The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About011-05 TOWN OF NANTUCKET BOARD OF APPEALS NANTUCKET, MASSACHUSETTS 02554 Date: r-e[/)((:R)CJrLj 6.3 , 20 CIS' To: Parties in Interest and Others concerned with the Decision of the BOARD OF APPEALS in the Application of the following: Owner/Applicant: Q(/--OS I< \ r 1'1 Sf? j) ~k KOnrl rr2.- Application No.: Enclosed is the Decision of the BOARD OF APPEALS which has this day been filed in the office of the Nantucket Town Clerk. An Appeal from this Decision may be taken pursuant to Section 17 of Chapter 40A, Massachusetts General Laws. Any action appealing the Decision must be brought by filing an complaint in court within TWENTY (20) days after this day's date. Notice of the action with a copy of the complaint and certified copy of the ~ecision must be given to the Town Clerk so as to be received within such TWENTY (20) days. cc: Town Clerk Planning Board Building Commissioner PLEASE NOTE: MOST SPECIAL PERMITS AND VARIANCES HAVE A TIME LIMIT AND WILL EXPIRE IF NOT ACTED UPON ACCORDING'TO NANTUCKET ZONING BY-LAW ~139-30I (SPECIAL PERMITS); ~139-32I (VARIANCES) ANY QUESTIONS, PLEASE CALL THE NANTUCKET ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS. ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS 1 EAST CHESTNUT STREET NANTUCKET, MASSACHUSETTS 02554 Map 73.1.3 Parcel 62 Sconset Residential - 1 15 Bank Street LC Plan 38116-A, Lots 1 and 2 COT 21,446 At a public hearing ofthe Nantucket Board of Appeals held at 1 :00 p.m., Friday, February 11,2005, in the Conference Room of the Town of Nantucket Annex Building, 37 Washington Street, Nantucket, Massachusetts, on the Application of KRISTIN ALEXANDRE, P.O. Box 367, Far Hills, NJ 07931, Board of Appeals File No. 011-05, the Board made the following Decision: (1) Applicant is seeking relief by SPECIAL PERMIT under Nantucket Zoning By-law Section 139-33A (alteration/expansion ofthe pre-existing nonconforming structure/use) and to the extent necessary, MODIFICATION of the previous Special Permit in the Decision in BOA File No. 021-88 that allowed construction of a deck within the setback area. Applicant proposes to construct conforming additions on to the easterly rear and the northerly side of the primary single-family dwelling and would raise a portion of the existing ridge height from about 12 feet to no more than 17 feet within the front yard setback area but come no closer than the existing structure. Nonconforming portions of the structure would be removed and the structure would then become conforming as to side yard setback requirements. The work would include placing a foundation under the structure. The siting of the structure would also be altered by sliding it to the north about three feet but would come no closer to the front yard lot line than it presently exists and would be actually relocated further from the front yard lot line at about 3.1 feet, reducing the nonconformity of the setback distance. There would be no change to the secondary dwelling to the rear. The ground cover would be increased from about 27.5% to about 29.5%, below the maximum allowed for this lot of 30%. The Locus is nonconforming as to lot size with the Lot containing about 3,486 square feet oflot area in a district that requires a minimum of5,000 square feet; as to front yard setback with the primary structure being sited as close as about 2.6 feet from the lot line alone Bank Street; as to side yard setback with the same structure sited as close as about 3.4 feet (with a ten-inch overhang extending further) from the southerly side yard lot line and as close as about 3.3 feet from the northerly side yard lot line, and with the studio/cottage structure to the rear being sited as close as about 1.5 feet from the southerly side yard lot line and as close as about 3.2 feet from the northerly side yard lot line, in a district that requires a minimum of five feet; and as to frontage with the Lot having about 38.7 feet of frontage along Bank Street in a district that requires a minimum frontage of 50 feet. The Locus is conforming as to rear yard setback and ground cover. The Premises is located at 15 BANK STREET, SIASCONSET, Assessor's Map 73.1.3, Parcel 62, Land Court Plan No. 38116-A, Lots 1 and 2. The property is zoned Sconset-Residential- 1. (2) Our Decision is based upon the Application and accompanying materials, and representations and testimony received at our public hearing. The Planning Board made no recommendation, as the matter did not present any issues of planning concern. There were no letters on file and no comment at the hearing for or against other than the representations of counsel for the Applicant. (3) Applicant, through counsel, represented that she was proposing to relocate an existing single-family dwelling by moving it in a northerly direction upon the locus about 2.5 feet, placing a new foundation under it, removing existing portions ofthe structure, primarily on the northerly and southerly sides of the structure, and constructing a new addition to the rear ofthe dwelling. The nonconforming side yard setback violations would be eliminated and the new addition would be constructed so as to be conforming as to setbacks requirements. A new front stoop would be constructed but would be sited no closer to the front yard lot line than