HomeMy WebLinkAboutVolume 1_02554 Draft Version 3_LG edits Feb 3Volume 1 Page 4 Wastewater UpdateCOMMENT/QUESTIONCORNERCommentsand/orquestionsfortheWastewaterPlanUpdatecanbesentto:Sewerproject@nantucket-ma.govAnswersand/orcommentswillappearinfuturevolumesofthisnewsletterand/oraddressedatBoardofSelectmenmeetings.16BroadStreetNantucket,Massachusetts02554TOWNOFNANTUCKETPhone:508-228-7255Fax:508-228-7272LocalPostalPatronTheBoardofSelectmenwillbeholdingworkshopmeetingsontheWastewaterPlanonWednesday,February10,2016andǡ ͻǡʹͲͳǣͲͲϐϐ ǡͶ ǤmeetingswillbebroadcastliveonNCTV18andcanalsobeviewedonlineathttp://nantucket-ma.gov/363/Video-On-DemandAllarewelcomeandencouragedtoattend.FEBRUARY&MARCH2016WHAT’SNEXT?We’reonthewebatwww.nantucket-ma.gov/259/Wastewater-Action-PlanVolume 1 Page 1 Wastewater Update
The CWMP Update is complete and the Town now has a state approved 20-year wastewater
plan. The major goal of the CWMP Update was to measure how clean our waters are and de-
velop a solution to address water quality Island-wide.
We can tell how healthy our harbors,
streams, ponds, creeks and estuaries are
by the creatures that live there. Decades of
studies by scientists looked at our waters
and their environments in order to deter-
mine how healthy they are and what crea-
tures and plants depend on the waters and
their habitats. One example, in Nantucket
and Polpis Harbors, are scallops that de-
pend on eelgrass to thrive. If eelgrass is
dying because of pollution in the water, then the scallops cannot survive. If the scallops cannot sur-
vive, then the scalloping industry will not survive. It is a domino effect.
Polluting of our water resources impacts us all. Nantucket depends
on its water resources for drinking water, public health, tourism,
fishing, boating, swimming, recreation, livelihoods and sole source
sustainability. These water resources help make Nantucket unique
and special.
This newsletter is the first of a series of public outreach efforts to help
you understand what this pollution is, what is causing it, how we can control it, at what cost, and how
we can all play a part to help. The CWMP Update examined the science and engineering and devel-
oped a plan to end this pollution. We are moving forward to implement this plan and need your sup-
port.The Board of Selectmen and Town Administration are committed to preserving and
protecting Nantucket’s water resources.
WHAT IS CAUSING THE POLLUTION?A major cause is nitrogen. Nitrogen is in our septicsys-
tems, fertilizers and stormwater. All of these drain into our groundwater, which then flows into our
harbors, ponds, streams and estuaries carrying the pollution with it. One cause and effect of too
much nitrogen is that it produces exces-
sive algae blooms, which limits sunlight
through the water and kills off eel grass
in the Harbors, which is impacting scal-
loping, as well as many other environ-
mental resources.
Nitrogen pollution reduces the quality of
our waters, which will impact recreation-
al uses, the environment, public health
and potentially our drinking water. Over-
use of fertilizer, roadway and rooftop
runoff from storms and septic systems
that leach into the ground are the largest contributors to this pollution that as a community we CAN
control. Plans to eliminate or lessen these impacts to our environment are contained in the CWMP
Update.
Nantucket
WastewaterManagementPlanUpdate
WastewaterPlanUpdateTOWNOFNANTUCKETBOARDOFSELECTMENVolume 1
February 2016
ComprehensiveWastewater
ManagementPlan(CWMP)UpdateComplete
In nitrogen enriched waters, eelgrass is increasingly covered by algae ;left: healthy eel grass
(right). Photo credit: Joe Costa.
Photo credit Joe Costa
Volume 1 Page 2 Wastewater Update
HOW CAN WE STOP THE POLLUTION?
The CWMP Update outlines plans to extend sewer, manage/reduce
fertilizer use and contain
stormwater where possible
in order to stop the flow of
harmful nutrients.
Sewer
Septic systems are the
largest contributor to the
nitrogen pollution that we
have the ability to control.
