The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink AboutSeptember 27, 2022 HDC Minutes for September 27,2022,adopted Oct. 11 • • r‘7.411°14 �Fr� HISTORIC DISTRICT COMMISSION . REGULAR MEETING 2 Fairgrounds Road - e� �+ �= Nantucket,Massachusetts 02554 6 \ q� t (,j �y ; \OAA� O www.nantucket-ma.gov Commissioners:Raymond Pohl(Chair),Stephen Welch(Vice-chair),Diane Coombs,Abigail Camp,Vallorie Oliver Associate Commissioners:Jessie Dutra,Carrie Thornewill,Connie Patten — MINUTES — Tuesday September 27,2022 Community Room, 4 Fairgrounds Road &Remote Participation via ZOOM. Called to order at 4:03 pm.and announcements by Mr.Welch Staff in attendance: Holly Backus,Historic Planner;Adrian Rodriquez,Administrative Specialist;Terry Norton,Town Minutes Taker Attending Members: Welch,Coombs,Camp,Oliver,Thomewill,Patten Remote Participant: Coombs,Thornewill Absent Members: Pohl,Dutra Late Arrivals: None Early Departures: None Adoption of Agenda: Motion Motion to Approve(Coombs) Roll-call vote Carried 5-0//Coombs,Oliver,Cam.,Patten,and Welch I. OTHER BUSINESS 1. 21 Pleasant Street—Foundation without HDC approval Welch—We had to have extensive deliberations over inappropriate grade changes,which after being brought into conformance were documented in the COA. Foundation demo/replacement was not included in the COA or discussion leading to its issuance.However, the foundation has been demolished.Work without a COA is not allowed. and work not included in the applications is not part of the approval.Subject to a vote,we will issue a stop-work order and require them to come before HDC with a proper application. Coombs—Asked if they might have done that on purpose. Discussion on the motion Camp—Confirmed the foundation wasn't indicated on the application nor referenced in the minutes. Motion Motion to issue the violation notice and stop work order and they are to come in with an application for a new foundation. (Oliver) (seconded) Roll-call vote Carried 5-0//Oliver,Camp,Coombs,Patten,and Welch-aye 2. 80 Surfside Road—Grade change Welch — This foundation appears 18" taller than was approved. This is a prominent location close to the road. Our position is to determine whether to vote to issue a violation and request for the applicant to come before the board with a revision and for work to cease in the meantime.The application was to raise the foundation 14"and what is being constructed appears about 18"above that. Camp—It looks like they intend to bring the grade up to the proposed level,but it's been bermed heavily. Patten—Agrees. - Coombs—We had a long discussion on this and now that is being ignored. Motion Motion to issue the violation notice and stop work order and they are to come in with an application for a new foundation. (Coombs) (seconded) Roll-call vote Carried 5-0//Coombs,Oliver,Camp,Patten,and Welch-aye 3. Letter to Select Board discussing reinstatement of remaining Advisory Boards Coombs—She sent a request asking this be held until Mr.Pohl returns. II. COMMISSION COMMENTS 1. Oliver—Asked if there is any news on the wind turbines.Backus—There is one out near Rhode Island. 2. Camp—Regarding subdivisions,when we look at one parcel and we don't know what will happen on the other,they should be looked at as a whole,not separate lots.Welch- Put that on other business for next week. 3. Welch—Resiliently Integrating Sustainable Energy workgroup will repost a legal notice format of openings including to instructions on how to receive an interest form;notice will be for a two-week period. III. PUBLIC COMMENT Terry Norton—121 Madaket Road vegetative screening inadequate and unplanted berm IV. SIGNS Property owner name Street Address Scope of work Map/Parcel Agent 1.. Nantaco 21 South Water Street `I,?fejeeting-s 12.4:2/102 Lee Milazo 2. Nantaco 21Sxouth Water'Street ' Menu/wall sign '12.1.2/.102 Lcc Milazo Page 1 of 16 HDC Minutes for September 27,2022,adopted Oct. 11 V. CONSENTS Property owner name Street Address Scope of work Map/Parcel Agent 1. 5 HL LTC 09-7009 5 Heather Lane Hardscape 30/24.1 Joseph Werner ! 2. Nicola Day 09-7150 5 Essex Road Add egress windows 67/602 LINK 3. Brian&Laura Millham 09-7170 6 Boulevard Sport court 8/75.1 Jordan Dennis 4. William Gribben109-7162_ 2 Mulberry,Street - Rev: 07-4236:rdc footprint- 55.4.1/20 Thornewill Design' 5. Shari A.Levitan Trust 09-7152 33 Madaket Road Change window to door 41/409 Thornewill Design 6., 37 ACK;,TLC 09=7169 33 Tennes"see Avenue, . Exterior deck&stair : ' 59.4/245 ., Thornewill Design , 7. Javier Vargas 09-7068 2 Washaman Avenue Addition to shed 55/47 Thornewill Design 8. Javier Vargas 09-7093 2 Washaman Avenue Bulkhead adtn&roof chng 55/47 Thornewill Design 9. Daniel Rizika 09-7092 18 MacLean Lane Window replacement 55/448 NAG 10. Wayne Berman 09-7126 93 Tom Nevers Road Rev. 04-6170:porch 91/40 NAG 11. Rachel Healey 09-7067 37 Washaman Avenue Porch&outdoor shower 55/585 Normand Residential 12. Emily Clarkson 09-7079 47 Hooper Drive Roof replacement 67/262 Linda Williams 13. Jeffrey Chapman 09-7078 14 Curlew Court Fence 58/520. Linda Williams 14. James Soltesz 09-7081 2 Grey Lady Outdoor shower 66/701 Linda Williams 15. Michelle Kalman 09-7074 55 Essex Road Replace windows 67/642 Linda Williams 16. Michelle Kalman 09-7077 55 Essex Road Driveway 67/642 Linda Williams 17. Mark Koorenny 09-7072 97 Tom Nevers Road Fenestration change 91/20 Linda Williams 18. 2 SP,LLC 09-7137 2 South Pasture Lane New fence 80/297.2 Michael Haijar 19. Chris Chadre 09-7171 29 Crooked Lane Roof replacement 41/206 Stegra Corp. 20. 56 Monomoy Nominee 09-7128 56 Monomoy road GH window removal 43/41 WAPD 21. Jennifer Ware 09-7174 36 Lyons Lane Add window well 72/38 Jennifer Ware 22. Dipak Thapa 09-7094 37 Beachgrass Road New shed 68/369 Structure Ultd. L23., Debbie lCulbertson 0 „ ..9-7100 53 Tennessee Avenue.. Rev.03-5854:reduce shed . 59.4/362 : Structure,-Ultd. ' 24. Dana DeNiro 09-7099 8A Hawthorn Lane Rev.008-4509:reduce shed 56/802 Structure Ultd. 25. 8 Walbang Nom Trst 09-7173 8 Walbang Avenue Rev.04-6126:hardscape 82/146 Ahern,LLC 26. Michael Bralower 09-7141 1 Hamblin Road Add shutters 30/192 Emeritus 27. Jeremy Trottier 09-7140 4 Windsor Road New cabana 49/193 Emeritus 28. Richard Belair 09-7127 2 Rudder Lane Hardscape 66/348 Richard Belair Voting Welch,Coombs,Camp,Oliver,Patten Alternates None Recused Thornewill Documentation None Representing None Public None Concerns No concerns. Motion Motion to Approve (Oliver) Roll-call vote Carried 5-0//Oliver Camp,Patten,Coombs,and Welch Certificate# HDC2022-(as noted) VI. CONSENTS WITH CONDITIONS Property owner name Street Address Scope of work Map/Parcel Agent 1. 5 EL,LLC 09-7008 5 Heather Lane Pool 30/24.1 Joseph Werner • Pool not to be visible at time of inspection and thereafter and to have no grade change from existing or as noted on the original application. 2. Michael Sweeney 09-7031 1 Longwood Drive New garage 71/54 EMDA • Due to lack of visibility 3. Ack Surfside Partners 09-7175 24 Woodbine Street Rev.07-6703: sport court 80/93 Ahern,LLC • Due to lack of visibility 4. Derrick Maxwell 09-7125 6 Cooley Court New pool 68/153.2 Derrick Maxwell • Pool not to be visible at time of inspection and thereafter and to have no grade change from existing or as noted on the original application. 