the existing structure. The structure would remain nonconforming and sited as close as about 2.8 feet from the front yard lot line after the relocation. Due to the placement of the new foundation the height of the structure may be raised within the front yard setback area, but the actual roof ridge height of the structure would not be increased. Applicant stated that the dwelling was validly grandfathered as to siting as it was constructed prior to the 1972 enactment of the Zoning By-law and was clearly visible in substantially the current location on the 1938 and 1957 aerials in the Town records. The Historic District Commission had approved the proposed relocation, alterations and expansion of the structure in Certificate of Appropriateness Nos. 45,121 and 45,187. In addition, the Conservation Commission had granted a waiver to complete the project as proposed in Order of Conditions No. NAN-055. The number of bedrooms in the dwelling would be increased from one to two, which would not increase the intensity of use under the Zoning By-law. The ground cover would remain conforming. No alteration or expansion was proposed for the ancillary structure to the rear of the Locus. (4) Therefore, based upon the foregoing, the Board finds that the proposed re- siting, alteration and expansion of the primary dwelling upon the Locus, would not be substantially more detrimental to the neighborhood than the existing nonconformities, notwithstanding the construction of an entry way stoop in the front yard setback area that would be placed no closer to the front yard lot line than the existing structure and minimal increase in height within said setback area. The alterations would be a benefit to the neighborhood as the side yard nonconformities would be eliminated and the structure improved. (5) Accordingly, by a UNANIMOUS vote, the Board GRANTS the requested MODIFICATION of the previous SPECIAL PERMIT relief granted in the Decision in BOA File No. 021-88, to the extent necessary, and the additional SPECIAL PERMIT relief under Nantucket Zoning By-law Section 139-33A to alter and expand the structure as proposed, upon the following conditions: a) No exterior construction activity in connection with the project shall be permitted between May 15th and October 1 st of any given year; b) The structure shall be sited no closer to the front yard lot line than the existing structure, as shown on the "Site Plan", dated February 11, 2005, as marked by the Applicant, a reduced copy of which is attached hereto as Exhibit A; c) The rear studio structure on the Locus shall not be used for human habitation without further relief from this Board; and d) The project shall be done in substantial conformance with Certificate of Appropriateness Nos. 45,121 and 45,187 granted by the Nantucket Historic District Commission, as may be amended from time to time. Dated: February-z$ , 2005 ~Ct VlM \ \n~~), Nancy J. Sevf~s u\w d P-l ,--"] !<. w - .J (,~ ~ s\:. .. ~ ~ ~ (I) W ~ Z ~ ~ ~ 5 (I) C) z ~ X W I ~ ~ ~ - ll:: ~ ~ 0 a:: a:: u... 0 o z u.. u.. 0 z z u 0 o z u u 0 z z z 0 o z Z 0 C) W VI Z tn :::> _ 0 0 I- a. '> !Q 0 W X ll:: a:: w a. Q. ~ ~ ::t ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 8: ........ ~ f:) u; ..J r-- ~. t') 8 II '-' g ~""':-o wu.,w a:: (/) U ......... IX) :::> tt')o ..LL o!t:! c> ' ..... ~ VI ~ ':::"w 1-(0" III VI !Q1X)r--. ..~=> x...ro:i~wIl10 w,..jI')I'iQ~:C III z ;( ~ ~ I 5 a:: ' t .~w z.:t' tou Ou.. 0 t')z ~U;O~Illr;-:3 ~ 0 It") ": a:i ~a. !:!:gw~via::5 (I) . C) (I) W (/)Il)~ w>u :5..I-'~QOz Ui55~IIlU- C)a::a::>"'~Ob z<(u..1- Zz Z . . z a:: => o~~~L5~~ N~~u..a::C)U; ~ ~ ::t ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ........ III W :J Cl. :::E o U '-' ll:: ' L5 ""':- u., ll:: u.. (I) "':- u; t') to- ..u.: r--N ~u; ...cnll _ l'l .......W !Q:gi--.. .. ~~ x...ro:ilOWIl1O W,..jt')NQr--:C IIlNZ ;( ~ I z a:: ' 0 t ,~w Z':t' tou Qu., oll1t')~ !;j:(/)o- r;-:J ~o It") ': a:i~Q. u..o"CD' ~ lijqwu;tna::o (/)It")~ w~u :5..I-'~OOZ ui5z~liju- c>a::~>"'.I1:IO~ z<(u..1- z~ Z . ,z~=> Ozzo 0,." --a:: a::.... N::e~,",-a::c>vi ~ ~ ~ ~ ~\( ~ V) , ..... ~ ~ ~ V) ~ ~ - - . ~ \-.l. .....J W U' 0::...... <(+ (L , LL LL . aU) <(0- wt0 o::r-- <( II + ~ ~ ~ V) ~ ~ -/+,9'Z .....J W U' 0::...... <(+ Q... . LL LL . aU) <(0- wt0 o::~ <( II ;n:t ~ I lL .. I I I I lI:: "- I + frl ~ I 0 vi I r- I ! ! I , -...... + to to I ......... + ~ vi w:B Vlr-- . J: II ~u..LJ .........~ ~~-< -0 , -...... + -.:t to -"1 lI:: U W C I ~\' Qvi 010 =>0 I-N . Vl II ~u.LJ I -~~ ______-----1 N .....J W U' 0::-""" <(+ (L . LL LL . aU) <(r--- w-.:t o::~ <[ II C7> ui !') , -...... + N .....J W U' 0::-""" <[+ Q...LL 60 <(r--- w-:t o::~ <( II ,O'll; I , + ~ dvi ON =>C7> ,In" . ~u.L5 r '0: I ~3:4: ___-1 .Losr ,O'll; ,6'gr , , ...... <.? ...... ,csr + z + <l: - -.:t J: -0 0::: to w to > 0 LL 0 S2' to Ol I ~ \:\ , -...... + L.{) to , ...... + N to 5.8'+/- r-- tC N ,LTl 5.8'+/- r-- tC N ,LTl I -...... + L.