Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout042-06 TOWN 'OF NANTUCKET BOARD OF APPEALS NANTUCKET, MASSACHUSETTS 02554 Date: Ju/ If 3 , 20 C)~ To: Parties in Interest and others concerned with the ---]5eclslon Of the BOARD OF APPEALS in the Application of t~ following :-"\ . ~~ ::0 Application No.: ()y. L, -0 to Owner/Applicant :--1 ~lX'.1bV1rO V'(1()("t-Ov\ SC~ I e9 ('nq ~y- ~ , v.J f"-. ("r' ." W U1 o. Enclosed is the Decision of the BOARD OF APPEALS which has this day been filed in the office of the Nantucket Town Clerk. An Appeal from this Decision may be taken pursuant to Section 17 of Chapter 40A, Massachusetts General Laws. ~.Anl action appealing the Decision must be brought by fiiing an complaint in court within TWENTY (20) days after this day's date. Notice of the action with a copy of the com~laint and certified copy of the necision must be given to the Town Clerk so as to be received within such TWENTY (20) days. ce: Town Clerk Planning Board ~uilding CommissJoner PLEASE NOTE: MOST SPECIAL PERMITS AND VARIANCES HAVE A TIME LIMIT AND WILL EXPIRE IF NOT ACTED UPON ACCORDING" TO NANTUCKET ZONING' BY-LAW ~139-30I (SPECIAL PERMITS); 9139-321 (VARIANCES) ANY QUESTIONS, PLEASE CALL THE NANTUCKET ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS. NANTUCKET BOARD OF APPEALS 2 Fairgrounds Road Nantucket, Massachusetts 02554 Map 42.3.4 Parcel 123 R-O-H 45 India Street No plan of record Deed Ref. 873/350 At a Public Hearing of the Nantucket Zoning Board of Appeals held at 1 :00 p.m., Friday, June 9, 2006, in the Conference Room of the Town Annex Building, 37 Washington Street, Nantucket, Massachusetts, on the Application of the REV A AND MORTON SCHLESINGER, 45 India Street, Nantucket, MA 02554, Board of Appeals File No. 042-06, the Board made the following Decision: 1. Applicants are seeking relief by SPECIAL PERMIT under Nantucket Zoning By- law Section 139-33A (alteration/expansion of a pre-existing/nonconforming structure/use), and to the extent necessary, relief by V ARlANCE pursuant to Zoning By- law Section 139-16A (Intensity regulations - ground cover). Applicants propose to construct an about 15 square-foot shed structure on the northwesterly side of their pre- existing nonconforming single-family dwelling in order to shield the existing oil tank from the elements due to chronic freezing of the apparatus. The attached shed would increase the nonconforming ground cover of about 67% by about .007%. In addition, the shed would be sited within the required five-foot northeasterly side yard setback area but no closer than the existing structure which is sited less than one-foot from that lot line. The property is nonconforming as to lot size with the lot containing about 2,178 square feet of area in a district that requires a minimum lot size of 5,000 SF; as to ground cover with the lot containing about 67% ground cover ratio in a district that allows a maximum ground cover ratio for undersized lots of 30%; as to setback, with the structure being sited less than one foot from the northeasterly side yard lot line, and as close as about three feet from the easterly side yard lot line, in a district that requires a minimum side yard setback of five feet; and as to parking with the lot containing no parking historically and none is planned in relation to this application. The Premises is located at 45 INDIA STREET, Assessor's Map 42.3.4, Parcel 123, no plan on record, Deed Ref. Plan Book 873, Page 350. The property is zoned Residential-Old-Historic. 2. This Decision is based upon the Application and materials submitted with it, along with the testimony and evidence presented at the hearing. The Planning Board did not make a recommendation. There were no letters on file and one abutter spoke in favor of the Application at the public hearing. 