5. John Lancaster Held 15 Burnell Street Solar roof array 73.4.2/48 Ack Smart • Due to lack of visibility Voting Welch,Coombs,Camp,Oliver,Thornewill Alternates None Recused Pohl Documentation Photos of 15 Burnell Street Representing Tim Carruthers,Ack Smart Public None Concerns Camp-Wants to ensure the solar on Burnell isn't on the street side.It's not visible from Burnell.Wants to view. Carruthers-West faces Burnell;south elevation,is the front but doesn't face the street. Motion Motion to Approve Items 1-4 through staff per noted comments. (Oliver Roll-call vote Carried 5-0//Camp,Patten,Coombs,Oliver,and Welch-aye Certificate# HDC2022-(as noted) Motion Motion to View Item 5. (Coombs Roll-call vote Carried 5-0//Coombs,Thornewill,Oliver,Camp,and Welch-aye Certificate# Page 2 of 16 HDC Minutes for September 27,2022,adopted Oct. 11 VIII.NEW BUSINESS 08/16/2022 Property owner name Street Address Scope of work Map/Parcel Agent 1 �;John"-Sully08-6894- 47 Pleasant Street As-built Window"replace 55/17.1' Aldain Allen Voting Welch,Coombs,Camp,Oliver,Patten Alternates. Thornewill Recused None Documentation Architectural elevation plans,site plan,photos,correspondence,historical documents,and advisory comments. Representing Aldain Allen Public None Concerns(5:04) (4:28)Motion to Hold for representation. (Camp) Carried 5-0//Coombs,Patten,Camp,Oliver,and Welch-aye Allen—Presented project;original windows were all 6-over-6. Backus—National Historic Landmark (NHL) circa 1900; due to the age and location, these windows should be true- divided light(TDL)with sash to match existing.Recommends a window survey to establish original windows. Read HSAG comments: Before replacing any windows,a window survey needs to be done to assess the condition and age of the existing windows.Any replacement windows should be 1'UL,not Andersen.The new window casings on the front lack the head casing detail that existed before.This head casing cap detail should replicate the original. Camp—Windows should be 6-over-6 with original headcasing cap detail. Thinks the 2-over-1 windows are original as they were.typical to the Victorian era. - Patten—Should be all 6-over-6 and 1'UL. Coombs—Should all be 6-over-6 and 1'LL.The 2 gable windows should be separated. Welch—Quired applicant's agent if the (2)windows in question can be used elsewhere at the house in the refit process; agent confirmed. Clarified existing versus replacement windows and sizes.The front 1st floor windows should be 6-over- 6 or 2-over-1 '1'DL and black storms to match existing. Side windows could be simulated-divided light (SDL). Other windows to be removed should have the same treatment.Explained where to find the window survey form. Oliver—In 2017,the windows were all 2-over-1 s and the side windows were 6-over-6. Motion Motion to Approve through staff with the 1st-floor front windows to be 2-over-1 TDL with black storms and side windows to be SDL with black-framed screens and submission of a window survey into the file. (Camp) Roll-call vote Carried 4-1//Camp,Oliver,Thornewill,and Welch-aye;Coombs-any Certificate# HDC2022-08-6894 2. _-___lt, ___g.,_—____ _ _1 4Baybenry-Lafie Fence 6 /57 Linda William:, Ti- I MS126':NT`08.6893 _ ,n 126:5 Main Street » :_' New-dwelling .ti 12:3.3/9S Linda Williarris.. 9 Oran g'e Street , Hardscape2&drfveway 42 31/150 Robert—Ran ;4 ,Robext Kuhn 08�G$20.r � � „ Voting Welch,Coombs,Camp,Oliver,Thornewill Alternates Patten Recused None Documentation None Representing None Public None . Concerns(4;29) Not opened at this time. Motion Motion to Hold for representation. (Oliver) Roll-call vote Carried 5-0//Oliver,Camp,Coombs,Thornewill,and Welch-aye Certificate# 5 I7anielnConway,08°6883 : .3'Meadow Lane - ' ;`; 1/,398. D „ Page 3 of 16 HDC Minutes for September 27,2022,adopted Oct. 11 I,6 NIR Retail 08=6885 -` 7:8 Old South:Wharf Fenestration Changes:::•' 42 4 2/2.4 Permits,:Plus Voting Welch,Coombs,Camp,Oliver,Patten • Alternates Thornewill Recused None Documentation Architectural elevation plans,site plan,photos,correspondence,historical documents,and advisory comments. Representing Mark Poor,Permits Plus Public None Concerns(4:29) Poor—Presented project,Bar Yoshi. Backus—Old South Wharf Cottages circa 1969, contributing according to NHL data. Historic information should be provided. Adding the gable-structured addition alters the structure; adding multiple ganged windows eliminates the simplistic character-defining feature of the cottage.Removing the batten doors is not appropriate;the north elevation is seen from the harbor and the public way.The design for the restaurant was appropriate.It would be nice to know how these two structures relate. Read the HSAG comments:All of the doors on those shops are red painted batten doors;these doors should remain as batten doors with or without sash of a similar style to existing. Window sash and doors should be red. There are too many windows.They should be fewer with more separation.The west vent should be made of wood.Asked if there are any exterior air-conditioning units(AC). Oliver She doesn't have a comparative visual or where the two structures are in relation to each other.The side facing the water should remain as is.A view would be good.Agrees with advisory comments. • Camp—The proposed is missing the character of the batten doors,which give the flavor of being on the wharf. Coombs—The proposal is inappropriate.The water side should remain as is.They should continue to look like a bunch of cottages.Asked what's going into the wart. Patten—Agrees.She'd like more information showing the related locations. Welch—It would be helpful to have images of what is being worked with. Motion Motion to Hold for revisions and more information. (Coombs) Roll-call vote Carried 5-0//Coombs,Patten,Oliver,Camp,and Welch-aye Certificate# HDC2022-08-6885 7. Partners Healthcare 60 Meadowview Drive New tertiary dwelling 51/167 Dennis Patnaude Voting Welch,Coombs,Camp,Oliver,Thornewill Alternates Patten Recused None Documentation Architectural elevation plans,site plan,and photos. Representing Dennis Patnaude,RJ O'Connell&Associates Inc. Kris Megna,Dreamline Modular Public None Concerns(4:40) Megna—Presented project.Driveway is crushed stone. Thornewill—The primary structure should be in front dropping toward the rear to the tertiary. Coombs—Agrees the primary structure should be in front facing the street. Welch—Asked to view this. Oliver—The address is Meadowview Drive but intersects with Somerset; the houses around this are 1-story so this in front would be more appropriate to the streetscape. Camp—Agrees with Ms. Oliver.Also,the vegetation should be in front. Motion Motion to Approve as submitted. (Oliver)Not carried. Motion to Hold for revisions and each set to have a site plan and to go on a view. (Camp) Roll-call vote Carried 4-0//Camp,Coombs,Thornewill,and Welch-aye;Oliver abstain Certificate# • Page 4 of 16 HDC Minutes for September 27,2022,adopted Oct. 11 8. Partners