{) ~ TOWN OF NANTUCKET ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS 1 EAST CHESTNUT STREET NANTUCKET, MASSACHUSETTS 02554 PHONE 508-228-7215 FAX 508-228-7205 NOTICE A Public Hearing ofthe NANTUCKET ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS'-will be held at 1:00 P.M., FRIDAY, FEBRUARY 11, 2005, IN THE CONFEREN<;E ROOM, TOWN ANNEX BUILDING, 37 Washington Street, Nantucket, Massachusetts, on the Application of the following: ~ KRISTIN ALEXANDRE BOARD OF APPEALS FILE NO. 011-05 Applicant is seeking relief by SPECIAL PERMIT under Nantucket Zoning By- law Section 139-33A (alteration/expansion of the pre-existing nonconforming structure/use) and to the extent necessary, MODIFICATION of the previous Special Permit in the Decision in BOA File No. 021-88 that allowed construction of a deck within the setback area. Applicant proposes to construct conforming additions on to the easterly rear and the northerly side of the primary sing le- family dwelling and would raise a portion of the existing ridge height from about 12 feet to no more than 17 feet within the front yard setback area but come no closer than the existing structure. Nonconforming portions of the structure would be removed and the structure would then become conforming as to side yard setback requirements. The work would include placing a foundation under the structure. The siting of the structure would also be altered by sliding it to the north about three feet but would come no closer to the front yard lot line than it presently exists and would be actually relocated further from the front yard lot line at about 3.1 feet, reducing the nonconformity of the setback distance. There would be no change to the secondary dwelling to the rear. The ground cover would be increased from about 27.5% to about 29.5%, below the maximum allowed for this lot of30%. The Locus is nonconforming as to lot size with the Lot containing about 3,486 square feet of lot area in a district that requires a minimum of 5,000 square feet; as to front yard setback with the primary structure being sited as close as about 2.6 feet from the lot line alone Bank Street; as to side yard setback with the same structure sited as close as about 3.4 feet (with a ten-inch overhang extending further) from the southerly side yard lot line and as close as about 3.3 feet from the northerly side yard lot line, and with the studio/cottage structure to the rear being sited as close as about 1.5 feet from the southerly side yard lot line and as close as about 3.2 feet from the northerly side yard lot line, in a district that requires a minimum of five feet; and as to frontage with the Lot having about 38.7 feet of frontage along Bank Street in a district that requires a minimum frontage of 50 feet. The Locus is conforming as to rear yard setback and ground cover. The Premises is located at 15 BANK STREET, SIASCONSET, Assessor's Map 73.1.3, Parcel 62, Land Court Plan No. 38116-A, Lots 1 and 2. The property is zoned Sconset-Residential- 1. N.<<I.~n~~ THIS NOTICE IS AVAILABLE IN LARGE PRINT OR OTHER ALTERNATIVE FORMATS. PLEASE CALL 508-228-7215 FOR FURTHER INFORMATION. NANTUCKET ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS 1 EAST CHESTNUT STREET NANTUCKET, MA 02554 CASE NO() [( -OJ FEE: $300.00 APPLICATION FOR RELIEF Owner's name(s): Kristin Alexandre Mailing address: P.O. Box 367, Far Hills, New Jersey, 07931 Applicant's name(s): Kristin Alexandre Mailing address: P.O. Box 367, Far Hills, New Jersey, 07931 Locus address: 15 Bank Street, Nantucket, MA Assessor's Map/Parcel: 7313 / 62 Lot No.: 1 & 2 Land Court Plan/Plan Book & Page/Plan File No.: 38116-A Date lot acquired:J.Q./-L/ 04 Deed Ref./Cert. of Title: 21446 Uses on Lot- Commercial: None--1L Yes (describe) Residential: Number of dwellings-L- Duplex_ Apartments Zoning District: SR 1 Rental Rooms Building Date(s): All pre-date 7/72? x or Building Permit Nos: C of O(s)? Previous Zoning Board Application Nos.: 021-88 State below or on a separate addendum specific relief sought (Special Permit, Variance, Appeal), Section of the Zoning By-law, and supporting details, grounds for grant of relief, listing any existing nonconformities: Please see Addendum attached hereto. I certify that the information contained herein is substantially complete and true to the best of my knowledge, under the pains and penalties of perjury. SIGNATURE: ~~~ Applicant Attorney/Agent X (If not owner or owner's attorney, please enclose proof of agency to bring this matter before the Board) FOI}~BA OFfICE USE Application received on:1-' cJ<Ps---By: L{1h) complete:~pieS?: Filed with Town clerk:L/2--//<<Planning Rmtrd: / " Buildil1~ Dept.: I >>ByQf2{_J Fee deposited with Town Treasurer:~/2)tJfBy:~ver requested?:_Granted:_/_/_ Hearing notice posted with Town clerk:L27 OfMailed:~/Zf/O.JI&M:1j2,:10r& 2;$jQr" Hearing(s) held on:_/_/_ Opened on:_/--.I_ Continued to:_/_/_ Withdrawn?:_/_/_ DECISION DUE BY:_/_/_ Made:_/.--I_ Filed w/Town Clerk:_/_/_ Mailed:_/_/_ DECISION APPEALED?: / / SUPERIOR COURT: LAND COURT Form 4/03/03 ADDENDUM The Applicant, Kristin Alexandre, requests a special permit pursuant to Sections 139-30A and 139-33A of the Nantucket Zoning By-law for this property located at 15 Bank Street, Sconset ("hereinafter the Property"). The Property is shown as lots 1 and 2 on plan 38116-A filed with the Nantucket Registry of Deeds. Lots 1 and 2 are regarded as one lot pursuant to a covenant dated June 5, 1981 filed with the Nantucket Registry of Deeds in Book 183 Page 61. Attached hereto as exhibit 1. The subject property is located in the Residential - 1 (R-l) zoning district. The front yard setback in the SR-l district is ten (10) feet. The side yard setback is five (5) feet. There are currently