3. Applicants represented that their property is a nonconforming lot of record and the single-family dwelling contained thereon was constructed in substantially the same site and configuration during a period between 1804 and 1813, and both the lot and structure are validly grandfathered as to the dimensional and parking nonconformities. Applicants state that their above-ground oil tank is located in an exposed location against the house on the northwesterly side and has been prone to freezing in inclement weather, causing disruption in their ability to provide heat for their year-round home. Applicants state that the problems have caused them financial harm in having to make constant repairs to the system. Applicants were advised by their service technician to enclose the tank in a small insulated shed structure that would be attached to their house. Applicants are seeking relief to be able to site the shed within the required five-foot side yard setback area and to increase ground cover in order to construct an attached one-story about 5' x 3' shed. As the Applicants have not had a formal survey done by a licensed surveyor, all data available was based upon the Assessor's Office records. The Assessor's records state that the lot contains about 2,270 square feet of area and a separate Town of Nantucket GIS website states that the lot area is about 2,178 square feet. Based upon the Assessor's records the increase of about 15 square feet of new ground cover would increase the ground cover ratio by about .006887 or about .01% to about 67%. Based upon the GIS map information the ground cover would increase by about .0066079 or again about .01% for a total ground cover of about 64%. The existing house has a ground cover of about 1,458 square feet based upon the Assessor's records. Applicants state that such an increase would be minimal and have no negative impact on the neighborhood. Applicants state that the oil tank was placed in that location in 1957 by a previous owner. Said owner Dorothy McGarvey submitted a letter dated February 10,2006 stating that she had put the tank in the current location in 1957 when they installed "central heat". Applicants state that there is no other location to move the tank to due to the siting of the house and the irregular shape of the lot and variance relief would most likely have to granted to re- site it. 4. Therefore, based upon the foregoing, the Board finds that special permit relief can be granted to extend the structure within the required five-foot side yard setback as the shed is not proposed to come any closer to the lot line than the existing dwelling, and finds that this proposal would not be substantially more detrimental to the neighborhood than the existing nonconformities and would have minimal impact. In addition, the Board finds that a grant of variance relief can be made owing to the unique shape of the triangular lot, bordered on three sides by streets, and topography of the structure, a historic single-family dwelling, and especially affecting the Locus but not affecting generally the Residenetial-Old-Historic zoning district, a literal enforcement of the provisions of the Zoning By-law would involve substantial hardship to the Applicant (specifically, the potential financial impact of repeated damage done to the oil tank and house), and that desirable relief may be granted without substantial detriment to the public good and without nullifying or substantially derogating from the intent or purpose of the By-law. 5. Accordingly, by a UNANIMOUS vote, the Board hereby GRANTS the SPECIAL PERMIT relief under Nantucket Zoning By-law Section 139-33A and V ARlANCE relief under Section 139-16A to construct the shed as proposed, based upon the following conditions: a. The shed expansion shall be done in substantial conformance with the plan approved by the Historic District Commission in Certificate of Appropriateness No. 47,985, as may be amended from time to time; b. The maximum ground cover ratio shall be no greater than 67%, and the permitted ground cover of about 15 square feet is not transferable to a different location and/or use without further relief from this Board; and Dated: c. The shed shall not come any closer to the lot line than the existing structure. ~ (~~3. (OdG \ ( 0~ TOWN OF NANTUCKET ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS 1 EAST CHESTNUT STREET NANTUCKET, MASSACHUSETTS 02554 PHONE 508-228-7215 FAX 508-228-7205 NOTICE A Public Hearing of the NANTUCKET ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS will be held at 1:00 P.M., FRIDAY, JUNE 9, 2006, IN THE CONFERENCE ROOM, TOWN ANNEX BUILDING, 37 Washington Street, Nantucket, Massachusetts, on the Application of the following: REV A AND MORTON SCHLESINGER BOARD OF APPEALS FILE NO. 042..06 Applicants are seeking relief by SPECIAL PERMIT under Nantucket Zoning By- law Section 139-33A (alteration/expansion of a pre-existing/nonconforming structure/use), and to the extent necessary, relief by V ARlANCE pursuant to Zoning By- law Section 139-16A (Intensity regulations - ground cover). Applicants propose to construct an about 15 square-foot shed structure on the northwesterly side of their pre- existing nonconforming single-family dwelling in order to shield the existing oil tank from the elements due to chronic freezing of the apparatus. The attached shed would increase the nonconforming ground cover of about 67% by about .007%. In addition, the shed would be sited within the required five-foot northeasterly side yard setback area but no closer than the existing structure, which is sited less than one-foot from that lot line. The property is nonconforming as to lot size with the lot containing about 2,178 square feet of area in a district that requires a minimum lot size of 5,000 SF; as to ground cover with the lot containing about 67% ground cover ratio in a district that allows a maximum ground cover ratio for undersized lots of 30%; as to setback, with the structure being sited less than one foot from the northeasterly side yard lot line, and as close as about three feet from the easterly side yard lot line, in a district that requires a minimum side yard setback of five feet; and as to parking with the lot containing no parking historically and none is planned in relation to this application. The Premises is located at 45 INDIA STREET, Assessor's Map 42.3.4, Parcel 123, no plan on record, Deed Ref. Plan Book 873, Page 350. The property is zoned Residential-Old-Historic. THIS NOTICE IS AVAILABLE IN LARGE PRINT OR OTHER ALTERNATIVE FORMATS. PLEASE CALL 508-228-7215 FOR FURTHER INFORMATION. ,:; ~ .. '" " ''''(~, ~ . t.. '.. '. I "" '1 · .. . .~: :) ( NANTUCKEt ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS " j, 1 EAST CHESTNUT STREET NANTUCKET, MA 02554 CASE NOuCfZ-ctp FEE~ $.300.00 APPLICATION FOR RELIEF Owner's name(s): R-euQ Qt?d (()CJ(''-hJf) S'c h!~S I~q~r ~ailing addr~ss:__L{~ . IiI d ('ei . SIre if! . jlJqtJ 1/d02 'r; /J:l4o ~SS' i Applicant's name(s): (^S()..;v'NL) Mailing address: - ( r OlfrVJ )_ . Locus 'address: I/s-;r:h eft 'a Slrc:.er Assessor's MapfParcel: '48-.8,0//26 Land Court PlanlPlan Book & PageIPliln File No.: -1 nI~~ ~ vU'C/)d! Lot No.: Date lot acquired: ;Z / J / 7Zneed Ret/Cer!. or Title: .. 3! 50 . -Zoning District> ,AO If . :Uses on Lot - Commercial: None-XYes (describe) -- _ "Residential: Number of dyllings-L Duplex~ Apartments_Rental Rooms . Building Date(s): AU pre-date 7/721 V - or C of 0(s)1 BUilding Permit Nos: Previous Zoning Board Application Nos.: -~-~ State below or on a separate addendum specific relief sought (Special Permit, Variance, Appeal), Section- of the Zoning By~law, and supporting details, grounds for grant of relief, listing any existing nonconformities: ~ a1{ac~J od&Of'~(I\) ~ :::;:: "._~ ::::<: N 0\ :'0 en "") -0 N h:. N ';'1 I certify that the in _ tion cont' h ein is substantially complete and true to the best of my knowledge, under t I in nd enal' 0 perjury. SIGNATURE: '\ ... APPlicant~" Attorney' Agent (If not owner or 0 i ne s at 0 ney, please enclose p of of agency to bring th~er before the Board) .t" r FO ZBA OFFICE USE , / Application received on:J f2JD!!JBy: Complete: Need copies?: ~ Filed with Town Clerk: -5! ~ . . -;-,,,+' _ 01 IDg .. 7_ BIJ..1J11:!..