HomeMy WebLinkAbout008-07
TOWN .OF NANTUCKET
BOARD OF APPEALS
NANTUCKET, MASSACHUSETTS 02554
Date:
..:J o-n U'a "'\ l~, 2007
To: Parties in Interest and. Others concerned with the
--"j)e-Eislon-of the BOARD OFl APPEALS in the Application of the
following:
Application No.: CO~~07
Owner/Applicant: J. Skw.C\., BrtCl./'i oncQ
/js:o. - 010.'- q Q re.:sr-- s. 13 nt >!Jl
Enclosed is the Decision of the BOARD OF APPEALS which has
this day been filed in the office of the Nantucket Town
Clerk.
An Appeal from this Decision may be taken pursuant to
Section 17 of Chapter 40A, Massachusetts General Laws.
Any action appealing the Decision must be brought by
filing an complaint in court within TWENTY (20) days after
this day's date. Notice of the action with a copy of the
com~laint and certified copy of the ~ecision must be given
to the Town Clerk so as to be received within such TWENTY
(20) days.
. ~~~4'~~1~
f\J0JV\~ J. :e" Chairman
cc: Town Clerk
Planning Board
Building Commissioner
PLEASE NOTE: MOST SPECIAL PERMITS AND VARIANCES HAVE A TIME
LIMIT AND WILL EXPIRE IF NOT ACTED UPON ACCORDING-TO NANTUCKET
ZONING BY-LAW g139-301 (SPECIAL PERMITS); 9139-321 (VARIANCES)
ANY QUESTIONS, PLEASE CALL THE NANTUCKET ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS.
TOWN OF NANTUCKET
ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS
2 FAIRGROUNDS ROAD
NANTUCKET, MASSACHUSETTS 02554
Assessors Map 41
Parcel 519
ROH
144 Main Street
Book 916, Page 151
Deed Ref. 1033/52
At a Public Hearing of the Nantucket Zoning Board of Appeals, held at 1 :00 P.M.,
Friday, January 5, 2007, in the Conference Room, 2 Fairgrounds Road, Nantucket,
Massachusetts, on the Application ofthe J. STEWART BRYAN AND LISA-
MARGARET S. BRYAN, of 4608 SuI grave Road, Richmond, VA 23221, Board of
Appeals File No. 008-07, the Board made the following Decision:
1. Applicants are seeking relief by SPECIAL PERMIT pursuant to Nantucket
Zoning By-law Section 139-33A(9) (alteration/expansion of a pre-existing,
nonconforming use/structure - ground cover). Applicants propose to demolish the rear
existing el that is sited as close as about three feet from the easterly side yard lot line,
construct a new foundation, and add a second story to the new rear addition. The
nonconforming setback would be eliminated with the demolition and the new addition
would conform to all setback requirements. The existing nonconforming ground cover
ratio of about 34.9% would be temporarily reduced to momentarily comply with the
maximum ground cover ratio of 30%. Applicant is therefore seeking special permit relief
to allow the reconstruction of ground cover up to about 34.9%. In addition, Applicants
are seeking reliefby SPECIAL PERMIT under Zoning By-law Section 139-33E(2)(a) to
increase the ground cover ratio from about 34.9% (about 1,203 square feet) to about 37%
(about 1,262 square feet) as part of the reconstruction of the rear el. The rear addition
height would increase from about 14 feet to about 22 feet. Parking would continue to be
provided on site. The historic front portion of the house is conforming in all respects. The
property is benefited by a previous grant of Variance relief in the Decision in BOA File
No. 073-84 that permitted the construction of the existing garage sited within the westerly
side yard setback area and the increase of ground cover beyond the maximum allowed of
30%. Relief to exceed ground cover in the ROH to 50% for undersized lots is now
allowed by a grant of special permit relief, as so requested by the Applicants herein.
However, to the extent the Board deems it appropriate, the Applicants are seeking a
MODIFICATION of said Decision to complete the project as proposed. The lot is
nonconforming as to lot size with the lot containing about 3,460 square feet of area in a
district that requires a minimum lot size of 5,000 square feet; as to frontage with the lot
having about 41.3 feet of frontage along Main Street in a district that requires a minimum
frontage of 50 feet; as to ground cover ratio with the lot containing about 34.8% ground
cover ratio in a district that allows a maximum ground cover of 30% for undersized lots;
and as to setbacks with the dwelling sited as close as about three feet from the easterly
side yard lot line and with the separate garage sited as close as about 1.5 feet from the
westerly side yard lot line in a district that requires a minimum side and rear yard setback
of five feet.
The Premises is located at 144 MAIN STREET, Assessor's Map 41, Parcel 519,
and is shown as the easterly portion of Plan Book 916, Page 151. The property is zoned
Residential-O ld- Historic.
2. The Decision is based upon the Application and the material submitted with it and
the testimony and evidence presented at the Hearing. The Planning Board made no
recommendation. The immediately abutting neighbor to the east was present at the
public hearing and expressed concerns about the new addition if it was going to be sited
within the required easterly side yard setback area. She also asked that the oil tank be
moved to a conforming location. There were no letters on file.
3. The Applicants represented that as part of an overall renovation of an existing
single-family dwelling, they proposed to demolish and reconstruct an existing rear el. The
rear el is currently nonconforming as to the easterly five-foot side yard setback
requirement as the structure is sited as close as about three feet from that lot line. The
new addition would conform to all setback requirements. The ridge height of the rear
addition would increase from the present about 14 feet to no more than 22 feet. The
existing ground cover is about 34.9%, with a maximum of 30% allowed for undersized
lots in the Residential-aId-Historic zoning district. Applicants are seeking special permit
relief in order to increase the ground cover to a maximum of 37% in order to eliminate
jogs in the wall planes ofthe existing rear addition. Parking would continue to be
provided on site. No other changes are proposed that would require relief at this time.