two dwellings on the Property; the main dwelling ("the Main Dwelling") and a studio ("the studio"). The Main Dwelling is currently situated within the front yard setback and each of the side yard setbacks. The Main Dwelling is situated approximately 2.6 feet from the front yard lot line. The Main dwelling is located approximately 3.3 feet from the North lot line and from the South lot line by approximately 3.4 feet. The Main Dwelling is a pre-existing nonconforming structure pursuant to Section 139-2 ofthe Nantucket Zoning By-Law. The applicant proposes to construct an addition to the existing dwelling as shown in the architectural drawings titled Alexandre drawn by Holcomb Designs. Attached hereto as exhibit 2. The Historic District Commission approved the proposed design on November 19, 2004. The applicant proposes to lift the current dwelling and relocate it approximately two and a half (2.5) feet in a Northerly Direction. This relocation, as well as the addition to the current dwelling, will cure the Northerly and Southerly setback 1 nonconformities. The applicant is requesting this Special Permit because the proposed addition will continue be situated approximately 3.1 feet from the front lot line. Granting the proposed Special Permit will not be more detrimental to the neighborhood than the existing cottage. To the contrary, the proposed Special Permit will allow the applicant to eliminate side yard setback nonconformities. The proposed cottage will remain moderate in size. By granting the requested Special Permit, the board will be acting in a manner consistent with the spirit and intent of the Zoning By-Law. The applicant respectfully requests that the Board grant her the requested Special Permit. 2 t~ W'.~ &1 COMMONWEALTH OF MASSACHUSETTS Town and County of Nantucket June S, 1981 t 0 V E N A NT I, THOI<tAS F. KENNEl,LV, of P. O. Box 353, Siasconset, Nan-tucket County, Massachusetts, the owner of Lots -1 an<!- 2 as shown 6n Land Court Petition Plilll.- No. 38-116 (pending), do herewith,' for myself. Illy heirs and assigns. in consideration of the issuance of a Building Permit by the Nantucket Building Inspector, contra.ct, covenant and agree that.. the afaresaid Lots 1 and Z wi 11 from this day ~orward be used and' regarded as one lot andlWill not be sold I. conveyed separately. .; ;i\.,: ~~; '" 'I '. '- .' ," . WITNESS II1Y ham:l yeal fir9t, abofe~ritten.' . - ,,.. ',. Nantucket 55. e ,)}. ;~~~-~'j::~ ~., COMMONWEALTH OF MASSAOIUSsrtS ' t._~;. ,.,. . \"':"'4' rJA ...~..J "-'. ' '0 ,- I <i:t<.:., 'June, 5~~ 1981 ~,- ~~t ::' ~'.: J ~!-: aoove.named thoril'as.tt= ;r"'Kenrtelly and Then personally appea{,ed the . ,. acknowledged the foregoing instr~enttobe his free act and deed, before me, I '- ~ I ~ ~ ~ ~ I - ~ ::i ~ 0 a:: I a:: L.i.. 0 o Z u.. VI u.. 0 z __ll ~ w Z u 0 ~ z u ~ o z u ~ u 0 z :::> z z 0 0 o z VI z 0 -- C) C) w Vl Z Z (f) :::> ~ i= ~ Q X !Q 0 (;j x a:: a:: w W Q. 0... ~ ~ ::t ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ........ u.: [l vi ~ " ~ ~ 8 II - 12 ~~o a:: vi ~ ':- 110 6 ..u.: t:3~ ~vi "..: i= 10 _ lli -~ !Q1lO"- ..~~ xvlri_WIOO w,.;'l'},.;oaiI iijNz <( ~ -! W U' 0::...... <1:+ CL . !L !L' oU> <1:0- wt0 0::1'--- <I: II ~ ~ I-::::: V) ~ ~ I z a::: . 0 t .~w z .:t-= tou QLL,u..o I'}Z ~ VI 0 - 10 ........~ ~ 010 .: cD ~c[ u..O ..m . ~ iijowviVla::o VI.o~ w~u ~ .. I-' ~ 0 0 z u~5<iiju- C)~e:>'~Ob z I- Zz Z . .za:::::> o~~~~ou.: N~~u..a::!3vi lL ........ VI w ::i Q. -! ~ W 0 u' ~ u ~ 0::...... - <1:+ a:: CL . L5 ........ u.: !L ::s a:::U;vi ~ ~u5 ':- Vl I'} ~ ..u.: t RN <1:0- , wt0 ...... ~vi "'lItkOlIl o::~ + _ .-w I-::::: <I: " I- 10 _ I'} Vl ~ !Q1lO"- ..~:::> V) to xvlrilOWIOO .t.~t W,.;'I'}NQr-:I VlN ~ z <( ~ l.. ~ I z I a:: . 0 ....... ~ t .~w + z.:t to~ ~ ~ QLL, 0 I") v; ~VlO....IO........~ .U') ~ ~ 8 10 .: cD ~Q. WeD .~,.... a> ~ u.. ..m' ~ ~u..~ Iri iijqwviVla::o 1'1 ~IO~ w~u lil: ~ .. I- ~ Q 0 z -~~ lrl u~5 VlU- 0 C)~e:>'~Ob /+,9'2 z I- Zz Z . .z~:::> oZzo o. N:i:ie:a:::!3~ <.9 , ...... z + 1-:. ..0 ex. UJ to > 0 LL 0 0 ex N -! W U' 0::...... <1:+ CL . !L !L' oU> <1:1'--- w..;t o::~ <I: II a> .n 1'1 N -! W U' 0::...... <1:+ CL . !L l.L . oU> <(I'--- w..;t o::~ <( II .O'~S I ....... + ~ OV; ON :>01 ~lii" Vl~~ _~o&( .L'8~ .O'~S I ....... + ~ OV; OU') :>0 . Iii N . ~lI.~ r _~!oli .J .L'8~ -,.... ~ ,0JI?2{:z005 13: 43 5083257572 HDC PAGE 02 - ,\ 'I. r f .' V j C\\ &-1 "-10 W n ~ ~lIJO J A~~t::; "1 ~ D Lj, ~) r-, ~ ;/~b'/~~ '~~ ~/l:J.[j:i -: ui 'f] -OHO/ 1~ I ~ ~- ';Y/'":'rr'l ~ n(Q CJt:q~0 ~0 J -~ . ~ - EJf p..jj (yfJ /J l~ , r- -= - ~ra -~ '/;/ - J ,J ;(1 ,1,/& ~ ~. ,r-, f'l1/ / ~I!/L., I - D ~ / --"':'7 . 'ft:Hl I ~ . I:!--t::f!i - -D 1 . r-fUlL., -- '~//J 1 ~ ~ ,. .iJ f,~~ ~/ ."'_--:St L mn('i,,'/r. .JQ ~ JL7J- _ ''1/1... II~~ . ~:::- 7i'i' ~ ".7 fU" ~I I ----r-. L,...- T'-- t r:. .' _ Rf:L /U . ~ ~ r-J ':0" . / 1.~1.L ~. J: 7 /...T'1 U J ...... .... . LIJ::L J ~ ~ ......... ~A1c-;;-;r..J.. 0..... t) m' ~ 0 ~ ~ci '-1' l_ . 0 · j ~ rJ ~ ~ 1) / " -- ~ _~ ...u 'N S n-..;:' ~ ~ 'rJT 55 ~J~~~ 7'"-: -=-. ~/ Jil.U' , '~~~ ~ ?1~- ~ . ~~ ~~ Ou '~~l .~ ~~~ -....1 ~ ~ "-. - \ -4 -I ... ., A 1 1 I II I , ~ 12~l:~g\f~~ V NOV 9 2004 U ~ N " / / / ; Ii .... i / ! i // --..........;. I - 01/25/2005 13:43 5083257572 HOC . II ~ 10 tile H1iTOIIIC OI&TRlCT QOMMI88lQN. NanluGMl. ~"M, lor a ill. ,...,'. ". CEATlF" ",.. OF APPFIOPFUATBN'" . " .; r flIr ....,..... ,1J, Ii' I , '^ NAIiIIIrM IMl bIIl11~ twI Oft ~ INK tllO PIlIClIl or 1!IIfI(ec1 NJA. '-.../ . '.' r~ltmf"en................... lit ,........ wlIiIiiMDC........ ....... ,...,..., 1ft MIntf, P'" \It ....... III ~ '. . ~,).:t ........ ...... fat IIlIlNllIIIII '""~ --..... ............ will'" lit rtVIeWed IW - "DC. . .. 1""'- tIlIIllI\lII .. IIlId IlllIIII lite. "'" ~ Ie IlMeDv l'IlIH faI ...._ 04 . CMllIe_ 04 AlIIlIOl!~"- uflCler Cl1l1Pl8f 3M 01 IN -- and 'fit .. ,.,.. ,., "..... wOIIl . G-'*' .....,. _ 1III1l1llll.. c1r1'llolnge tNI phllIIgr.,m -.-ytne "II apeillcalIon - rnlIIII I II1II nereoI '" .-.- ""IiNino- 11_'" 110m de.. eI .....".. No .....,. m.y dIlIIr....... ~........' ~'lM' m~ lInplde illUMe' 01 CtIIk... aI/~. _P"'lt..~ PAOPE," DElCRlPTION ./ ~ ;*>c MAPN": 7~. J. '3 Pl'ACEI. N'. ~ 2- ....u Numbt. tlIl'lllpOeed WlIIIC: 1$ IIItA'K:IT: lM-tlI_l'll: np~rJ:N A"/iIK~t>~ "1lII~ p()"~ :J'7 , f'A~ H%+J.."s NT h7f' ( Telt~: .. (GtI1IIInd) ~1-Z..~' ~ltIMIIl MEN'/' :nON " ..,T ~. I ,.., H~ l>tfC.tn t.IdInOAdd- po ~t)1t l-6JI "N'ltM"tle4rET...... ()a-U"" TIltjll\one: 77'1wU~"" (0/\ ItIMd) (ClIt IIIIlICI) DMt~---' Mull.. eelIld on Ily: EllWlcltcllD: -'~ , CMItmw>: ~.... c~_ N_.CCIMI_.II..~ 'ii1~{t (lOA 0 ~. .. 0; DDCIIIPnON Of WONt TO U PllUOfIIIID ..._Ior.....~ o Nww DwtlIl"9 C AddIIoft 0 GMg. 0 GIMIW~ 0 ~I AltI1It1Oric:III R___lon 0 DIck 0 SltpI Cl8Md o Oalor cn..e Cl "- l:) _ 0 ...... ~ ...... 0 PttnolI\1IIn C AWelo".lc. ~ <:.n. No, Jl8lher (..... --"'l ~ D2~'t... .. al &llVdallt 01 AddlIkIn: .... ~. A '" ~1 u Sq. FooMvt'1UI*' 'tCI ~/' r; C e-. Jt:l\ " 1Il\. ......ftaar; I'JIJ 1~n.. l. )J"I>I>~.s Sq.--,- SrdllllOr: D~~.""...nPf'OPOlICl ~ ~'-~ -- IiY'l ,--- ~ --- W ~ ~~n:::=-'lrWllrlthgNlla: -. Ii -, 7'r 80lIIIl Ii LJ 7" hat 'I -j.y.,' w..l ['!'l7't.~ "h. p -...- I. bill ~ ~WE'f) 1. F'f-PKH ~Q"1Wb ~ _: p e-ue I-I 2.lIOUfl EM\IOIl a(" '~ ...c>.. 0tlgNl 0-, "', ;tb~et> f' 'TO 61lJ>:ITrMI ~if1'1II ~ O<lalnel hIkIt<. ____ S. WMl 1t~ :'b".. . w:rw......~. J_'~ . b..__ 4.~ ~... ....~ ~~ Ia _. M Io4OC aurwy lCllll\ tlIr INe INIkIllfI pcu'" 0 No ......~ S ICyu..,.". 'ClcN4 on al\d .\IbII'I~ Ci! " 1'ooIIIddoft. ~~ l II 0-.... O,,~DETALOF~IUCTOI!I'l!"POflMl!D , ......... ..- PllIDICl :.... lIIIcIl (type) ~ ~ 0 IlloCIk Pu;ed 0 Irtck (~l LI 0tltI' ."-'Pllch; ""M_-JL.Jt~~MMe--112_ OoImw-i!:l,t...-.- O\he< \~~lftooIng-......; ~ ~ :rklJ JJl?t-. .. O'~M ~~ . : . 0 Wood ~'Red c.dw. WlIIIt Cedar. 8...... MD.) :,. ~ (lItoI only): ~..-- ! ~ Modet No. :.' ~- MoeItl No. , GuIItta: 0W0cltI CI'I\le) Ce))-"'''- 0 AI'"'*-' ;,~(--'_"'a); 'In c.lT&AL ~~I: ~WMt*"''''''' ~T{". 0 Oller .~: L...TlIM< lJpe 0 PIne 0 ~ ac.cllor 0 Olht< T~ ...... 0 _.... 0 NMlnlIO ...... 0 Cl.- allIr1IIh OI",tntIont: ~........... SoMt (o...tlIIllll) :.. '.. ""_ ~II", WlAdlrwc..lnt Dourf_ ~: ~IlIeHUftO o~ IJ,. Wood OOlhw - . " III 1M 0........ UgMt(l!lUIIh) 0 IDL... ....... DMMd ~ 'DooIw Itypia .1lCI........): I'ront t"tDo\6-"'" ,~....."", "'" T'O'tf 't' 0..0. DooI('); Type --- M_ .. ......-: Orl_p. ___ W__~ .. ClIrnIM*'1Illllr _ Mncloow...... ......... . Dtdw: S12~ '2.,', ~Yf'ialtl1loor 02ndft_ .....".. SIze; 0 lat toor 0 2nd woor o Pou.. Conc:twIa SIn 1"-- H-OIW: Lengto: ~t: ~ SIn Locallon o C<ow o CII\IbOMI (ItllIUUIr. 1nclI8I) From anIy Come. !loa'" Potla: AouncI_ 8quue_ SIde ., .-t.~A.N ,.~ Wallt .,N'*Et:lML 4. "It ... ~i."'I FRo) . KA-114.M- ........... 0llI0r ..... COLOM CIIpIl-.r(I~ ~ ~~ .. III: n... ~Vt'l(iott-'_ "CIWldIian ~Mt,. F..,Ot bl..lfc,k (tClft/(R- 6Mr ",- ShIlllM ~~k~ 11M In \hi. ~lloIIln O~r III bMg lI\t Ill.,.. appIeadon. I .... &gIW ,.. "" ~ ~ J PAI:JE 01 !ffiI l>OOl 6 I AOH 1UI \UI~LJ1Q~ ~ ~ (QI ,,', 9(3 39~d -J -.J . ~..J..J...JClci-! ClClClCl.......=~ t-.--l-....~~t- .o.o.oIt)::E::2:'" .....................C)"'..... .o.o.o",-_tI') (/) (/) CJHf) -.J -J (j) ~~~~"''''3: 0000(/)(1)0 QQQQ~~Q ~~~~og~ ~~~~~Z~ C)C)C)C)--~ ZZZZ3r:~Z :J:J:J:Jt-.....=> ZTfffzz::r ~WUJUJWUJUJW ......J..J..J...J2::t:...J -~~~~W>>t~ ~gggg~~g ~ClClClClQQQ 'J. 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 ~l 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 :i;~~~~~3: :!::;: ~^ 0.. " 0.. · . .,.),.... , 1 I 0. ~ 0. ..... - . I I I ~..tIt)N"'- _- g;><><)(><><)()( ~~.."a... ,.. ".' tI') .0 9 Cl 0 0 ~ -' .' 1 1.1.1 aNNNNNNN - '" z ~ ~ ~ o ~ 8 <t :I: :t: u t-Q:Z G08~ _ I.L ~:I:O o:UO oz~ ow~ ~OlXl.U :Su.....J _o~~ ~J:o..o :t~~~ :t.t-~~ ~a~~ ~ D :s~ ~ elf :r:.o.g~ ~)(><x ~9Qp:r o:",~;" * i ::: s ~ rtt: ~ [: ~ ~ ~~ ~ ::J~ w~ o b!: ooooooo=! Y: a1:0 ~F= ~~~~~~8-'o ti~~ ...... oooooia:: 141 :J~~ U ~~~i~mmW UUeD (/) I>- :I: >-- 3:t- u- - en;:: I- o ~..;t 4" ..;t _ ", ..;:t t\.l ~ ~1 _ - N o~ 05 Zw 0 ~ 9 -4 m wow u.. C) 0 e - ~.~ "U!'" ...... :J(11-l ,__....M'_._ ......-.----------------... 7JCJC7"QGlC "h:"T CQQ7/C7/TQ ~ tOre 6 I AOH ! I. ~. II '--~-'"'''-''''' It:!fn c(lJi g~ ~ ~ !I.II ~ 1'-- (I) I I -~ t- IJ ~ O~ alii' ~ Z c '_'I' .....". ~~ ,tI.: ~ 0;1: OC) ~Z ~i= ~~ ~w 1:>13 39\;;1d .iiI c:Ji ,..-' ~ CL ~~ ~ C'J -, l!'\ -4 .q- p t'- c.. <..J LLJ ~ r-'\ I ; :)QH - _.----'-ZLC,LC;7.FRc:tc; .b:.r CClCl7/C7/TlA if 9 tv " ~ ,((1/ ~ 6 I ADM ~ . : ;'~:~::;"-7\-n"",;'1. 0 . . .~ ~:i' . ,. ~ , "'- " . .: ..:. 'j _.'-"'~"'-"""'''W . ...... "..~, .. '''-- -... C) "- -t ".-.... S0 39~d ;"-" ......-..--....."-..--..".---'..