- Fee deposited with Town Treasurer:~ (2 aQBy:.ilJt(!)Waiver requested1:_Granted:_'_'_ Hearing notice posted with Town Clerk: S/~([Q Mailed: I)i ~AA&M: siZt! a:o & Jg 1-/112 Hearing(s) held on:_'_'_ Opened on:~_I_ Continued to:_'_I_ Withdrawn?:_I_'_ DECISION DUE BY:_'_'_ Made:_'_'_ Filed wrrown Clerk:_'_I_ Mailed:_'_'_ Town of Nantucket Web UiS - Printable Map rage 1 VI. k Town of Nantucket Web GIS Sale Date Sale Price Book/Page Lot Size 42.3.4 123 45 INDIA ST SCHLESINGER REVA & MORTON 45 INDIA ST NANTUCKET, MA 02554 02/11/2004 $0 00873/0350 0.05 acres NOT A LEGAL DOCUMENT o Prop 10 Address Owner For general reference only: Important caveats which must be considered when using this data are available from the Nantucket GIS Coordinator. [)J~cLaimeI The information displayed on this or any other map produced by The Town of Nantucket is for reference purposes only _ The Town of Nantucket does not guarantee the accuracy of the data_ Users are responsible for determining the suitability for individual needs_ All information is from the Town of Nantucket ~,,-.~ ~~ ~ V ~~-C- Town of Nantucket, Mass Map Composed http://host.appgeo.comlnantucketmaIPrintableMap.aspx?Preserve= Width&Map Width=864... 5/26/2006 r,...,,...~..~....h;,... T....~,...,....-........;"'.... C'"....+-,............ frye' ..-l~.._h...,...,.., 1 uwn U1 t'lamUCKel weo V1l::) - rnmllOle lVlap rage 1 Ul .&. / /- / / ' J-.. '" .:... ~ ff o Prop 10 Address Owner Sale Date Sale Price Book/Page Lot Size Town of Nantucket Web GIS ------........ --- -- ----------. \t-IO\I'- S'- 12ft 42.3.4 123 45 INDIA ST SCHLESINGER REVA & MORTON 45 INDIA ST NANTUCKET, MA 02554 02/11/2004 $0 00873/0350 0.05 acres NOT A LEGAL DOCUMENT CJ For general reference only: Important caveats which must be considered when using this data are available from the Nantucket GIS Coordinator. Di5c1<'lIn1~r The information displayed on this or any other map produced by The Town of Nantucket is for reference purposes only - The Town of Nantucket does not guarantee the accuracy of the data _ Users are responsible for determining the suitability for individual needs_ All information is from the Town of Nantucket ~ .....)V ~V- cr./' "'- "~ -----. -----....--- Town of Nantucket, Mass Map Composed http://host.appgeo .com/nantucketmaJPrintableMap.aspx?Preserve= Width&Map Width=63&... 5/2/2006 r........,..._-.~h;.- T.....~"..._........._...;.......... c.,.-..."'..--. IrTC\ .-I......I-.....h-.__,... 0- ~ ~ :s~ ~ ~~ \....J czJ ~ ~ ~ (r-> e:C C/) 0 C(S~ ~ v '8 0 (:)-' 't:l {'- N (j\ '- \ . ~ C'? 0 ~ (,) Q) (~~ ..- v.....- a:: ..- ~ (j) ~ c: 0 0 T ~ 0 ~o ~ - 0 C'? J: ~ -= Q) D. ~ . 0 z :0 ~ ~ 0 <Xl N l- ~ ~ - \C Q Q M Q f<i Q - Iii Q - Q ~ ~ :;s l:I ~ l:::i s .5 "J .. ~ - ~ - "l:I .. a - ~ ~ :: ~ 4":il; _ <..l ~"3 - ... o -- -- ~ M - -- ~ ~ M ..". S ~ ~ - o , ...l ~ ~ ..". M N Q - Q Q Q 'II: ..... :: :: ~ ~ "'0 "'- 8~ o <; Eo- IJJ :S ~ z .... l/l ..". i:i~ .2 ~ 'a..... <:l '. ...;j~ F.... ~ :: ~.~ <:l .'" t~ OJ "S.o = :c rJl -= ~ ~ ... ~ ~ ~ 6 (3",_\C ~ ~f'I"'ltf) ~ Ii: '" ttl N (\) _ N ;.,IOIOB u::: ::: u ~ 5 5 g go ->: -5 ~ (JB~o u >< >< 0 -= ~ ~ ~ e ~ ~ ... -= Qj >!:I -= OJ ... ~ N 1I"l_ N co co .,. vl oc 0- ... '" '5 ~ u.. 'C ~ 8 .suB "'" "8!;:!;: E~g is ~!;:!;:oo O.o~ BU.. 000 ~ ~ ..0 '" ",~~>o!;:U p.p.88 is.. ~ -52 @-~ on !;: E E ~ ...... E ~.~ ~ t; .; ~ 0 ...... - B .8 Qp.. t) B v;]8 ~ p'op.o..~ ~ t;i t;i (\) 5 >< 0 o:::R > ~ (\) (\) .- .- 0 0 ~ Qt::>==OC <:IN.,.'''''' ~~...QOf'I"'lOO -..:- ~ i2 \j -= Qj .c '" "= iZ N ,!:: ~;:; .. &: '" '" So .s~ oE;03ii:s ~ ~g."2.g~g8';rJl f-o>->CllCll::t:Xez:: ......f------- i3u~~~~~ 0- t- o II'l o<l \0 - oc o N oc o<l - ..... o \C 0- 1- ~ !-.~ ~~ ;;:!;:;;. !-. ~ ~ t- l"l ~ .... -~ Q Q N ~ ~Q Qiii .... Q a; a; '" '; Oi::::l .. - - ~ = ... "t: rJJ ~ 00 00 " QO III :i 00"': ~ Q\N ...... ~""':, ~ '" ~ '" '" -..: .... " 00 ~ ~~ ~ ~:.:i ~ '"'1"~., .'" - ~ 2: -..: ... Q .... "Cl I- ~ U ~ ~;: d ~;: .... ... Q ~ .... ~ ;z; ~~ - <.I ~~ ,'. I:: ....Q '" E-oz -,:: z< I'-@, e.... ,~ ~~ .... ... Q .... ~ bIl --"Cl ~CQ - -- ~ l"l N "1' Q ... ~ < ~ .. Q; ~ Q; en ,!:! :E Ie: I", "1' ..... N Q - Q Q Q ~ - = = 8 \'" <I~ Ig E-o rJJ ~ Q Z ... III "1' = ~ Q l"'l '~ N ~ = <.I _ o . ~S t = ~ ,~ o '" c::> z ,0 t: o ::; ~ < > ~ ~ ~ ~ rJ:J "" $ 11i z o ~ 00 ~ > \;'. I~ n'::I~ M .... Ii 8 -: ..u ~en It=; ;:; .... III III M o ~5 .= E-~ fn ~~ < uOl ~ ~~ ~~ ~ 00 00 , ~~~ -,..H- : ~ ",r- '"1::l " ~ I ~ '<: ~;:;: '6;:;: o;;i.,j ........ ~ i:l!: ":00 -0 ~ ~,~~ M ~ 00 'D'~ 0 0 ..: .1::5.--- ~ OCr- ~ I~.<:~r:: ~~",r- ~~ Q~~ Q_~ t.-.l "l~'<: ~:.~ ~~~;:;: ~., 6 ;: ;: E'\l ~. ..:~~ _ ~~,5?