The property is benefited by a previous grant of V ariance relief in the Decision in BOA
File No. 073-84, which allowed the construction ofthe existing garage within the
westerly required setback area. At that time, variance relief was also necessary to
increase ground cover beyond 30%. Such relief is now available by special permit as a
result of a vote of the Annual Town Meeting in 2003. No changes are proposed for this
garage, but the structure may be temporarily moved off site in order allow access to the
rear ofthe property in order to facilitate the removal and reconstruction of the rear
addition. As a condition of the previous grant of relief, no human habitation is allowed in
the garage. Applicants state that they have no plans to alter the use of the garage at this
time.
4. Based upon the foregoing, the Board finds that the demolition and reconstruction
of the rear addition on the single-family dwelling and increase of the ground cover to a
maximum of37%, subject to the appropriate conditions as set forth below, would not be
substantially more detrimental to the neighborhood than the existing nonconformities,
particularly as the easterly side yard setback encroachment would be eliminated and the
addition would conform to all setback requirements of the Zoning By-law. The Board
finds that there would be little impact upon the neighborhood as the current use of the
structure would not be altered, parking maintained on the lot and no other
nonconformities increased. As the demolition and reconstruction of the rear el would
entail possible temporary removal of the garage from the site in order to access the rear of
the property and minimize disturbance to neighbors, the Board finds that a Modification
of the previous Decision in BOA File No. 073-84 would be necessary to allow such a
temporary move, provided that repositioning of the garage would be on the same site and
no closer to the westerly side yard lot line than presently sited at about 1.5 feet. In
response to the Board's concerns about possible negative impact on the easterly abutter
with the placement of a new foundation under the reconstructed addition, the Applicants
stated that they would take every precaution to protect the neighbor's property, including
the use of metal sheathing below grade to stabilize the ground should that be necessary.
5. Accordingly, by a UNANIMOUS vote, the Board GRANTS the requested relief
by SPECIAL PERMIT under Nantucket Zoning By-law Sections 139-33A(9) and 139-
33E(2)(a) to allow the project to be completed as proposed; and to the extent necessary,
MODIFICATION of the previous variance relief granted in the Decision in 073-84 to
allow the temporary removal and replacement of the garage in order to provide access to
the rear of the property for demolition and reconstruction of the rear addition as
proposed, based upon the following conditions:
a. The reconstructed rear addition shall conform to all setback requirements;
b. The new siting and ground cover of the rear addition shall be done
substantially as shown upon the "Site/Locus Plan" done by Applicants'
designer, Emeritus Development LTD, dated December 15,2006, a
reduced copy of which is marked as Exhibit A and attached hereto;
c. The maximum ground cover allowed for the lot shall be 37%;
d. There shall be no exterior work related to this project allowed between
June 15th and September 15th of any given year; and
e. There shall be no human habitation of the garage and the garage shall be
repositioned no closer to the westerly side yard lot line than presently
located at about 1.5 feet.
Dated: J anuary r~ , 2007
~
=
z
--"
-'0
~-.)
.b:
N
90'9~'G~
UO!l~mJlSUOJ JOJ lON - UO!l88!ldd'v' ''v''S'Z
'-'-'=tJ
I .
I !!
.s
I ,.
/ hi
'1
~ I I;
- ----i/ '
. _. IN-".dl.OS.'B__li~
in
in
<;t
'$
.J
~~
i ~~~:
I "
i
g..~
_IL_
~~
"'El
i;!!~~
i~H
:Z~L.l...u...
~
'68
<!-g
:;r,
;\\0
~
-l5-
ON:lWe;;-- . - .
- z
31101W1!A~1i dIIV
"iii l'!'
;n~
t:
0 0>
:;::; ~:c~
CO
E ..-oo~~~
-.;to::l!)Ol!)l!)
~
0 Q)
...... Ol
t: ro
c: Ol-
'" _CC~~J::::
a:: C) Q) .- 0 u u u
~aU:E22
"' t: ~~Ea;a;a;
=>
0 t: o(lc~(f)(f)(f)
~~ 0 a.~.~cQ)ro
co ::l.~ e ~ Q)
oor- N 2U2LL(f)O::
~
'6 ~
::1.-8
:~-g
In
"/+.691
.,
it
:!< "<f!.
0
-.;t <D
e e
~~ ~
~ g-g-~g-
g- ii: gi
g~g8i:~
C!.O-.;t.N.<D"!.
LO(I")C"')~LO.,....
Q) ~ . U
NO ~0
(j)~ 0-00
o~ ~ 0>~0
....J 3: '-.f: 0
co~.~g.I9
~~3~cl:~
c:
'"
Q.
~i
N
TOWN OF NANTUCKET
ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS
~-_.----------"-
2 FAIRGROUNDS ROAD
NANTUCKET, MASSACHUSETTS 02554
PHONE 508-228-7215
FAX 508-228-7205
NOTICE
A Public Hearing of the NANTUCKET ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS will be held at 1:00
P.M.. FRIDAY. JANUARY 5.2007. in the Conference Room, 2 FAIRGROUNDS ROAD,
Nantucket, MA, on the Application of the following:
J. STEWART BRYAN AND LISA-MARGARET S. BRYAN
BOARD OF APPEALS FILE NO. 008-07
Applicants are seeking relief by SPECIAL PERMIT pursuant to Nantucket Zoning By-law
Section 139-33A(9) (alteration/expansion of a pre-existing, nonconforming use/structure - ground
cover). Applicants propose to demolish the rear existing el that is sited as close as about three feet
from the easterly side yard lot line, construct a new foundation, and add a second story to the new
rear addition. The nonconforming setback would be eliminated with the demolition and the new
addition would conform to all setback requirements. The existing nonconforming ground cover ratio
of about 34.9% would be temporarily reduced to momentarily comply with the maximum ground
cover ratio of 30%. Applicant is therefore seeking special permit relief to allow the reconstruction of
ground cover up to about 34.9%. In addition, Applicants are seeking relief by SPECIAL PERMIT
under Zoning By-law Section 139-33E(2)(a) to increase the ground cover ratio from about 34.9%
(about 1,203 square feet) to about 37% (about 1,262 square feet) as part of the reconstruction of the
rear el. The rear addition height would increase from about 14 feet to about 22 feet. Parking would
continue to be provided on site. The historic front portion of the house is conforming in all respects.