-. :JaH 7.JC,JC,7..RClC .b:,1 caa7/C7IT~ ~1IL8IL~~5 13:43 5083257572 oIL- '-.../: HDC PAGE 03 , ~' EXISTING HOUSE LOCATION WE WNT TO MOVE HOUSE :5' OVER OUTSIDE OF THE SETBACKS FOR ZONING COMPLIANCE BANK STREET I I I , I I I t I I L.., ~1.. -, ) \. TOWN OF NANTUCKET BOARD OF APPEALS NANTUCKET, MASSACHUSETTS 02554 April'l' , 1988 Re: Decision ~n the Application of DONNA BEASLY (021-88) Enclosed is a notice of the Decision of the BOARD OF APPEALS vhich has this day been filed vith the Town Clerk. Any appeal from this action shall be made pursuant to Section 17 of Chapter 40A of the General Lavs. and shall be filed within twenty (20) days after this date. ~~:-;(~ William R. Sherman. Chairman BOARD OF APPEALS cc: Building Commissioner Planning Board Tovn Clerk ,f '> BOARD OF APPEALS TOWN OF NANTUCKET NANTUCKET, MASSACHUSETTS 02554 DECISION: The BOARD OF APPEALS, at a Public Hearing held on FRIDAY, MARCH 25, 1988 at 1:30 p.m. in the Town and County Building, Nantucket, made the following Decision upon the Application of DONNA BEASLY (021-88) address Box 241, Siasconset, MA 02564. 1. Applicant seeks relief under the Zoning By-Law, originally by variance and here by SPECIAL PERMIT under SECTION 139-33A, from the 10-foot front-yard setback required by Section 139-16A. Such relief, if granted, would allow construction of an approximately 11'6" x 14'6" deck to extend easterly from the existing dwelling parallel to the south- erly front lot line with a spacing no less than 3.45 feet (the spacing of the southeast corner of the dwelling fro~that lot line, which there- abouts is also the street line of Fawcett Way). The premises are located at 15 BANK STREET, in the Cod Fish Park section of Siasconset, Assessor's Parcel 73.1.3-062, Book 219, Page 270, Lots 1 and 2, zoned RESIDENTIAL-I. 2. Our findings are based upon the Application papers, including a plan dated 1/22/88 titled "Deck Addition" (our Exhibit "A"), also copy of a portion of plan showing surveyor's date of 9/14/73, together with representations and testimony received at our hearing. 3. Applicant's lot of about 3846 SF was acquired 10/15/84 by Appli- cant jointly with Jack S. Beasley. As shown on the surveyor's plan, that lot originally comprised 1739SF Lot 1 with the dwelling and 1747 SF Lot 2 with a square shed near the southerly lot line. On Exhibit "A", the dwelling is shown as having a small northerly addition, the square shed is gone and elongated accessory building is shown near the easterly lot line. No reference is found on the Application form to any building permit for those changes since 1973. In any event, the original dwelling pre-dates -30 Y"\.ing and is non-conforming to zoning, notably by having less than the required la-foot setbacks from Bank Street (aka Jackson) to the west and Fawcett Way to the south. For zoning purposes, Lots 1 and 2 are legally merged. "~ (021-88) -2- 4. As a pre-existing, nonconforming single-family residential use, the premises qualify for relief under Section 139-33A by Special Permit. The proposed deck, by its proposed location within the required front yard, would "increase the nonconforming nature" of the residential structure. However, the non-conforming distance (3.45 feet), where the deck will tie into the southeast corner of the dwelling, is not made more non-conforming. Instead, the deck will parallel the Fawcett ~ay street line with that 3.45-foot spacing. 5. No opposition was heard, the Planning Board's recommendation was not unfavorable, and no detriment to the neighborhood from the pro- posed deck is foreseen. The relief by Section 139-33A Special Permit is found to be in harmony with the gneral purposes and intent of the zoning chapter. Findings required for the requested variance relief cannot be made and are here unnecessary for adding the deck. 6. Accordingly, by UNANIMOUS vote, this Board GRANTS to Appli- cant a SPECIAL PERMIT under SECTION 139-33A to alter and extend the existing dwelling structure by adding the proposed deck substantially as shown on Exhibit "A". (Relief by variance, unnecessary for such purposes, is denied.) Dated: April { 1988 Nantucket, MA 02554 &_I~;f~ William R. Sherman a n ()h Q)~ \ ~C1L C) ~ ----- Dale W. Waine .... , """f ..; - ~ . ........~.: _~:1~~ :'i"lJ .t TOWN OF NANTUCKET BOARD OF APPEALS NANTUCKET, MASSACHUSETTS 02554 ',,' iJ.- f Date: April <t , 19 88 CERTIFICATE OF GRANTING OF IX<<IKN<<KXKNDX01~~SPECIAL PERMIT (Massachusetts General Laws, Chapter 40A, Section 11) The BOARD OF APPEALS.of the Town of Nantucket hereby certifies that a VariaRcc and/or Special Permit has been granted: To: Donna Beasly (021-88) (Owner/Applicant) Address: Box 241, Siasconset, MA 02564 affecting the rights of the Owner/Applicant with respect to land or buildings at -15 Bank Street, in the Cod Fish Park section of Siasconset, Assessor's Parcel 73.1.3-062, Book 219, Page 270 Deed Reference-==:- Lots 1 and 2 The BOARD OF APPEALS calls to the attention of the Owner/Applicant that'General Laws, Chapter 40A, Section 11 (last paragraph) provides that no Variance and/or Special Permit, or any extension, modification or renewal thereof, shall take effect until (a) a copy of the Decision is certified by the Town Clerk that twenty days have elapsed after the Decision has been filed in the office of the Town Clerk and no appeal has been filed (or, if such appeal has been filed, that it has been dismissed or