HomeMy WebLinkAbout021-06
TOWN OF NANTUCKET
BOARD OF APPEALS
NANTUCKET, MASSACHUSETTS 02554
Date: /ifr(( 7
, 20eCp
To: Parties in Interest and. Others concerned with the
-DeelsTon of the BOARD OF APPEALS in the Application of the
following:
Owner/Applicant:
g;;(I-O (Q
1r~ AJe-rct- IffiJ-P LL C-
/"-.
Application No.:
Enclosed is the Decision of the BOARD OF APPEALS which has
this day been filed in the office of the Nantucket Town
Clerk.
An Appeal from this Decision may be taken pursuant to
Section 17 of Chapter 40A, Massachusetts General Laws.
Any action appealing the Decision must be brought by
filing an complaint in court within TWENTY (20) days after
this day's date. Notice of the action with a copy of the
com~laint and certifi of the necision t be given
to the Town Clerk as to be r eived within s ch TWENTY
(20) days.
cc: Town Clerk
Planning Board
Building Commissioner
/
PLEASE NOTE: MOST SPECIAL PERMITS AND VARIANCES HAVE A TIME
LIMIT AND WILL EXPIRE IF NOT ACTED UPON ACCORDING' TO NANTUCKET
ZONING BY-LAW ~139-30I (SPECIAL PERMITS); 9139-321 (VARIANCES)
ANY QUESTIONS, PLEASE CALL THE NANTUCKET ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS.
NANTUCKET ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS
One East Chestnut Street
Nantucket, Massachusetts 02554
34 Center Street
Assessor's Map 42.3.1, Parcel 120
Residential-Commercial-Downtown
Plan Book 16, Page 34, Lot 1
Deed Book 1006, Page 223
DECISION:
The Board of Appeals at a Public Hearing held on Friday, March la, 2006,
at 12:00 p.m. in the Conference Room of the Town Annex Building, 37
Washington Street, Nantucket, Massachusetts, made the following Decision on
Application No. 021-06, of THE NEXT HALF LLC, Jamie Gries, Manager,
(formerly noticed under Rosalie T. Maloney, Owner, and for Jamie Gries,
Contract Purchaser), of P.O. Box 3515 Nantucket, Massachusetts 02584, regarding
property located at 34 Center Street, Nantucket, MA 02554.
1. Applicant (Gries) is seeking relief by SPECIAL PERMIT under
Nantucket Zoning By-law Section 139-33A (expansion/ alteration of a pre-
existing nonconforming structure/use), and to the extent necessary,
MODIFICATION of previous SPECIAL PERMIT /V ARIANCE relief granted in
the Decision in BOA File Nos. 042-85 and 080-95. In addition, to the extent
necessary, Applicant is also seeking affirmation of the waiver of the loading zone
under By-law Section 139-20, that was waived in the previous Decisions and
SPECIAL PERMIT relief under By-law Section 139-18 waiving the additional
parking spaces required for the change in use of the first floor (second level).
Applicant proposes to convert the first floor above grade of the existing mixed-
use building to retail use with the elimination of one of three rental guestrooms
and one apartment on the first floor, while maintaining the ability to maintain
two of the guestrooms for guesthouse use or add them to the one retail
establishment on the first floor. The second floor (third level) guestrooms and
apartment would remain. Similar relief was granted in the Decision in BOA File
No. 067-96, but has been deemed to have expired. The building contains one
retail establishment in the basement pursuant to relief granted in the Decision in
BOA File No. 080-95 and two apartments and five rental guestrooms pursuant to
the Decision in BOA File No. 042-85. The Locus is nonconforming as to lot size
with the lot containing about 2,650 square feet of area in a district that requires a
minimum lot size of 3,750 square feet of lot areas. The lot complies with all other
dimensional zoning requirements of the By-law.
The Premises is located at 34 CENTER STREET, Assessor's Map
42.3.1, Parcel 120, Plan Book 16, Page 34, Lot 1. The property is zoned
Residential-Commercial-Downtown.
2. The Board's decision is based upon the application and materials
submitted with it, plans, and representations and testimony received at the
hearing on March 10, 2006. No letters from abutters were received and no one
appeared in opposition to the application at the hearing. The Planning Board
made no recommendation on the application as there were no matters of
planning concern.
3. Applicant, through counsel, represented that the building on the
Premises, has been the subject of prior relief granted by the Zoning Board of
Appeals in the Decisions in File Nos. 067-96,080-95,042-85, and 030-83. The
structure has three levels: the first level (basement floor), the second level (first
floor above grade), and the third level (second floor above grade). The current
uses of the building, allowed pursuant to said Decisions, are retail space in the
first level, with a total area not to exceed 700 square feet; one apartment and two
guestrooms on the second level; and one apartment and three guestrooms on the
third level, which apartments and guest rooms have been operated as part of
"The Grey Lady" guesthouse use. In BOA File No. 067-96, the Board permitted
the then owner of the building to convert the second level to retail space, with
the ability to include or exclude the two guest rooms from the retail space
without further relief from the Board. After receiving the relief in BOA File No.
067-96, the Building Department took the position that, notwithstanding
conversion of the second level apartment to retail space, since no application to
change the use had been filed with that department, the zoning relief granted in
BOA File No. 067-96 has lapsed. The then owner of the building learned that in
order to receive a building permit for change of use of the second floor to retail
space, the owner would be required to install a lift to make the first level and
second level handicapped accessible, and the owner decided not to proceed with
that work and the second level was voluntarily converted back to the apartment
and guest room use and the relief is now said to have expired.
4. Applicant seeks to re-issue the 1996 relief exactly as previously
requested and granted. Applicant intends to apply for the required change of
use permit with the Building Department, and plans to immediately begin the
work to install the handicap lift and make other improvements that would result
in the first level and new second level retail uses of the building being
handicapped accessible. No other change as to the third level uses is
contemplated. Applicant presented a first floor plan of the building, drawn by
Burnham Engineering, dated March 7, 2006, a reduced copy of which is attached
hereto as Exhibit A, and a copy of a site plan of the Premises prepared by
Blackwell and Associates, Surveyors, dated February 8, 2006, a reduced copy of
which is attached hereto as Exhibit B. The resulting uses in the building would be
two (2) separate retail uses, and one (1) apartment and three (3) guest rooms on
the third level, with the ability to convert the two (2) second level guest rooms to
retail and back without further relief from this Board.
5. According to the Applicant, the current uses of the building require
nine (9) parking spaces and one (1) off-street loading facility, all of which have
been waived by the Board in the prior relief. The proposed uses would require a
total of thirteen (13) parking spaces, or fifteen (15) parking spaces if the second
level guest rooms are also converted to retail space. All fifteen (15) required
parking spaces and the off-street loading facility required by the new second
level retail use were waived in the relief granted in BOA File No. 067-96 but such
relief needs to be granted anew. No spaces can practically be provided on site
and a waiver would be in harmony with similar relief granted for this property
and in the surrounding commercial area.