Removing septic systems
eliminates the pollutants from entering the groundwater and thus
provides protection of our water resources in multiple ways. Re-
moving wastewater from entering the groundwater eliminates risk to
nearby drinking water supplies, protects the public health from po-
tential contamination, protects pollution from environmental areas
nearby, as well as protects our water resources from pollution by
nutrients like nitrogen.
We can extend municipal
sewer in areas determined to
be at risk with resource pol-
lution. We have room to
treat additional wastewater
at the Surfside Wastewater
Treatment Facility (WWTF).
The WWTF is able to dis-
charge thoroughly cleaned
water to the ground in the existing sand beds. This is a “highest
and best use”of a facility we currently own and operate, so it makes
sound financial sense to use it to its full capacity. The Town re-
ceived approval from the MassDEP to sewer all areas from the
CWMP Update Report shown as needing an off site wastewater
solution. The map below shows the nine geographic areas (colored
and labeled) proposed for future sewer. Gray areas stay on septic.
Fertilizer
The Town developed and implemented
fertilizer regulations, Board of Health Local
Regulation 75.00, to manage fertilizer use
Island wide. The Natural Resources De-
partment took the lead with implementing
the regulations, working to develop and
complete educational sessions, as well as
bringing the process of licensing the land-
scapers to fruition. All of this work is on-
going and being enforced, specifically in
areas where the science is telling us that
overuse is impacting our water resources.
Continuing to reduce fertilizer overuse by
incorporating the guidelines developed in
the Town’s Best Management Practices
for Landscape Fertilizer Use on Nantucket
will contribute towards eliminating another
source of excessive nitrogen pollution
from our waters.
Stormwater
Work with stormwater is ongoing, especially in the Town area along
Nantucket Harbor. The DPW
regularly sweeps streets and
cleans catch basins to keep runoff
from entering the water resources.
Town drainage projects include
addressing runoff into the water
that happens with undersized
pipes and existing outfall pipes
that contribute to pollution.
Managing wastewater, fertilizer use, as well as stormwater,
reduces the pollutants going in to our waters.
“The purpose of the BEST
MANAGEMENT PRACTICES FOR
NANTUCKET [BMP] is to provide
science based guidelines for
ĨĞƌƟůŝnjĞƌƵƐĞĂŶĚŽƚŚĞƌůĂŶĚƐĐĂƉĞ
ƉƌĂĐƟĐĞƐƚŚĂƚ͕ǁ ŚĞŶĨŽůůŽǁ ĞĚ͕
reduce the loss of soil nutrients
ĨƌŽŵĞdžĐĞƐƐŝǀ Ğ͕ŝŶĐŽƌƌĞĐƚůLJƟŵĞĚ͕
ŽƌŝŶĂƉƉƌŽƉƌŝĂƚĞĨĞƌƟůŝnjĞƌƐ͘KŶ
Nantucket, lost nutrients find
their way rapidly to the coastal
waters, harbors, ponds, and
streams where they may cause
ĐŽŶƚĂŵŝŶĂƟŽŶƚŚĂƚŝƐŚĂƌŵĨƵůƚŽ
ĂƋƵĂƟĐŽƌŐĂŶŝƐŵƐĂƐǁ ĞůůĂƐƚŽ
human health and welfare.”
Excerpt from
Best ManagementWƌĂĐƟĐĞƐ for
Landscape &ĞƌƟůŝnjĞƌUse on
Nantucket Island
Prepared by theƌƟĐůĞ68 Work Group
2010–2012
Priority Areas for 2016 Annual Town Meeting
The arrows on the map
show the two geograph-
ical areas proposed for
extension of sewer for
consideration the 2016
Annual Town
Meeting Warrant.
Larger maps are posted at
various locations around
Town at Town Hall and
the DPW.
Volume 1 Page 3 Wastewater Update
IF 2016 ANNUAL TOWN MEETING APPROVES THE SEWER PROJECTS, WHAT WILL THE
COST IMPACT BE?