Healthcare 60 Meadowview Drive New 2nd dwelling 51/167 Dennis Patnaude Voting Welch,Coombs,Camp,Oliver,Thornewill Alternates Patten Recused None Documentation Architectural elevation plans,site plan,and photos. Representing Dennis Patnaude,RJ O'Connell&Associates Inc. Kris Megna,Dreamline Modular Public None Concerns(4:47) Megna—Presented project. Thornewill — Understands Ms. Oliver's comments about context of the area. Architecturally it's okay but is 24'11" above grade with the main being 29'.The smallest in front is atypical for such a dense development. Coombs — The main house at 29' on Meadowview is inappropriate. All houses on Meadowview have vegetation in front and this vegetation is now gone. The little structure should be tucked into the back. Camp — Not in favor of flush dormers on the front. The windows are too small, and the trim should be more substantial.Front door trim is overly formal.Should have more of a cottage feel to it. Oliver—No comments. . Welch—Agrees large windows would be more appropriate.The frontispiece is "in the middle'of carrying the façade as formal;a transom light over the door with simple trim would be good to balance it out. If the windows are larger, the dormer window meeting rails should align with the eave—nod to John McLaughlin.The pitch is non-traditional for this style,which is typically 8/12 or 9/12. Motion Motion to Hold for revisions and each set to have a site plan and to go on a view. (Camp) Roll-call vote Carried 4-0//Camp,Coombs,Thornewill,and Welch-aye;Oliver abstain Certificate# 9. Partners Healthcare 60 Meadowview Drive New primary dwelling - 51/167 Dennis Patnaude Voting Welch,Coombs,Camp,Oliver,Thornewill Alternates Patten Recused None Documentation Architectural elevation plans,site plan,and photos. Representing_ Dennis Patnaude,RJ O'Connell&Associates Inc. Kris Megna,Dreamline Modular Public None Concerns(4:53) Megna—Presented project;28'2"from grade;roof,trim,sash,and doors are all matching. Oliver—It's appropriate. Camp—She'd prefer it be eave forward.The gable forward looks awkward.The windows are better proportioned but still a little off.It could be successful if the driveway weren't straight to the rear with vegetation to soften it. . Coombs—She'd like to see an elevation of all three structures as seen from the street.The 1st-floor windows should be larger. Thornewill—Agrees it should be an eave forward with a shallow pitch. The mid building could have a porch and be moved to the front if this is going to remain in the rear.Feels these windows are fine. Welch — If the front door is going to be formal, it should have a transom. The fascia detail on the gable isn't appropriate; the rake board is too short,the shadow board is too tall.The roof pitch should be steeper with the height plate dropped.Window sizes going up might not be the solution. Motion Motion to Hold for revisions and each set to have a site plan and to go on a view. (Camp) Roll-call vote Carried 4-0//Camp,Coombs,Thornewill,and Welch-aye;Oliver abstain Certificate# Page 5 of 16 HDC Minutes for September 27,2022,adopted Oct. 11 IX. OLD BUSINESS 08/23/2022 Property owner name Street Address Scope of work Map/Parcel Agent 1'.. .Lions Foot,TJ C 03-5844 9 Sherburne Way Demo 30/37 Topham'Design Voting Camp(acting chair),Welch,Coombs,Oliver,Thornewill Alternates None Recused None Documentation Architectural elevation plans,site plan,photos,historical documents,and advisory comments. Representing Joe Topham,Topham Design Public None Concerns(5:14) Topham—Reviewed additional information regarding age per previous concerns. Backus—'Windy Side" circa 1930 possibly 1923 per Sanborne maps;it is contributing.Not appropriate to demolish a contributing structure which adds to the district's sense of time and place. If demolition is allowed, this should be scanned,and those scans submitted into records. Read HSAG comments:It is not clear what the final building will look like after demolishing the identified sections.The 1939 aerial photo shows a footprint that is nearly identical to the present structure; regardless of the evolution of the building, a cottage that existed in 1939 is an historic structure and deserves to be preserved;demolishing a contributing building to improve someone's view is not what the HDC should be allowing; the HDC's mission statement includes the words"the preservation and protection of historic buildings."The main portion of this building should remain in its current recognizable form. Welch—Appreciates the additional information. Were this a replacement, modifying the design to a more traditional gambrel would be appropriate;he'd prefer a move over demolition.Discussion revolving around this structure being of Individual Significance isn't appropriate,it doesn't meet criteria; lists the criteria; explains how Individually Significant differs from that of a Contributing Structure. Regards criteria, asks for and receives confirmation from Preservation Planner,Holly Backus. Coombs—This is a contributing structure.We're losing houses in this area.She doesn't support the demolition without knowing what will replace it.It's inappropriate to remove a historic structure to open the view.It should be reused. Oliver — Keep what you can; it's a waste to remove it. Its outline has been there since the 1930s and it should be reutilized.The lot should not be left empty.What goes on this lot should at least harken back to this. Thornewill—This has evolved over time and is contributing.She doesn't support a demolition. Camp—She feels it has individual significance to it and been there for 100 years.The interior is full of antique elements. Demolishing it is inappropriate. Discussion about criteria for contributing versus individually significant and if this meets the criteria of the latter. Discussion about the validity of the contributing status of a structure which has been revised so much. Motion Motion to View and Hold for additional historic information. (Welch) Roll-call vote Carried 5-0//Oliver,Welch,Coombs,Thornewill,and Camp-aye Certificate# 2. Chris&Ashley Austin 07-6692 7 Maple Lane New dwelling 67/303 Emeritus Voting Camp (acting chair),Coombs,Oliver Alternates None Recused Welch Documentation Architectural elevation plans,site plan,and photos. Representing Matt MacEachern,Emeritus Development Public None Concerns(5:43) MacEachern—Reviewed changes made per previous concerns.Asked to omit the roof walk without prejudice. Oliver—Appreciates the changes.Still thinks the roof walk is inappropriate for this style. Coombs—Suggested the left shed dormer come in a little on the sides.Agrees the roof walk doesn't go with this house. Camp —Agrees about the roof walk.Wishes there were more differentiating in the mass of the garage stepping back some. Motion Motion to Approve through staff with the front left dormer sides pulled in and no roof walk at this time.. (Oliver) Roll-call vote Carried 3-0//Coombs,Oliver,and Camp-aye Certificate# HDC2022-07-6692 BREAK 3. Eric Silfcn 07 6665 3 Meadow Vicw Drive Roo top-solar 2 . Cotuit Solar Page 6 of 16 HDC Minutes for September 27,2022,adopted