~ a~. == ~ 00 ~ M... u:. :o_r- ~~~ "1::l - " '" '" " '" '" I. '<: .... '" M o - "00 ., "1::l__ d;:;: ..:'g'g ~15?0 ,~"'''' :::1lr"'''' ~oo ~ i ~. ':::"l: ~ i- 'lIo dilt ~~;;;l c..;1~: g~~~ ~;,~~ ~~,-- ~ "O-"~"o, M M 0_ O'D lfl", "'M e;;, ~;; IlOO go '" M - .... ..; N .... C:l .... ~ (S z o E- ~ o ~ ~ << >> ~~ ~~ rill rill rJrJ ~~ 0000 rill,," $$ 11i 1i o ~ .. - ~ ;: ~ - 1;l ~ .. I:l .. a ~ ',- ]~ ~~ ~ I::l ~ o ~.s .....1::: ~ .~ - ~ ~ ~ 1 I:l " :: 'i~ ~ : .. a ~ g,~ r- "" IlO "" 'D ,~ :~ 1- .. .!S E . l: ..::....6 s . ~ 'i: :0 C t: '<: '- '" .() l: ~ I:: 1~1:1 ~ ~ 6 M 'D M o - - ,~ ~ M '<: 000 o 0 .... .... .0";- '" .... o 0 o III r-: M -. - ;;.." I ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ .~. ~, ~. bnbO ~:Q:9bO tacoco"O S~~~ 0) .2 ..a 0) ;j ~ ~ ;j ta>>tav .,'- > ""';3' > .a ciJ ~ '-'"0 ~ ~: ~ ~ @L~ i "2"2"2"2...:1 .~ .~ .~ .~ ca ~ ~ e ~ .0 0.. 0..0.. 0.. v ~~~~~ ',_:. ;' . I, '; :, 'f I ::c .~~ ~ " ~] ~ f-o w ~ z x w o ~ f-o W ~ f-o Vl = o '';:: Co e Q; .. rill I::'i c ,. Ii? = '~ Q; '-"Cl u ,_ '" III I~~ 1-'- \~I'~: w .' ~ z Cl :r: l!l z ~g ~- ~ 00< 00 :r:~ I~ '-M '=l'" ~~ g U (;l 0 ~ 6 M - 'D M ..; <l) ;j ta > "0 ~ c..~ "2-5 '" <l) -e ::E 0.. l: 0..0 <t: '-g ta ;j -ta ~> I I' . I' I I -: " . rJ "" ~ ~ I~ ~ QO >" Q; .. ..... '> '> Q Q; Q; IJi _~~ ....-l -.. .... 3- ........ ~,~,~ <~~~ "'rill,," }; ~ ~~ ,\ ~ .... l~ ,~,~ Q; Q; .. .. = c I~ra 00 .... ;., "2 o .. o ';: .. ~ e~~~~ ~ "S -Rg s ~ v -= &j~ .. :: ~ ~ 1i ~ I~\_~ ~ h .; I,:~', 100 0.. 0.. <t: -; .. o E-o I~ '''!!"'''It'........... C\O\C\OC ~Ct\Q\c\Ct\ ~,....,....,....,.... Q~~\DQ ~~~~ .,.,,,...,.\0 :. ~ I:: '" l: l: d i;i t: d '" 'ii Q S l: d 6Z '" 'ii Q <i '" .!S 'i: :0 C t: -..: I:: C . -g , .~ , to i I~ . Ie..: l~ _~ I' h \::1 ~ I "il2S '" :0 '" ~ El -~ '" 1~~:ICl, I o ",0 :olfl ~~ - "1::l . 1::'"" t:l '-l , . . : I., '. "'<10 -~ 'C! Cl,~ .-..:: '''It' :S :.:: ~ o => . ~ -c ~ - t:l 'C .~ '<l I ~ '<: , ~ ~ + o o o o o 12 ~g -..:~ t:j;g ~ '- 0 "'C? Cju- 1~1 ~ III ...:'" <>:i '- 0 s ~ ~(,,),.... ~ <10 r- N <10 liil:';:: ~ <:-- ::stt ... en ': ",0 .~ ~ :Sri .(. '.- oJ:: ~ '" Q ~ t:l 'i: c Lt Q "'= 1::0 ~~ I ~ I:: .... ~:~~ :::5 ~ e 2l: Q; "6il = ;;: "'~ ;: :::Jd ;: Cll'llo _ ... o on r-:- M - - ~ :: 'i > "Cl = '" .... 'i .. o E-o - ... en o I- 1::1- .. Q; .. < "Cl = .. .... ] c:l E-o 'ii ... .. .. =- ... rJ:J o r- M ri ~ 'c ;;J "Cl = '" .... "Q .. '" U 'i ... c:l E-o t~,~~: ..... ;"..,"'...,-';.,...., . "'-" 1: " '1' ": iI. ,I I.~ 1'-'1 ! 'I ,",j . -, 1 j I <J I.... .., . 11'1' I .... ~.illi '.".., ~.~~~_. .., .. ;;-'......ll"~. ;tY';1.. .......'1." .'. " ; " .. II IIIro , . i . I I I I . "'-~.;- --"'-- i I, ""If, Ll]'TIW ' "f" "c.'~ 1 ~ .1.:..."tM;~'~J~i "~fflH;\":rf 'c',, /' ,L\'!"Y~~ :~~~'I!1i1C1; 1J"(<\\' ':"',"}.J:' !: ':, f, ri ~ -f'11 ~"."'\C,_ (f"!l: 't~.~.f;lI I~H"~{iij .. f'f f..,.. ~'. '" u '. ',"~" ~ . t:-.{~~;~. ~ 'i :qtt",_\.-. ~ . '-;;~:fF~~;"~}\~ .' !'''.'~' .:C. I'~' l - ", . ". -;....r,.,-....~ , '-"; < j ; f rage 1 OI L lown 01 r..arlLUCKel weD VIi:) - rnmaDle Map Town of Nantucket Web GIS 42.3.4 123 45 INDIA ST SCHLESINGER REVA & MORTON 45 INDIA ST NANTUCKET, MA 02554 02/11/2004 $0 00873/0350 0.05 acres Prop 10 Address Owner NOT A, LEGAL Docur'lENT For general reference only: ImpOltant caveats which ITlUSt be considered when using thiS data are available from the Nantucket GIS Coordinator. Sale Date Sale Price Book/Page Lot Size Olil of Town of Nantucket, Mass Map Composed http://host.appgeo.com/nantucketmaIPrintableMap.aspx?Preserve=Width&Map Width=216... 5/2/2006 _.""""" 47"1 e> 5 ",,, _. ~ AppblICIIIIO \116 tilSTOfIIC l)l$TAlCT CQMMlS8JON. ~. ~.. 1ar · CERTIfICATE OF APPROPRIATENESS tor ~..Ill, I\ll tIIenkW fllulllle ~hd In \IlIiflO 9WE OR IIlJICI( 1Nf(~':' =- '" """" ~ 10 ~11II ~. Non;: 1111 1lr0ftllY ....-.......... thal tIW .:r:=- "'::'::::=".="::~~_Ine" .-.. r--..Ily Il1t MaC. _ _ ...... . . 01 c.rtIIl:IIII 01 "'-0pI1>N ... undet CNptI' 3M 0111I ~ IIllI T"'. ill _~ ~ lIflCI Rl\lIIlIellltof 011I 11>"- M =.....~ n:~l'Dr~ ~1IlV.... ~ _1lIIdI1 pet '*-' by ..-. _"'.. or ...... ,.no. tDf prop<>Md ~ II ~ .....eIn an ...--_'-' 01 CeIlIlaII 01 0c0UflI"CY Ttlt cenIIIooM Ilval4 "" ......,.... _ dIlIe at ..,._. No __ Ny d- ""'" 1M 1lJPlC'II6~' \IloI- mly ~ ~ . - \\ PROPERTY o{SCRIPTION j ~ PIllt. 