The property is benefited by a previous grant of Variance relief in the Decision in BOA File No.
073-84 that permitted the construction of the existing garage sited within the westerly side yard
setback area and the increase of ground cover beyond the maximum allowed of 30%. Relief to
exceed ground cover in the ROH to 50% for undersized lots is now allowed by a grant of special
permit relief, as so requested by the Applicants herein. However, to the extent the Board deems it
appropriate, the Applicants are seeking a MODIFICA nON of said Decision to complete the project
as proposed. The lot is nonconforming as to lot size with the lot containing about 3,460 square feet
of area in a district that requires a minimum lot size of 5,000 square feet; as to frontage with the lot
having about 41.3 feet of frontage along Main Street in a district that requires a minimum frontage of
50 feet; as to ground cover ratio with the lot containing about 34.8% ground cover ratio in a district
that allows a maximum ground cover of 30% for undersized lots; and as to setbacks with the
dwelling sited as close as about three feet from the easterly side yard lot line and with the separate
garage sited as close as about 1.5 feet from the westerly side yard lot line in a district that requires a
minimum side and rear yard setback of five feet.
The Premises is located at 144 MAIN STREET, Assessor's Map 41, Parcel 519, and is
shown as the easterly portion of Plan Boo~116, Page 151. The pro erty is zoned Residential-Old-
Historic. ~(,
Nancy J. Sevrens,
THIS NOTICE IS AVAILABLE IN LARG RINT OR OTHER
ALTERNATIVE FORMATS. PLEASE CALL 508-228-7215 FOR FURTHER
INFORMATION.
._ ~ ...r:' "" "
'~,~~.'\! ,I
.,~,,,,. I
. \",., <. -
',;. ..
.. . ~~
3' (
FEE~ ~300.00
NANTUCKET ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS
.. ., 1 ~AST CHESTNUT STREET
NANTUCKET, MA 02554
APPLICATION FOR RELIEF
CASE NO.CDS>--G7
Owner's name(s): :r '>TeuJor
~ Maili':lJ~~~dress: 4:~o~ S' u l u
. ----------.-..---.-.-- --1"------ .---.-.----- --.--.----...-.----.-.--...- ...-----.---.
Applicant's name(s): L s: ~) .
Mailing address: . C S. Q~")
. Locus 'address: I L-f \.{ fYlo In S1Yee[ .fssessor's MapfParcel: 4 ( I 5t 9
Land Court PlanfPlan Book & PagefPhin File NQ.: q lLR / t 5f Lot No.: ~
Date lot acquired: (/61/00Deed Ref./Cert. of Title: /C)33 / ~ J-. ZoningDistrict:~
. t .
:Uses on Lot-Commercial: None ~Yes(des.cribe) .'
. . ReSidential: Number of dwellingsL Duplex----.: Apartments_Rental Rooms
. Building Date(s): All pre-date 7/721 ~ or . C of O(S)'l'
Building Permit Nos:
Previous Zoning Board Application Nos.: ~CL O'{ 3 - rrLj- .
State below or on a separate addendum specific reli~f sought (Special Permit, Variance, Appeal), Section of
the Zoning By4aw, and supporting details, grounds for grant of relief, listing any existing nonconformities:
~ ctfff)okaJ Orfl~ckm) ~ .1
.
-"
_' ~::;J
, .:J
'r')
',-0
SIGNATURE: Applicant Attorney/Agent K
(If not owner or owne's orney, please enclose proQ of agency to bring this matter before the Board)
ro ~ lm~U~ . .
Application received ou: Il-Il ? (k By: Complete: Need copies?: ~
Filed with Town Clerkt~Iz1/cJGPlanning ~anl: " I DtlildiRg J)ept: 1 I~r:
Fe. deposited with Towu Treasurer: bL-rv, ;cG BJ' ~ Waiver requested?:_ Grauted:_I--:I_
Hearing notice posted with Town Clerk:l.:L1!Lf3:gMailed:~iZ'o ~I&M: tl721-c&.- & (0/ltlcfo
Hearing(s) held on:_I_I-: Opened on:_I_I_ Continued to:_I_I_ Withdrawn?:_I_I_
DECISION DUE RV: I I Made: I I Filed wrrown Clerk: / I Mailed: 1 /
ned herein is substantially complete and true to the best of my
alties of perjury.
I certify that the infor
knowledge, under the
ADDENDUM
Applicants are seeking relief by SPECIAL PERMIT pursuant to Nantucket
Zoning By-law Section 139-33A(9) (alteration/expansion of a pre-existing,
nonconforming use/structure - ground cover). Applicants propose to demolish the rear
existing el that is sited as close as about three feet from the easterly side yard lot line,
construct a new foundation, and add a second story to the new rear addition. The
nonconforming setback would be eliminated with the demolition and the new addition
would conform to all setback requirements. The existing nonconforming ground cover
ratio of about 34.9% would be temporarily reduced to momentarily comply with the
maximum ground cover ratio of 30%. Applicant is therefore seeking special permit relief
to allow the reconstruction of ground cover up to about 34.9%. In addition, Applicants
are seeking relief by SPECIAL PERMIT under Zoning By-law Section 139-33E(2)(a) to
increase the ground cover ratio from about 34.9% (about 1,203 square feet) to about 37%
(about 1,262 square feet) as part ofthe reconstruction of the rear el. The rear addition
height would increase from about 14 feet to about 22 feet. Parking would continue to be
provided on site. The historic front portion of the house is conforming in all respects. The
property is benefited by a previous grant of Variance relief in the Decision in BOA File
No. 073-84 that permitted the construction of the existing garage sited within the westerly
side yard setback area and the increase of ground cover beyond the maximum allowed of
30%. Relief to exceed ground cover in the ROH to 50% for undersized lots is now
allowed by a grant of special permit relief, as so requested by the Applicants herein.