denied) and (b) the certified copy is recorded in the Registry of Deeds for the County of Nantucket and indexed in the grantor index under the name of the Owner of Record or is recorded and noted,on the Owner's Certificate of Title. The fee for such recording or registering shall be paid by the Owner/Applicant. ~u~~ ~~ Chairman And the BOARD OF APPEALS further certifies that the attached Decision is a true and correct copy of its Decision granting the Variance and/or Special Permit and that copies of the Decision and of all plans referred to, in the Decision have been filed with the Planning Board and the Town Clerk. -,LJv~ J. Ldly t- Clerk I.J; " -~-------- r jj :;: 00 . / 2-89 BoA Form NANTUCKET ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS TOWN AND COUNTY BUILDING NANTUCKET, MA 02554 ASSESSOR'S LIST OF PARTIES IN INTEREST PROPERTY OWNER: \( (: ~~J\ A \(2 't. o."d Q APPLICANT FOR RELIEF (SAME? ~): ADDRESS OF PROPERTY: t ~ \&+\~'<:.. 5'\. S c..ONS~\ ASSESSOR'S MAP - PARCEL: ? 513 ,tl * * LIST OF PARTIES INCLUDING ADDRESSES *(OR SEE ATTACHED ~): RECEIVED BOARD OF ASSESSORS DEe 1 6 2004 TOWN OF NANTUCKET, MA I certify that the foregoing (or the attached _) lists all persons, natural or legal, who are owners of abutting property, owners of land directly opposite on any public or private street or way; ~nd abutters of the abutters and all other land owners within three hundred feet of the ~roperty line of Owner's property, as they (and their address) appear on the most recent applicable tax list [per M.G.L. c.40A, ~ll and Zoning Code Chapter 139, H39-29D(2)] 0 Iii o. ~ &?teo ~3 ~oPt/ ~a ---L~ ate ' A sessor's Office Town of Nantucket *NOTE: Applicant (Petitioner) should include with the lot for which zoning relief is sought, any commonly-owned abutting lots which might become involved in the zoning matter. List map and parcels for each abutter. j ahl ~ORl1S /bo;o Submitted Date: Client: ~c~ "</1. Dale, P. C. J'1t,..:1J f..v . , iil .~ l .... "' ... o 0: o rJl .., H .. .... " " 0 o u " .. "' .. .. rJl rJl 5 5 ~ B ~ ~ .... "' M ~ Lll N ~ ('II M 0 ~ ~ Lll ~ q M M N M N ~ ~ 00 ~ ~ ('II N iil iil ~ ~ "' ~ "' 0: rJl .. H .. 8 W u ~ iil .. .. .. rJl ~ i i ~ :z; 0: r- "' "' r-.. t' r- ''It CD ('II N N iil iil ~ ~ 0: 0: rJl rJl H H .. .. g g u u .. rJl .. rJl iil iil ~ ~ ~ "' "' 0: 0: .. rJl '" .. H H tl .. .. ~ 8 8 .. .. .. rJl rJl .. ~ ~ i M "' M M .... co 0'\ rl 0\ 1.0 .. .. ~ ~ ~ ~ 00 ~ ~ ~ ~ rJl rJl 0: 0: ~ rJl ~ ~ @ i i a ~ ~ Iii .... .... "' N r-- 0'1 r-t ...-t .. '" ill '" a ti !3 ti .. .. .. ~ tIJ en tI] tIJ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ tl 2 2 2 rJl rJl rJl ON'" \D r4 00 .... ('I") Lll .... ...-t .... r- .... 0'1 ...-t ''It ~ r- ~ M 0 1.0 Lll r-t '" '" '" ('I") '" ~ '" '" 1.0 '" ''It ~ .... .... 0 0 N r- '" '" N 0 ..... ('II '" M 1.0 ~ M ..... M 0\ M '" \D \D Lll 1.0 M 1.0 \D 1.0 1.0 0 ('II 0 1.0 r- M ('II ('II 0 0 \D co 0 .... ~ ~ r- ...-t 0 Lll ~ ~ ..... 0 co 0 ~ 0 Lll Lll Lll r- Lll Lll Lll Lll ~ r- '" Lll ..... 0'1 ~ .... Lll 00 Lll Lll ('II r- .~ 1.0.... ('II 0 ('II N \D ('II 1.0 ..... 0 ('II ('II ('II N ('II ..... ('II ('II ('II N ('II ..... ('I") ('II ('II r- ..... ~ .... 1.0 ('II ('II co 0'1 N 0 0 0 ..... 0 0 0 0 0 0 N 0 0 0 0 0 .... 0 0 0 0 0 0'1 ('I") 0 0 0 0 . 0 0 0 0 N .... o "' r- .... , ..., 0 Nil)'" \D 'IIi:I 0'1 I.D C"l 0 .., Lll 00 \D \D Ul 0 O'l 0'1 III I""l U') '" N r- \D r- N r- ('II M o 0 0 0 0 U') 0 M o '" "' '" r- "' .... 0 o .... ~ ~ u '" :z; " t; !3~~~~~!3~!3~g ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 8 ~ ti 0: g rJl t.!l ~~ en H HE-! en~ P:u ~~ ~~ ~ 0: .. ~ fZ .. ~ ~ :~~~u g ~~~~~ N " ~ ~ g 'M .... 'M :2 ~ ~ 5 ~ ~ 'C ~ .... ~ I~~~; j ~:::::l ~ ~ " ~ :z; " . " " ~ .., <.'l :z; I ; ~ I o 0 ..... ..... u u .. r:! :i! ~ ~ .. g; 0: 5 r:l fJl e ~ H .., ~ g fil H r;l ~ @ ~ ~ a ~ ~ .. '" .. !:l r:l ~ I .. .. '" '" rJl .. rJl 5 ~ 5 u ~ u '!J .. ~ H '" H rJl rJl rJl .. :'< ~ .. ~ tl ~ ~ : t;: a 0: ei .. e r- ~ ~ rJl !; i!l ::l fil ~ gj ra ~ ~ : ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ o W ('II \D ~ ~ ~ Lll M ~ ~ ~ ~ 2 ~ ~ ~ ~ .. .. .. '" '" '" rJl rJl rJl 555 u u u a a a rJl rJl rJl tl 0:" :z; ~ ~ l:l ~ III 8 ~ ~ ~ a 111 u _ tfJ .. B 0: .., i : B ;111 !I; ~ ; '" .. ~ i E u.. ~ S a ~ .. 5 ~ : I ~ I :; i ~ ~ ~ : ~ ~ o ~ ~ .. u ~.. ~ 8 ~ 0:" 0: 0: 0: w &l:E~"'lZi :c",:a ~ Q ~ i ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ I ~ ~ i ~ ; ~ ~ ~ ; ~ ~ ~ ~ a 5 ~ tl B ~ ~ g ~ ~ I ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ : ~ ~ :z; S i ~ ~ ~ ! i ~ I ~ ~ a i ! ~ I I i I ~ ~ I I ~ ~ I a ~ rJl .. r5 ~ ~ i E .. ~ ~ 0: \:l ~ 5 &l 0: 0: r:l U U U ~()l~~rare~d fq fa.! Cf) tf.l U UJ .... :z; H .. rJl ~ I I o ..... U :z; .. .. ~ H '" ~ I I I I I "' N .... ~ rJl .. .... N .. .. i a ~ ~ ~ 5 rJl '" ~ :i III .... o '" N , N o N '" N &l ~ ,., .. ,., :z; U :z; ~ ~ ~ ; I ~ rJl U '" ~ ~ ~ K "' rJl r:l :ll '" ::: ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ '" H H H .. B :z; rJl .. => H .., ~ ~ ~ .. :z; .. .. 0 ~ ~ ~ .. ~ ,., 000 .......... ..... U U U .. a :i! ~ S :ll ~ fZ E g ~ S! ~ "' N .... ~ H => rJl .. rJl 0: r- ~ g ~ ~ ~ ~ o U III 'C H :z; H ~ H > ~ :E ~ I :z; 0: ~ I ~ ~ <.'l ~ :E 'C 0 tl H ~ ~ ~ ~ rJl r:! ~ ~ ~ fj 0: " .. "' .. 5 i ~ .. ~ rJl ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 5 ~ :i! ~ " ~ $ t; Eot ~ H U rJl .. r:l ~ ~ 'C :z; ~ ~ ~ ~ '" a ~ p: () t! U)'" M III 0 ., .,:( 0 0011( \D <of r-- 0 ...... 