Oct. 11 4. Jean Morant01-5621 4 Washington Avenue New pool , 6-.2.4/65 Ton Paul Couture Vpting • Camp (acting chair),Welch,Coombs,Oliver Alternates None Recused None Documentation Landscape design plans,site plan,photos,correspondence,historical documents,and advisory comments. Representing Jon Paul Couture Public Bruce Mandell,for Madaket Residents. Concerns(6:04) Couture—Reviewed changes made per previous concerns;the natural buffer will remain. Backus — There was concern with the property line for the pool and garage meeting zoning; this is within Village Residential Madaket requiring Zoning Board of Appeals (ZBA) permit for a pool. The surround should be softer and more organic including the "boxy" fence and vegetation. Photos show extensive lawn from inside;would help to have photos from the public way.Asked if the pool and garage could swap locations. Oliver—The farther back the pool sits, the likely it is to be visible. The pictures label the front as north but the rear faces north.Also wants the garage to be closer to the street with the pool between it and the house. Welch—Agrees generally. In addition to relocation, the vegetation should be closer to the pool and softer—the yard space in Madaket is traditionally somewhat open with indigenous plant materials in clumps. Concerns are lack of vegetation and visibility down the street.The left side will be visible and the 5'fence on the grass lawn will stand out. Coombs —The pool is inappropriate here; this intersection of Washington and Madaket is very flat and not heavily vegetated,and it sits on the edge of the sideline.It should be set in the grass with no surround and moved back. Mandell—This property is highly visible from Millie's 2nd-floor.The plans are incomplete with no indication of where equipment will be and if it will be buffered. Groundcover doesn't include pols and decks so this will become a very busy site with the garage and pool.We are working with the ZBA to impose further restrictions on pools. Camp—It's inappropriate to have a pool on Washington Avenue;it's very open with a view from Millie's into the pool. Agrees with switching the garage and pol and using the garage for additional screening. Motion Motion to Hold for revisions to orientation moving the pool between the house and garage and address screening of the fence with indigenous plants. (Welch) . Roll-call vote Carried 3-1//Oliver,Camp,and Welch-aye;Coombs-nay Certificate# 5. jean Moran 01-5199, 4 Washington Avenue New garage , 6-.2.4/65 Jon Paul'Coutu"re Voting Camp (acting chair),Welch,Coombs,Oliver Alternates None Recused None Documentation Architectural elevation plans,site plan,photos,correspondence,historical documents,and advisory comments. Representing Jon Paul Couture Public None Concerns(6:22) No comments at this time. Motion Motion to Hold to track. (Welch) Roll-call vote Carried 4-0//Oliver,Coombs,Camp,and Welch-aye Certificate# X.NEW BUSINESS 08/30/2022 Property owner name Street Address Scope of work Map/Parcel Agent 1. Michael Zarcone 08-6964 16 Cherry Street New shed 55/379 Structures Unlimited Voting Welch,Coombs,Camp,Thornewill,Patten Alternates None Recused Oliver Documentation Architectural elevation plans,site plan,photos,historical documents,and advisory comments. Representing Nancy Drahzal,Structures Unlimited Public None Concerns(6:23) Drahzal—Presented project. Backus—Circa 1984 infill.No concerns with the shed. No concern. Motion Motion to Approve as submitted. (Coombs) Roll-call vote Carried 5-0//Coombs,Camp,Patten,Thornewill,and Welch-aye Certificate# HDC2022-08-6964 2. Bruce Turner'08-6966 9 Long Pond Road Sblar roof array _ 59/33 Ack Smart - Voting Welch,Coombs,Camp,Thornewill,Patten Alternates None Recused Oliver Documentation None Representing None Public None Concerns(6:25) Not opened at this time. Motion Motion to Hold for representation. (Coombs) Roll-call vote Carried 5-0//Coombs,Camp,Thornewill,Patten,and Welch-aye Certificate# Page 7 of 16 HDC Minutes for September 27,2022,adopted Oct. 11 3. Kristin Conley 08-6971 91 Hummock Pond Road New dwelling 56/118 EMDA Voting Welch,Coombs,Camp,Oliver,Thomewill ' Alternates Patten Recused None Documentation Architectural elevation plans,site plan,and photos. Representing Ethan McMorrow,Ethan McMorrow Design Associates Public None Concerns(6:29) McMorrow—Presented project.Could make the north elevation the front. Oliver—Appreciate the location.Which elevation is the front is confusing;it looks like it's the bank of French doors. One of the doors should look like a proper front door.Suggested a porch roof over the French door. Camp—It needs a front door,and the bank of French doors shouldn't be on the front. She thinks the dormers will be minimally visible. Coombs—Combine the 2 shed dormers on the east elevation. Thornewill—Concerned the bank of French doors will be visible from the road. Welch— Given its location, the dormers will be at an oblique angle at the back of the property. The doors would be approved subject to screening at the driveway. Motion Motion to Approve with French doors not to be visible at time of inspection and thereafter. (Camp) Roll-call vote Carried 5-0//Camp,Oliver,Coombs,Thornewill,and Welch-aye Certificate# HDC2022-08-6971 4. Steven Cohen Trust 08-6974 8 Sachem Road Demo shed 30/239 WAPD Voting Welch,Coombs,Camp,Oliver,Patten Alternates Thornewill Recused None Documentation Architectural elevation plans,site plan,photos,and historical documents. Representing Sam Titone,Workshop APD Public None Concerns(6:38) Titone—Presented project. Backus — This is a historic neighborhood; the main house is circa 2000. It would be nice for this to be moved if someone wants it. Coombs—It should be approved as a move/demo.It's in good shape. No others have concerns. Motion Motion to Approve as a move off/demolition to be held on the site in the interim. (Coombs) Roll-call vote Carried 5-0//Coombs,Oliver,Camp,Patten,and Welch-aye Certificate# HDC2022-08-6974 5. Steven Cohen Trust 08-6975 8 Sachem Road New shed 30/239 WAPD Voting Welch,Coombs,Camp,Oliver,Patten Alternates Thornewill Recused None Documentation Architectural elevation plans,site plan,photos,and historical documents. Representing Sam Titone,Workshop APD Public • None Concerns(6:42) Titone—Presented project. Oliver—The shed is fine but not sure about the location,which is unusual.Tucked into the corner near the front of the drive would be better. Camp — It should go on the other side but not in front of the house; we don't put sheds in front of the house; it obliterates the front of the house. Consensus agrees. Motion Motion to Hold for revisions to the location. (Coombs) Roll-call vote Carried 5-0//Coombs,Camp,Oliver,Patten,and Welch-aye Certificate# Page 8 of 16 HDC Minutes for September 27,2022,adopted Oct. 11, 6. Olsen Family 08-6976 28 Prospect Street Driveway apron&parking 55.4.4/77.1. Val Oliver Voting ' Welch,Coombs,Camp,Thornewill,Patten Alternates None Recused Oliver Documentation Landscape design plans,site plan,photos,and advisory comments. Representing Val Oliver,V. Oliver Design Public None Concerns(6:50) Oliver—Presented