However, to the extent the Board deems it appropriate, the Applicants are seeking a
MODIFICATION of said Decision to complete the project as proposed. The lot is
nonconforming as to lot size with the lot containing about 3,460 square feet of area in a
district that requires a minimum lot size of 5,000 square feet; as to frontage with the lot
having about 41.3 feet of frontage along Main Street in a district that requires a minimum
frontage of 50 feet; as to ground cover ratio with the lot containing about 34.8% ground
cover ratio in a district that allows a maximum ground cover of 30% for undersized lots;
and as to setbacks with the dwelling sited as close as about three feet from the easterly
side yard lot line and with the separate garage sited as close as about 1.5 feet from the
westerly side yard lot line in a district that requires a minimum side and rear yard setback
of five feet.
Town of Nantucket Web GIS - Printable Map
Page 1 of2
Town of Nantucket Web GIS
1
-----"l-
I
I
i
T-~-
-----~
~. ~i~-
. I
rl19 i
#'." j
! I
I . I
" I
o
129ft
Sale Date
Sale Price
Book/Page
Lot Size
41 519
144 MAIN ST
FOSTER GENE G & W
DOUGLAS
115 NORTH WESTVIEW
DR
WINSTON-SALEM, NC
27104
10/01/2004
$1,150,000
00916/0151
0.08 acres
.
Prop ID
Address
Owner
NOT A LEGAL DOCUMENT
CJ
For general reference only: Important
caveats which must be considered when
using this data are available from the
Nantucket GIS Coordinator.
Dj~claim~r The information displayed on this or
any other map produced by The Town of
Nantucket is for reference purposes only. The
Town of Nantucket does not guarantee the
accuracy of the data. Users are responsible for
determining the suitability for individual needs,
All information is from the Town of Nantucket
(:;,::I.nnr::.nhir Tnfnrm~tif"ln ~\lc:t~m ((;Tc;" r1~t~h;::tI:j:I
~~ ~\.
'~'0 6/
"
~
Town of Nantucket, Mass
Map Composed
http://host.appgeo.com/nantucketma/PrintableMap.aspx?Preserve= Width&Map Width=86... 12/13/2006
Town of Nantucket Web GIS - Printable Map
Page 1 of2
Town of Nantucket Web GIS
Prop ID
Address
Owner
41 519
144 MAIN ST
FOSTER GENE G & W
DOUGLAS
115 NORTH WESTVIEW
DR
WINSTON-SALEM, NC
27104
10/01/2004
$1,150,000
00916/0151
0.08 acres
.
NOT A LEGAL DOCUMENT
a
Sale Date
Sale Price
Book/Page
Lot Size
For general reference only: Important
caveats which must be considered when
using this data are available from the
Nantucket GIS Coordinator.
QjscJaimer The information displayed on this or
any other map produced by The Town of
Nantucket is for reference purposes only, The
Town of Nantucket does not guarantee the
accuracy of the data. Users are responsible for
determining the sUitability for individual needs.
All information is from the Town of Nantucket
r::pnnl"';:mhir Tnfnrm;"ltirm ~\/c:tpm ((;Te;,) rl;"lt;!h:::lC:p
~y--~
~
Town of Nantucket, Mass
Map Composed
http://host. appgeo. com/nantucketma/Printab leMap. aspx ?Preserve= Width&Map Width=4 3... 12/2012006
Oct 11 06 10:57a
Liss~
804-359-1549
p.7
::C~ pili 47-N
20!JS' k~ 16_15'
,;;--(L_~ It.-
00 V.o
~ - ~ g' I
u.
n.
""
~
':0'
Il'
.,
tn
~,
:;y
W
0::
0
::.
<:
0
Q) Z
IlJ -i I
0 1'-.
ll: -:
:j- ~ ;;:=
:J: Q
u
ii'
:)/. ....
'-...
" ~.
~6
,~:~
1/.. '''J~
.,.. ~~~... 1,11"
'J c{----' ' ~
.Jr.
.~~,(
",-~:~lnn
/ /' ./ /" / / / / //
/ /~/// - "o'.-
.~~/-/:; ///'/%?:'./~//~:;;.
/ // /. 0
' // o'/ /
~;//~:(/~~/ //
/ /~/'/; '// //%' /'./ +
. ./ - /./ ,/ " '-
</ . //;/5(<"'/ /;/ _..::..0
//:.<>/:> W/F ~ '/0/' 1 j
/ ///DWELlING/ / // _..rJ
/ ////// / / .
/ // // // / // //
:~/;/*{:~~::-
./ ././ ,/ //
/ >i'./ /,/
/ ///~/ / //
//// //
/>'// J://
/ ,.' //::~ ././
//// //
///~~~'l/ J' ~
y;://// / // /' / ,-
;:/;~~~~::::~:..:
1//' ././~/0/ /.(/
/ _.. / /,-L
',//// /.- I
/' />>~//>~ '8! rl
/" //- /'" /~ ////" ~
/ //::/>:/-' //> / /
~/~~%-;~>
1-~t~
I'
/
o:c
'"
In
w
Q: I
I
I
,
I
!
I >-
Ii
..
,.
~
I
I
I
I
I
I
-J
:./ .
"-2'./
/
I
I
I
./"':-y.-
I
L
.1
LS ._-
-
..,.
,
l"-
V
=
-.5
o
111
('oj
\Xl
-~~A
fJOlF.: tOT OOES NO_
COl~FORM TO CURRfNr
lCNlF,G RfOJIRHIENTS
V,llH H[SPEcr fO MIN.
AR[A "ND MlN_ rROH 1 AGE.
