 ~ ~ E-4 ~ ~ ~ E-4 U1 U1 U1 U1 ~ U1 ~ U1 U1 U1 tl ~ ~ ~ ~ U1 ~ U1 ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ m ~ "" N 0 ~ ~ ~ ~ II') .... .... .... .... .... m m ~ "" "" :'l :'l ~ 0< 0< ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ '" ... '" on ... '" ~ ~ ~ 00 00 00 II: iJ: II: U ~ ~ ~ CD I ... N 0\ r-- ~ ~ ~ ~ en U) en rn ~ ~ ~ ~ '" '" ... ... .., .., '" '" I I .., ... ... CD CD on CD 0 on '" '" '" 0...0 '" ... o on '" on .., '" 00 ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ !5 ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ g IIU;UIUlIuluui ~~~ Q ~ ~ ~ 2 2 = ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ > ~ ~ ~ ... 00 Q Q ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 2 :'l ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ; ; ; I I ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ! ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ i 00 Q ... is ~ i ~ Q .. ~ t ~ i a II: U ... ~ Q ~ ~ Q ~ U ~ U ~ ~ ~ ~ i ~ ~ i "'''' ~~ ~a !i:l ~ ~~ ~:z; :Z;iO:~~ ~ ~~ ~oo~~o<: :: 5~~1I: ~..l ~:il:il ~ ~ ..l ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ t ~ ~ ~ ~ ... 00 00 ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ on ~ ... ~ ... ~ ~ ~ ~ '" .. ~ ~ ~ i I ~ i ~ 8 i i 5 I ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ i ~ : : I : ; : ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~... 0... on : '" '" ~ Q ~ 0 0 ~...... ~ g g ~ g ~ g '" ~ ... ... ~ g ~ ~ ~ III ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 2 ~ ~ = ~ ~ ~ ~ 2 2 ... ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 2 ~ '(;: Cf.l .:: ::! ~ ~ c\ --i -.. ,-i ~ o:z; ~ tl~ i i ~ <;:0..., i!1 is ~ 0< ~ ~ ..l S! ..l ~!Ztl .... ~ g)l ~~;l ~ jl:z;~~~~ EE ~ ~ e ~ ~~LHl ~~~., ; 5 ~ ~ .. 0 ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~)l 00 00 ~ ~ ~ d d 00 ~ g ~ .., ~ ~ ~ ~ ; : ~ ~ ~ iJ: iJ: ..l ~ .., tl ~ ~ ~ .., ~ ~ )l ~ = ~ ~: : ~ g ~ ~ Q~!;>lOS~~gf:lg;g;:z;~o<E~~""'Q;;~..l ~~oooo Iilq2= 9 ~::l~~~o<~s~~l:ll:l~Q~O<~..l~..~~~...~r:l~~f:l~",,;lO<~ ; al:l~~u~u~: gg::l ..O<!:l~~O:~"'g~Q~~~~~~~~ , e~;!~I!i~IHiiii:aildU;~i~U~i~n ~ ~:I:...~!i:o!i:..l0<:E__ijt!lI:!::l!~!ilooo~~~~~<1Il0000E5~~~ -.., '" .. " ~ ~ l> <= .M .... .M :2 t!l ~~ Ul H HE-4 ~B ~~ ~~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ , ;nn ~ ... ~ ~ -: ~ C:lt'I~O~ .... ('I"j t'l .. ~ O'l I ~ ., .. i ~ tJ ... ~ ~ ~ i ~ ~ ~ '" '" ;;; g ::l on o '" .. ~ 00 ... ~ on '" :z; ~ ~ g CD g ~ ... ... on on '" '" ~ ~ g g .... ~ ..( ::! ::! ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ :z; z .. .. I ~ ~ ... ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 9 :z; " I " ~ ~ 000 .......... ..... u u u o U .M <= ::> () ~ ~ ~ ~ '" ~ 00 O'l 0 ~ N t'l ... It'I ~ ~ O'l 0 ~ N M ... It'I ~ m m ~ ~ ~ O'l N ('I"j N o ,...O'lO'lOO'lONNN(I')I.DOr-tN...LtlP1M.....................,...lI'JU'lUltJlllllllLt)tt)It)\Q\DI.ONlIlltlllll.Or"'CI).. H r-t.........'" Nt"ltl"lt")tr')('l')M............,f"lf"'1('l')('l')MMMMMMMMMMMMMMMP1t"1('1"j('l"j\D\D\D('l")("')MM M .,. ... '" .., ... ... ~ ~ ~ .. ~ ~ ~ ..l 00 .. ... Iil III :il ~ ~ .. ~ ~ 00 II: ~ o ..... u ~ 00 ~ ~ ~ ~ j i ; I ... ~ )l :z; ~ 8 ~ !< U 00 l!l ~ :i1 ~ ~ ~ o U ~ ~ 00 ~ ..l ~ ~ ~ ~ o i I ., a 0< ..l ~ ... ~ .. 00 :il o ..... U o ..... U ~ ~ ~!:l!:l 00 E~ ~~ cn5 0< i i ~ :z; ; ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ g ~ iJ: ~ ~ i!1 !:l i!1 = .., ~ = ., iJ: a g ~ i ..l Q ~ ~ Q ~ ... ~ ~ ~ ::! ~ ~ ~ : ~ i!1 d 5 d ~ ~ ~ ~ d ~ ~ 5 ~ ! ~ ~ ~ i ~ g ~ I :i1 = iJ: = ~ ~ Q ~ i ~ ~ ... '" ... '" '" .-t .-t .-t "'" ~ ......,..,.......... ~ ~:g ~ :g :g :g :g :g :g :g :g :g :g :g :g :g :g :g :g :g :g :g :g ~ :g :g :g :g :g :g :g :g :g :g :g :g :g :g :g :g :g :g :g ~ :g :g ~ o N ..... U") ~ o .... ~ diiiiiiiiil ~ 0< ro P'I'" \0 .... P. ri.... rot ""' 1;; Ed' E< ~ 1;; i Ii I ! OMrtUll"-1""'lC"1aJ N .... .... .... M M N N ~ ~ l"- ~ Ul Ul ~ Q) 0> <1j 0.. E< E< E< :;j ., ., ., ~ ~ t! t! t! 000 .. .. .. '" Q) 0 .-t .... N r-l . . ~ ... r-l NO'" ... Ul . \0 .... \0 0 ~ M 0 ... ... r-l Ul Ul ... Ul ~ l"- N Ul Ul \0 Ul ~ ~ ~ ri Ul ~ CX) Ul Ul Ul P. e>>ll'Ir--lt}Q)O...lIl Ul.... Ul.-tQ)COlXlO'lOOUlUlQ) .... t'lN....NON\ONNNNf""\D\D....""NONN\D N OOOONOOOOOOUlOOOMOMOOO 1;; !ll~~~~~t~~~~ '" E< E< ., U U ~ I;l ~ ~ ~ ~ t ~ E< ~ ~ ~ g ; ~ i lO ., B ~ i B BIB ~ ~ ~ E ~ ~ ~ E E 1;; E ~ w ~ ~ u ., ., ~ ~ ~ ~ ., ~ ~ :<: u a E< E< 0: ~ f:H! ~ ~ I I Iii ! '" " " G j g .... ... ~ ~ H 0: '" t.!> ~~ rn H HE-! rnt! U ~ ~ E< ~ ~ \0 CI) 0 Q : :lO~E<~~ ~ ~Iii~i ~ ",;:on~;:~ = lO " , ~ G ! o u '" ... .. .. ..:l '" ::> li! " .. ..:l ! ~ ~ i I ~ ~ ~ [;j ~ f:l ::l ::J ~ ~ !:l E< i .. '" = s ~ ilO ~ H " ilO , H ~ 0: G ~ ! ., .... g .... N C"'1 l"'4 N ~ 0: E< ..:l W ~ E< E< ~ ., ., '" lO lO ~ ~ I I ~ ... o U"I ,... M 1fI .... r-I .-t ..:l .. ~ Q) ; ~ I ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ I ~ lO ... ~ 2 ~ ~ ... M ~ 0: H ..:l U '" E< ., ~ a ~ ~ ~ :'l lO ~ H > III :I: i ~ I ~ .. a ., o .,.... ~ re ~ : ~ 10: I ~ i ~ : .. s ~ ~ ~ : ~ a ~ 5 ~ 0 ~ ~ 0: f:l ~ '" " ~ ~ w ~ !:l ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ e i G ~ ~ ~ .. E< W 0: ~ ~ H g; ., 0: '" CD .... ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ H l< ~ 2 ... ~ on ... 