project;10'deep and 19'wide at the street. Backus—The lot is an infill.Zoning was amended to require any encroachment with an apron to have HDC approval first.Brick is appropriate for an apron and gravel is appropriate for the drive.The driveway apron is limited to 10'depth behind the pavement.The apron width is consistent with the area if there were a sidewalk. Clarify the dimension. Read HSAG comments:As proposed it feels like too much brick for this less formal area of Prospect Street.It would be preferable to keep the brick to the width of the sidewalk and use gravel beyond that. Camp—She's fine with a brick but Belgium block apron might be better. Coombs—Its dimensions are good.She'd like Belgium block because it's less formal. Cobblestone would be good too. Thornewill—No concerns. Patten—No concerns. Welch—Brick or Cobblestone.Initiate the flair 5'away from the property line. Motion Motion to Approve through staff with the apron to be Cobblestone and the flair runs 5'from the road into the driveway width. (Camp) Roll-call vote Carried 5-0//Camp,Coombs,Thornewill,Patten,and Welch-aye Certificate# HDC2022-08-6976 7. William Fordyce 08-6977 '3 Darling Street Handicap ramp 42.3.2/163 -- Val Oliver Voting Welch,Coombs,Camp,Thornewill,Patten Alternates None Recused Oliver Documentation Architectural elevation plans,site plan,photos,historical documents,and advisory comments. Representing Val Oliver,V. Oliver Design Public None Concerns(7:01) Oliver—Presented project;circa 1840s.Mr.Fordyce can't get into his house;will be temporary as long as it's needed. Backus—Has a draft Form B for Mr.Fordyce.This is circa 1830 typical Nantucket home attributed to Labin and Mary Swain Paddock.No concerns;design integrates into the architecture;should be temporary not permanent. Read HSAG comments:no concerns as long as it's removable after no long needed. Camp—Supports this as long as it's removed when no longer needed. Consensus agrees. Motion Motion to Approve as temporary in nature,not a permanent alteration. Camp) Roll-call vote Carried 5-0//Camp,Coombs,Thornewill,Patten,and Welch-aye Certificate# HDC2022-08-6977 8. 6 Yawkey Way Nom Tr 08-6978 6 Yawkey Way New duplex 69/298 Val Oliver Voting Welch,Coombs,Camp,Thornewill,Patten Alternates None Recused Oliver Documentation Architectural elevation plans,site plan,and photos. Representing Val Oliver,V. Oliver Design Public None Concerns(7:05) Oliver—Presented project. No concerns. Motion Motion to Approve as submitted. (Camp) Roll-call vote Carried 5-0//Camp,Coombs,Thornewill,Patten,and Welch-aye Certificate# HDC2022-08-6978 Page 9 of 16 HOC Minutes for September 27,2022,adopted Oct. 11 9. Lamb&Nassif 08-6979 38 Wauwinet Road Window replacement 20/21 Val Oliver Voting Welch,Coombs,Camp,Thornewill,Patten Alternates None Recused Oliver Documentation Architectural elevation plans,site plan,and photos. Representing Val Oliver,V. Oliver Design Public None Concerns(7:08) Oliver—Presented project. "Chaos Corner." Backus—Attributed to Ms.Lamb; approximately 1930s possibly older.Due to the age, 1'DL is more appropriate.The 1930s photo shows both 2-over-2 and 6-over-6;thinks 2-over-2 are more contemporary;recommends keeping 6-over-6. Camp—Understands the request for SDLs; suggested the windows visible from the street be 11.)L and the rest can be SDL. Coombs—The mixture should remain as is. Thornewill—She's okay with 2-over-2 but the front should be 6-over-6. Okay with them being SDLs because there'no sidewalk or bike path. Patten—Agrees with keeping it as is. Welch—There will be a bike path past this.Agrees 6-over-6 1'DL on the front with 2-over-2 SDL on the ides. Motion Motion,to Approve through staff with 6-over-6 TDL on the front with 2-over-2 SDL on the ides. (Coombs) Roll-call vote Carried 5-0//Coombs,Camp,Thornewill,Patten,and Welch-aye Certificate# HDC2022-08-6979 10. Anthony Mazotas 08 6980 29 Essex Read 67/611 Cotuit Solar 711. Kathryn Cook 09-6988, 85Low°Beach Road Demo main house ,` 75731.3 IMiichaelBard Voting Welch,Coombs,Camp,Oliver,Thornewill Alternates Patten Recused None Documentation Architectural elevation plans,site plan,photos,historical documents,and advisory comments. Representing Elizabeth Dunne Marcoulier,Architecture and Interior Design Public None Concerns(7:15) Marcoulier—Presented project. Backus — Main dwelling is circa 1976, non-contributing. It would be a shame to demolish this. Dwellings must be advertised for moving for 30 days before demolishing. Oliver—She's okay with this;suggested correcting the address on all the copies. It should be advertised for a move off; barring that,try to save as much material as possible. Camp—Agrees. Coombs—Agrees with Ms. Oliver. Thornewill—Nothing to add. Welch—Nothing to add Motion Motion to Approve as a move-off/demolition meeting Building Department advertisement requirements and allowing people to salvage. (Oliver) Roll-call vote Carried 5-0//Oliver,Camp,Coombs,Thomewill,and Welch-aye Certificate# HDC2022-09-6988 ,12. Kathryn Cook O'9.6989' ,185Low Beach Road Demo garage 75/31.3 Michael Bard 1 Voting Welch,Coombs,Camp,Oliver,Thornewill Alternates Patten Recused None Documentation Architectural elevation plans,site plan,photos,and historical documents Representing Elizabeth Dunne Marcoulier,Architecture and Interior Design Public None Concerns(7:22) Marcoulier—Presented project;circa 2001. Same concerns as for the main house. Motion Motion to Approve as a move-off/demolition meeting Building Department advertisement requirements and allowing people to salvage and reach out to Nantucket Housing. (Oliver) Roll-call vote Carried 5-0//Oliver,Camp,Thornewill,Coombs,and Welch-aye Certificate# HDC2022-09-6989 13. Kathryn Cook 09-6990•° <.' -' .'85 Low Beach Road °D p ` emo ool'house` 75/31.3" .. �e�chael'-;Bard Voting Welch,Coombs,Camp,Oliver,Thornewill Alternates Patten Recused None Documentation Architectural elevation plans,site plan,photos,and historical documents Representing Elizabeth Dunne Marcoulier,Architecture and Interior Design Public None Concerns(7:23) Marcoulier—Presented project;circa 2001 No concerns. Motion Motion to Approve the demolition and making salvage available. (Coombs) Roll-call vote Carried 5-0//Coombs,Camp,Thornewill,Oliver,and Welch-aye Certificate# HDC2022-09-6990 Page 10 of 16 HDC Minutes for September 27,2022,adopted Oct. 11 14. Braine-Ivey08-6961 10 Lily Streef Rev°06-6530:°dormer 73 3.1/1.11° . , Val Oliver Voting ' Camp(acting chair),Coombs,Thornewill,Patten Alternates (Welch Break) Recused Oliver Documentation Architectural elevation plans,site plan,photos,historical documents,and advisory comments. Representing Val Oliver,V.Oliver Design Tim Braine,co-owner Public None Concerns(7:23) Oliver—"The Rambler",presented project. Braine—Explained how they re-worked their plan to keep the quirky character. Backus — Edward Underhill cottage circa 1882. The proposed dormer alters the main facade changing a character defining feature.Doesn't think any of these cottages have shallow pitched dormers. Coombs—The dormer shouldn't take up so much roof on that part of the house.Stretch roses across the