5 :9.5 ::.:=~.~:,~~~3 ::=~~ ~~~ oS5J~~ ~= T~ne: ~~:).'li..~~~1 \"";.~ AOBn INFOAIIATIOM (If appIIc(lbte) Tetet)hone: (an iIllIndl ~; ~n: ~: IoIIlfobe< : ~: ~: Name: (011-1 ~ lolaiIifIQ MG'_: o N.... o-Ring :-~ AdcfolIM ...J CGIOf C'*9I ~ F_ = 01'* 1'-- tpedlyl SIZe oISltuCture Of ~ Lll1lIIh: -: =GIf. :':QeW D8CNPT1ON Of' WOM TO lII! f'E1lI"OflIIED SII_ tor required CIlle__. : ~~ =~ ::HIefOti(II ~ CD"'" -:: PavinG ::... -.ling :: o.-auon -= ~ 10 ~ Cert Mo. :: Slept ~ Sq. Fo<oMQe '.lloor: 8q.'~a...s-: 8q.~ :11II"""" Dlllerenl:Ol-- eooItlIr'lI ~ ..... propaHO Ilf1Ieh 11'- PIO!lI\ HfI9l1I 01 ridp _1It,.l- gnow. - =~-:-~~M ~\?~ \t-Mt =::..: ~ ~~ OIlCIlI: $lie: 9b: _ 'el_ : 2nd floor ltl_ ::2nd1aOf 5cMIlh &tt Willi SOltIl WllIl EMI '_ e-l E......... 2. SoulIt ~ 3_ WMI ,-- ._~- RI'WiIOIG: ,........) IIlh... ." t4DC ~ "'"" lot.. 1I~1 :: V.. i: N6 'ClauoI.... ............ eubmIt tlhulv..... allllldng ........... _ DDM.Of'--fO.NJlI'OflIIIl!D ,..........: HeIgIlI EIIpOHd :J _ -_ 8Iod< PlIIpCI --:-Brid< ~) MoMMy ell......." '= IllacI< PlIIpCI :J _ (~ !: ()tMr _....: _~/'2_~""'---112_ DOf1llP ---1'2_ Olher ~-;: ~ ~._.:~ '_ \IVoolI (Type: ReI! ceder, ~~. Shek_IlC-) ~ ~ ~: _JOINt -...-.. ~; lIky......11IIt onM: _ Rour 0pInIflll ~ 1HnvIeOl~'" ....... ()penir1g 9Ia Qu"",.: ~: W I - Alumitvn 18_( ....Ilaet- .-.-: . '18 e-. .: c...-..s \...-"'.: ~: 0\Mr T,I"" A. WOOO _ . PN .: AtdwoOd - B. TrMl-'\ ._ Ptinl ~:; __ . c.... all fi<>Ith C. Olmenolonl' FMCla SoIIIl (0YIrha"ll1 CorM' _felt F.... WIndow CMIlO Door Fr_ CONmnelPOI18: Round _ 6...-". - Wl,",-': Do...... l4u..O -:: ~ont ~.:.u Wood .-:: au. = TNI OMcled lJghIalfl'Ul'\lntl =- SOL'. 1&;n>.II- OIYIdtd UgNtI llaora' (lyVIend "'-11): F<OnI - !IlcI. aal.Ooo<(s): Type _II lMIdK_ _"III: Driveo.ayt W"""IY' Wl41t , Nole: CompIell GoO' ."d ..._ 1CIledv'" If. r8Qlli<ld. = P-*, CoI1c.$ '::J ...... j lbcIIIQn LQCtIIIOR - Copper -I Front - Side ::: COLOM SIo6W1ll1 CleflllOe'O (II ~) Trim 6<<th DedI f!o~ . AtlIICh mtIf1UIIetur... cdor tamCII- " cdor . 1lOI1~ HOC lW'ovW IiII , nerq a""oriulhe agenllllmW _... \0 ~ an "." lIIhtII \D ..... ~ In .,ploMoII1ltlO GDI'IIfI;e..ea _ ... HOC ~. , !WallY 19'1110 ~ bV ~ .. "'Y~' 10 ,,. ....,.o:a1lor1 will i_ . n_IIIftr-Clay ..-..- Aoot 000.- F...ee s~U\\.,. Md In .... ~ Ifl ordef 10 Drlng"" attllle eppInIIan. , ""Ill>; IlIfII trill.... l..":.,( ....___....~ .._.....,., M"'.v ~ ~~ .~ -'("- ~->. ~.- ",. ~ ~ ',.) '(J- r-' ,-= - rt. ''> ~...:;,. \J'... 7' \~ if}/L ~ --. .-- - --1 ....... ~ ---. /' /'l.~ ,/ ,-3\ ~ .>A'O'~ k-:-.1 'f 0) .... t~ l~~ ~ ,~ ~~ ~ ~ 1,,- i ~I~~\~ \~I-H-'1-------- - --1\12 ~ &~ ~~/J ~ I~ - 2,.=:'1 r U~ 7 . . j- -Lr3':' ....--). I Y. 'i --- 1--. -:! 0<; \l.. I"-c. I ~' ~~~J'3.~~~O' I)~ - ~ ~ 1~1-'3~Z ~ .-l c!- ~ ' I ;: ~ ~~ ~-3 \~\l!.~~ ~~ '" ,~ ;~ - ; ~ _+ g -4:" LL\~ _ <J I ~ ".. rJ - t.~ ~L9 I~ ~ - 0- ~ _ -:_-,;, .~..I v - I ~-:- r- \~ ~ \1 It - -~ - ' . \- \5 ~r-q~ ~ / ~7: -~ ._-_1 n ~ I f I.. ~ ~~ I..... V) ~ "" t '.:~ '- ~ '; I I(l) ~V'\ 'Of\ 0.. W.\'~ ~i} Il ',-4 . 1'- ~ 0' ~ ?= ..h r ,.. -, ~ -=' ~ ~~-::t~~>~~d -.---1:--.%f,-- ~ ~! t~-t ~~~ ~ .- ~ *~~~!~~ ~ --.., ---.. - -... ~ .,:) .oP ..-- - -...-- , /'/-T-'---'---~~ l~ I :-. -- \'- Yifr ~~)(fY.) 3-~(Y.J1I 4'-1J.j'~~~ P-r ly ~ -.. --- 7(;1 "XlH-' J / 1t q, 00 Town of Nantucket ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS LIST OF PARTIES IN INTEREST IN THE MATTER OF TIlE PETITION OF PROPERTY OwNER....,......>~.h.k:S,~..~...~..'!."~i. ))pL-I-oYL . '. I ..-J".."". MAl LfN GAD D RES S.. . .. , .. .. .. , .. . . . .. .. .. .. . :. . .. . , .. . .. . .. ... .. . . .. . . . .. .. . . .. . . . . .. ... . PROPERTY LOCATION........, ..If.s.... ..kd~.Ch.....> t................ ASSESSORS MAPfPARCEL..,...... .i..p..Lf. .-:-:....1 ~..?...... ,.......-... APPLICANT..........., ......&t.,'!.d~.~...,..................,.. SEE ATTACHED PAGES 1 certify that the foregoing is a list of persons who are owners of abutting property, owners of land direct 1;, opposite on any public or private street or way; and abutter.s of the abutters and all other land owners within 300 feet of the. property line of owner's property, all as they appear on the most recent applicable tax list (M.G.L. c. 40A, Section 11 Zoning Code Chapter 139. Section 139-29D (2) - /}l'-'1pJ,i?