0'" ~ 2 ~ ~ ~ a ; ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ i2 t! 0: Ii o S 0 "U2"U ~ a ..:l .. .. ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ o 0: ~ ~ [;j a ~ ffi 5 t! m !;l <Il ~ ~ .... ~ '" N '" U) o rl III H :'l gj u !:l ~ .. s: :I: III .. ~ " I e ill g re o ., <Il <Il .. 5 ~ ~ m '" .. ~ M ... Ul .... o P'lMMo\O'lOO....NP1""II'IM...Ul"',................ ..:I .........MC"'l'" ""........ ""O'lOlO'lO'lO'l....rtMN ~ .... .... r-I .... .... .... .... .... .... r-I .... .... .... .... .... .... .... .... p. ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ~ ~~~~~:g:g~:g:g:g:g:g:g:g:g:g:g:g:g:g o N "- U) "- rl rl ZONING' CLASSIFICATION: . .~Ok. MIN. AREA: . . . . . . .4;QQ9. S";:; MIN. FRONTAGE: . . . . . . . s:O '. ~ FRONT YARD S.B.: . . . <<t7K~ REAR && SIDE S.B.: . . : . . . .S.P"7:" GROUND COVER (7.): . . . .:T.q .% EXISTING: . ~~~~~.S,E . .~y...a9~ . . . . . II. . . . 1/ . . . . . . . . . II . . . . . . . . . .x t N E VV S To 3~.I3 #z;z. ~ S/I<' I "';;:S ~ .,q .eA.~77/V'G I /;("fX, '1~-1( ! i I .(:t_ ..H/Z^ "/,,( TAAi'i< ss- .3-43 ~UN~ CO V...e--"e ~/S77NG :' / /1"',<./:SE :; 55% i "R....eO.4?S...E:P::: //0 -:t S,;=; ro-:rM..- :: //Z-S/l~S,;::: = 38 %~ .;, - ~ //IJ ~,' , , ',' ,... /, '" . :."",'.:,';,(,',',',",',',",,.,~",.'. if" ,J ~ ~Zi;Q).;L~<1f /-/2 -2t;J- ASSR:5S0R.S~ S-6--3:>7 C,\JOOS\CWH\9U' is-'- '- z~oo '. I I .I ~ .s ,:>, w 1;:- .}(o uS F.: G.C, = 8tP!3 /,..,b :f:; S.F'- ........,."W' 80S,) No. 20 I I I 56'-338 /Y/r- A. p. A~.s (No ,P~) ON ,c//vi[ tJ )E c K ~ :--...', \J~ S~ ~~ i " tl ( , ~~ Ql ~ ,:) . I I I <::IN'' ,-.- -- . .~/v'"e' \ o ~ '" ~ , ~. ," ~ I I I I ; .I. ' o..s '<' , - I - 1::5..5~ / --- I ZO.-V-V ~/ 0..1 -~I I ~l ~I 5'5-34-+ I n..j.f:' -"~;.,S. 7/~R.Ne'::"l . PL.fiA:/~- 78 ZOK//(C EOA.RO Or-- Ap?~ PA-.A./V OF LAND IN NANTUCKET, M'ASS. / SCALE: 1w./5 DATE: JAJ.(./.z/Z.~5 Owner: ~.v.(. i-?,f/':;c;/w./'!. $'!I::~I?Sw.;y Deed: tW-/Z'Q .,;.;'~'.~I:" PIon f?~ !7--:e:Kp~/1(<o Locus . ;(;Q. ~.-e-kv:'" .-.3~~T . . . CHARLES W. HART &. ASSOCIATES, Inc. SANFORD BOAT BUILDING 49 SF .ARKS AVENUE NANTUCKET, MASS. 02554 \ (508) 228-8910 H-~c?8 / .. <~~:~~_:,-". "'""'~ "''''~iil<.~ - ~ '.J j ----" \ ); ~ f\ WAY TOWN OF NANTUCKET 521 6.6.4 ~ILL HILL CEMEn/i:Y ~ 11.l..1 11'.1 J >- oq ~ N.C.H, ~ 5.5 A ~ II? 8.3 A g TOWN OF NANTUCK(T 101 ~f,.';I' 14.8 A '00 _ , / JuliesfPT~ ATTORNEY AT LAW 4 BARTLETT ROAD P.O. BOX 2567 NANTUCKET, MASSACHUSETTS 02584 FAX (508) 228-7526 fitzgrld@nantucket.net IN HAND January 20,2005 Nancy Sevrens, Chairperson Board of Appeals 37 Washington Street Nantucket, MA 02554 RE: Application of Lee W. and Priscilla F. Saperstein Property: 20 New Street, Nantucket Map 0055, Parcel 337 Dear Ms. Sevrens: COpy FOR YOUR INFORMATION TELEPHONE (508) 228-7525 ['.1 --' -:; ~ Enclosed please find four (4) copies of the HOC approved plans for submission with the above Application. Very truly yours, lieA.Fi~>~ Enclosures cc: Catherine F. Stover, Town Clerk Lee W. and Priscilla F. Saperstein (j) -\ m \1 r )> Z Jan 19 05 10:54a Deb 508-228-2082 p.2 CERTifiCATE NO: ~rsMJ, P.'\ {,,-; I . DA TE ISSUED: Application to the HISTORIC DISTRICT COMMISSION. Nantucket. Massachusens, for a CERTIFICATE OF APPROPRIATENESS tor structural work, All blanks musl be filled '" using BLUE OR BLACK INK (no pencil) or marked N/A NOTE: It Is strongly recommended that Ihe applicant be familiar with the HDC guidelines, Building with Nantucket in Mind, prior to submittal 01 application. Please see other side lor submittal requirements. Incomplete applications will not be reviewed by Ihe HDC, This is a contraclual agreement and must be filled OUl in ink. An application is hereby made for issuance of a Cenifica,e of Appropriateness under Chapter 395 of the Acts and Resolves of Mass., 1970, for proposed work as described herein and on plans. drawings ar'ld photographs accompanying this applicatiOn and made a part hereof by reference. The certificate is valid for three years from date 01 issuance, No structure may differ from the approved application, Violation may Impeoe issuar'lce of Cert,ficate of Occupancy. Extended 10: Approved: Cha,rman: FOR OFFiCE USE ONLY II / ~ II) 4 Fee Paid: S '5 0 I/I/"Sk",:> ..- ! / v{;J Disapproved: ();V'f'1(IJ:i~ t.;It'f"r-- 'f:r1J //'Ywl/ (I .cr I A M .____-'. 'j L'L' ~)', "-''-' u;-., ~:.. - '_ _,~ \,,/\ ( <.:, ,0'--'-. I \ PROPERTY DESCRIPTION TAX MAP NO: t:) ~ PARCEL N' _ 7.37 Street &. Number 01 Proposed Work: 20 We J-.J -::'-t f\.Q.~" Ownerofreeo,d: ~_ Ii 0'''-.~\~ ~F~ O:-,t,~V' Mailing Address: ~O \ '-.,. "-' N' () D" rC eo\l", M 0 (o~4 0\ Telephone57-:S 3lo~ 3/~2(on island) , AGENT INFORMATION (if rliCable) Name: 1"1 ; I +c.ro.. 120...)L:. ~1 t., ~,~ '" C' . Mailing Address: ~ r D "^ ~ ,- -: 'IX (~)-, ~'~, "'^- +v ~~ H A... 0 7, :::, 'j ~ Telephone: 2J;b' Z-o -4 'T (on islar'ld) Dale application received: Must be acted on by: Member. (of! island) Member: Member: Member: Notes. Comments. Rr~:J { Fr~Ut~ ,n0co, t /V., d -- (off island) DESCRIPTION OF WORK TO BE PERFORMED See reverse for reqUired documentation. :J New Dwellir'l9 z:4'-'Addition :J GaragelApartmen: = Commercial :J Historical Renovation = Deck [] Color Change :i Fe..9l'e = Paving = Move Building = Demolition = Revisions to previOUS Cerl. No, SlOther (please specify) ~ t- }.;. +-: Size 01 Structure or Addition: Length: Sq, Footage 1s1 Roar: Width: Sq. tootage 2nc! floo:: I Sq. footage 3rd floor: Difference between existing grade and proposed finish grade: North (j' South Height at ridge above final finish grade: North 11' - o^ South II' - OA Addilional Remarks o Steps :J Shed ~ g -17Q~d,'!,.l-, k' ....... . \.. '.u9C S. -~ Size: = I sl nocr =, 2nd 1I00r = 1 st Roor =: 2nd floor Size: East West ~ West 0 II'-cr ex East \31,'- C)" ()~ Hlslonc NarTie:' Onginal Date: Original Builder: REVISIONS' (descrine) ~. , , East Elevation ,Ai), S' o.dJ....