STRUCruR(S DO N01
CO~FORW TO CURRENT
ZOHa-lC RfOUlRtI.lENn;
"'1TH RESPECT TO (;ROVI~O
COVE~ MiO SIDE YARD S::TBACK
MAIN
STREET
REBAR
FOUND NOT
A7 COR. ~i!'.e PH.' 4S...~
(SEE DETAIL. I'
PLfl45 A) 30,73'~~
- ~ Jl -5.:1"0'
, V~-
<:)
:z
...,
c:
<:
lD
....
c:
---
<::
I
Il")
oq
o
z
-:(
ID
-J
~
>--
2:
o
;::;:
41.3' (calc)
;...,
~. 'I
, I
0.,
l
I
CURRENT ZONING: ROH
MINIMUM LOi SIZE: 5000 SF
M!NItI.LlM rRONTACE: 50 rT
rRONTYARD SETBACi<: NONE "'j I. 1_'
SIOI:: AND REAR SETBACK: 5 FT 3,\ Et.'^Cr; I;:;:
ALLOWABLE G.C,R.: 507. ( 30% FOR ~. ~ ~ ,!!
WtTH AREA UNDER 5000 SF). ~<J.~~l~:l~.f
EXiSTING G.C.R.: 34.8%:!: ~/-:~~ 'Yol( L .
. "\l ~
FOR PROPERTY UI!E DEI[RMINAllON liS PLOT PLNol
REl.IE$ ON C'Jl\RtNT OEWS AND PLANS Of RECORD.
VERlF'lEG l'!Y FIElD IAEASI)REMENTS AS StI01l~~ HER::OO,
TH:S PLAN IS ....OT Rt:PllESENlED TO BE A TIRE
(X^"lINATION OR A RECORDABLE Slll~II(Y.
, HERESY CERilfY TO iHE aEST OF lAY I<NO\\l.EOGE
1 HI- 1 HiE PREM:SES SHO'ioN ON lUtS PlAN ARE
lOCAT(v W:1HI/o,' 'H( c: ZONe AS OE.lIt'EAt(D
0,,, THE -riRM" ur,p 0;- COMMUNI rl' NO. 250230;
""ASS [fFECi/V(: 6-J-8&. R(IIISfI) 7-2-92 BY
11-1E r(O(l~A.!.. ~I.fERCENCY l,!JlNIo.C(t.IENT AC[NCY.
-.5
<'>I
<D
oj
1:0
~
a w
<'.I U <<l:
<() >- I
I ~ ';J.
~ ~ ""
-< Ci
-.
L.J
<<l:
:J:
U
~
4-
'"
:z
J.2'::
.f 4000'
. (pl(t
'Yr ~~' - 518 47_IV)
"'fo",
" O~Ol<E'
"
N.1l 15/65
.(,
MORTGAGE INSPECnON PLAN
IN
NAN!UCKET, MASSACHUSETTS
SCAlE; 1""'10' DATE:SEPT 14. 2004
DEED REFERENCE: DBK 789. PG 25
.ELAN REFERENCE: NONE
ASSESSOR'S REFERENCE:
f-JAP: 41 PARCEL: 519
PREPARED FOR: GENE C.FOSTER
!L. W_ DOUGLAS rOSTER
EMACK SURVEYlNG
2 WASHAM AN AVENUE
NANTUCKET, !.lA, 02554-
(50a) 325-0940
J-- 712
[JOB NO. 5104]
141 007
10/11/2006 WED 10:56
~
oen
~ -.
Ii;;;
"
'"
=>
;;0 en "TlsOs
mg:g~:~~
..., .-+ 3 ('[)
enenenc:JSI<>
~~~3N;J
ggg~gn
() () 0 0 -. CD
:::,\^7'::J::J-
_<0
tll
<0
CD
U1U10U1;;o.::o-
::l>::l>::l>oO~
. . . ~I;:;;
to
c;i~~b~~
[.g~C;;$!?
o -. -. '" r
0~cE ~ ~~
OCl.G) roen
'00 0~'
0' 0
....l.(..V....l.WWOl
~~~o,OD
<.0+0')01*0
~a-O~ 0
+00++ U'J
.....0 -.-.... ...Q
cn:""'UJfJJ :-
~:--?~ ;i"-
~ ?' ?'
W W
.::0- W
~ ~
0
"
~
Li!.
HI
~
<n
0If-8i50(~",,-N1
'It-
:1 I~ --
!",
t~ I
~I I
I
I
L
lB.9'+-/.
G'l~"'lJ
l.p~
,,::i!.
~ -1::
~ (
.-
.E"
8'
1
N
o
::J
::J
c.c
::J
-
o
"""I
3
Q)
:::::!:
o
::J
-lo
. .
'" 0
"
c:
00
"
'"
=>
~~
~~
~C'
jj
NlF R1ciJiMAMORE
z. --
_ . --!!!BA.RFND
~-
~
~
s:
~
" ~
~ i
~"
il
""i
i
[
~
f
om
l~
00
..
"
Z.B.A. Application - Not for Construction
12.15.06
~ ~
0 :3 ; ~
~ <1> ;;:::::t:= i 'J.
0 '-' ~ - ~ riSlgS! lilt
'6 c: - ~ g~ ~~~~5 ~~~~
::i' <1> Ih~
-0 ,~ , ".,
-in .. ". IH!l
c t.I {l .r:
en 0 <1> '" ~ 1 ~i~h
~ oc i JdjJ
..... c: i '-!.;4
(0 co ~o' ;mi Mil
'" c:- Hhi
C) .. ro z
o
N
<i.
0')
~
CD
o
5 J!I
.!! - ~p
:n~
_.;"".......~'O,__
""--""'..""",....,,,.....
!
c c
0 0
m m
> >
" "
~ ~ ~
m "
W ! ;;: ~
N ~
!
H.
m
co c
0 0
'" '"
> >
" '"
w
~ ~
. ~ ,
0 0
z <n
..... C"')
9 0 'g t . Z t U 0 !J :J n J J SUO J J 0 j JON
A/UQ /BIIOJddl;j 'J'O'H JO:1
-,:- 0')
~
:::I -.: :~ -,:- "r"
Q) ;I~~ ilH <i. c.o
u - i. - ~
c: - , ,<1 t ~S~~~ <:)
Q) hp
-c : ~ jfiJ
"in iHl~
Q)
en rr: Hill i(ih -""'.........",..........