{!t!~p '_ DATE' rF> . w. ,.' !i .i?~pq? ~~ ASSESSOR'S OFFICE Town of Nantucket , . I {. . MAY - 2 2D06 ~~--...." f-o g tIl 'f-o f-o .rl P:; 00 tIl " O' ~ ~ ~ ~ S ~lZ;&l&l '" '" '"' H H Q) CI) ~ ..1 ~ r: :zo ~ '" '" ... f-o f-o f-o tIl tIl tIl f-o f-o f-o f-o f-o tI) tIl en (I) 00 >< ~ ~ ~ >1 H H H ..:I 0-1 ., ., f-o >< t: 0: 0: >< ~ ~ tJ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 0: 0: tIl tIl tIl lZ; ~ ~ O' O' O' tIl tIl ~ ~ '" '" '" ~ ~ , 5 ~ ~ ~ rot I.tl M r4 r-l N N N f-o E-t E-t E-t tI) tIl tIl fIl '"' " 01 III E-t E-t E-t E-t E-t E-t E-t t E-t t E-t E-t E-l E-I Pol E-t 00 E-t E-t E-t E-t E-t tIl tIl tI) 00 tI) tI) E-t tIl tIl tIl tI) tI) 00 m tI) tI) m tIl E-t E-t E-l en tIl tI) ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ : : : ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ en tI) 00 tI) tI) tI) tIl ~ ~ ~ M ~ ~ H H H en 00 M en ~ ~ M M ~ ~tIl tIl tIl tIl tIl '" '" '" '" '" '" ~ ~ ~ tIl ~ '" ~ '" '" '" '" = ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ H H H ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 0 ~ . M M ~ ~ ~ ~ 0 N rl ~ ~ 0 ~ ~ m M ~ M M N N N N N MM. ~ . . M M N M N ~ N N M M f-o E-t foI E-t 00 foot ~ ; ;; ~ ; ~ H H H H H . ~ ~ ~ ~ : : ~ ~ H ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ : ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 8 ~ ~ ~ I.tl . 0 ~ n ~ ~ N ~ ~ n M I.tl 0 I.tl r4 n ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ I.tl ~ 0 M I.tl 0 1"'"4 I.tl M . 00 I.tl I.tl I.tl 0 0 I.tl · I.tl I.tl I.tl ~ 0 · ~ N M 0 n ~ 0 NON N ~ M NON ~ m N N N N N N N 0 0 NOM N N NON N N 0 0 N M N N N NON ~ 0 N 1"'"4 0 . Nom 0 0 M MOM 0 M MOO 0 0 0 0 M M MOM NON 0 N 0 0 0 N MOO 0 0 0 N ~ 0 ~ S!!il~S!8!ilS!~S!S! O' ~ ~ f-o ~ ~ ~ ~ p 0 ~ 0 g ~~~~ N lQ lQ .. " '" ~ C1 <l -.< '"' -.< '" :El t!l ~~ 00 H .:IE-< r>::I 001><: ~~ gz ~ ~ ~ 0-1 ~ ~ i I ... 0 ~ ~ ~ ~ t; ~ N ~ M 0 0",' N r- U 0: O' f-o fIl lZ; ::l ~ ~ ~ '" ..: f-o tIl ~ f-o ., .. "O' ~ ~ \:i lZ; tIl H to ; ~ I lZ; I ~ ~ o ~::i! U U ... tIl .. 0 ~ ~ f;; ~ f-o f-o :Hitlo88 ~~~;~~ f-o tIl lZ; !ii o "' M '" '"' '"' .. f-o f-o fIl tIl ~ ~ f-o f-o f-o tIl 0: O' P O' ~ ~ ~ H 0 :El O' tJ ~ \:i lZ; H 0 >< :El fIl ., 0 ~ H lZ; ., ..: ., f;l ~ O' :J Z H ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~ o H '" '" 0 O' fIl f-o g; ~ fIl tIl H >< ~ ~ >1 '"' ., ... '"' '"' N '"' '" r- rl s o O' ",,, O' f-o H ~ IZl tfl tIl tIl ~ ~ O' ~ ~ ~ ~ ;a ~ ~: ~ H E-t ~ E-t POp. E-t g ~ 8 0( ~ ~ \:i ~ ~ ..: OJ ~ ~ ., ~ ~ ~ .,lZ;lZ;!::.,O'':3O' ro H ::c ra:l H H P! ~ lZ; ;;Jg~!i~~~'" ~ t: H tIl fi! ., '" !!l :oj ... &1: OOIlQHe e ~~9t:~~e1!9 ; ..:~~~~8~~ " -.< g f-o tIl 0: 0: H '" f-o ... O' 5 tIl f-o ~ f-o O' ~ ~ 3 tIl ~ ... is ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ : ~ ; g lZ; ~ M M N ~ O' O' i o ., ~ ~ o , U 0( ., '" ... S! ~ S! ..: ..: '" '" S! ;! ~ S! S! S! ~ ~ ~ S! ~ !il ;! ~ ;! ~ S! S! S! g ~ S! ;! S! S! ;! ~ >1 S! O' ~ ~ III O' ~ ~ j f-o H '" III 0 '" ... ~ ~ III III ti ~ ti ~ ~ tl 0 tl ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ i ~ re re 5 5 ~ 0: '" tIl g B B B 8 ~ -< B ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ i ~ ~ ~ o tIl = ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ m m N ~ ~ ~ co co 0 rt'I ~ FJl C7\ ~ ~ : : : : : : : ~ ~ 0 0 0 0 ~ 0 0 w co ~ ~. ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ U o 0 0 0 0 0 000 ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ tIl ., ., ~ Ii! o tIl >< ~ E ~ 0( E-t H E-t E-4 E-t 8 ~ lZ; a 8 B 8 ~ ~ i I ~ ~ ~ ~ ., H ~ ~ B ~ B B B I ~ lZ; ~ i ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ i fi! CD CD '" f-o ~,tIl f-o tIl O' '" o 5 ~ ~ fi! a ~ ~!~i! o tIl '" o '"' 0: '" ~ 5 ~ ~ t; 8 ~ ~ ti ~ E ~ g e el ~ ~ ~ o ~ ~ JQ M ~ 0 0 M 0 ~ N N ~ 0 NON co ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ FJl ~ f-o O' [:l ti ~ t; a fJ tIl ~ tIl ! ~ ~ ~ ~ m _ r.. H ~ S lZ; ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ "' '" N rl '" 0: o U ..: f-o [:l O' ., o , U f-o tIl ~ f-o O' 0: \:i gj H '" :El 0 ~ ~ ~ e ~ ti tIl "l ~ :< H > ~~ ~ '" O' f-o tIl ~ o ~ ~ S !:i ~ :< &l .. '" '" o H N ~ 11'I H .... M CD r-- \D .... 