-.t , i~ v-i~.~ 2. South Eevation ~o.:A. ~"t..-O...-l -{~-l~ ~ ~ 3. West Elevation tl "',.....' . " Y7 r--' ~.~ \~. S ,->.r-<:> 4. North Elevation . , , c-...cJ-U-...J --;"" \ '" Is there an HOC survey form for this building? =' Ves .Cloud on draWlngs and submit photographs of existing elevalions. Foundation: Height Exposed to. _- BI""" --..:~Il. DETAIL OF ]l(ORK TO BE PERFORMED ~ ,...J:ilock Parged :.-1 Brick (ty;:>e) = Poured Concrete == Piers Masonry Chimney: ::: BlocK Parged :J Brick (type) j 011,." Rool Pitch; Main Mass _It 2_ Secondary Mass 112 Dormer _'t 2_ Other Roofing malerial: ~phaJt Manu/acturer I K () _ ~-y- ~ == Fiberglass Manufacturer =:'No Fence: Height: Length: Type: = Wood (Type: Skylights (flal only): Manufacturer Red Cedar, While Cedar, Shakes, etc,) Model No, Model No. :-; Aluminum S,ze Size LocatIon Location :J Copper Manufacturer Ouners: C Wood (type) Leaders (material and size): Sidewall: S<!White cedar shingles [J Other Trim: Lumber type :J Pine Treatment ~ Redwood )',leeda, _ Other ~ Stain-solid ~ Natural to weather --: Clear oil finish Fascia \.... ,') Rake I.,.. <; Frieze Window Casing 51.... "f . Windows: ~ouble Hung ::::; Casement ~AtI Wood = Other tmrrue Divided Lights(muntins) = SDL's (Simulated Divided Ughts) . Doors (type and material): Front Rear Garage Door(s): Type Landscape materials: Driveways . Nole: Complete door and window schedules are required. cJ Clapboard (exposure: inches) Front only '&'Paint Dimensions: Soffit (Overhang) 0 Door Frame 5/ 'r." -4- Corner boards Pesls: ROUr'ld _ Square_ Side ;.) '.' ,~ :~-t- i, ,)"-J~ Malerial Walkways Walls COLORS Clapboard (if applicable) Sash ~\- lY'-. Foundation ~)~j,..c' ~ Rool G~ C,p-TI J.l.- o Irlt=. (2,:.,.,1...- Sidewall 1\..\ (,..p.,.. r.....Q Trim \r-)"";"Y-- DecK . Attach manufacturer's color samples. I hereby authorize the agent named above 10 acl on my behalf to mak h" , ., , appll,?,hOr'l Into compliance w,tl1 the HOC guidelines, I hereby ag'ee t; ;bi~~gbes In ~he SP~clf'qat'ons or Ih~ plans contained In thIS appllcatien ,n order to brirtg the submlSsiofl of any revisions to this application will initia1e a new sixty'da" re . Y.J an .codmlP ~ WI,I,h the terrl:.s) a,rt? C~nd(}I~~S of thiS appl1cation, I hE:reby agree thai the . ~,~, , voe\. perlo. '.' I ,~1-_ h 'I' Jio '71' . Dale (, I..., ~-c SiQnatur~ of owner of record ';,), :'~ i:.. \)~I j(y.-J.~X',~"" ,>~ P', vUe-.. SK1;')ed under penalties 01 oenurv DOlors Fence Shutters CJ) () c: -\ :r: rn r- m -<:: )> -\ () Z E-d 2802-822 -80S q~a ei7S:01 SO 61 ue r Ul o c -\ I [tl )0- Ul -\ [tl r [tl -<: )0- -\ o Z II v '" .. EEEffi ~ mD w z o 711 -\ I [tl r [tl -<: )0- -\ o Z EE ~ Ul -\ [tl r [tl -<: )0- -\ o Z .. e e o 0 ~ E3 i I e VI [T1 () 0 Z <::J " i r 0 0 7'l 'I r > @ z e I "" JtdieLW:!!T~ ATTORNEY AT LAW 4 BARTLETT ROAD P.O. BOX 2567 NANTUCKET, MASSACHUSETTS 02584 FAX (508) 228-7526 fitzg rld@nantucket.net TELEPHONE (508) 228-7525 IN HAND January 13, 2005 Nancy Sevrens, Chairperson Board of Appeals 37 Washington Street Nantucket, MA 02554 -~ '"j .-~ i-JJ RE: Application of Lee W. and Priscilla F. Saperstein Property: 20 New Street, Nantucket Map 0055, Parcel 337 ~-:J >,) r,.,.~) C\ Dear Ms. Sevrens: Enclosed for filing, please find the following: 1. Four (4) copies of a revised Addendum; and 3. Four (4) copies of a Zoning Board of Appeals Plan by Charles W. Hart and Associates, Inc., dated January 12, 2005; Very tr I yours4 ~ eA. Fitz9~~~~ Enclosures cc: Catherine F. Stover, Town Clerk Lee W. and Priscilla F. Saperstein ADDENDUM The Applicants seek relief by Special Permit pursuant to Section 139-33 E (2)(a) to increase ground cover on a pre-existing nonconforming lot by 110 square feet. The existing Lot contains 3,231 square feet per the Plan by Charles W. Hart, dated January 12, 2005. The current owners' Deed recorded in 1979 recites a lot area of 3,395 square feet. The existing ground cover is 1,142 +/- square feet or approximately 35%. The proposed ground cover is 1,252 +/- square feet or approximately 38%. This increase is well with in the limits of the permitted 50% ground cover ratio in the ROH zoning district. The Board may find that such increase in permitted ground cover shall not be substantially more detrimental to the neighborhood than the existing nonconformity. The Applicants also seek relief by Special Permit pursuant to Section 139-33 A (5) to allow the extension/expansion to a second story of the two existing structures along pre-existing non-conforming rear and/or side setback lines. The main house on the front of the lot does not meet the