The Town studied various ways to cover the costs of bringing sewer to all of the areas deter-
mined to be removed from traditional septic systems. We took all of this information and
worked to develop scenarios for funding and public acceptance. A Sewer Planning Work
Group (SPWG) was formed and worked diligently to provide the Board with a report detailing
its work in recommending a variety of items, including how to distribute costs fairly and equita-
bly. With the SPWG information, we further refined the funding options and arrived at a plan to
apportion costs between the proposed sewer user and the general tax base. Overall costs in-
clude design, (which is NOT eligible for State Revolving Fund (SRF) funds) and construction. If
the 2016 Annual Town Meeting approves the sewer extension projects, we will apply for the
construction costs under a zero percent state loan program with a 20-year pay back. Under
new state legislation, we can extend the payback an additional 10 years at a low interest rate,
currently at 2 percent. The Town will then be able to finance the cost to the property owner under a Betterment Program,
with payments made over 20 or 30 years. With an interest rate of zero percent, the Town is able to maintain the lowest
possible end user costs. While we understand that these costs are high, our goal is to provide a mechanism to repay indi-
vidual costs at the lowest possible terms.
The two Needs Areas proposed for sewer extension at the 2016 Annual Town Meeting are shown on the map on page 2
and in the box above. The current schedule for sewering proposes Nantucket Harbor Shimmo (formerly shown as
“Monomoy” and encompassing Brewster Road to the southwest to Gardner Road on the northeast and Kelley Road to the
south to the Harbor) as the first area constructed with a planned start date in 2017. PLUS (larger neighborhood in-fill are-
as within or adjacent to the existing Town Sewer District) is proposed to follow in 2019. The April 2016 Annual Town Meet-
ing will ask voters to approve moving forward with this plan.
Estimated planning costs shown in the box above include both project design and construction costs. Once the Town be-
gins the design process, these estimates will be refined, with more accurate costs arrived at during the actual project bid-
ding.
Capital costs apportioned to the property owner can be paid by the assessment of betterments. A betterment is a special
property tax typically used by municipalities to recover the cost of a public improvement, such as sewer. The method under
which betterment assessments will be made is under discussion now and will be explained in upcoming public meetings
and publication of materials to the public and affected property owners in advance of the 2016 Annual Town Meeting. The
Board is further refining how much to assess property owners receiving sewer and how much goes on the general tax
base. The betterment is typically assessed when the sewer is operational, but in some cases an Estimated Betterment is
assessed when the project is at 50 percent completion in order to cover borrowing costs to the Town. There is a 20-30
year pay back term on betterments, which the Town can set up as payment plans with each property owner on the same
schedule as property taxes. The property owner can also canchoose to pay all at once.
The Board of Selectmen is planning to hold public meetings to explain all cost information in greater detail.
WHAT IF WE CHOOSE TO DO NOTHING?
The science and engineering is telling us that several factors are contributing to polluting our water
resources. There are many reports, which conclude that excessive nutrients, mainly nitrogen, from
multiple sources are polluting our waters.But, more importantly, we are SEEING the impacts! With
algae blooms, red tides, reduction of fish/ shellfish/eelgrass/plant life historically found in our waters,
we can see that there are issues. What we cannot see until it is too late, is how this pollution has the
potential to impact our drinking water, the fishing/shellfishing industry, the public health, our tourism,
all of which can eventually impact our property values, not to mention the impact on Nantucket’s
unique attributes.
The Massachusetts Department of Environmental Protection, (MassDEP) under the jurisdiction of the
Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), is mandating that Nantucket eliminate the pollution of water
resources and restore water quality to established standards. Both agencies approved the CWMP Up-
date Plan and will work with the Town as it voluntarily works to achieve restoration of the waters.
The sewer plan is a major piece of the restoration process, along with stormwater
management and fertilizer reduction. These are the items that we, as Nantucket residents, can control.
Every individual contribution counts!
If the Town chooses
NOT to do
anything, MassDEP
will issue orders,
and together with
fines, will mandate
restoration under
its terms and
conditions.
DESIGN / CONSTRUCTION
COST ESTIMATES
Nantucket Harbor Shimmo
(2017 Costs)
Design - $2,782,916
Construction - $25,046,246
PLUS (2019 Costs)
Design - $1,309,821
Construction - $11,788,385