dormer. Patten—It's needed but not sure how it fits into the house and style of`Sconset. Thornewill—She has no concerns;we've allowed other bump up and this helps give another small detail on the side. Camp—She agrees with Ms:Thornewill;it lightens up that elevation. Motion Motion to Approve as.submitted. (Thornewill) Roll-call vote Carried 4-0//Patten,Coombs,Thornewill,and Camp-aye Certificate# HDC2022-08-6961 15. =Eleven Lincoln AveTrust'08 6929: 32 Jefferson Avenue' Demo'main house _ °3.0/132 ;; .B;otticelli+Pohl Voting Welch,Coombs,Camp,Oliver,Thornewill Alternates Patten Recused None Documentation Architectural elevation plans,site plan,photos,historical documents,and advisory comments. Representing Syi Tong,Botticelli&Pohl Public None Concerns(7:33) Tong—Presented project. Backus—This is non-contributing.The as-built provided are of the previous revisions.No concerns. Thornewill—No concern. Coombs—Okay with it as a move-off/demolition. Camp—She prefers the previously approved;would prefer this be moved or salvaged. Motion Motion to Approve the move-off/demolition advertised per Building Code and salvaging what is possible. (Oliver) Roll-call vote Carried 4-0//Oliver,Coombs,Thornewill,and Welch-a e;Camp abstain Certificate# HDC2022-08-6929 16.sEeeven Lincoln;Ave Trust 086917 z32 Jefferson.Avenue;=`_ ,„ Rev 12-5457 main house 30/132 =` Botttcellia+.Pohl''.' Voting Welch,Coombs,Camp,Oliver,Thornewill Alternates Patten Recused None Documentation Architectural elevation plans,site plan,photos,correspondence,and•advisory comments. Representing Syi Tong,Botticelli&Pohl Public None Concerns(7:33) Tong—Presented project.This is a new design including all the previously approved as well as desired revisions. Backus — It's confusing if the main-house application is a revision to the previously approved plans or a newly constructed dwelling.For clarity's sake the application needs to state it'a new dwelling. Read HSAG comments: The previous gable design was much more appropriate for the neighborhood. A 21/2 story gambrel with 3rd floor dormers is too tall and does not relate to any other buildings nearby; they are very rare on Nantucket, and don't have dormers facing the street. Due to the elevation on the hill, this will feel extraordinarily tall. The overall proportions are not appropriate,especially on the North elevation. Clarification of what is different from the previously approved. Thornewill—A gambrel is too much for this site;it makes the 3rd-floor too full;the original application did that more appropriately.North elevation main gambrel on the right is"limp".Suggested lowering the grade with the gable design. Coombs — Agrees; the gambrel is too heavy to on a hill; she doesn't support this. They should use the previously approved drawings. Camp—The gambrel roof line is very complicated especially on the south and north elevations.The gable was simple and old-fashioned. Oliver—Okay with a gambrel; 17 Lincoln is a big gambrel as well as one down on Jefferson Avenue.The proportions of the north elevation are off.The previously approved was better. Welch—Agrees: The width of primary gambrel (south?)•could be truncated without losing 2.d-floor program, though the opposite side would be compromised. Given consensus of the group's comments,it will come down whether or not you want to go back to the previously approved. Motion Motion to Hold for revisions. (Coombs) Roll-call vote Carried 5-0//Coombs,Thornewill,Oliver,Camp,and Welch-aye Certificate# Page 11 of 16 HDC Minutes for September 27,2022,adopted Oct. 11 :717: Shenandoah Trust 08-6925 -40 Easton Street: Rev. 11,6592:fenest chn 42.1.4/20 Botticelli+Pohl, Voting Welch,Coombs,Camp,Oliver,Thornewill Alternates Patten Recused None Documentation Architectural elevation plans,site plan,photos,correspondence,historical documents,and advisory comments. Representing Syi Tong,Botticelli&Pohl Public None Concerns(7:54) Tong — Presented project; asked about the possibility of using SDLs with 5/8" historic muntins; he'll forward the addresses of other structures with these windows.All existing windows are Andersen windows.. Backus—Circa 1893 eclectic within Brant Point old historic district. The previous east elevation was more in keeping with the historic structure.East elevation needs to be revised. Read HSAG comments:The proposed east addition has shifted forward to within a few inches of the front wall on the second floor. This essentially extends that wall another 10 or 12 feet distorting the massing facing the street; this addition worked much better when it was set back 6'feet or so. Oliver—From the east,the mass moving forward hides the main mass corner boards. Camp—The previous east elevation was more appropriate. Okay with south elevation changes. Coombs—Agrees about the east elevation. Thornewill—Okay with the south elevation:Agrees the secondary mass on the left of the north shouldn't be pushed so far forward;it'll read as part of the primary mass. Welch — The concept with the vertical boards for FEMA clearances, there is no sense of a horizontal break of the vertical boards accomplished with perception of posts at intervals and at the corners;may consider simply using a wider board for this effect.Suggested submitting images of the SDLs they wish to use and flag locations that could be viewed. Motion Motion to Hold for revisions and more information and places to view windows. (Oliver) Roll-call vote Carried 5-0//Oliver,Camp,Coombs,Thornewill,and Welch-aye Certificate# , 18. Joseph Motta.08-6962 ' 38/40 Cliff Road Addition 42.44/43 Thorpewili Voting Welch,Coombs,Camp,Oliver,Patten Alternates None Recused Thornewill Documentation Architectural elevation plans,site plan,photos,correspondence,historical documents,and advisory comments. Representing Luke Thornewill,Thomewill Design Public None Concerns(8:09) Thornewill—Presented project. Backus — Circa 1804 Greek revival. Appreciates keeping the additive massing to the rear. The rear addition windows dates later than thought. Recommend the plan should show in read removal of the existing rear, photos of existing conditions.The back roof addition on the right over the sunroom,the visual intrusion should be minimized to retain the main silhouette. Read HSAG comments:No concerns Oliver—That roof is 30'back from the front of the house so thinks it won't be discernable in 3D. Camp—Thinks since it has a cedar roof,it'll fade away.She has no concerns. Coombs—Agrees with Ms. Camp. Patten—Nothing to add Welch—Could clip the gable reminiscent of the hipped roof,but given the 3D and distance thinks it'll be oaky Motion Motion to Approve as submitted. (Oliver) Roll-call vote Carried 5-0//Oliver,Camp,Patten,Coombs,and Welch-aye Certificate# HDC2022-08-6962 19: ,We R6m4no-08.0981- 55-Eastipn'T Street * 'Ngv'shed .,42.4.1/186 'Shelter,7 Voting Welch,Coombs,Camp,Oliver,Patten Alternates Thornewill Recused None Documentation None Representing None Public None Concerns(8:19) Not opened at this time. Motion Motion to Hold for representation. (Oliver) Roll-call vote Carried 5-0//Oliver,Camp,Coombs,Patten,and Welch-aye Certificate# Page 