6. Therefore, for the same reasons set forth in the Board's prior
Decisions, specifically that the requested relief from on-site parking and loading
facility requirements in connection with the conversion of the uses on the second
level, as conditioned herein, would be in harmony with the general purposes and
intent of the By-law, and that compliance with these requirements would be
physically impossible for the Applicant to provide on site and would have a
significant and adverse effect on the scenic and historic integrity of the
neighborhood, and would not be contrary to sound traffic and safety
considerations. Furthermore, the Board finds that granting this relief would
result in the Applicant proceeding with improvements to the building that
would make its first level and second level handicapped accessible, which is a
benefit to the neighborhood. In addition, the Board finds that the change in the
use of the second level to retail use, with the ability to change the two guest
rooms to retail space and back again, would not be substantially more
detrimental to the neighborhood than the existing nonconformities and retail use
is consistent with the downtown commercial area.
7. Accordingly, subject to the condition herein set forth, by a
UNANIMOUS vote, the Board hereby GRANTS a MODIFICATION of SPECIAL
PERMIT relief (a) to waive the additional six (6) parking spaces required by
Zoning By-law Section 139-18 and the off-street loading facility required by
Section 139-20 for the conversion of the second level of the building to retail use;
(b) to alter the pre-existing nonconforming structure/use as proposed; and (c) to
modify the Special Permits granted to the extent necessary in the prior Decisions
of this Board in BOA File Nos. 080-95, 042-85, and 030-83, on the following
conditions:
(a) There will be no more than two (2) separate tenants for the
retail spaces in the building as a whole, being limited to one (1) retail tenant on
the first level and one (1) retail tenant on the second level;
(b) The two (2) guest rooms situated in the rear of the second
level may, if not incorporated into the new single retail establishment on the
second level, continue to be used as rental guest rooms, and either or both may
revert to guest rooms at any time when they are not being used as part of the
retail establishment on the second level; and
(c) There shall be no exterior construction in connection with
the project permitted by this relief between June 15th and September 15th of any
gIVen year.
8. In separate action, the Board of Appeals, by a UNANIMOUS vote,
waived site plan review as required under Nantucket Zoning By- aw Section 139-
23.
Dated: April 7 , 2006
r
'"D
h
cD
o
o:l
tl.O
oed>=:
oIJ'a 0
.~ 0 >
,.oN 2
.~ 0-
..c:-<-' 0-
~ J;; <C
Ig
oIJ-<-'
Ql>=:
QlcD
I-lZ
oIJ
CI.l
I-l
Ql
oIJ
m
u
~
('I")
;=-
o
u
E".-
W
Z
o
Z
W
o
Ui
Z
3c
.0
Zf-
oz
>=3c
<to
'='0
LL
~~
:56'
uw
",2
Z2
_0
ZU
8;i
f->=
zZ
wW
",0
~(f)
U~
~ 'Wl;'
u)tZlf)~
o tf)
oLf)Z ..f'--
",n "'
". L:5
r<) ..0::::
'"
W~~~ ..
~~trC3~
f-6Ult;j[;j
On::OVl>
-.Jl.J....0::: 0
<twU
2:i>-9
~~Z~~~
__ o::=>
ZZ0L:50
~~e=lY~
o
w
z
CJ
(j)
W
f--
<C
o
VJ
>--.:1
~
& vj
~~ ~
C;:s""~~
q Q, "" h' Sl
Q:;k1j~~
~ho..c..;,2(
O(;:)O::::'<..i
i:q h g:
c..':J ~
~ ~
~
o
Gl
<0
""
""
""
""-'
t3
~
~
~
~
'--.:i
~
"i-
S2 ~
~ q~
~"C3ac.o
~ .~ Q:; . a
2S ~h~ ~
c..s"<lk1~ I
~tlVJ~ co
~~Q:; ~
.;l k1 h'
~ i;l ~ r__ -...
~a~ co
~i:VJ0a
S2o.. -::::, ~
S co~
Q:j ~
'-:>
>-...::i
>-...::i
""
~
r;...., ~
~ ~
~ ~
V) "i
~
~ '"
~ ;;j
t;~
~
~ ~
C>J Vj
'"
Ql
...-l
"" ell
I t)
..... tIl
Ii
o
~oIJ
.;,;; oIJ
'" 0
u ~
VJ
~'
>-...::i
~
~
~
~
c:....;
o
z
W
-.l
c;::
'a
-
~
IE]
~
I~
~
IE] :z
S
D-
o:
0
0
...J
LL
~
u:
Cl
w
Vl
~
0
0:
D-
alE]
al~
OJ
C)
'0
I
Q:j
t;
fg
'"
~
II ~
t3 ~
lJ '"
~ 2
\€ "
s: :.<f
~ ~
'WINS ClJSSlflmlOl: ReD r
M~. AREA: . . ,{;7~Q. '?'.0. . .
MIN, FROijTAGE: . .~:[ rr.. . . .
FRONT YARD S.8.: , .0.' .FT.. . . .
5'~ 0'
REAR & SIOf S.B.: . . . , . . . .
GROUND COVER (%): . 7~ .r., . .
EXlSJ1N.G:
. .~~~C? !5:F
. fJff .P.0.N
II If
I
~
5TR~E\
. . . . . . . .
/I II
: : j~ 7.>
CENIE R
511)EW'AU(
~
i.J.J
lJJ
Q:'
Z srot:.y 5TRI./CTURF:
<t.:34 CENTER 5TR.EIT
'PlANTI N 65
31
~
".
"
STEP
)r).3.1- J:LJ
nJp
'rIARN"E-R :J6ftN D TR.
~
4.t
If)
If)
o
~
CoNe. .
'PAD
~ ?ROPMJE TA IJKS
117-5.) - 161
nlF
!VOR.HAN I CARL
-+-PtCl(ET FENCE
BRICK 'WALK
-i-
01.,
=E.
z"""
I.P.
PH!)' ,
,1, --
f?"
~.
!.p.
36. :~,tr: ;t
JJ'J.S. ) -/)'?J
nJp
J)AVID P. \.!j.{ITF:
TO: . I:/A.J..J.T.LJ.CKE;T.1:YY{/{JA P~V!3.IP1!. . . .
.OF. . ?9'{~1;'1.G;l-.( . , . . . . . AND NO OTHERS.
I CERTIFY. TO THE BEST OF ijy KOOWI.EIlGE. lHAT THE
PREMISES SHOWN ARE LOOO'ED ~ FlOOD ftAZNW ZONE:
. . .l; . , . DEUNEAlED ON F.I.RM. I c:ouwwrrf mn
NUMBER: 250230-00 . .1 J . . . D, iN THf FEllERAl
EMERGalCY I.tANAGEMEWT AGENCY. EfFEClM: DAlE Of
MAPS: JUNE 3, 1986 >>ID AS PERiIOOlC'AllY RE\4SEO.