...- c: .0 . '-! .4 > , ~f : ~!~
(.0 '" dlh
e=- Mil .J! p-- ~ -..-......"--,,....-.
c ~ "l!:~l!:
II) <<"':II::!: ,""*......"..u_~..,
g
~
"'
Q.
o
o
u..
~
u..
~
:;::10;>
~ ;
-- .
K'
w'
N
!
H
H
.r-/~~
" "\
~
ro
Q.
o
o
~
ro
Q.
o
o
u..
"
~ e
0:
~ ;
<nO
"0:::1"
9 0 'g i . 6 i U 0 !J :J n n suo J J 0) ION - A I U 0 I e II 0 J d d 'v' . J . 0 . H J 0 :i
"
~
o
"
"
<n
-,:-
~
'; :-
w;
M
0)
......
<.0
o
Q)
<..)
c
Q)
-a
00
Q)
0::::Q5
Q)
"-
-+-'
COO
CO .c
ct'l
>.~
L... oo::::t
(()~
Q)
'-'
c
Q)
-c
-;;;
Q)
IY
c
'"
c:-
oo
~
I ~lli!
~o
CO')
~ -r-
<i.~
~j~~
j il~
Illl
iHil
';~J .
ii'll
I fl"
lI!.l
~
.--........,,,-"'"
,._...~".._....."".....,
~~;~~
lfM M
,. ,i, 10!"
~HH ~dl!
:: ~!~
~ ~~~
i
h
II
~~
~
c
o
oq-
'$-
c
'"
CL
'"
>
'"
w';:
'"
V).
I.(')
I I
~._.
Main Street
iQg jJ;j
oo::::t
LO iug Ihl
LO
N
C> lUl l!i!
<(
~rg '"
~ ,r I " JI~~
!l,/ -0 "
'" "
c ""
-+-' u -0
Q) '" iug ,-;1 t- V) '"
CL i I ""
..::z::. jJ,iJ ~ iii u
U ~ 0" V)~
" -0 .
~ u. .:: ~ 0'-
0" 0'
-+-' -' . <'15 , St : ,ij!I~[~~~@ I 0-
C ~ ihl N I j M
ct'l HI
Z
90.9~.Z~ uOfpnJjsuoo JOj JON - A/UQ /B!lOJdd'tj 'O'O'H JOd
TOWN OF NANTUCKET
BOARD OF APPEALS
NANTUCKET, MASSACHUSETTS 02554
November 30, 1984
Re: EVELYN TRUBY (073-84)
Enclosed, please find notice of a decision of the BOARD
OF APPEALS which has this day been filed with the Town
Clerk.
Any appeal from this action shall be made pursuant to
Section 17 of Chapter 40A of the General Laws, and shall
be filed within twenty (20) days after this date.
BOARD OF APPEALS
;>;>>~~
TOWN OF NANTUCKET
BOARD OF APPEALS
NANTUCKET, MASSACHUSETTS 02554
DECISION:
In the matter of the Application of EVELYN L. TRUBY
(071-84), at a meeting of the BOARD OF APPEALS held at 1:30
P. M. on Friday, November 2, 1984, and continued to 1:30 P.
M. on Friday, November 16, 1984, at the Town and County
Building, Nantucket, the Board enters the following Decision
and makes the following findings:
1. This is an application for a VARIANCE granting
relief from the requirements of Section 5.3 (Intensity
Regulations: side lot line) and Section 5.1 (Intensity
Regulations: ground cover ratio) of the zoning By-Law. If
granted, the Applicant would be permitted to construct a new
garage, eleven feet wide and nineteen feet long, which would
be 3.0 feet from the side lot line (five feet setback
requi red by the by-law) and which would, together with the
existing buildings upon the lot, cause the lot to have a
ground cover ratio of 33% (30% maximum permited by the
by-law) . The subject premises consist of the property
approximately shown on Assessor's Map 41 as Parcel 519, are
located at 144 MAIN STREET, and are zoned as RESIDENTIAL-OLD
HISTORIC.
2. Based upon the application and the materials and
testimony presented at the public hearing, the Board finds
that the subject premises contain about 3,698 square feet and
contain a single-family dwelling, antedating the effective
date of the Nantucket Zoning By-Law, with ground cover of
1,019 square feet; the present ground cover ratio, computed
under the by-law, is 27.6%. There is no garage upon the
subject premises. The Applicant proposes to construct a
detached garage, containing no living space and no additional
dwell ing uni t, between the westerly side of the existing
dwelling and the westerly boundary of her property, near the
end of the present driveway. The proposed garage would have
a ground cover of 209 square feet, for a total ground cover
for the lot of 1,228 square feet, or a ground cover ratio of
33.2%.
3. Under the Zoning By-Law, the ground cover ratio
permitted in a Residential Old Historic District is 50%.
However, the by-law further provides that a lot with a
previously existing structure which contains less than 5,000
square feet is limited to 30% in ground cover ratio. This
Board rules that the applicable ground cover ratio permitted
upon the subject premises is 30%.
4. The Board finds, based upon a review of the
Application, supporting documents, plans, testimony,
correspondence, and a viewing of the sUbject premises, that,
due to circumstances relating to the shape or topography of
~
the subject premises, and especially affecting the subject
premises but not affecting generally the zoning distr ict in
which they are located (such circumstances consisting of the
boundaries and dimensions of the subject premises, and the
location of the existing structure and walls thereon), a
literal enforcement of the provisions of the Zoning By-Law
would involve substantial hardship, financial or otherwise,
to the Applicant (such hardship consisting of the fact that
there is no other place upon the subject premises where a
garage can be constructed), and that desirable relief may be
granted without substantial detriment to the public good and
without nullifying or substantially derogating from the
intent or purpose of the by-law (in that the requested relief
will permit the construction of a garage, which will be more
aesthetically desirable than the outdoor storage of an
automobile upon the subject premises, and a garage as an
accessory building is perm itted under the Zoning By-Law).