side yard set back along the westerly boundary. The secondary dwelling does not meet the side yard set back along the easterly boundary and the rear southerly boundary. The Board may find that the extension along a non-conforming set back for second story additions on both structures will not be substantially more detrimental to the neighborhood. The Applicants also seek relief by Special Permit pursuant to Section 139- 18 B. There is one nonconforming parking space currently on the lot. There is inadequate area or readily usable space due to the location of the existing buildings to provide additional parking. The Board may find that the granting of Special Permit relief from Parking would be physically impossible for the Applicant to provide and/or if physically practical would have a significant and adverse effect on the scenic or historic integrity of the neighborhood and/or would be contrary to sound traffic and safety considerations. The property is numbered 20 New Street (Map 0055, Parcel 337). It is located in the Residential Old Historic District. ZONING' CLASSIFlCATION: . .~Ok. MIN. AREA: . . . . . . .-?;C?99. S";=; MIN. FRONTAGE: . . . . . . . s:a '. r::r;- FRONT YARD S.B.: . . . <<G?IY~ REAR /,& SIDE S.B.: . . : . . . .S.~ GROUND COVER (7.): . . . ...:T.q .% EXISTING: . ;r~.:1{ ~.s, E . .~.y,.aQ: . . . . .;1. . . . If . . . . . . . . . " . , . . . . . . . :x 't N ,E; vv S T: " 3~,I.3 '- ;3~OO . 00 , ., PI<:. I X5-'- " ,. /' ' ,. ;' :r/I;z;2. ~ SIR ~s--~s ~ /'r/ rr ~ .eA.~77/VG /j(" ;=:(, LI ~ -){ ..H,ZA 01..( 7A;<..,/<' ..5".5--3-4.:3 / .I ~ S'r;J/ w/;::, Ro us F.: G.c.::: 8G9 (",,, :i:; s.P. """":N" BOS.) No. 20 / / / / / S'ry () ,IE c K 5.0-3:58 /Y/r- A. ~ A~..s I NO p~) '\ ON ,c://JF / '(:t: _ ~"., rj~ S~ ~~ , '- c..c. ~'1ot -/l ~ S,F P;ROA:JS~ A.OLJIT/O/V-S a,e, = 70 -t: $,;::" i \I( , ~, ~r QJ ~ ,,~) . '" , - I . /.3,5~ -" . - - I ,2.0,-Y..y' _/ 0..1 -~I I ~l ~l :55-3"""'" I n.j-P ."R. S. TI.I!:R.NR.:'::JI . PL,U/~- 78 ~ON.P co v..e-"e ~/S77NG ::: 11-7";Z.:CsJ; = :55%-1: ".o....eOA:?S..€P .:: / /0 x ,S,,c; , e1/...J- -ro-r~ :: /,.eo'z~S,,c:: -= 38}0 - n,';<',' ZOKI/tfG I3::JA.RO Or .APj?~ P^-AN" OF LAND IN NANTUCKET, MASS. / SCALE: 1-./5 DATE: JAf(./.z/z~5 Owner: ~.~ i-f?~$t;/~/f. ~..e:~w.JY Deed: tW-/l'Q ...-:'~'...q7." PIon f?~ f?~/V'p.(/1(<o Locus . ;C;Q. ~~~ .-3T~..E'T . . . CHARLES W. HART &. ASSOCIATES, Inc. SANFORD BOAT BUILDlliG 4-9 SF .ARKS AVENUE NANTUCKKT, MASS. 02054 '" (50~) 228-8910 H _ -Y08/ //1) . ,,' ' ~C{ttJ'4J,~o/ I-I 2 -2~- ASSRSSOR.S-P!:" S-6--- 3:>7 c:\ Joe S\ CW11\9l)' " ~':"',~'1J.tc~rr:.,.~1M.i~ '."'~""'~ $die~_/C;(PT~ ATTORNEY AT LAW 4 BARTLETT ROAD P.O. BOX 2567 NANTUCKET, MASSACHUSETTS 02584 FAX (508) 228-7526 fitzg rld@nantucket.net TELEPHONE (508) 228-7525 IN HAND January 11, 2005 Ms. Catherine F. Stover, Town Clerk Town and County Building 16 Broad Street Nantucket, MA 02554 RE: Application of Lee W. and Priscilla F. Saperstein Property: 20 New Street, Nantucket Map 0055, Parcel 337 Dear Ms. Stover: Please certify the date and time of filing of the attached Board of Appeals Application on the enclosed copy of this letter. Thank you for your assistance. Very truly yours, ~-'"- --/ 4- . J ie A. Fitzger ~ Received and entered: Catherine F. Stover, Town Clerk cc: Lee W. and Priscilla F. Saperstein Julie~WPT~ ATTORNEY AT LAW 4 BARTLETT ROAD P.O. BOX 2567 NANTUCKET, MASSACHUSETTS 02584 FAX (508) 228-7526 fitzg rld@nantucket.net TELEPHONE (508) 228-7525 IN HAND January 11 , 2005 Nancy Sevrens, Chairperson Board of Appeals 37 Washington Street Nantucket, MA 02554 RE: Application of Lee W. and Priscilla F. Saperstein Property: 20 New Street, Nantucket Map 0055, Parcel 337 Dear Ms. Sevrens: Enclosed for filing, please find the following: 1. Application with Addendum plus three (3) copies; 2. Certified Abutters' Lists plus three (3) copies; 3. Four (4) copies of a Plot Plan by Charles W. Hart and Associates, Inc., dated January 6, 2005; 4. Four (4) sets of elevations for the existing buildings and proposed building changes; 5. Two (2) sets of mailing labels; and 6. Check in the amount of $300.00 Please schedule this matter for hearing on February 11, 2005. Ve rul Y;4 ~ ! lieA.Fittge~ Enclosures cc: Catherine F. Stover, Town Clerk Lee W. and Priscilla F. Saperstein NANTUCKET ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS 1 EAST CHESTNUT STREET NANTUCKET, MA 02554 FEE: $300.00 CASE NO. APPLICATION FOR RELIEF Owner's name(s): Lee W. and Priscilla F. Saperstein Mailing address: 801 Laurel Drive. Rolla. MO 65401 Applicant's name(s): Same Mailing address: Same Locus address: 20 New Street. Nantucket. MA 02554 Land Court Plan/Plan Book & Page/Plan File No.: Date lot acquired: 4/13/1979 Deed Ref./Cert. of Title: Book 170 Page 37 Assessor's Map/Parcel: 0055/337 Lot No.: Zoning District: ROH Uses on Lot - Commercial: None X Yes (describe) Residential: Number of dwellings 2 Duplex_ Apartments_ Rental Rooms_ Building Date(s): All pre-date 7/72? X or C of O(s)? Building Permit Nos: No file available at the Nantucket Building Department Previous Zoning Board Application Nos.: None State below or on a separate addendum specific relief sought (Special Permit, Variance, Appeal), Section