THIS iNSPECTION PLAN WAS PREPARED FOR UOR'fGAGE PUIlPOSES
ONlY mo is NOT 1'0 BE CONSlOOlED A f'lIlL ~ SURVEY.
TfIlS PLAN SHOULD N()!f B~ USED TOmABUSH PmPER'IY!JNES.
FENCES, HEDGES OR mf AN:cIll.AA'f ~ o.l M PAElIl5Es.
THE PROPERTY LINES SHOWN RELY ON CURRENT DEEDS AND PlA)IS
OF RECORD.
THIS INSPECTION PLAN IS NOT A CERTIFJC.IJION AS TO THE TIlli OR
O~SHlP OF THE PRQPER'IY SHOWN. owt.IlRS Of ~N.G PROPfRTlES
ARE SHOWN ACCORDING roClJRRDlIT ~ Of NANruCICET ~
RECORDS.
THIS PLAN SHA/.l NOT BE USED FOR AHf OTHER' PURPOSE OlHER ~
ITS INTENDED USE STATED ABCM..
~~
~~~
m
~Il~
SCALE: 1"= 10' DATE: FEB.S, 200<;'
Owner: .'. ~~~~~'.~ .~. 0~LP'N.E.( . . . . . .
("'") ,
r
rtl
::;::1.'
"~~'
. . . . " . . . . . , . . . . . . . io r' t' . . . ,
DeedjCert.: ~1~..2~~ ~,pz Plan: ~~_!G. fq.~. .
Tax M<lp: ~'?.3..I,-J40 Locus:It;31~C;i{r.E!e.~r;. . ,
BLACIaELL d: ASSrJCbt1ES, I'AC.
Pfio.~ I~ ~
20 TeasdBJe Circle
~t ~ 026U
(SfJIJ) ZZ8-9DZ8 B- G 701
BlockweU " Asaocialea Inc.
lOOT TO BE RECORDED I
FBK.:
g .::tJ
==-
;g
I
-.J
-0
V.J
Ut
---
TOWN OF NANTUCKET
ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS
1 EAST CHESTNUT STREET
NANTUCKET, MASSACHUSETTS 02554
PHONE 508-228-7215
FAX 508-228-7205
NOTICE
A Public Hearing of the NANTUCKET ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS will
be held at 12:00 P.M.. FRIDAY, MARH 10,2006, IN THE CONFERENCE ROOM,
TOWN ANNEX BUILDING, 37 Washington Street, Nantucket, Massachusetts, on the
Application of the following:
ROSALIE T. MALONEY, OWNER AND FOR JAMIE GRIES, CONTRACT
PURCHASER
BOARD OF APPEALS FILE NO. 021-06
Applicant (Gries) is seeking relief by SPECIAL PERMIT under Nantucket
Zoning By-law Section 139-33A (expansion/alteration of a pre-existing nonconforming
structure/use), and to the extent necessary, MODIFICATION of previous SPECIAL
PERMITN ARIANCE relief granted in the Decision in BOA File Nos. 042-85 and 080-
95. In addition, to the extent necessary, Applicant is also seeking affumation of the
waiver of the loading zone under By-law Section 139-20, that was waived in the previous
Decisions and SPECIAL PERMIT relief under By-law Section 139-18 waiving the
additional parking spaces required for the change in use of the first floor (second level).
Applicant proposes to convert the first floor above grade of the existing mixed-use
building to retail use with the elimination of one of three rental guestrooms and one
apartment on the fIrst floor, while maintaining the ability to maintain two of the
guestrooms for guesthouse use or add them to the one retail establishment on the first
floor. The second floor (third level) guestrooms and apartment would remain. Similar
reliefwas granted in the Decision in BOA File No. 067-96, but has been deemed to have
expired. The building contains one retail establishment in the basement pursuant to relief
granted in the Decision in BOA File No. 080-95 and two apartments and fIve rental
guestrooms pursuant to the Decision in BOA File No. 042-85. The Locus is
nonconforming as to lot size with the lot containing about 2,650 square feet of area in a
district that requires a minimum lot size of3,750 square feet oflot areas. The lot
complies with all other dimensional zoning requirements of the By-law.
The Premises is located at 34 CENTER STREET, Assessor's Map 42.3.1, Parcel
120, Plan Book 16, Page 34, Lot 1. The pro rty is zoned ~~i~ential-Co~ercial-
Downtown. llCW~
Dale aine, Chairman
THIS NOTICE IS AVAILABLE IN LARGE PRINT OR OTHER
ALTERNATIVE FORMATS. PLEASE CALL 508-228-7215 FOR
FURTHER INFORMATION.
NANTUCKET ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS
1 EAST CHESTNUT STREET
NANTUCKET, MA 02554
CASE NO. 0 7J ,-()CQ
FEE: $300.00
APPLICATION FOR RELIEF
Owner's name(s): Rosalie T. Maloney
Mailing address: 2430 Tracy Place, Washington, DC 20008
Applicant's name(s):Jamie Gries \ Q; ~'
Mailing address: P.O. Box 3515, Nantucket, MA 02554
Locus address:
34 Centre Street
Assessor's Map 42.3.1, Parcel 120
/Plan Book & Page: Book 12-, Page ~ Lot: 1
Date lot acquired: 5/9/1988 Deed Ref: Deed Book 298 , Page 272 Zoning District: RCDT
Uses on Lot - Commercial: None_ Yes: guest house apartments and rooms with basement retail
Residential: Number of dwellings_ Duplex_ Apartments-1-Rental Rooms 5
Building Date(s): All pre-date 7/72? building pre-dates zoning C ofO(s)? yes
Building Permit No: 3482-8
Previous ZBA Ap Nos.: 22-83 denied' 04 -85 SP for 2 a ts' 5 uest rooms' 080-9 V to bless lot and SP for
basement retail);061-96 (first floor retail, deemed expired); 12{98 (denied)
State below or on a separate addendum specific relief sought (Special Permit, Variance, Appeal), Section of
the Zoning By-law, and supporting details, grounds for grant of relief, listing any existing nonconformities:
See Attached Addendum
I certify that the information contained herein is substantially complete and true to the best of my
knowledge, under the pains and penalties of perjury.