5. Relief granted hereunder is conditional upon the
proposed garage not being ued as an apartment or other
additional dwelling unit and not containing any living space.
6. For the reasons and upon the conditions set forth,
the BOARD OF APPEALS hereby GRANTS the Applicant relief from
Sections 5.1 and 5.3 of the Zoning By-Law by a VARIANCE, by a
UNANIt10US vote.
Dated: November JO, 1984
~.;~
Ly le L. Rickard
RECEIVED
BOARD OF ASSESsORS
DEe 0 1 2006
It fJJ I ()o
TOWN OF
NANTUCKET, MA
Town of Nantucket ..
Zoning Board of Appeals
LIST OF PARTIES IN INTEREST IN THE MA TIER OF THE PETITION OF:
PROPERTY OWNER.. $.'~Y~.....................................................,... .'...
MAILING ADDRESS.................. ./?(??~.. .~t:'........................................
PROPERTY LOCATION.. ...........If.f...//If./1!~..~..
ASSESSOR MAPIPARCEL.......... :1./.. ./....... .?"!1..:................................
APPLICANT...&?J.~/!!:':.~....P.~/?!!?~..~.~.....
SEE ATTACHED PAGES
I c.ertify that the foregoing is a list of persons who are owners of abutting property, owners of land
directly opposite on any public or private street or way; and abutters of the abutters and all other
land owners within 300 feet of the property line of owner's property, all as they appear on the
most recent applicable tax list (M.G.L. c. 40A, Section 11 Zoning Code Chapter 40A
Section 139-29B (2)
J)~, d, ~otJ b
DATE ~
~a/h~
~SSESSOR'S OFFICE
Town of Nantucket
<:
o
OM E-<
... '"
~ ~
o
~
E-<
8 tI) H E-t E-t
~ : ~ ~ : :
tfl H E-l H H H
~ ~~~~~~
H~" ..:IO\f"o
"' ri M r-- ....
III Mr-Iri""Mrt
~
~
H
=:
'"
H E-t E-t E-t
:il :il ~ '" '" !i; '"
III III ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
~ i ~ ~ ~ i ~
(Jl (Jl 0< III III
ltl 0 III III an an
~ N ~ r-I ri ri ri ri
E-< E-< :il !i; !i; Q E-< E-< ~ E-< E-< E-< E-< E-< E-< E-< E-< Q !i;
~ ~ ~ ~ m III tI) 00 ~ m tI) tI) tI) ~ ~
~ ~ e ~ ~ III ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ III ~
~ ~ ~ ~ i ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ i
Illri O~~H~""No~~omO
~ .. 0 M M ltl M III III III III .. .. .. M
ri ri ri N N M M M M ri M r-I r-I M ri ri ri
'"
01
<lj
'"
..,. "1ft 0 0 CJ) r-I 0
an LO III N .. co an
III U"I "lIl r-- 0 .... ..
N N t"- r-I t' M r--.
o 0 0 0 0 ,., 0
!i; ~ t ~ t ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ t ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
E-< E-<
CI] foot E-t fJ)
f-l E-t E-t tr.l t1J E-I
: : : ~ ~ ~ : ~
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
N ri Ol III ~ ~ 0 -<
M M N f""I M M M M
.... ri r-I ri r-t M ri r-I
II>
'"
o
II>
,
.. 0 .. 0 .. .. NO" .. .. .. ri .. .. ~ t' .. ~ 0 CJ) .. .. r-- ri t' .. N r-- r-- r-- .. U'l
III r-- III .. U'l III .. m III III III III 0 0 III r-- r-- U'l r-- r-t MillO r-I M ri III 0 0 0 0 III ..
Q III m III m III III t' .. III III III III M m III III III U"I ~ .. ri III M 0 CJ) 0 ~ N r-I ri .... III 0
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ g 8 ~ g g g g ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ g ~ ~ ~ g ~ ~ ~ ~ g ~ : : : g ~
5
E-< i E-< ~ E-< E-< 5 E-< E-< E-< E-<
g i~i:III;1111
'"
~
~
~ E-< E-< ~ 5 '" E-<
:il m ~ a ~ ~ ~ m ~
~ I ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ I
..
..
..
"
'd
'd
0<
to
<:
'M
....
....
~
:>:
~
.
E-I
IZl
~
U
P
~
E-<
:il =
1':1 !i; E-< E-< ~
~ ~ ~ ~ : :
to ~ E-t IZ1 H H
2 g~~~~::!
't1 ~ r-- CJ\ r--
'd 0 r-- 0 ..,. '....
,.:( ~r--rlt'rt.-t
E-<
'"
lil
E-<
'"
!ll ~
H
:>: E-<
m ~ ~
~ E-< to
'"
.. III
~ ~ ~
~ ~ H
'"
o .... E-<
.(J N l1.l
'"
'"
..
=:
'"
H
E-< ~
~ ~
'" U
lJt 0 lJt lJt
: ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
m ::l!ll ~ 0 ~ ti:
~ gJoii1~u~
.. III ~ '" =: :;! 0<
I Z H Z H
l-40..:lHtI:ZH
.. """'''0''
e ~ II( ~ H E-t E-t
6 gg;dl~~
r:!
E-< ..
~ ..
...
....
<:
D
..
'"
D
III
..
'"
!ll
H
:>:
~
u
"
'"
E-<
'"
III
..
<Xl
:il ~
l:l ~ :il
o
a ~ ~ ~ ~ ;
Ul 3 H [f.I tI) 0
OlU&~~~
E-<
'"
'"
III
.... ..
tl') fI.l E-t 0)
~
H
III
Q
Q
Ol 0
i ~
=:
i;! U i;!
~ ~ i ~
g ~ ~ ~
000
U U U
'" '" '"
H H H
E-t IZ1 U U U E-t E-t E-t Q
~ I : : : I I ~ I I
a ~ m 00 00 ~ u ~ Z ~
'"
j H
~ ~ g
H )1 0
~ S is ~
'"' S III Q
~nl ~:;!