of the Zoning By-law, and supporting details, grounds for grant of relief, listing any existing nonconformities: See addendum attached hereto. I certify that the information contained herein is substantially complete and true to the best of my knowledge, under the pains and penalties of perjury. c.. Applicant Attorney/Agent X- nclose proof of agency to bring this matter before the Board) FOR ZBA OFFICE USE Applicati received on:---1---1_ By: Complete: Need copies?: Filed with Town Clerk:_/---1_ Planning Board:_/---1_ Building Dept.:_/_/_ By: SIGNATURE: (If not owner,-6r Fee deposited with Town Treasurer:_/_/_By: Waiver requested?:_Granted:_/_/_ Hearing notice posted with Town Clerk:_/---1_ Mailed:---1_/_ I&M:_/_/_ & _/_/_ Hearing(s) held on:_/_/_ Opened on:_/_/_ Continued to:_/---1_ Withdrawn?:---1_/_ DECISION DUE BY:---1_/_ Made:---1---1_ Filed w/Town Clerk:---1_/_ Mailed:_/_/_ DECISION APPEALED?: / / SUPERIOR COURT: LAND COURT Form 4/03/03 --- ADDENDUM The Applicants seek relief by Special Permit pursuant to Section 139-33 E (2)(a) to increase ground cover on a pre-existing nonconforming lot by 110 square feet. The existing Lot contains 3,135 square feet of occupied area per the Plan by Charles W. Hart, dated January 6, 2004. The current owners' Deed recorded in 1979 recites a lot area of 3,395 square feet. The Applicant has calculated the ground cover based on the smaller lot size for which the existing square footage is 1,142 or approximately 36.5%. The proposed ground cover is 1,252 square feet or approximately 40%. This increase is well with in the limits of the permitted 50% ground cover ratio in the ROH zoning district. The Board may find that such increase in permitted ground cover shall not be substantially more detrimental to the neighborhood than the existing nonconformity. The Applicants also seek relief by Special Permit pursuant to Section 139-33 A (5) to allow the extension/expansion to a second story of the two existing structures along pre-existing non-conforming rear and/or side setback lines. The main house on the front of the lot does not meet the side yard set back along the westerly boundary. The secondary dwelling does not meet the side yard set back along the easterly boundary and the rear southerly boundary. The Board may find that the extension along a non-conforming set back for second story additions on both structures will not be substantially more detrimental to the neighborhood. The Applicants also seek relief by Special Permit pursuant to Section 139- 18 B. There are no parking spaces currently on the lot as there is inadequate frontage or area next to the existing building which fronts on New Street to provide a parking space. The Board may find that the granting of Special Permit relief from Parking would be physically impossible for the Applicant to provide and/or if physically practical would have a significant and adverse effect on the scenic or historic integrity of the neighborhood and/or would be contrary to sound traffic and safety considerations. The property is numbered 20 New Street (Map 0055, Parcel 337). It is located in the Residential Old Historic District. ZONrnG' CLASSIFICATtON: . .,/c. 0.1(. MIN. AREA: . . . . . . .-?;QQ9. S ,or: MIN. FRONTAGE: . . . . . . . s:o '. ~ FRONT YARD S.B.: . . . /.Y."t7.1Y'~ REAR & SIDE S.B.: . . : . . . .S.~ GROUND COVER (7.): . . . ..:r.q .% .:~'.;:"'.'....:---""-_?~"" EXISTING: . f'1{~/~//V'A.7:ilZ ~.I?MK . . . . II. . . . If . . . . . . . . . /I . . . . . . . . . x \ N ;€; W S T. " -:?j~. 13 '- #;z.z ~ \ SIK I ~S-Y6- ~, I tY/r- , /? .eA,~7//VG I /?i" rx.. '-/{;-/{ I I I I $$- 3-4.3 .:II;V<. OIl- TAArA r ~ .., J... ~..5" .p 1:. - ,IN!' ~ J:> .i 3:3':t.: " , -_.,_.-,_._..~..,~ ".-." \ F ,/ /' "J,/ , , , , I I I I JJ I<! . r"'/ " "';t';" .-.../.,' ,f' ..... ,,..,i /1,/' .I!z Sr;:; Wi1=' .7-(ous,s G.C.::: 8~9 ("'10 %; s).P. .........Jor 00.5. No. ;20 / / ,I .' I I N ~ ~ I 'i f ~ I lu'H't: '~' ,.. , " ~.lC o;:D;#\t 1 Q) I.c)"- _/\ ~. 7V I~O)O) ;;~:::.s 5,~ 1 ~ ~ I a,.C. = 70 -t: S,/?, I 5.0- 3::58 /Y/r- A.? A~.s (NO p~) OIYP/N/i' ~ c K , ~~ . <t), ~, ,..--...,..- ,'- T , . ~- '53 't; (:55 ,-O~j)) n.-j-P . .'R.. s. TJ.t::;R..N.F.:'::Y . PL.~/~- 78 55-34-+ /./orz;: P~.P Re-r:: gK../70 ,P~.. ~7 II COH.7A#f/N~ 3'$9!3.... sC?uA-eA PE",e7) ~ $A/P /L1~.;J.sv~M~ AK..P CONT,.e-/v"TS A-to~ 0..< A.€:SS,I/ Z.OK//I{C fXJA.RO Or AP;?~ PA-A.I'< OF LAND IN NANTUCKET, MASS. / SCALE: 1-. /5 DATE: J',,4).(: 0/ -cooL( Owner: ~.\-.(, ~?,.fI$~.I:M;::' $'fI7A~W.)./ Oeed: &'(, /7,"Q .J:7~.;3. 7.' PIon . <<c:?A(....e-: . . Locus . ~Q. /,V',.e-V ...sT~ET. . . . CHARLES w. HART &. ASSOCIATES, Inc. SANFORD BOAT Bun.DING 4r9 SP ARKS AVENUE NANTUCKET, MASS. 02554 '\ (50a) 228-8910 H-r'o8/ ;VO/Af:': OeCU?/~ "..(~,-( "";5:5 '-1; X 9S';f:: ':5135fS,F , , .10-MLll1J~if I ~JO!'J ASSE5S0R-S'~ S-~t'-337 C,\JOOS\ CW!1\BlP ~:"::_~:,pkJ!!"ll",___,,__ ."'1 'h,_,';~~~""" ._~-,j,>i~~~ ~A'tI "'DUr~ rn CD CD OJ II I rn rn DO CD rn DO DO ~ t11~dl'; , NORTH ELEVATION (F..IiT) =-J ~ ~ , ' ' ' . q ~ 1 p".,..eti ~ FR"dI.,.. (MCAu") OJ OJ OJ CD I rn rn DD rn rn DO DO ( ==I r--I j EEB1 leal Gx/i--hn) :::::, PnM~J ~1},1tI HiJWG D ~ Z .. l.i..i 0 UJ -' U \-< UJ <U \S) D\S) lI.l 0 Z ~ El ..