12 of 16 HDC Minutes for September 27,2022,adopted Oct. 11 20. Nick Pappas 08-6984 7 Beaver Street ` „ - Rev.03-6067: main house" 55.1.4/82 Va1 Oliver Voting ° Welch,Coombs,Camp,Thornewill,Patten Alternates None Recused Oliver Documentation Architectural elevation plans,site plan,photos,correspondence,historical documents,and advisory comments. Representing Val Oliver,V.Oliver Design Public None Concerns(8:20) Oliver-Presented project. Backus - Circa 1839. Appreciate reusing west elevation window. When it comes to rear ells, raising the height isn't always necessary. Read HSAG comments:no concerns. No concerns. Motion Motion to Approve as submitted. (Camp) Roll-call vote Carried 5-0//Camp,Coombs,Thornewill,Patten,and Welch-aye . Certificate# HDC2022-08-6984 Rest held for Oct.4 21. CCH 67 Br LLC 08-6904 67 Bartlett Road Roof top solar 66/435 Sun Wind , 22. High Cliff Trust 08-6985 11 East Hallowell Lane Rev 04-6206:windows 30/17 Botticelli+Pohl 23. High Cliff'Trust 09-6986, 11 East Hallowell Lane' Rev.04-6191:grg windows 30/17 Botticelli+,Pohl 24. Sea Realty Trust 08-6923 25 Squam Road Demo cottage 21/5 .Botticelli+Pohl 25. Auburn Cotta e LLC 08-6920 46 Easton Street Rev.06-6463:main house 42.4.1/22 Botticelli'+Pohl 26. Jeannette&Bob LLC 09-6987 43 Kendrick Avenue New guest house 76.4.3/31 CWA 27. Dorothy ACK LLC 08-6934 2 Mariner Way New dwelling 55.1.4/72.4 Linda Williams 28. Dorothy ACK LLC 08-6937 2 Mariner Way Hardscape 55.1.4/72.4 Linda Williams 29. Dorothy ACK LLC 08-6939 4 Mariner Way New dwelling 55.1.4/72 Linda Williams 30. Dorothy ACK LLC 08-6941 4 Mariner Way New garage 55.1.4/72 Linda Williams 31. Dorothy ACK LLC 08-6943 4 Mariner Way New pool&hardscape 55.1.4/72 Linda Williams 32. Dorothy ACK LLC 08-6930 6 Mariner Way New dwelling 55.1.4/72.2 Linda Williams 33. Dorothy ACK LLC 08-6931 6 Mariner Way Hardscape 55.1.4/72.2 Linda Williams 34. Edward O'Brien 9b Hussey Farm Road Addition 56/96.2 Linda Williams 35. Jay Harmon Lot 2 Maple Lane New pool 67/303 LINK 36. Jay Harmon Lot 2 Maple Lane Porch addition 67/303 LINK 37. Nantucket Lifesaving Museum 158 Polpis Road Replace windows 27/28 LINK 38. John Ribik 12 Chuck Hollow Road Bulkhead shed 72/29 Linda Williams 39. Richmond Crcat Pt 08 6778 1 Bluc Court New-dwelling 684-348 KOH 10. Richmond Great Pt 08 6779 5 Bluc Court 68/315 KOH 11. Richmond Crcat Pt 08 6777 7 Blue Court New dwelling 68/311 KOH 12. Richmond Great Pt 08 6787 9 Blue Court 68/313 KOH 13. Richmond Great Pt 08 6786 11 Blue Court New dwelling 68/312 KOII 11. Richmond Great Pt 08 6789 5 Sandplain 68/ KOH 45. Corkish Coo• 09-7046 320e Pol.is Road New shed 24/1.5 Structures Unlimited XI. OLD BUSINESS 09/06/2022 Property owner name Street Address Scope of work Map/Parcel Agent 1. Joseph Minella 03-5939 • , 9 Gingy Lane New Dwelling 41/851, ' SCI 2. Joseph Minella 06-6555 9,Gingy Lane. Solar main house 41/851 SCI 3. Joseph Minella 03-5937 9 Gingy Lane Pool&°hardscaping 41/851 ° SCI 4. Brew Bean 01-5615 2 Candle House Lane. New Dwelling 55.4.1/1 Concept Design ` 5. Jason Mendelson 05-6328 7a Sherburne Turnpike New dwelling 30/112 Studio Ppark 6. Nantucket G&S,LLC 07-6725 81 Vestal Street New fence 56/254 MCA+ 7. Conway Family 08-4328 167 Surfside Road New dwelling 87/118 Val Oliver 8: Sankaty,LLC 06-6439 49 Sankaty°Road ,.New dwelling , 49/60 Dustin Maury 9. GregoryTourt6'07 6727 20 Midland Avenue ' New dwelling 59.3/164 Gryphon Architects '10. Greo Tourto 07-6728 20Midland Avenue ':Ne • ra•estio 93/14 G'jhon Architects ' ;o _a _ d 5 XII.NEW BUSINESS 09/13/2022 Property owner name Street Address Scope of work Map/Parcel Agent 1. Jacqueline,Welch 09-6997 - 38 Union Street - 'Covered Deck ° 42:3.2/88, George Win g 2. Kim Kilgore 09-7034 19 Liberty street. Roof replacement. 42.3.4/111 ` T&T Roofing 3. Doug Mullen 09-7006 ,6 Sconset Avenue ' , Move off cottage, ; ,' ' 49.3.2/12 Topham Design ,' ,4. ,Doug Mullen 09-7007... ' 6 Sconset Avenue 'New dwelling`'- 49.3.2/12 ° Topham=Design 5. , 13 ComniercialWf,LLC 09-6996 ` 13 Commercial Wharf Rev.,09-4749:reduce struct =42,2.4/10 ,' .NAG 6. Nantucket Land Bank 09-7021 70 Washington Street. Move off/demo , , : ,42.2.3/16 Normand Residential 7. Walter Glowacki 09-7011 5 Meader Street , Rev 04-3953:addition ,, 42.2.3/37.1 Val Oliver 8. ,,G2Bunker Hill,LLC 09-7005 ,,7 Bunker Hill' ';Alterations , 73.4.2/39`., Topham,Designs 9. David Laura Finley 09-7017 7 New Lane Door&window change , '.41/285' EMDA Page13of16 HDC Minutes for September 27,2022,adopted Oct. 11 10. 5 Orange St,LLC 09-7016 '.5 Orange Street Porch doors&windows rev 42.3.1/149, Thornewill Designs 11. Elizabeth Almodobar 09-.6999E 4 Atlantic Avenue like Kind wndows&doors •55.4.1/46' ElizabethAlnibdobar , 12. 41 Hulbert,LLC 09-7036 41 Hulbert Avenue' Raise GH&fenes revs 29/18 Botticelli+Pohl 13. 32`Hulbert Trust 09-7037 32 Hulbert Avenue, Rev. 11-5220 29/72: ° Botticelli+Pohl 14. Carol Muehling 09-7013 17 Okorwaw Way New Dwelling 79/180 Thornewill Design 15. Carol Muehling 09-7014 17 Okorwaw Way New pool 79/180 Thornewill Design 16. William Waldorf 09-7001 50 Madaquecham Vly Rd New guest house 88/74 EMDA 17. Stark Point,T T C09,-6993 a '16'Easton Street Rev.04-6118:main house - 42.1.4/11 Botticelli+Pohl 18. Stark Point,LLC 09-6994 16 Easton Street • Rev.04-6122m . 42.1.4/11 Botticelli+Pohl 19. Crow's Nest,LLC 09-6995 9B Crow's Nest Way Raise,addition,reno 12/20.22 Botticelli+Pohl 20. Nantucket Boat Basin 09-7028 29 Commercial Street Demo/replace like kind - 42/24.1' . Dennis Patnaude , 21. Barbara Phillips Trust 09-7023 7 North Liberty Street Rev. 12-2628 , 42.3.4/6 ° Val Oliver 22. Elizabeth Phillips 09-70101 ° 4 Pittman Road New shed F 73.4.2/61 ° Elizabeth Phillips ' 23. Deborah Wasil 09-7015 51 Pleasant Street Replace windows , • 55/32.3 Structures Unlimited 24. Town of Nantucket 09-7049 16 Broad Street Alterations ` 42.4.2/30 Rick Sears, 25. Town of Nantucket 09-7057 20 South Water Street Alterations Bldg 1 42.4.2/29 Rick Sears" , . t 26. Town of Nantucket 09-7058 20 South Water Street Alterations Bldg 2. ' . 42.4.2/29 Rick Sears _ 27. 5.Sherburne Way,LLC 09-7003 5 Sherburne Way New Beach stairs 30/38 Botticelli+Pohl 28. Michael Zarcone 09-7010 16 Cherry Street Minor alterations 55/379 , Val Oliver 29. TwentyOne MilkSt Tr 09-7033 21 Milk Street Parking 42.3.3/87 David Troast 30. John Welch.09-7039'. . 40 D Union Street Infill dormer 42.3.2/89 , Gryphon Architects 31. Eleven Lincoln Ave Tr09-7051 , 32 Jefferson Avenue New guest house. 30/132 Botticelli+Pohl_ . 32. 40 OSR,LLC 09-7045 40 Old South Rd 39/40 New dwelling mixed use 68/410 Emeritus LI'D 33. 40 OSR,LLC 09-7046 40 Old South Rd Lot 41 New Dwellin:mixed use 68/10 Emeritus LID XIII. OLD BUSINESS 09/20/2022 Property owner name Street Address Scope of work Map/Parcel Agent 1. 42.EastonSt,LLC:07-6755 42 Easton Street Add Shuttersi• ' 42.4.1/21 Emeritus'LTD ' 2.' Frank Twarog 05-6231 18B Atlantic Avenue Patio;fence,arbor&drive 55/24.2 Todd Farrell 3. Frank Gannon 04-6147 6 Sandy Drive New dwelling 29/76 NAG 4: `Patience Killen- 1 Old North Wharf • Demo/move off 42.3.1/80.1 ' Linda Williams , 5. High Tide Prtnrs,LLC 04-6196 26 Douglas Way Main House 39/41 BPC 6. High Tide Prtnrs,LLC 04-6198 26 Douglas Way Garage 39/41 BPC 7. High Tide Prtnrs,LLC 04-6193 26 Douglas Way Gazebo _ 39/41 BPC 8. High Tide Prtnrs,LLC 04-6197 26 Douglas Way Pool 39/41 BPC 9. High Tide Prtnrs,LLC 04-6172 26 Douglas Way Shed 39/41 BPC r 10. Petrillo&`Thomas Tr'07-6598 ° . 