Jamie Gries, by her attorney Emily A very
SIGNATURE: Applicant X Attorney/Agent X
(If not owner r owner's tt rne please enclose proof of agency to bring this matter befor~ the Board)
U:J /'... FOR~~AOFFICEUSE. /'
Application received on~~ _ By: I{/ LA../) Complctc:~Need copies?: . \
Filed with Town Clerk:~A2QPlanning Boa~ Building Dept.:_I_/ ~:~
Fee deposited with Town Treasurer: 80+ Oa! By:~ Waiver requested?:_Granted:_I_I_
Hearing notice posted with Town ClerkrW2~ctQMailed: ~-1sfrg I&M:~3112& ~/ 2--1 qp
Hearing(s) held on:_/_/_ Opened on:_/_/_ Continued to:_/_I_ Withdrawn?:_/_I_
DECISION DUE BY:_/_I_ Made:_I_I_ Filed wffown Clerk:_I_/_
Mailed: / /
DECISION APPEALED?: 1 1
SUPERIOR COURT:
LAND COURT
Form 4/03/03
ADDENDUM TO APPLICATION
34 Centre Street
A I. d'f' . f" S ~ V\.QWI P :v .(j)'~B'
pp Icant requests mo I lCatIon 0 eXIstmg pecIa ermIts pursuant to Bf1aw
Section 139-33A to allow the conversion of the first floor of the premises from a one
bedroom apartment and one guest room to a single retail space, with the ability to add
the other two guest rooms on the first floor to the same retail space, and a waiver of the
parking spaces and any loading zone that would be required in connection with that
use pursuant to By-law Sections 139-18B and 139-20C. Applicant's requested relief was
previously granted by the Board of Appeals in 1997 but has been deemed to be expired
because it was not exercised within two years of the grant.
The premises at 34 Centre Street are known as "The Grey Lady" guest house.
Prior to the adoption of zoning, the building was used as three apartments. The current
uses in the building are two one-bedroom rental apartments and five guest rooms
(pursuant to BOA File No. 042-85) and a single retail tenant with 700 square feet of
gross floor area in the basement (pursuant to BOA File No. 080-95). The lot contains
approximately 2,650 square feet of area, which nonconformity has been blessed by
variance relief granted in File No. 080-95. The lot has frontage on Centre Street and
Hussey Street, and is conforming as to setbacks and ground cover in the Residential
Commercial Downtown District. No on-site parking is provided, with the thirteen
parking spaces required by the current uses grandfathered or waived by the Board.
~ In 1997, the Board of Appeals granted a modification of the existing special
ermits to waive parking and loading requirements so as to permit the conversion of
(j /' the first floor apartment and one of the guest rooms to a single retail tenant with the
ability to convert either or both of the other two guest rooms on the first floor to the
same retail space (BOA File No. 067-96, copy attached). The owner in fact converted the
first floor to retail use after the relief became final, but unfortunately did not apply for a
change of use permit at the Nantucket Building Department within two years of the
issuance of the relief. Therefore, the relief was deemed to be expired.
The elimination of up to four bedrooms and the conversion of those rooms to
retail space, plus one space for three employees at peak shift, triggers the requirement
of up to four additional parking spaces, which in addition to the three spaces originally
grandfathered and ten spaces waived in prior decisions, results in a total of seventeen
required spaces to be waived.
;W~bNING CLASSIfiCATION! . 1;Z.-,~
;. . , 5 000 :::.f'"
~'.A. R.E..A. , '.' . ,', l.i' 'n' ,
..FR.oNTAGE: , , 'N~' . ,
,NT ..YA.RD . $.B.: . , '~fr . ,
13 & S[DE S. B. : '~A ' .
fl.OUND'CQVER (Yo): , , , , ~ . .
EXISTING:
2,650 !6F
~ ' 'pLMf
:: >i:::::
"
: : :5.4 %:.~::
N
c.
~!!
C:ENiE R
5TP-~E.\
./" AS Pj..{ALT ,sIDEWALK ./
Z STOl?Y'STRl./qURf:.
1t::A C EJ..JTER5TREIT
~-
~
)n,S,I- I:LJ
nJp
'r/AF-N"E.-R. JoHN D TR. .
)...
CoNe. '
"Pr\D
4.t
lr)
V)
:)
~
, i
ti.7'i
!
DE.ek;,
,~I
'::t-
i'Y
/'0...'
i'.
4J.S.} - 16J
nlF
IY07<,HAN I CARL
-~J~:.
I,P,
F",.Jl). .... _ _
:fI 36.:z.J..r::J:
"""
IF. OJ nip
WHIJt.!... ! DAVID P.
,
.... :'~'.~"\ i'( '~\ '::j! ~~~ ~..~\
IF Ii ~i) V l!;..::>,~J
t~~",.~d'~ .;::~T LU:t[t::'~3 L=;'-'~~.
} CERTIFY, AS OF: . , ~.-.Z;~~,?~. . THAT
THE BUILDING(SI IS/ARE LOCATED ON THE
GROUNO ~ SH~i,:b:OJ
PRO ~sI6NAL LAND SURVEYOR
Bur DING LOCATION PLAN
OF lAND IN
NANIVCKlEl, MASS.
THIS PLOT PLAN WAS PREPARED FOR THE TOWN
OF NANTUCKET BUILDING DEPARTMENT ONLY AND
SHOULD' NOT BE CONSIDERED A PROPERTY LINE
SURVEY. THIS PLAN SHOULD NOT BE USED TO
EST ABLISH PROPERTY LINES. FENCES. HEDGES OR
ANY ANCILLARY STRUCTURES ON THE PREMISES.
THE PROPERTY LINES. SHOWN RELY ON CUR>lENT _ .
. "', DEEDS AND PLANS OF RECORD.
. THIS PLOT PLAN IS NOT A CERTIFICATION AS TO
TmE OR OWNERSHIP OF THE PROPERTY SHOWN.
OWNERS OF ADJOINING PROPERTIES ARE SHOWN
ACCORDING TO CURRENT ASSES OR RECORDS.
ASSESSOR MAP:4~:~,,1. PARCEL: .18-9.
SCALE: ,", 10' DATE: :rver J.D J ;c:/)6
Owner: , . !?~?f..~~~ . r:. M 4'-:-9^".1f,( , , . . .
LoT 1
Deed: ~~.~?~ ,'ffj',Z!l:, Plan: l3cp/<,/~.?G:M. ,.
loella: :/I.~l{ . ~!I;'-~. . ;:?~E;-l7- T. . . .
BLAG:KMELL'-&: ASSOCIA rES, Ino.
e YOUNGS WAY
NANTUCKET, MASS. 02554
(508) 228~ 9026
NOT TO BE RECORDED, B-l+b;z..3.
C,\J06S\HB\&L.P
Town of Nantucket
\ Property ID 42.3.1 120
location 34 CENTER ST
~.... ,.-
Ii
, . _1\- .' .. ~'"?BCiJS .~w.<; -zalN,g'? . ' \;: :'
~~., . '.' '.' '14+ffi . ~~~
, ___~____~,-______,,::L,~~l
r--:,,_n'_'_~--c----~-:l_jj'" ~ . --r l
I .... '.. q,U @ .' .' '. ~,I' 34 CENTRE STREET
I. <3 . r ....@ lr-J First Floor
.1. . 0 ~. .' . " '~..[ .~~. Proposed Floor Plan
! ~. l; ,~ \~~:'l E:~~s:P::=~~ and
. L=::--=='--l '. ~i3~..~,~~~ /: ':.' .... .