-. ......... ..-. C/fJ lI.l ..-. ci. ..-. Z ~ lI.l ..-. ~ ~ r ~ L.. ~ r ~ uJ @ ~ lI.l ~ ~ ..-. a... ~ ~ , ~ ( > C/fJ ~ , [ lI.l W [ , ..-. Z I ......... :c I C 0 , r ('ll ~ MIP55/337 till tmtffi . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . SOUTH ELEVATION ~ -' I::>... ~ ~ g ~, u.. ~. o ~ ~ * ~ \S) D \ Em ~ U Z ~ El ..-. ......... ......... C/fJ lI.l E2 ......... Z ......... ......... lI.l C r C/fJ ci. ......... lI.l 5:: ~ C/fJ ~ :c c r Em Em tffitffi M/P:55/~ SOUTH ELEVATION ~IIIN NDllrE m - . , . . . . , . . , . . . . , . . . . . . . . . . . . . ltIJafE8J . . . . . . . . . ::::> e~,~ ~N.~ ~M . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . m IFt1r@ P"."I,J WEST ELEVATION """-~"""~b.\~<:;Jo;:"';I:'b~-"-"/'ll ffIBE1El . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . e--~ - . . . . . . . J_l.~~,.:,,,..\,......,, .. . ".....,."...-.,.-"-.!\~-- ".....,,". .,. ~;r~Z:(f~(O~ '~rPU lJ]!])~l~rP~~ IlrP~)~J\\JUO) ~~ mrwlnl011 ~Oll~U HIU hUI t'iI '~;' I'll l' · m;r\2iZ:(fOO~ f~' 1 ~1JL:J~~~)y~~WJU 1J]!])hlMWJ~ I1f; JJJ[jJ~n! lrP~)11J\\JUO) ~~ Hi J QlrP~)O~~~ ~ (Qj~fr?}lmOJJ ~Oll~U iF i :SNOISIA3~ :SNOISIA3~ 89 88 83 2 -t c 1 i= <{ ..... u U l- ll" <{ " u m ffim ~ \Q ffim ..~ ~ - ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ . A:. ~ EIE~ ~ II II ~ PLAN Cd~~.1e. Em . . . . . Em . . . . . . . . . . . E'rlsl--In" WEST ELEVATION m EfB . . . . . EfB Em . . . . . . . . . . . P"ptJSltI WEST ELEV A TION- C"i-4-te- Ern ) e~/sJ.,ri9 NORTH ELEVATION ~,:~~-,:"",,".~C';_.: [IE [IE [IE tm tm proptlS~J NORTH ELEVATION- .. , I " ~.. J ~' .'...." ..""",,: : " .,> C'tJ~tAle. . ,F11 r""J SOUTH ELEVATION ]>I>>PIJSlJ s;:,ld'h cJ.v..t"n tt8 .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. CIJI/II," ffiJ ffiJ . . . .' .............. &1i~ EAST ELEVATION #,C'~:o 1 I I . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ~......IAA~.J r....___ _ ____._~. Smooth Feed Sheets™ David J, Leiter 3014 32nd St. NW Washington, DC 20008 Kathleen M. McGorisk 35 Alden Road Swampscott, MA 01907 C. Leo and Donna N. Wilson 918 Haven Ave. Ocean City, NJ 08226 Paul M. & Elisabeth o. O'Rourke PO Box 2951 Nantucket, MA 02584 James F. Mondani c/o James F. Mondani 1320 Morningside Dr. Charlotte, NC 28205 Dean Kevin & Michele B. Lurie 5125 Chevy Chase Parkway Washington, DC 20008 Karen L. Murphy 60 Pleasant Street Nantucket, MA 02554 Joseph W. Phelan, Trustee c/o Sally Phelan Engelhirk P.O. Box 257 Germantown, NY 12526 Patrick & Ashlee Keating P.O. Box 135 Nantucket, MA 02554 Edward S. Grennan, Jr., et al PO Box 1829 Nantucket, MA 02554 Adele P. Ames 227 Summit Ave.-Apt. E205 Brookline, MA 02146-2302 Alfred E. Bernard 74 Orange Street Nantucket, MA 02554 Eileen M. Ouellette 215 Brookline Street Newton Center, MA 02459 Alfred J. Souza 628 Belmont Street Manchester, NH 03104 Rosemary S. Tierney 322 Maple Street New Bedford, MA 02740 Jill M. Packard 1462 Asylum Avenue Hartford, CT 06105 Julie Young P.O. Box 474 Nantucket, MA 02554 Donald H. & Kathleen Araujo c/o Back Street Properties, LLC 68 Orange Street. #2 Nantucket, MA 02554 James S. Sulzer Barbara Elder 14 Back Street Nantucket, MA 02554 James B. Sulzer Barbara Elder 14 Back Street Nantucket, MA 02554 .AVERY@ Address labels Use template for 5160@ Myrtle T & Manuel J., Perry, Jr. Mark S. Perry 10 Atlantic Ave. Nantucket, MA 02554 Charles Leo & Donna H. Wilson 918 Haven Ave. Ocean City, NJ 08226 Artists Association of Nantucket P.O. Box 1104 Nantucket, MA 02254 Joseph W. Phelan, Trustee c/o Sally Phelan Engellhirk P.O. Box 257 Germantown, NY 12528 Linda J. Groves One Laurel Street Charlestown, MA 02129 Henry & Cecilia M. Huyser 12 New Street Nantucket, MA 02554 Rosemary S. Tierney 322 Maple Street New Bedford, MA 02740 Aguinel A & Benvinda Rose Trustees 60 Dartmouth Street Dartmouth, MA 02740 Back Street Properties, LLC 68 Orange Street #2 Nantucket, MA 02554 John G. Ewen, 747 Mountain Road W. Hartford, CT 06117 laser 5160@ Smooth Feed Sheets ™ Robert F. & Sheila L. Cross 977 W ashington Ave. Albany, NY 12206 Mary Jo J, Bevilacqua Michael A. Goode P.O. Box 12 Nantucket, MA 02554 Kenneth W. & Nancy D. Fontaine 106 Nuttree Lane Chapel Hill, NC 27516 Elizabeth & Christopher Holland P.O. Box 144 Nantucket, MA 02554 Lauren S. Pearce-Mercadante 537 Hilaire Road Saint Davids, P A 19087 Alfred E. Bernard 74 Orange Street Nantucket, MA 02554 Lee Morgan 11 New Street Nantucket, MA 02554 Jo-Ann M. Shettles 50 Hilltop Trail Salem, CT 06420 William & Virginia Youngren, Trustees WVY Nominee Trust III Temple Street West Newton, MA 02165 Barbara R. McKee 15 Wildflower Trail Greenwich, CT 06831 .AVERY@ Address labels Paul A. & Simone R. Pasquariello 11 Lampercock Lane Lincoln, RI 02865 Thomas W. & Jean A. Austin Trustees Austin Barnabas Realty Trust 4 Bayberry Portola Valley, CA 94028 Christopher T. Wilson 76 Pleasant Street Nantucket, MA 02554 Alfred J. Demarco C/O LMD Corporation 177 Good Hill Rd. Weston, CT 06883-2312 Elizabeth & John Murray, Trustees J Murray Nominee Trust 16 Monomoy Road Nantucket, MA 02554-2312 Wayne P. & Paulette D. Semprini P.O. Box 336 New Castle, NH 03854 Kane Nantucket Family Group LP #1 5 Kane Industrial Drive Hudson, MA 01749 Peter Debarros 15 Warren