92 Washington Street Rev.02-0589:small addition 42.4.1/22 Smith&Hutton LLC 11. Petrillo&Ripley„ 92 Washington Street Hardscape , 42.4.1/22 Studio 211'2 12. Mike Romano, . 55 Easton Street -,° Addition`&move on site 42.4.1/68 Shelter 7. 13. Ack N Back,LLC 06-6502 33 Quidnet Road New dwelling 21/27.2-27.4 WAPD 14. Ack N Back,LLC 06-6503 33 Quidnet Road Garage&studio 21/27.2-27.4 WAPD 15. Ack N Back,LLC 06-6504 . 33 Quidnet Road Pool cabana 21/27.2-27.4 WAPD 16. Ack N Back,LLC 08-6785 33 Quidnet Road Pool&hardscape 21/27.2-27.4 Ahern Design 17. 4 The Kids Realty Tr 07-6708 79 Pocomo Road Rev. 10-4971:add roof walk 15/5 CWA 18. Brandon Lower 08-6790 ', 146 Main Street New garage,patio&pergola '41/518 Matthew Rider 19. Brandon Lower 08-6781 ' , ' 146 Main.Street MH clapbrd,perg,trim clr 41/518 Matthew Rider 20. Not.so Eas ,LLC 06-5679. 26 Eas Street New mixed-use structure 42.4.2/23 Emeritus XIII. NEW BUSINESS 09/27/2022 Property owner name Street Address Scope of work Map/Parcel Agent 1. Valentine Hussey,,LLC' 31 Main Street , Roof replacement r g 42.3.1/212. Jim Lydon '` ''2. . McGovern.Moriarty , . ., . 26 Lincoln Avenue y . Rev.07-6633:rear,doors .. '.73.4.2/3, , Thornewill Design 3. Scimone 6 Sandpiper Way Renew COA 76/89 Watersca es 4. Jayne Culkins, . 20 West York Street Window replacement 55/7.1 ' 'Ernie Culkins° . 5. , Tom`Forman ' ., ' ` ' ' . 6 Coffin Street Sias _E . Rev. 12-5323:hardscape;,` 711.4/19 Waterscapes 6. Richard Holt 121 Madaket Road Barn addition 40/60.1 Botticelli+Pohl 7. Ron Lefevre 7a Maryann Drive New 2nd dwelling 68/216 SCI 8. HJB NI Trust 30 Western Avenue Window modification 87/79 SCI 9. Amy Ambrecht 13 Gingy Lane Garage as-built revisions 41/850 SCI 10. Brian Wright,, 2A Copper Lane ' Hardscape ' 42.3.3/191 SC1 . ..• ' 11. Hillary Cunniff 37 York Street ' Roof replacement' 55.4.1/104 SCI 12. Hillary Cunniff .•" , 37 York Street ., . 'New gaffe , 55.4.1/104" SCI 13. Mark Alderman ' 17 High Brush Path . Rev.05-6413:addition 56/375 SCI 14. Margaret Zarcone 16 Cherry Street Roof replacement 55/379 Stegra Corp: ..15. .Lisa Linton • ' " 2 Creel,Lane .. New pool&hardscape ,38/93 , Andrew Falkenstein 16. Dipak Thapa 37 Beachgrass Road Solar roof array-house 68/369 ACK Smart Page 14 of 16 HDC Minutes for September 27,2022,adopted Oct. 11 17. Dipak Thapa 37 Beachgrass Road Solar roof array-shed 68/369 ACK Smart 18. `Lois•Sager 33 Hulbert Avenue Roof replacement 29/21 Linda Williams. 19. KMS Nt 126R Main Street Demo Garage 42.3.3/98.1 Linda Williams 20. Catherine Sperry 4 Chapel Street Roof replacement° 73.4.2/19 ° Jim Lydon 21 Cary AhI __ _ , mY # 5 Pochick Street Sias` Add`door&_projecting roof ,73.3.1/ DTA 22. Ocean Heath,LLC . '9 Fa�ltnouth Avenue �� Window revision . 82/423 JN Design N_• • 23. Leon Francis 10 Killdeer Lane New shed 66/661 Leon Francis 24. Carlos Sousa 20 Vesper Lane Replace fence 55/248 Carlos Sousa 25. Dan Conley 91 Hummock Pond Rd New pool 56/118 Craig Taylor 26. 79 Polpis Rd RE,LLC 79 Polpis Road New Dwelling 44/23.3 Dustin Maury 27. 79 Polpis Rd RE,LLC 79 Polpis Road New garage 44/23.3 Dustin Maury 28. 79 Polpis Rd RE,LLC 79 Polpis Road New pool 44/23.3 Dustin Maury 29. 79 Polpis Rd RE,LLC / 79 Polpis Road New cabana 44/23.3 Dustin Maury 30. Rosalie&Grennan°Maloney .15 Old North Wharf Renewal of COA w/revs 42.3.1/26 McMullen&Assoc. 9 31. Michael Altman Trst Et al. 37 Sankaty Head Road Main house revision 48/2 BPC 32. Michael Altman Trst Et al. 37 Sankaty Head Road Guest house revision 48/2 BPC 33. Tic T'Ack Toe,LLC 2 Fawn Lane New dwelling 68/972 Meerbergen Design 34. Tic T'Ack Toe,LLC 2 Fawn Lane Pool&Hardscape 68/972 Meerbergen Design 35. Tic T'Ack Toe,LLC 3 Fawn Lane New dwelling 68/971 Meerbergen Design 36. Tic T'Ack Toe,LLC 3 Fawn Lane Pool&Hardscape 68/971 Meerbergen Design 37. Tic T'Ack Toe,LLC 4 Fawn Lane New dwelling 68/973 Meerbergen Design 38. Tic T'Ack Toe,LLC 4 Fawn Lane Pool&Hardscape 68/973 Meerbergen Design 39. Tic T'Ack Toe,LLC 5 Fawn Lane New dwelling 68/970 Meerbergen Design 40. Tic T'Ack Toe,LLC 5 Fawn Lane Pool&Hardscape 68/970 Meerbergen Design 41. Tic T'Ack Toe,LLC 6 Fawn Lane New dwelling 68/974 Meerbergen Design 42. Tic T'Ack Toe,LLC 6 Fawn Lane Pool&Hardscape 68/974 Meerbergen Design 43. Tic T'Ack Toe,LLC 7 Fawn Lane New dwelling 68/979 Meerbergen Design 44. Tic T'Ack Toe,LLC 7 Fawn Lane Pool&Hardscape 68/979 Meerbergen Design 45. Tic T'Ack Toe,LLC 9 Fawn Lane New dwelling 68/978 Meerbergen Design 46. Tic T'Ack Toe,LLC 9 Fawn Lane • Pool&Hardscape 68/978 Meerbergen Design 47. Tic T'Ack Toe,LLC 13 Fawn Lane New dwelling 68/976 Meerbergen Design 48. Tic T'Ack Toe,LLC 13 Fawn Lane Pool&Hardscape 68/976 Meerbergen Design 49. Tic T'Ack Toe,LLC 15 Fawn Lane New dwelling 68/975 Meerbergen Design 50. Tic T'Ack Toe,LLC 15 Fawn Lane Pool&Hardscape . 68/975 Meerbergen Design 51. L.Iannetta&D.Fisher 7 Paul Jones Addition 30/68.12 Emeritus LTD 52. Suzanne Turner 9 Long Pond Drive Rev.11-2257:resite garage 59/33 Botticelli+Pohl 53. Little Nauti,LLC 1 Smooth Hummock Wy New dwelling 66/177 JB Studio. 54. Little Nauti,LLC 1 Smooth Hummock Wy New pool 66/177 JB Studio 55. Charliston Pires 62 Hooper Farm Road New shed .67/321 JB Studio 56. Charliston Pires 62 Hooper Farm Road New pool 67/321 JB Studio 57. Alan&Mary Raul 169 Main Street Fenestration chugs ° 42.3.3/150`. JB Studio 58. Rufio ACK Holdings ; 93 Main Street .' New shed . 42.3.3/17 JB Studio , 59. Berry Pleasant,LLC . ; 15 Pleasant Street ' MH Alterations 42.3.3/123 Patrick Ahern 60. Berry Pleasant,LLC 15 Pleasant Street New carriage house • 42.3.3/123 Patrick Ahern 61. Berry Pleasant,LLC 15 Pleasant Street - Hardscape . . 42.3.3/123 Patrick Ahern XIV. OTHER BUSINESS Approved Minutes September 13,2022 Motion Motion to Approve. (Camp) Roll-call vote Carried 4-0//Camp,Oliver,Coombs,and Patten-aye;Welch abstain Review Minutes September 20,2022 Other Business • Next HDC Meeting: Tuesday, October 4th @ 4:00 pin Hybrid - Zoom & 4 Fairgrounds Road, Community Room • Letter to CPC endorsing the tree mapping:motion made 9/20 to draft the letter of support. • Classification of street trees&vegetating mapping • Discussion of Wind Turbines • Section 106-Sunrise Wind Farm Project,intro (update as needed) • Review policy of Move/Demo hearings in relation to new dwellings • Hardscaping • Discussion of salvaging demolitions • Discussion of options for house moves Page 15of16 - HDC Minutes for September 27,2022,adopted Oct. 11 • List of additional documents used at the meeting: 1. Draft minutes as listed 2. HDC draft letter supporting funding for tree mapping. Adjournment: Motion Adjourned at 8:28 pm. (Camp) Roll-call vote Carried 5-0//Camp,Oliver,Coombs,Thornewill,and Welch-aye Submitted by: Terry L.Norton antucket Old Historic Distc� PScgnset.Old Historic District Madaket Village District pign Advisory Grow) • Page 16 of 16