J.::>'=-S- '. . , ---"r.===-:r --'-"'-l
r-(,::;;)//' . .' '. . ." ,. ':
,J LJ ..', .....j
if .~ $' . ':1'0"1 ..' '.~ : CD.' .:." . ..J
., .'. . 11 ' '.. ci' 0, I
'.. . .' i . . . .It:... >.:'.~': . " ..... . >1.
\'::h . t1~"'J .:. .' ,: '. . ~ . .' '.. '. ~.~-_.._.__...- - n
<:~?>:.~ . . . '. '. <-. . . '.'. . ..> -< .'. '. ..:~ .; . .,':':. :'~:-~'~""'~~j.
"~-r( vlS7. . . ...... I,..
'>-1 'rr"':JI:t~/ ,. .... . "l'~~- L-i "~=: ~I
.' ODl :..-l J. .:, .;O.l"~' '., 0:' ....:. II
"/' ':........ ~:.. :'''':. "';'i',< .':;':-.' ....'l
~'.' . ..0" ;':. ,'.:; .li\'::~I:' ":.:: ../.~ ;r..){ :. c=j.... .
-- . :'." ',',':. : :.,' .\::);~:s . ,.....;.. .:' . '~,'" .: ". .'\.'
II '.~:.'..' ~ ''';~'./:<;-:',' "'""::', ,.~", ::.~":':.. -" :'.. . " . " ct. ' '-'~It
I L \' . . :' . Uti , 'I~ ;,)fi;:;"i:i~. .><~, ",;..: 1~:":. ~... y
! i U . -7'-"~' ~;'~:2itff1.! \: :...~:Jr>.;. ...... () .... : j
I, : ',;. +~~~ZJ '..'.... Lh.l d'" . 'f'
,Ii.,.... ."m~~r~..' ; , :', ;,\ . . 'jfr
I to'l. .... ")'-'~~f.;j:"_":~ >::-,:.. '. . 0. _.' :.-~,.. . I"
a\ - -'~-". '. '. . . r-\ . '(!""'. -/
W '-.. '.m.--t . (
I ' i;'/' .':' . . L.l.J'-.J . . ,
, ~;,'" rz;......@~. i
, ~!". .\0 I
! f .. i
;f '. ~--' !
. i\ . .~.: . . j.
~::::::-.:::..... .' :" [iJ . ~I" I
. ...._....f. :"7J~. 7--- ~
. '. \./ ~.' "~,~:,":"" j '.--=::'._..~.. ~.- . ~:::'::::'_-~'-':'':':~':'':'::.:...:~.1
1-..':,/
If) IJ .
. ~~
..
.' . . o. .._. ,.','
--- ------_.__._-..~_._-----_..._. .......-..
f' "I
~ e~~ 526PAG~314
NJUITUCKET ZONING BOAlW OP APPEALS
37 Washington Street
Nantucket, Mas"sachusee'ts 02554
34 Center Street
Assessor's Map 42.3.1, Parcel 120
Residenti~l-Commercial
Deed Book 298, Page ~72
Lot 1
Plan Book 16, Page 34
DECISION: .
,
I.
. 1. At a public hearing of the Nantucket Zoning Board of
'Appeals, on Friday, December 6, 1996, at 1:00 P.M., in the
Selectmen's Meeting Room; in the Town and County Building, Broad
Street, .Nantucket, Massachusetts, the Board made the following
decisiOn on the application of. ROSALIE T. MALONEY, c/o Reade &:
Alger Professional Corporation, Post Office Box 2669, Nantucket,
Massachusetts 02584, File No. 067-96: .
,
~
(
\
2. The Applicant is 'seeking a SPECIAL PERMIT under
Nantucket Zoning By-Iaw.U39-18.B(3) (Parking Requirements) 'and
5139-20.C (Loading Zone Requirements). .The Applicant proposes to
convert the first floor of~ the existing building upon the s'ubject
property to retail use with the elimi!1atiOn of the existing four
(4) lodging rooms on the first floor. Parking for the existing
uses upon .the subject property requires thirteen (13) spaces, all
of which have. been previously waived by the granting of zoning
relief. The parking requirement for the proposed uses would be
fifteen (15) spaces. No ..,parking' spaces nor loading zone have
been provided and none are planned. The subject property (the
"Locus") is situated at 34 CENTER STREET, Assessor's Map 42.3.1,
Parcel 120, and is shown upon plan recorded in Plan Book 16, Page
34, as Lot 1. The subject property is situated in a Residential-
Commercial zoning district.
i
I
1
.
f
I
1
\
3: Our decision is. based . upon the application and
accompanying . materials, and representations and testimony
recei ved at our public hearing. The Planning Board
recommendation was favorable as to both parking and loading space
relief. Except for one let.ter expressing no opposition to the
Applicant's project, but stating dismay at the reduction of
lodging rooms in the neighborhood, there was nO support from
others than the Applicant's representatives, and no opposition,
presented at the public hearing.
4. The building upon the Locus, which ha~ been the subject
of prior relief granted by this Board of Appeals in. Cases Nos.
042~8S and 080-96, has three levels: the lower floor or basement,
the f.irat or main floor, and the second or top floor. To. avoid
confusion, this decision shall refer to these floors as the first
level, the second level, and the third level, respectively. The
Applicant proposes to convert the second level, now containing
fou'r lodging units into retail use, eliminating these lodging
rooms. The Applicant requests a Special Permit under By-law
59139-18.B(3) and '139-20.C, for. the waiver of all off-street
parking and loading spaces in connection with this change of use.
i
I
i
~
~
,
I
!
i
,
t.~.
. ,
~~,- ....-
ew
526 p^G~:]15
The parking requirement for the. existing. uses upon the Locus is
tl:1irteen spaces ,all of wl:1icl:1 have been previously. waived by
relief granted by the Board of Appeals .in Cases Nos.. 042-85 and
080-96. As presented by the Applidint, the total parking
requirement for the uses which would exist upon the Locus if all
of the requested' relief were granted would be fifteen spaces.
The Applicant states that no off-street. parking spaces nor
loading facilities have been provided, nor is it physically
possible to provide any. The proposed use as retail space is a
p.ermitted use in this district.
5. For the same reasons set forth in the Board I s prior
decisions relating to the Locus, specifically that the requested
relief from on-site parking and loading space requirements in
connection ~ith the conversion of 'uses upon the second level, as
conditioned herein, would be in harmony with the general purpose
and inten.t of the By-law,. and that complianc~ with' .these
requirements would be physically impossibl~ for the Applicant to
provide and would have' a significant and' adverse effect on the
scenic and historic in.tegrity of the nei'ghborhood, and would be
contrary to sound traffic and safety considerations'.
Acc.ordingly,. su:Qject to the condition herein set forth, the Boa.rd
voted UNANIMOUSLY to. grant the relief herein requested, waiving
all parking and .loi;lding" requirements' for the Locus' in conne'ction'
.with the conversion of the second level of the existing building
to retail' use.
6. The relief hereby granted is conditioned upon there' not
being mor'e than one retail establishment upon' the second lev.el of
the building (there being already one retail establishment on 'the
first level pursuant to Board of Appeals Decision No. '80-96..)..