0 N .-i \D ,... rt U N rot ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ .... H .... 0: " ........ .... ('II N M N 1"'1 ....t rt rt r- ~ ~ III o "' ~ .. 0: .. ~ " ~ o fj '" ~ rJl ~ o "" \" 4 ~ " <.'l :z; H 0: o ..... U .. :'< ~ III '" 0 o '" "' ~ ~ ~ g ~ ~ t; ~ ~ o ~ o ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ a ~ I~ ~ ~H i '" ~ H H ... CJ .~ ra.. ra. H II:: rJl ~ ~ H ~ ~ ~ > ~ I ~ " ~ .. ~ H g H .., ~ ~ : ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 5 ~ ~ ~ i ~ :ll ~ ~ ~ " .. ~ ~ ~ :z; ~ ~ ~ ~ g ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ B ~ ~ rJl '" ~ H .. o ~ U 0 H 'C ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ :z; ~ rJl" :Z;"' 'C "' " 0: " 'C ~ 5 ~ 5 rJl :i! ~ g ~ g ~ ~ :;; :;; ~ r;j ~ ~ H 0: " ~ ~ ~ ~ 0: '" rJl H .. ~ : ~ ~ III r- 0: '" '" o r-I r- I.P Pol .... M .... .... '" N o '" .... '" 0: ~ 0 '" ~ m ~ ~ 'M 5 .... H '" "' .... l)j N ~ 0'1 H M .... (I) :z; N .... ~ M ~ ~ :ll III o '" 0 .... "' "' ~ s '" .... .. ~ III o "' r:l I ~ i~ ~ 8 ~ ~ H a ~ ~ 5 ~ ~ III 000 .......... ..... o 0 U (i) ~ t. <.'l :z; ~ " .., ~ U )1 .. rJl ~ '" fi! ~ ~ '" ~ rJl H .. i s ~ ~ i ! Ei ... t) ~ rJl tl &l ~ i ! ~ ~ fil ~ .. tl 0 .., i ~ ~ a 0 H...... fI) ......... fq U H U '" &l H > '" r:l ~ ~ fZ ~ U ~ ~ :z; H -3 "- ~ ~ ~ ". o ..... U :5 ~ ,., '" I!j ~ ~ ,., !:! '" .. .. ~ ~ ~ ;~O:I~;" o 0: 0: S E ~ e ! ~ ~ ~ ~ S ~ ~ ~ ~ r:l ~ ~ ~ ~ ::;: 0.. CD f'1 ., o riN'IlfanOOrtM..,.."IDE""CXlO'lOCIJOrtNM...ltllDr'-'(I)ort"'..,Ul\Dr--COc\OnNM'IlfU"!I.Or"""mO'lOr-fM.. M rt rt .... rt 1""'1 N N N N N N N N M .., Ul an U') an II} If) Ul Ul an \0 \D \D \D \D \D \D ID \D r-- r-- r-- r-- r-- r-- r-- r-- ,.... r-- CD co co N ,.; f'1 o N ..... N a. ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ::: ::: ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~.~ ::: ::: ::: ::: ~ ::: ::: ::: :::: ::: :::: ::: ::: :::: :::: :::: ::: :::: ::: :::: ::: M M M M M PI M M ~ I ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ESS~~~~~~ , . t!l ~~ en H ~8 en [::1 POU rzI0 88 ~~ ~ " o 'rl '" ~ u o ~ ... ~ ~ ~ 8 8 8 8 8 8 ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ I I ~ ~ I I ~ ~ I I I M o '" "' I o ~ ~ ~ ~ N ~ ~ ~ ~ 0 ~ 0 ~ ~ ~ N ~ ~ 00 0 ~ P. OllOCDCDt"-OC\lI.t}lf)ItlN -.-I ('flOOOMO~N"'Olr-t N P')ri('llNOt"'t~OONN E; ~fHJ!i!!:!~5!:!!:!~!i! ~ t 01 CO ('I') I,p 1.0 'O:P C\I \D O'l (7) U") C'Il Il1 C7'I -.:t r-- 0 '" 0 U"I 0 P'J \0 0 P'I C\I C\I l.D (T) 0 \D N 0 0 0 ~ ~ !:! !:! .. o '" M I o .. "' .. '" r- a> "' OJ '" OJ M 000 .. .. U U 01 '" 1.0 r-t '" if) if) '" '" ~ '" 0 '" M ~ r-t ~ 1.0 '" '" 1.0 ~ CO if) P') if) o IS} CD '" if) O'l 01 if) if) CD if) 00 IS} o C\I 0 n N ri M N C'Il \0 N \0 N " 0,'" MOO 0 0 0 0 000 t: !:! t: !:! tll 0( ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ t.. ~ ~ ~ ~ < g ~ ... ... ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ S ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ < 2 ~ ~ ~ g g 8 ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ g ~~~lilg~~a~~~~~~~~ OJ " " " j ~ !il H tll .. '" ... '" to " .rl ... i .. u ~ H > .. ~ ~ H tll ~ 8 ~ ~ '" ~ .. '" M ~ '" ~ "' o .. o '" ... ... '" ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ i ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ "' ... OJ 2 ;:!; ~ 5 .. ~ ~ H .. ... tll '" '" ~ ~ : ~ tn 5 ~ 9 ~ OJ ~ Ii ~ III ... '" "' M " r- ... ~ ~ .. 13 13 o '" ~ ~ ~ :c Z w fI1 0 U H ~ ~ ~ :: ~a~~13 " :>: 0 ~ ::I.t}:;:;~ ~ ~g~~~ ~ ~ ~ III III OJ o r- ... '" a> '" OJ ... OJ ... ... 2 2 .. ~ " = ~ ; a " ! 8 8 i .. ::! .. I; " ~ f!l $ E; ~ S! ::> .. ... ~ ~ ~ ~ = o iI'i '" g ~ 2 000 ~f:~ tll U ... ~ ~ o u ~ '" H ... ~ '" " I ~ ~ .. 5 ~ !l ... " a> g ~ ~ ; ~ ~ ! i ~S~ ~ ~ I o .... u ~ ~ " ~ :>: e e i ~ ~ '" '" " ~ 8 8 .. .. : ~ ~ !:! i ~ !:! !i! ~ !:! !:! !:! !:! ~ i B ~ ~ I s ~ I ~ I ~ i ~ ~ I i ~ I ~ ~ &i ~ ~ ~ ~ UJ ~ ~ i 0> ... a> M"' r-t \D N P'l .. !il ~ ~ ~ o ~ I S E; '" E ~ ~ ~ ~ "' ~ g ~ ~ III III o '" 2 ;;l ;;l .. ~ ~ ~ ... ~ <r; ~ ;j ~ " "~ i.. ..I E : ~ ~> I;:.ae~ ~ I ~ I ~ ~ ~ 5 ~ 1;" i ~ ~ 01-) Ct)1k1~! W=P'I 2:=: .. H : .. : ~ ~ ; ~ ~ ~ i E ~ .. ~ ~ : ~ ~ g a ~ ~ ~ g m B ~ ~ ~ ~ s e ~ ~ ; : " ~ 5 a I ~ ~ ~ g a : i re ~ i I ~ ~ j ~ ~ ~ ~ j ~ I I ~ ~ I 1. s ~ u ~ ~ g lil o 5 " l2 g !Il ~ .rl 5 " ~ ~ t: ~ ~ .. 2 tll .. ~ ~ ~ u ~ Ll) ~ ~ .. ~ ~ ~ III ~ i <r; tl '" a E .. ~ ~ ~ ~ :>: ~ ~ 0< 0< ~ m m E; E; ~ ~ I I I ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ g III ~ 8 ~ ~ Sl ... <r; ~ ; I a a ~ u ~ ~ ~ a ~ ~ .. re o .. ~ I ~ ~ ~ 00 ~ tIl OJ p:: j:( \0 M ~ ~ ~ ~ C) l!) IQ IQ ~ ~ ~ 2 .. .. ~ ~ ~ ~ '" '" ~ ~ 8 ::> tll g ~ ~ r.J r.J ~ ~ s s o 0 ~ H U ~ j ~ ~ ~ gJ tll ::! .. H CI) :r: ~ ., i I ~ ~ ~ t: ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ .. .. '" '" tIl ~ 5 5 z U U 0 ~ ~ .. lil lil i! .. tll .. B U ~ i I I ~ ~ !il ~ ~ "" '" s E; ~ ~ B IQ f:! g ~ r.J !il ~ H H ~ E-4 <r; '" B iI'i .. M " ...... ('If ra::I N U ~ .. ~ o .... U .. ;j H r.J ~ H ~ .. ... 0 t i ~ U lil ~ '" ~ 0 ~ ! i "- c- ... ~ 0 ...... N ~ ~ ~ \0 ~ ~ ~ 0 ...... N ~ ~ ~ \0 ~ o o..-t('\f('l'1..,Ulr--ooo,\oooooooOOO..........I""iM............I""'t...... 0...." H 0\ 0\ 0\ 0\ 0\ 0\ 0\ 0\ 0\ M ...... .... .... ..-t ...... .... .... .... .... .... .... .... .... .... .... .... M ~ ~ ~ ~ 0\ .... .... ~ ~ ggggggggggggggggggggggggggg~~~~~~~~ w tj> '" '" ~- :.: '" co M '" rl M o '" .... '" '" .... '" rl