0 rt \D N N l/1 Pt rt rt'I ~ ~ O' '" ..: f-o 0: f-o ~ ~ f-o tIl '" I '"' tIl O' O' f-o tIl ~ ~ f-o f-o lZ; lZ; H H ... ... ... ... o 0 U U lZ; ~ ~ >1 ~ ~ ~ ~ '" '" '" '" f-o tIl ~ f-o :El ~ f-o O' O' '" f-o tIl >< ., H ., f-o tIl ~ f-o ~ ~ III f-o O' tl ~ ~ H 0: 0( tIl :O' ~ ~ ~ lZ; ~ ~ ~ H H j g U ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ e u E-t E-t U ~ ~ f-o ~ ~ ~ ~ [:l O' ~ O' ~ ~ OJ ~ g ~~., ~ rz. tJ 1liI. i! tr.l ~ Ill: ~ H ~ m ~ tr.l ~ ~ i ~ ~ tr.l H ~ f-o f-o ~ ~ III U OJ ~ S ., ~ OJ ~ ~ ~ i i ~ ~ I i ~ ~ ~ ~ g ~ ~ ~ ~ @ ~ i ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ i = i ! a I : ~ I ~ ~ g ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ i i ; ~ ~ i ~ i ~ e ~ e f-o f-o f-o U f-o tIl tIl tIl ;:: ~ ~ rl ~ t:i .. 0 '" o '" H '" '" ., o ... II> '" .... N ",00 r-- ~ N N N "" .... M i H 0: o , U CD rl :1 rl 0: '" ., ., ~ ~ ~ :El ~ l;i :El a ~ tIl '" o ~ '" tIl f-o tIl f-o ~ ~ ~li ~ 0: la tIl f-o 0 tl O' ~ ~ ~: III ~ ~ ~ ~ e ~ H H H ~ ~ tIl r&I ~ 0 u ~ ~ rA ~ a ~ .... OJ OJ lZ; lZ; H H ... .. ... ... o 0 U U tIl 0: '" f-o ~ ~ ~ g ~ s ~ a tIl OJ lZ; OJ ., 8 tIl ~ '" 0: f-o O' ~O' ~ 0" '" :El 5 f-o g ~ OJ ~ '" OJ III ~ ~"'H~tlth~ ~ ~ ~ ~ I I tl ~ O' ~ f-o f-o ~ ., '" ~ g ~ ~ ~ >< >< '" ~ ., t:i O' t:i ~ 8 ~ i i ~ ~ g el ~ ~ ~ i i ~ j ~ ~ ~ ~ tJ U '" ~ ~ tn Ill: 0-1.,0: tl 0 ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ TlI:1 ra ~ TlI:1 '" '" H H tn Ill: ~ ~ ~ ~ Pl .... ~ ~ u ., ., rl ~ N '"' N '" ~ r-- w C7\ 0 " N ~ ~ ~ 0 co ~ "" l/1 \D ~ co o rt M "" l/1 co ~ 0 .... 11'I FJl \D ~ rt N M "" FJl r-- co C7\ 0 rot N N M l/1 \D ~ co M " M N N N N N N ~ M "" ~ "" "" "" "" H rot ~ ~ .... ~ ~ ~ 11'I 11'I l/1 FJl co co co co co co co co co ~ ~ ~ C7\ ~ ~ C7\ C7\ ~ M M ~ ~ M M M ~ M rt M ~ M ~ rt M M 0 o N , '" ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ i ~......~.........~~~~~...~...~~~~~~...~~~~~~~...~~...""~~~~~~~~~~~~;;:; '" .. .. .. .lJ 'tl .c j tl1 <l .,. ... -,. .. :& t) ... ... Po f-< Cl t- Z "" ~ H ~ ~ ~ E-t f-< 1'\ tIl ~ '" '" '" H :>: ..:lE-t <Il !; <Il f:iI f-< ~ f-< ~ ~ till.: <Il ~ <Il g ~~ .c '" '" .. H 0> ... .. !il ... r< .. 0 .. 0 .. H , t- , 'tl '" r< '" ~Z ~ '" ... OJ> ... r< ... ... '" OJ> r< ~ ... ! .. <Il i H ~ :z: 1'\ .. I <Il .. <Il .. 0 ~ '" t) 0 ~ t) t) '" .. '" f-< .. tIl .. ~ ~ <Il E-< H <Il f-< ~ ~ .. t) E-< H ., '" .. ! : ~ i .. ~ <Il :z: '" ~ ~ 0 ~ .. .. I'\:Z: I H C> C> .. ~ H <Il '" H .. <Il <Il [l! tIl ~ ~ 0 ~ '" <Il f-< t) .c ., ~ ... S '" ... N M '" ., '" 0 r< '" M 0 ... OJ> OJ> OJ> OJ> '" ... ... ... ... ... 0 0 N '- ... ... ... ... ... M i M M M M M '- '" '" '" '" '" ... ... ... ... ... U1 2- B;'I Gcfz-eJ if;) ADDENDUM Applicants are seeking relief by Special Permit under Nantucket Zoning By-law Section 139-33A and to the extent necessary pursuant to Zoning By-law Section 139-16A. Applicants propose to enclose an existing exterior oil tank located on the northwesterly side of the structure with an about 3' x 5' one-story shed. Applicants state that the tank freezes in the winter and the only way to protect it is to cover it and insulate the enclosure. The tank was in its present location since before the 1972 enactment of the Zoning By-law and is thus grandfathered as to siting. The structure covers almost 67% of the lot and is sited at about zero feet from the front and the side yard lot lines. There is no other place to re-site the tank safely. The shed would be attached to the house and would be no closer to the northwesterly side/rear yard lot line than the house and could be done by special permit. The Applicants have never undertaken having a formal survey done and the only records of the house are contained on the GIS maps on the town website and the Assessor's tax cards. The ground cover appears to be between 66.5 and 67% based upon the size of the lot in the records, with a maximum ground cover for undersized lots being 30% and by a grant of special permit relief up to 50%. The new shed would increase the ground cover ratio by .007%. Applicants are asking for variance relief for the minimal increase in ground cover ratio. There is no parking on the site and there is none possible. g --1-.\1 0"':" :E. 2- =:J: =< VJ o r r"l -" :r.:> \0 .i:::. w