The two rental units' situated upon the rear of the second level
may, if not incorporated into the single retail establishment on
the second level, continue to be used as rental units, and either
or both may revert to lodging house units as now used at 'any time
when -they are not being used as part t e .single retail'
establishment'on the second level.
Dated: tl<:c'-".:k..~, 199~7
.:::0-1'\ <XVC ~
70"", RaCEIVED .
N..~,..~. ClER:{'S OFFICE
I)r:''-'.~T: 1.''\ 02554
. JAN 06 1997
I "..e.' 3: V.s {) L
----~
CI.F:"lI(: If.. oiL . .
;:<~~!/:;;frr-
I cERnf,;',itI;po'~yS H'A\(Ii'E~PSEQ Arm Th( n:GI~!S:',
\,lfS:RtiO)N M.O~iICi:Oli,TnE tOW~CL(til;. t.' '~l ii;,;
NO{iP~Ei\i.~af,WFI!-f,~GTtt
,,~:~?rJj.:~~ll.0L.~:~~1~_~ cwi
. .:" ..;1 '. ........,'!\ c. .jAM 28 1997
. .::...:.;~J O!.. ';;'~~\.:' ,,\.... . .
. "'I'lU.l~;'"
Mich .
vf.? ~ t1--'~ ~
William'p. Hourihan, Jr.
JAH 2 9 1997
NANTUCKET COUNTY
REC'O ENTERED
q; O~l\<<\
SANDRA M CHADWICK
mEST REGISTER
2
--.:-
End of
Instrument
-......
~. .-....
. ....'............---.---.-'"'-">-..,---....
I
,
: '
I
!
I
I
i
,
I
I
t ~
..
'2
,
'0'
!
,
.t
I!
Ii
Ii
i.
,
,
i
i
l
; ~
l
i
J
J.
j
i
1
! .
i
,
I
!
I
I
~
L1
Ii .-' 0
*/7,0
./
RECEIVED
BOARD. OF ASSESSORS
Town of Nantucket
JAN 3 b Z006
TOWN OF
NANTUCKET, MA
ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS
LIST OF PARTIES IN INTEREST IN THE MATTER OF THE PETITION OF
PROPEI3-TY OWNER.. .:RP:~J~e..T.. ..!i0\Q~................ ..............
MA I UN G ADDRESS.. ~.~.. T~<;:.o-.. f \9,.~'J' .u)Mh~~.4-... .~.~o8
PROPERTY LOCATION.. dY... .~k. ~{'l' ..A!~kkt-........
ASSESSO RS MAP/PARCEL..... /IJ 3.1./L9?9....................................
A PPL I C A NT.... .~le.-. .~~1h. .Grl~)' .'~k.-\-:.. f~........
1- : t-6:Q. eu,:
- 0 rMLBAlCK AND AVERY LLP
P.O. BOX 148
ZERO MAIN STREET, 2ND FLOOR
SEE ATTACHED PAGES NANTUCKET MA 02554
I cer1ify that the foregoing is a list of persons who are owners of abutting property, owners of
land directly opposite on any public or private street.or way; and abutters of the abutters and all
other land owners within 300 feet of the property line of owner's property, all as they appear on
the most recent applicable tax list (M.G.L. c. 40A, Section 11 Zoning Code Chapter 139.
Section 139-29D (2)
~d<..~...~~r;
/), -. a 1/0_ ')
~.......:.~
DATE
ASSESSOR'S OFFICE
Town of Nantucket
t!>
Z
~;!
rn
H -
...:IE-!
IZl
rnl<:
P:U
1Zll:l
~~
III
<
~
o
~ ~ ~ ~ ~
~ ~ E-4 8 E-t fIl fIl tIl t1l
j ~~~~~~~~;
~ ~~~~~~8~~
ItS <Dl.DLtlM ort
111 'ot' "l$t M M U"l M r-4 N l'i
.. .. .. ..
CIJ tI) OJ CIJ
~ ~ lii tl
51 B ~ Il;
H~Sl8
CD '"
... ...
E-t E-t E-t E-t E-t E-t E-t ~ E-t E-t
E-t tIl E-t tI) 00 00 00 E-t E-t E-t E-t tIl tIl fIl tIl
tIl tI) tIl tIl tIl tIl = E-t E-t E-t E-t E-t
~ ~ ~ I ~ I I ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ a a a ~ ; g g ~ ~
~ tl ~ u tl u u Sl ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ '" z z .. ~
~ ~ U Q ~ 00, = ~ H H Sl Sl
. . N 0 0 0 0 ~ ~ ~ M l.D l.D Q) l.D ~
U"l N . . 'ot' 'ot' ~ . ~ ~ M ~ M . N M M ~ ~ M M ~ N
. 0 rt rt m ~ . . M . 0 l.D Q)
U"l rt U"l N N U"l U"l U"l 0 U"l . Q) N
Q; U'lO'l:l"OOU"lIllU'lOU'lcortO
...4 NO'\r--OONNNNNIDNO
N o....ortl""'lOOONOOOri
CD
'"
'"
M
,
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
M M N ~ U"l U"l III Ltl Lt'I ~ III III ~ U"l U"l rt U"l U"l U"l U"I Ltl U"I
\0 N M M N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N
Q) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
.. ..
'" tIl
e I ; :
~ u ~ ~
'" '"
M ('it 0\ r--
111
...
M
~ "
M . rt . ~ 0\ . rt r-- H .
M U"l N U"I III U"l U"l rt N N U"l
~ ~ ~ ~ g g ~ g ~ a ~
...
III
tJl
<U
P<
..
tIl .. ..
tIl tIl
a ~ ~ 5
Q IlII IlII
~ = e t1
0: ~
... ... '"
... ... ...
.. .. ..
tIl III III
~ ~ ~
~ ~ ~
'" 111 M
... ... ...
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ t ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
8 ~ I ~ ~ B 8 8 ~ B I
g ~~~ii~~~I~~
N
..
..
..
"
'tl
'tl
~
tl1
~
....
...
-0<
'"
:0:
~
..
tJl ~
~ g
::l ~ ~
.. u 0
"
'tl 0
'tl to 0
~ .......
..
'"
IlII
.. 0:
III ..
tJl ..
e ~ tJl
.... '" '"
'" to
'" ..
tJl ..
~ r:J ~
'" '"
to
o III '"
Po ... ...
u
,..,
,..,
o ..
U tJl
9
Il;
.,
I
"
~
lii I I
!i1 ~ u
~ ~ =
~ IlII e
!il ~ ~
.. H '"
'" H
~ ill is
000
............ ......
u u u
o
u
[;!
H
..
~
U H U
.., ..,
.., IlII ..,
rr! ~ t1
~ ~ gj ~ ~
&l ::! ':l III c>
! ~ ~~~tJl
~ ~j~~~1
j ~il~~a
..