E-<
'"
D
III
E-<
'"
~
H
)1
~ ~
=:
.. III
'" 0
::l ~
~ ~
..
'" Ol
=:
.. E-<
~ ~
0< III
'" '"
.. ..
~ ~
.. to
~ E-<
III
:::l r:l
'" u
'" '"
~ ~ .,
III ..
'" ~
'" '" '"
Q !ll S
e ~ ~
~ ~ ~
~ ~ ~
U .. Q
..
:l ~
In. ::<
.. '"
E-< '" ~ III ~
N ~ ~ ~ M ~ H
I ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 00 ~ ~ ~ ~
~ 00 m ~ a ~ Q 8 ~ ~ ~
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ m 8 ~ ~ ~ # # * ~
N ~ H N ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ : ~ ~ ~ ~
~ : ~ ~ i : ; ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ M
~ 0 ~ ~ 0 0 n N ~ ~ H H H 0
8 ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 0 0 0 0 ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ : : : ~
'" 0
.... N
.... N
E-<
'"
'"
III
E-<
'" '"
....
~ N
H
~ tl
III
'"
r4 \D \D N ..,. 0
N ri M P1 r4 ~
)1
'"
~ ~
to III
H
.. :>:
0< ..
.. ~ ..
'" III
0< is ~
~ ~ ~ fa ~
~ ~ 0 ~ ~
H ~ ~ .&1 ~
8 gJ ~ ~ ~
~ ~ ~ E 2
0< Q )1 :>: (j
'" ..
'"
.. to
'"
lil ~
.. 0
=:
~ ~
~ ~ ~
'" ~
~ ~ ~
to U '"
'" '"
'" N
..
'"
III
..
:>:
~
E-<
'"
~
~
~
><
E-<
III
o
..
E-<
'"
lil
.. :=
E-<
'" Ol
~ ::l ..
~ ~ ~
~ '" E-<
E-< III '"
'" ['J !ll
z H ~
~ ~ ~
'" 0 U
11>.... "
.... U '"
~ ~ ~ 0 r4 M M ..,. ~ rl ~ ~ ~ N M ~ ~ ~ ~ 0 M N N ..,. ~
o ~ ~ 00 \D ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 00 00 ~ M M " rl M M n N M M N N N
...l MMMrtrirtrtMMrtr-lr-lM""~LOLO~~LllI.tlI/'lll'lLllLlllOlO
....
!ll
o
'"
'"
'"
~
'"
'"
o ..
III '"
III
.. ..
III to
to
'"
<Xl 0<
~
~ ~
~ ~
~ a
E-< ~
'"
'" =:
E-< E-<
'"
III ::l ..
'" .,
H H '" ~
~ ~ '"
~ '" E-<
~ ~ ~ ~
'" '" 0
'" E-< U
~ ~ ~ ~ ~
t1 ~ ~ ~ II(
;j ~ ~ ..:I
U H =:
H III III )1 ..
III Ol '" ~
" " '"
Z H H 0
g :il :il ~ '"
~ ~ ~ a eJ
~
~ 0<(
~ 5l
0< H
'" ~
~ ~ j ~ ~ !i;"
M HOOp P: ~ 1!11
III ~ DillE-< ..
~ 0 0 ~ ~ 00
E-i CI) E-i ~ '" rs1
00 rs1 ~ 01 H Q H
eJ .. ~ g ~ ~ .. ~ ~ ~ ~
~ ~ III ~ E-< '" ~ 5 ~ ~ a
ii1 III ~ E-< 0 to =:
U '" '" H to E-< >< ~
>t :-:::-:: E-i P:: P:;
E-< '" ~ '" D '" " ~ ~ '"
! ~ ~ ~ ~ ; ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
III
I ~
.. ~
>< '"
'" H
~ :>:
o 0
.. '"
o 0
.... ....
U U
~
H
~
~
co
u
~
..
'"
to
0<
.... N '"
~
!< ~
~ 8 g ~ ~
~ ~ CI) ~ ~
~ ::: ~ g ~
tI) ~ = :-:: 00
'" .. D
M 00 0 Q
... 0 0
~ ~ ~ an
:il
:il
Q
o
~
~ ~ 8
o ~
o '"
~ ..
H 0
CD D 0
.... '" II>
'"
III
E-<
E-<
'"
'"
~
..
'" .. 0<
D '" H
III D '"
~ ~ .. ~
.. ~ to III
~ ~ ~ ~
III ~
M >t ~ tI1
rt II( E-t H
.. 0< III
~ '" ::l 0
..:z; 0
00 H 0 0\
~ ~ tl ::1
III
E-<
:>:
'"
f;l
III '"
~ ~
E-<
'"
'"
E-< '"
'"
0<( "
~
'" ~
~ ~
o =:
.. III ..
o '"
to ~ ~ ~
~ ~ = ~
~ ~ ~ :
~ ~ I
>< ~
'" III
~
III ..
'" '"
Ii!
H
'"
~
~
H
"
U
:>:
o
....
U
~ is
~ ~
~
~ i
~ ~
U U
~
..
III
'"
H '"
~ ~
~ =:
E-<
~ ~
H 0
'" III
=: III
:;:
0.
'"
M
.... N '"
N
'"
rl
'"
N M N M lO ~ ~ ..,. ~ ~ \D M
..,. ~ ~ ..,. ..,. ..,. ~ 0\ ~ ~ ~ rt
o
N
.....
....
M M M M M M M M M M M M M
Q M M M M M M M M M M M M M
m M r4 r-l rt M ri r-l r-l M M r-l M M rl r-l M M ri r-I M M n M M M rl M N N M N N N N N N N N M M
~ ..,...,. ~ ..,. ..,. ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ..,. ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ..,. ~ ..,. ..,. ~ ~ ~ ~ ..,. ..,. ..,. ~ ~ ~ ..,. ..,. ..,. ~ ..,. ..,. ~ ..,. ..,. ~
o
'" >< III
2 ~ ~
.....
N
rl