Street Nantucket, MA 02554 Penelope Dey 17 Warren Street Nantucket, MA 02554 Stanley J. & Carol B. Truffini 12 Parsons Lane Redding, CT 06896 Use template for 5160@ Keith Yankow, Trustee Backwilliams Nominee Trust P.O. Box 675 Nantucket, MA 02554 Elizabeth & Christopher Holland P.O. Box 144 Nantucket, MA 02554 Mark L. Valerio 33 West Putnam Avenue Greenwich, CT 06830 Robert W. Arra Larry L. Weatherholtz P.O. Box 759 Cape Neddick, ME 03902 Erik Liljegren 14 Warren Street Nantucket, MA 02554 Andrew B. & Terri B. Sackett 1411 Lewisdale Raod Clarksburg, MD 20871 John G. & Patricia Malloy P.O. Box 312 Stoughton, MA 02072 Georgia A. Axt 23 Warren Street Nantucket, MA 02554 Craig & Ann Okerstrom-Lang P.O. Box 01055584 Sioux Falls, SD 57186 David F. Dick 881 Franklin Street Wrentham, MA 02093 laser 5160@ Smooth Feed Sheets™ Koren & Nina L. Paige Reyes -:'/0 L. Paige Reyes 1617 Ivy Spring Road Symrna, GA 30080 Lori Sherman & Gordon M. Folger P.O. Box 1408 Nantucket, MA 02554 A.1ison P. Scavone 1223 Foxboro Drive Norwalk, CT 06851 49 A Pleasant Street LLC 49A Pleasant Street Nantucket, MA 02554 8AVERV@ Address labels Use template for 5160@ Amy McGrath c/o Alan Worden P.O.Box!11 Nantucket, MA 02554 laser 5160@ ~ !l " I Boli rOUe\ 2-89 LIDO j)J . . / , NANTDC~ET ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS , 'TOW~ AND COUNTY BUILDING ", NANTUCKET, HA 02554- ASSESSOR'S LIST OF PARTIES IN INTEREST ./ PROPERTY O~'ER: l..ee, w. O-f'\cL V/h5~ F ~~ 'APPLICANT F9R RELIEF (SAME? /): , AD,DRESS.OF "PROPERTY: ;j(J~..L0 JtJuJL;t-- * A~SESSOR' ~ MAP - PARCEL: (){'t5.t) - 3?Ji- * " ' LIST "OF PARTIES INCLUDING ADDRESSES*(OR SEE ATTACHED ---) : r. .' RECEIVED , BOARD OF ASSESSORS NOV 0 3 2004 TOWN OF NANTUCKET, MA "' ~ .... . ;: ., I' cel:tify-.,th~t ~:the'for,~going (or the attached _) lis~s all ,"persons.~:': natural ar legal, who. are owners af abuttJ.ng . propei-ty~,~'Jo,wner,s:, of' land directly opposite o~ any public " or private.: str:eet or way; .and abutters of the abutters and all other land owners within three hundred feet of the property' line ',of Owner I s property, as they (and their address) appear on the most recent applicable tax list (per, M. G'.L. c. 40A, Section 11 and zoning Code Chapter 139, Section 1?~~2~D{2)]. /)/tH/: S- ;L()tJ i Date / " " . ", *NOTE: APplicant '(petitioner) should include with the lot for which zoning relief is sought, any commonly-owned abutting lots which might become involved in the zoning matter. List map and parcels for each abutter. -----------..---- ~---_. ---- 3 " ~.. .~~&;U)~~ ~ ~~~~~ ] ~~:~I lG f"'o O'l O'l 0 ('I') ..-t 114 ..,.., .., .... .., U') ('"J Ul .... N 3 3 3 Ii; ~ Ii; ~ ~ Ii; Ii; Ii; re .,., ~ ~ ~ : : ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ g ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ M 0 ~ ~ N ~ .., N 0 Ul ~ ~ .... N N M ..-4 .... M ~ 8 ~ 8 8 U) 8 888 U) U) (I) U) ~ 8 0 {I) 0 U) ~ {I) tt) ~ en ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ U"I.....rt I m\O""NO at M M ..-t O'l f"'o Ul .... .... .... .... .... CD CD <Xl ... on o on 0 o on '" o '" <Xl '" 0 '" i~in:~~ '" o M '" I ~ \0 .., .., O'l .., \0 .., .., O'l .., 0 0 N N Ul Ul NUl.., Ul ~ Ul 0 .., .., Ul Ul Ul Ul M Ul M Ul ~ .., M ~ ~ N N N N N N N N N N M N N .... .... 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 ~ ~ ~ (Xl r-- .., .., \D ... \0 o 0 Ul III N (X) N j;l. Oa'lUlIllNIllN 'ri O..-tNNCDNCO N NOOOOOO ~ U ~ Q ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ i ~ ~ Ul 0 .., .., .., .., .., f"'o \0 Ul .., .., CD .., .., .., \D 0 o .., Ul Ul Ul Ul Ul .... 0 \D Ul Ul N Ul Ul Ul M M M f"'o Ul Ul Ul ~ Ul .... N CD Ul Ul 0 Ul Ul Ul Ul CD \D N N N N N N \D N N N N ... N N N f"'o \D o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 .... 0 0 0 O'l 0 0 0 N 0 ~ U ~ [i! ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ g ill Iii ill ~ I ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ I ~ I I I i I I I I l>: ~ l>: !i! !i! tl ~ 2 2 Q (I) Q i:I at ~ !i! ~ ~ 2 ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ '" ~ ~ ~ j t> " ,~ ... .~ )!! t!l ~~ CI) H ..:IE-! ~e ~~ ~~ IXlZ ~ ~ ., ~ [;! ~ ..0: : i:li ~ .., ~ Pot .-: :g C:on~o -< MM...rt ~ ~ ~ ll: ~ I ~ ~ ! o u :0: ~ ., ~ ~ .., ~ ~ ~ .. ! ~~~~ ~ ei:~ ! ~ il ~ re -, .~ g ~ ... on ll: '" ~ ~ 2 <Xl 0: ~ ~ ~ ., ., a f;l ~ u ... ~ ~ ~ ~ i 2 0 '" ~ :::: on o '" ., ~ ~ ~ en 8 en CI1 ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ u ~ ~ ~ III III ..0: '" ... ... ~ ~ OJ 0- '" 0. on '" .... ... '" ~ ~ III III ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ j i : I U H H ..:I :0: ..:I ll: ~ ~ ~ 8 ~ ~ ~ ~ !i! ~ ~ l>: 0 ~ ~ ~ ..0: :i! ~ ~ 8 l>: ; ~ ~ ~ 5 ~ .. ., .. ~ U ~ ~ g ~ ..:I ..:I P 0 H ..0: .. :E ... '" 3 3 ~ ..0: ..0: r~ ~ ~ ~ ~ '" .... '" ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ E-t E-t 8 E-t tM:; U) fJ) Q] en ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ '" I ... ('II O'l E"" co III r"" 0\ '" '" ... ... M M '" '" I I M .... ... <Xl <Xl on <Xl 0 on '" '" '" 0"'0 '" ... o on '" on M '" 00 t ~ :i! ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ U E-t E-t lIIC Z U U Pot .. ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ !i! ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ .. ~ B B B B B ~ ~ 3 B B ~ B B B : i ~ i i i i i ! ~ ~ i i ~ i i i ~ I .... .... on on '" '" ~ a Ii; ~ Ii; ~ ..:I ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ i I ~ ~ ~ 2 ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ '" '" !i! ~ ~ ~ Ii; ~ ~ ~ Ii; - - ~ ll: ~ ~ H ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ H ~ U ~ ~ ~ ., ., ~ 5 ... ~ ~ Ii; ~ ~ ~ 8 ~ 8 ~ ..:I ..:I ..:I 0 .... .,., ~ S H ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ a ~ '" .... .... ~ ~ ~ : : = = ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 3~~~~ ~ ~H ~ en ..~ ... ~ ... ~., 5 ~ ~ .. '" ., ~ ~ ~ ~ M 0 ~ u ... ~ ... Q ~ ~ .... ~ ~~ ~ g K ~ Ii; 8 H ~ K ~ ~ ~ 2 ~ .. ~ 2 0 '" ........ . ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 2 ~ ~ Q ~ Q ~ ~ ~ H ~ ~ ~ H ~ Q ~ t! Q t! ~ ; ~ ~ ~ ~ I U ~ ~ ~ ..:I ; ~ ~ 5 o i I ., a ~ ~ E ~ ..:I ~ ., H !i! ., ~ ~ ~ ~ ., ~ ~ ~ ~ o ..... U ~ !i! ~ Q ~ .. i ~ U .. ~ ~ ~ E ; ~ ~ g .. ~ ~ on '" '" ... ... '" on ii1 ii1 ~ ~ ..0: ~ ~ ~ .. ..0: ..:I ~ H ~ ., ~ ~ o ..... U o ..... U .. :E .. ., ~.. .., ~.. ., ., ~ ~ a ~ ..:I Q ":E Q Ht!~~aa~~ ~ ~~;~~~ ~ ~ 0 0 I ., ~ .... H U r&l ~ cr: ~ ~ i ~ i l i ~ I ... '" ... oS :::; ~ '" ~ ~ 0 1""4 N M .. ~ ~ ~ ~ 0 M N M .. ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ N M N 0'0 01 0 0\ 0 N N N M \0 0 1""4 N .., 10 MM. 'lIP 'lit .. . . .., .., .., III It) II') U") III III lO U'l U') \0 \0 \0 N IfI It) LO \0 t'" Q) .. 1""4 1""4 N N M M M M M M .., .., .., .., .., M M M M M M M M M M M M M M M M M M M M M M M \0 \0 \0 M M M M M "" .... ~ -.( ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ r. ll: ll: ., ., I ~ ~ H ~ ~ ~ .. .. ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ i i ~ .. ~ l>: ~ f.t W W ra1 ~ ~ ~ ~ .. ., ~ .. .. .. 0 ~ ., ~ : i ~ ~ ij 8 ~ ~ ~ ~ 0 ~ ~ ~ I ~ ~ i ..:I ~ H ~ ~ .. i : .., ., ~ 0 ~ s .., ~ .. ..0: .. ~ ~ i ~ ~ .c ~ r:l 8. t! ~ ~ ~ g ~ ~ s: ~ .. (J) rl rt r1 I""l _~ It) It) Lll 10 lfl III 1O If) If) III U') 10 l.t"I Lt'I U') Lf) LIl III Il'l lO Lf) If) If) U') Il'l U"I U') Lf) III l/l U') U"l t.ll IO U"l 11'I l/l II) 10 IO U') U'l ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ x U"l It'l It'l It) It'l It'l III U"I III It'l III If) 10 It'l 11'I 11'I 11'I It'l If) III 11'I It) It'l III III U') U') It'l 11'I 11'I U') III III It'l 10 10 10 11'I It'l It'l U') 10 U') Il'l III U') M o N ..... '" !:; ~ "" -I- ~ \JI ~ <l ~ ~ :t.. . ~ I!j c...., 000 .......... ..... U U U ~ ~ III i ~oi .,., ~; :0: ~QU[j ~~ .,!i! ~ ~ .. ~ ll: ~ ~ ~ ~ ..:I wo~o ~~ I-i lot Ox U)fI) .. ~ ll: ~ ~ ., tlll: .... ~ ~ ~ r. :E :E ..:I !i! .., ~ Q..;.., ~ ~ :0: ~ t! g ~ ~ ~ ll: ~ ..0: ~ ~ ~ .. H Q ~ ~ j U S ~ s ~ g g a ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ I ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ t! ll: Q ~ ~ ~ ~ .. ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ l>: ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ I I i ~ I I i ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ I ll: .. I .. :0: ~ ~ ~ ... oC I'l) ~ ~ '" M ... ... .. r. ~ " ~ ., ~ ~ l>: l>: g .,., ~ e.:: N N Z fI) ~ ~ ~ 5 5 ~ .. .. Ul Ul .. .. .. Ul Ul Ul .. >< .. t ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 0 i i i i ; i i i i I W"Ir-'I"'4P1C>> N M ~ N N W"I W"I ~ ~ W"I W"I .. .. .. ~ Ul Ul Ul tl tl tl g! o 0 0 ~ >< >< >< lil \D CO 0 n ..... N I'""l <l! '" oj p., .: o ," ... ~ U ~ ; I ... ~ .. .. ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ .-t .... '1"'41""4'1"'4 .., ... .... .... ~ ~ ~ ~ 1""4 N 0 ~ ~ W"I ~ ~ n ~ 0 ~ P1 0 ~ ~ 1""4 W"I W"I . W"I r- r- N W"I W"I ~ W"I CJ) M ~ '1"'4 W"I ~ CJ) W"I W"I W"I Cl. Q)U')f""Il'ICOo...anU"lr-fLl'l....mCJ)CO<nOOIllU')CX) ..-j C"'lN....NON\oNNNN.....\O\O....""'NONN\O N OOOONOOOOOOU'l000P10MOOO ~ ;~!H!i~tl~~~~ '" .. .. Ul U U ~ f;1 ~ ~ ~ ~ tl '" ~ !hUIIU~liIU;hUI '" " " ~ .lj ~ t> .: ." .... ," il (!) ~~ tIl I-t ..:lE-4 tIl~ ~U ~~ ~~ ~ ~ :i! '" ~ .. ~ ~ \,Q 1:1) 0 ~ : ~ill~"~~ ~ !I~i~i ~ .. ;'; on ~ ;'; g ~ ~ .. .. Ul Ul .. ., ~ Ul .. Ul ... ~ e ~ ~ ~ CO Ul ill ~ I ~ ~ ~ ~ il ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ Ul :8~~~qE lil ~ .. ~ g r- ill .... .... g ~ ~ ... .., III ~ " '" Q) """ ~ = ~ ~ ~ ~ 2 lil on o '" g .. ~ I I I I I .... o If) r-- '1"'4 C"l Il'I n .-t .... N o U .. Ul ~ ., ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ : ~ o-:l ~ ill Ul 8 ., ! ~ ! <J2<J 9 ill " I ... ~ ! '" .... .. .. o-:l .. 8 ~ ~ ~ H ::: ~ .. ~ .. III III 0( 0( ~ o-:l :0: ~O ~"a~1 ~ ~~ ~""Bg" ~ "::::0: "g ~,," ~ .. iii III " ~ ~" " ~ "," liJ" i ~ I g i i g I ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ I I ~ i ~ ~ ~ m a ~ ~ >< ~ ~ i ~ ~ I ~ ~ i ~ ~ : ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ a ~ 8 ~ a B ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ffi ~ ~ ~ :0: .. i Ul '" '" >< ~ 0 :0: .. 0 0 '" ~ Ul ~ Ul o-:l " ; ~ ill = H " ill I H ... " ~ ~ ! Ul .... ('II ('I') rot N ~ ~ ... ." :5 }. ~ '" N "" U) ~ P1 ... W"I 1""4 o C"lM('I"tO'lC7'lOOr-4NM...&t1P1.It)\Dr-........n ..:I ......MP1"'.........""O\O'lO'lO\O'lr-!....I""lN o .-< o N ..... U) 1""4 '1"'4 1""4 '1"'4 1""4 n n 1""4 1""4 " n 1""4 n 1""4 " ..... '1"'4 1""4 Q. ...""...............""....................... ~ ~~~~~~~~~~:::;~:::;:::;:::;:::;~~~:g:::; ..... .-< .-<