IlII
'"
'"
..
tJl
LI
....
g
LI
o
lo.::! M N M "'" U'l
U
j
~
H
P
tJl
..,
~
..
..
tJl
..
'"
o
~
..
f4 tI) ~
~ ; ~ 8
., ~ a ~
B 0 Jk. 0'\
....
'" 0 '"
'" '" M
u
,..,
..,
..
'"
r:!
..
tJl
~
'"
&l
~
o
'"
o
......
U
t1 ;!
13 ~ g 13
.. ....
~ ~ : 51
IlII
"
Q
H ><
0: S
B Cl
~ !
; i i ; ; ; I ; ; I ;
V>
IlII
I:l
tIl
P
~
u u
j j
13 ~
H H
.. ..
H H
tJl III
88
!:Hi
~ ~
.. ..
tJl III
I I
~
H
U
I ; I I Ii; I ; ; I I I i
~
~
~ ~ ~ I
51 ~ ~ ~
..
IlII
IlII
~
tJl
I
Il;
; ~ ~
~ Po CD
M
o '" '"
Po ... ...
..
tJl
~ ~
~ :
~ 0
'"
o
M 0
M Po
.. ..
~ ~ t; ~ ~
~ = ; ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~'W~ ~
m m ~ 0 0 M m
Z ~ ~ M N " M ~ ~ M
H H H ~
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ H51 B ~ ~ ~
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 0 " ~
'"
~ 0 0 0 0 0 0 ~" ~ 0
M ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ " M N " ~
III
.., '"
.., '" H
~ ~ lil
!l! ~ 0
o ~ Po
H ~
lil '"
o 0
.. ..
..
~ .. ~
..
~ a ~
~ III ~ t;
!:! ~ '"
H ...
~ ~ ..
.. '"
III ...
CD
tl ...
OJ ~
~ ~
o 0
... Po M
~
u
..,
..,
~
H
0: ..
.. H
tJl
~ S
a ~
tl t;
a 0:
: ~
~ ~
u u
...
u
'"
..
..
~
..
><
~
~
tJl
IlII
:=
U
~ i5
..,
" ~
W
H ><
tJ ~ ~
~ ~ ~
~ u .. ~
j Il; IlII ..,
~ B ~ ~ ~
!il @ ::J H :0:
~~i~i8
~ ~ ~ ~
iHJQg~
..
=
0: CD
.. '"
III '"
M
'"
CD H
o
.. '"
'" 0
... Po
u
..,
..,
tJl
~
~
!il
..
tJl
'" Po
I:l ~
III
~ ~
~ ~ ~
J I ~ i i i i
H f-I H ~
IlQ H ~ p:; '" '" ~
'" 0:': w ~
0: Il; ~ : ~ ~ .., .., ..,
~ I ~(~ i ~ ~ ~ ~
> ~ H ~ ~ ~ .. '"
Il; >< ~ u 5 .., ~ Il; ~
g ~ ~ ~ ~ g ~ ~ ~
~ ~ ~ !il ~ ~ 8 8 8
rot ('of t""I M N M ..
o 0
...... ......
U U
...
... CD
'" ...
....
..
III
~ ~
..,
~ ~
15 ..
.. OJ
0:
0: ~
~ ~
..
o
...... ...
U '"
..
tJl
P
~
IlII
!l!
~
~
r:J
~
~
a
o
l:l
~ II: 8
0: ~ '"
~ ~ 8 tJl
~ ~ l:l ~
: 13 ~ g
~ ~ ~ ~
~
~
i ~ ~ ~ a ~
Po ~ 13.. ~ is ~ ~
8 ~ ~ B III IlII ~ ~
! ~~ ~ : ~ I ~ ~ ~ ~
tIl Q.. ~ S ~ ~ ~
I ~ ~ ; I I ~ i ~ i ;
~ ~ ~
tJl
~ ~ t; ~
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ g
~ ~ '" e i: ~
Po ~ i i ~ 8 B i ~ ~ i :
~ ~ !il g ~ ~ ~ ~ 1 ~ ~ ~
~ ~ ~ 0 ~ ~ ~ H ~ ~ ~ ~
!l! ~ ~ e ~ ~ ~ 9 ~ g ~
i!!hdsa51 ~
'"
li1
is
~
~
..
..
'"
..
~
H
U
~
!il
o
"
U
~ ~
.. ~
OJ
a ~
~ ~
~ ~
111
'" '"
... '"
1: ~
H ..
~ ~ Ik1
; ~ ~
tJl S ><
... ~ ~
...
.... '" 0
Mill'"
~
~
~
:0:
...
o
... ...
... '"
tJl tJl
~ j ~
~ ~ ~
!l! !l!
.... 0 0
o
u
.. ..
~ ~ :=
U u ~ tJl ~
; ; a: ~
H H J4 ~ rn
~ ~ ~ ~ ~
; 0: ~ ~ ~
~ ~ ~ ~ a
................0........
u u t:Q U
o
......
u
tIl
o
~
III
...,
~
co
....
o
...
'"
NLIll.Dt'CDC7\MNI"')...U1"".....COC7\Or1 0
..... co ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ : : : : : ~ : ~ : : : ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
'-
...
p ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ M M M n M M M M M M M M M
::I ~~~~~~~~~::~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~E6S6E56ES6S5S ~
t.!l
:z;
~;!
m
H
~E-t
r:<l
ml><:
ll::U
r:<l~
~~
~
~
o
OM E-o
.., en
..
u 0:
o ..
o-l !;
... ..
" '-'
u
.. -<
.. 0
'" M
E-o E-o E-o
E-i 00 CI1 tI)
en
0: 0: 0:
~ Ck1 Ck1 Ck1
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
H '-' '-' '-' Ii! Ii!
H H
E-o
~ ~ t ~ ~ ~ CI1 ~ ~ ~ ~ t t ~ ~ ~ E-i
~ ~ ~ ; ; ~ a ; ; ; ~ ~ ~ ; ; ; ;
~ m m ~ ~ m ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ B ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
E-o E-o E-o E-o E-o E-o E-o E-o E-o
00 00 CI1 CI1 00 00 00 00 00
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
~ Ii! e = = gJ gJ e Ii!
~ H ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ H
MOM"'" 0 M 0 ~ ~ N'N m 0 N "'" ~ 0 ~ M ~ ~
"'" N N ~ m ~ ~ N N M M M N N M N M N N N M ~ N N N N
co
..
..
~
~ .... N ..,. ~ ~ "'" ~ M "'" .. ~ ..,. rot 0 0 0 M ..,. . ..,. N
~ ~ N ~ ~ 0 ~ 0 0 ~ ~ ~ ~ . ... M N N ~ ~ ~ rot
~ ~ 0 ~ ~ M ~ N ~ ~ ~ M ~ ..,. ~ M m 0 ~ ~ ~ M
N NON NON ~ M N N N N ~ m N ~ ~ N N N ..,.
o 0 MOO M 0 N MOO 0 0 ~ 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 M
"'" .. ..,. ~ ~ ..,. N ~ ~ "'" ... "'" 0 ..,.
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ M ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ M ~
Po U')U')U).....""U'l\D"".U"IUlUl\DUl
.... NNNNNN\ONNNNNNN
N 00000000000000
"'" ..,. .... 0\ 0'1 ... ... 0\
ItI III U') III U'l 111 U) 111
U'1 III U'l ..,. .... III U'l 'If
N N N N N N N N
o 0 0 0 0 000
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ t ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 6 ~ ~ t ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
.. ..
.. o-l o-l
. UL8p.mWU~U~Hludq!
~ i i i ~ ~ i a ~ ~ i i i ~ i ! i i i i i ~ i I 0: i i ~ a ~ ~ ~
..
..
"
..
'tl
'tl
-<
'"
Q
...
...
oM
..
:0:
:il
!il
rt ~ &; ~ ~
tl en 0: en en
o -< I'liiI ..::I ..:I
E ~~~~~
:g ooco~~
0< NriMQO
~
H E-o
en
en p
.. 0:
'-' E-o
H E-o '-'
~ ~ ~ j
~ ~ ~ :::
" t: 0: ~
~ ~~~~
't ~ i! : ~
Q) Po Ikt Po ~
i gog~
o :il ::l
8 ~ fi ~
'-' ~
~ ~
o-l 0:
H
~ f;;
::l a
0: en
H
Z o-l
~~a
'-' '-' '"
0:
E-o
en
..
..
...
en
~
E-o
~ ~
...
..
~
~
0:
'"
~
..
:0:
~ ~ ~ ~ ~
~ ~ ~ ~ ~
~ ~ ~ ~ ~
en ~ ~ en en
tfl H ..:I 00 In
!:l:i~tHl
..
! ~
.. 0:
~ ~
~ i
0:
E-o ...
~ e
~ ~ ~
en ..,
p '"
en 0: 0
>< ~ ~
Ii! ~ H
::i .. ~
..,
'M
15
~
~
H
:<I
00 ...
'" 0:
'" 0
'"
M en
o
III
o
o 00
'" 00
0:
...
~
II
1'(\
\..
en
o-l
o-l
..
..
~ !3
= gJ
Q ..
8 88. 8 fi fi . . 8 I .
i i ~ i i ~ i ~ ti i z ~
~
-<
..
~
III
~ i ~
~ !; f;;
l;! ~ ~ ::l
f;; f;; ~ ~ ~ '" ~
00 ... E'~ : ~ e tl ~ z
~ en en ~ ~ ~ ~ = ... ~
~ ~ 5 ~ ... ~ ~ '-' ~ ~ ~
~ 00 en 0 ~ ~ '" : 3 ~ ~
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ g ~ 0 N ~ ~
o rl 0 ~ M , ~
~ ~ ~ M ~ N rl U H
5 ~
E-o ~..
~ 0: j
~~ : ... ~ ~ E-o i
OJ ~ f;j t/] tf! ~ tf! S
~ i a I ~ i! ~ ~
tJf:1tl O~H~
co III CD .. 0 0
N 'If' .. ..,. ..,. N N N
~
lEi ~
~ ; ~ ~
III t:Q 0 III
....
\D 0 t"I N
.... .-t At f'"I N
~
'" '"
., ...
... 00
~ ~
III III
g g
E-o
..
5 ~ ~ ~ 5
en
to rn tQ Ol
~ :j ~ ~ ~
~ ~ ~ ~ ~
~ ~ ~ :!; ~
....
fi E-t f-t 0
rn tI1 tQ l'
...... OIl
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
U U j;Q III rl l:Q
co co 0 0 co 0
N ('II At l1t N ~
Z Z
o 0
E-o ...
~ ~
en en
o-l o-l
o-l o-l
~ ~
= ~
o 0
z
g
~
..
H
H
...
en
::l
...
en
~
...
E
H
~
.. ..
H H
H H
'-'
:<I
...
..
a
H
o-l
..
..
III
><
0:
g
..
~
-<
H
..,
I
~
...
0: 0: en
tJ U rf re ~
H H l1t p,. E-t
~ H ra:1 JlI1
'" '" ..
::1 ~ .., .., 0: III
g ~ e e ~ ~
to to ..
~ 0: ~ ::l ~ ~
z ~ .. .. Q '-'
~!2.~~a~
'-' '-' '-' '-' ... :0:'
M
! ~ t1
~ ~ :
o
~ ~ ><
... H ::l ~
B ~ ~ en
i 0 0 ::;:
..........0
'-' '-' '"
E-o
en
~ III
~ ~
~ ~
is lil
a a
H 0
o-l.....
.. '-'
~
a
o
0:
a en
: ~
'"
'" '"
H 0
o H
o-l '-'
o 0
..... .....
'-' '-'
.. ii:;
o ... Q
en
~ ~ I ~ !
i i I I ;
~~~~~
~ ~
~ ~
a ~
0: 0:
...... .. ~ ~ en a
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ III i -<
H .. r:! en i ~ ~ .. ~::l E-o E-o ~ o-l
'" '" g '" ~ '" m a .. a ~ ~ ~ ~ ~; e ~ 8
... E-o .... 5 ~ g ~ ~ a f;; .. ~ ~ .. ~ : ~ ..
I ~ l i I,; ! i ~ Iii ~ I i I ~ ~ i i ~ i I ~ i
~ ~ ~ H III ~ 0 e 6 ~ '" a ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ = '-'
~ ~ ~ i ~ I ~ ~ ; i I I ~ i I ~ ~ I ~ ~ ! ~ I j ~
o-l
'-' '-' '-' '-'
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
u a f-t e ~ ~ OJ
i ~ ~ ~ : I I l I I
: en : ~ ~ .., ~ ~ f;; ; ~
o ~ ~ en ~ en en ~ ~ en
E-o ~ H S ~ H H ~ ~ H
s~ I ~~ s I~ i B B~'" ~ ~ S
H 8 o-l ~ M a ~
IlrJ ~ C!) aN&: a
\
r-t 1"4 M .., It'l \0 r--
...
~ ~ ~ : ~ : ~ : ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ co ~ 0 r-t N N M .. .. ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ M r-t N M .., ~ \D ~ co r-- r-- co
H M r-t M r-t n M .-t N N N N N N N N N N M .-4 N N N \D \0 \0 \D \D \0 " .-4 " M M ~ ~ M M M M M t"I t"I r-- r-- l'
M r-t M r-t M M r-t r-t r-t r-t .-t .-t M M .-t M M .., .., .., .. .., ..,. ..,. .... .., .., ..,. .... .. .. .. .... .... N N N N N N N N N N N
i ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ s ~ s s s S S 6 6 ~ S S S 6 ~ 6 ~ 6 6 6 ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
...
N
III
01
oj
0.
~
'"
lO
<Xl
...
o
....
o
o
N
"-
...
"-
N